Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to be here now network.com slash Joseph.
Meditation as being the heart of the path of awakening. And in any ways it is. It's through the cultivation of mindfulness and concentration and equity and all the qualities that we're cultivating that makes possible the wisdom that actually liberates the mind. It's important to remember that the Buddhist teaching of liberation, of enlightenment, of awakening is much more inclusive of life experience than just sitting in a meditation hall.
Our life is our practice and we really see this unmistakably when we consider and investigate the noble eightfold path. Having established ourselves here to some extent in right understanding and understanding of the three characteristics of understanding of attachment causes suffering and having established ourselves at least somewhat in the second step of right thought. That is seeing the value of thoughts of renunciation, of non-greed, of loving kindness, of non-hatred of compassion, non-proability. The Buddha then lays out the next three steps in how we can apply these understanders and how we can apply our wisdom in the world.
The next three steps on the path are actually about how we live our lives. That is how we live our lives in our speech, in our action and in our livelihood. As we reflect on our own commitment at whatever level it is to freeing the mind, to freedom, to awakening, we might notice a tendency to relegate these aspects of the path of speech, of action, of livelihood to a somewhat secondary role. As if the real work is here.
It is sitting on a question, walking meditation. But if we hold it in this way, we are really fragmenting our lives and weakening essential elements of the path. When you think of the Buddha in his first discourse, if there is enlightenment when he laid out the four noble truths in the eightfold path, he didn't actually say there is right view, wise understanding, wise thought. Then if you have time, work with speech and action and livelihood.
It is a path of practice that includes all of it. It is interesting, there is one list where the Buddha lays out 10 unholed actions to avoid, like not feeling and not stealing. Seven of the ten are purified by these next three steps on the path, the right speech, action and livelihood. This is not some kind of insignificant addendum to our practice.
In some ways, it is very hard about practice as we live our lives in the world. Michael Bodhi with his usual clarity of expression, he expressed this really well. He is talking about these three steps on the path. He said, though the principles laid down in this section restrain unskillful actions and produce good conduct, their ultimate purpose is not so much ethical as spiritual.
They are not prescribed merely as guides to action, but primarily as age to mental purification. It is so important to see how we are living in the world. Of course, ethics are important, but the depth of these steps have to do with the furtherance of the purification of our minds. They go much deeper.
As a necessary measure for human well-being, ethics has its own justification in the Buddhist teachings and its importance cannot be underrated. But in the special context of a noble eightfold path, ethical principles are subordinate to the path's governing goal, final deliverance from suffering. So I hope you have a sense that these steps which involve ethical conduct have a much deeper and more profound context. And that's why they are steps of the eightfold path to freedom.
So the first of these triad of path factors is right speech. And this is the one I'd like to talk about this evening. And speech is this incredibly powerful force in our lives. And it is so precisely because we speak a lot.
In our lives in the world, we are just most of the time and most of us are just speaking all day long. And how often are we really paying attention to this as part of our practice? You know the speech we use conditions or relationships, the conditions are on hearts and minds, it conditions karmic results, karmic consequences in the future. So the most basic aspect of right speech is truthfulness, not saying that which isn't true.
So although this may seem exceedingly obvious and straightforward, it may not be as easy to practice impeccably as we assume it to be. Now there are many kinds of false speech from perhaps slight exaggerations or humorous untruths or false words that may be motivated by some desire for self protection in some way. We feel we have to say something untrue or the protection of others. We feel that somehow we're lying to protect other people.
Sometimes they are deliberately with an intention to harm, to cause divisiveness. Of course we see this illuminated in any election year. You know where people both candidates and commentators and partisan voices are just saying all kinds of things. And you know you're probably familiar with that.
There's some kind of, I know there's a programmer who wants to go to fact check. You know, there's somebody, fortunately just watching. And it is amazing how much of what is said in that context is just blatantly untrue. It doesn't seem to stop it.
At least it's good to be cognizant of it. So in any situation on any level, it would be really interesting and important to look at what the motivation is when we say something that is not exactly true. Is it greed for something? Is it a desire for recognition?
Maybe some kind of self aggrandizement? Is it out of a fear of rejection that we don't say what is true or jealousy? Or envy? It could be so many different motivations.
But telling untruths as we all know, it becomes very complicated. Because then we have to tell otherwise to support the first lie and then we have to remember it all. And Mark Twain just captured the problematic nature of all this. He said, if you tell the truth, you don't have to remember anything.
So our lives, our minds, our hearts become that much simpler. We're not holding up this construct. You know, as we all know, probably from our own experience, lying is a great corrosive force in our relationships. And in society, because it undermines, it weakens our ability to trust.
The German philosopher Nietzsche said, I'm not upset that you lied to me. I'm upset that from now on, I can't believe you. And we may have had experiences with people we know or friends or associates when we've been lied to. And you know how it just undermines the ability to trust.
You can't no longer believe that person when they say something. So the Buddha spoke of the importance of truthfulness in a very blunt way. He was not mincing words about this. He said, thus one should never knowingly speak a lie, either for the sake of one's own advantage or for the sake of another person's advantage or for the sake of any advantage whatsoever.
I find that just the clarity of that teaching, because there are so many ways we can rationalize telling an untruth and we kind of justify it, oh well, it's important in this situation. And the Buddha saying, no, the commitment to the truth should be impeccable. And in the Bodhisattvas, long journey to Buddhahood, and these are the stories of all his many past lives as he's cultivating the qualities of Buddha, it said that he broke all of the precepts at one time or another. He was a being like us with all the flaws and problems.
So he broke a lot of the precepts on his path to Buddhahood. But it said that the one precept he never broke, that from the time he was committed to this path of awakening, it said that he never said that which was untrue. So central is truthfulness to the path of awakening. So we can reflect on this, we can reflect on this standard really as an inspiration for our own commitment to truthfulness in our lives.
But what seems so simple can be surprisingly difficult. What could be simpler than, yeah, we just say what's true and we don't say what's untrue. It seems obvious. Sometimes I imagine the Buddha as a second grade teacher teaching us, don't lie, don't steal, just saying the most obvious things.
And yet it's very interesting just to take a really refined look at one's own speech and actions. Sometimes lies just seem to tumble out before we're even quite aware. At the end of the three month course, every year at IMS, we meet in groups and transfer people to integrate a little bit. And one of the groups, who was around speech, one of the yogis was commenting on a pattern that he noticed in himself.
So he said, you know, as I was getting together with my friends and talking about our practice and some of the conversation, you know, how long did you sit for? How long did you sit for? And he said, you always ate at 15 minutes. It was just a little thing, but it's not true.
It's kind of to present himself in a slightly better way. One story which I've told very many times, but it is a classic. So at the end of one of the three month retreats, at IMS, these big walking refrigerators in the freezer. So one day a set person was going into this big walk-in to get something and they saw a yogi in the refrigerator with his hand in a box of dates.
So the staff person very politely said, can I help you? And the guy just without thinking at all, oh, I'm looking for the maintenance person. In a box of dates. It is amazing.
I think it's interesting just to watch in ourselves, you know, in these, it's a basically harmless situation, but still we can see just a habit of justifying ourselves or protecting ourselves or whatever and an untruth comes out. Sometimes there are lies of omission covering or withholding something of importance. Perhaps some of you are familiar with the poet Adrian Rich. She wrote, lying is done with words and also with silence.
So this is another nuance of right speech, of truthfulness that is worth looking at. And I had an experience of this. It goes back 50 years and it's still completely vivid in my mind. I had finished my time in the Peace Corps and I was traveling back to the States.
I'd stopped on the way home. I'd been stationed in Bangkok. So I stopped in India and Nepal, just traveling back home. And in Nepal, there's a day hike up to a place called Nagar Code, from which you can see Mount Everest.
So it's kind of a popular one day hike. And there was a shelter there on top and people often would stay overnight and there's very basic shelter. So I had a hike up there and it was a glorious view of Mount Everest. And then there was this room where the dorm room was like 10, 12 beds.
And the beds all had two blankets on them. And so we're going to sleep and then after the lights, where somebody comes in late and on their bed there was only one blanket. And then I noticed that on my bed there were three. It was really cold.
And I just, you know, when looking back now, kind of this rationally, well, I didn't ask for it. It just happens to be on my bed. So I didn't say anything. And then once I started getting into the practice, and I was just going on with my trip and, you know, I think at the time I didn't think much more about it, but it came to my mind as I started to meditate.
And just kind of the blatant breed and selfishness, a lying lie of omission. So we want to, as we open up, become more sensitive in our lives, just to be aware when that kind of situation may arise. We might also be under the illusion that we would never lie in whatever form it might take. So if we are living with that belief, it's possible that the belief actually makes it harder for us to see when we do, because we just have this self image, oh, I don't lie, I would never lie.
Well, I had another one. This tonight's kind of confessional. Yeah. Well, the wrong speech confessions.
But they all highlight a particular situation that can come up. I had one really powerful, painful, but ultimately freeing experience with seeing what my mind could do. So this was the first course with Sider Wunditos in 1984, a very intensive course. You know, we're just looking for, I was a knight practicing very rigorously.
He's a very demanding teacher. So it was stressful. It was not useful. And I had some idea of where my practice was at.
I'd already been practicing and teaching for some time. And I thought I had a pretty good understanding of the map and how things unfold. I had this notion of where my practice was at. So in the interview, I was just kind of slanting the report according to this view that I had of where my practice was at.
So one particular interview, I go in and I'm reporting on my experience, you know, this little slant. And after the report, he just said one thing to me. He said, that's not true. Even though my heart starts to work, I was devastated because it was true.
He said, so I mean, here, I am in this completely vulnerable situation to begin with with a teacher I had this tremendous respect for. And I was not very conscious. I was a little bit conscious. I kind of knew what I was doing, but really wasn't seeing the implication.
So when he said, that isn't true, it took me days to recover. I was so upset. So working over days, I was working with feelings of shame and self-judgment and guilt and all of it. But it actually came to a place of greater freedom because I came to see when I worked through kind of all the terrible feelings and the reactivity of self-judgment, I came to the place of seeing my mind more clearly and realized, yeah, my mind can do that.
I had been under the elute, no, no, no, I would never shade the truth, especially with my teacher. But I know the mind can do that and worse. So when I let go of that previously unnoticed, pretense and delusion, it became much easier than to recognize even those little impulses in the mind to fabricate in some way. You follow because I reckon, yeah, the mind can do this.
And I got freer and less self-judgmental about it, having gone through that terrible experience. So then it was much easier to see as these impulses were, oh, yeah, this is the mind wanting to do that. And it became much easier than to see it and actually to refrain from that kind of speech. So it's often in the most painful situations and experience that we actually learn the most.
We really see where we've been caught in some way and the possibility of not getting caught. Sometimes it takes tremendous courage to practice speaking only what is true. So one inspiring example of this for me was reading a book called Life and Death in Shanghai, I know that any of you read it quite a few years old now, by a Chinese woman, Yen Chang. She lived in China with her husband, her husband had been sort of a big executive in one of the multinationals that had been in China.
But during the cultural revolution, I can't remember whether the husband was killed or something, but everything was taken from them. She was put in prison for years and then tortured a horrible situation. And they wanted her to confess to being in some kind of conspiracy with the then premier of China, China, and I know how many of you remember Chinese history. He was a very important person, but the cultural revolution faction wanted to bring this person down, so they wanted her to confess.
And the book is the story of her being in prison under these terrible conditions and being unwilling to tell a lie. And they were really tormenting her. But she was so committed to truthfulness. And after a certain number of years, they let her out and she ended up living in DC.
But to read our account of just the integrity of even in situations that are horrible, to be so committed to the truth. And who knows what the consequences would have been in China and for the rest of the world. That could have been a pivotal shift in one way or another. So sometimes it really does require a tremendous courage, commitment to the truth.
Now, in one of the meanings of the word the term dharma, that's the way it's done in Pali, one of the meanings of that word is truth. And our whole goal in practice, everything we're doing is about seeing what is true. That's what practicing the dharma means. Again from Piccoboti, he makes it.
It says, truthful speech establishes a correspondence between our inner being and the real nature of phenomena. Thus much more than an ethical principle, the motion to truthful speech is a matter of taking our stand on reality rather than illusion. I love that. I mean, what a clear statement of what the commitment to truthfulness means.
It's taking us in on reality rather than on illusion. The Buddha emphasized the overriding importance of the sin, this is why I'm going on a little bit of length about this. The Buddha emphasized this so strongly in one conversation with his son, Rahul, who was then Anabas, Anabas Munkh. The Buddha pointed to a ball with just a little bit of water at the bottom.
He said to his son, so little is the spiritual achievement of one who is not afraid to tell a deliberate lie. Therefore one should not tell a deliberate lie even in jest. This is a strong statement. So little is the spiritual achievement of one who is not afraid to tell a deliberate lie.
So we want to really watch and make this an essential arena of practice. But what's important as we hear this is to recognize that it is a practice. And it's a powerful one to undertake and to realize we may not yet be perfect in this. The statement may be many times when the words come tumbling out, oh, I'm looking for the maintenance person or whatever the lie may be.
A little slanting of your meditation report. But if we have established taking us, taking us, taking us, taking us, taking us, taking us down on our commitment to being truthful, even though we realize it's a practice, we realize that maybe many times we fall from that standard. Still just having made the commitment, it helps to sensitize ourselves in our own speech to even small falsehoods. And I've seen this in myself since I've begun really consciously trying to work with this.
I can see perhaps an impulse to say something that's not quite true. And because of the commitment, oh yeah, it's like a little mindfulness bell goes off. I don't know, this isn't true. I don't need to say this.
So just the commitment, having made the commitment, begins to transform our lives and how we use speech. Okay, so the second aspect of right speech, the first and the critical importance is truthfulness. The second aspect of right speech is refraining from slandering gossip, backbiting. You know, those words that cause disharmony and loss of friends.
So again, who just words very clear? He said, what one has heard here is not repeated there, so as to cause dissension. What one has heard there is not repeated here, so as not to cause dissension here. One unites those who are divided and encourages those who are already united.
One delights and rejoices in Concord. And it is Concord that one spreads by one's words. So this would be a very helpful frame to consider before we speak. I'm kind of specially given the strong, worldwide tendency to gossip.
And this is just such a common pattern of speech. This is kind of what we do. You know, we get together with our friends. And it's all of the worlds.
People, this is what people do. But it might be interesting to ask the question as we're in the middle of some really juicy. First of all, I noticed that this is what's happening. And then to really ask us, well, what's the enjoyment of this?
What am I getting out of this? When we gossiping about others, does it in some way reaffirm our own sense of self? You know, is there some ego gratification? So now I'll tell you a successful speech story.
This goes back again many, many years. Just when the meditation, it was just beginning in this country. It was just beginning to spread, perhaps in the late 70s. There's quite a famous writer who wanted to do a book on the spiritual, the burgeoning spiritual scene in America, Buddhism, and other meditative traditions.
So he came to my house and very skilled into you. He's written many books, very skilled. And so we're engaging in a really interesting conversation. And in the course of the conversation, he starts asking me, just what I think about this teacher and that teacher.
And of course, I had my two cents about everybody, my viewers and opinions and judgments and whatever. And I was just like, yeah, that's really good. But fortunately, yes, the question is, the mind don't spell. This is not a good idea.
And so I just need to go into that arena of the conversation. I was so happy at that decision when the book came out and everything that was in our conversation was in the book. And if I had just spilled out all my opinions and judgments and it all would have been in the book. And I really would not have been good.
So I just appreciate the power and the gift of mindfulness, if we can really be watching and monitoring. So when I first my first introduction to Buddhism, when I was in the Peace Corps in Thailand, just at Finnish College, and I was teaching English and Bangkok, I was my first introduction to Buddhism, I was really quite excited by it all and a tremendous interest. And I was reading about the Eightfold Path and right conduct and no background at all. So it was all new and fresh and exciting.
And I read little pieces about right speech. So I made an experiment. And for some period of time, it was extended. I can't remember exactly, but maybe a couple of months.
I decided not to speak to someone about someone else. It was not gossip. If they weren't there, I wasn't going to speak about them. About 90% of my speech was eliminated.
It was astounding to see how much of what I was saying was that kind of speech. And it wasn't, it was particularly malicious or anything like that, but it was just gossip. So even, so you might want to make a little experiment. There were times when I got a little awkward, like if somebody else was speaking to me about a third person, I had a device, all kinds of little strategies for not engaging.
You know, like smiling, changing the topic. So it took a time to talk a little, but it was a very interesting thing to do. And nowadays, you know, when so many people are aware of this or similar path of practice, we could even say, oh no, I'm practicing, I'm practicing this kind of voice speech. You know, it would be much more understandable now.
But even if we loosen the parameters a little bit, you know, at least say, okay, we may be speaking about a third person, but we're going to really watch what we say. Is it to divide or is it to unite? Such as that, that would be a great frame. And then to watch our motivation.
Now if the intention is kind of to divide people, what's behind that? What's motivating us? Or is the motivation really to help people who may be divided to help bring them together? That would be a much more skillful use of our speech.
And another level of speech may be a kind of gossip about ourselves. And this is another interesting pattern to observe. It's a form of what in poly is called mana, M-A-N-A. And that's translated usually as conceit.
But as a defilement of the mind, it's basically that sense of I-M. It's the I-M sense. And it's not a root until one is an art. So this particular tendency goes very, very deep roots in the mind.
Even when we understand the selfless nature of it all, the habit pattern of I-M, of mana, is still there. So when we're speaking, we might look, is our tendency to always be self-referential? To be over and over again, bring the conversation back to ourselves. That's kind of a gossip about ourselves.
It's a form of mana. Or we might have the opposite conditioning. Rather than taking center stage, we may be obsessively staying behind the scenes, never giving voice. You know, to our views, to our opinions, to our thoughts.
Speech is such a powerful mirror of our minds. When we're paying attention to our speech and what kind of speech, it is like reflecting back, if we're paying attention, it is reflecting back to us what's going on in our minds. And so we can learn a tremendous amount. Just to give you a sense of the force of mana, you know, this kind of I-M sense, and how it's expressed in speech.
I was in New York with a friend, we were driving back to Massachusetts, where I live. And on the drive back, we were just talking. And then the thought came to say something. It was just self-referential, but without any purpose whatsoever.
It was out of context of the conversation. And it was just me. Okay, so I saw this. You know, I saw this impulse to say it.
Come up with my mind. No, that's just mana. I don't have the wrong to say this. So I let it go.
About 10 seconds later. The thought comes again, watching. It's sort of like that cup of tea. So I watched it 10 times, 15 times, 20 times.
Then it came out. At this time, I was really amused. I was just watching my mind, and it amused me. Just how strong.
It was like being pregnant with mana. You know, and just had a giver. So these patterns will be there. You know, we're not yet fully enlightened.
These old habit patterns, we're going to express them. But can we begin to watch? Can we begin to see what's going on in maybe a time's refrain? So the third aspect of white, right, wise speech, right speech, has to do with the emotional tone in our hearts and minds.
And the Buddha talked in this way of refraining from harsh, angry, and abusive speech. So these are the Buddhist words. One speaks such words as our gentle, soothing to the ear, loving. So what such words as go to the heart of courteous, friendly, and agreeable to many.
So this really is how we're speaking. What's the tone? What's the feeling behind it? There's a very simple reference point from monitoring this.
And I think this just serves us in so many different situations. And it's basically, are we being kind? In our speech, are we speaking kindly or not? And Dalai Lama, he stressed this when he said, be kind whenever possible.
It's always possible. So do we remember that? And can we be present enough, we'd be mindful enough in our speech so that when something's coming out that's not kind, that is harsh or angry or judgmental or whatever it may be, maybe we won't catch it till we have to sum the words already out. But with practice, maybe we can begin to see the intent beforehand and remind ourselves, can it be kind in this situation?
It's really important to be aware of the energy behind our words. Because how do we feel when we are on the receiving end of angry energy? It doesn't feel good. And what do most of us do?
Very often, we put up some defense because it's kind of a violent energy coming at us. So we get defensive and probably feel hurt. And then maybe anger arises ourselves as a possible response. This is not a good environment for communication.
And really, in the end, that's what wise speech is all about. Can we connect? Can we have connection? So the interest here is not to suppress the feelings, maybe, of anger or irritation or annoyance.
So we want to be cognizant of what we're feeling. But as Kamala was spoke of so beautifully last night, can we see what's arising, create some space, and maybe wait a bit until we can say what needs to be said from a kindly place? This is a practice. This practice is as hard as anything you've done here in these last days.
It's not an inferior kind of practice. Because the patterns of our speech go so deep that we're tremendously habituated. So we need to be really mindful. So now I'm going to offer some teaching of the Buddha that is tremendously challenging.
This really raises the bar. Because the right speech also has implications for how we listen. And the Buddha outlined a practice for listening that will be very challenging. Okay, ready?
Biggus, that's us. This kind of everybody walking on the path. There are five courses of speech that others may use when they address you. So this is listening.
This is speech coming to us. Their speech may be timely or untimely. True or untrue. Gentle or harsh.
Connected with good. Connected with harm. Spoken with a mind of loving kindness or with a mind of inner hate. Herein you should train yourself thus.
Our minds will remain unaffected. We shall utter no unskillful words. We shall abide compassionate for their welfare with a mind of loving kindness. Okay, so picture the scene.
You're speaking with somebody and they're speaking at completely the wrong time, speaking very harshly, lying, just saying what's untrue, wanting to harm you, filled with hate. Our minds will remain unaffected. We shall utter no unskillful words. We should abide compassionate for their welfare with a mind of loving kindness.
It's a pretty high bar. But I love that because it's just a reminder of the direction of our practice. We may not be, then we probably aren't there quite yet. But there are very few people in the world that would even hold that as a value.
You know, we'd say, oh yeah, this is really challenging and hard, but it's something to aspire to. And so when we're in those difficult conversations, maybe some of these words will come back to you and you'll remember it. Because when somebody is speaking in that kind of really unskillful way, usually we're just reacting, reactive to the behavior, if there's some presence of mind, it actually becomes possible to drop down a level and see the suffering in them that is the cause of that behavior. People at peace do not speak like that.
It's coming out of their own suffering. But normally we don't go to that level. And then we're just reacting to the behavior. So this is just a reminder.
There's another dimension, you know, as we relate to people, as we speak with people, as other people speak with us. Do you see why this whole domain is as profound as anything that happens here? You know, sitting on the question. The last aspect of the right speech is refraining from useless talk.
And the poly word for this is an example of an amount of pia, you know, where the word sounds like what it is. So the poly word for useless talk is sampapalapa. And said to say, we sampapalapa a lot. A lot of our speech is really useless.
And we see this very often in just social situation. I see it just hanging out with friends. You know, it kind of informal, just hanging out, shouting away. How often I see in myself the impulse, just to add something to the conversation.
That is totally useless. It has no point at all. The only point perhaps is to announce here I am. The words themselves have no meaning.
There is nothing meaningful being said at all. And it is very innovating. It is really an energy dream. So one of my favorite practices in these kind of situations is just our daily life, ordinary interactions with people.
And it happens a lot with friends. We are just kind of relaxing. I love it in those moments when I can see a little sampapalapa about to pop out. And I am aware of it.
No, I don't need to say this. It feels so victorious. It is like one of life's little victories over Mara. You know, there is shh.
No, I don't need to do that. And it is amazing how energizing that is. It is just back in myself. Sometimes sampapalapa has really bad consequences.
So there is one story which illustrates this, but it needs a historical setting because it was before 9-11. After 9-11, it would have been a whole different building. So before 9-11, his friend in New York was going on vacation in Bali. He made a lot of planes for it.
So he goes out to the airport, gets on the plane, and he had injured his hand. So he had exercise balls and he was just exercising the same. So the flight attendant comes by and says, oh, what is that? And just without thinking and trying to be funny, plastic.
Which is detonating, explosive. So he was just trying to be funny, I guess. Within two minutes they had the police on the plane. They escorted him off, they detained him.
It was a huge thing until he convinced them. He actually was a psychiatrist. I'm okay. The airline, I don't think I would jail.
The airline banned him for life. So finally, a couple of days later, he finally managed to get on another flight and went, of course now he probably didn't jail. So he's in Bali about to come back. They're sitting in the airport and sitting next to somebody and he's just kind of talking and talking to him and says, hey, you know, you're sitting next to a terrorist?
Fortunately, I mean, again, there was free terrorist days as we know it now. So nothing happened from that. But even after he had been through, you know, it's like that tendency is just so strong. We just, the words pop out completely useless.
So a very good question, which we can begin to incorporate into our lives, you know, in this kind of verbal communication before we speak, at least at times, is just to ask ourselves, is this useful? Is it useful to say this? And we'll find, I think, much to our surprise that very often it's not. And we can just stay at ease.
Our mind becomes our hearts become more peaceful. So the Buddha expressed it this way. He said, one speaks at the right time, in accordance with facts, speaks what is useful, speaks of the dharma. Such a person's speech is like a treasure uttered at the right moment, accompanied by reason, moderate and full of sins.
So as we hear that, just to give ourselves a little more, a little bigger playground, the Buddha here is speaking to monastics. So he's creating quite a refined standard of speech, which would be worth practicing. But Bhikkhu Bodhi, when he was writing about right speech in his book on the 8th of April, he kind of expanded the parameters a little bit. And probably as lay people, we could just give ourselves a little more leeway.
You know, as Bhikkhu Bodhi said, acknowledging that we have some need for affection and small talk, you know, with family and friends, or just polite conversation, you know, with people we made or talk with connection at work. So we don't have to, we don't have to get tight behind us. We can engage in kind of normal social convention, but with a much greater awareness than we might have now with regard to speech. And particularly with truthfulness, with some papalapa, with harsh speech, you know, with gossip that causes division, with those kinds of really harmful speech, we can learn just to let it go, even as we see the patterns arise.
So it's not by accident that the Buddha made right speech, just an essential element on the path. This is an arena of practice and a profound arena. And it's a way of cultivating a mindfulness throughout our day, throughout our ordinary daily lives because we are speaking a lot. When we pay attention in this way, we are weakening the unwholesome states of mind.
We are strengthening the beautiful qualities of mindfulness, of compassion, of caring, of kindness. And most importantly, our attention to our speech, it aligns us with what is true. And so our whole lives become a trajectory of Dharma practice. So I just like to close with a teaching from the Tibetan Master, the Gagongchul.
He said, the potential for realization is universal and present for all of us. True benefit will come from your own efforts and realization. For your efforts to bring benefit, you must take your life into your own hands and examine your mind and experience. From this point of view, nobody could be kinder to you than yourself.
Nobody could have a greater effect on you or actually do more for you than yourself. The Buddha said, I have shown you the path of liberation. Now liberation depends on you. This is really true.
If you don't take your life into your own hands, not even the Buddhists can make a difference. It's up to you. And it is up to all of us. We need to do the work.
The path is there and the path is clear. And so it's just inspiring ourselves to continue walking.