Skip to content
Ep. 263 – The Certainty of Direct Experience: Q&A + Guided Practice episode artwork

Jul 2, 2026 1 hr

Ep. 263 – The Certainty of Direct Experience: Q&A + Guided Practice

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

Touching into the selfless nature of experience, Joseph Goldstein explores uprooting the defilements through the clarity that comes from practice. Today's episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/insighthour and get on your way to being your best self. This time on Insight Hour, Joseph Goldstein provides his perspective on: Engaging with mindfulness The radical uprooting of self and identification with experience Seeing a glimpse of the deathless in our practice versus the transcendent moment of the unborn Slowly seeing clearly over time with dedicated practice The emptiness within the defilements Taking all things as an invitation to explore rather than to believe A brief guided meditation with Joseph Moving our mental dialogue into a passive voice This episode is the 3rd and final part of a 3-part series. It was originally published on Dharmaseed and recorded at the Barre Center for Buddhist Studies, a non-profit organization founded by renowned meditation teachers Joseph Goldstein and Sharon Salzberg to integrate Buddhist study and practice. To start at the beginning, check out Ep. 261 – Gradual Cultivation in Buddhist Practice. “If you put your hand in fire, do you know that it burns? Do you have any doubt about it? In the genuine experience of things being uprooted, there is that quality of certainty. It is very different than what you were saying about ‘Yeah, it looks to me that the defilements are uprooted.’ The experience that results in the uprooting, which is the experience of the unborn. It has that same immediacy and certainty as putting your hand in fire and knowing it burns.” –Joseph Goldstein

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 263 – The Certainty of Direct Experience: Q&A + Guided Practice

0:00 1:00:05
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com.

We thought now we'd spend maybe about 40 minutes in conversation and we'd begin by offering our distinguished teachers an opportunity to say something, to quiz you, to engage in Dharma Combat if we wish, whatever it might be. So who would like to be sitting? And I think William's going to run the mic for us. So is anyone with any of you have any thoughts, comments?

Sure. I really love Joseph. I have something to say because I just said this to Joseph. It was very inspiring and illuminating the way you described with some precision moments that came to you, unexpected as they do.

And it's just lovely to hear. And I appreciate very much the granularity, the precision with which you describe these things. I feel that that's something we, it's good to learn as a practitioner, that that is very liberating to see the pixels and not get lost in the hole. And in that way, as you suggested, to actually get the wholeness that also includes oneself.

And so yes, it was very inspiring. We share a love, I think several of us are Chinul. I was telling Joseph I taught with Robert Boswell decades ago into Stanford and learned about Chinul then. And he has really stayed in my heart since then.

Yeah. I also really appreciate the way you are showing different echelons, different dimensions of the path that can look very different. Indeed, zokchan could look very different. It's very shocking to be a sutra practitioner, even in the Mahayana, for a long time.

And then here, oh, you know, you have a moment of break by. And that's the realization of emptiness. And we're taught, no, that takes three countless eons. Don't get ahead of yourself, you know.

So these have been kind of colons and riddles for me for a long time. And I think it's worth reflecting on how that could possibly be. And either way, if you get stuck on either notion as being the only option, you're definitely going to be in trouble because the world of awakening is way more wide than that. I feel you have suggested that.

I really appreciate it. And also my first time to hear a talk by Joseph Boswell. Thank you. Thank you.

Yes, Guagu. Thank you so much, Joseph. Of course, I appreciate your talk. But I appreciate more your selfless presence, your humility.

So thank you. There are several points that I want to touch on since we're on Chino. Chino got it from me. So when this Chinese master, 8th century, she elaborated.

He was both a Chan master and a Hawaiian master. So he elaborated on these different variations of sudden gradual practice, sudden awakening, sudden awakening, gradual practice, gradual practice, gradual awakening. The different calibers are being. And so is that they like to hear you cite Chino.

Some of the other points. In the Chan tradition, the glimpse of no self awakening, it's not the uprooting of the identification of the self. It's way down the preliminary stages. So I think the terminology, a lot of people use these terms.

There's more to explore in that. And for the scene one's self nature, which is none other than selfless state. Even though the language maybe phrased as the nature of the nature of the nation itself. For the Chan tradition, the person may be in that state a glimpse, maybe in it for days, weeks, months.

And it's important that the practice is definitely not finished, definitely. And it's important to continue the practice because at that point, it becomes very clear when self is present. Once a person has the experience of no self, it becomes very clear what selfing is. It's like sometimes I use the analogy, it's like cleaning windows.

A person can polish the windows, so it's spick and span. Even birds may not know the windows there, fly right through it. But the difference between window and having no window at all, it's completely different. It's like night and day.

So any subtle reification, selfing, the four or four ways of identifying with experience, it's like a thorn, a polka. Of course, depending on the depth of the experience, if a person has shadow experience, then it's possible to take the window as a thing. But for a person who has, I'm going to just use the word experience, even though that's problematic, no window for them to fall back and start taking windows and taking spick and span. It's just a student, silly.

And that transition, that shifting, the person needs to experience this again and again and again. Not in a seeking way, in a natural way. And there are methods in the challenge tradition to cultivate this because cultivation continues. Most of the challenge teachings brings one from the person from the scattered state, to a concentrated, from a concentrated to a unified, unified to get initial breakthrough.

But there are approaches to continuous after that post awakening. And it's like, in a way you have shared so intimately, these moments in unpredictability are unanticipated. Sometimes a person was slipping through it. Sometimes it's like a breakthrough.

And sometimes even in dream, or in slipping through it. Because the fact of the windowness and no window at all is so radically different. So that these differences is readily apparent. Another thing about the Madhimanika I, the Sittata you mentioned, a quick way that the challenge tradition identified those fourfold problematic ways that we relate to, experience, relate to everything.

The shortcut approach to the problem, identifying the problem is self-consciousness. Self-consciousness, it's like the raw, fundamental expression of grasping. And a lot of people, and this was in your about mindfulness. And I feel this is a point that we can also explore.

Because most people can't distinguish between mindfulness and self-consciousness. In other words, they take whatever object or meditation, the fourth one, as mine. So they're washing themselves, washing decisions, washing themselves, walking, washing themselves. Or they're a bystander, the third one.

Apart from it, some kind of witnessing this, all of that, is just self-consciousness. So, and same with the first two, which is the subtle form of identification, within the midst of it. They're just subtle form. The first two are so, the latter two are kind of coarse.

So this may be something that we all can go into a little bit to clarify what is the popular term mindfulness, how does one actually engage in it. So the Chan approach is one of the Chan approaches, not allowing practitioners to have anything to abide, to hold onto, to objectify. Because that's our tendency. We make everything into a thing.

And once we make it into a thing, we're through. That's why we wanted to early, one long, or more, I don't know. I don't know which one to put that says, once you experience the thing, or if you experience, if you experience the object of your meditation, I forget what with the object that he said. If you experience it, that's not mindfulness.

This is very radical. I think most people may not notice, because I'm supposed to experience my breath when I walk. But he says, when you experience it, that's not mindfulness. You're already off, that's not it.

So that's like, what he's saying is again, this facet of self-consciousness, making everything into a thing. So the Chan approach one way is to engage in what I call the practice of wonderment, which is nothing. It's a question. It's a genuine particular feeling tone.

And the feeling tone is grounded in the sense of not knowing. But you can't use your thinking mind. You can't redefine into a thing. Because that's making it into a thing.

So he's just left in this non-conceptual state. Yet, we call. Receptive. That is one way to answer your question.

I'd just like to respond to just a clarifying point that you highlighted, which is that the description of that experience that I mentioned at the end, that is not what I was referring to as the uprooting of the view of self, because that uprooting function was not about what I described. Rather, the uprooting function happens in the experience of the unborn. And the experience of the unborn is very different than what I was describing as glimpses of a mind free of I am. So it was very clear that that was not the unborn or any demonic experience, because it's that one, which just as you said, that's the radical uprooting.

And interestingly enough, I'm glad you brought it up. One of the examples I've used in my teaching is the difference between a clear window and no window. So that distinction is critical. And it's the experience of the unborn, which is the no window.

And so what I was describing at the end was a different experience than that. So I just wanted to clarify the two different levels. Could you mind if I just ask, can you clarify that exactly? In other words, how does that experience of the no I am relate to the experience of the unborn?

Is it a step toward it in some sense? No. Are they only unrelated? Should I stop asking questions?

No, I'm trying to find the right frame for the response. So that moment of the unborn of that experience, so that's the first glimpse of Nibana in the understanding of it in early Buddhism. So that is the radical break. I think that's what you're referring to.

Yeah, everything is different from that point because we've gone beyond this whole mind-body process. And so that view of self, it just doesn't make any sense at all. When it's experienced something beyond that, namely, the unborn non-manifest non-occurring. Or that's the powerful moment.

But as I said, and we all know, there are many defilements which still remain, including the conceit I am. So what I was describing at the end was more a deeper dive into that. But that's very different than that moment of uprooting. And the conceit I am, the reason it was so momentary, you know, short period, is because that level of experience did not uproot conceit.

Because that level was not going beyond. It was still all of this, but seen free of the free of the I aming. But it's still that was not a transcendent experience. That was like a deeper understanding of this.

Whereas the moment of the unborn, that's transcendent. Beyond this. That's beyond this. And that's why it's so powerful and has that uprooting function.

And that is the difference between having the mind really still and clear and current. Well, that's the clean window. And no window at all. Did that mention?

So I just wanted to comment a little bit, and start first of all by saying, just if I really, really appreciate your talk. This is maybe the third talk that I've heard of yours. And I resonated so much with much of what you said. And I appreciate also the sense of humor that you brought to it and introspection and intimacy.

But to John's question, maybe this. So the constructed phenomenon is what is being seen as experience. So when we want to see that clearly as clean window, then those are the Bahia moments of the observer merges with the phenomenon, or that's what it feels like, actually, as more like observer falls off. And the mere knowing is the thing.

There's no separation between subject and object. And there's no one observing object. That's a conventional way that we talk about in early Buddhism. We do talk about subject and object.

That's a conventional way that can fall away very clearly. And that is still looking, though, at constructed phenomenon. But the constructed phenomenon, no matter how clear the window is, is ceasing. Is ceasing.

Ceasing entirely. Ceasing entirely. And I really, y'all will see that my talk tomorrow is going to dovetail very nicely, which I just have said. But just to say, the connection is that by our ability to, with precision, even allowing is too much, but be present for the cessation of one experience, without picking up the next experience, then there is where the, which is the way it's calling the unborn or the non-constructed, the non-experience, is apparent.

And then another moment of experience then takes that as the object or takes that. And then that's where we see very, very different understandings of how, what happened there or what's described or how was it known. But it is for that reason, for the reason of cessation, that by studying the self, then we can know what is the non-self, what is the unpoint. And I wanted to say, I also just separate leading on from that, or perhaps moving on a little bit from that, was I really appreciate how you spoke about mana and seeing mana and knowing mana as, also, mere experience, mere phenomena, right?

Phenomenal rolling on, as we like to say. Right? And it reminded me a bit of a framework that I like to share. With folks, and if all things go as planned, I will be back here in January, actually, to teach about this.

And sometimes I call it three layer cake, but actually it's more like three facets of the jewel or three different forms of investigation of any particular kind of experience. One being the content, when we talk about taints or tendencies or wholesome and unwholesome, qualities and so on, there's the content view, super important, without actually doing that part of the work, that's called spiritual bypassing. Right? So that's a very, very important aspect of the work.

But then there's another perspective, potentially, on any given experience, which is this process perspective that the Vibaga gets is really talking about, right? That contact happens and it spins off certain aspects of mind that we can't observe and responses reactions to that and so on. And yet another, and that is one way of kind of arriving at that more dry-eyed view of, right, even, deluded thought is just that, is just that process unfolding, moment after moment after moment. And then the third view, which is one that the Vibaga brings up here specifically at the Knight of His Enlightenment, which is the specific conditionality, right, kind of getting even more deeper into what can be known as present.

So to the question of, is there really a self, my answer would be, well, is there really a mirage or is there really a shadow? Right? Go find out. Have a look.

There is such a phenomenon. And yet it is a mirage. That's what really like the, it's real, but not really real. Yes.

That's what I think that's what you're pointing to. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

I wanted to respond to John, your question. The difference between a glimpse versus the unborn, the deathless from the John perspective, it's not that they're wholly separate. It's more like different shades, different gradations. So it's like getting a few drops of water in your mouth.

Did you taste? Well, but did that have any transformative effect? Pretty much not. In fact, the person can turn around, take that experience as a thing and be very proud of this.

Now it becomes another object attachment, but the water or the wetness is in line or you can say in accordance. So the issue is beyond these glimpses to be in their experience and actually engage in the complexity of life. Those were one sees the functioning of the wisdom for self-resfunction, which is compassion. So that's why the practice needs to continue again and again so that these experiences, well, it's like the analogy I have is like, it's like a piece of paper, you poke a hole through it.

Is there a hole? Yeah, there's a hole. But basically you can use the paper to write, you can do anything with the paper. It's still pretty much intact.

Versus, you start to poke it with a finger where you just shred the paper, right? So that paper becomes useless now. But these little holes, keep on poking. Keep on poking.

So it would be kind of the litmus test would be the transformation in relation to, in behavior, I guess, behavior in relation to greed and aversion. Thank you very much both of you. Anything else on your side before we open it up to the audience? You're good.

Okay. I do have one question, but I want to turn it to the audience and see what you all have and if there's time I'll ask my question. Anyone have a question they want to ask? Or comment.

Or comment, yes, I should say. Comment, correction. Advantishments? No, I'm sorry.

No, let's welcome. Yeah, so as I've been listening, okay, so for me, I've been practicing in the Tarovade tradition and you know, reading the little booklet and now listening to the different viewpoints, there's an understanding of the difference of the basically, let's say, two traditions, but experientially, like I found myself listening to Gogugas now, nodding, yes, yes. And so experientially, they do not feel separate. You know, it's like the self view dropping away and then those flashes of nothing.

I mean, just, you know, it feels like what's been described as the obscuration disappearing. You know, it's like the seeing gets clearer, clearer, clearer, clearer. The obscurations disappear. There's no separation.

So it feels very much like what, you know, from what's described in the other traditions, that unity and no separation and just function. And with that though, it's connected again to if, you know, looking into that, there's no clinging because who would cling and what would they cling to? And so it's like, you know, I'm finding that experiences that sound like what's described over here are totally connected with what's described over here. And what ultimately, you know, the gradual cultivation is that the more clear-seeing, the more dropping away of separation, the dissipation of desire and aversion.

And then it's, you know, love, kindness, compassion, that's it. And so, yeah, I'm kind of like, because you've mentioned several times that these differences are really important. And so, yeah, I'm just kind of wondering about that. And yeah, about, yeah, just wondering about, you know, how to practice with that sense of are they really different?

I mean, I know they are. I mean, it's for this. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Are they really different?

Yeah, ultimately. Are they really really different? It's all like, it's all passing experience anyway, you know? So, yeah, I'm not sure if that was clear.

So I think the bottom line, I'll take a stab at this. Tell me if I'm misrepresenting the later traditions. But it seems to me the bottom line of any practice is, have that the fileman's been uprooted or not. And it doesn't matter the technique or the method.

If that's the result, then it's serving the purpose of coming to the end of suffering. Because, you know, when the Buddha was asked what he taught very often, his response was really simple. He teaches suffering and the end of suffering. So that's what all our practice is about.

You know, ending suffering in ourselves and helping others with that. What is the cause of suffering in our lives? It's the defilements in the mind. I think there are different approaches and different methods.

One is, well, I think they all share, seeing that the defilements themselves are empty of self. But that's seeing that is still not uprooting them. And so that's why I say, whatever method, whether it's a Zen or Tabetna, that seems to me the critical point. And I think the only thing I would add is something that's already come up, which is, I mean, I think I can even say from personal experience, one can fool oneself about what one has realized.

In some ways, the touchstone is also, have things actually changed. Especially my behavior. I can even fool myself about having fewer cliches. Like, oh, I've got fewer observations.

I'm less angry, whatever, less attached. And then someone touched me off and trafficked. I'm like, you know, so I do feel like that's the touchstone is also that. And as you said, in life out there, if that behavior hasn't changed, then all the talk about removing defilements is just talk.

Yes. Don't agree with that. I think probably if we can go to essence, maybe two questions, maybe one. We want to leave time for a practice here.

So is there another question or comments? Thoughts? I'm not sure who was up, either James or... So the Buddha spoke of suffering and the end of suffering.

I find myself wondering if there is actually an endgame. You describe the subtler and subtler levels of attachment, right, to all these different domains. Who's to say that even the cattle in strong herd, that power across the fjord, who's to say that a day or so later, Mana is not going to show up in that person or persons. And then if one actually abruts all the defilements, how does one know?

And what's the measure? It seems a little bit qualitative to me, so I'm wondering about that. Okay, so I'd like to ask you a question. If you put your hand in fire, do you know that it burns?

Sure. Do you have any doubt about it? None. In the genuine experience of things being uprooted, there is that quality of certainty.

And it's very different than what you were saying about. Yeah, it looks to me like the defilements are uprooted. And I don't see them there anymore. That's on a whole different level.

That's just on a personal perception of how our mind might be. The experience that results in the uprooting of the defilements, which is the experience of nibana or the unborn or whatever word you like, it has that same immediacy and certainty as putting your hand in fire and knowing it burns. And that's why one of the defilements that is uprooted at that first glimpse in addition to uprooting the view of self is doubt. Because it's exactly like that you know from experience the zero center.

That's very different than having different experiences and then just interpreting them or cleaning today. Yeah. So again, I would just suggest two things. One, don't believe me.

And two, as we continue our practice and each of us has different levels of these kind of experiences, then we know for ourselves. We know whether it's like putting your hand in fire or not because you've just had the experience. Yeah, so it's not a question of taking any of what's said. Take it as an invitation to explore, not to believe.

And I think that's really important. You know that we find out for ourselves the meaning and implications and experience of these various experiences. E, push your, come see. So I think we had, in order to leave enough time, should we do one more question or I think the meditation needs a little intro.

Okay, so let's do that. So let's transition now. Thank you very much. Thanks to everyone for their comments and our teachers also.

And we'll move to a practice now. Okay, so this is a meditation that I actually have not taught quite in this way before. So you were all the guinea pigs. And you can let me know afterwards how it goes.

You may remember it in the booklet I described it briefly how the language we use to describe things in very much conditions, how we experience things. And so the language that we usually use describing our experience in the world is in the active voice. Right? I'm hearing a sound.

A subject, verb, object. So this is our usual grammatical framework for how we language our experience. What I found to be extremely interesting and freeing in the meditation to reframe the experience, the language of it in the passive voice. So for example, instead of unknowing a sound, a sound being known, a thought being known, a sensation being known.

And just in this grammatical construction, the eye has disappeared. The eye is no longer the subject. And so when we frame our experience to ourselves in this way, I found it's a very, very simple and immediate way of touching into the selfless nature of experience. It's very immediate.

And if I could go out on a limb in this way of experience, which is really a way of practicing that bahi a sutta in the scene, just the scene. I heard just the herd. Not I'm seeing, I'm hearing, I'm thinking. A sound being known, a thought being known, a sensation being known, no one there, things are known immediately, exactly, precisely, not a moment before, not a moment after.

And going out on a limb, this might be one way of experiencing what later traditions call the non-dual. Right? So this is what I'd like to have us do in the meditation. So I'll guide it a little bit.

So just keep in mind, the general frame is holding the question silently, although I'll guide it a little bit, in any moment what's being known. Just what's being known, moment after moment. There's nothing to do. Everything is arising by itself.

There's nothing to do, not interfering in any way. It's just letting phenomena unfold. In moment after moment, what is it that's being known? Does this sound clear to you?

Okay, let's just try and see what it's like. So it's settled into just a meditative posture. And at first just open to sounds being known. Nothing to do.

Sounds are appearing by themselves and being known spontaneously. It's really relaxing to it. It's completely relaxing and open. It's just the sound is being known.

No one doing anything. It's like listening to music, not interfering, not manipulating. It's all happening by itself. And then begin to be aware of the sensations of the breath being known in exactly the same way sounds are being known.

Really relax into the natural flow of the breath, let it come and go just as it is. Don't try to manipulate or change or pull the next one in. Very relaxed, very open. The sensations of the breath are appearing spontaneously in the same way that sounds were appearing.

And allow for the breath to unfold in whatever way it does. Trust that your body knows how to breathe. Be aware of sounds being known now. Sensations of the breath being known.

And no one is doing anything. Watch out for trying to do something. It's all happening by itself. And if you notice a kind of trying or a little bit of efforting, then it's simply trying being known or efforting being known.

It's completely simple. Maybe other sensations in the body are appearing and being known. So may be unpleasant, unpleasant. Simply let them be known.

It's all happening by itself. Be aware of the tendency sometimes to pull the next in breath in after an out breath. You kind of are initiating it or pulling it. And that's just the self getting involved.

The breath will come and go in its own time in its own way. And it's simply sensations being known. In the flow of phenomena, thoughts or images may appear. Simply a thought being known or an image being known or an emotion being known.

And you can let the mind become very open and choiceless and just sitting with what's being known moment after moment without any directing towards anything in particular with just settle back moment after moment what's being known. And if you feel like you're losing that sense of relaxation and go back to simply being aware of sounds being known, that's so easy. And in the last few minutes, consider this co-one known by what? Is there anything you can find?

Things are clearly being known but known by what? There's nothing to find. And the not finding is the finding, the empty nature of knowing. There's nothing to find and still the knowing is happening.

No one there doing anything. Sound being known. Anticipation of lunch being known.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 1 hour and 0 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on July 2, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.