Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com.
Slash, Joseph. I'd like to continue the discussion of mindfulness of the Dhammas, the fourth foundation of mindfulness with respect to the aggregates of mental formations and consciousness. So, last week we talked about Sankharas, or the mental formations, which is the fourth of the five aggregates. These are all those factors of mind apart from feeling and perception that are the building blocks of our thoughts, of our emotions, of our moods, of different mind states.
According to the Abhidhamma, the Buddhist psychology, there are 52 of these mental factors, different qualities of the mind. Some of them are wholesome, some of them are unwholesome, some of them are ethically neutral. But they all color consciousness, each in their own particular way, according to their own characteristics. So, just as a reminder, as an example of some of these mental factors, it's things like desire and aversion, of restlessness, of doubt, of concentration, mindfulness, wisdom, rapture, energy, all of those different states of mind that we experience, each of them is called a mental factor.
By being mindful of them as they arise in our experience, whenever they become predominant, we begin to see directly for ourselves that each of these factors is impermanent, it arises, it's there, it passes away, and we see its impersonal or non-personal nature, it's arising out of causes. So, in this aggregate of sankara, of mental formations, which includes all of these different mental factors, the Buddha highlighted one particular factor as being the chief, as being the one of them all that plays a very critical role. So, he highlighted this particular one, and sometimes the word sankara itself refers just to this one factor, and that is the mental factor of intention of volition. And the poly word for that is jaitana.
So, bhikubodi, you know, that wonderful American monk who studied for so long in Sri Lankan, is this amazing scholar, you know, and has done these fantastic translations of the discourses. He described the function of jaitana of volition as being that factor, which is concerned with the actualization of a goal. It's that quality of mind that's concerned with actualizing a particular goal. So, we can think of it somewhat as being the chief of staff of the mind.
It conditions all the other factors to accomplish a specific purpose. Now, intention or volition is common to every moment of consciousness. And so, in every moment, it's functioning to organize and gather all of the other associated factors. It's gathering them together, directing them together for a particular end.
So, what makes this factor so important? Why did the Buddha highlight it? You know, in this teaching of the five aggregates. Volition, what jaitana is of such crucial importance, both in understanding our lives, and also in understanding the possibilities for happiness in our lives, is because it is this factor of volition which carries the karmic force of the action.
So, volition, and the Buddha has said this, that volition is karma. That's the factor of mind that carries the force. So, what this means is that all of our intentional, volitional actions, and I'm using these two words, synonymously intentional and volitional. So, all of these volitional actions of body, speech, and mind, have the power because of the volition to bring about results.
This is tremendously important. It means that the actions we do, whether it's actions of our body, actions of speech, actions of mind, are not happening in isolation and not happening in a vacuum. It's not as if we do the action and then it's done and over with. The Buddha is pointing out that because of volition, when we are willing in action, that power of volition, the power of it is to create fruit, it's to create results.
So, there's a trail of results that come from each of our actions. We could think of volition with the energy of intention as being like the potential of a seed. You know, a seed can be a very small thing, and yet out of a seed, you know, can come a giant regulatory, this huge potential in a seed that we may not see in the moment, but as it germinates and matures. Not only does one fruit come from a seed, but each seed can produce many fruits.
So, this is the power of volition, the power that's driving our actions. So, what determines the particular karmic fruit of each of these volitional actions, whether it brings us happiness or suffering in our lives, whether it's sweet fruit or bitter fruit, is the motivation associated with the intention. So, the volition, intention, that's a neutral factor. It's just that gathering force in the mind is what gathers all the factors to accomplish a goal.
So, it's that intention which has the power, carries the power of karma. But what determines the result is what are the associated factors? What are the motivations associated with that intention? Of course, the famous opening verses of the Dhammapada, just expresses this so clearly to Buddha said, mind is the forerunner of all things.
All deeds are led by mind, created by mind. If one speaks or acts with an unwholesome or impure mind, suffering follows, like the wheel of the ox cart follows the hoof of the ox. Not a very contemporary image, but I think it's clear enough. The fruits of the act follow the act inexorably.
So, if we act with an unwholesome motivation in one way or another suffering follows. This mind is the forerunner of all things. All deeds are led by mind, created by mind. If one speaks or acts with a skillful mind with a pure mind, happiness follows, like one's shadow which never leaves.
So, how can we sort out? You know, what's wholesome, what's unwholesome? I have so much gratitude to the Buddha for sorting it all out. You know, when you just say it's hard enough just for us to watch our breath and you see someone who had such amazing depth and clarity of mind, he could look into the mind and actually sort out all of these different factors and what led to what?
It's quite amazing. Of course, we can test it for ourselves. The Buddha taught of how the three roots of all unwholesome actions are greed, or hatred or version, and are ignorance, delusion. So, we can know if those factors are in the mind in one form or another.
If we're acting out of greed, if we're acting out of aversion or hatred, if we're acting out of delusion or ignorance, suffering follows. And he pointed out that three wholesome roots are just the opposite, non-greed, which is generosity, non-hatred, which is non-ill will, or loving kindness, non-delusion, which is wisdom. If those are operating in the mind, we know that the results will bring us happiness. So, we clarify this to a marvelous extent for us.
In this teaching, we need to remember that it is the motive, the motivation, which is the determining factor for the result which follows. So, this is expressed in one teaching which I reflect on so often, and it just seems such a powerful, incisive reminder to us, where it says everything rests on the tip of motivation. But how often in our lives do we actually pay attention before we act to examining or investigating our motivation? Probably not that often.
Maybe we just get carried away in the momentum of our lives and our actions and our habit patterns. If we are contemplating this aggregate, Sankara, with respect to the power of intention, the power of volition and what it brings, so then it can inspire us to practice paying attention before we act, before we speak, before we get lost in some mind-drama, what is the motivation associated with it? Is it bringing happiness? Is it bringing suffering?
So, a question for us in meditation is how can we practice seeing and understanding this factor of volition of Jitna? It's not just going to buddhist philosophy. How do we actually experience intention? Can we train ourselves to see it, to be aware of it, to be mindful of it?
It's important that we practice becoming mindful of intention, not only because of its karmic potential, which is certainly reason enough, but also because we very often unknowingly identify with intention. We identify with volition. We have a sense of this because even as we become more mindful of all or many of the different mental factors that appear, now we can become mindful of a version or mindful of desire or mindful of being concentrated, and mindful of happiness of sadness of grief. So even as we can become mindful of them and begin to see their impermanence, their not self, their rise out of conditions, they pass away, still we can easily fall into the identification with the volition behind our actions, the felt sense that in the midst of all the actions and activities of our lives, it's that felt sense of, well, I'm the one willing all this.
I'm the one who's intending all this. And so intention can become a subtle hideout of self because we haven't particularly trained ourselves to notice the intention very precisely. So how can we practice this? You know, being on retreat in this environment provides a perfect place to refine our awareness of intention.
Although intention is a common factor, which means it's arising in every moment, it's not always the most predominant one. So in practicing becoming mindful of intention, we want to pick those situations where it's most obvious, but we don't have to go searching for it. You know, those very obvious situations. For example, we can begin practicing, noticing the intention before a change of posture, before we're reaching for something, before the body turns.
These are things that are clearly not happening of their own accord. The body by itself doesn't change posture. The body by itself doesn't reach for something. It doesn't turn.
It's so clear that there has to be something in the mind which is directing it to do these things. There's some energetic quality in the mind which is willing the action. So in these very obvious movements, we can begin to see it. We can see it in various ways.
We might get a forewarning of intention through being aware of a thought to do something. The thought may arise in the mind. Oh, I want to get that. I want to reach for that.
I want to go someplace. I want to do something. So the thought is telling us, kind of the forewarning, that an action is about to happen, and it can set us up then for pay an attention to the intention that actually moves us. So thought itself is not the volition, but it can alert us to the intentional action that may follow.
Okay, so we're in the setup zone. We know movement is going to happen. And then we're just watching. And if we're very careful in our observation, sometimes we begin to feel a kind of energetic, an energetic gathering or a welling up of energy that's going to initiate the movement.
It's just that gathering and the mental energy to move the arm to reach or to turn or to change posture. Sometimes we might not even feel anything so tangible. We might not feel that energetic welling in the mind. But we might simply be aware that there's a knowing we're about to do something.
When you're being mindful in a kind of series of actions, and if we're going slowly enough, so not just skipping over these powerful moments, we're moving along, moving along, and then there's a knowing, a silent knowing that we're about to reach, about to turn, about to move. So I often think of intention as the about to moment. Very helpful, at least at times, to be going slowly enough so that we can allow ourselves that moments pause before inaction so there can be an acknowledgement of about to move and then the movement. So much is revealed in that moment.
First we begin to see the cause and effect relationship between the mind and body. We said the body's not moving by itself, it's moving because of a mental intention. It also opens up the place of choice. If we can be aware of the about to moment before we actually move, then is a moment.
We can bring some wise discernment to that moment. Is this skillful? Is it not skillful? How often?
Not here, of course, but maybe at home. How often is just our hand in the refrigerator before we know how it even got there? It's probably not too aware of the about to moment. So it opens up a chance to make wise choices in our lives.
What's so interesting to observe is that intention of this volition is not only happening at the beginning of an action, but it's happening all the way through an action. An example is given as like an electric current running a motor at any time or light. At any time the electric current stops, the motor stops running. The light goes off.
It needs that continual flow of electricity to keep going. Every action we do needs the continual flow of intentions to keep it going. It's not only one that initiates it. And so you can play with it.
I've often had a lot of fun just in the simplicity of walking meditation and tuning in to volition to intention. And just noticing like even in mid step, what happens if the intention to keep moving stops? The foot stops and then kind of charge it up again. It is possible to have fun with this.
It's like just this this investigation of how this whole thing is working and especially this very amazing interconnection between the mind and body. And understanding what the mind is, what the body is, and how they work together. This is all the teaching of the five aggregates. It's really the Buddhist analysis of our subjective experience is saying, you know, if you look in this way, you'll begin to sort it all out.
Take time in your practice to be mindful of these moments of intention, these about two moments. You know, when the mind is quite still, you can sometimes even be aware of the intention to think. You know, mind is really quiet. It's somebody can feel the welling up of about to think.
And then the thought follows. And sometimes not. If you catch the intention, sometimes just about to. Take an investigative interest in this particular factor.
The Buddha highlighted it. I mean, in this fourth aggregate of Sankara, he's saying of all of the different mental factors, volition is the chief. So it's worth our interest to see how it's working. Because it's this volition which holds the power contains the power to bring about results.
And this has such amazing impact in our lives. I'm just struck by how little we reflect that what we experience now in our lives is the fruit of all of our many past volitions. And it's not happening accidentally and it's not happening without reason or without cause. And the Buddha said it's we are the heirs of our own actions.
But especially in our culture, we don't we haven't grown up with this understanding. We don't frame our experience usually in this way. The Buddha saying, this is important. This is a key piece in understanding how our lives unfold.
So we should really investigate this. And just as a reminder of the liberating power of the practice, knowing that volition each volitional action bears fruit, depending on the motivation, when mindfulness is present, when the mental factor of mindfulness is present in the volition. Mindfulness has the power to bring together to attract all the other wholesome factors. So in mindfulness is present, it's like a party of wholesome.
So every volitional action that we do with mindfulness just brings about all of the fruits of wholesome action to come mind at that time in every moment of mindfulness. Each of those volitions when we're being mindful, the mind is filled with whole array of wholesome factors. So there's a tremendous power in this case. So this is the fourth of the aggregates spoke a lot about it last week and now this week, particularly with regard to intention or volition.
The last of the five aggregates is consciousness in poly the term use is Vinyana. And this is the cognizing power of the mind. It's that function or that quality of the mind, which simply knows consciousness in the teachings is often designated by different types delineated, seeing consciousness hearing consciousness, smelling tasting, touching consciousness consciousness of mind objects. So this delineated according to what its object is, but the way consciousness functions in all of these different situations is just the same.
So the quality of consciousness, whether the object is a cider, sounder, smell or taster, the quality of consciousness is the same in each case. And again, it's this quality, we could say of bare knowing was simple knowing. So this has a powerful implication in our lives, namely that the characteristic of knowing does not change in different circumstances. No matter what we're experiencing, whether it's pleasant, whether it's unpleasant, the quality of knowing is exactly the same.
The consciousness may be colored by different mental factors at different times, colored by greed, colored by aversion, colored by wisdom, you know, by concentration. But the knowing faculty, just that particular characteristic of knowing functions in the same way, regardless of what it is that's arising. So in this sense, we could call it like a mirror like awareness. Now, the nature of a mirror is simply to reflect what comes in front of it.
And that nature of the mirror is not changed. It's not affected by what it is that is reflecting. Likewise, the quality of knowing is not altered by what it is that's being known. One of the most inspiring examples of this insight, and again, it has a powerful implication for us, you know, what this means.
One of the most inspiring examples for me of this insight is that of Henry David Thoreau. And many of you on other retreats may have heard this often. He died in his 40s, he was 44 I think, and he was dying of DB. He had an amazing wisdom, you know, never done it without any formal meditation practice, but maybe his time at Walden Pond was just sitting and looking, sitting and looking around the pond.
Anyway, this was written by a friend of his, you know, who was visiting him at the time of his dying. This friend wrote, Henry was never affected, never reached by his illness. Very often I've heard him tell his visitors that he enjoyed his existence as well as ever. I remember he's dying of DB, which is not a pleasant thing.
He remarked to me that there was as much comfort in perfect disease as in perfect health, the mind always conforming to the condition of the body. That's amazing. Could we say that there's as much comfort in perfect disease as in perfect health? Well, to the extent that we understand this mirror-like quality of knowing the consciousness simply knows it's not affected by what is being known.
The mind always conforms to the condition of the body. The mind simply knows there's a tremendous freedom in that. He said the thought of death could not begin to trouble him. So there's a tremendous wisdom and application of this insight in our lives.
In these teachings of the aggregates, the Buddha gives a special emphasis to understanding the impermanent, conditioned nature of consciousness. So this is really important. So just as an example, seeing consciousness arises when four causes are present. There needs to be the organ of the eye, in the working order.
There needs to be a visible object. There needs to be light. And there needs to be attention. And if any of these four causes are missing, seeing consciousness is not going to arise.
Consciousness arises out of conditions. And the Buddha emphasized the contingent nature of consciousness in response to a monk named Sati. And Sati had the view that there was just one consciousness that went from life to life. There was one consciousness throughout this life and went from life to life.
So this is a little dialogue the Buddha is having with Sati. It's the Buddha in his fearsome mode. So Sati was saying it is the same consciousness that runs and wanders through the round of rebirths. The Buddha then asks Sati, what is that consciousness?
And Sati replied, it is that which speaks and feels and experiences here and there, the results of good and bad actions. Sati saying, okay, it is that speaks and feels and experiences the result of good and bad actions. And then the Buddha said, misguided man. So whom have you ever known me to teach the Dhamma in that way?
Misguided man in many discourses, have I not stated consciousness to be dependently arisen, since without a condition there is no origination of consciousness. So this is pretty direct. But the Buddha is saying that consciousness itself is a conditioned phenomenon. It's impersonal arising out of course, arising out of conditions moment to moment.
So here we see that consciousness is not something that's permanent. It's not something that's always present, kind of waiting for an object to appear to be known. But rather consciousness itself is a process continually arising and passing away moment after moment. We don't often see this very clearly because of the rapidity with which it's arising and passing.
According to the Abhidhamma teachings, the lifespan of consciousness, which in the terminology is called a mind moment, is such that in the blink of an eye, there are billions of mind moments. I've always wondered how they have accounted. Five billion. But the point is that it's not one continuous or not one steady state.
The consciousness itself is a flow. So in Dicobody's book, Manuel of Abhidhamma, he writes so clearly. He said within the breadth of a mind moment, consciousness arises, performs its momentary function, and then dissolves, conditioning the next consciousness in immediate succession. The flow of consciousness continues uninterrupted, like the water in a stream.
And it's just such a clear image of the nature of our minds, the nature of knowing. So how can we begin to get a handle on this for ourselves? How can we begin to experience this directly? So it's not just what's said in the Abhidhamma.
There are different perspectives we can bring to our investigation of consciousness. One comes from the understanding that the more mindful we are of the arising object, the clearer the consciousness of it becomes, that the more mindful we are of the sensation of the sound, of the movement, of whatever the object is, the more mindful, the closer we are in the observation of it, that very process of closer and closer attention and mindfulness, that process refines the quality of consciousness. Just by this continuity of very careful mindfulness, the consciousness itself becomes very clear and very lucid. So that's one way of beginning to allow the experience of this clearer vivid knowing become very obvious to us.
There's another approach that I found really helpful, and I've mentioned to quite a few of you in interviews. Another way of investigating directly the nature of this knowing, and that is by reframing our experience in English, linguistically, in the passive voice. It's the language we use, whether voice or unvoiced, to describe experience, the language we use, very much conditions, how we experience things, the language is powerful. Usually, in our lives, our usual linguistic construction is the active voice.
I'm hearing, I'm seeing, I'm going, I'm thinking, I'm feeling. And so the very language we're using, again, whether it's spoken or not, is just reinforcing the subject, it's reinforcing the sense of self. Almost every time we speak or think, is reinforcing the sense of the witness, the observer behind experience, to whom it's happening. So a way of cutting through this, way of cutting through this subjective sense, is reframing the experience, linguistically putting it in the passive voice.
For example, a sound being known, a thought being known, a sensation being known. And it's not that we need to continually repeat this phrase in our mind, it's just using the phrase as a way of allowing us to drop into the experience from that perspective. This became very clear to me in walking meditation. And just doing the walking meditation, it's so obvious that the sensations that are appearing, the sensations are simply coming as a function of the movement.
You know, if you lift the foot, there are going to be certain sensations appearing, moving forward and placing. So to be in the walking, framing it in this way, you're just walking sensations appearing and being known. There's no one there doing anything. This passive voice construction takes the eye out of it.
There's no subject. Is this clear? It's very simple. This is not some esoteric, you know, meditative experience.
This is very simple. It's just, you're walking and it's just the sensations are appearing in space and being known. To remind oneself to frame it in that way. When you do, we realize some different things about the nature of consciousness.
It's very illuminating about the nature of this aggregate of knowing this thing that's so fundamental. One of the things we see is that the consciousness, the knowing, is arising simultaneously with the object. It's not a hairsbreath before. It's not a hairsbreath after the knowing is rising absolutely simultaneous together with the object, whether it's a sound, a sensation, a thought.
And we see that the consciousness is also arising spontaneously. When you're walking and just in that experience of the sensations being known, do you have to prompt the consciousness, the knowing to be there? No. It's happening just by itself.
You're walking, the sensations are appearing, they're being known, they're being known exactly vividly in the moment of their rising, absolutely simultaneous and completely spontaneous. So it becomes very effortless. We just settled back in this amazing experience moment. If the moment you can be in this flow throughout the whole day, does this flow of different experiences, different objects being known simultaneously?
So whether we're attending to each object of experience actively, sending the mind to the object, refining the consciousness through that kind of careful mindfulness, or we're attending to it passively in a way I just described, receiving each object, seeing how each object is being known, as the mind settles, practicing either of these ways or some combination, as the mind settles, for some sustained periods of time, this continued mindfulness and investigation lead us to different insights, different insight experiences about the nature of consciousness. So this is our direct exploration of the knowing mind. One of the insights is called purification of view. And at this experience, we are seeing each moment as a paired progression of knowing an object.
There's no one of a sight, no one of a sound, no one of a smell, no one of a taste, no one of sensations. Every moment of experience is a paired progression, knowing an object, knowing an object, knowing an object, knowing an object. And when we see this, we see that there is no one behind this paired progression to whom it is happening. It's not that there's an eye or a self lurking behind.
What we call eye or self is this paired progression, knowing an object arising and passing in each moment. We can really distinguish very clearly the difference between the number of between mentality and the physical material elements. So just as a rather strange example, highlighting this insight, imagine a corpse. And by some means, maybe you know, you move the arm of the corpse, or maybe you pump it with air in its chest, rises and then contracts.
Okay, clearly the physical movement is there. But it's in that corpse, as far as we know, is there any knowing of that movement? It doesn't look like it. You know, it's just the physical matter is there, but there is no knowing.
Yet when being alive is the movement of our arms, you know, or our chest, not only is that the physical movement as was in the corpse is something else. Well, knowing is that something else. And so we can begin to really see the difference between what's just material elements and what is the mind, what is consciousness. It's a very important understanding of this mind body process.
It's really the beginning of understanding selflessness that what we call self what we call I is simply this process of knowing an object arising and passing moment after moment. We want to be able to distinguish knowing from the object. It's two different things. They're different and distinct, but not separable.
So this is an important idea that something can be distinct, but inseparable. What does that mean? If you look at something, you can see both its color and its form. The color is in a form and the form has a color.
Form and color are inseparable. And yet they're two very different aspects. They're quite distinguishable. And we can easily understand the distinction.
Mind and object, knowing an object is like that you cannot separate them, but you can distinguish as clearly as you can distinguish a color and form of an object color and shake. As we continue the practice, you know, and our perception of impermanence becomes more and more refined. There are times when we can see the momentary dissolution of consciousness. We are really seeing the impermanence in the flow of moments of knowing.
We begin to see that the knowing we see this is direct experience, the consciousness itself is just dissolving, like water over a waterfall. And at this time it becomes so obvious that there is nothing to hold on to. Now there's no stability. There's no security.
And it's that always no place to take a stand. It's as if suddenly we're on the sands of a shifting slope. Nothing's lasting long enough to call I to call self. At this time, sometimes people get a bit discouraged because it feels like the meditation is going to pieces.
Things are dissolving both the object and the knowing is dissolving so quickly. It feels as if it's impossible to be mindful. The mindfulness is not landing in place and the mindfulness itself is dissolving. And so people often feel I can't meditate in the mindfulness.
I've lost it somehow. But actually it's a deepening of the practice, a deepening of seeing the fleeting momentary nature of the knowing itself. So if we can stay steady through that difficult time, we come to even deeper experiences of the nature of consciousness. And some of the some of the very great masters of the terravada tradition described from this mature place of insight, kind of this quality of the mind.
So I want to just read a few of these descriptions because it's so clear. One is from a time, Ajahn Jambhian, who's a wonderful monkey. He's still alive. He's visited the states.
He's a great practitioner of meta and just seems to reside in this open quality of awareness. He wrote, at some point the mind becomes so clear and balanced that whatever arises is seen and left untouched with no interference. One ceases to focus on any particular content and all is simply seen as mind and matter, an empty process arising and passing away of its own. The perfect balance of mind with no reactions.
There is no longer any doing. So our practice comes to this place, just through the development of the mindfulness and concentration and insight. There's no longer any doing, perfect balance of mind with no reactions. Then this is from Mahasicida describing in a little more detail, this place of equanimity.
He wrote, at times the number of different objects to note may shrink to one or two, or all objects may even disappear. However, at this time the knowing consciousness is still present. In this very clear open space, this very clear open space of the sky, there remains only one very clear blissful consciousness, which is very clear beyond comparison and very blissful. Yogis tend to take the light in this clear blissful consciousness.
This is known as Dhamma Raga, Dhamma Lust. At this time it has to be noted knowing, knowing, knowing, this is a critical point. In the mind the consciousness gets so clear and so refined that maybe all the other objects disappear, that's all that's left, is that open sky of the mind, the open blissful clear consciousness. It's important to be mindful of that, because it's so easy to become subtly identified with it.
Somebody today in an interview gave me this saying by the 12th century, John Mester, Taokhui. It's a wonderful line. As soon as there's something considered important, it becomes a nest. I just think how often we create these nests in our lives, and even in this very refined state of consciousness where we're experiencing, the openness and the bliss and the clarity of this consciousness.
If we latch onto that become identified with that, that becomes the nest. It's very easy to mistake refined states of consciousness for the mind released for the mind freed. One last teaching I want to read is from Ajahn Mahabua, who is still alive. He's one of the great Thai forest masters.
He's considered to be an Aand. He's been very in his writings. He's very acknowledging of his own process of becoming an Aand. He's just described his path and his experience all the way up to the highest.
He says something very profound here about how we need to relate to consciousness itself in this very refined state. He wrote, once when I went to practice at Wat-do-dham-ach-edi, the temple, the problem of unawareness, of ignorance, had me bewildered for quite some time. At that stage, the mind was so radiant that I came to marvel at its radiance. Everything of every sort which could make me marvel seemed to have gathered there in the mind.
To the point where I began to marvel at myself, why is it that my mind is so marvelous? Looking at the body, I couldn't see it at all. It was all space, empty. The mind was radiant in full force.
But luckily, as soon as I began to marvel at myself, to the point of exclaiming deludedly in the heart without being conscious of it, why has my mind come so far? At that moment, a statement of Dhamma spontaneously arose. This too, I hadn't anticipated. It suddenly appeared as if someone was speaking in the heart, although there was no one there speaking.
It simply appeared as a statement. If there is a point or a center of the knower anywhere, that is an agent of birth. That is what it said. If there is a point or a center of the knower anywhere, that is an agent of birth.
So this is a very critical point. As long as there is any identification at all with anything, even with consciousness, as long as there is any identification, we are creating that reference point of self. We are still bound by the conventional mind. So in our practice, through mindfulness, through investigation, through wisdom, we keep deconstructing the sense of self until only the genuine ease, the genuine freedom remains.
In our practice, we just are first refining our understanding of the nature of consciousness, the nature of knowing that it gets increasingly vivid and clear and refined and radiant. And in that itself becomes the object of our awareness, freeing ourselves from identification with that as well. So next week, I'd like to conclude this section on the Five Agriets, the section of the Satipana Sutta, of how we can use this framework of these five aggregates we've been discussing over these last weeks, of the material elements of feeling of perception, of volitional formations of consciousness, of how we can use this framework of the aggregates to actually come to the place of freedom. Because that's the point of all this.
Now the Buddha was not giving these teachings just as some philosophic understanding. All of the teachings are pointing to how we can free ourselves. This is a book by René Domal, a Frenchman, it's quite old now, it's called Mount Enelogance, a metaphor of the spiritual journey, claiming Mount Enelog. And he wrote in this book, keep your eye fixed on the path to the top, but don't forget to look right in front of you.
The last step depends on the first. Don't think you're there just because you see the summit. Watch your footing. Be sure of the next step.
But don't let that distract you from the highest goal. The first step depends on the last.