Skip to content
Ep. 50: Sin episode artwork

Dec 31, 2023 7 min

Ep. 50: Sin

from The Daily Vedantic Hosted by James Beshara

In this episode, James dives into the Vedantic perspective on sin, differentiating it from traditional religious views. He explains that Vedanta, stemming from the Vedas and Upanishads, does not adhere to a strict set of commandments or the concept of sin as seen in many religions. Instead, Vedanta considers sin as anything that agitates the mind. James highlights that in Vedanta, individuals are punished by their sins, not for them, meaning the consequences of one's actions are inherent and not imposed by a cosmic judge. He challenges the idea of cosmic punishment, arguing that actions like lying or cheating, in certain contexts, are not sins if they don't cause agitation and serve a higher purpose. The episode emphasizes self-awareness and the importance of understanding the natural consequences of our actions, encouraging listeners to seek harmony with the world rather than focusing on external rules or fears of eternal damnation. The Daily Vedantic is a daily podcast and YouTube channel dedicated to the timeless wisdom of the Upanishads (⁠https://www.thedailyvedantic.co⁠). Dating back to over 5,000 years ago, the source of nearly all Eastern Philosophy, and loved by Western giants from Emerson to Thoreau to Carl Jung and Alan Watts, studied daily by Joseph Campbell to Aldous Huxley to Arthur Schopenhauer and countless others, The Daily Vedantic aims to make this ancient philosophy as modern and accessible as it is simple, practical — and profound. James Beshara (⁠https://www.twitter.com/jamesbeshara⁠) is a renowned startup founder of multiple companies, a prolific startup investor in 200+ others including some of the biggest startup names on the planet, a husband and father of three little girls, and philosophy student and teacher in Los Angeles. James also co-hosts Yoga For Your Intellect (⁠https://www.YFYI.co⁠), a biweekly long-form conversational podcast with his teacher Joseph Emmett ( ⁠https://www.instagram.com/yogaforyourintellect⁠ ). James is a student of Swami Parthasarathy, the acclaimed author of Vedanta Treatise (⁠Vedanta Treatise – The Eternities⁠) and teacher at Vedanta Academy in Malavli, India. As James says often, when you’re ready for the real thing, Swami’s daily lectures are where the true wisdom and systematic discovery of the world’s oldest continually studied philosophy resides: ⁠https://www.vedantaworld.org⁠

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 50: Sin

0:00 7:46
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

be back and we're talking about that sin, y'all. So last episode touched on the concept of sin within the lens of Vedanta. And you know, I felt like we need to do a whole episode on the Vedantic perspective on sin. Within Vedanta, one of the things that separates it from religions is that there is no concept of sin.

There's no shoulds and shouldn'ts, thou shalt, thou shalt. There are no rites, there are no rituals. It's at the end of these four textbooks called the Vedas. It's the Upanishads, or what the end of the Vedas are called, the Upanishads.

And it is not about ritual or shoulds and shouldn'ts. And the closest that the Upanishads and Vedanta gets to sin is that which agitates. It approaches sin like physics talks about the law of gravity. And that says, if it agitates you, well, why do it?

And to cultivate the observation, the witness that recognizes, oh, wow, that action agitates me. Swami will say often in his lectures that we are punished by the sin, not for the sin. So let me explain that for you. Then we're going to get into the natural question people might have of, well, does that mean you could do anything if it doesn't agitate you?

So first off, you were punished by the sin, not for the sin. There's not some cosmic judge that says, all right, Sarah, Arjuna, I'm watching your every move. And like Santa Claus, there's going to be repercussions if you don't do what I want you to do. It's more like if you touch the fire, if you touch that burning stove, you're going to get burnt.

You don't need a cosmic judge that is taking stock and telling you, all right, I need to punish you for that action. You lie to your co-workers freely. Well, it's going to result in diminished trust, likely no longer a job. And you're punished for the sin, not by the sin.

You murder someone. Macbeth, the Shakespearean tragedy is so beautifully articulate around this topic where Macbeth, he kills the king because he thinks he should be king. And afterwards, he doesn't say, I murdered King Duncan. He says, I murdered sleep.

I murdered sleep. No prison is as constraining as having murdered sleep. And this principle is both freeing and also pretty heavy. It's freeing in that there are no commandments in which we have to blindly apply to our lives.

The Old Testament has over 640 laws to it. And we think it's 10 commandments, but there are over 640 laws to keep track of in the Old Testament. Vedanta, there isn't any. Christian, at the end of the Bhagavad Gita says, hey, I've said what I needed to say, and now you can do whatever you want.

There's no cosmic repercussions. To those that are enlightened, to those that are on the path to enlightenment, there are no cosmic repercussions where it is, you do something bad and it's eternal damnation. There is no eternal damnation within Vedanta. There is no mistake that is insurmountable.

There is no act. There's no seven deadly sins. There are no acts that have been making it possible for redemption. And there's no place that you get sent to where once you're there, it's final for eternity.

And you were on trial for 80 years and you misbehaved. And now you need to spend eternity in hell. Oh my God, that's a whole other episode on how insane that idea is of you didn't ask to be created, but a creator God made you. You've got 80 years to be on your best behavior for eternity on the other side of it.

Christianity and Judaism has so many beautiful elements too, and it's profound in its symbolic significance on how to approach life and our perspective on this existence. It can get you to heaven too, liberation, without a doubt. But the cartoonish idea we have around sin and eternal damnation in a fiery pit, that's hundreds of years after Christ's time that we start to layer on these things that now people take as literal, like a devil with horns or an actual fiery pit that you'd spend eternity in. Within Vedanta, heaven and hell are mental states and not geographical places.

I think that is the case for Christianity as well, for Christ's words, for Judaism, for Islam. In fact, there are sects within each of those that have that view explicitly stated. The Kabbalah and Judaism, Christian mysticism, Hesekism, and the Eastern Orthodox Church within Christianity, Sufism within Islam. And as we go back to this concept of sin, it's simply that which agitates.

And yes, if you can kill someone without agitation, if you're actually doing that to make sure there's less harm in the world, then that is not a sin in any stretch within Vedanta. And everyone that has been caught in the middle of a righteous war against unrighteousness or protecting their city, their family, their community from great harm that requires such extreme means, well then, this philosophical approach is clear. And when it comes to punishment, you're not punished for the sin. We're punished by the sin.

Murdering sleep, the distrust of your co-workers, your family, your friends, the distance you create from those around you through your behavior, we're punished by the sin, not for the sin. Like the physicist working around these natural laws, there's no cosmic judge that's watching over you and ready to hammer the gavel and send you away. It's simply recognizing this is the way it all works. Maybe I should move with the way it works instead of against it.

Instead of memorizing the 640 plus laws of which to live a good life, it's a simple recognition of maybe I shouldn't agitate myself. This has been another reflection on the Daily Vedantic. We'll see you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Vedantic?

This episode is 7 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Vedantic episode published?

This episode was published on December 31, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Vedantic episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.