Skip to content
Ep217: Greg Saunier (Deerhoof) episode artwork

Dec 29, 2020 2 hr 18 min

Ep217: Greg Saunier (Deerhoof)

from Conan Neutron's Protonic Reversal Hosted by Conan Neutron

Conan Neutron's Protonic Reversal

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

The mighty Greg Saunier of Deerhoof returns to Protonic Reversal! It has been over a year, and last time was pre-pandemic, uprising and election. Wow! Since we barely got through the first couple records last time with all the talk of San Francisco... this talk includes Defund the Police, and policing those that SAY Defund the Police, as well as all of the world events since then. It also gets us through the Chris Cohen era of Deerhoof and (almost all of) the 2000s. Many finea tales, including DAVID BOWIE, Thom Yorke slam dancing and putting together samples in the most torturous and labor intensive way possible. Work/life balance. All that. A DEEP DIVE into Reveille, Apple O, Milk Man, Green Cosmos, Runners Four and a little bit about Friend Opportunity. Whew! Part three will be a lot sooner than the gap between part 1 and part 2. Promise!

Ready to play

Ep217: Greg Saunier (Deerhoof)

0:00 2:18:23
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I imagine all life as you know it's stopping you instantaneously and every molecule in your body exploding at the speed of light. Total Protonic Reversal. Protonic Reversal. Protonic Reversal. With your host, Cumin Neutron. Broadcasting from a secret underground lair in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. A gigantic middle finger doing everything that is rock about music, rock and roll, and program power. The thing is, though, if you don't laugh, you're going to go on a killing screen shop and nail it. Confidence. But a hero or a fool doesn't make a certain wish. It may not be more professional. It's all in one. I just do. Don't mind I do.

That's like a science thing, right? Indeed. Indeed. Indeed it is. It is a science thing. It is a science thing. It is a science place. It is a scientific fact that we are all up in your face. It is time for the one, the only, Protonic Reversal. Welcome to it. Welcome to it, everyone. Tonight's guest, Greg Sonier from Deerhoof, as a part two for a part one that happened.

So long ago, it actually seems like it was in a different world in some ways. Yeah, so that's something that is happening. Thanks, of course, to all the Thrasher Peace Theater folks. Always great times. You can bang yo head if needed. Of course, this show is called Protonicoversal. Protonicoversal.com for the archives. And yeah, this is a thing that we do. We talk to people, and we use the royal we, apparently. This is the whole situation. So I'm really excited to talk to Greg. Dear Herb's a very interesting band. They're very cool. They follow their own...

North Star, if you will, as well as, you know, making really great music, really interesting. It's a great idiosyncratic, cool, interesting drummer, and a very, you know, a sweetheart of a guy, and real, real thoughtful. We got into a lot of stuff last time, as what tends to happen with this show is you get, you know, people from the Bay Area, you're going to talk about the Bay Area, how things used to be, how things are different now. And, but, you know, we also talked a lot about, we talked a lot about other things, and so we're going to, you know, there's going to be more of that. We're going to talk a lot about Dear Earth Music. I realize, in retrospect, we didn't get that far into the

Discography of the Media Year of. So we kind of spent a lot of time in the early days. And I think we're going to get more into that now. So, yeah, some housekeeping. There's been some, not been a ton of episodes lately. Not as much as I've kind of been doing. That's largely due to, you know, just life concerns, things along those lines. But I always appreciate everyone listening, tuning in. Lots of great, great, great, great, great, great, great feedback on the Lucifer Fab episode, Sid Butler. And, you know, it's something where...

Sometimes I've got more time than others. That's really what it comes down to. So, if you've missed it, sorry. If you haven't, not sorry. So, yeah, anyway. Tonight is Greg Saunders. I'm excited about this. This should be good. Is there anything else to say? The ACDC special was good, clean fun. Good, clean American fun. That should be heading out soon to the free feeds. Oh, yeah, patreon.com slash Britonicoversial. If you want to get these episodes sooner, if you are looking for a specific episode and you're like, hey, it's not my thing that does this stuff, that's why. It's...

in that and uh patreon.com dollar a month will get you there helps support the show pay the bills all that good stuff anyway uh we're just gonna get right down to it i'm looking to uh looking to see what's on greg's mind interesting dude and uh There's just been so much that's happened. There's been so much that's happened. Greg, welcome, welcome. So I was just thinking about how much stuff that has happened since you were on. Like, it's a different world almost. You mean since we did the test 10 minutes ago? Well, no, no, but I mean, not that much has changed since then, yeah. It's been a busy 10 minutes for me. 10 minutes seems like 10 years now. No, but last time we talked, I just looked. It was October of 2019. So that was pre-pandemic. That was pre-uprising. That was, again, I'm going to harken back and say it was a different world.

It's crazy to think that how much stuff has has changed just since then. I mean, yeah, you know, maybe maybe maybe you could maybe one could faintly glimpse the outlines of some of these possibilities, you know, but but it's true. They've come to pass. Yeah, I mean, it's certainly, you know, black folks being killed indiscriminately by police officers and large scale economic. But we didn't know that.

one particular murder would, you know, it would stimulate the largest mass movement in American history. You know, didn't expect that to happen. And that to me is maybe one of the, I mean, that's maybe the biggest news since we talked last time was that large of a popular uprising. But it's, I don't know how you felt. But and I'm not really sure how everyone's feeling and everyone may be feeling differently, but I'm feeling in a very weird zone about it right now where I've noticed like maybe just in the past week or so that It's a bit like it seems like it's no longer OK to post on social media, defund the police. However, it is OK to comment on someone's post saying you shouldn't have said that in your post. Now, in the comment, they say, of course, I'm for defunding the police, but you shouldn't have put that on social media, which, by the way, I just did in this comment. And there's this funny zone right now where.

There seems to be a new mass movement. It's not as powerful as the one from the summer, but there's a new mass movement shaming people for posting that they support defunding the police change, but then also. Kind of in parentheses saying, of course, they also support the police, but we shouldn't be allowed to say that aloud because it's not it's not popular enough. And therefore, and even, you know, I was watching this. It was Noam Chomsky's birthday a couple of days ago. And I watched this really neat, you know, it was from really recently, just a Zoom call that some college students had done with him.

And it's like, you know, so much truth is stated so plainly in the interview. But when it comes to that question, at least to me, it becomes his point of view becomes confusing. He's saying, well, of course, that's not going to be a popular point of view, defund the police or abolish the police. And so therefore, to say it. is to give a gift to the right wing. But then I'm thinking to myself, yeah, but is anarchism a popular mainstream point of view?

You know, defunding. I mean, the number of stances that he's taken in his 92 years that were not mainstream left me just on that one point scratching my head a bit. Like, why? I mean, why was it OK to have a dissenting opinion that was not likely to come true anytime soon on all these other issues? But for some reason, on that one, it was considered bad form, in his opinion, to to state it aloud. And so I still feel a bit confused because of how much right now I many.

of the voices that i trust are not agreeing with each other i guess you know so i feel a little lost about what to do what's what's what is helpful to say and what's harmful to say aloud yeah so with along those lines so if the right wing had done it they call it police reform right that's what they want to call it and because they just excel at the framing of language in a way that makes the terms uh favorable to them and that is something where if you stop and think about what that means, what does police reform mean? You can accomplish the same goals as defund the police. Defund the police is more aggressive language.

I guess, yeah. To some people. But I have noticed what you've talked about, that it's a meta conversation. And it comes back to the thing of like, oh, well, we don't, you know, I was all fine and dandy until everybody started writing. And it's like, well, you didn't like the kneeling. So, you know, I mean, guess what? Like the kneeling wasn't so bad, was it? And it's a kind of ridiculous sort of weasel language, I think, as far as that goes. Ooh, weasel words. I learned about weasel words on our Wikipedia page. Wonderful. Because it was flagged for being filled with weasel words.

That's amazing. So I think it's interesting when we talk about like language we weaponize and also the idea of, you know, we kind of touched upon briefly, you know, the Dear Herb social media presence, like it's you advocate for the things that you advocate for. You put out information and there's opinion. You're not trying to fly 50,000 feet above the sky and pretend you're in some aloof ivory tower and not part of the world. And I think that's interesting because it seems like some artists are still attempting to do that as if they're like in some parallel universe where these things are not happening. Maybe it's more like...

I mean, I know I've felt this way sometimes, where if you're making music or any art format, feeling a little nervous to be either too topical, which can make your music dated, and you wouldn't want it to get dated because you've been raised with the goal or the ideal that your music is better if it... outlasts you you know and that if it's posthumously respected you know and so it feels a little um too unambitious to write a song on a current event topic because you know it's going to be out of date but and sometimes also you know maybe one can feel that you you is related like oh i want to address timeless concerns you know in in our whatever we do and so i don't want it to be too wrapped up in 2020 you know um and so i can understand you know someone wanting their art or their

you know, whatever it is they're projecting to the world to feel, if not aloof, I mean, at least kind of angelic, you know, and kind of, yeah, sort of a floating orb or a crystalline orb floating, you know, untouched by the soap opera of human foibles, you know. Yeah, I mean, I think that's actually very relatable, and I think that's a good statement for art being art. Because, I mean, granted, there's some artists like Billy Bragg or something along those lines that melds the two pretty seamlessly. But I don't think the requirement should be explicitly and directly writing songs about what's happening. But I guess what I'm more talking about is using the band platform to communicate with your fans in such a way that you have a deep connection about the things that are happening in the world that are beyond the fact that they're a fan of the music of Deerhoof and you guys' art. There's probably going to be an affinity for other things. And I feel like some artists and bands...

shy away from that maybe if not for commercial concerns then just to sort of uh deny again the the i am also a human being that lives in the world and sees the same thing that you do i mean when we started maybe this is what we talked about in the last episode i think that when you have started in 94 that is that was kind of our vibe we were very shy and we didn't really know too many people in san francisco um I think we, you know, we were secretive, like, you know, a bit like magicians, you know, who didn't want to, you know, reveal our tricks or whatever. And, you know, we sort of coveted seeming mysterious or whatever. But, yeah, I mean, that has been one of the joys over the years is I mean, particularly when you go on tour, that isn't really so possible anymore, especially if you're doing your own merch table. I mean, you get in conversations with people. And that's one of the things I'm missing most right now, you know, is just meeting people at the merch table.

Because that's where it's like, you kind of can't really pretend to be aloof at all. You're just a person, you know, trying to sell some, some discs, you know, or some t-shirts. To get some gas in the van, get down the road. And as a prop making entity, there's certainly many things you could do that would probably make more money. But the idea that you get to have this. Yeah, but it also just became, it started to become more appealing to, to be a person, you know, and to have the band be.

um made up of people um with distinct personalities and and you know we started opening up to like doing more um collaborations with other people so you know john will do a record with his friend raven or i'll make some record for for um you know um my friend valethizer or you know this kind of thing um We became more like individual people instead of some, you know, mysterious, you know, group filled with anonymous. Yeah, yeah. I mean, and as much as, you know, I adore David Bowie. David Bowie is David Bowie because he's David Bowie. And he conducted himself the way he conducted himself. It involved an era of mystery and kind of, you know, presenting personas and characters that were parts of his personality. But there's no kind of... Did I ever tell you about feeding David Bowie? If you did, I don't remember. That would be astounding because that sounds wonderful. Yeah, please tell me. Because one year...

in new york they had something called the highline festival and he was uh appointed guest curator and he i guess had seen us play just regular club shows in new york um two or three times although we'd never met him um but we'd hear about it you know like i think i saw david bowie up in the balcony or you know this kind of thing but then he he invited us on his festival and so you know we were there at the show um And, you know, maybe it was before the show started and suddenly he shows up backstage and we're all chatting and he has learned all our names. He knows all of our names and introduces himself and says, hi, Satomi, you know, I'm David, et cetera.

And he had just come straight from another show at another venue that was also part of the Highline Festival that he curated. And it was, I forget what, New Music Ensemble, but they were playing. There was a composer called Conlon Nancaro, who during the era of the Spanish Civil War, pre-World War II, had gone to Spain and volunteered or something, and then ended up exiling himself to Mexico and divorced from all of his, you know, new music community that performed whatever he was writing. He started writing instead for the player piano. So he composed on piano rolls, you know, where you just...

you cut out holes in paper, you know, and then that's when the player piano will hit a note. And it has no dynamics at all. It's all just like banging on the piano. But one of the things that he realized he was able to do, obviously, incredibly easily on piano rolls that human performers can basically not do at all is do... hyper irrational um rhythms so it would be 14 against 17 but taking place in one second or something like that super bizarre complicated cross rhythms um and then he he sort of um you know became a kind of legend and his music uh for player piano became legendary over the years and you know he just had these home recordings of it um they got released on lps and and it became uh legendary but no one could ever perform it and finally um i suppose you know uh classical performance had become insane enough that some people started to think they might be able to pull off the 14 against 17, you know. And so somebody started making arrangements for chamber ensemble of these player piano pieces. And David Bowie had just arrived to our backstage from such a show, which was a live performance of some chamber music by Conlon Nantero, you know, arranged for live humans to play. And I'm telling you, it was like...

I don't know whether he was maybe in his 60s at the time, you know, exactly how old he was, but it was like talking to a college freshman. You know, the level of excitement that he was just exuding in the room, having seen this Conlon Nankaro thing, was really so charming. And I get your point about how, you know, he's the eternal man of mystery and chameleon-like and always changing his image. But the fact is, in person... What a nut, and so friendly, so charming. A fan of music, it sounds like. A real fan of music, a true fan of music. It wasn't just a way to make some bread for him. He was excited because Ken Nordean was going to be the next show that was coming. He was showing up and down in a couple days. This word jazz guy from maybe the early 60s.

I'm trying to think of where I know Ken Ordine from, but I'm very familiar. He was famous for doing those, he has one album that was called Colors, and he had this like personality voice. And so there'd be like jazz music in the background. He'd be like, you know, or whatever. Yeah, totally. And David Bowie was so excited that he was going to get to meet Ken Ordine. And I was just like, wow. And yeah, it was just an unforgettable, you know, sort of 10 or 15 minute experience that I had, you know, that we all had that we got to share. That's pretty cool, man.

I mean, that's, well, and it's to a certain degree, like with David Bowie also, there's, you know, like he would put on the performance and he would like go be David Bowie, but he's also a guy that is clearly interested in art and interested in music and things like that. It's so neat to kind of see that window into that first, I mean, that's gotta be a surreal situation. Yeah, yeah, he was dressed up in a suit. His hair was perfect. I mean, it was surreal because it's like you expect to see you know, a certain level of heightened beauty on an album cover or in an MTV video. But then when he's standing right in front of you and he's that beautiful, it felt surreal.

Yeah, he's much, much missed. Much like you're experiencing with me right now. You know, here's my actual voice. I mean, just the amount of beauty that's pouring out of my throat right now. It is beautiful. I'm glad to be talking to you again. Because I realized last time we spent so much time talking about old San Francisco and things along those lines, we didn't really get that far into the discography. I think the last thing we talked about was like Half Bird. Which one? Was Half Bird. Which is still like, you know, early times. That's like almost close to 20 years ago, right? That's like 19 years ago? It's early times, yeah.

uh so can we would you mind going through let's go through some of the records It's Reveille, that's how you say it, right? That's how you say the word? I say Reveille. Reveille? Okay, is it Reveille? Yeah, but that's sort of the, you know, that's the American English pronunciation of what the bugle blasts first thing in the morning. Yeah. I wasn't going to actually do it, you know. Yes. That's why this show is the show, Greg. That's exactly what melody we're referring to. That's Reveille, yeah. When you mentioned the record Reveille. They're like, oh, Reveille, you know, they have their own way of saying it. But at that point, that's John.

And Chris does have some extra guitar in there. No, Chris has not joined yet. Oh, okay. A guy called Chris Cooper who played on one song called Cooper. But that was Chris Cooper who used to be in Carolina. That's referring back to our last episode. That's right. Chris was not in the band. Although he joined before it was out. We had...

Pretty much, we'd recorded everything, but we hadn't finished the mix. So he was treated in the car, and we'd go on tour, and the record wasn't officially done yet. He'd be treated to endless variations of rough mixes, like, oh, we need to turn down the snare drum in this song, or, oh, we should cut that song or change the song order. And he was like, what are you guys talking about? This sounds fine. And then we'd be on the next tour, and we will have added 10 more overdubs to everything. And he's like, you guys are crazy. Just leave it how it was. It sounded fine. And I think that that ended up.

I think that the first album that we did with him, his point of view there was, you know, in response to the obsessive, you know, kind of overdubbing on Reveille. He kind of guided us to do something that was just plain, you know, and live. So, like, with Reveille, the problem was we had recorded some of the songs. We were basically kind of stealing really short times in a couple different recording studios. One was the now defunct, what's it called, the one tiny telephone. And then of course the one at Mills College where we just engineered it ourselves. But what we ended up with on these really quick recording sessions was we had to bounce it down at the end of the session. So we didn't have anything to mix. We just had a really, really bad stereo rough mix of like drums and guitar and bass.

And then for like two years afterwards, we're like, this sounds terrible. This sounds terrible. We can't afford to go to another studio and we have no way to remix it. So let's just find some way to mess with it. You know, we edit out this part and, you know, paste in some drum samples on this part when the drums get too quiet and then overdub a guitar in this part or add some key, you know, and it just, it went on and, you know, whatever. I mean, just the way things can when you discover, you know, computer recording or computer mixing. And it just was a,

I mean, yeah, I think a lot of And sanity was was feels like it was was lost in that process. You know, I mean, I guess I guess I could say that about all of them. I mean, we're so happy about how they turn out. And then that's when we say, OK, it's done. You know, let's let's try and put it out ASAP. But, you know, the process leading up to it always felt, you know, a bit. I don't know. We just just felt like we didn't know we were doing, you know, and stuff sounded really bad to us. And we we didn't know how to fix it and we didn't have help.

So we were teaching ourselves, like, okay, what does an equalizer do? What does a compressor do? Learning the tools with it. Yeah, learning the tools the hard way, all trial and error, which, you know, is great. I mean, I wouldn't trade it in, I think, but it was also like, you know, sometimes I, if I have regrets in my life, I sometimes think back to my 20s and how much of them were spent.

figuring out what an equalizer was instead of doing fun things, you know? Yeah, like learning this technology that was to achieve the end of doing something. something cool and accomplishing something, but spending so much time and effort on it. Yeah, it was always exciting and human. But yeah, the recording part of it just always seemed to take too long, the mixing part. It goes faster now, and I'm really happy about it. Yeah, I mean, I think Reveille is sort of like where the dividing line of, you know, for lack of a better term, where you, you know, not got weird necessarily, but like where the recording process became more...

involved in the music like I think the earlier records are just kind of more straightforward like you know not exactly it but here's a band playing in a room here's what the songs sound like and then that's kind of where it seemed like you know you get a glimpse of what was gonna come on the next couple records where you're just like well why don't we try easy for you to say I couldn't get it yeah I guess looking back historically now right because if you got like on Reveille you have like that I mean most of the songs are pretty short but there's not that eight minute one but that's the thing they just kept getting chopped down you know they were all long and we just like well that part the mix didn't work or somebody hit a bad note you know we got it we couldn't remix it so we just had to either find a way to cover it up or or or just edit it out. I mean, the songs got so short. That's another thing, obviously, that happens when you spend a long time reworking something. You know, it's not uncommon for it to just keep getting shortened and shortened and shortened until the song's so short, you know, it's a minute long. Yeah.

So that's interesting that it was basically like a utilitarian arrangement thing. It felt like desperation. I don't know if I feel the same vibe about making music now that we felt then. I think it was really insular and it was silly. Actually, it's still silly. That hasn't changed. But it was sort of self-absorbed, I guess. I think that one thing that hasn't changed on any of the records was that...

I think there was the feeling that this is probably going to be the last one or this could easily be the last one for any number of reasons. You know, the band could break up or the label drops us or, you know, or you just can't stand it anymore. You don't like doing it. Like it's just feels like too, the result isn't worth the trouble, you know? Like it's cool. Like we're definitely glad when something is done and we love how it sounds, but you sort of question like, was it really worth, you know, like sometimes arguing with each other or, you know, or like, like.

Or your computer would crash and you'd lose files or, you know, or just, you know, or just the sort of comparing your song to another song that you love. I mean, I remember on Reveille, it was around the time of Amnesiac. And that was the first Radiohead record that I think... It was definitely the first one I'd ever heard. I was not a fan and hadn't ever listened to them before that one. And that was the one. And somehow, you know, I went to, I don't know, whatever it was, Tower Records or something. And heard it at a listening station and thought it was cool. And so we bought it. So I was just kind of A-B-ing everything we were doing on Reveille with Amnesiac. And I'm like, well, why isn't our song as loud as theirs? Why does it not have as much emotion? Why does the guitar sound so terrible in comparison to their guitar? Right, right, right. You've got a standard for this thing that you're...

I know, but it's really it's like it's not really the most healthy process, you know, to feel like you're competing. You know, regardless of the fact whether the what you feel like you're competing with is so much more funded and supported in every way than what you're doing, you know, sitting there in your bedroom or whatever. But but even not counting that, just just that kind of. I don't know, the process of spending years comparing oneself to someone else, I think does some kind of some kind of inner damage, you know, that that is really not necessary. You know, I'm glad people like Reveille or any other record, but I do feel that that process is not necessary. And that's something that I've that's dawned on me over the years is that, wait, you know, I can let go of that.

feeling of trying to outdo you know whatever was the top thing you know that year or out trying to outdo anybody even just outdo the other band on the bill you know like especially you know thinking about 2020 you know and comparing comparing it to 2000 you know the the difference of of mindset i just i would not at all recommend And it doesn't matter because I'm not sure anybody's doing it anyway. I would not recommend approaching music the way Deerhoof did in 2000, in 2020. I think that communities and supportiveness and backing each other up and letting people be who they are and not having to make everything a battle of the bands and struggle for survival. Just being in a band is a battle. But I mean, it doesn't need to be and it shouldn't be. But there are, of course, forces.

in 2020 that are stronger now than they ever were that are that force the issue and make it a struggle for survival um it's not just the music industry i mean it's our whole society i mean any if you live in a country that gave up on gave up on um avoiding the you know pandemic you you know that you're in a society society that has left you for dead but what do you do therefore do you do you is it do you is the way that you will survive that you simply win against everyone else or is the way that you survive um that you band together in some way and you accept um you accept the differences between people or you know um thinking in terms of music then in terms of music artists and musicians just accept their differences and not not have to funnel it into this um competition for who's going to get on the label or who's going to get more plays you know on streaming or whatever i just feel that that competitive approach seems more

like a disgusting relic of the past now than it ever has you know and something that the that if humans hope to continue to have civilization on planet earth they're going to have to let go of so much of of what seemed absolutely life and death essential um you know um in our own past and i know that i felt that way when we were making reveille it was like oh wait we have to make this you know this is make or break you know like rob fisk and kelly good quit the band i can't even keep the band together um john dietrich has joined but this is like now or never you know, make or break every cliche, you know, of like, we better do this or else, you know, curtains. And so, yeah, that mindset was like, I don't know, I just felt like it sort of took its toll, even though we were happy with how the music sounded in the end. Well, it's funny you mentioned curtains, because I was going to ask. Yeah, and then I joined Chris Cohen. When he joined Dear Hope, I joined curtains on keyboard, and that was really fun. Which happened first? Was it kind of at the same time? I think it was simultaneous, yeah. I can't really remember.

And we all practiced in the same practice space, too. And Curtains was rehearsing. If Chris and I showed up first and the drummer, who was Jamie Peterson at the time, was late, then there was another band that nobody knows about. There was me playing Chris's guitar through Chris's amp and Chris on Jamie's drums. Oh, wow.

which was, we only had one song because Jamie wasn't ever that late. The song was called Brown Sugar. We were a Rolling Stones tribute band. I was Keith and Chris was Charlie. And we were the best Rolling Stones tribute band I have ever had. We had no vocals. It was only one guitar and one drummer. But still, it was like carbon copy. Like I could do Keith so perfectly. And his guitar through his Ampeg amp, I mean, it sounded exactly like Brown Sugar. And then he plays drums exactly like Charlie Watts. Nobody says that, but, you know.

Obviously, when you listen to the Chris Cohen records that have come out, the three Chris Cohen records. You get a feel for that. Yeah, for sure. You get a feel for that. You can hear that Charlie Watts is very much his biggest influence on his timing and his way of doing fills and the way he records it and mixes it and everything. And it's just the best, you know. So then can you speak a little bit to the songs on Apollo then and how those came together with having Chris? Yeah, well, I mean, once we joined the band, we just started writing them. And it was a really super creative.

time period i mean i guess there hasn't really been an uncreative time period but i just remember you know john was still somewhat new and there were still song ideas of his that he'd written before reveille that for whatever reason we weren't able to record or we played them so badly on the recording that they got axed and so and then chris joins and chris is just writing songs a mile a minute and i mean one of the first ones that i remember writing after chris joined was um I seem to remember the same day we were in John Dietrich's living room in West Oakland. And the same day we made up Panda, which was Satomi made up the Panda part and Chris Cohen made up the intro. And we just put them together and it was like it worked like magic. And then Satomi made up a different song called Flower. And then that got combined with something, the B part was something John had laying around. And we just suddenly turned that into a song, like all in like the space of like half an hour. We had two songs, you know.

on Apollo that we ended up playing, you know, we still play them. I mean, you know, and just, you know, it was just really, really, really fun. And, and we, we decided to record it fast. You know, we had about, we realized we had enough songs and we, we were going to go into a studio in Menlo park and our friend Jay Palicci was going to record us overnight. Yeah, exactly. He was going to record us in the middle of the night.

when the studio you know it wasn't booked and just do it um we weren't going to pay um he was going to sneak us in there and uh and so you know it was all done in one night um except for the two songs at the end um and just you know everything played live vocals were done later but all the instruments were live it was incredible again i mean as much joy as there could be in the process of writing songs and and touring on it later and everything it's like the actual recording process was so stressful i mean i just i just remember how you know I don't know how to explain it. I mean, I guess anytime you're doing a band, it's going to be a bit like this. And you know from experience that, you know, if you're on no budget, it's not like you can come back into the studio tomorrow and maybe somebody's in a better mood or somebody's a little more inspired or whatever. No, we have to nail it right now and move on to the next song. So we're so uptight with each other, trying to get everything perfect, you know? I mean, for us, perfect wasn't...

precise it was more like we wanted to have everything sound like some really exciting take that had some magical you know some magical moment happened that was just spontaneous and that we didn't predict you know and we were trying to get you know performance of every song that had something really magic like that happen in the middle of it you know we're all listening to each other playing and reacting to each other and you know like Yeah, we really had a lot of fun reacting to each other. I think we had some really nice chemistry. But it's hard. Well, whatever. We had difficulty under pressure. I wouldn't say that we choked under pressure, but I would say it was hard to...

take chances you know we wanted it sound like we were taking chances and having fun and of course it's hard to sound like when you're having it's hard to sound like you're having fun when you're not having that much fun and you're like biting your nails and like yeah you have an imaginary clock in your head counting down yeah it wasn't imaginary it was a big clock in the studio I think it sounded really, I mean, it was so cool to record in a studio. And then we got, for the first time ever, separate files that we could mix and, you know, spend the next year mixing it at home. And, you know, didn't have to, like, mix it that night or whatever. We could spend some time. And that was like your, what, like your fifth album? I mean, technically? I guess so. I don't know. It depends how you count it. You count it. And that's, like, the first one you basically got to mix.

the way you want to do well yeah i mean you mix the four track records there are two of the early records were on four track and we we had plenty of time to mix them um you know years to mix them on four track but these this was a nicer recording because it was from a studio and that was just i don't know i don't know if it's nicer it was just different it wasn't something that we'd ever done so it was a new experience like get a high fidelity recording um or whatever, what's considered a high-fidelity recording, very clean, and then be able to figure it out at home. And then we recorded all the vocals at home. We lived on a noisy street in the Tenderloin, so there's a lot of traffic noise, fire engines away in the background of the tracks that you can hear sometimes if you listen really closely.

And if I'm remembering right, I think the track order is slightly different on the record versus the digital, right? I think it's different again. Well, there wasn't a record, actually. It was CD only, but then a reissue was done only a few years ago. Oh, is that what it is? Okay. It changed the order a little bit. Because I remember I was listening to it and I was like, I thought this was later in the record. Wow. You're a super fan. I like that record. I think that's one of my favorite records of you guys. So I've listened to it quite a bit. But then I thought it was like one of those Berenstain Bears things, you know, where they, are you familiar with this concept? No. Oh, there's, oh.

No, no, I'm not. So there's this cartoon family of bears, a series of books called the Berenstain Bears. I mean, that I remember, but what's the concept? Well, the idea is that like some people swear up and down that the spelling, they remember it differently. And this is like a parallel universe theory thing. Like it's sort of a, it's a questioning what you see metaphor. No, I understand now. Yeah. And it's, it's actually, the websites on it are frankly incredible. If you ever just want to break from conspiracy theories that are terrible and awful and mundane.

We were, you know, we played once at CERN, you know, the Large Hadron Collider in Switzerland, a very odd gig. There's a physicist who works there who was a longtime Dierhoff fan, and he's like, we've got to get you to come play here inside the premises, you know, in some of the different rooms that we have where we store the super cooling, you know, things and the other machines and just, you know, really bizarre. But once we played there, you know, the Large Hadron Collider. has associated with it a lot of conspiracy theories that proliferate online where people assume that it's a satanic attempt to cause a black hole where there once was a planet called Earth. And once we played there, we became a topic of the conspiracy theories. And when I read, when I started reading how all of the different reasons that that Deerhoof is satanic, I found myself convinced. I mean, it was a Berenstain Bears thing where

a member of the target was actually kind of like, wow, you know, this is actually pretty convincing, you know, plethora of evidence here. They present a strong argument. Some strong arguments. Yeah, maybe we are satanic. So, yeah, every album we've done since then has been, you know, to hail Satan. Well, yeah, of course, clearly. Wow, holy moly. That's a lot to unpack there. Well, they did it. They unpacked it. There's also the theory that when the Higgs boson...

was found that the act of doing it actually created a parallel world. And some people, of course... You're further up on this than I am, even. I'm also kind of a nerd about physics. How can you be a nerd on this many things, Conan? Man, follow your bliss. All right, let's follow your bliss on to the next question. Yeah, hey, hey, hey. All right, so Apollo, and it's a well-received record. Yeah, yeah, actually it was. I think that was the hype. I mean, in their own ways, I think all of them, every...

that we've done has been surprisingly well received you know far beyond my expectations but that was one where um we got good online reviews and year-end lists and stuff and where that it was also a different era where that fact seemed to directly translate into more people coming to the show you know or more people buying a record yeah you know where i think i could be wrong but sometimes it feels like now it's a little bit more complicated it's a little bit more diffuse and just because you get a good review in fact i would say right now a good review means almost nothing you know and in those days for whatever reason at least in the realm whatever realm we inhabited you know maybe it was indie rock or noise or you know whatever it was we were trying to do underground music um it seemed like reviews counted for a lot then they were trusted more they were read more widely um and uh whatever i don't know so so we did well with the critics for a couple years and that was i mean we still do do well with a lot of critics but yeah that early 2000s time period there was like that moment where it kind of seemed like that's you know like a well there was well there's almost a return to that like lesser bengsian style uh form of writing as well yeah where the writing is more important than the record right yeah and but then by the same token people would find out about you know for lack of you know more idiosyncratic or unique bands that didn't sound like other things in a way that really

On a larger level, it wasn't as large as the early 90s or anything along those lines, but in a way that was like, oh, that's cool. There's people finding out about this kind of music from all over. To me, it was less about whether it was idiosyncratic. To me, what it was was it was a good time, in terms of whatever critics, it was a good time if you were a band that... had subtexts you know it did context that did concept albums or that had hidden meaning in the lyrics or that that was you know that seemed to give the impression that there was more than meets the eye you know and i think that was something that we were always really into you know with other records that we loved or with movies or whatever you know just hidden meaning or multi-layered or you know you could you could sort of like i mean you know, like if I was listening to Amnesiac, you know, you know, during a couple of those years, it's like you can sort of map those lyrics onto, well, is he talking about a romantic relationship or is he talking about his band or is it more political? You know, it's kind of like this, like a fairy tale that seems to, to be both evocative, but also general enough that it applies to many life circumstances. And that was something that we were always like fancied ourselves as trying to do. I mean, we still do, you know, that we like.

the kind of uh yeah whatever that like a record that might sound different to you when you listen to it again you know you hear different things or you interpret it a different way the second time or the third time or that at least that it rewards listening to it again and that's the kind of thing that's like you know sort of like tailor-made for music critics you know so it was like it was just a lucky coincidence that at the time that music criticism was at a kind of peak that they happened to discover us who was trying to do music that appealed to that kind of thinking or that kind of interpretation. That kind of attentive listening and repeat listening in a lot of cases. Exactly. So I just think we got incredibly lucky, you know. It's just pure coincidence. So then talk to me about the, between Apollo and Milkman, because Milkman's a concept record. What about Milkman? Yeah, I mean, it's, well, say it again. So isn't Milkman a concept record? Because you mentioned concept records. Oh, I mean, to me, all Deerhoff records are concept records.

Call me crazy. No, no, no. Worse than that, I'll call you desocratic, which I consider a compliment, by the way. Well, and I only bring it up because it's sort of like, okay, that's a very eye-catching cover, right? I mean, you guys always have very interesting covers, but the... Yeah, our roommates. Our roommates in San Francisco were living in San Francisco for a year or two from Tokyo. It was Satomi's middle school friend, you know, her childhood friend had married or whatever, you know, was...

romantically involved with a visual artist called Ken. And, you know, like he lived with us and, you know, he was our great friend and, you know, we were always joking with each other and, and, um, he was hearing Dierhoff constantly and we were seeing his art all the time. He's really, really funny person, really serious, uh, silly. And, um, you know, just always making dirty jokes and just, uh, just everything was sort of the grotesque and crude, um, you know, with him and his art was so funny. And, uh, so.

You know, at some point, like, why don't you do the next album cover? And then we realized, why don't we have the album cover first and then make the record? Gotcha. Okay, cool. So it's almost like when you have a title and then you figure out the song. Exactly. So I don't know if that makes it more of a concept record. I mean, I don't, to me, like, they're all kind of concept records if you want to think of them that way. Sure. That they're all grouped around the theme and stuff. But this is just one where we happen to have a character first thing, you know. Well, there's in the liner notes, there's kind of like, you know, stuff about that guy. And, you know, like, it's sort of, I guess it depends on what the listener. What are you talking about? Like the, well, isn't there some kind of like a...

I don't remember. Well, I mean, there's, I'm trying to write, I actually don't know that one. It's been years. Maybe I'm projecting, you know what? I'm Berenstain Bears in it. I'm remembering liner notes that did not exist. Yeah, you're remembering a triple gatefold, you know, MTV music video campaign. But that's also, so that's, and that's a, I think that's a really interesting, cool record also. That's also the first time there's like the electronic drums and kind of almost like synthy stuff going on there. Was that something where, was that a conscious choice or was it more like, hey, let's try this?

We didn't have electronic drums. When we were in Tiny Telephone recording a couple of the songs on Reveille, they had an ancient drum machine called the Rhythm Ace that had really cool sounds. You know, it's a coveted sound. And so we recorded. the sound of the bass drum you couldn't get individual sounds on it but you could play some of the rhythm patterns you play the merengue or whatever bossa nova really slow you know turn the speed all the way down and sometimes you'd get an isolated bass drum or an isolated tom or an isolated snare and so we recorded that so that we would have it and then for years afterwards we just used those that rhythm ace bass drum and that rhythm a snare drum and that rhythm ace tom tom sound just pasting them in to your recording program to just create a drum beat or whatever. We didn't have drums. We were just pasting in these rhythm-based sounds. Oh, wow. Okay. There's a song called Eyebrite Bugler on Reveille that is those sounds pasted into a little drum beat. And then there's one or two on Milkman for sure. I think at the beginning of Deciper SRA starts with those blips, you know, with those rhythm-based sounds. But those are just pasted in, you know.

But, you know, John really liked electronic music or computer music, I should say. And so when he joined the band, he would sort of create. textures I guess would be a good word for it sometimes that ended up getting used on songs on Reveille and on Milkman that definitely we had nothing that sounded anything like that before he joined the band and so that was fun you know he could like layer things there's a lot of keyboard Milkman. A lot of it was constructed in the computer. We did record ourselves one session where we recorded some of the songs with live drums and live guitars and stuff. But a lot of it is pasting.

pasting drums from samples pasting bass from sampled bass notes off of some record you know and the songs are sort of put together um and even the i remember the drums we recorded you know maybe after we've done apolo and it's like oh it's really easy to record drums you know those drums sounded fine so we can record our own now and so we got back into diy recording and then of course recorded them and everything sounded horrible and like and just like and so you know it became that's where we started getting into the um you know another time waster which was you know, here's the drum performance recorded with three microphones or two microphones or something. It doesn't sound good. What can we do? Well, I'll take this drum hit off of a Queen record or I'll take this drum hit off of a, you know.

I don't know, you know, something recorded by Steve Albini or something, you know, it sounded really like big and powerful. And then paste, you know, sit there and paste. Every time I hit the snare, I'd paste in this drum, I'd line it up, you know, whatever. I mean, it's a waste a year of your life. Like I said, it's like when the record was all done and it sounded, you know, to our ears, like really slick and really fancy and sort of everything in its place and kind of...

almost garish you know like um with all the keyboards and and you know it sounds like there's orchestras and it does have a big sound it's like it's just it's just the result of pasting stuff um i had a really funny experience um this year actually um one of the things that We did first on that or that that we attempted first on milkman was Via computer pasting on adding trumpet parts to our songs So there's a song called milking that has quite a bit of trumpet on it And you know, we didn't know anyone who played trumpet or we're too shy to ask anyone even if we did or we thought it would be too expensive So we thought as a cost-cutting measure we would sample trumpet off of a record and, you know, use, you know, a bit of this note and a bit of that note and some pitch shifting and some fudging and finessing to try and make it sound like, you know, a trumpet player was playing the trumpet part that we had in my specific melody, but they're definitely not playing on their record. But, you know, with enough samples and fudging and stuff. And it was really hard to find a record that had trumpet solo. Yeah, drums or other things. It was nothing, nothing, just trumpet, isolated trumpet notes. And what we found was.

What we used was a duet record of Anthony Braxton on saxophone and Wadatta Leo Smith on trumpet. And they both played in such a way, Wadatta especially. It's very known for playing in such a way that he leaves an incredible amount of space. Right. Records recorded in this incredibly dry, you know, it's not a concert hall. They didn't add reverb. You know, it's just like this totally dead sounding room or studio or whatever. And they play this incredibly minimal music. So there's lots of chance to find isolated trumpet notes. So that's how I constructed that. That was the first time. And for years afterwards, I kept using Wadatta.

trumpet samples to construct trumpet parts for records. And then later in life, we performed with Wadada Leo Smith in concert. And in 2020, our live record came out this past summer that we put out to benefit Black Lives Matter. And it's on Bandcamp. And we did an interview much like this one.

you know for some online interview or whatever after the record came out and two years after we had played the show together so we were kind of reuniting conversation and I hadn't even had a chance to tell him the night of the show because it was you know frantic and you know we're playing a show you know I finally got to tell him you know how we've been using his trumpet samples for years to construct our trumpet parts or whatever and it was so funny to reveal it so many years after the fact but yeah what was his reaction to it did he kind of get what you did oh you know like his reaction to everything just you know uh such cool um kind of like nothing surprises him laugh and uh he would you know just be he's like ready for anything i mean that that person has has taught us and you know for those familiar with his music or who've ever had a chance to work with him you know as a student or a performer in one of his groups or whatever so much about how music can be a practice for not just music but a practice for being a life form on the planet you know and how to accept whatever comes when you're playing music that involves you know people doing something other than just playing their part you know and there's room for the spontaneous then being ready for anything.

And that's one of the reasons. that it was such a treat to play with him and what ended up coming out on this live record this year. He even deliberately showed up late and missed soundcheck in order to prevent him knowing what we were going to play. He didn't know our songs at all. So walk on stage in the right mindset and Deerhoof starts playing their songs. Much of the audience knows Deerhoof songs. Deerhoof knows Deerhoof songs.

Wadada has never heard them in his life. And he starts playing in a way that's so powerful and so expert and so kind of commanding that Dierhoff must adjust on the spot. So he's rewriting the song on the spot and forcing us, you know, he has that presence that says we're slowing down now. Now we're going to get quiet. Now we're changing to this feel. And the four of us, you know, John, Ed, Satomi, and me,

suddenly hearing our own song fresh for the first time and playing them in some way totally unlike we had ever played them before you know and how exciting that was that he had taught us something about ourselves about our own music you know and how profound you know of an experience you know so grateful it was just another it was another really lucky and unexpected case of meeting a musical hero you know kind of like the Bowie thing it just you never expect it you never dream it and and he did that really cool record with Henry Kaiser that was like the Miles Davis Exactly. I forget what it was called. Yo Miles, that's what it was. Yeah, yeah. I mean, that was a band that he had for years. Yeah. Maybe he still does. I don't know. Yeah, that's awesome. I like how he's just kind of nonplussed about you taking his stuff and forensically reassembling it.

that was milkman that was green cosmos too that was the next thing that we put out as kind of a mini album it was like maybe 25 minutes long or something not quite a full album but um you know that one we recorded with eli cruz over in oakland that new improve right yeah yeah yeah but still even that you know even that again recorded like in one afternoon or something really fast and kind of like ah like these sounds need some help you know and just spending so much time pasting in samples pasting in I mean, I think Green Cosmos is where we hit the climax of that, of pasting in samples.

And just the sort of tedious. Now, a lot with, you know, and maybe even then, but we just couldn't afford it or didn't know about it. But it's definitely much easier now. Like, now there's a program. Yeah, exactly. You just press a button and you've replaced your drum sound with any drum sound you can afford. There's a workflow and like what you did in a year, you could, you know, do in like five minutes. But that's just it, Conan. I have to say.

It wouldn't quite be the same. No, absolutely not. No. They would quote unquote on paper do something basically the same thing, which is replace drums or add samples to drums, you know, or add a lower octave to the bass or, you know, whatever kind of stuff, or, you know, pull down some menu of like a percussion loop in the background that you can play along with. But, but there's something for better or worse, you know, there was a quality.

that results from having to do it in a sort of handmade style and one sample at a time and like lining up the waveforms so that they're in phase and, you know, oh, maybe not on this one hit. This one hit sounds cool without the sample and making a separate decision on every single hit, you know, kind of stuff. And it was just like, yeah, I don't know. So, you know, if I heard Green Cosmos now, I think that a lot of what I hear, like it sounds very glitzy and fun and layered, but it also sounds... you know, I don't know, it was like a tedious, time-consuming labor of love, you know, process. Well, I'm thinking of that, there's, I can't remember the song right now, but there's a Queen record where to emulate the sound of an orchestra, they recorded a single guitar note just an absurd amount of times because they had, you know, all the time in the world to record a record and they could just do that. I mean, he overdubbed single note guitar stuff on tons of songs. But yeah, but if you listen to it, it actually, it sounds like an orchestra, but it sounds...

different because obviously that's it that's a crazy way to do that why don't you just get an orchestra right but yeah he's got that infinite sustain yeah yeah compressed guitar so he can sort of hold a note maybe feeding back and so like a string player or something you can sort of hold a note infinitely um and then just and then he had that obviously that very eccentric kind of tone you know that that had a lot of a lot of sizzle to it yeah it's kind of like a bow across a string you know and so when it when it's just holding infinitely you can imagine it sounding a bit like a cello or something and and then you just like overdub you know a whole bunch of those so that you get um I mean, my record was always with the news of the world. I think that was my first LP actually when I was a child. That was my very first record. When I was a kid, the album cover used to scare me. Which I think it's awesome now. And, you know, it's just kind of like I couldn't for the life of me understand. Like I heard We Will Rock You and We Are the Champions on the radio, which was at least where I lived, was always played as a...

twofer yeah which is so bizarre you know is like you played the single which meant you played both sides of the single it was wild you know and i loved it so much and had the record and um i think my babysitter gave me the record actually they didn't want it anymore and uh I couldn't for life of me figure out why a band that made such great music, one, would do such an ugly cover or just a horrific sort of intentionally disgusting. But it was gory and bloody and the band is dead on it. It scared the hell out of me when I was a kid. Exactly. Why would they do that? And then the other thing I couldn't understand is why they would do a song called Sheer Heart Attack, which comes right after We Are the Champion. So it's the next song. I'm listening to bopping along to my two favorite songs as a kid and then this song.

that I just despised. It was like fast. It sounds like a rock and roll by Led Zeppelin, but it's kind of like a little bit punk rock, you know, maybe just right before punk rock became a big thing. You know, really up tempo, super fast. It's kind of like, you know, almost just one A chord through the whole song, you know, really distorted guitars. And it just seems so rude.

I just couldn't, as a kid, I could not figure out why they would do this. And I remember my mom had some whiteout. And for a little while I was obsessed with whiteout. I thought it was so cool that I could erase something that I typed on the typewriter with whiteout. And I actually took the LP and I whited out the song. I hated it so much, I wanted it to disappear from existence so radically that I whited out the song. I was attempting to delete it from the LP. And of course, as these things do in life.

And music is always a great case of how this can happen, where the song that you hate the most at first becomes the song that you love the most later. And of course, Your Heart Attack is one of my absolute favorite songs in the universe now. And a real deer hoof model, you know, for like how to make stuff sound. And like I said, you know, many an hour was spent pasting in Roger Taylor, you know, Queen snare drum sounds into deer hoof songs to make it sound more like Queen, you know. you know there's there's one hit there's one place on that record it's in get down make love where there's a drum fill that happens without anyone playing where he just hits the snare drum and then the band comes crashing in and so that's the perfect place to grab a single snare hit and that one queen snare hit i mean i can't tell you how many dear songs have had their snare drum beefed up by that by that one hit of roger you know that one swing his arm has like been years of

of zero content, you know. Well, if you ever run into him, you've got a great icebreaker. He knows it. I mean, he knows how many bands have been influenced. I'm sure. I mean, that's not going to mean a thing to him, you know. But I think it's fascinating that, you know, I think the way that you assembled that record and the way that you kind of painstakingly went in, no by note, hit by hit even, as labor-intensive as it is, it makes it a very unique sounding record.

Like, it's a record that... Thank you. You know, first of all, it's good. So, I mean, we'll start there. But, like, it's unique. Like, just based on the method of... I guess you would call it production. But it's just... Yeah. You can barely call it production. There was another aspect. In Milkman and... And the EP... EP Green Cosmos. I'm sitting here telling you... I'm telling you how much it was all about layer after layer after layer. But...

We were using the free version of Pro Tools as our music recording software at the time. We could not afford Pro Tools. And so there was a free version you could download. And the problem with this free version is eight tracks maximum. That's it. So what that meant is, yeah, I mean, eight tracks is still a lot. But once you're trying to pile on, probably the song that has the biggest pile is the song Green Cosmos. No, that's not true. Maybe there's one called Spiral Goldentown.

It was another one that had trumpets. You know, pitch shifted, you know, sampled trumpets or whatever. Both of those, you know, so many layers. And the problem was, at least, you know, working on it at the time, the problem was. Once you hit eight tracks, you had to bounce it down to two and you could add six more and then bounce it down and then you could add six more. So then it was impossible to go back. Or I defeat it because room was running out on my computer. So, you know, it was coming back to this thing of I had this stereo bounce that after listening to it for four months, I realized the stereo bounce isn't good. It doesn't good. I wish I could have mixed it a different way, but now I can't. And so I've got to cover it up in some way or doctor it in some way to to hide its flaws or beef up its.

thinness or, you know, whatever it was. So that was another part of it. It wasn't like we had some, like, it wasn't like we were prints in a, you know, in a giant studio with an infinite number of tracks. You know, we had an infinite number of tracks, but, but only if you kept bouncing down. And, and so you were stuck with whatever makes you were in the mood to make that day. You know, I don't know. I think that that, again, you know, we kind of hit a wall on Green Cosmos. We need to do something different. This is too, you know, why can't, it's like when we would go on tour, it would be so fun to play the songs.

It wasn't painstaking at all. It was the opposite of painstaking. It was pure joy to play. Why can't we get that joy on the record? And so that's why we're like, okay, we are not doing this anymore. We're not going to do this. We are going to rent a rehearsal. We're going to stop doing these makeshift recordings too. We're going to stop doing this thing where we record the whole record in one afternoon and then, you know, suffer for the following year trying to fix every flaw, you know, that that one afternoon produced. We're going to take our time. We're going to rent a practice space. And in Oakland, you know, one of the, it was one of those ones in West Oakland where, you know, where there's a 200 practice room. Yeah, yeah. Like that would have been Soundwave at the time, I think.

I think it was Soundwave, yeah. So we moved into Soundwave. We moved all our instruments into Soundwave. We had a monthly thing, and we stayed in there for about five months. And we went in there like, I don't know, whatever, like a regular job. And we were at least 40 hours a week. Every morning, we'd get on the part. We'd get to show up first thing in the morning. Everybody's so tired. And we'd just start pounding on the drums. Okay, what's your idea? And it was the four. It was Chris and John and Tommy and me.

I seem to remember that it was over the winter as well. And I admit, yes, I admit that Bay Area winters are not. You're living in the Midwest now, so you know. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Not the hottest winter ever. But still, it was cold. And it was a windowless room. It was, you know, a strange place to spend five months of your life. It's a little stranger when it's empty than when there's like 20 minutes playing, you know. It has an eerie sort of feel to it. Yeah, I mean, it was eerie. And, you know, had only each other for a company for most of that time. And just obsessively retaking songs again and again and again.

and just recorded so much stuff. That's why it ended up being double record, the Runners 4. It was 100% recorded in that practice space. And it has a really sort of crappy, dead sound on the drums. But one of the reasons that the guitars sound so nice, and it was Chris Cohen switched to bass, and Satomi switched to guitar. So the guitars are Satomi and John. And one of the reasons the guitars sound so nice is that we bought those amp simulators. We were so sick of failing to record good guitar sounds.

you know years of just like not ever feeling like the guitar sounded you know we couldn't ever get a recording of a guitar sound that sounded as good as it sounded in real life it seemed like we just couldn't do it and we were like let's just buy a pod you know so we got this amp so we were all in headphones and john and satomi were plugged into pods um and getting simulated amp tones and so then You're in headphones, and we didn't have to record a crappy sound and then spend a year mix it. We could spend the time first getting the sound, and we would design really, really unusual, I mean, what we thought were unusual, really fun guitar sounds with strange delays and wah-wah pedals and all this stuff that we didn't have, but it was in this simulator, and just record it straight in the computer like that, and then that's the sound, and then you didn't have to mess with it so much. You didn't have to cover it up, and it was just like, that's the sound. So in a way, that was really a pleasure.

But we also, you know, started to get at each other's throats. Instead of recording in one afternoon and feeling stressed out, it would be all day, every day. And so, you know, that became the last thing that we did with Chris. And we toured after it, actually. I mean, so that wasn't the last that was the last record that we recorded, but it wasn't the last thing we did. We toured and it was always really, you know, it was fun to play those songs. But it was, you know, it was the same. It was just.

I mean, and I think Chris maybe understood that better. Well, no, actually Satomi did too. I think it was me who understood it the worst. But I think that Chris, he came into the band saying, guys, what are you doing? Come on, this record already sounds fine. Put it out. I'm talking about Revlon. And by the end of Runners 4, you know, had kind of fully...

He might tell the story differently, but my interpretation is that he, you know, ended his time in Deerhoof having fully converted to the obsessive overwork. The other way around, yeah, yeah. Not the other way around. We were all in it together. And I think that part of it was realizing, you know, can't the process be a little bit, whatever, the process can be whatever it is, but can't I have a few more hours to live, you know, to just have a little bit more of a life and not devote?

I mean, everybody can do a residency or they can do a thing, you know, a retreat or something where you say, I'm going to forget everything. I'm going to a monastery and I'm going to live like a monk for two weeks, you know, and put the rest of my life aside and focus on this. But when you've done that now continuously for, you know, whatever, five years straight, which was the time that he was in the band approximately, you know, he was right. It was too much. obsession and there were sacrifices getting made and you know I just remember like I'll go to the grocery store and get food later you know I've got to get this mix right and I feel like it's almost right and you know it's like it's a pleasure to go back and listen to those records but I'll be honest you know it sometimes it I get a little bit tearful remembering those times because it's just I I feel like such a fool, you know? And Chris and I still talk about it sometimes. It's like...

The records sound really cool, but it was like a dark path in a way. And it became almost darker over time because Dear Hope was doing this in part because we had no budget, because we couldn't sell very many records. Or at least we didn't want to ask labels. It was Kill Rockstars at the time for all of those for an advance like other bands do. You know, oh, we want a recording advance because we really needed the expenses to be low so that we had some hope of making an income from the record after the fact.

And so we're like, no, no advance. We're going to do this all ourselves. And what we could have spent money to have a producer or a helper, you know, to do it better. We're going to just do it. We're going to substitute time, hours, you know, we're going to substitute hours. And the thing is, what Chris pointed out to me years later, which I think he's really right, is that the idea of the DIY band that records on a zero dollar budget, finishes a record and then sends it to a label and says, hey, you want to put this out?

has become the norm. That's become expected, is that it's the band's responsibility to shoulder all costs and all effort, and that anything beyond that is considered like, oh, only celebrities get a budget, you know? What's up, Rockefeller? Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah, exactly. And so Chris feels a little bit guilty that Dear Hope was one of the causes of this change of paradigm, that because we volunteered to do everything for free, that...

that the labels began to, I mean, obviously it's not just because of Deerhoff, but that we were just part of a movement that ended up resulting in labels expecting bands to do everything for free. Yeah, it is funny when you talk about shifts and... culture and how things have changed you're right it's sort of like it's almost this oh you don't record you know most of your stuff like oh why not why wouldn't you just learn to go do that and you know you want to go to a studio oh okay yeah it's like well yeah i wanted to sound good i've got a vision for this come on uh which doesn't say that home recordings can't sound good don't get me wrong i'm just saying that it's interesting that like to watch that shift being like oh kind of like You know, push your nose up at home recording, whatever, to be like, no, of course, everybody says that now. It's pretty much what we knew. And I just remember at the time feeling very depressed about it. I would always be happy with the record, like I said. I mean, I thought the record, we loved our records. I mean, we didn't deem them finished until we loved them. But I remember feeling depressed, like, I am spending year after year teaching myself.

the most useless non-transferable skills. Yeah. I mean, you know, keystrokes on the computer in Pro Tools or, or like how to make, how to make Satomi's voice sound good in a deer hoof mix, you know, all this stuff that seems completely irrelevant to the rest of the universe, you know? And I'm like, boy, I'm, I'm teaching myself useless skills. And it's been in more recent years that I think, um, you know, especially John and Chris and me who were the most involved with the sort of you know, recording, engineering, mixing, mastering, minutia, that we were all, like, just hitting ourselves with the head, like, what are we doing? We are wasting our lives learning this stuff. That it's become, there's been some relief in recent years where we've all started to...

record or mix or master other people's music and people have started hiring us to do that or we do it for friends for free or whatever like and we realize well maybe it wasn't for nothing we're gonna make it not be for nothing because we're gonna share you know whatever totally self-taught you know backwards workaround kind of skills that we taught ourselves over those years we're gonna we're going to spread them and we're gonna make use of them and try to bring some benefit to someone besides ourselves, you know, for having acquired... Non-transferable skills that... Yeah, yeah, exactly. They seemed non-transferable, but they turned out to be transferable. And that has been a really gratifying life change, you know. We couldn't see it at the time. Right, of course, because it's, you know, later on down the line, it becomes more apparent. So then Chris leaves the group. Yeah, Chris left, and we had, you know, John's old friend, Ed Rodriguez, John had played in Ed...

in bands with ed two different bands with ed in back in minneapolis um called uh and like skin graft uh bands uh great band actually we all knew that really well he had moved to the bay area and uh you know he was our friend we saw him all the time and you know um actually we had been on tour with him when chris was in the band because we'd done a europe tour where deer hoof was opening for gorge trio which was john ed and this guy It was Deerhoff's first European tour. Which was basically, if I remember right, it was most of Colossomite, right? Most everyone from Colossomite. Well, this was Gorge Trio, which was like a spin-off of Colossomite that was even more obscure. Yeah, no, Gorge Trio, because I saw Gorge Trio, but I remember it being the Colossomite, like most of the guys from Colossomite played in Gorge Trio. Yeah, it was three out of four of Colossomites. It was minus the vocalists, so it was just instrumental. I think it's some of you guys, actually, now that I think about that. Yeah, yeah, exactly.

The first time I saw them was when we were opening for them on this European tour in 2000, probably 2003. It was Apollo tour. And, you know, Chris was still pretty new in the band. And we were on tour in Europe in February, really cold. Ed took video.

every night of Gearhook on that tour. And since 2003, 17 years, we have been pestering Ed Rodriguez, one of my best friends, my bandmate, one of my closest friends. Ed, when are you going to digitize those stupid videos? You know, I want to see what that tour looked like. And he finally did it last week. No way! Oh, that's awesome! And I'm looking at these videos now after 17 years. And all I remember at the time was...

I'm really sad he videotaped this because we're playing terrible every night and they're so funny. And there's actually, I mean, they're really, really fun to watch. And I'm making an edit of like, you know, kind of like we were playing more or less the same set list every night, but I'm trying to like find the best version of Panda and the best version of Dummy Discard the Hearth and the best version of Come See the Duck and all that kind of stuff. It wasn't like how it is now where everyone just has. you know, an amazing video camera in your pocket that takes like high definition video. It was a little more of a weird thing like that. But the weird thing is that for some reason a lot of cell phone video stuff that you see online, you know, I see it on YouTube.

The sound is often really blown out and terrible, but the sound is not so distorted on these. I'll probably eat my words if I ever put any of this online. I'd be like, what are you talking about? But for some reason, it doesn't sound as bad as the stuff that's recorded on itself, like a really loud band. Any loud band with just concert video, unless they have some kind of outside mic or something, it generally sounds pretty bad. Or, yeah, if they have a way to control the input. Maybe Ed had a sound input knob on his video camera or something. Really funny, grainy videos. Anyway, so, yeah. So, in any case.

We already knew Ed well, and we had been on tour with him. We were all in the same van on that tour. So we knew we could get along with him. There was no question. So we did, well, actually, first we did another, right? We did a friend opportunity, right? Yeah, so I guess we struggled through that for a while as a three-piece. I don't know what we were thinking, but, well, I guess Ed was busy. He was playing in XBXRX. He was playing flying Luttenbachers. He wasn't available. He was pretty busy around that time. Now that you say that aloud. That's why we didn't ask him is because he wasn't available. So Dierhoof, I mean, one of the incredible things.

in my you know reminiscences of that time um around 2007 um when friend opportunity came out and we were playing those songs on tour one of the things that well as we were finishing runners four we got a random email saying would you be available to open for radiohead and and we had some difficulty actually figuring out if that was going to be possible and um and uh we And then Radiohead was like, never mind, we've got too much gear and we're playing kind of smaller stages than we normally play, which of course was like, you know, Greek theater. But for them, it was a slight underplay that was going to sell out overnight or whatever. And they're like, there's no room for another band. And Chris had just quit. And we're like, basically wrote back an email. It's just three of us. John's got a single 12-inch cabinet.

The drums are the bass drum of a Pearl Rhythm Traveler, which is, you know, five inches deep or something, and one snare drum, and that's it. And then we can set up in the front four feet of the stage. If you have four feet empty in the front of the stage. We can do it, Radiohead. And then they wrote back and said, okay, you're on. And, you know, we drove in to the first show, which was Berklee.

Greek theater in a Prius. The backstage load-in area. They didn't believe. We're like, no, we're the opening band. You know, Radiohead obviously has a lot of obsessed fans who are trying to sneak in. And we're like, no, we're the band, you know. And they wouldn't let us in. They couldn't believe we were a band in that car. Where's your crew? We rented a Prius for the tour. I think none of us had cars. Maybe John had a car, but he didn't trust it to make it all the way to San Diego or something. So we rented a Prius for the tour. And, yeah, it was an incredible experience where...

The... The band that you had been unfavorably comparing yourself to and trying to master your master your records to and that you had done so much self-destructive, you know, psychological, you know, imposter syndrome, negative comparisons to, you know, to musicians who you thought were better than you turn out to be watching you from the side of the stage every night and going crazy. And and that it was.

you know i mean it's just very touching and again kind of surreal moment where you realize that in years where you know i'm not going to say that dearhoff's only purpose was to match up to radiohead it was not our only purpose but among the many things that we were trying to do was trying to create musical responses to some of our favorite music and uh particularly you know current music and two of our biggest musical heroes were the roots in Radiohead, and we were always listening to their music and comparing ourselves to it, and to think that even if they didn't hear us, we were trying to write music that somehow responded to their music and one-upped it. We imagined ourselves as being in conversation with them, even though that was a ridiculous, absurd fantasy. And then at some point, those fantasies, they turned out to be true, and that they were hearing our responses to their music, and then they were making music. And I can't say for sure that any

particular Roots song or Radiohead song is, you know, reminiscent of Deerhoof. But sometimes I, you know, I think I hear it, you know, now and again. Sure, of course. Bangers and Mash on the record that they did right after that tour, In Rainbows. It's not on In Rainbows. It's on the In Rainbows kind of extra disc or whatever. But Bangers and Mash, it was one they were playing a lot on that tour. Really cool song. I always kind of wondered if maybe, you know, it was a little bit of a Deerhoof imitation. But, you know, just, yeah. And to realize, you know, in person.

They weren't the Mount Rushmore, you know, or they weren't the ogres that I might have imagined. They were so funny and so sweet and so kind and helpful. I mean, on tour, I mean, every day we were just – John's pedal would break or, you know, I mean, my drums were – taped together with duct tape and we're sitting there playing gigantic audiences and it's radiohead audiences too so they're listening it's not like they're just milling around going to the bathroom drinking beer it's like you know they're like attentively listening to every note yeah exactly listening to every note so we're just like up there like trying so hard to to not like bomb and uh and stuff's breaking and like it's not just the band i mean the the radiohead crew was like also watching our show like hawks and like something would go wrong with john's guitar and like johnny greenwood's guitar tech would run out onto the stage and like fix it right right happening right now you know yeah at the end of that short tour of california they invited us on another leg in europe and uh and um

And we couldn't afford to bring someone to mix our sound. So their front of house sound, who by now knew all our songs by heart and everything, he mixed us, no problem. And it was brilliant. And then Johnny Greenwood did our light show on the one indoor show that we did at the end of that in Amsterdam, the Heineken Music Hall. He put on a hoodie so that no one would recognize him and stood back at the light board. And he knew every one of our songs. I mean, we've never, never had a light show like that because he knew exactly when it was going to kick into.

this part when the whole audience was totally lost you know and he'd throw on the strobe at you know just the right moment and when you go in the last part or something and there was another show where we There was a day off on the Radiohead tour, and we booked a show of our own in a tiny club in Edinburgh. And we had had soundcheck. We were frazzled, stressed. We went out for a quick dinner. We didn't have much time. We had to get back to the show. We were illegally parked on this cobblestone street in Edinburgh, and we felt like we had to get back in a hurry. We went to this restaurant. We're like, oh, no, they don't have anything vegetarian for us. And we suddenly, just sheer luck, looked up, and there was a sign.

vegan you know restaurant we're like thank goodness and we walked in we're like quick let's order something we walk back to the table and there are johnny greenwood tom york and one of their tour managers eating at this eating dinner at this vegan restaurant right and uh and we go into town what in the world are you guys doing here and and uh Tom rolls his eyes and says, well, Johnny is playing this Irish music gig tonight, and he roped me into coming to watch. And then Johnny rolls his eyes and said, well, actually, it was this other guy who roped me into doing the Irish music gig, and I don't really want to do it. And then I'm like, well, have fun. We're playing down the street at this other place. We had a nice little visit, and it was just so funny and just out of the blue. And then we go play this show.

And we think we're not playing very well. And, you know, we think we're not having such a good show, but man, there's a ruckus happening in the audience. It's like almost like a mosh pit, you know, we had these kind of fans in Edinburgh. It was Dublin. I have it wrong. We were in Ireland. It was in Dublin. I remember it incorrectly. Edinburgh was the next day. That's why it was Irish music. We were in Dublin. And, you know, we'd never been to Ireland. And but then we looked down after a few songs, we realized what was going on. It was Tom York dancing like a madman.

to our show he had bailed on the irish music gig and was the only person in the audience who knew how our songs went and um and so he was like crashing into people and just like it was so funny and after the show we went back to the merch table and he was like they're like totally drenched in sweat he's like oh i really enjoyed myself anyways very very every one of them very sweet and uh you know a great memory from from friend opportunity era but it was That tour, I mean, not just the Radiohead shows, but all the shows where we attempted to play those songs as a trio were a real struggle. You know, I don't know. I mean, it's just like the new songs, the songs on the record had so many keyboards and, you know, layers. Yeah, there's a lot of layers to it. There's only three people. Trying to cover everything at once. And some songs that Tommy wanted to dance, so he was having to do the bass on the guitar plus the guitar parts on the guitar plus keyboard parts. It was really funny. Quickly, you know, quickly we were like, we need to get a guitar player. And just by sheer miracle, Ed suddenly quit.

both of his bands we're like what really he's available and we like you know we had a three-way you know we had a band meeting you know should we ask ed into the band and five minutes later we were decided that definitely we're getting ed in the band and then ed i mean john called up ed hey do you want to go out to dinner tomorrow and then you know 24 hours later ed was in the band and then you know it's just been like you know that was 2008 12 years ago Well, I mean, I don't know. We've just all become so much closer. And I just, you know, Ed brought a, well, I don't know. Ed is different than anyone else and different from us. And I don't know what the difference is, but it's just, he immediately was very fun on stage. And so Tommy had someone that she could interact with a little more. Yeah, the live vibe, speaking as somebody from the outside of it, the live vibe became more of a show almost. Not that it wasn't a show before, but meaning that it was. Yeah, but it's different. There was a showiness to it that Ed.

that ed picked up on from satomi and added but he always i mean that was always part of his thing too he always dressed up in suits when he played with lutenbachers or something and uh you know eventually he started sewing his own outfits and every tour he'd have a new outfit um and you know he still does that and we'd always be like i can't wait to see what he came up with this time he'd literally be sewing after sound chair he wasn't done with it i didn't realize he made himself on stage that's amazing walk on stage and we would finally see for the first time what his outfit was going to be for this dude like totally insane um you know kiss He always says that the first show he ever saw...

was Liberace. He went with his mom to see a Liberace show that had, it was one of these where he was doing classical hits like Blue Danube Waltz and stuff like that, but it had fountains on stage, fountains that were timed to go with the music. And I think ever since, and it seems to be kind of true ever since then, you know, he's just very glamped out and very, you know, and there's something of the pleasure in being. somewhat artificial about you know i think they put it this way dear i mean when i look at pictures of me robin satomi in 1995 it's like it was as far from glam as you can get nothing was artificial everything was so earnest and you know it was just jeans t-shirt flannel you know whatever it is like not thinking about that just in sound world audio world only thinking about the music and and um But it's more than that. It's not just a negation of visuals because both Satomi and Rob were and are visual artists who did think visually, but it had more to do with the always earnest and direct approach that we tended to take with everything at the time and the secretive approach that we took to everything at the time. And I think that when Ed joined, we started to enjoy.

you know, the artificial more. Kind of lean into it, yeah. Yeah, and to play act more. I noticed that my own performance style changed a lot in the years after Ed joined. I became more self-conscious as a way of being fun, you know, to be more hammy, you know, or to play tricks on the band or play tricks on the audience more often.

And to, you know, I don't know how to explain it, but I just think that Ed's influence... you know, created something of, and Camp came into the band more. I think that Camp was always part of the band. We were always deliberately bad. I mean, I think that that's an element of noise music in many cases, particularly, you know, kind of first wave original noise. You know, it was meant to be, destroy music, you know, so it was bad on purpose. And that kind of humor has always been in Dear Hope. But I don't know, I don't know, whatever. Once I joined the band, it was like, we found a new way to embrace that humor. And I think that it's become, I don't know, the band has become.

uh more loving and more fun um we always had fun i mean i don't want to i don't want to oversimplify but it's just become and and we've also still had our struggles and difficult times you know since 2008 but yeah it's just been uh i don't know uh um i'm very very grateful because that's the period that we're still in and uh i i sometimes can't believe that we're still together and and we seem to enjoy it more now than we did you know um it's more fun now every all the you know we did offend maggie first and we went back to tiny telephone for that one actually um for the final time um recorded everything there and maybe even had a couple days you know like we really and i still mixed it at home but but like we didn't do the panic rush thing um which is kind of the beginning of that era and amazingly enough i'm gonna have to have you on again to talk about it because we've because we're at two hours because we're at two hours and we've already talked about so many amazing things but i'm very glad that we're at least uh starting to get into you know almost this decade uh and i will make it a year and a half before the next one uh for sure uh greg it's been so great talking to you man thanks so much for coming back on the show

Thanks for letting me ramble on. And let's, yeah, let's do this again soon. I always enjoy hearing from you and I want to get into the latter day stuff as well. And I just really appreciate you and everything you do, man. Yeah, likewise. Thank you very much for keeping in touch and reaching out and finding me again. I'm good with that. Next time we'll talk about what you've been up to more. No, no, no, no, we won't. It's not interesting. Nothing. Thank you, Conan. Thank you so much, Greg. Stay warm, stay healthy. All right, take care. Bye. Bye. Oh, there he goes. Greg Sondner of Deerhoof. That was awesome. Hey, thanks so much everybody for tuning in. This has been Conan Neutron's Protonic Reversal.

Protonicoversal.com for the archives. I'm going to try to have them on again soon. We'll get even further into discography. All right, let's hear a Deerhoof song. We talked a lot about the Chris Cohen era, so let's listen to something. Let's listen to Panda, Panda, Panda. Here we go. Deerhoof, Don Coversal. Man, by Deerhoof. And before that, we have Panda, Panda, Panda. Both great records by Greg Sonier and company. The wonderful band known as Deerhoof.

Got into more of the actual record stuff this time. Hope that was enjoyable for folks. The last time I... It was a delightful ramble last time. I think it was kind of cool. Why am I doing a postgame on my own show? Whatever. Anyway, hope you guys enjoyed that. I enjoyed that as well. I'm on again. We'll talk about the stuff done in the last decade. That's all worthwhile to you and very cool. Make sure that we talk about that at some point. But hey, thanks for coming in. Thanks for watching to the show. Watching to the show? Watching the show? I don't even know what I'm talking about anymore.

The name of the show is Come to New Trust, Protonic Reversal. The show airs Thursdays, 8 Eastern, 7 Central, 6 Mountain, 5 Pacific on RadioNope.com. ProtonicReversal.com for the archives. Patreon.com slash ProtonicReversal to get new episodes sooner and support the show. One dollar a month will get you there. Otherwise, always free. No ads, no sponsors, no kidding. Thanks everyone for sharing the episodes around, liking the show, and liking the show, and doing reviews and things. That helps people find it. That's awesome. I always appreciate that. I genuinely...

Appreciate that. There's a bunch more cool stuff coming. Stay tuned. Stay tuned. Stay safe out there and take it easy. Take it easy!

The last what? Leaves a transmitter. Circles the globe in search of a listener. Can you hear me now? Is it really broadcasting if there's no one there to receive? And radio. Come to the close. Broadcast. I've got my radio. Can you hear me now?

Quickly Kevin; will he score? The 90s Football Show This Is A Real Test Ltd A series in which 90’s football aficionado Josh Widdicombe is joined by friends, and fellow 90s experts, co-host Chris Scull and ‘Director of Podcast’ Michael Marden, as the trio embark on a tour of niche football topics of the period 1st January 1990 to 31st December 1999. Join the Quickly Kevin fan club for early release and extended episodes as well as exclusive bonus episodes and live shows, merchandise, events, and much much more... Explicit The Kiss Me Quick's Erotica Rose Caraway Fueled by art, sexuality, playfulness, adventure, and imagination, Rose & Dayv Caraway will arouse your senses with libidinous tales of love, loss, action, adventure, romance, suspense, horror, science fiction, paranormal, and fantasy. Brimming with limitless creativity and moxie these erotic stories are sure to seduce your thoughts and leave you and your partner(s) wanting more! This show is for adults only. Explicit 00's Dance Classics Party Favorz “Experience the best of House Music with the “00’s Dance Classics” channel’s non-stop mixes of top songs from the Millennium! Explicit The Sum of All Wisdom: Conversations on Music, Makers, Meaning & More Musician, broadcaster, ethnographer, Dr. Scott Catey There's more to music than meets the ear.Season 1: January - October, 2026: Indeterminacy: Music, uncertainty, and the art of becomingMore than a podcast, The Sum of All Wisdom is a community and resource platform dedicated to exploring music as a way of knowing. Music is humanity's oldest way of knowing and one of our best technologies for making meaning, and through long-form conversations with musicians, producers, writers, and cultural thinkers—along with performances, essays, and educational resources—we investigate the creative life and what it teaches us about memory, identity, creativity, community, and the human condition.Whether you're a musician, artist, scholar, or simply someone who loves music and believes it matters, The Sum of All Wisdom is an invitation to listen more deeply: to great music, to the people who make it, and to the wisdom gained through a life devoted to music and musical worlds. Because music is more than entertainment. It is one of humanity's mo Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Conan Neutron's Protonic Reversal?

This episode is 2 hours and 18 minutes long.

When was this Conan Neutron's Protonic Reversal episode published?

This episode was published on December 29, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Conan Neutron's Protonic Reversal episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.