Skip to content
Ep. 262 – Letting Thoughts Dissolve episode artwork

Jun 10, 2026 33 min

Ep. 262 – Letting Thoughts Dissolve

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

Joseph Goldstein investigates the not-so-obvious delight of seeing our own arrogance (Māna), and the balance of knowing ultimate truth while living with a functional sense of “I.” Help us celebrate 10 years of Be Here Now Network and support the next chapter of Ram Dass Here and Now. Gifts are matched dollar for dollar through June 30. Learn more and give here: BHNN 10th Birthday Fundraiser Today's episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/insighthour and get on your way to being your best self. This week on Insight Hour, Joseph Goldstein discusses: Realizing the truth of non-self while still having an underlying feeling of ‘I am” The Buddhist concept of Māna, which can be translated as "pride", "arrogance", or "conceit" Our tendency to project the past into the future Recognizing Māna for what it is and letting the thoughts dissolve How the residue of ‘I’ and ‘self’ can fall away during practice Engaging the self just enough to live in the relative world This episode is the 2nd part of a 3-part series. It was originally published on Dharmaseed and recorded at the Barre Center for Buddhist Studies, a non-profit organization founded by renowned meditation teachers Joseph Goldstein and Sharon Salzberg to integrate Buddhist study and practice. To start at the beginning, check out Ep. 261 – Gradual Cultivation in Buddhist Practice “These days, I am totally delighted when I see Māna arise in my mind…one of the reasons I am delighted is that I would much rather see it than not see it to recognize 'that’s Māna', instead of not recognizing it and being caught up and identified with that pattern. Just the seeing of it is freeing.” –Joseph Goldstein

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 262 – Letting Thoughts Dissolve

0:00 33:34
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

A quick word from the Be Here Now Network. Everyone has a story about how these teachings found them. One listener caring for her 90-year-old parents told us, I'm able to keep my heart soft and my head clear. Another in Ireland wrote, I'm 65 now and feel that I've found where I need to be. Sharing those stories is how we tend the fire. This season, every gift to the Love Serve Remember Foundation is matched dollar for dollar up to $50,000.

Help tend the fire at ramdas.org slash give. That's ramdas.org slash give. Thank you. Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to BeHereNowNetwork.com slash Joseph. So in the Theravada tradition...

It offers a pretty clear framework for understanding these two elements. That is sudden awakening, gradual cultivation. So as I mentioned, from the first glimpse of Nibbana, the view of self is uprooted. So that is not going to arise again. And from that point on, there is no doubt about the path. Said enlightenment is guaranteed. We're firmly on the path. There's no going back at that point. But still...

the other defilements still remain. We're still like the feeble young cattle, right? So there's still desire and aversion and restlessness and conceit. So all of these qualities are still present in our mind. So I want to spend a little time focusing on the particular defilement of conceit, which in Pali is called mana, M-A-N-A, because it highlights how we can have realized the truth, realized it, realized the truth of non-self.

yet still have a persistent underlying feeling of I am. And that's the meaning of mana. It's translated as conceit, but there are different connotations in English. But in this Buddhist context, conceit is this I am-ness. And it can be very obvious, and it can be very subtle background. So mana, this conceit I am, can take different forms. It can take the form of comparing ourselves with others.

I am this in relationship to others. That is feeling better than, feeling worse than, feeling equal to. And we may think, well, I don't really do that. But it would really be interesting, and I've just noticed this in myself. You know, we meet somebody, maybe meet somebody for the first time. And friendly and engaging. But how often are there some background thoughts of some kind of comparison going on?

Oh, they're shorter than I am. Whatever. You have more hair than I do. It can be that trivial or it can be a little more meaningful. But that's an expression of this mana, this conceit. I am in relationship to this. It can also refer to the projection of this I am-ness over time. So every time we're caught up in thoughts of, oh, I was this or I did this in the past.

Notice what the subject of that sentence is. I was this in the past. I did this in the past. Projected into the future. I will do this. I will go there. And of course in the present. I am this now. So this mana, I hope you can get a sense of why it's so deeply conditioned. The pattern, even after the view of self has been uprooted, we understand that there's no self. But I am-ness continues until full enlightenment.

That's how deeply conditioned it is. But because identity view has been uprooted, we can then begin to see mana, I am, even these thoughts and feelings associated with them, this I am-ness, we begin to experience and understand the very I am-ness as being selfless. It's just a pattern. It's a deeply rooted pattern that's there until full awakening. But after having uprooted identity view, we see, yes, this is just an empty pattern, empty of self. So we see this as being selfless. So I finally kind of put all this together. These days, I am totally delighted when I see mana arise in my mind. I love it. And I love it for two reasons. And it arises quite enough to be delighted a lot of the time. One of the reasons I'm delighted is that I would much rather see it than not see it.

to recognize, oh, yeah, that's mana, instead of not recognizing it and being caught up and identified with that pattern. So just the seeing of it is freeing. And then the second reason I'm so delighted is knowing that it's not uprooted till full enlightenment. Every time I see it, oh, mana, I feel like I'm working on full enlightenment. I'm working on the end of the path. So that gives me a lot of joy to see that, okay, I'm really investigating something that is that deep.

This understanding has very practical applications. I'll tell a little story about this. I think most of you know Biku Inalio, who lives right down the lane here. So we had become friends during the time that he's been living here at the study center. And one year, he's on retreat a lot of the time. But during one period, we were both going to be on retreat at the same time. I was doing a self-retreat in my home just up the road. He was down in his cottage here. So I knew we were both.

you know, practicing. And in my practice, just one afternoon, I was just frittering away sometime. I didn't know what I was doing. And the thought that arose in my mind was, I'll bet Inalio doesn't fritter away his time. He's so disciplined and such a good yogi. And when I had that thought, I just started getting down on myself a little bit. You know, just kind of get it together. Be a little more disciplined. But it didn't take long. I don't know, maybe five minutes of kind of wallowing in that self-judgment. And then I realized.

That's just mana. That's just comparing mind. As soon as I recognized mana, yeah, just another empty selfless pattern. In the moment that I recognized it for what it was, the whole thing just dissolved. You know, the comparing dissolved. All the feelings I had about that self-judgment all dissolved because I recognized that it was just mana creating that result. So I just find this is tremendously freeing because we get caught up in this kind of comparing so often. And then...

To the degree that we're identified with it, we can have all kinds of self-judgment going on. So to see it for what it is, is very freeing. So a few years ago, I had an experience which really showed me the very ways conceit, this conceit of I am, arises and is sustained. And it turned out to reveal just how radical the Buddhist teachings are. So just as a little side note.

The usual refrain at the end of the Buddha's discourses, again, these are in the Pali Canon, the little sentence at the end of almost every discourse is, the bhikkhus was satisfied and delighted in the blessed one's words. But at the end of one sutta, it says, the bhikkhus did not delight in the Buddha's words. So that's very startling. So this is at the end of the first discourse in the middle length sayings called the root of existence.

And it's a difficult sutta, you know, to understand. It describes the very subtle ways the sense of self is conceived in the very subtle stances the mind takes in relationship to experience. So this is pre-thought. This is way beneath the level of thought. Just in the course of everything we do, the mind takes stances, different stances, in relationship to those experiences. So this sutta,

describes four different stances the mind takes, which create, and the Buddhist term, which conceives of the view of self. So I had read this many times, and kind of my mind glazed over it a little bit, because the sutta is very complicated, and I thought, well, that's interesting Buddhist philosophy. But what I've done for quite a few years now on my self-retreats, instead of reading the suttas, I listen to them on Audible, and they're all there. For one credit, you get the whole Majimanukaya. I mean, it's quite amazing. And it's read really well. So I've just taken to listening to the suttas. So it's like the Buddha's giving the evening Dharma talk. And what I found is listening, things go in in a very different way. And for me, and I think perhaps it's in common, much more powerful. I began to, in hearing...

Every retreat I do, every self-retreat, I'm always learning something from the suttas that I had read but hadn't had any impact. But in listening, oh, that's what this is about. So in listening to this very complicated sutta, there was one aspect, oh, that's what this is talking about. So the four ways it describes, the stance the mind can take in relationship to experience, it can conceive. And again, it's a free thought. It's not worth thinking about this. It's just...

a habitual way of relating, we could conceive of the self as being the experience. I am this experience. Or it says we can conceive of the self as being in the experience or being apart from the experience or the experience belongs to me. So those are the four ways that are outlined in the sutta. So when I heard, and it was particularly one of those, that as I was listening, just jumped out is I could connect totally with what I was saying.

And it was very apparent, kind of in walking meditation, it was the line, conceive of the self being apart from experience. And I realized that when I'm walking, and it's in the sitting, but it was just very obvious in the walking, being really mindful, mindful of the sensations and of the movement and all of that. But I noticed that the mind was taking a stance apart from it in being mindful of it. And that was just super clear to me. So after I heard this, I was outside walking up and down my driveway. And I wasn't kind of doing the Vipassana creeping along. I was walking at a more or less normal pace, but being mindful. And seeing, yeah, being mindful of. And so there was a stance apart from the experience. So I was seeing it clearly. But then I thought, well, what do I do about this? Because there's no instruction, at least that I remember now, in the sutta that says, okay, these are the four ways. Now do this, this, and this, and you'll be free of them.

So I had no idea. I saw it clearly, had no idea what to do. So I just started playing, which is my want on retreat. I really like to play with my mind. So I just said to myself, Joseph, stop conceiving. That's all I could think of to do, since it was this conceiving of being apart from. So Joseph, just stop conceiving. And then quite amazingly, this was just completely out of the blue and unexpected.

For a very brief period of time, maybe it was 10 or 20 seconds, that's not long, all that sense of I am-ness completely fell away. There was no residue of I or self in that brief period of time. And then I thought, well, am I just making all this up? But then it turned out to be replicable. So in that period of time...

I periodically, Joseph, just stop conceiving. And then again, 10 seconds, 15 seconds, it all fell away. There was no sense of anyone there at all. So this experience reminded me of the famous Bahiya Sutta, which I also mentioned in the article. In the scene, let it be just the scene. In the heard, just the heard. Sense, just the sense. Thought, just the thought. And the sutta goes on. But the person who was giving this teaching to heard this and became fully enlightened because this sutta just gets to the heart of...

non-self, in the scene, just the scene, just what is seen, just what is heard, just what is sensed, just what is thought. And the second part of this says, when for you there is only the scene, etc., then, by here, there is no you in connection with that. When there is no you, when there's no you there, you are neither here, nor there, nor in between the two. Just this is the end of suffering. So for me, This was such an unexpected experience. It just revealed a new level of understanding what non-self means. And it goes beyond uprooting the view of self, even the deep realization of that, the uprooting of that identity view as the frame for how we experience life. It went beyond that to not having any sense at all of I am. There's no you there. There's no you here. There's no you in between. Okay, I'm going to end a little bit. Just a little side note.

One time I was in India with my teacher, Manindraji, and he gave a three-hour talk on 21 kinds of silence. And so I'm very conscious of time ever since then. So I hope you're doing okay for another five or ten minutes. Okay, so talking about that experience, we even conceit the conceit of I am. just completely falls away just for those short, you know, short periods of time. But it was a glimpse, it was a taste of what that is. So I just want to give two examples of why I felt that this to be so radical in terms of what the Buddha is really teaching. So in one, there's another sutta where the Buddha is talking about the five aggregates, you know, as being impermanent and unsatisfactory and non-self, and he's going through.

the physical elements, the feeling tone, perception, mental formations, consciousness. So he's referring to these five aggregates, which is really the totality of our experience. He said, whatever is not yours, abandon it. When you have abandoned it, that will lead to your welfare and happiness. Now, abandonment, he doesn't refer to abandoning the aggregates. It's referring to abandoning the clinging and attachment to the aggregates. But then he gave an example of what that would mean.

And the example to me is startling and radical. He said, suppose people, they were sitting in some forest grove. So the Buddha says to the monks and the nuns and whoever was teaching, suppose people were to carry off the grass, sticks, branches, and foliage in this grove or to burn them or to do with them as they wish. Would you think people are carrying us off or burning us or doing with us what they wish?

And then they replied, no, venerable sir. For what reason? Because the branches of foliage, sticks, whatever. That is neither self nor what belongs to self. Then referring back to the aggregates. So whatever is not yours, abandon it. He had been teaching the aggregates do not belong to anyone. They're empty of self. There's no self contained in them or within them. Whatever is not yours, abandon it. Again, abandon attachment. You have abandoned it will lead to your happiness and welfare.

So the reason this image just sticks in my mind so powerfully, even after identity view is uprooted, understanding there's no self, but if people were to kind of burn me or carry off my legs or my arms, I would probably be a little reactive. But the Buddha is giving the example of somebody who is fully realized. They would not be taking any of that to be self, as self. And there are different stories in the text.

The Buddha is describing, he was describing some past life where he was just a hermit and a jealous king saw him teaching his queens and the king got angry and he ordered his soldiers to cut off the arms and legs of this hermit. And as the Buddha tells the story, even then, I felt no aversion, wishing for their welfare and happiness. Okay, I think there's a little more work to do here. Okay, so that's one example of why it seems so radical to me. And I just want to emphasize one point. It also means,

or includes non-attachment or identification with consciousness. And we often forget that piece that we, okay, I can really let go of attachment to the body, to thoughts, to emotions, perhaps for some periods of time. But we still are subtly identifying with the one who's knowing it all. And so consciousness very often becomes the last holdout of this sense of self because it's very hard to see. Okay, so one other example of how this experience felt to me.

This is an image that came to mind afterwards, but it also perhaps highlights just, I wish I knew another name for radical, because it is just such a mind-blowing understanding. So the example that came to my mind was of a character in a movie. The movie's telling some story, and there's this character in the movie engaging with everybody else. And then at a certain point, he or she, the character, understands or experiences that all that they are are pixels of light. That's all that's really happening. Pixels of light not belonging to anyone. And it's not that the character is aware that it's pixels of light. The character has disappeared. The character is no longer there. And it's just the reality of what is actually happening. Does that strike you? I just find that a totally amazing understanding of what our practice is about and where it's leading.

Of course, a very big question remains for us along the path, even just conceptually, or if we've had brief glimpses of what this means, real experiences of characters is no longer there. It's just the mental physical elements playing out, which are analogous to the pixels of light. No one there. So the very important question remains, how do we integrate these two levels? The level of no one there.

And the level of being the character, living our lives and engaged in conventional reality, which is where we spend most of the time. So it's really important to kind of explore, okay, what do we do with this understanding, with this insight, in terms of how we live our lives? So one way of understanding this integration is contained in the teaching on the two truths, relative truth and more ultimate truth. And relative truth is just our conventional way of being.

you know there is a sense of self and we engage i'm here you're there and just our ordinary lives is the relative level of truth the more ultimate level of truth we might say and that could be parsed in many different ways but one way of understanding it more ultimate truth is the level of pixels right or just the rise and fall of the aggregates moment after moment where there really is the felt experience of no one there so this was this integration was expressed really beautifully by one Tibetan teacher when someone asked him, is the self real? So, is the self real? And he said, yes, the self is real, but not really real. You exaggerate it. I think that captures it. It is real in the sense of how we are living our lives and we're engaged on this relative level, but it's not really real. And when we understand that from the more ultimate level, then we can engage on the relative level with much greater freedom.

with much less attachment, with much less clinging. You know, we just begin to live with more spontaneity, with more ease. The question that still remains in my mind, well, what will it be like when it's more than just glimpses? You know, these were 10 seconds, 20 seconds, really brief. What will it be like when the mind is fully awakened and it's not just glimpses? And I realized that remains to be seen, but it's a really inspiration, you know, continuing on the path.

So thank you for your kind attention.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 33 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on June 10, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.