Skip to content
Ep. 251 – The Selfless Path to Happiness episode artwork

Aug 30, 2025 39 min

Ep. 251 – The Selfless Path to Happiness

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

In part 1 of this Q&A session, Joseph Goldstein gives Buddhist-flavored insight on accepting impermanence, developing our practice, and loving selflessly. This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/insighthour and get on your way to being your best self In this episode, Joseph Goldstein offers his perspective on: The path from accepting impermanence to happiness Letting go of clinging and becoming attuned to the truth of change The stages we go through in Vipassana meditation practice Understanding meditation experiences—why difficult moments don’t mean a “bad” practice How developing a regular practice helps us approach life more equanimously Feeling the whole mind-body process within practice and how this helps us let go of our sense of self Walking meditation as an effective tool for immediate selflessness The challenge of engaging with the world without getting lost in it Seeing the clear possibility of loving without attachment and with pure generosity of the heart This talk was recorded at Insight Meditation Society - Retreat Center and distributed by Dharma Seed “On a conceptual level, being afraid of impermanence is like being afraid of gravity. It’s the way things are. The more we can see that and open to it, we get over that conditioned fear and we’re just in the experience and the acceptance of the flow. It’s actually quite easeful.” – Joseph Goldstein

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

In part 1 of this Q&A session, Joseph Goldstein gives Buddhist-flavored insight on accepting impermanence, developing our practice, and loving selflessly.

Ready to play

Ep. 251 – The Selfless Path to Happiness

0:00 39:34
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. We talk about mental health more openly now, but asking for help can still feel hard. BetterHelp's latest research confirms it. BetterHelp's 2026 State of Stigma report surveyed 2000 Americans and revealed that 85% of Americans believe getting support is wise.

Yet 74% say society discourages people from doing so. If you're struggling with mental health, please consider getting the help you deserve. BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform. Don't let stigma stand in the way of support.

Start therapy with BetterHelp. Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com.com. That's better, h-e-l-p.com.com.com. And as we accept it, then there's ease in the face of inevitable changes.

And even on a conceptual level, what I'm talking about is really developing this understanding of practice, so it's experiential. But even on a conceptual level, being afraid of impermanence is like being afraid of gravity. It's the way things are happening. And the more we can see that and open to it, so we get over that conditioned fear, oh my god, everything's changing.

And we're just in the experience and the acceptance of the flow, and it's actually quite useful. Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness.

If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com. Slash, Joseph. Good evening. You will go to a lot of easy questions.

You know, we used to call these Q&As questions and answers. We changed it to Q&Rs. Questions and responses. So we'll see if it actually answers your questions or not.

Yeah, so yeah, thank you for being here. And thank you for all of your questions. I had the difficult task of going through over the 100 questions you offered. And categorizing, narrowing down, and I've combined some of these questions, and we'll see what time we have to answer them.

So apologies for not being able to get to every question, but looking forward to the responses that do come. And so we'll start. So a little context is we've been doing the Anitra chant each evening. And so impermanence has been on some minds.

So I'll start with these two questions. The wisdom of impermanence is often seemed like a cold comfort. What is the path from accepting impermanence to happiness as the Anitra chant refers to? And then also, how can I work with my fear of impermanence?

You know, when you see on the TV the little buffering, I find my mind is often buffering. Impermanence, it's interesting that it's not uncommon, I think, for people, maybe when they hear that everything is changing, that it may feel cold or uninviting to really explore that or understand that or the implications of it. And what's a little odd about that is that it's exactly the opposite because when we look to see the basic cause of suffering in our lives, it's because we are in one way or another trying to hold on what to want, what to crave, that which in its very nature is impermanence. And I think I talked about that the other night.

And it's precisely by the flow of changes, both externally but specifically in the meditation. And this is really what happens as it's some out of the concentration deepens. There's a certain momentum or flow that begins to happen and we are just in the flow of changing phenomena. And when we're in that flow without trying to hold on, without trying to grasp, there's a tremendous sense of ease and openness.

Somebody, a meditator once came in to an interview and they were describing their insight into impermanence. And they described it saying, trying to hold on to that which is changing is like rope burn. If you hold on to a rope that's being cold through your hand, the tidier you hold on, the more rope burn there's going to be. And what's interesting is just to really notice in our lives how often we do that.

Because we can understand intellectually that that makes sense, but our conditioning or habit is, we like what's pleasant, we don't like what's unpleasant, and it results in a lot of holding, of one thing, of craving, which is the cause of distress, of unease in our lives. So actually opening to the truth of change, not only opening to it but dropping into the flow of it. It's really quite, at times it's joyful, it's always peaceful because we're not fighting against the way things are. Excuse me.

So a lot of the practice, the second question was about kind of a conditioned fear of change. I think I mentioned in the talk The Other Night, that experience where I had to relax and walking, and then do you understand anything can happen anytime? And it's relevant here because the first reaction to that was fear. Oh my god, anything can happen anytime.

But as I settled into it, the whole thought was relaxed because it got attuned to the truth of change and the acceptance of that. And as we accept it, then there's ease in the face of inevitable changes. And even on a conceptual level, what I'm talking about is really developing this understanding in our practice, so it's experiential. But even on a conceptual level, being afraid of impermanence is like being afraid of gravity.

It's the way things are. And the more we can see that and open to it, so we get over that conditioned fear, oh my god, everything's changing. And we're just in the experience and the acceptance of the flow and it's actually quite easeful. Maybe one more.

This is maybe tangentially related of how we can have different perceptions. Not quite sure how it's related. But there was an example of a person's experience kind of jumping out of a plane. And the first hit was tremendous exhilaration of an incredibly exciting experience.

And then realizing they didn't have a parachute. So then there was tremendous fear. Oh my god, no parachute. So went through a whole stage of fear.

And then they realized in this particular story, there's no ground. And as soon as they realized there was no ground, a hard mind just settled into the experience of the free flow of things. And so it's really interesting that description really is applicable to some of the stages that we go through in meditation in Vipassana practice. Because as the practice deepens, you know, and as the concentration gets a little bit better, it doesn't have to be super amount, but enough so that the hindrances are not quite so activated.

There's a stage of practice where we are seeing, experiencing the rapid rise in fall of phenomena, just on a momentary level. And it's very rapid, very quick. And at that stage, the mind is filled with light and, mind is like crystal clear and it's extremely joyful. But that's just a stage in the unfolding practice.

Keep on practicing, sitting, and walking. And then it evolves into a stage where we are just seeing the dissolving side of the impermanence. Not so much things arising, but the continual disappearance of things. So the mind is attuned to that, that particular stage.

So when we're in that stage, it's called rolling up the mat stage because it's so disconcerting. There's no stability anyplace. We're just seeing things dissolving all the time. There's no place to take a stand.

So there can be a lot of fear at that time. Because this is not, we're looking at it from the outside, we're experiencing this whole mind-body process like that. Dissolving is often dissolving. So there's a lot of fear in this where they call rolling up the mat people.

That's what they want to do, just to roll up the mat and go home. And we keep practicing. We go through that stage until it comes to a place of profound equanimity, which is just a fantastically peaceful quality of mind, where the mind is not affected and not reactive to whether things are pleasant or unpleasant. It's just like the space and everything is just arising and passing, which is tremendously fulfilling and peaceful.

And that time people can sit for hours at a time, the body is light. And it's out of that stage that's like the ground out of which these moments of enlightenment can happen. So it's just to say that there's a progression. It's not just one kind of experience that unfolds in our practice.

And sometimes it's joyful and sometimes it's fearful and sometimes it's equanimous. So it might be helpful just to have that in mind as you go through many different kinds of experiences in practice. When it's difficult, it doesn't mean that it's a bad meditation. It just means that's the phase we happen to be going through and seeing things in a particular way at that time.

Thank you. And so it speaks directly to this question. Could you describe the relationship between selflessness and the rapid movement of attention? And the rapid movement of attention, which I think we might have meant.

The insight into impermanence has people spoken about the three characteristics. The three general characteristics of experience are impermanence, dukkha, unsatisfying nature and selflessness. So impermanence and dukkha, they're easy to understand. Selflessness is not bad easy to understand.

But one doorway into getting glimpses of what the Buddha was referring to and how we can experience it is through the doorway of impermanence. And there are other ways of experiencing as well, but that's a rather accessible one because impermanence is very clear. It's not some esoteric truth. Especially as the mind becomes qualities of mindfulness and concentration, gets strengthened, which is really what you're doing here in the practice.

You're strengthening those qualities. At a certain point, it really becomes effortless. There's enough momentum of those qualities that they're working by themselves. So just one image, which kind of describes this point of shift in our practice.

So in the beginning, if you think of an arch, and you're kind of balancing on the top of the arch, and the mind falls off, you're full off on one side, and you have to get back, full off on the other side. So it's very effortful. And we do that a lot in the beginning of our meditation journey. At a certain point, the arch becomes a trough, and we're just balanced at the bottom of the trough.

And the mind still will get pulled out from that place of center, but falls back naturally to that place of balance. So that's a development in the practice. As we strengthen these qualities of mindfulness and concentration, it really becomes quite easeful even when there are difficult things happen. So it doesn't mean that in that place of ease it's all blissful.

There can be challenging things come up, but we've established ourselves in the flow that's just carrying us along without, it really doesn't take much effort at that point, except that resolve just to stay with it. When we're in that flow and we continue the practice, our perception of change gets really refined. You know, and we can just see something I call NPMs. NPMs are not a thing per minute.

In the beginning, the NPMs are pretty low. Maybe you don't have 5 NPMs at 10. But at a certain point, and you can see this even with something as simple as being with the breath or being with a stab. You know, at first, in breath out, breath.

In breath is one thing, out, breath is another. But as the meditation gets more centered and connected, the in breath is made up of so many different, more microscopic sensations. The breath is not one thing. It's like that.

And we can feel and experience, you know, the the rapidity and the microscopic nature of what's going on. Another example, you know, okay, what do you hear the sound of the bell? But if we're really listening, it's not one thing. There's so much going on in that short interval.

So as I'll practice deepens in this way, and we're feeling the whole mind-body process, you know, with these high NPMs, nothing lasts long enough to consider it as self. You know, because the notion of self, the very concept of it, implies something stable. Okay, everything is happening to a me. And the me is just there throughout one's whole life.

But when we are really paying attention to the truth of our experience, it's not like that. It's just this rapidity of changing mental physical phenomena, arising and passing very quickly. So another image which I've just been playing with lately. Actually, it just came up on my list, Self-ritude.

So it's walking. And I hope you guys are doing the walking. Because sometimes people have the idea that the sitting is the real thing, and the walking is kind of an interlude between the sitting. There is so much that can be learned in the walkout.

It's in some ways more insight has come to me in walking than in sitting. So that's just a plug for you, not to overlook it. So I was doing walking meditation. Okay, I have to ask you, I can't remember everything I talked about in the first talk.

Did I talk about the passive, using the passive voice? I did. I'm getting two different answers. Stop confusing me.

No, okay. Somebody did tears it. I'm going to throw this for you. So this is one really effective way of having an immediate experience or taste or glimpse.

Of selflessness. Now, a lot of how we experience ourselves in the world and life, a lot of it is conditioned by language. The language we use conditions how we see things and how we understand things. So in English and in many languages, I think, but certainly in English.

The usual way we construct sentences is subject, verb, objects. I'm going here. I feel happy. I feel sad.

So the passive voice, that's what the active voice. The passive voice, an example would be a sound being known or a sound being heard rather than I'm hearing the sound. So at one point in my practice, and I don't even know how it arose, but just somehow it came, and it was in walking meditation, I suddenly started framing the experience in the passive voice, sensations being known. I'm just a little exercise.

If you move your arm, just see if you can frame it in the movement being known. And you can move quickly, slowly, but it's being known rather than framing it, I'm knowing the movement. The power of this is that in the passive voice, there's no eye. Just through a change of language, we've taken the self out of it.

And so we're describing the experience to ourselves in a selfless way. It's just things being known, sound being known, a thought being known, a sensation being known. And what's so powerful about this is that it's being known effortlessly. You don't have to do anything.

It's happening all by things. The movement is being known effortlessly and perfectly, and not a moment before, not a moment after. It's exactly in each moment of something being known, without any reference to a self, to an eye. So I forgot where I was going with all this.

But this would point to end that. Yes. So in terms of impermanence and selflessness, I was doing walking meditation. And I was just walking in this open kind of way, not limited to just the sensation, the movement being known, but moment after moment, just being aware of whatever is being known, sound being known, a sensation in the body, the feeling of the breeze, thought being known, moment of moment, things being known, being known, being known, being known.

All of a sudden, I had the image of a film. And usually we're totally caught up in the story of the film. But what is the film? It's really just separate frames moving really quickly.

But because they're moving so quickly, it feels like there's a continuity. And so characters are built up and actions are built up and the whole world of the story is created. But what's really happening? Is anybody on the screen getting chased or falling in love or getting murdered?

No, it's just separate frames of film and pixels of light. But because it's happening so quickly, there's the illusion of continuity. The sense of self and the deeply conditioned feeling of self, which is very strong in all of us. And that's why it's so hard to really get a glimpse of what the Buddha was talking about.

But if you're practicing in a way, again, incorporating perhaps this passive voice construction, so even in the way you're languaging into yourself, you're not reinforcing, I'm walking. Or I'm happy or I'm sad. You're taking the eye out of it. Movement being known, happiness being known, sadness being known, sound being known.

And then you see how rapidly it's happening. It's just like separate frames of the film. And you see, there is no one there. No self, there's no abiding self there.

But it's happening so quickly that we have this sense of a continuity. So then, some just playing with this, doing a walking meditation, thinking of my whole experience as just like frames of a film. And then it was just playing with the idea of being a character in the film. We all are.

We're all kind of stars of our own movies. So it'd be like character of the film, all of a sudden realizing that in any moment, it's just a film frame. And some of it's like the character steps out of the film and understands what's really going on. And then steps back into the film and continues with the story.

That's what we're doing. One of the through lines of what pulls us back over, what sustains the illusion of the whole story, the illusion of self is the force of craving of one thing. That's the mental energy that keeps us in the film. Now, the challenge for us, we were all lay people in the world with not monastics, who were devoting them their whole lives to having stepped out of the film.

Not that they will do, but that's the idea of living my life. But we're engaged in the world. And we're engaged with other people and relationships. So for myself, I just find it extremely interesting to learn how to play with being in the film and stepping out of it, being in the film and stepping out of it.

At different times, because it's a way of finding or connecting with some sense of greater peace. We're so caught up in the turmoil of our lives and the turmoil of the world, especially these days, but all really always. So is the rest in all that? Where is the piece?

We're continually in this film of our lives of the world. But when we have the ability to, I don't know, back when I was a kid, there was a show on Broadway called Stop the World I Want to Get Off. It's just kind of like that. It's moments of where we just understand things on a much more fundamental level.

And there's a quality of peace. There's a quality of rest. And if it's just for a few moments, you know, and I think that's our challenges, lay people, practicing with an aspiration to be free, with an aspiration really for the deepest kind of peace, how do we do it in the midst of our busy lives? And so this is one way.

So I hope this makes sense. But for me, it was just a very clear and engaging understanding. Yeah, and so I just started playing with it as you can. Thank you.

So this question says, I understand the truth of that for all of us. This is inevitably everything ends in separation. So while I understand this truth, how does one cultivate love for someone free of attachment? One of the phrases my teacher used to say very often about Dharma practice in general, he said it's simple, but not easy.

So it's not complicated. But as you all know, it's not always easy. So one way of really seeing clearly the possibility of love without attachment is first to really get very clear in your own experience of when each of those qualities in the mind and the heart are operative. So for example, at any time when you feel particularly loving, whether it's the spouse, partner, or kids, or friends, or in any situation where you recognize that feeling of loving, that feeling of that quality of the heart, if you can remember, just pay attention in those moments to really see and feel, what does this feel like?

So you learn to recognize very clearly, a love feels like this. Because usually we have these emotions, you know, and we go through them and we like them, we don't like them, but it's not that often that we remember to actually investigate a little bit. What is the actual quality of this emotion? And because we're having it at that moment, it's right there for us to see.

You know, we don't have to be looking for it or waiting for it. It's already here. Oh, love feels like this. We spend some time exploring that feel.

Then pay attention in your experience to when you feel most attached. And for whatever reason, that feeling of attachment or clinging to the other person, or could even say wanting in some way is there. And then without judgment, just pay attention to what that feels like. In my experience, they are two completely opposite feelings.

Love, when I feel most loving, it's the energy of generosity. It's like a generosity of the heart. It's just wanting the other person to be well, to be happy, to sort that giving. When I've experienced the most attachment, it's exactly the up.

It's the energy of holding on. And then we could really examine, well, what's the consequence? What's the results of each of those feelings? When we're loving, does it drink about more happiness?

We're more suffering. When we're attached or holding on, what does that bring? It never brings more happiness. It's always the source of some kind of contraction or tightness or fear or fear of losing.

All kinds of things are born from attachment. So if we can both distinguish clearly the difference, not theoretically, from our own experience of how we're feeling those emotions, if we can clearly distinguish them and see each clearly and then see where each leads, that could be a strong motivation to practice cultivating the love. And when we're feeling the attachment, as everyone will until we're quite enlightened, but at least to recognize that and to see, it's to see something which goes quite against our usual way of understanding, because I think most people feel that attachment is an inextricable part of loving. Of course, it'll be attached to the person I love.

That's our usual understanding of it, but it's because people have not really investigated that they're two really different things and in a way opposite things. So it is possible, but this is a lifelong practice because the attachment we have to the people we love is very strongly conditioned. So it's not that it's going to go away magically, but we don't have to simply be living out this habitual pattern of conditioning if we understand the right way to investigate it and to see through it. And that's why, and when you meet people who have just cultivated this to a very great extent, they have extraordinary beings.

And some of our teachers think of the Dalai Lama, you know, he had one line, something like, I tried to be with everyone I need as an old friend. That's how he goes through the world. And you never get the feeling that he's attached to the person, he's just loving them. And many great beings manifest that quality.

So for me, it's an inspiration that's possible, but it takes, I think it takes that kind of investigation and clear seeing. Again, not theoretically, in our actual experience.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 39 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on August 30, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.