Skip to content
Ep 598: The Problem With Modern Philosophy episode artwork

Dec 12, 2025 17 min

Ep 598: The Problem With Modern Philosophy

from The Daily Vedantic Hosted by James Beshara

In this reflection, we explore the Vidantic principle of depth over breadth — the idea that mastery, clarity, and true transformation come not from consuming endless new ideas, but from deeply reflecting on timeless ones. Drawing on insights from Joseph Emtt’s 30 years of studying Advaita Vedanta, Rick Rubin’s “out with the new, in with the old” philosophy, and examples across spiritual and athletic disciplines, we break down why ancient teachings endure while trends fade — and how focusing on depth can reshape your spiritual path, your craft, and your entire life. Whether you're seeking personal growth, philosophical grounding, or a clearer path to inner mastery, this reflection cuts straight to the heart of what creates real progress. The Daily Vedantic is a daily podcast and YouTube channel dedicated to the timeless wisdom of the Upanishads (https://thedailyvedantic.com/). Dating back to over 5,000 years ago, the source of nearly all Eastern Philosophy, and loved by Western giants from Emerson to Thoreau to Carl Jung and Alan Watts, studied daily by Joseph Campbell to Aldous Huxley to Arthur Schopenhauer and countless others, The Daily Vedantic aims to make this ancient philosophy as modern and accessible as it is simple, practical — and profound. James Beshara is a creator (Magic Mind, Apt, Tilt, acquired by Airbnb), podcaster (Yoga For Your Intellect, The Daily Vedantic), angel investor in over 150 companies (Gusto, Mercury, OpenAI), musician (openstate_), and encourager living in Malibu, California with his wife, 3 young daughters, their dachshund named Wendell, and their hamster named Smokey. James also co-hosts Yoga For Your Intellect (https://www.YFYI.co), a biweekly long-form conversational podcast with his teacher Joseph Emmett ( https://www.instagram.com/yogaforyourintellect ) James is a student of Swami Parthasarathy, the acclaimed author of Vedanta Treatise (Vedanta Treatise – The Eternities) and teacher at Vedanta Academy in Malavli, India. As James says often, when you’re ready for the real thing, Swami’s daily lectures are where the true wisdom and systematic discovery of the world’s oldest continually studied philosophy resides: https://www.vedantaworld.org

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep 598: The Problem With Modern Philosophy

0:00 17:22
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

What up, party people? We're back with another reflection on the daily Vedanta Donk. And within this ancient, timeless wisdom tradition of Advaita Vedanta, I often reflect on this concept of depth over breadth. We recorded a recent Yoga for Your Intellect episode.

That's the conversational longer form episodes within this philosophy that I do with Joseph Emmett, who's been a teacher of Vedanta for 30 years. He went to the ashram when he was 19, left university, and he was looking all over the world for different places to go experience what these timeless traditions were pointing towards. These monasteries in Greece, different temples for Buddhism to traveling throughout the U.S. And he wanted to go beyond the classroom that he was studying at Washington University and in St.

Louis and go deep into experiencing what these philosophies were talking about. So long story short, he ends up finding Swami, our teacher, Swami Parthasarathy. And he was probably 30 years ago, so he must have been about 70. And in his 30-year journey with this philosophy, we met about 10 years ago here in Malibu and Calamity Ranch.

Shout out Calamity Ranch for having a philosophical resource on staff like Joseph. In one of the episodes that we just started recording our weekly conversations that he and I have had for the last decade around this philosophy. And in one of our recent episodes, we talked about this topic of depth over breadth. It's very different in the systematic approach to philosophy within Vedanta.

Then it might be an academic approach to philosophy within a university structure, for example, where it is to go wide. Go super wide. And if you're going to contribute, if you're going to study philosophy, if you're going to grad school for philosophy, if you're going to get a postgraduate degree in philosophy, you have to introduce something new. And that is so different from the Vedantic approach to philosophy, the Eastern approach to philosophy, which is just find out what the sages, the lighthouses throughout history have already said.

It's not discovering something new, it's discovering the timeless, what has always been. It's not a construction of words or ideas in a new and novel way. It has nothing to do with words. We recently did an episode on the fact that the truth, in the Eastern sense, philosophically, is not in words.

It's not about your contribution. It is about your reconciliation, your discovery, your clarity. With these paradoxical observations, principles, concepts that sages throughout nearly every major tradition have been saying over and over and over again. The Rig Veda says it well going back 5,000 plus years of the truth is one, the sages call it by many names.

All of these major traditions, the things that they're pointing to, that seem so paradoxical. Christ saying, turn the other cheek. How is that a good strategy? The Buddha saying that suffering is caused by desire.

How is that the case? Vedanta saying, all agitation comes from selfishness. How can an external agitation, someone trying to sabotage me at work, how is that agitation caused by selfishness? All of these seemingly paradoxical premises and principles within these philosophies, they all stay as paradoxes, as perhaps something that people keep talking about hundreds of years, thousands of years later, but they're just stories.

They don't make it into our approach to life unless there is reflection. Reflection is a function of depth over breadth. A reflection on hearing the same thing when reflecting on it day after day, week after week perhaps, month or year after year to try to understand the truth within it versus, oh, that's interesting, so-and-so said that. Now let me see what this other thinker said and this other thinker and this other thinker.

Let me go from Hegel to Kant to Kierkegaard. Let me try to understand all of these different historical aspects, which is more like journalism. It is more kind of theoretical than the applied sciences, so to speak. It is memorization, recitation, instead of discovery or transformation.

It is scholarship. It is not a shift in evolution. It's not progress towards the higher. Rick Rubin, the famed producer, producer of Johnny Cash, Red Hot Chili Peppers, and just like every who's who within music.

He said in an interview once, he doesn't read, he said, I don't read anything that isn't over a thousand years all these days. And this is what Joseph and I talked about in our conversation. Out with the new and in with the old. Out with the new and in with the old.

Instead of finding out a new way that a modern thinker has put a spin on an age-old idea, why not just reflect on the age-old idea? And if an idea has lasted more than a thousand years, then it's lasted longer than any empire, any business, any invention, ever has. If an idea has lasted two, three, four, five thousand years, it has lasted than any human empire. It's lasted longer than any really, really important hip, cool company or product right now.

It might have more truth to it than the iPhone that you are listening to this podcast on. It most likely does if it's been around for five thousand years. He said, I don't read anything that isn't over a thousand years right now in my life. Out with the new and in with the old.

It's so beautiful about that. Totally sent me for a hit when I first heard him say that. And then I was like, God, what a G to not only have that perspective but to just drop that. God, he has so many of these soundbites too that are just like, I would have never thought a human would ever say something like that.

And yet, you hear it and you're like, why hasn't a hundred, why haven't a hundred other smart people said the exact same thing? And when he said that, I was like, God, that is such a great way to highlight depth over breadth. Understand a timeless concept and it could be a foothold to anything you want professionally, personally, in your entire life. It's so damn valuable to really understand, really understand a framework.

And you don't get that from, this book said this in 2023, this book, this great book says this in 2024, this thing from 1988 is really great, this course, this philosophy has this, this principle, this other philosophy, this other eclectic approach has this other principle. These can be really great in the beginning of our approaches and pursuits of truth. To know the terrain, to know the different ideas out there, it can be phenomenal just for nothing else to say, wow, there's a lot of coherence between these different traditions or, wow, there's a lot that doesn't make sense in these others. When it starts to click for you in a philosophy that does speak to you, and Vedanta explicitly says there are as many paths to the divinest there are people on earth, one in 10,000 might be attracted to a Vedantic approach to the pursuit of truth.

This is not a philosophy of conversion trying to tell everybody that they should get onto the Vedantic path. This philosophy is basically saying, yeah, one in 10,000 will be interesting. When I wound down my startup podcast to turn it into a podcast, after two years, I was like, you know what, I talk about startups all day, every day. I want to talk about the thing that I actually want to talk about, this philosophy.

And it didn't bother me at all when the listenership was seven, ten, twelve people. It is a chance for me to go deeper with these concepts I've never looked at the stats on this podcast. Whatever the numbers are, it's so great to have met the people that I got to meet through this and build a concept, the community that we have in Venice of about 30 of us that meet each month. But more than even the community, the chance to go deep with these concepts, these episodes, and the newsletters, conversations that I get to have with Joseph on Yoga for Your Intellect.

It gives so much more resonance to this concept of depth over breadth because there will be something that was once novel to me, sounded good, maybe it became something I said in a dinner conversation a week later within this philosophy, but then when I heard it the hundredth time, reflected on it for the hundredth time, it's like I was seeing it for the first. Some of these things reflected on it a thousand times. And each time it provides more depth. One of my favorite principles within this philosophy of attach is attach you lose, detach you gain.

When I first heard that, it stopped me in my tracks a decade plus later and I am still blown away by how practical, helpful, applicable that timeless principle is attach you lose, detach you gain. Whether it's people, whether it's professional pursuits, status, validation, happiness, avoiding suffering, that one principle applies to them all. And the thousandth time that I reflect on it, it's like, wow, now I know how to wield that sword that much better. Apply it to my life that much more effortlessly.

And that's just one of the principles. Depth over breadth allows for a mastery of a subject, yes. It's like, would Tom Brady have been Tom Brady with seven Super Bowls if he had tried to play football, baseball, basketball, and run track and field all at the same time? I was about to say probably not, but I'm going to go ahead and say no.

He would not have been a master at that craft if he was diluting his efforts across five. And that's the same for our philosophical approach to life. We will dilute our progress, our efforts. Which, whatever path, by the way, you might have a path that is not Vedanta at all.

It's completely antithetical to Vedanta as a path of studying, listening, reflecting on the words of the masters. There are other phenomenal paths of devotion, of service, and action that prioritize, let's say service. Vedanta certainly makes ample use of karma, karma yoga, the yoga, the spiritual pursuit of service. Karma yoga is certainly part of the path of Vedanta, but it's not the priority.

The priority is studying and reflection of the words of the masters. Devotional path, in Sanskrit, you'd call that bhakti. The bhakti yoga path, the pursuit of the divine, eternal, timeless, through devotion. Devotion to a practice, devotion to a teacher.

That's certainly part of this philosophy, but it is not the priority. The priority is study, reflection, simply study and reflection of the words of the masters. And then the words of the masters will include things like, don't forget, service, usefulness to your community. The words of the masters will include, don't forget to also have a devotional aspect to your spiritual pursuit.

So it'll incorporate the others, but there are certainly paths like a conventional Christian path is a priority of devotion. Devotion towards Christ and not so much studying and reflecting on the words of the masters, but it is to devote your life to Christ. That might include studying some of the words. That might include listening to a sermon once a week.

But it is also clearly a devotional approach to the teacher that is Christ and to the community, the church, your community. And whether it is that approach to the divine, whether it is an approach to your professional pursuit, mastery of a craft, and more importantly, a mastery of oneself, this philosophy, and pretty much every athletic coach around the world would say, mastery comes from depth, not breadth. There is value in breadth, but mastery of a craft and mastery of oneself does not come from breadth. Take the breadth towards the depth, but ultimately depth, systematic approach to playing quarterback or to realizing one's true nature.

Depth, according to this philosophy, is the path to truth. That is today's reflection on the Daily Vida. We'll see you next time. The Daily Vida

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Vedantic?

This episode is 17 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Vedantic episode published?

This episode was published on December 12, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Vedantic episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.