Welcome back, party people. Do I have a bit of almond in my teeth? Yes. Are we going to discuss the differences in the approach to truth between East and West?
Also, yes. Probably both of them at the same time. So what is the difference between the approach to truth, capital T, truth, the pursuit of truth? The lifelong, the lives-long pursuit of capital T truth from the Western perspective and from the Eastern perspective.
Some ways in studying development economics and undergrad, it is an oversimplification to approach philosophy or the world in over simplistic terms like East and West and yet sometimes it is quite helpful when there's such a foundational difference between the two. Such a foundational difference between the two and certain topics. Do take the approach that is an oversimplification. That obviously does not cover all exceptions to the rule, but is generally is directionally true and when it comes to our pursuit of truth, culturally speaking.
Philosophically speaking. From the West there is a high contrast, a big difference between the foundational pursuit of truth and the worldviews from the East. The difference is being the Judeo-Christian Islamic approach to truth and truth being linguistic. The truth being something that is a factual statement, belief viewpoint, putting words in a specific order and stating them as a vow or as a belief system versus the truth in the East is transcendent of language.
It according to Advaitiv Adanta, the truth is not in words as is said within this ancient philosophy. The truth is not in words. Language cannot grasp the truth in the same way our fingers and hands cannot grasp the ocean. To try to take as they say a God defined as a God confined to try to take something as infinite as the truth.
Reality itself and try to confine it with words is not only impossible laughable from the Eastern perspective, but the truth in the West oftentimes gets relegated gets boiled down to honesty speaking the truth. It becomes instead of a pointer towards reality. It becomes a civilizing force. Putting the truth, everybody must speak the truth.
Synodimizing honesty, in the spoken word with truth, is like I said a civilizing force. It works wonders to tell a community. They must speak the truth that the truth is in words, that they must string their words together in the proper order for them to be true, for them to approach truth. The words must be in the right order.
The credo, the belief system must be stated back and and growing up in Texas it must be stated back when you're like seven years old and then reinforced at 10, 12, 15. Growing up Roman Catholic, you're literally told words to say as a child and as an adolescent and you're told these words are the truth and the quote unquote truth is a smattering of facts about events. Long ago, people long gone, forces that we cannot perceive. This is again very different than the Eastern approach to truth.
The Eastern approach to truth is not about pledging allegiance to some imperial power, metaphysically or literally the truth in the Eastern sense is an experience. The truth, reality, Torah, mocha, nirvana, liberation, realization, it is experiencing reality. And as I've said on this podcast project before, this philosophy of Advaitivadanta, which if this is your first episode you're coming to within the Daily Vedantic, feel free to check out the first episode on the entire project, which is a 15 minute overview of the whole philosophy of Advaitivadanta, which this ancient philosophy that predates all Western philosophies, this ancient philosophy can be explained in a matter of a few minutes, 15 minutes, the whole philosophy, no shoulds, no shuns, no shouts, shall nots, there's no codex of rules you must follow just eternal principles. One of the eternal principles of this philosophy is that this philosophy is not the truth.
Another word for Advaitanta, another term for Advaitivadanta, Sonata and Adarma, which means eternal principles. And one of the two dozen or so eternal principles that are emphasized most within this framework, approach to living life, is this concept that this philosophy is not the truth. I have never come across a philosophy that disavows itself, usually a philosophy reinforces itself from every angle and anything that comes across the desk of that disavows it, you put your head in the sand, you can see that with literal interpretations of the Bible, where you have people that are like, nope, whatever that scientist says that is, that is, I don't know, the dark forces at work do not listen to it. But with this philosophy, not only does it make space for the best of science, the best of philosophy, the best of religion, all of it fits under the umbrella within the concepts and principles of Advaitivadanta, all of it.
It actually is no wonder that you have people like Schrodinger, who named his dog Ottmann, a quantum physicist that names his dog Ottmann because he finds so many similarities with his observations, with his scientific approach to the world, and this ancient philosophy. Yeah, philosophers like Chopinar, Emerson, Thoreau, Carl Jung, studying this philosophy daily, and someone like Carl Jung is as much as you can, drenching himself in the experiences of the world, the psychological approach to the world, and finding so many similarities to these principles and a life well lived. So this philosophy can become a container for any of our experiences in the world, any of our pursuits in the world, and it will make you better at that pursuit. In fact, the great saint Vivekananda was asked when he was speaking in the US over 100 years ago, he was asked, did you come to convert us?
And he said, no, I came to make a Christian a better Christian, the Jew, a better Jew, a better Muslim, a better Muslim. This philosophy, like I said, makes space for the best of religion, science, philosophy, Socrates, allegory of the cave, as we have discussed, fits so hand in glove perfectly within this philosophy of Advaitivadanta that predated Socrates predated even the pre-Socratic philosophers like Thales by thousands of years, and the Silk Roads were well established, the trade roads were well established between East and West at that point, between Greece and India. In fact, you have Socrates' heroes, Pythagoras, and the historians believe Pythagoras spent up to a decade in India, 20 years before Socrates was even born. So these trade routes existed, the exchange of these ideas for those curious about such topics existed, and you find it in all of these world traditions we have in the West.
And this philosophy is not mutually exclusive. It does not exclude the philosophy of, let's say, Christ or of Socrates, a Plato of Hegel, of Kant, of Schopenauer. They're quite compatible when looked at through the right lens, but significant distinction is many philosophies in the West, worldviews in the West believe that the truth is in words, is in statements, is in facts. This philosophy would say, well, that statement about a dream, the statement of the dream you had last night, someone was wearing a blue shirt, has as much value and substance in your waking state, as talking about facts in this world would have to waking up to reality.
In other words, stating a fact about a dream you had, let's say you were on a cruise ship cruising through the Atlantic that might have some factual value of the dream that you had, but was it the truth? The truth is you were asleep in your bed, comfortable beneath your covers, not on a cruise ship. And stringing together words to describe an experience here that is not according to a philosophy like Vadanta reality, stringing together a series of words to describe facts, or a historical account is not the truth, according to this philosophy, because this philosophy says the truth transcends this experience. The truth, what's really happening in the universe within the limitation of language, I'll use that phrase, what's really happening has nothing to do with words.
Words do not touch it. Just like talking about surfing does not get anywhere close to the experience of gliding down the line. The truth philosophically from the Eastern lens, whether it's pedantic, whether it is a Buddhist lens, whether it's a Janist, whether it is any number of the derivations of all three, the truth is an experience much like riding down the line of a five foot wave, surfing, and the difference in kind, not just a difference in degree from talking about surfing. So what is the value of words of listening to a philosophical podcast episode like this?
Well, words are great pointers. Talking about the experience of surfing might intrigue you enough to go out and get that experience. In the words, the pointers, the direction towards the truth, towards transcending words, it is like a pole vaulter and their pole. You can't cross the bar without the pole.
Might be 12, 13 feet up. You can't cross that bar by just jumping. You need the pole. But if you hold on to the pole, if you get attached to the pole, obsessive about getting all of the words exactly right, quoting chapter verse and attached to scholasticism, that is the opposite of the goal, which is to transcend the words.
You can't cross the bar with the pole and you can't cross the bar without the pole. Use the pole and then drop it. And similarly with this philosophy, use the words, reflect on these words, internalize the words of this philosophy of the sages from chonkra to ramuna to Christ, to the Buddha, use these words from these lighthouses throughout history, but use these words to transcend their words and to experience what their words are pointing to. A great example of this is John chapter 17 verse 11 where Christ says, I'm leaving the world, but they're still in it.
Holy Father, protect them by the power of your name so they can be one united just as we are one. And that is Christ praying loud enough for every disciple to hear what his desire is, his lone desire, is for us to discover our union and a union that he says just as we are one, him and the Father. These words are pointers, but they are pointers to something that transcends all prayer, all words, all credos, all belief systems, all verse, all scripture, they point to an experience, an experience of unity, of oneness, the experience that Christ prayed for, the experience that Raman Maharshi talked about 2000 years later, the experience that Vivekananda is even encouraging, Christian to become a better Christian, to follow Christ and not the pastor in the corner of the street, to follow the words, to listen to the prayer, perhaps in John 17, listen to the words, reflect on the words, and then transcend the words. That is today's Reflection on the Daily pedantium.
We'll see you next time.