Skip to content
Ep. 50: Bud-Jaitley Speaking episode artwork

Feb 6, 2017 43 min

Ep. 50: Bud-Jaitley Speaking

from Simblified Hosted by IVM Podcasts

This week, in a special Chuck-free Simblified we demystify the process of the bureaucratic behemoth, that is the Union Budget of India. From the impact (or lack of it) of this year’s budget, we meander into the bylanes of India’s budgetary history to uncover some little known fiscal quirks, apart from the usual boring money talk. Srikeit (@Srikeit) and Naren (@shenoyn) try valiantly to make up for the Chuck’s (@chuck_gopal) absence with some pitiful groaners but fall woefully short! The Simblified podcast is also available on iTunes: https://goo.gl/S5t15w You can find us on Audioboom: https://goo.gl/43zsI7 Or generally, on just about any app you use to get your podcasts; Stitcher, Overcast, Beyond Pod, Podmalaxmi (that is not real, but don't you wish it was?) Follow Simblifed on Facebook: https://goo.gl/UlU34v This is an IVM Production; for more such awesome podcasts, come find us: Website: Indusvox.com Facebook: https://goo.gl/P130uw Twitter: https://goo.gl/7P7Uec Instagram: https://goo.gl/qH3PHm #budget #indianbudget #unionbudget #ArunJaitley #finance #moneyscenes #wallet #cashless #economy

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

This week, in a special Chuck-free Simblified we demystify the process of the bureaucratic behemoth, that is the Union Budget of India. From the impact (or lack of it) of this year’s budget, we meander into the bylanes of India’s budgetary history...

Ready to play

Ep. 50: Bud-Jaitley Speaking

0:00 43:18
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I, V, M. Yeah, so the reason we are doing this checklist key is that it can't wait because this is our budget simplified, right? With you, dear, listener are dying to understand because how else I don't understand if it's not un simplified. Of course, Narayan.

But honestly, my fiscal knowledge is limited to locating the nearest functioning ATM that dispenses the new 500 rupee nodes. So before we begin, let's examine what the root of the word budget is. Budget comes from the middle French word, Bouquet, or leather bag, wallet, or pouch. So the modern financial meaning is from the notion that the treasury minister keeps his plans, fiscal plans in a wallet.

Considering that Arun Jaitlin's full speech was over around 100 minutes long, he must have had some massive kadi pajamas to carry that wallet. I'm trying to visualize him. I'm probably in true Indian tradition, he had a couple of minions carry that wallet for him as well. So one of the things that fascinates me about budget is we don't see so many pictures, but the entire thing, the ceremonial thing about the finance minister walking in, and a group of people, and a lot of secrecy and things like that.

And I have very strong opinions on this, so hopefully it will come out later. I'm sure on the course of this podcast, I'm sure we'll be able to extricate some of those very entertaining opinions. So one of the things right up front before we go any further, and this might colour my things, I'm very against the idea that the government is any good. So I refuse to accept that we need any kind of form of government, accept the barest minimum law and all that kind of thing.

So that's the end of spectrum that I come from. And many people have told me that it is a naive and foolish position to take. So I take that criticism and... Who need a jacket?

Please forgive me if I say something which is abrasive to your political spectrum, so let it pass. And so budgets are like for me they are interesting in the way debt toads are interesting. You want to see them, you really don't have anything to do with them. But we have a huge responsibility to our public.

It's simplified and millions of people are all the country tuning in waiting here. It's almost like the rest of the world is watching America with great entertainment. Like it's this amazing zoo kind of thing where certain animals are chasing certain other people. But I'm sure it must be not so entertaining to be inside America itself.

Totally. To kind of go through that and I think... Actually America is quite a mess. I mean, whatever I've been saying is pretty scary man.

Yeah, I mean... Yeah, I mean when you think of it that way well some of its pres conferences and stuff that it is entertaining. But the rest of it seems to be genuinely very scary right now from the migration point. Yeah, for all years and years I always belly ache about...

So India is like this bad government and 30 streets and there's that in a while. And after looking at Trump saying I'm actually happy. I'm really happy to be in India and also I'm happy. We're much better off.

Definitely. So, Narayan, anyway, on the topic of budget. As you may all know, I work in advertising where the physical knowledge of the average employee is like Donald Trump's hair. You can try to fake it to be substantial but it is undeniably fake and it's definitely stupid.

So I've had colleagues who have not been aware that they're supposed to file taxes because they see some tax being fired deducted at the end of every month. And in the case of one amazing creative director who would until a few years ago, withdraw his salary as quickly as he could from the ATM. And do you know the reason? The reason was he's...

He believed banks are all thieves and they cannot be trusted with his money. So as soon as the salary hit his account in the first of every month, he would withdraw the whole thing and started a way in a shoebox under his bed. Which he was so much for digital. Actually, many...

I hope to share that article completely beside the point. So, but it's really happened to me. So, now I don't know the first time in the hospital and my dad opened that account for me in the bank and he happened to know the manager. So he used to send me money and I used to go every month to draw it.

And since my dad knew the manager, he would... Every time I was in the bank, he just get asked me to accept another cabin and he would take me to a cup of tea and you know, sort of politely inquire after my health. He used to have this fight in my very sweet guy. So, one such month I was there and he sort of asked me to say it in order to tea.

And all of a sudden, he just disappears under the desk. I'm like, I don't know what is happening. So, I'm sitting opposite of the dimensions under the desk. And I'm non-plus.

And I hear his voice from under the desk saying that, there's a man who would come and just tell him that you don't know where I am. That's all he said. And then he shut up. And one cantanker is an old man.

He's like, where is that fool of a manager? I want to catch him and another. So, he asked me where I said, I don't know. He's stealing my money.

You don't know these bank people, they are big chos. They are better not keep your money in the bank. And after writing for about 5 or 10 minutes, he went out and quietly the manager comes out. He carries on as a manager.

He carries on as a manager. So, anyway, there might be substance to your colleagues' belief that... My financial misadventures aside, what were the key highlights of the budget this year? Well, you know, I like to think, when we were in college in hostile, someone or the other would get an ampere than equalizer.

And moment people see an equalizer, everyone has to go and twiddle the knobs. They feel that the music quality improves. Somebody goes and increases the bass. Somebody just goes to the triple and somebody rearranges whatever.

And it absolutely makes more difference to the colleagues. The shit is on and comes out of the shit is on and comes out of the good side. But does exactly what finance ministers do when they come to. They love to twiddle knobs.

And this budget is yet another twiddling of knobs. And meaningless twiddling of knobs, I must understand. I mean, yeah, so I mean, in fact, I think someone on Twitter, I was following, I don't remember exactly who, but the moment the budgets speech started, he pretty much tweeted. He tweeted in a row of some five, six tweets, whereas this is a horrible budget.

It is going to put an amazing burden on the poor of the country. This budget is inconsequential and doesn't really do anything. And then immediately after this is a fantastic budget and we do amazing things for the economy. I was wondering what is wrong with this guy because I mean, generally it seemed like quite a funny guy.

And then he's like, we'll delete based on what it actually was, but prevailing public opinion turns out to be late. So he's like, I'm covering all my bases for political correctness. So basically what they did was usually the twiddle with the direct and the indirect taxes. This time they didn't twiddle the indirect taxes at all because the GST is going to come and it's pretty much covered in that area.

So in the direct taxes he twitted a little. He gave a little discounts to the lower range of people. So people earning very little money have to pay even less tax than they have to pay. And people are paying very, very high taxes also got away with pretty much whatever.

So there's one little sort of segment between 50 lakhs and one crore who basically got it squarely in the Gullis. Whatever little exemption they were getting is all gone and now they are squarely on it. It's basically saying that for the masses, like we will give you like some chill-out discount. For the amanis and gang they are like, you guys can continue your business.

And the guys who are trying to beat the amanis, you better get back in your box. So it's something on those lines. Coming to the substantial substantive things that the budget had to talk about, it's been pretty limp. So there's nothing earth-chickenly good or bad that has happened.

And it's probably best that way because financial, so one of our most terrible finance ministers, Muraji Desai, every time he used to come and talk about the budget, people would really urinate. Manis, they really were big, big, big control freaks in that time. So we are much better off. I mean, Jayatli has left a lot of things alone.

I think the elephant in the room, as far as I'm concerned, is the demonetization. So whatever effect it's likely to have, I personally believe, and it's the second of February that we are recording this, that we are yet to see the worst effects of demonetization. But I don't know what the effects are and how bad they're going to be. I'm hoping, I'm wrong.

So I'm hoping no bad effects. This is the worst. The worst is gone and everything will go on. But what is likely to happen is this.

People have stopped spending in the wake of the demonetization and the entire tempo of the economy has slowed down a lot. We don't know how loud, how slow. And one of the things that is going to happen is everything is slowly, like as Domino is falling in slow motion is slowly going to get hit. So maybe two wheelers and three wheelers get hit first, then maybe four wheelers, maybe, I don't know, FMCG, consumer goods, white goods, whatever.

And when the economy starts shrinking, as we were discussing a little while earlier, whatever you try to do to revive it doesn't work instantly, just as the demonetization. Yeah. It sounds like you're almost like you're at the helm of a really large ship. And you see this, I mean, I can almost put myself in the shoes of the captain of the Titanic who sees the iceberg right ahead and decides to go full Ferrari turning on it.

But then he might turn all that he wants. But at the end of the day, it'll only turn so much. But once it starts turning, it won't stop. Yeah.

And then you're, you're. Then you turn the wheel the other way, it takes its own time. It's own time. Yeah.

So that's a very good analogy for the economy. So demonetization, something that is possible might happen. I really fervently hope I'm wrong. I hope that it just, you know, India is wonderfully resilient country.

We have faced droughts, famines, all kinds of calamities and we have sold your dog. So our, I mean, Indians are so resilient, so strong. There's a lot of industry. So unlike other countries where calamities sort of seem to break the spirit, Indians somehow their fatalism or whatever it is, it just goes on and on.

So all that is good. But if that doesn't happen, you and I are going to be in tough. Yeah. I mean, it's almost like, so with the demonetization thing and drawing another terminology when Trump became president, a lot of people started making jokes about him being the last president of America.

Yeah. So I mean, in the wake of demonetization, like next year, next year when Arunjali comes up and he'll be like, he'll just get to the mic and he'll be like, budget, budget, very economy. So it might be something on those lines. Yeah.

And so let's on that again, open this note. Let's take a shot. Great. And if there is any company, I'm going to be back and see you.

Yeah. See you soon. You know that feeling when you finish a movie and you just need to talk about it, that desperate need to discuss why Kalhuna Ho hits different. Enter IBM's brand new podcast, Sennified.

It's streaming and current just yapping over Hindi cinema every Friday. romcom's directory debuts career-defining moments, whatever they're vibing with, they're breaking it down. Join the podcast on IBM Pub's YouTube or any audio streaming platform. Question, you want to rewatch everything after listening to us?

Come join us on Sennified. And welcome back, folks. And Shrikit. And there are important questions and important things about the budget speech.

Yeah, important things. Like, I mean, there is one important thing that's really on my mind that why despite having so many Bengali citizens in our country, we have never had a speaker named Bo's. Same reason I think you never had an ambassador named Maruk. Yeah.

Yeah. I mean, there is no justice in this world. Anyway, you were saying about important questions and important facts. Yeah.

So the whole thing about the process of budget, for all that I despise and deride the process of budget sign, the control that it implies, it is done in a fairly methodical way. And so I'm just going to give you a little outline. The union budget of India, whose full Christian name as Chakra would have said, is the annual financial statement in Article 112 of the Constitution of India. Is the annual budget of the Republic of India?

And it is presented each year on the last working day of the February by the Finance Minister in Parliament. And this year by that logic, a rest of February should be a chutev. Yeah, I know. I mean, we've done this.

This is the word. Yeah. Your word. Constitution.

Mary, let me tell you. But yeah, they did for very wise reasons. Mostly, I mean, there are a lot of reasons. We'll go into that a little bit.

And the budget has to be passed by the House, the Lok Sabha, before it can come into effect on the first of April, which is the start of India's financial year. This year, the date has been advanced. So they're saying to the first of February, to the leader of opposition, Malika Chakra Gay, very willingly tried to get it postponed to the second day of February because the parliamentarian from Kerala died. He wasn't able to present a clear argument as to how exactly postponing it by a day is going to make the last more variable.

Oh, but because I was not very receptive to that idea. And he just bleated a little about his disapproval of government parliamentarians being insufficiently respectful towards non-governmental parliamentarians. Everyone said, well, it's not long. And they started on.

I mean, it's almost like the speaker could have just re-promanded him and said that you couldn't have heard on for a day longer. Like, let us finish this nonsense before we go ahead. Right. I mean, government parliamentarians will be government parliamentarians.

Go on, Lorraine. Thanks, Shikit. Well, first some history. So references to the budget can be found in Kautilia's Arthasastra, Kautilia's World Flemish Chanak.

So basically, the budget is not against Indian culture. It is very much part of Indian culture. Very much part of Indian culture. Yeah.

So he laid out, very, very sensible guy actually for all that, you know, he used to wear whatever, very funny looking ponytails. He laid out general principles with remarkable common sense. Okay. It said that the minister in charge of the king's finances should first estimate revenue from different places, add them, add old payments due, which have now been deceived, then deduct the king's expenses on himself and he sends 75 concubines, and then decide what to build for the citadelanry.

So he sort of introduced the concept of discipline in the collection and spending of money, which I'm sure was not very common back in the days when you were king and you could, you know, any protesting citadelanry could immediately divide him into four citadelanry. So it's not that bad. And she thanks everything a lot. But on the topic of funny, on the topic of his funny ponytail, I have a theory that the world has entirely been changed by people with funny hair.

I mean, as you can see over here, Kautia had had had that, Einstein had that, and now the world is very dramatically been changed by a man with very funny hair. There is something about hair in the world. There is some correlation between the two. Please go ahead and add.

Yeah. So Kautia or Chanakya's concept of budgets was very similar to what happens in present day budgets. With the king's expenses on the 75 concubines replaced with administrative expenses, as you will see. And to continue with the historical debate, the origins of the modern budget can be traced to the Norman period, the origins of the modern budget with reference to Western government, the Norman period, some nine centuries ago when two departments dealt with finance.

The second department was called a treasury and the second was called the exchequer. This word exchequer has always fascinated me a lot. It is something that it is a check that I gave long ago and has bounced now and it outdated or something. It's the exchequer.

It's also given me some very sort of useless checking of your exchequer. Basically, it's booked out the exchequer. What am I exchequer? Yes.

But let's go back to its Christian meaning. Yes. So the treasury, what the tragedy did was, it received and paid out money on behalf of the modern, so it did do the solid stuff of actually running the domain and the exchequer had a lower office which received money. So actually got money to spend and an upper office which gave money to the king and basically to the concubines and whatever.

So as you mentioned in your this thing, that's where the word budget started from the Bouquet, the wallet, all those things. And the first use of the term dates back to 1733 in a financial statement by Walpole as Prime Minister and the Chancellor of the exchequer. So a cartoon of him opening a patent medicine seller was published at the time with the satirical comment, the budget opened. And budge is an old word for a smaller case.

So initially, the budget referred solely to the Chancellor's annual speech on the nation's finances. Now the term is used for an annual financial statement of income and expenditure of government. But I'm very surprised that there was actually, I mean I understand maybe in 1733 there was still room for satire without people being decapitated. But that's quite fascinating.

But again, then coming back to India, how does our local Indian budget process really function? So the discussion is really good. What is the sludge between the gears that make this moving? So the budget is prepared for the financial minister of the assistance of a number of advisors and bureaucrats obviously.

And the financial minister seeks the view of industry captains and economists prior to preparation, which is an ignobesum. And then various accounting and finance related organizations are there, they should have started accountants or lobby groups and things like that. They send in their opinions and suggestions. The financial manager carefully considers these and ignores them.

It's almost like it's very fitting that there's this proverb in Hindi that says, Bhakra Kadega, subme badega. That was very much the word. So then finally what happens is he asks his bureaucrats from the finance department, what is doing? The bureaucrats prepare the budget and give it to them.

That sounds somewhat sensible. Where is the catch? So it's very sensible. And the budget making process starts in the third, so it starts pretty early.

So basically after half the financial errors over these guys have started collecting the data and all. So four stages, first estimates, they're estimates that stage. So they get revenue from different kinds of taxes. So they've got revenue for half the year and a lot of these taxes are seasonal.

So for example, if you're expecting revenue from the automotive sector by way of excise duty on cars, you would expect them to spike somewhere just before the festive season. There's a lot of people buying cars. So the cars would have left their automotive factories a month or so ago. So you would see a spike in the other side.

And there will be some lulls. So there is this pithropakshman where very few people would buy cars. So one month before that you would see a slump in the collection, things like that. So they've got their forecasting model.

So they know based on how much taxes they've got in any particular period, how much they are likely to get over the rest of the year. That's the income sort of focus. And they do a similar expenditure forecast. They know what their some of the expenditures are pretty well laid out.

They know what it will happen. But some which go on projects, which go on outstanding items on defence per command or what 100 things that you're having spent money on. Fact finding missions to like those times. I mean, very very, I mean requirements for, I mean, they have to in fact finding missions.

I'd also for the Olympics where family members are also required to motivate the athletes. Yeah. So those kind of things, so they get an estimate of the expenditure. Therefore, it kind of means that they first estimate the inflows and outflows and then they decide how to raise the inflows to match the outflows more closely.

Correct. Yeah. So the tacit assumption here is being that the inflows will always be less than the outflows. Correct.

And what is if it might often happen if it's the other way around? It's very hilarious. And it was very nicely explained in a just prime minister episode. Why is it never hot?

Amazing. Please go ahead. So the background is as follows. Okay.

Hacker the prime minister wants the government not to buy some expensive military hardware because they will never use it anyway. So he tells the bureaucracy to cancel the order and return the money saved to the tax by a tax cuts. So Humphrey, who is the cabinet secretary is a host of the suggestion. And here is the exchange.

Hacker. Why is the chancellor opposed to tax cuts? Sir Humphrey, because he's advised for the treasury and the treasury don't believe in giving money back. Hacker, it's not there.

It's the taxpayers money. Humphrey, that is one view, but it's not a view of the treasury. Once they've got their hands on it. Hacker, but what if they don't need it?

Humphrey. Taxation is not about what you need. Hacker, what's it about then? Prime minister, the treasury does not work out what they need to spend and then think of how to raise the money.

What do they do? They pitch for as much as they think they can get away with and then think how to spend it. If you start giving money back, because you don't need it, you're baking with centuries of tradition. So this is how taxation has been going on in most of the free world.

In the non-free world, of course, the government simply tells us all this money. I know, I mean, Jitna means that there's nothing in the living. So we are lucky to be living in a functioning democracy where the government sees it necessary to make some pretense of actually needing the money before asking for it. So in autocratic government, I'll just pass along the box.

Yeah, just hand it over. It's like elections in North Korea. You might as well go and tick that box in the ballot. There's only one.

So before we continue to more of the formal stuff within our own union budget, what do you think should be taking a small break? Yeah, we'll have a little breather where you can sort of meditate on all the way of lean information that we'll give you. And contemplate on how much money the government will get away with this time. Yeah, and you're actually lucky you're not living in North Korea.

That's not awesome. And see you right back if the economy is still functioning in all five minutes. See you soon. Are you looking for finance products and services that can enhance your post-war?

What's your personal finance experience? Are you looking for a space to talk about your financial product or service? And are you looking for a Christ Rock show where the conversation is all about money? Well, your search ends here.

Hi, my name is Arupak Gupta and I post other best of us at Hot Cars and I invite you for the conversation about your post-war show. So, the first thing you're going to do is you're going to do a shutdown. Correct. So, that cliff that data or the fiscal cliff that we talk about is that.

So, the government goes on spending and it does need to go periodically to the house to get its permission and the house, if it's against what the executive branches are, as it was when Obama was on the power, they make life difficult. And there is a bit of a catch to it. They can't shut down the government because a lot of the functions of the government are pretty vital. Yeah.

And so, there is this eyeball to eyeball thing and then... It's a basic game of chicken. Yeah. You're both running towards each other.

Who is basically going to take that? Has that ever happened in India? Have you ever gotten close to it? I cannot recollect.

So, I'm not a parliamentate. But I don't think anything like that has ever happened in India. And I'm not sure we have a situation where that happens. It's that tight here either because government goes, it's fair to complete, goes and spends whatever it likes and it basically signs, you know, it's checks and adorn.

They'll use a huge debt for... So, basically we are a very credit card type economy. Yeah, very credit card type economy. But it's one of those things which is very difficult to explain to young people.

My children are asking, especially in the American context, how stupid this whole thing is. It does look stupid, but yeah, it has to be there. So, that was about a consolidated fund of India. And the other fund is what is known as a contingency fund, which is basically the petty cash account, which you can basically take out and tell, sir, what you spent it on later.

So, that is the... It's the idea type. So, account to meet unforeseen expenditure. So, urgent fact-finding missions to study the government system in Burma and all will be under this.

This term, petty cash is also damn interesting. It's almost like, I mean, it's the money that you have given out of spite to your girlfriend. It's like, you keep saying that I'm a stingy fellow, so take this. I'm being petty and I'm throwing some money at you.

Type petty cash. It seems like a very interesting term as such. Yeah. To continue, there is also something called a public account, which is the amount collected to the government acting as a banker.

For example, a proud and fund. So, we all have proud and fund accounts and all that is deposited with the government, who holds it in custody for us. So, those funds are basically available to the government. And government is supposed to treat them as a banker would treat the funds.

So, you can't just take it and spend it on the dollar. You have to give it back to the people. But you can borrow from it. You can borrow from it.

Yeah. And the finance bill, which includes the tax proposals and the tax rates, it provides the fine print of the budget. So, all those little wherein hereafter and here before side, I'll explain there too is all that in the finance bill. All the 16th century language.

And of course, there's more to it. The bills have to be forwarded to the Rajasabhavha comment. The Lok Sabhahava is not obligated to accept the comments. And Rajasabh cannot delay the passage of these bills.

These bills become law when they are signed by the president. And the Lok Sabhah cannot increase the request for funds submitted to the executive nor can it authorize new expenditures. Yeah. And whenever I was going up, we used to have this subject called history and civics.

So, civics covered all these things. And whenever it would be sending stuff to the Rajasabhavha comment, so we would be like, you know, finding a very amusing... How you would comment on the bill, what is the succeed? What is the succeed?

What is the succeed? Bill about the succeed? I don't know. I mean, there's also, I mean, along with commenting on bills, there's also a lot of other commenting that we have discovered.

And he's doing sitting with his smartphones in the houses as well. And, well, yeah, I mean, the other part of being that, this signing of things by the president, I mean, in India from the beginning, I think in our book, so little, the president is rubber stamp. Like, even in the most formal of languages, they were like, yeah, the president is inconsequential. Please ignore him.

But at the other day, he has to do all of the signatures. But he's practically obliged to do those signatures, right? So, I mean, I really wonder what if he got a rogue president? Like, say Donald Trump became president of India.

Like, he would be like, Janikarika. Jokhan, Janikarika. I won't sign this. And the nominee, so I, I don't know, I'd gone somewhere and, you know, the president of India owns everything.

So, everything that exists in India, which is not claimed by someone else, it belongs to the president of India. So, he decides to have a garage sale or something, and we'll just screw it. He's like, hey, you're a bomb, you're a cello, bomb, you're a little bit like a 25 rupee, child like that. And we cannot be entirely sure, but he didn't do that in all of us for interest.

Anyway, so, yeah, so moving on, some more fine points of order. The proposal is in the budget coming to force on the first of April. And between the presentation and the effective date, there is a gap of one month during which the rogue looks up, I can review and modify the government's budget proposal. This doesn't happen most of the time.

In fact, never happens. And the parliamentary scrutiny of the proposal and the passage of the budget gets completed in May, well after the commencement of the new fiscal year. And this is what has been happening year after year, ever since independence. Since the proposed budget has to be effective from the first of April, the government usually seeks an interim approval to meet, imagine, expenditures that have to be incurred pending the approval of the budget.

So, this is the avoidance of that, you know, the fiscal year. This is called a vote on account and a sanctions given by the passage of the vote on account get automatically overridden once the budget is, so the temporary and then once the budget is approved then the budget takes on. But what is the main advantage of moving the budget data head? Well, the stated objective behind advancing the data budget presentation is to ensure that the finance bill is passed before the start of the fiscal year on the first of April.

If that happens, all central government departments will have the full allocation from day one of the fiscal year. It will happen also just in time for the UPL. Of course, because there is, that is just going to come on. You have to give the government benefit of it.

You have nothing but nobel intentions at heart. So, the decision comes with some advantages as well as disadvantages. The major advantage, though to my cynical eyes, this doesn't look like it makes a bit of a difference. Of advancing the budget presentation date is that the budget along with the finance bill is passed before marching.

The central government department will have a clear picture of the allocation right from the beginning of the financial year. Of course, yeah. The biggest decision advantage and again, I can't for the life of me see what enormous disadvantage this brings. Of advancing the budget presentation date is that the government, one of the revenue and expenditure data for the first nine months of the financial year.

That influences any of their rights. Yeah, it doesn't give any really, it makes any real difference there. But yeah, I think we have a fairly well-rounded express trade like fast outline of the budget process. You had some historical facts you were saying.

Yeah, from being highly secretive to occasionally satirical and exceedingly lucid, budgets have had a remarkable history as we have been discussing. The first Indian budget was presented by one James Wilson. Of course. Surprisingly for me, when I found out, way way back in 1869, on February 18th of that year to be precise, 1869 imagine that.

Wilson, whose designation was finance member of the India Council that advised the Indian Wiceroy, was also founder of the Economist, World Fame as Economist magazine, and described by Karl Marx as an economical Mandarin of high standing. Karl Marx, World Fame as Karl Marx. But he also a largely self-taught man who had worked his way up in his family occupation making and selling hats. He loved Topi Panam.

And before becoming a scholar and writer, largely based on his billions and knowledge of economics and commerce. He seems like a guy who genuinely had the pockets begin for that wallet. Our budget seems to follow the UK budget in many ways, including for many years timing, since it used to be held at 5.30pm, which was noon in the UK. And extreme secrecy, which may have been reinforced there by a scandal that broke out in the UK just as RK Shanmukam Chiti, India's first finance minister incidentally, was preparing his first budget.

What happened was on budget day in the UK in 1947, you, Daitan, the British Chancellor of the Exchequer, met a journalist when he was walking into the parliament and mentioned a few details on tax changes that he was planning. The journalist broke the story before the speech and Daitan had to resign. And this definitely would have made Chiti all the more determined to maintain secrecy. It's obviously very auspicious for India that all our entire financial planning of the country began with his scandal.

I think it was a very auspicious start that has led to many precedents since. And the biggest problem for his successor, CD Deshmuk, was finding money for the plans which meant higher taxes. In one budget speech, he tried to buck up tax payers with the story of a letter he claimed to have got from a villager who paid no taxes but wanted help. Deshmuk said he has limited a sum of rupees 5 to me and has promised to remit a similar sum every year so long as the common run of people can produce men and women with this spirit, the country can face the future.

However difficult it may be with confidence. No one felt for it of course, but you are not allowed to call out our finance minister's budget speech stories for fakeness. Indeed and T.T. Krishnamacharya who replaced Deshmuk was an industrialist who strangely enough had a lot of enthusiasm for taxation because normally would expect industrialists to be anti-taxation but T.T.K.

was Chai Sikit Ligarama. Chai Sikit Ligarama. In 1957 he invented two new levies. So one was a wealth tax and the second was an expanded tax.

He was turned into all those who had to pay these to display some patriotic spirit because obviously it was a whining. I am one of those who also believed that the greatest advances towards economic equality and positive social improvements are made in difficult times when the conscience and solidarity of people are raised to the highest pitch. And then immediately on QA someone in the background, he is not a national anthem. Everyone has to stand up and one and a half minute break, everything was forgotten.

Muragite Sai of course the man who is very famously consumed a lot of urinal fluids for surviving up to the age of 100 had his political philosophy of socialism on steroids. He relished levying taxes and in 1968 he said, I now come to the much dreaded part of my budget speech. I trust honorable members will not take me to task if the proposals do not fulfill the expectations of dread. The deficit of this kind is usually an invitation to an FM to sharpen his knife.

I propose to engage myself in a minor operation of plastic surgery taking out a little flesh here and adding a little bit there. Desai was the first to make the budget into a big opportunity for publicity for the FM and also the first FM with serious aspirations for the PMC. He was very bad as I think he was the most bad as finance minister we have ever had. And all these guys are like total Kachalimu.

He is also one of the other guys who was not committed in those traditions. Would have had to be buried with a separate casket for his balls. Indeed. Imagine telling the people that I am making very nasty laws and forgive me of the law that are nasty in the first position.

That's what he said. So sincerely, I mean. Yeah true bad as. So C Subramanam is also the first recorded finance minister to end his speech with the word.

I now commend the budget for the acceptance of the house. That's what all these guys say. So some variation on this has been the usual way to end the budget including the one we just saw yesterday. And he was also the first Q-lam to hold the proposal.

Which is the first Q-lam to hold the proposal. Which is the first Q-lam to hold the finance minister. It is C Subramanam because C Subramanam. Madhu Dada Vadhe was one of the first to start making other labelled puns to introduce his specific excise proposals.

I mean this is a man, I mean he's probably chucks IDL as a FM. Chuckles, Claudia, wanted to put it over. When falling far short of simplified exacting standards we must grudgingly admit that he tried. In 1990 he quipped, I proposed to remove excise duty on pickles altogether in the hope that this will lead some flavour and spice to my budget.

How elegant. How truly elegant. And yeah so that pretty much brings us to the end of our simplified episode on budget. I'm sure your sort of face is glowing with the light of enlightenment.

You will go ahead and spread the word to the few unfortunate people. I haven't heard of simplified tell them to go listen to them. If nothing else you will be more capable of making at least a few bad financial puns. You'll know all about pickles and how they can add flavour and spice to your life.

So here's our budget version of the financial budget of the union of India. And we will be back with our regularly scheduled programming in about Fortnite and with Mooseo Chuck into as well. And till next time I'll see you in the rain. And see you guys, have a great Fortnite.

See you soon. Bye bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Simblified?

This episode is 43 minutes long.

When was this Simblified episode published?

This episode was published on February 6, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Simblified episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.