Skip to content
Ep. 88 - Relative Truth Versus Ultimate Truth episode artwork

May 29, 2020 1 hr

Ep. 88 - Relative Truth Versus Ultimate Truth

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

Joseph Goldstein answers questions about relative truth versus ultimate truth, how compassion is related to Metta, dealing with hurtful people, and much more.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 88 - Relative Truth Versus Ultimate Truth

0:00 1:00:22
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com.

So, this is my first retreat since a little context. I was wondering if you could offer some advice as far as what may work and what wouldn't. If I plan to integrate these teachings into a more general, maybe science-forward, mindfulness practice post-retreat, and some more context I think I first learned of you and got some of your energy from the 10% happy route. So, is the question how to bring the practice back to your life outside?

Yeah, I'm concerned with how all encompassing this practice seems here and how it's long sits in so many levels. It's just such a rich history. And how not to water that down so that it's useless, but incorporate it into just like maybe shorter practices, practices where I consider like where brainwaves are going and flow states and have it science and that kind of stuff. Sorry, that was a lot.

Forget the last one. There are a few things that are just really important in terms of carrying the practice forward. One is a daily sitting practice and the regularity is more important than the length. That being said, you want to sit along with five minutes.

And so if you can sit an hour a day, that would be great. I think it's two hours a day. That would be great. Maybe it's half an hour.

But really try to establish a routine and a rhythm where that just becomes part of your life. And it's really important because it just sets the day up. There's more of a chance of carrying mindfulness then throughout all the busyness of the day. It's a touchstone each day into the depths and the fullness of whatever you experienced here.

So that's a really important piece. So another huge arena of practice is huge. We'd be really undertaking the practice of right speech because we speak a lot. And it's a major use of our energy in the course of our lives and the course of the day.

And mostly, I'm sure you will recognize, mostly in our speech the words just come tumbling out. And it's not that often much attention paid to the motivation behind what we're saying. So somebody came up with this acronym, Weight W-A-I-T. Why am I talking?

So before we speak, wait. Even if it's just for a moment, you know, so instead of just it being on the forward momentum of that energy tumbling out, then the Buddha talked about four different kinds of wrong speech. I'll just back up a minute. There's one list of 10 wholesome and 10 unwholesome actions.

And obviously, the wholesome are to be cultivated and unwholesome to be avoided. Four of them, four of the 10 are about speech. So this is not insignificant. This is a core part of our practice, which obviously can be undertaken more effectively out of retreat than in retreat.

It's even go down in cheer. So the one kind of speech that some is obvious, you know, not lying, not harsh speech, not sland or gossip, things like that. But there's one category which I love to practice with. And the poly word is anemat, anemat, anemat, what's the word?

Anemat, for its English translation. So the English translation is useless talk. The poly word is sampapalapa. How it sounds just like what it is.

It's sampapalapa. And I just find it so interesting. Just in our social interactions, you know, I can be hanging out with friends and just hanging out. So often the conversation would be going on and I'll just see this impulse to say something totally useless.

Basically it's just a way of saying, here I am. That's the only point of those particular words. So I really try to keep an eye out for the impulse to sampapalapa. And in those moments when I'm successful, I don't have to say this.

First it feels like a great victory over Mara. The Mara is the embodiment of delusion in the Buddhist texts. So Mara is trying to keep us ensnared and unhold some activities. Oh, I defeated Mara in this moment.

But even more than that, the felt sense of that restraint is a conservation of energy and can feel it. Instead of just our energy spilling out in a useless way, we're about to do it. No, I don't have to do it. There's more integrity in the being.

So write speech and just paying attention to that. And when you go home and if you want to do some reading about it, you might just explore in different books about Buddhism, even books on the basic A-fold path, write speeches, one of them. You might explore in great adapts just through some reading, all the various aspects of it. So that would be a big area.

I think that's enough enough enough because again tomorrow not people can be speaking for other kinds of practices to do on our lives outside. Daily sitting, let's teach. Particularly if there are people who have not spoken or asked questions before. Can I ask two questions?

If you just keep it to one. But one at a time because the second one is going to push out the first. I'll start with the easy one. What can one expect if they go on a one month or a three month retreat like the ones offered here or perhaps what should one consider before committing to such a long retreat?

You can expect more of the same. Which should be encouraging because if you made it this far in this retreat, you'll be fine. Especially if you don't have expectations of anything else. That being said, over time and over a longer time, there's just a chance to strengthen the concentration.

And that often people will see a deepening of the concentration, a greater continuity of practice. All the things we've been talking about here, but there's just a longer time to cultivate them. Most of that they get stronger. It's very valuable.

If there's an interest and an opportunity in your lives, as you can imagine, I'm a big fan of intensive practice. Just because it's so rare to have the opportunity to investigate this mind body in this way. It's just a really precious opportunity and the long retreats, they're great. Not always happy.

It's really just like the same ups and downs. Some settings will be really clear and calm and quiet and others will be turbulent and restless and all that. But over time, day after day after day, we really learn a balance behind all those changes. So instead of being the word whip sword, just thrown about by all the changes in the ups and downs, we really develop quite a stability in being with those changes.

There's a book about the Buddha's life. It was written by Joseph Campbell, who was a Scratch scholar of world medicine. He wrote this book called Hero with a Thousand Faces and he used the Buddha's life as the archetype of the journey towards awakening. In this book, there's a very beautiful, kind of mythopoetic description of the night of the Buddha's enlightenment as he was sitting under the tree and assailed by all the forces of Mara, both the seductions, the sense of the lights and also the fearsome aspects.

And all of these energies came to a sail, Bodhisattva. And there's one line that Joseph Campbell wrote in describing that scene. And this one line has really stuck with me in terms of being a beautiful expression of what our practice is actually about. So as the Bodhisattva, as he was known before, his enlightenment was a sail by all of these forces, Joseph Campbell wrote, and the mind of the great being was not moved.

I love that. The mind of the great being was not moved. So can you imagine the beauty and the power and the steadiness and the openness of a heart mind like that? That whatever life presents, stillness, peace, openness.

So that's really the direction we're going in. And we learn to be less and less moved or reactive, one could say, to the events, whether it's in meditation or in our lives. Thank you. And my other question was regarding the nature of thought.

Several times you've mentioned how thoughts are empty and how that's just like cutting at the root of it is just recognizing that thought has no true nature. Throughout this week, in dealing with thoughts, I've found some I can simply label planning, fantasy, and they're very easy to go away. And in those thoughts, I can see, oh, OK, empty or like the content is of no meaning or significance. But then there's other thoughts where the content, usually with an emotional charge, so much more evidently meaningful or well into my life.

And when those arise, I'll either sit with them and just try to feel into them or I'll tell myself that something to meditate on at a later time. For some thoughts, the content seems evidently meaningful and something worth pondering, like perhaps past actions, how to write them or something of that sort. Can you speak to a bit about the emptiness of thoughts in that way? So this really points to one framework of understanding experience, the framework of relative truth and more ultimate truth.

And so on the relative level, the contents of thoughts are worth paying attention to in both ways, either because they're meaningful and they're worth pursuing in one way or another, or we see the content as meaningless and letting go. But we're actually attending to the content. So that we could say is on the relative level. On the more ultimate level, it's on that level that we're seeing the momentariness and the insubstantiality and the ephemeral nature of them.

And from that perspective, the content is relevant, because we're just seeing the thought as a phenomenon coming up. So our practice is the union of the relative and the ultimate. It's not like the two separate things. It's the same phenomenon seen from different levels.

And in our practice, I think it can become quite intuitive when it's appropriate to pay attention to the relative level and when it's appropriate to really stay on the ultimate level of just seeing the momentary change. So just as an example of the importance of the relative, in the years that I was practicing in India, it was in Baud Gaya, which is small village, but it's where the Buddha was enlightened. So it's a significant spiritual place. And in the village, one of the big landowners had a working elephant.

You can sometimes see in India. And so sometimes I'd be walking into the village and the elephant would be walking the other way. I always stepped out of its path. I did not just say seeing, seeing, seeing.

Sometimes the application of the relative is absolutely appropriate. It gets a little trickier in the examples you gave in terms of when we're sitting and different thoughts come and the content does seem meaningful in some way. So there's a variety of ways you can handle it. And you mentioned a few.

You could either make a note, just mark it and say, OK, I'm going to really reflect on this later. So that would be one approach. If it feels very compelling in the moment, and sometimes it's so compelling, we don't even really have a choice where we get involved in some reflection about it. And that would be OK.

I would just be watchful that it's very time limited for a while we're sitting. Because it would be easy to spend the hour, just kind of in re-revery about it. But if you spend five minutes or something like that, some brief amount of time just trying to highlight the main points of its significance, which could then be taken up later, I think that would be fine. Very often, certain kinds of thoughts, not only kind of the personal thoughts, personal to our lives, they're never coming up, but a very seductive thought pattern, a dharma thought.

I spent hours sitting, just reflecting on dharma thoughts. And I justified it to myself, I said, well, this is the dharma. But it was really just thinking. So sometimes those kind of thoughts happen when we have a certain insight in our meditation, we're going along and we see something really interesting or clearly or some aspect of the teaching becomes very obvious.

And so the insight then becomes the initiative for them thinking about it. I mentioned in a couple of my groups, have you ever chewed sugar cane? I go, so when you're in the tropics, they're both on the streets, they'll sell little stocks of sugar cane. And you chew them, and the first few chews are very juicy and sweet.

But if the three of our chews, it becomes dry pulp, and then you spit it out. And you take another chew. So with these dharma thoughts, where we're really kind of reflecting on maybe an insight or an understanding, we can generally extract the juice of the insight in the first few minutes. And then it becomes a lot of repetitive thinking about it.

That's the dry pulp. And so we don't want to spend time in that. I don't know if that's covered. That works.

Thank you, Joseph. Are there any female identified beings that would like to ask questions? Men have a tendency to do that. In your personal practice, do you have an intention for every time you sit?

That's it. That's not it. Pretty simple. You asked for something.

Yeah, yeah, good. Sometimes. And it really covers the range. For example, there was a time in my practice where I spent a year just doing metapractors.

And that was my intention for each sit. That's what I did. At other times I had an intention that I really wanted to work on the concentration at one point in this. And so the intention for that sit would be just what we talked about.

Up the intentionality dial, just with the breath, just with that. Sometimes the intention has been to sit in an open awareness, no more choiceless awareness. So the sitting within follow that. Perhaps most often.

So those are specific examples. But most often what I find is that I said and really trust the intuition of the move between a directed awareness, for example, on the graph, some other single object and the more open choiceless awareness. So even within one sitting, I may start with really attending to the breath. And then at a certain point, it's very intuitive.

It's not a formula for it. But after some time it feels just the moment to open up. And then it becomes more choiceless. And then at a certain point, that intuition might be good to refocus just on the breath.

But there's a very easeful, interweaving of the two. So the sitting is often like that. So it's all about that. Thank you.

Hi. So we practice over the past few days. And just today we started talking about that difficult person in our lives. And we were talking to start easy and then work our way up, which is great.

But there was also a mention about compassion or compassionate practice. And I was curious about it. I don't know if you can talk more about it. So obviously the meta practice and compassion practice are related.

But they have a slightly different flavor and a slightly different phrase up, phraseology. And also a different field of beings. So when we're doing meta, first we start out with the individual categories and then finally we'll move up to all beings. And meta really is for all beings that well-wishing.

And is addressed primarily to the suffering of beings. Meta is just a feeling of goodwill for everybody, whether they may be in a happy stage, and we're just wishing well to all. The phrase for compassion that we use is a single phrase rather than like three or four phrases. And the phrase is simply, may you be free of suffering.

May you be free of suffering. And we start, the first category that we start with in compassion practice is we visualize somebody even known to us personally or maybe just from the news or somebody who's in a lot of suffering. So that's what we're visualizing because that person in this framework, it's easy to feel compassion for because we can, you know, in two-wheel feel, see the actual suffering that's there. So the wish may you be free of suffering.

Really, it has a deep meaning in that wish. And generally compassion practice is addressed to those suffering beings. You know, so may you be free of suffering. In one way it also becomes universal because on one level we're all suffering.

So in that sense it could be extended to anybody. But it particularly highlights beings who are in a situation of particular suffering. What's really interesting about doing that practice, I mean one might think that visualizing beings really in a lot of pain or difficulty, you know, perhaps terrible circumstances, and expressing the wish may be free of suffering, it might sound like even though it's a good thing to do, it's a downer. You know, because we're just, we're filling our mind with the suffering of other beings.

It's quite extraordinary when we actually do the practice. Even though it's all about suffering and wish to be free of it, the practice is hugely uplifting. There's a certain kind of joy, it's not the right word, but it's not a downer, it's an upper. You know, because compassion is such a beautiful quality.

And when we tune into it, it's just an ennobling quality. You know, and to cultivate that, you know, for over an hour at a time where sometimes people do intensive, you know, matter or compassion retreats, and that's all they do all day long, it really opens the heart a lot. So it's a little different than that, although you can see that it's related, but it's quite specifically oriented towards the suffering, either our own or others, and that wish may be free of it. Can you talk a little bit about the difference between wanting things in your life and pursuing them and craving?

One of the problems is that in English, the word wanting or creating, wanting in particular a desire can have a wide range of meanings. It covers a lot of different mind states, it's not a single mind state. And so we might say, I want to get enlightened, or I want to be more compassionate, or I want that second school of ice cream. Those are very different mind states, right?

And one is a little more changed with greed, and the other may be with really a beautiful aspiration. So the mind state is very different, even though the word we use is the same. So I think you need to look in each of those situations where you're using the word I want to say, okay, what is the quality in the mind that that word is expressing? And just to see, I don't know about that.

Living as lay people in the world, we live in the world of sense pleasures and that's totally fine. We're not. We haven't chosen to live more nastic lives with that level of renunciation. So we shouldn't hold that model up necessarily for how we should be living as lay people.

We could, but it's not necessary. So when we look at the wants we have as lay people in the world, some will be of the non-read variety, like coming here, or as I say, you know, a noble aspiration. They have desire. But others will have some degree of greed in it.

So I think what we want to do in this situation is really monitor the degree of greed. You know, are we really obsessing about this thing? There's a little sequence of phrases that might help illuminate this. This came in a very specific example for one of my wants.

That's, I want, I need, I must have. That's going to the degree of greed. You know, where it just becomes so intense. The basic want for basically an innocuous pleasure, I don't see as being a big problem.

Although even in that, as lay people, it is interesting, at least to practice more for the fun, but the game of it, moments of renunciation. Just to see what it's like. You know, we have a desire for cup of tea or something. No.

And we're only having cup of tea. So it's not about that. It's just about exercising that renunciation muscle. You know, the ability when we see a wanting that doesn't particularly serve us, that we're not compelled to act on it.

That we actually have some inner space to see. Do I really want this or not? Do I need it? It just opens up a lot more space.

So it's monitoring, even in a situation when it is the greed factor, which is going to be there in a while. So it's not about the third stage of enlightenment. That's when desire is uprooted. So all the time before that, it's going to be there.

You know, it's not a question of having some ideal literature and the rise it is going to rise. But can we sort of keep it in balance? That's how I say it. Of course, are you familiar with the Buddhist personality types?

There are three personality types. There's a personality map within the Buddhist teachings. There's the greed type, the aversive type, and the deluded type. We all have the mix, but for many of us, one or another is predominant.

So I'm firmly in the greed type family. I like that. Oh, that's nice. That would be good.

Whereas the aversive, that's not good. That's not good. That's not good. More from the anger.

And the greed type is more from the desire. And the deluded type doesn't know what's going on. I like it not as a way of kind of... I want to hold it lightly.

I find there's a certain usefulness in it, both in seeing oneself and others, because it depersonalizes it. Oh, yeah, that's just this personality tendency showing itself. So, it's really... We have a guiding teacher council here for IMS.

I'm going to go to 10 teachers. And this is the mix of those three types. It's a riot. The meetings are a riot.

It's like we each a cartoon figure of these types. And so I'll come into a discussion. Oh, this is going to be fine. It's going to work out.

No problem. And then the aversive type. What do you mean no problem? This is going to go wrong.

And the deluded what? So seen in that light, it's all held much lighter. You know, and then we can go back to a few minutes. I didn't mean to scare you off.

Just want to balance things with this. I'm just curious how important it is to meditate with other people, with your practice. If you can practice alone all the time and just have that be your practice or if joining a song or practicing in a group is important. I would say, first I think it depends a little bit on where one is on the path.

And probably for people beginning, probably group support. For most people it would probably be quite helpful. Because as you know, it's challenging. And if one is just beginning and not quite sure, you know, it was stabilized in the path, the group support can be hugely helpful.

But after that, if one is established in the practice, to some extent, then I think whichever way motivates you to practice. You know, so if you motivated more by kind of sitting alone in a quiet, that's great. If it motivates you more to be sitting in a group, and that motivates you to do it, then that's better. So the morning is what gets us to sit.

Thank you. I'm trying to understand the notion of dispassion and why it's not at odds with say compassion or and also so it makes sense to get rid of one suffering, if possible, to whatever extent. But at the cost of the things that are enjoyable, these two can sort of cock down. I think it's because again, so much of these questions have to do with linguistic confusions.

So the word passion and dispassion in English, there are lots of different connotations of those words. It would be easy to interpret dispassion, but to feel into it as being this interest. You know, just not engaged. But that's not what's meant by dispassion in this Buddhist sense.

So in example, I've been given in some of the groups. There's one suit over where the Buddha uses the image of, he talks about sights, sounds, smells, tastes, touch, and mind, heart experience as the terrible bait of the world. I love that because, so again, just to remind you that Mara means it's the embodiment of delusion or ignorance. So often in Buddhist texts, the term Mara appears.

So sometimes I think of Mara as the fisherman, you know, with this fishing pole and hook and with the fish and all these experiences of sights and sounds and smells and tastes and touch come along and we the fish bite. We get hooked. So dispassion would mean not getting hooked. It doesn't, now we have to, we have to leave the metaphor of the fish.

But not getting hooked doesn't mean not being responsive. It means not being hooked in identifying with what's going on. So instead of I'm thinking I'm, I'm wanting, I'm whatever, adding the eye of the self to the experience, which is our usual way of being in the world. dispassion means not being identified with all of these passing phenomena, but still being engaged and responsive in an appropriate way towards arising.

And so in the face of suffering, compassion is almost, if people have somewhat of an open heart, compassion will be the natural response to suffering. One time I was doing a retreat and there was a lot of, a lot of teaching about bodhijita. And bodhijita is this particularly in like the Tibetan traditions and other traditions, but it's embedded in this one as well. Bodhijita is that aspiration to get enlightened or awakened for the benefit of all.

So that actually becomes our motivation to practice. And for me, this has been a very interesting development in my own practice. So for the first many years, I would be practicing with an aspiration to awaken that was a strong aspiration and understanding that the freer I was, it would inevitably be of helped others. You know, if we are less judgmental and less angry and less greedy, of course it's going to be a positive influence on everyone we meet.

But when I started hearing the teachings of bodhijita, instead of seeing the benefit of others as being the inevitable byproduct of awakening, I put it at the beginning as the motivation to awaken. Do you see the difference? We will inevitably help beings, you know, the clearer we did. But to actually make the benefit of beings the motive for practice, I felt that a huge energizing influence, you know, because in a way it took the practice out of a more narrow personal endeavor.

And it just put in this vast context of all beings. And we're practicing with that motivation aspiration that I'm doing this for the benefit of all. And it was an infusion of energy into my practice. So that's the kind of responsiveness I'm talking about.

And so this passion is not about disengaging. It's just about not getting hooked in this self-identity, the identification with experience, which is a limitation, which is a contraction, the creation of the sense of self. So I think it's just important to see how that word dispassion is used in this context. Yeah.

Sometimes when wonder and gratitude arise for the practice, it's followed by a longing to share it with others. And aside from noticing that and not clinging to it, I was wondering if you had any thoughts on how to work with that skillfully over time. I have plenty of thoughts about everything. You name it?

I have a thought about it. Would you like to share them? I would. I'll share with you.

First, I'll suggest having not to share when you leave here and go home. Hey, mom, you know, there's really no self. Wouldn't do that. Fundamentally, the fundamental sharing.

And we can build on it. But the fundamental sharing is how we are rather than what we say. And so if you go back with family and friends and work at, and you're more, you're more calm. You're less judgmental.

You're less reactive. That's the most meaningful sharing. You know, because people will feel it and see it. So that's the main thing.

That's why just doing the practice, as I say, it inevitably helps people around us because it transforms the way we are. Okay. So that should be the priority in terms of actual verbal sharing. I think it's really important to learn how to listen carefully because we have to listen to where people are at.

And then, and over time, and this is its own practice. So then we can share what's appropriate to them at that time. But if we have some preconception of what we want to share, and we're speaking with somebody, and they're not in that space at all. It's not going to be very meaningful.

So listening, you know, a careful listening to the other person and feeling into that is really important. I think that I can also do the two main things. And then sharing from your experience. You know, you might feel into where a person's at.

And, you know, I had a similar experience and I worked with it in this way. Well, this is what I understood. So that becomes a meaningful communication. So my question is about the term heart mind.

I think it's the word mind that's confusing for me. And I feel like the body has a mind, the heart has a mind, then there's the brain. And can you explain what you mean by that? Yeah.

So first, it's kind of interesting that in many Asian languages, the word for heart and mind is the same. So it's like an English. We've made that distinction. So that's interesting in and of itself.

And so the phrase heart mind is to try to collapse them into one rather than being separate. And it just really means every aspect of our awareness from thoughts and intellectual activity and concepts to feelings and emotions to awareness itself. So heart mind is just inclusive of it all rather than by rotating, is that the word? You know, mind up here, heart here.

And in the practice, maybe you've had the sense it's not like that at all. It's like, there's just kind of an open space and different things are arising within some of thoughts and some of the feelings and some of our emotions. So it's all, it's all of that. These were just a couple of questions that people had left.

And in a way, they're related. So how do you forgive someone who has served you many times? And then the other one was you mentioned asking the question, what is a thought? But you said this was not a metaphysical question, but isn't it?

Also, it's one thing to not be consumed by your thought, but how do you avoid being consumed by negative thoughts and expressions that one says of you? So how do you relate to that? That's a really interesting, very practical question, because we face situations. When somebody has done us a lot of harm, how do we forgive them?

And how do we relate if people are kind of expressing a lot of negativity toward us? How do we relate to that? And it's when I use the question, I just reflected on situations I've been in like that. Where some, in certain situations, some people did things which I just felt were really harmful, both to me and to others.

And said I had saying a lot of not such nice things. So at one point, I was on retreat, just in the midst. This was a whole big story that was going on for quite a while. And then I was going into retreat and it was very up in my mind.

And so I would be going over and over again, you know, the situation in the story. And I became a very good lawyer for arguing my case. As I was going through the situation, then seeing what they've done, he's these five points where you're so wrong and whatever. And right around that time, I was reading this quite amazing book, which maybe some of you've read.

It's called Tattoos on the Heart by Father Gregory Boyle. He's a Jesuit priest working in LA with the gang kids. And right in the middle, he's living right in the middle of it. And this huge amount of violent people, a lot of killing and stray killings and intentional, violent, violent situation.

And he's there and working with these kids and trying to find some way to bring them out of that mirror. And one of the lines in the book really stuck with me, or the theme, we could say, the theme of the book is love no matter what. Love no matter what. And this is not love meaning condoning those actions.

It's not he was right in the middle of it and seeing the violence out it. But even underneath all that, his vehicle for connecting with the kids was love no matter what. So I read that the book was really, it was a kind of transmission of that theme. And it was really powerful, a powerful impact on me.

So in the middle of this duke of this situation that I was in, and I was going on and on justifying my own point of view, which of course was the right one. But just so you're clear. But then I tried to bring that in. And it was really, really revelatory because there was some moments when I could really let go of being the lawyer from my side and say, underneath all of that, love no matter what.

And it was an interesting piece of this for me. He's a Jesuit. So he was using a lot of God language, which is not my language. It's not the language I resonate to particularly.

But there was something in the way he was talking about it. It actually served me at that particular time because as he was talking about it, I could just imagine using the concept of God as he was using it. I just got a very strong feeling of what it might be like or the love of God looking down on all of us, all of us being struggling in all the ways we're struggling and caught up in all our everything we're caught up in, the fights and the struggles and the loves and everything. I could just imagine, again, using that language, which is not really my language, but God, just loving everyone, independent of the particular activity.

It just gave me a window into that possibility. Yeah, love no matter what. And what was so striking in this was when I contrasted what it felt like when I was caught in being right to what it felt like when I was in the space of love no matter what. The first was a prison.

It was like it was a contracted space. And love no matter what was just open and spacious. And it just illustrated to me that even when people are being hugely difficult and even harmful, all of this is not to say that we don't respond in a way that seems most appropriate to the situation we do respond, but the response is very different energetically and in many ways if we're coming from that space of love no matter what, rather than unright and you're wrong. It's a whole different experience.

So I think there is a way and it's not to say even from that space that the situation will be resolved because sometimes it's not. Sometimes for whatever reason, there's a stuckness involved in the situation that is not getting resolved and could even be ongoing. But still, even with all of that, I've seen the possibility of just resting and okay, all of that stuff is happening and I'll do what I need to do in response to it, but underneath all of that, not however any of you feeling. It's like, okay, all of that's going on.

It's not good, whatever, but a lot of no matter what. And for me, that was a really powerful learning of that possibility. Did that seem clear to you? It was really quite impactful.

So love no matter what is a beautiful aspiration. How do you take that wider lens? Like what skillful means? It takes you out of that contracted space.

I mean, you have a lot of practice at it. For the less practice, the less I'm sorry. First I want to just add a piece, which I forgot. That in certain situations that continue to be harmful in one way or another, sometimes the appropriate move is just to remove oneself from it.

So I don't mean to suggest that love no matter what means that we necessarily have to stay entangled in the conflict. Sometimes removing oneself is exactly the right thing to do. What can we remove ourselves maintaining the love no matter what rather than out of anger? So that's the key piece.

I'm not sure there's any one answer to that. Clearly, practicing the mental compassion as a practice in that specific situation might open the doorway to at least a glimpse of, okay, it's kind of realizing that we're just all these suffering beings trying to do our best. Sometimes it's working and sometimes we're just spiraling down. But when we see that bigger picture of just suffering beings, why do people do harmful things?

Do you think happy people go around and do really harmful things? I don't think so. Usually people are acting out in an unskillful way because of their own suffering. And they don't have to deal with it.

So it just spills out into these unskillful unwholesome patterns. So we can see that when we see the suffering underneath the action. I think that actually is the key. And it's interesting, in these situations, even on one on one, if somebody is being really difficult in one way or another, and we really need to stay on the level of difficulty or it could be the level of harm or whatever, it'd be very interesting.

And I've done this to actually look at them, not look at our idea of them, but actually just to open our eyes and look. And when I've done that, the suffering is so obvious. And most of the time or often we are reactive to the personality expression because that's the most apparent. So somebody's acting out.

It's like a weird behavior, unskillful behavior. We just react to that. And we don't look. We're not actually looking at the person.

We're reacting to the behavior. And when I've looked, as I said, the suffering is so apparent. And in seeing the suffering, it's much easier to drop to this level. But we really feel compassion.

And again, it doesn't mean not engaging. We take whatever response is appropriate and helpful as best as can. But our hearts are really open to that person. It's a whole other way of relating to difficulties.

OK, gang. We just sit for a few minutes in the space of love no matter what. And we might just extend this underneath everything, underneath all of our interactions. And people we love, people we don't love, people we dislike.

But underneath it all, can we hold ourselves and everybody else in that space? It's really beautiful. It's a beautiful way of being in the world. There will be at ease.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 1 hour and 0 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on May 29, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.