Skip to content
Ep 413: The Deep End episode artwork

Feb 13, 2025 20 min

Ep 413: The Deep End

from The Daily Vedantic Hosted by James Beshara

In this episode, we explore the mind-bending idea that our reality might be an illusion. From advancements in AI generating hyper-realistic videos to ancient Eastern philosophies discussing the concept of Maya (illusion), we examine the nature of perception, reality, and what we trust as "real." As AI continues to redefine what's possible, could we be living in a simulation? Or is everything just an intricate projection of our minds? Join us as we dive deep into these profound philosophical ideas that challenge the very fabric of existence. The Daily Vedantic is a daily podcast and YouTube channel dedicated to the timeless wisdom of the Upanishads (https://thedailyvedantic.com/). Dating back to over 5,000 years ago, the source of nearly all Eastern Philosophy, and loved by Western giants from Emerson to Thoreau to Carl Jung and Alan Watts, studied daily by Joseph Campbell to Aldous Huxley to Arthur Schopenhauer and countless others, The Daily Vedantic aims to make this ancient philosophy as modern and accessible as it is simple, practical — and profound. James Beshara (https://www.twitter.com/jamesbeshara ) is a renowned startup founder of multiple companies, a prolific startup investor in 200+ others including some of the biggest startup names on the planet, a husband and father of three little girls, and philosophy student and teacher in Los Angeles. James also co-hosts Yoga For Your Intellect (https://www.YFYI.co), a biweekly long-form conversational podcast with his teacher Joseph Emmett (https://www.instagram.com/yogaforyourintellect ) James is a student of Swami Parthasarathy, the acclaimed author of Vedanta Treatise (Vedanta Treatise – The Eternities) and teacher at Vedanta Academy in Malavli, India. As James says often, when you’re ready for the real thing, Swami’s daily lectures are where the true wisdom and systematic discovery of the world’s oldest continually studied philosophy resides:https://www.vedantaworld.org

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep 413: The Deep End

0:00 20:41
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Good reminder that we shouldn't believe everything we see. We have back with another reflection on the daily pedantic and today's reflection. Reflection that I've been thinking about since two or three days ago, my welcome from the office here in LA. I was thinking about the pace of innovation around AI, especially around video and image generation where it's, it is crazy how realistic and beautiful these videos, not just images anymore, but videos can be created by typing in a few words or speaking into your phone of 10 elephants walking with castles on their backs through the Saharan Desert.

Then within seconds, you have countless pieces of sand, these immaculately illustrated elephants, castles that you don't even have time to imagine the details of what would go into the castle before it is generated in video right in front of you. It is truly wild. It makes it feel and simulation theory is all the rage these days and the last 10 years, technologists have spoken more and more about, are we in a simulation? Seems like we are in a simulation.

If we were in a simulation, could we simulate all of these details, all of the intricate details of a room of nature of another human being? The simple breakdown of this that I've heard really smart people say, I heard Elon Musk give this, this perspective a few years ago, he said, you know, it's possible to know whether we're in a simulation or not. This is by the way, this is just crazy that people are talking this way. Because this would never come up 20 years ago.

When the Matrix came out, people were like, whoa, that would be crazy in the future. Now people are talking, debating whether we're in something like the Matrix. This philosophy, the end of this philosophy, the deep end of the pool, as the first episode touches on the first episode is the whole philosophy in about 15 minutes. And the end of the story, the end of this philosophy, the deep end of this philosophy is two main observations that the sages in saints over the last 8,000 plus years within this philosophy have said.

Are these two observations? One, you are that, you are it, you are what is, and all of it. Not part of it, not just a reflection of it, but you are that. You are what you are seeking, you are what is.

That phrase, tat tvam asi, maha vakhi, the great phrase, that thou art, is the whole philosophy in three words. As plain vanilla as it might sound to hear it for the first time, you could spend a couple of lifetimes cracking that nut open of what is being said with those three words. That's why it's the deep end of the pool. It's not the introductory comments of what this is, what life is.

It's defined as a stream of experiences and an experience is defined as subject and object, subject and its environment interacting. And life is just a stream of those experiences. The first episode gives that breakdown from the known to this unknown territory that we're talking about in this episode. The other observation at the deep end of the pool is that none of this is really happening.

This is all an elevated version of a dream. It is perceived for sure. There's no doubt that we perceive a table. We perceive this voice in your ears.

We perceive everything that you might be looking at right now. There is a perception, but these perceptions are not real. They're not really happening. It's just a projection of our minds or technically projection of our ignorance and not seeing what is really happening and perceiving.

Oh, there's a table. There's Johnny. There's Sally. There's the sun.

Nature. But in this second observation that this is all an illusion, Maya is what it's called. Maya is the same Sanskrit word in which we get the word magic. Ironically, the same word that we, it's the root of the word matter, the term we used to signify that something is real.

It's made of matter. And yet the root of that word is illusion. This Maya that we're in, whenever it comes up as a topic, and it's interesting, within this philosophy, there's two sets of people. One, I'll just say, one in 10,000 find this philosophy interesting.

So very few find this philosophy and philosophy in general interesting. But for those that do, there's a fascination with it where it's like, becomes something you can't get enough of because it's so fascinating. And within those that are interested in this philosophy, there's like two buckets of people, some that never want to talk about the illusion because it's just so gnarly, so incredible to try to think about that. They'd rather focus on 97% of the philosophy that is just practical.

That is the manual for living life well. It's phenomenally useful and in that regard, and it's why it's the deep end of the pool, and you stay in the shallow or the intermediate depths, and that's plenty. And there's no interesting going into the real deep water, the discussion, discussing the illusions. And then there's this other bucket, people that's all they want to discuss.

They love talking about it. I mean, it's not all because there's so much value in the practical side, but they love talking about the illusions aspect of this philosophy. But for the ones that don't want to talk about or don't find use in talking about it, or the folks that hear this and there's immediate resistance, which is the only natural reaction to hearing that these are not perceptions, but misperceptions of what's really going on, like telling someone, telling the subject in a dream, hey, this isn't real, this is all a dream. The subject in the dream, each one of us in our dreams are convinced, absolutely convinced that it's real until we wake up and realize, whoa, holy hell, that was all a dream.

None of that was real. And we do that every night. We have that contrast, that disbelief, the incredible certainty that it's real, then the disbelief, oh my God, I imagine that wasn't real. And then the integration back into the world, we're like, yeah, okay, well, fades away.

That's not real, but this is. And yet we find ourselves a couple hours later listening something like this and thinking, there's no way that this isn't. But this has to be real. I can feel it.

I can smell it here, I touch it. And it's the same thing as the dream. There's nothing you can say about this world that you can't say about the dream experience. It's just our perceptions as the arbitration of whether this is real or not.

And like I said, in like I said in previous episodes, our perceptions two hours earlier, 12 hours earlier, whenever you had that vivid dream, it's so simple to point out examples where our perceptions had nothing to do with reality. But when we talk about this, this aspect of the philosophy that this is all Maya, this is all an illusion of projection and not reality. A lot of times people are convinced that it's real because of the intricacies of it. To find details, the grains of wood or the grains of sand, the other people, the gravity, the elaborate clothing, the visuals, the makeup of a sunset.

But intricacy, as we know, even now in 2025 cannot imagine 2035, 2085. But in 2025, we already have examples where intricacy has nothing to do with reality. The quantum of detail has nothing to do with reality. You take the graphics in a modern video game, you take the details in a dream, you take the intricacies in the AI video generation that basically just came out in the last two, three months.

And you see example after example where intricacy has nothing to do with whether it's real or not. It's worth spending time pointing to what are the things that tell me this is real, that convince me this is real and then deconstruct and whether those should be the arbiters of what is real. The typical ones that come up are perception. So our sense perceptions, which we just talked about, an example of the dream has very little proof that it's a great arbitration on what is real or not because we perceive things in every dream.

Then you have emotions. You feel that it's real. Are you feel that deep hurt when something you don't want to happen happens? You feel that joy when you see someone that you love.

You feel that. So you have perceptions, but that's not a good arbiter of what's real. You deconstruct that within 20 seconds of thinking about the dream. The same goes for feelings or feelings.

Are very real in our dreams. Our desires can be very real in a video game. Our awe and beauty can be very real and just playing around with AI generation tools on online. That is gorgeous.

And you'd never get that shot. So one of whales swimming through clouds. Unbelievable, but also unreal. The feeling that you feel in a vivid dream has nothing to do with whether it's real.

And lastly, you have intricacy. That's one of these arbiters of, well, it's so intricate. The details in my hand are so intricate. It's got to be real because, well, movies or video games are not that intricate.

And yet it's a foregone conclusion that they will be pretty soon. They will be. You couldn't say that 15, 20, 30 years ago, 40 years ago yet, pong. And now you have 3D whales swimming through the sky with ho-hum computational power and about 2 to 3 minutes of speaking it into your phone and then watching it and seeing crazy intricate details.

Therefore, intricacy is no longer a valid arbiter of what is real or not. This philosophy is so big on questioning. So question everything that is being said, every episode, every reflection that I ever touch on, question the hell out of it. So the idea that this is all an illusion, a misperception, an appearance that is not the reality.

Question the hell out of it. But this episode is also this reflection. It's just as appropriate for to be perhaps the beginning of saying, well, this has to be real because I'm perceiving it. I'm feeling it.

It's so intricate. Perhaps this episode, this reflection is the beginning of potentially questioning that. Not saying with certainty anything other than, could this all be an illusion? Non-reality?

The last thing on this topic, if you believe in a divine or infinite, the infinite of infinite, you believe in higher power, God, the Supreme, whatever word you might have for it, whatever this is, mathematically in comparison to that, which always is mathematically anything compared to infinitude is the limit case for zero, limit case for nothing. So even if you have a, and we all do hard, very hard time entertaining this idea that this isn't really happening. Just compared to eternity or infinitude. 50 years, 500 years, 500 trillion years divided by infinity is zero.

It is so infinitesimally small, point zero infinitely repeating zeros one. So it's the limit case for zero. It is zero is just a concept. Nothing is just a concept, by the way.

And by the way, it was another, by the way, to the by the way, the Indians came up with the concept of zero. But zero is not a real number. It doesn't actually exist. But the limit case, if there is an infinitude and eternity, infinity is also just a concept.

Do we can't write down what infinity is? You can't see it. It cannot be perceived. But if you do believe in a God, that's infinite.

Then all of this is relegated to nothing in comparison to the divine. That isn't even flossy. That's just mathematics. Put it into a calculator.

500 trillion years divided by infinity. Compared to eternity, is the limit case for zero. If you believe in a divine or infinite power, then it relegates this to the exact same thing that this philosophy has said for thousands of years. That this is an illusion.

There is something happening, but it's infinitesimal to reality. This idea that this is reality. This philosophy says that we are mistaken to lean on this world. This perception is to lean on illusion, like a mirage.

The same way the water and mirage will not quench your thirst. Everything we're pursuing in this illusory experience will not quench our thirst. That's what this philosophy, that's what nearly all Eastern philosophy, that's what Christianity has said for thousands of years. No matter how vivid and no matter how intricate and no matter how unbelievable.

Maybe just question our senses, given the example of the dream. Question how much we lean on intricacy given the example of the day. So I got with the t-shirt the other day, I said the matrix is a documentary. What was an amazing movie built off of this Eastern wisdom?

Maybe that t-shirt is more accurate than it's not. And that's today's reflection on a daily pedantic. If this is too heady for you, this is your net bucket where you'd rather get back to the practical stuff. Well, don't worry because most of the reflections stay in that side of things.

But today with the crazy advancements in our technology right before our eyes happening in weeks and months, not even in years anymore, it's a good reminder that we shouldn't believe everything we see. We'll see you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Vedantic?

This episode is 20 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Vedantic episode published?

This episode was published on February 13, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Vedantic episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.