Skip to content
Ep 596: Do We Have Free Will? episode artwork

Dec 11, 2025 9 min

Ep 596: Do We Have Free Will?

from The Daily Vedantic Hosted by James Beshara

In today’s reflection, we explore one of the oldest questions in philosophy: Do we actually have free will, or is everything predetermined? Using insights from Vedanta, karma, and the law of cause-and-effect, we break down how your past shapes this moment — and how your choices right now shape your future. This episode explains why destiny and free will coexist, how “reverse karma” works, and why self-reflection, questioning your assumptions, and daily study can radically shift your life. If you’ve ever wondered why things happen—or whether you can truly change—this is your answer. The Daily Vedantic is a daily podcast and YouTube channel dedicated to the timeless wisdom of the Upanishads (https://thedailyvedantic.com/). Dating back to over 5,000 years ago, the source of nearly all Eastern Philosophy, and loved by Western giants from Emerson to Thoreau to Carl Jung and Alan Watts, studied daily by Joseph Campbell to Aldous Huxley to Arthur Schopenhauer and countless others, The Daily Vedantic aims to make this ancient philosophy as modern and accessible as it is simple, practical — and profound. James Beshara is a creator (Magic Mind, Apt, Tilt, acquired by Airbnb), podcaster (Yoga For Your Intellect, The Daily Vedantic), angel investor in over 150 companies (Gusto, Mercury, OpenAI), musician (openstate_), and encourager living in Malibu, California with his wife, 3 young daughters, their dachshund named Wendell, and their hamster named Smokey. James also co-hosts Yoga For Your Intellect (https://www.YFYI.co), a biweekly long-form conversational podcast with his teacher Joseph Emmett ( https://www.instagram.com/yogaforyourintellect ) James is a student of Swami Parthasarathy, the acclaimed author of Vedanta Treatise (Vedanta Treatise – The Eternities) and teacher at Vedanta Academy in Malavli, India. As James says often, when you’re ready for the real thing, Swami’s daily lectures are where the true wisdom and systematic discovery of the world’s oldest continually studied philosophy resides: https://www.vedantaworld.org

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep 596: Do We Have Free Will?

0:00 9:34
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome back to another reflection on the Daily Vedantic. Last episode I did a community question. I've got another one here from Philip C. Philip C says, and this is on question of free will in destiny.

And this is such a massive topic within various schools of philosophy and has been for thousands of years. And you will be likely be surprised at how succinct and quickly this topic can actually be answered. Here's the question. If the self is beyond stewardship, so capital S reality truth.

Raman. Raman is Sanskrit for the vast, the eternal. It's colloquializes God, but it's think of it like the vast. If the self is beyond stewardship, does free will exist at all?

Am I actually choosing my path? Or is everything already determined? The question about free will. You have some philosophers that bought ink by the barrel to try to answer this question, and this philosophy answers it quite succinctly by saying, Philip, you are the product of your past and the producer of your future.

So on the question of does free will exist? Am I actually choosing my path? Or is everything already determined? It's both.

There is a predetermination to and a destiny to this very moment. You could not escape it. This moment is the unfolding of cause and effect. Karma is just cause and effect.

And every Eastern philosophy has this concept of karma and cause and effect. Every Western philosophy has it as well of cause and effect. They don't call it karma, and it doesn't it doesn't have as much of a strict lineage of cause effect cause effect in a linear fashion. It's more like your karma might be eternal, damnation, and a pit of fire.

Your cause and effect. What you did might lead to eternal provenance in heaven. So you have aspects and sex within Christianity within Judaism within Islam that also have cause and effect. They don't refer to it as karma.

And it's not nearly as let's say nitty gritty as the Eastern approach to karma, which is that car wreck that extra hundred bucks that a friend just put in a birthday gift for you. All of that. And anything and everything in between is cause and effect from decisions that you made. You get that car wreck and you wonder why may why this happened.

It was predetermined based on the decisions that you made in the past. It could not be escaped. You listening to this episode wherever you are, you could not escape it if you tried. Inescapable grip of cause and effect.

But what we do with this moment, the decisions that we can make right now, the decisions that we make in this present moment completely up to you. You can choose to correct a path that you might have previously been on. You could choose to rectify wrong. Swami will call that reverse karma.

Just get rid of some of the bad karma that you might have accrued. You could instantly wake up. It said that with the gate to the baguagata, you can understand one verse with this very cryptic, top seat, her be head turning 30 minute poem. If you can understand one verse and you're instantly realized instantly, and that understanding is a choice.

The obfuscation that choice do not understand, the choice do not reflect. The choice to not see clearly is a choice that this philosophy says we make every moment of every day that we're in this relative existence. We could choose to wake up, but we choose to be in this illusion as this philosophy states it so bluntly. We're choosing this, which means we can choose the alternative.

You can choose to make an accident, a wreck, a foothold towards the higher, recognizing, ah, shouldn't have been texting. I knew it. I shouldn't have been rushing to that. I knew I caused that.

It could be a reflection on I didn't cause that at all. Well, logistically, this philosophy says you did, but logistically, maybe someone swerves into your lane, totals your car, but your reflection isn't why this happened. Your reflection is, thank God I survived. That is a toehold towards the higher.

The three daily practices of this philosophy are questioned, everything. Don't take anything for granted and study reflect daily. Those three practices, those are a great way to make the most out of any present moment. This one included.

Question everything that's being said by the speaker, by the boss that's giving you that incentive, that career that is telling you, yeah, you know, your, these golden handcuffs are worth it. That might be completely antithetical to what you're really wired for. Question, the notions of, well, I love my parents. So I probably should just repeat and say the things that they believe to make them happy.

Is that what will make them happy? Is that what's right for you? Is that love if your parents conditionally only love you if you're saying the right things in the right order? Is that love?

Question and everything. Don't take anything for granted. You survive that car wreck. Maybe even if you're paralyzed from the neck down, you survived.

Don't take it for granted. Cancer diagnosis. Maybe it's the best thing that ever happened to you to wake you up. Benjamin Franklin has that famous quote, most men commit suicide by 25.

Some just take 50 years to do it. Maybe that cancer diagnosis wakes you up to life and not death. Don't take anything for granted, according to this philosophy study, reflect daily, not just hear the words but reflect on them. This very moment might be a pause of the audio for you to reflect on one nugget that might have spoke to you might have resonated with you more than another and there's a few moments of reflection on it.

There's a shift, a change. That's your free will in action. Determining. Yes, the cause and effect of what will unfold on the other side, but succinctly put you are a product of your past, but you are a producer of your future.

This philosophy is not big on victimhood. It's also not big on heroism outside of ourselves. You make yourself, you mar yourself. You are the author of your fortune.

You are the author of your misfortune. It can be heavy when you're in the midst of misfortune, but man is that empowering when you know you can be the author of your fortune. There's nothing in this world that has predetermined every aspect of your existence right now. It's a moment where you can change it all, but this moment is also inescapable based on the decisions, the choices you made leading up to it, destiny.

But it's also destiny for you to have this choice to change what happens next. And that is today's Reflection on the Daily Vodotic. I hope that answers your question, Philip. See you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Vedantic?

This episode is 9 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Vedantic episode published?

This episode was published on December 11, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Vedantic episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.