Skip to content
Ep. 87 - Metta and Fear episode artwork

May 11, 2020 1 hr 6 min

Ep. 87 - Metta and Fear

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

In this dharma talk, Joseph Goldstein explores connecting to our capacity for Metta, or loving kindness, and how we can work skillfully with fear as it arises.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 87 - Metta and Fear

0:00 1:06:24
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to be here now network.com slash Joseph.

First step in both the Bopassana practice and the Neta practice is collecting the attention, it's gathering the attention. We gather in the scattered mind and shepherd it back either to the breath or to the body or to hearing, or when we're doing the metapactist shepherd in the mind back to the phrases or the image of the person we're sending it to. And in this process of collecting the attention, concentrating the mind, from time to time we get overcome by different of the hindrances, sometimes singly, sometimes multiply. Sometimes we get overwhelmed by a flip of emotions, those emotions which are really painful to be with.

But slowly as we keep coming back, we make that effort to come back to a main focus of attention. For anterly and over time the mind begins to settle down, begins to get a little bit quieter, begin to create to some degree an inner spaciousness in a relaxation. Slowly the mind becomes somewhat less reactive, less judgmental. We're not so completely lost in the discursive mind and the proliferation of thought in our particular stories.

As we abide, more and more in the simplicity of the present moment, this is we settle back into that very soft, open, exact, relaxed awareness. What happens is that our minds begin to relax, our hearts begin to relax, begin to open. We begin to see ourselves with much greater clarity and see parts of ourselves that we had not seen before, or not seen before so clearly. It's a poem by a 10th or 11th century Japanese woman poet Izume.

She wrote, watching the moon at dawn, solitary, mid sky. I knew myself completely, no part left out. When I read that I really thought how close that is to what we're doing in the meditation practice, learning to know ourselves completely with no part left out. In this process of collecting the attention, settling back into the moment of opening up, as we create more inner space, there often comes a flood of memories of images.

At first it might be things from our recent past and over time these memories or images or impressions start to come up and reveal themselves from the far distance past, things we didn't even know we were holding or remembering. We thought to emerge in the mind. This process that happens for most people is really an emptying out, it's a clearing out process. There's this vast accumulation of impressions that we carry.

We may think of people that we haven't thought of in years, suddenly we're sitting watching our breath in this person who will pop into mind. People will start remembering, reviewing old movies and TV programs. I went through so many hours of that. Father knows Beth, we visited.

We remember past incidents, past situations, and with the power of a focused awareness, sometimes these impressions and memories and images are extremely vivid, extremely clear. Very often these memories of people or situations from the past may carry the same emotional charge that they did then. We may be reliving old hurts or arguments and feeling again the same old reactivity. Sometimes we remember things, the unholts and things we've done.

When it brings up the remorse, just a further note on Sharon's true confession about my life. This is just kind of a little p.s. to the story of that poor. It turns out that almost nobody else went to that party either.

That's why when I thought of it, it felt so bad. Forty years later, I had another example of a very powerful thing come up in my practice when I was in the p.s. I went to right after college. I went to Thailand.

We were doing some training in Hawaii. As part of the training, for some reason, they had us kill chickens. I ended up teaching English in Bangkok. This had absolutely no relevance.

At the time, I didn't know what to miss. I had this very strong macho idea that this is something I would be able to do. I'm a man. It's a manly thing.

There was this poor chicken. This other volunteer in training was holding in. I had this picture of myself from just after holding this chicken that I had just done in. There was this big grin on my face.

I was really proud of myself. Years later, after the p.s. I had been in India practicing. I was in intensive meditation.

This started coming up in my mind with a very unwanted clarity. I really started reliving actually what that was about. It was just like murdering this being. I felt this tremendous, tremendous remorse about it.

Looking at the delusion that I had been in, I was thinking that that was a good thing to do. It was a very powerful, a few days in the last stage. This whole incident lasted a few days in my practice as it was coming up so strongly. I was very painful to relive it consciously.

What I saw and appreciated so much about the practice is that I understood that by attending to it with mindfulness, with awareness, with an honest acceptance, this is what I had done. This was unsquilpa and feeling the remorse. There was a real purification that was happening. It came up and came up and came up and was very strong and vivid and painful and at a certain point it left.

It really cleared out the charge, the emotional sorrow of that. It really left. I saw that I appreciated this purifying aspect of bringing awareness to all the impressions, to all the memories that may come up. We've all done a combination of skillful and unsquilful things.

We want to appreciate the practice as a way of purifying the mind stream. As our mind becomes quieter and as our hearts relax into the experience, whatever it is that's arising. We begin to see all of these things with less projection and a lot less defensiveness. In the softness of awareness we're not so caught in trying to defend the protecting image of ourselves.

It's just a willingness to be with things as they are. In this lack of defensiveness, there's often a much greater ability to both forgive ourselves and to forgive others because we're not so fixed in our position. All of this has to do with the opening, the opening of the heart that takes place through awareness. As we settle into this space of less defensiveness, less projection, more openness, more willingness to be with the whole range of experience, something very beautiful starts to happen.

And that is we begin to experience feelings of matter, feelings of loving kindness arising quite spontaneously in the practice. Begin to get a sense, not theoretically but really deeply from our experience, that the loving kindness and compassion really are the feelings that are coming from our deepest place. When we let go and strip away all the most surface perceptions, we find that at the depth of our experience, the depth of our heart mind, there's this basic reservoir of goodwill. We begin to feel this as our deepest place.

And that's a very beautiful discovery. But underneath all the reactions and all the judgments and all the aggressive or evasive patterns that underneath it all, when we settle, we connect with this feeling of matter within us. We begin to see that loving kindness is an expression of awareness. Loving kindness is the basic generosity of the heart.

It's a very simple wish for ourselves and for others to be happy. This feeling of loving kindness is not seeking any self-benefit, it's not wanting anything back, it's not saying be happy and what can I get from it. It's just a movement out, a movement of generosity towards all beings, be happy. Very simple.

In this feeling of loving kindness, no distinction is made between people, between beings. And this is what differentiates it very starkly and very clearly from the feeling of desire and attachment, which is often confused with matter. You know, for most of us, in our lives and our relationships, love and attachment are inextricably entangled and sometimes even hard to imagine, well, how could I really love somebody without attachment? They become so mixed up with one another.

One of the really transforming insights that comes from the stillness and clarity of meditation is we begin to distinguish, we begin to discriminate between different feelings, we begin to separate out and see that attachment or desire, that feeling and the feeling of love and loving kindness are two very different feelings and not the same thing at all. And we learn something else. That desire and attachment does not enhance the feeling of love in any way whatsoever. In fact, not only doesn't it enhance it, it serves in a variety of ways to obscure it.

When love and desire are mixed up together, it's always for a limited number of people. Now, we can have desire for one person, for two people, maybe for three people. But I don't think there's anybody who has desire for all beings. It would be a hell realm.

Can you imagine every being that you saw having desire for? It would be horrendous. But on the contrary, love and kindness precisely has this capacity. And that's what's so amazing about it, that we actually can wish well for all beings.

There's no limit. You know, there's no, it's not in limited supply within us. We can have these feelings and direct these feelings of goodwill to everyone we meet. And that's the great power and the great difference of loving kindness, of meta, this ability to embrace all.

And there's another nuance of this feeling of meta, which is very striking. And that is that loving kindness or genuine love, unlike desire or attachment, does not easily turn into ill will. I mean, how often in our lives, or people we know, where people can have this great desire, love for one another and a week later or a year later or ten years later somehow, you know, it's turned into its opposite. This does not happen with the feeling of meta for one very important reason.

And that is the feeling of loving kindness does not depend on how the other person is. It does not depend on the other person being a certain way, because it's a simple wish coming out of our own heart to be happy, regardless of how the other person is. This becomes very clear and maybe you've got a little taste of it this afternoon. Now, when we go from benefit to friend to neutral person, begin to see that here's a person that we really don't know and can actually start generating loving feelings towards.

And I had this experience very strongly when I was doing the meta intensively. And I had gotten up to the neutral person. And I didn't even know who to exactly send it to. And my teacher said, I was in India at the time, said, well, there's this old gardener, when there'd be a heart in the place I was staying, do it towards him.

This was a person that I passed every single day that I was there. And I saw him every day. And until that time, he could have been a telephone pole for all that I was relating to him. It was that itself was shocking to me when I realized that he was another human being.

So then I started doing that. He was my neutral person. And I saw all day long, be happy, be healthy, be filled with love. Well, after a few days of this, it's like every time I saw him, I got this big smile.

You know, he was my love object. And it was amazing. He didn't change. It was amazing to learn that how we feel about people is up to us.

It does not depend on the other person. Well, this is tremendously empowering because usually we live under the impression that it's other people making us feel a certain way. An old girlfriend of mine had a great line from our relationship. She used to tell me, stop making me feel a version.

Well, no one makes us feel a version. It may be a habit. It may be a deeply ingrained habit. And it may be difficult circumstances.

But how we feel is up to us and the development and strengthening of this feeling. Of loving kindness, we can tune into that channel when it's developed at any time. It's particularly interesting when we're with someone who's difficult. And that's going to be tomorrow's meditation.

I mean, in the classical Buddhist, you know, language, we start sending me to the enemy. It doesn't have to be some major big enemy in one's life. But just someone who's difficult, with whom we're having difficulty. Just as an exercise you might do, which I have found very helpful and transformative in the very moment.

There was a situation arising with somebody. Whenever I thought of this person and the situation, I could just feel my heart contract in a version of dislike, because of something they were doing. And for quite a number of times I was just caught in this feeling and staying very contracted. But at a certain point, I really got interested in the suffering that this was causing me.

And what I learned to do with it was to drop out of the storyline of what was going on, which was just feeding, you know, that feeling. To drop out of the storyline and to trace back energetically, to trace back the sensations right to that contraction in the heart, you know, that I was holding in the version. So kind of just trace it back, feel the contraction in the heart, and then relax the heart. And it was quite amazing, because as I actually could feel the contraction, and then make that move of relaxing it into the space of awareness, the feeling of being separate from that person completely disappeared.

And it was quite amazing, because I let go of that contraction, I let go of that ego stance of me and them, relaxing to the space of non-separation. Then it was just two beings doing the dance. And there was a feeling of much greater connectedness, much greater love, much greater compassion, just all the crazy dance steps we do with one another. How we feel is up to us.

We have that capacity to connect with feelings of meta and loving kindness. It's the simple wish, be happy. May I be happy? May you be happy?

And we practice it in relationship to our own minds. There's a samurai poem from another 13th century or something like that. And one line in this poem, which I really like, it says, I make my mind, my friend. And in one way, that's what we're doing here.

We're just sitting and being with every part of ourselves, no part left out. And we make our minds our friends, instead of being in battle with it. And we take the same relationship of friendliness to all others in the world. There's a Tibetan teacher who, instead of, when he'd meet you, would meet you, instead of saying, Hello, how are you?

He would say, has your heart been kind? I thought that's really a nice reminder, that this is how we can practice being with one another, practice having a kind heart. So as the feelings of meta and goodwill, as we settle more and more into them, what happens is that our minds get a lot softer, a lot more pliable. And in this respect, meta becomes the ground or the foundation of wisdom.

Because as our minds and hearts are softer and more pliable, we're less reactive to difficulties. Instead of being impatient or reactive or judgmental, this greater softness allows us to be accepting of things that are difficult. And as we're more accepting, we can bring some wise discernment to those situations. Instead of the knee-jerk reactions, as we often get involved in, okay, just let me be with this, whether it's within our own body or mind or situation in the world, there's a little more space.

We're more patient, we're less reactive. We bring in some discernment. What's the wise response here? With the discernment, we make wiser choices.

As the result of wiser choices, we become happier in our lives. Because we're happier in our lives, we feel more loving kindness and meta. The meta makes us even softer, more chance for wise discernment, wise choices, more happiness, more, it's a spiral upward. It's not a bad way to go.

It's important, I think, for all of us to realize that the Buddhist teachings is not simply something to admire in others, you know? Yeah, that seems like a good idea. It's about our own transformation, the way we live in our lives, the choices we're making. It's not Han, the enemy's meditation, medicine, poet, and activist, and a really wonderful being.

He said, practicing Buddhism or practicing the Dharma is a clever way to enjoy life. Happiness is available. Please help yourselves to it. And that is the kind of juice, the essence of Dharma practice.

It's about happiness, genuine happiness. As we become a little more centered, as we settle into a relaxed awareness and these feelings of meta begin to come more spontaneously, then when we come close to suffering in ourselves or others, the method is transformed into compassion. If we are resting in a place of goodwill and we meet suffering, then what is the response to that suffering? The response is one of compassion.

Well, how can I help? Now, compassion is that feeling which motivates us to try to alleviate the suffering. And it comes as a natural response of the heart in the face of suffering. Being calm, stronger and stronger as we're willing to come closer and closer to the suffering.

Some years ago, I saw this video, which you may be familiar with, it was called Romero. It was about the life of the Archbishop, I believe, in El Salvador during the terrible kind of civil war and struggle there. And the movie started out with him really being part of the higher establishment. But then it traced his growing awareness of the tremendous amount of suffering that was going on in El Salvador at that time.

It came really close to the people who were in this tremendous place of suffering. And the video was a wonderful and very moving account of how he came closer to suffering, how he allowed himself to open to it, how this tremendous outflow of compassion started to come from him. It was really a very inspiring lesson in the wellspring of compassion. But suffering is all around us.

Tomorrow night, Steve is going to talk more and this is the first noble truth of the Buddhist teaching, which is the truth of suffering, he's going to elaborate this in detail. If suffering is all around us and compassion comes from being close to suffering, then the question arises, why isn't there more compassion in the world? Suffering is the cause of compassion and there's so much suffering, why is there so little compassion? That's the co-on.

When we look, when we investigate this, both in the world but more particularly in our own experience, we see that what happens very often is that we're not open to the suffering that's there. Close to it, very often there are patterns of denial or avoidance or closing down because it's painful we don't like to feel the suffering. It can be difficult to stay open to it. And so we retreat from it.

And as we retreat from it, it closes off that heart of compassion within us. It was one of my favorite stories which many of you have heard. It's so funny and to the point. It was told to me by a friend of mine about his grandfather and father.

And they were in a car traveling on December 7, 1941, Pearl Harbor day. And they're in the car and the radio announcer comes on announcing the bombing of Pearl Harbor. And the first thing that his grandfather says to his father is, don't tell your mother. And now World War II would be a big one to keep out.

That would have been a hard one to avoid. And we can laugh at this but on a differing scale, we all do the same thing. And then we do it with ourselves. We kind of, we close off.

We try to keep it out. Behind all of these movements of pulling away from suffering in whatever way we do. You know, and it could be avoidance, it could be denial, it could be aggression. Sometimes we get aggressive in the face of suffering.

Behind all of these movements of pulling away are some very deeply conditioned fears. That's why we pull away from suffering out of fear. In meditation practice and in our lives, what happens is we reach edges, we reach boundaries. You may have noticed this in the retreat.

It becomes very vivid on retreat. Where we just reach an edge of what we're willing to be with, of what's okay, of what's comfortable. And we reach that edge and then begin to experience something a little more intense or a little more difficult. And we can feel that shrinking back from it.

It's right at that edge, right at that boundary of whatever it is. That fear, the very deeply conditioned fears, begin to reveal themselves. And that's why this is such a valuable place in practice to explore. It's right at the edge of what we're willing to be with.

In order to connect more deeply with love and compassion and more full awareness, we need to investigate how these fears are arising. We really need to see clearly this process and how fear can be transformed into a very liberating understanding. Now each one of us is conditioned in different ways and we have fear about different things. For some people, there might be a great fear of discomfort, of being uncomfortable.

And so we try to organize our lives so that we're never uncomfortable. It generally doesn't work very well. And I had a very striking experience of this. I was in India and going up to Kashmir for the summer months when it's very hot on the plains.

And I was on one of these interminable Indian bus rides really long, I don't know, like 17 hours. And the bus was old and rickety and crowded and smelled of oil and gas and fumes. And I was quite tall and I was kind of just sitting swash and I was right over the engine. Whatever that's called.

And when I got on this bus and I just, I know this is a long ride. My first strategy, the first thought I had, okay, I'm just staying on my breath. I'm going to really lock into the breath and stay really concentrated and just keep all of this out. And so I got on the bus and that's what I tried to do and I tried to do it for several hours.

You know, well, it was extremely stressful. I was trying to hold on to the breath for dear life so I wouldn't have to feel all of this discomfort. Finally, I mean, it took me that long to realize, this is stupid. And so I let go of that and I just began to let all of these uncomfortable unpleasant sense impressions come in.

Now just the jostling of the bus and the crowdedness and the smells and everything. I just let everything wash through and it was amazing because when I let go of my fear of being uncomfortable and could just let it all in instead of trying to keep it out, it actually was no problem. But it was amazing to see what I had constructed out of fear of the discomfort and how that just creates more attention. So really the essence of the practice is to let it all in whatever's happening.

Let it in, let it wash through. This fear of discomfort. For many people, there's a fear of pain. Now this is a real concern for many of us and maybe you've gotten some glimpse of this in your practice.

Pain starts to arise in the body and because there's a fear of feeling pain. We concoct all kinds of strategies for dealing with the pain. Sometimes it's real aversion and the mind just goes into this mode of, I hate this. Sometimes it's in the mode of self-pity.

I wonder where we just are feeling sorry for ourselves. It's like Sharon was saying, let's not, you know, everybody else in the room is in bliss and I'm here with this horrible pain and we kind of wallow in self-pity. But sometimes we start bargaining with the pain. You know, I'll watch you if you'll go away.

And we think that being mindful. It's not. All of this is based on fear. Now it's interesting with pain and our fear of it is that very often it's not really the fear of what we're feeling in the moment.

It's the fear of anticipated pain. Now we imagine what it's going to be like when we extrapolate in our minds. Well, if it feels like this now, how will I bear it in the next five minutes, or ten minutes, or hour, or day, or lifetime? And we build up this scenario in our minds and then get very afraid.

It was very useful when we're at that age of what we can easily or comfortably be with the pain. Just to watch whether the fear is of what's happening just then in the moment, or there's fear of something that the mind is creating, some anticipated feeling. There's a way to bring meta into this relationship to the body in pain, which is very wonderful. And I was first taught by this very old Sri Lankan monk, who was an under my triad, who was here, who was here, I must have been ten years ago, and he was in his nineties then.

And he might still be alive. I haven't heard that he died. But anyway, he had this one. This was this ninety-three-year-old monk who was just wonderful.

And he taught this way of meta. He would go through the body and he would say, may my head be happy. May my neck be happy. May my shoulders be happy.

And he would just go through the whole body like that. And it's really a wonderful practice because it shows us the possibility of infusing meta into awareness. So as we're feeling, whatever we're feeling, it's held with that loving feeling. So we're really bringing love and awareness together.

So sometimes this fear of discomfort, sometimes fear of pain. For many people, there might be fear of certain emotions. Certain emotions are difficult. They're painful to be with, they're painful to bear.

There are certain ones for each of us that are not okay, they're not okay to feel. And different ones for each of us. It might be anger, it might be unworthiness, it might be loneliness, it might be embarrassment, it might be rage, it might be boredom. Whatever.

Certain feelings, which because they're so uncomfortable, we don't want to feel and we close ourselves off. Now in our culture, how much of our society revolves around people's desire not to feel bored. As if that would be horrendous. Not just the worst.

And we have to do everything we can not to feel bored. Oh, that's a lot of energy. Now to build a whole life around the defense against a certain feeling. It would be much simpler as we're doing here to simply learn to allow whatever feelings they are.

Even when they're painful, it's okay. Let me just feel it. They come and go like everything else. Often people are afraid of the feeling of insecurity.

The basic that feeling insecure is unpleasant. So we construct the life so we never have to feel insecure. Unsecure about our bodies, about our relationships, about the world. Well, things aren't insecure.

Alan Watts wrote this wonderful book called The Wisdom of Insecurity. And there's a wisdom in understanding that, rather than trying to protect ourselves from the feeling of it. What's really interesting is to see how much of the greed and desire in the mind comes out of the fear of insecurity, fear of feeling deprived. Because we're afraid to have this feeling.

I'll just tell one little story. It's an IMS retreat story. I was on retreat here. And as you may have noticed during your time here, sometimes at lunchtime, before certain dishes, there's a signed moderation, please.

And one of the things that I noticed is that this signed moderation, please, almost always is in front of the dishes I really like. So I'm going through the line and I get to this dish. It was sesame spinach. I was coming in this bowl and said moderation, please.

So everything I'm going to tell you now, I saw in retrospect. I didn't see it going through. So I'm going through the line. I see the sign moderation, please.

I look at this sesame spinach. And the first thing my mind does is things. Well, how much can I take and still be moderate? It's like there was this feeling of, can I get enough?

And I proceeded to take as much as I thought I could get away with it. Well, about, you know, 45 seconds later, I had this massive guilt attack that I take too much. And this whole lunch period, I'm looking over my shoulder to see if there was still some spinach left with this dish. There's still some spinach left with the people behind me.

It's like, because in that moment, that feeling of panic about not having enough, you know, it just drove that action. Well, the sesame spinach isn't such a huge deal, but this pattern gets acted out a lot in so many ways in our lives and in the world. Because we haven't learned how to be okay with those unpleasant feelings. Okay, that feeling of not having enough, okay, can I just feel like, can I be with it?

I have to protect myself against it. Very often, fears are fueled by thoughts of the future. There's another interesting pattern to watch in our own minds. Now, we get lost in various potential disaster scenarios, whether our personal disasters or social disasters, we create these scenarios in our mind and then get afraid.

And this happens even more strongly when we think that it's likely it really is going to happen. And so that just fuels the fear. And then the fear starts generating either anger or despair. But what we're forgetting in that moment is that all that's happening is that certain thoughts are arising in the mind.

That's what's happening. These scenarios are not going on. It's just a thought. And there's one story which just encapsulates this whole insight and it provides a very useful mental note.

It's the story of this Zen practitioner in Japan who lived in a cave and was a great artist. He spent all these years in a cave and he was painting a picture of a tiger on the wall of the cave. And he spent years doing this. And he painted it so realistically that when he finished, he looked at it and got frightened.

We do the same thing many, many times a day. We paint tigers in our mind. We paint pictures in our thoughts of something happening. And we look at them and get frightened or involved, whatever.

We forget that they're just painted tigers. They're just thoughts arising. So I recommend the use of that label for you. And when you really get caught in a scenario of one kind or another, use the note, paint a tiger.

And you'll see. Oh yeah. And that's all that's going on. For each of us, different fears arise at different times.

We all have our own particular conditioning on particular stories. And in the times of these fears arising, there's very often a great vulnerability there. And it's a very tender state when fear is strong. But in that vulnerability, there's also a great potential for a powerful heart connection.

I'll just tell you one of my fear stories. A few comes up. I mean, I've got a lot of fear stories. But this one was really the way the most transforming.

I was doing this seschine with seschine, was a very fierce and he's really demanding. And the whole zen form is very tight and controlled. And everything's in a group. And there's not much space.

And he uses the colon method, where he gives you a kind of puzzle or problem that doesn't have an intellectual answer. You really have to respond from experience. And then you see him four times a day to give you a response to the colon. Everything's pressure and building and he's sitting there very fierce.

So we're doing this seschine and gives me this colon. And I go in these four times a day to my bowels. So I give my answer and he looks at me and says, mmm, very stupid. And this was just over and over again day after day.

It was just one variation. I thought I was doing well when he said, oh, very good, but not zen. So I'm getting more and more uptight. You know, I was dreading going in there.

I mean, I was just like this. So finally, in one interview, I think he had some pitted and he gave me an easier colon. He kind of backed me up. And so he gave me the colon.

How do you manifest Buddha nature while chanting a sutra while chanting a discourse? And we had been chanting every day. Okay, that, I understood that. I go in and just change something.

But whether he knew or not, I don't know, but this just touched this deep, deep, deep conditioning I had about singing, which started when a third great music teacher told me, Goldstein just mowed the words. And that was reinforced over the years many times from some of my dearest and closest friends. Okay, so this just touched off this huge fear. So I'm sitting in the sitting before the interview.

I'm just rehearsing. A million times going through my mind. You know, there's a few lines of a chant I was going to do. So I go to the bell rings.

I go in there. I wait until the last one. I go in and I do my bows, say the colon. I start chanting.

I totally screwed it up. I mean, I got all the words wrong. I got everything mixed up. And this was, you know, after this pressure of a session, I felt awful.

I felt so completely exposed and vulnerable and naked and raw. It just felt like my heart was completely exposed. It was a horrible feeling. Then he just sat there and he looked at me and it was an amazing moment.

He just looked at me and he said, oh, very good. And it was amazing because he was right there. I mean, he wasn't just trying to make me feel good. And it was precisely because I was so open and so exposed and so vulnerable that those words, it literally felt like they were touching my heart.

And I just saw the power, you know, and the possibility that can come when we're able to be in that state. Now, even though it's tremendously difficult, it's really hard to be with, but something very powerful is open. There's tremendous potential in that state of vulnerability. Okay, so mindfulness gathers the attention.

We begin to create some inner space. From that spaciousness feelings of met the start, feelings of basic goodwill start to arise spontaneously. And as we come close to suffering, we feel a compassion. But we also reach these edges where we begin to close off to the suffering.

Our edges are boundaries and it's right at that place that fears begin to emerge. So the question then is, how can we work with these fears? How can we work with them skillfully? It might be fear of pain, it might be fear of certain feelings or emotions, it might be fear of death.

The first step is to recognize it as it arises. We have to become aware, yes, fear is arising, fear is appearing. Can we recognize it and can we accept it? There's a favorite mantra, a positive mantra, which I used with fear and it was very helpful.

It's okay, it's okay, just let me feel this. Let me feel the feeling rather than trying to avoid it. Thich Nhat Han wrote something. He wrote it about anger, but it really applies to fear as well.

He said, the Buddhist attitude is to take care and all substitute fear here, is to take care of fear. We don't suppress it, we don't run away from it. We just breathe and hold our anger in our arms with utmost tenderness. The fear is no longer alone, it is with all mindfulness.

Fear is like a closed flower in the morning. As the sun shines on the flower, the flower will bloom because the sunlight penetrates deeply into the flower. Mindfulness is like that. If you keep breathing, mindfulness particles will penetrate the fear.

When sunshine penetrates the flower, the flower cannot resist, it has to open itself and show its heart to the sun. If you keep shining your compassion and understanding on it, your fear will soon crack and you will be able to look into its depths and see its roots. Can we be with fear in that way, with that kind of tenderness? As we might be with a child who's afraid, it's easy for us to understand how we would be with a fearful child, which is being present and caring.

But somehow we have difficulty being with our own fears in that way, and that's the practice. We want to take the measure of the situation. Now sometimes when a situation and fear arises, we want to apply some discriminating wisdom here. Because sometimes we want to open to the fear and stay right with it and perhaps even act, even though fear is present, and this is really the quality of courage.

Even though fear is present, it does not have to limit us. We can act anyway if we've developed this ability to be accepting of the fear. We want to apply some wisdom to the situation. The ballet lama had a very useful piece of advice here.

Somebody asked him how we can work with deep fears. He said, if you have some fear of pain or suffering, you should examine whether there is anything you can do about it. If you can, if you can do something about it, there is no need to worry. If you cannot do anything about it, then there's also no need to worry.

We also need to see those times when the suffering may be too much, where we don't have the strength. We don't have the balance. And for whatever reason, the suffering is overwhelming. At that time, we need to recognize that and to pull back, to retreat.

That's not the time to plow through it. That's the time to back up, to regain balance, to regain strength. And so it takes a great sensitivity to our own process. We want to recognize the fear, become accepting of it, shine the light of awareness on it.

We want to take the measure of the situation. And we want to explore and investigate the nature of the mind itself, the nature of fear itself. I'm going to talk more about this in a few nights. But it's really about seeing deeply the empty, transparent nature of all phenomena.

We tend to solidify things and then get lost or imprisoned in that solidification. The whole practice of awareness, of wisdom, to see the empty, transparent, insubstantial nature of all phenomena. There's a direct link between seeing the insubstantiality of things and the development of compassion. There's one very great Tibetan meditation master of this century.

His name is Dilgokensir Rinpoche. He was one of the teachers of the Dalai Lama and a really wonderful, great being, a non-sectarian. This is what he wrote. He said, when you realize the true emptiness or transparency of phenomena, you will spontaneously feel and all embracing non-conceptual compassion for all beings who are immersed in Samsara's ocean of suffering because they cling to the notion of an ego.

This troublesome ego, which is so concerned about itself, has in reality never begun to exist. It does not exist anywhere now, and so it cannot cease to exist. Not the slightest trace of it can be found. When you recognize the empty nature, therefore, any notion of being an ego to dissolve vanishes, and at the same time, the energy to bring about the good of others' dawns, uncontrised and effortless.

As we see into the empty nature of phenomena, see into the empty nature of fear itself, the energy to bring about the good of others' dawns, uncontrised and effortless. To the movement from awareness, to method, to compassion, to open to suffering, and to the cultivation and the maturation of bodhijita, that aspiration that our practice and our life be for the benefit of all. I like to close with a poem by Wendell Berry, When despair for the world grows in me, and I wake in the night at the least sound, in fear of what my life and my children's lives may be, I go and lie down with a wood-drake rest in his beauty on the water, and the great herring feeds. I come into the peace of wild things, who do not tax their lives with forethought of grief.

I come into the presence of still water, and I feel above me the day-blind stars waiting with their light, for a time I rest in the grace of the world, and am free. This is really our practice. For a time I rest in the grace of the world, and am free.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 1 hour and 6 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on May 11, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.