Welcome to the 59th edition of the Bogleheads on Investing Podcast. Today, our special guest is Dr. William Sharp. I'm John Luskin, and I normally host our Bogleheads live show for the folks of Twitter. I'll be taking over for the normal host Rick Ferry while he takes a summer sabbatical.
Please allow me to introduce Dr. William Sharp. He was one of the originators of the capital asset pricing model, developed the Sharp ratio for investment performance analysis, and developed other methods for the evaluation of options, asset allocation optimization, and investment return analysis for evaluating the style and performance of investment funds. Dr. Sharp has published articles and a number of professional journals, and is a past president of the American Finance Association.
In 1990, he received the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences for his work on the capital asset pricing model. You can learn more about Dr. Sharp at W Sharp dot com. Some announcements before we get started on today's episode with Dr. Bill Sharp.
This episode of the Bogleheads on Investing Podcast, as with all episodes, is brought to you by the John C. Boglehead Center for Financial Literacy, a nonprofit organization that is building a world of well-informed, capable, and empowered investors. Visit Boglecenter.net, where you'll find valuable information, including transcripts of podcast episodes. Another announcement, registration is currently open for the 2023 Bogleheads Conference. This year's conference is on October 13th through the 15th in Maryland.
We have some phenomenal personal finance and investing rock stars who will be attending as speakers, including Charles Ellis, Paul Merriman, Clark Howard, Jonathan Clemence, Michelle Singletary, Barry Rittholx, Wade Fau, and more. And of course, Boglehead's favorites, post of this show, Rick Ferry, Christine Benz, Dr. Bill Bernstein, Mike Piper, Alan Roth, and much more. Go to Boglecenter.net slash 2023 conference to see the full lineup and to register. Also, you still have time to take advantage of the discounted room rate.
Again, that's Boglecenter.net slash 2023 conference. And finally, a disclaimer, the following is for informational and entertainment purposes only. It should not be relied upon as investment advice. And with that, let's get started on our interview with Dr. William Sharp.
Bill, welcome to the 59th Bogleheads on Investing Podcast. Thank you for joining us. Hi, pleasure. In 1990, you jointly received the Nobel Memorial Prize in economics with Harry Markowitz and Martin Miller for your work on the capital asset pricing model. Tell us about the capital asset pricing model.
The idea is that the more securities you have in a portfolio, the less important is the risk that's specific to a given stock, whether it be from the company's activities or from the industry it's in. So as you put more and more securities in a portfolio, what we call idiosyncratic risk, the risk that's attributed to the fact that gemomotor is the fact that it's in the auto industry, that risk tends to be diversified away. And as you diversify more, the risk in your portfolio becomes predominantly due to what's going on in the broader market. So certainly Bogleheads are fully subscribed to this.
We love diversification and we love those low-cost index funds. We want the return of the market. We're not necessarily putting all our money into just one individual stock and that helps manage risk. Let's jump to one of our questions we got from Twitter. This question is from user name Levi who writes, do you still fully subscribe to the capital asset price model?
Well, it's a model and models abstract from reality in various ways and get results based on what goes into the model. What do you assume in the model? The CAPM, the original version in the dissertation assumed that all stocks had risk that came from quote the market and then idiosyncratic risk that was unique to them and not correlated with anything else going on. So in that sense, it assumes that was not perhaps surprising. I got the result that expected returns would be related to beta values.
That is sensitivity to the market. The broader model used just the idea that the more diversified your portfolio, the greater would be the component of risk in that portfolio that was attributable to the market as a whole. And so in a sense, it did not assume that the market was the only source of returns. It in some sense got that results that the market portfolio was predominantly, I should say, to be careful the risk for which there would be rewards in higher expected returns. There was a radical difference between the two and some people who knew the first were had thought that the second result in CAPM resulted from assuming the quote single index model.
That is, that only market risk was a correlated risk in securities. It did not. Again, if you have enough stocks that will diversify away and be of much less importance and therefore not rewarded, the non-market part would not be rewarded in higher expected returns. This question is from David from Twitter who writes, it would be great if Dr. Sharp could comment on cap and assumptions and that agreed to which the model's value has changed as markets have evolved.
It's hard to describe to somebody in today's world how irrelevant the stock market was for most human beings back in the 50s and 60s. Relatively few people had individual stocks that were not 401k plans and there certainly were as many securities as there are now or as many different exchanges, et cetera. At the time, the idea was that the market as a whole could be sufficiently dominant in expected returns that it would be a high, high, high percentage of the influence on expected returns. That was the idea that only the beta of a security would have an impact on expected returns.
That was a pretty far out assumption. Now there are so many securities, how many markets for that matter? And so many people who own securities, if nowhere else in their 401k's, 401k's, or 3b's, I think it's to me at least a more comfortable assumption. Let's jump to measuring risk. Next, this question comes from user name 95.
Seated from the Bullheads forums who writes, should investors consider volatility to be the primary measure of risk by constructing financial portfolios? I would say yes, if they have a bunch of securities or a mutual fund that has a bunch of securities or multiple mutual funds. Obviously, if they have an investment portfolio of three stocks, there's a lot of non-market risk in that portfolio. But if they do what bullheads might by and large, I would assume do. Yes.
Yes, certainly I wonder if 95 suited is referring to some other risks that long-term investors might face such as inflation risk. That's to say, if you don't want to take a volatility as a risk for the risk that your investments decrease in value, then you're not necessarily getting rid of all risk so much as you're trading that one risk volatility for another risk, which is inflation. If you're not going to invest in assets like stocks that have historically grown more than inflation, then you might be looking at your wealth decreasing over the long term. Well, I think there's a very strong argument that for most people, there returns that matter are real returns inflation adjust. Now, we can talk about how important is inflation for all people versus young people.
But in a sense, I would favor thinking of returns not as nominal returns, but as real returns. Pick your country in time period. Inflation may be dominant at May if you're lucky for a short period in some countries be sort of minimal, as we well know, and as we're experiencing. In most countries, in many times, inflation is important. So in some sense, it's easy to just do everything in real returns when I'm doing projections, Monte Carlo, what have you.
I tend to like to do it all in real returns. Then the literature, there's an argument that for retired people inflation may not be quite as formidable a factor depending on if they've bought their house and they paid off their mortgage, etc. Property taxes in some places in California, for example, is a limit on how much they can be increased once you bought the house, etc. My inflation may be different than your inflation. There's some research by David Blanchott that talks about the spending smile of retirees, showing how retiree spending might not actually keep up with inflation.
I will link to that in the show notes for our podcast listeners. David Blanchott, by the way, was our guest on episode 14 of the Bobolehead's live show. I'll also link to that in the show notes. Let's talk more about measuring risk. This question is from the white coat investor from the Bobolehead's forums who writes, risk adjusted return calculators such as the sharp ratio use volatility as a measurement risk.
Volatility is the change in price of your investment. The white coat investor goes on to say a long term investor really shouldn't care much about volatility. Does that mean that they should care about the sharp trainer or sortino ratios? And before we answer that question, perhaps you can tell us what those ratios are. I can probably answer that part, what the sharp ratio is.
And let me say, by the way, I didn't call it that. I called it the reward the variability ratio. And I think it was Gene Fonda started calling it the sharp ratio. The idea of the sharp ratio is to at least take two things into account, you know, an average of returns and a standard deviation. Standard deviation for those who aren't investing nerds is just a way that we can't measure risk.
How much our portfolio changes in value? This is the same thing as the volatility that we just mentioned. That's how you did on average when how much variation was there.
If you did this on average and it was almost the same every single period, then using that number as a prediction makes me more comfortable than if it was that on average, but it was very all over the place. The original idea is, you know, it takes into account the risk free rate. So it's not just the average return on the top. It's average over and above the risk free rate. That's because it assumes that you can borrow and limit at that rate.
And so you could take that portfolio and lever it up or down at that rate. That's the economics behind it. But the sharp ratio, it's a useful number. I would not refuse to look at it if somebody offered it to me for an investment. And again, it's particularly important to understand that for a piece of a portfolio, the risk of that piece may or may not be important depending on how correlated it is with what's going on with the other securities of the portfolio.
I sometimes say when people ask about the sharp ratio, they say, look, folks, we have computers now. We don't need to put everything in one number. We can look at more than one number. You know, what was the Evans return and what was the risk and what was the beta, et cetera. We can do things that are more sophisticated.
I serve on nonprofit investment committees. Very often the consultant or the manager will show you sharp ratios for every investment in the portfolio. This fund that fund, et cetera, that doesn't really help you much with what it was originally intended for. It does help you in the sense it's like a t-statistic. It is interesting if a manager did not only well, but did it with quite some consistency.
You have more reason to believe that you might get some good results in the future. Recently some manager who was topping a sharp ratio out of it was five or something, you know, this humongous sharp ratio and looked at it and said it was based on, I think it was 14 monthly returns for private equity for which there was no market value. It was just an estimate and they put down these 15 estimates. Sure enough, there wasn't much variation and they've done all right at boarding to the estimates. So sometimes there are uses that I would not endorse.
For those folks who aren't in investment nerds, why that is hilarious for two reasons. Number one, a 14 month investment return is pretty much random. And then also if it's a private investment, the manager can pretty much make up whatever price, whatever investment return. What do you want? I would like it to be worse.
All that's to say how they use the sharp ratio in that situation is quite silly. And then for me, the sharp ratio is very special because I looked at how endowments did next to index one portfolios for our master's thesis. Hey, what happens with $600 million to invest? Well, the date already exists to show that those endowments would have been better off with low cost index ones. But what about risk?
What is the risk of just a return? So I use the sharp ratio and the short-chain ratio to show even on a risk adjusted basis, considering how much risk you are taking that the amount of return you're getting compared to that index on portfolio is not that great. And of course, if you're comparing portfolios and you can borrow and lend at the riskless rate, then the portfolio with the highest shock ratio is golden because with leverage up or down, that can beat anything below it. Let's jump to the second part of the white coat investors question who asks, how can we adjust for the deep risks discussed by Dr. Bill Bernstein, such as inflation, deflation, confiscation and devastation?
Let me maybe twist the question a little to a broader question to what extent is it useful to look at historic returns on a security portfolio, the market, whatever, as a prediction of future returns and risks? And that's a very serious question you have to ask yourself. I would say I think it's incumbent upon you or your advisor to look at history to see how that particular portfolio would have done in the past. I don't think you should say, past is not a predictor of the future, so don't look at all. On the other hand, if a portfolio did well in the past, how likely is it that it's going to do well in the future?
And I would say, generally, not very likely. Risk is a somewhat different matter. Past risk is probably a better predictor of future risk. In an efficient market, past expected returns that are abnormally high are unlikely to be repeated as our terrible returns. If it's done really well in the past, the market knows that.
And the price reflects that to the extent that it's predictive of the future. So don't expect with any kind of certainty abnormally high returns in the future. Let's talk a little bit more about the risk adjusted metrics that are out there. User name, Chiggy from Twitter writes, we should ask them if the sharp ratio is the best risk adjusted return metric to compare index funds versus mutual funds. In principle, the sharp ratio should be used for your whole portfolio.
In many cases, it's used for pieces of the portfolio. It's useful, but in a different sense. And if you're using it for pieces of a portfolio, then it's more in the sense of the t-statistic. How did that piece do on average? And how much risk variation was there?
Getting to that average. If you got that average return almost every single month, then that's a very different story than if you got it ranging all over the place. For a whole portfolio, don't just use the standard deviation. Look at the whole distribution. How many months, let's say, over the last 20 years, did it lose 20 percent?
Did it lose 19 percent? Show the range of things that happened and how frequently they happened. That's what a whole portfolio, for pieces of the portfolio, even standard deviation, the typical risk measure. Standard deviation of a portfolio of X plus Y is not just the average of those two standard deviations. It depends on how they move together.
So it gets more complicated. Thoughts on the sortino ratio. My recollection is that what a sortino ratio or the risk side uses downside risk on the nouns that the risk that you'll do better than expected doesn't seem to be something you should worry about. And certainly right, when you're looking at a whole portfolio, what you'd care about is downside. Upside risk is fine.
The more the merrier. And the issue, if the distribution is symmetric around a middle point, when you plot it, it looks sort of the same on the downside as on the upside, then it kind of doesn't matter whether you use standard deviation or the standard deviation of the downside. Bill, I mentioned earlier that I used the Sharper issue to compare index on portfolio to the very high fee portfolios of endowments. To compare their performance on a risk-adjusted basis, I also used the sortino ratio and the results were very similar. That's kind of my expectation.
The probability distribution is not symmetric, but they're typically of a similar enough form. Probably if you rank on one, probably rank on the other. This question is from user name Derek Tenon from Twitter, who writes, are the persistent flows to index funds changing the market structure? Well, I guess there are two ways of looking at that question. One is, were there not those funds?
How different would things be? The other is, given there are those now and there were not back in my early days, how different are things? I'll skip the latter one because the world is so different in general. I don't even know how to start on that one. I guess one difference if people generally stop using index funds would be they'd be poorer because they'd be paying higher fees than as Jack Vogel has wrote about and talked about many times.
That's not a trivial difference. That's a major difference. One of the ironies of efficient market theory broadly construed is, this is a sort of a contradiction. We assume that people are really working hard to figure out exactly how much more general motors is worth than general electric and that all those prices are taken to account information in very efficient ways. Yet we encourage investors to pay no attention to any of that and just pull them all.
There has to be a point at which there aren't enough active managers, people doing research on securities to keep the market prices right as it were, to incorporate the information that's extant into security prices. That's a really interesting thing to worry about. Even over the many years since we all started in this field, question is how much indexing is too much? I hope at least it ends up. If and when we got to that point, enough people will peel off and start doing security research and become active managers, where that point is, I don't know, but it is a dilemma.
You don't want to convince too many people to index. Unfortunately, the people who don't index are paying the price for that research through higher fees. It's a very strange kind of equilibrium. Do I worry about it now? No.
Do I index now? Yes. I think that's the only investment course at Stanford, and this would have been 1970 or thereafter. I would start the course by going into the classroom and writing on the board a phone number, and I would say this is the most important information you'll know to get in this course, and I'd wait for somebody to say, well, what is that? I said, that's the new customer line at Vanguard.
This is true. I'm not making this up just to please the vocal heads because they were at that time the only place you could get an index fund. It's an issue to think about, if not worry about, is there too much indexing? The answer is no, but I can't prove it. Certainly to your point.
Any index fund investors means an opportunity to make some money. Someone's going to try and do just that. Of course. And the question is how much of any of that will the managers, pastors, to shareholders of the fund to quote Rick Ferry, if there is any alpha, it goes to the managers. Let's move on to another question on index investing.
This one is from username SB1234 for the vocal heads forums who writes, are buying hold index fund investors free writing in the sense that they do not contribute to price discovery? I think so. There are certainly managers who get rich by being in some sense superior and getting information and acting on it. But I have a general audience teaching the investments course at Stanford and I will divide them into two halves left side of the right side. They're all money managers in this market and they collectively are the market.
I would assign half of them to be index fund managers and tell them what they did, have to figure out how many shares were outstanding of each and by exactly proportion of amounts. And the people on this side were active managers and I would describe this one does research on this and that one does this and give them a sense of what active managers do. I'd say these folks owned half the market and those folks collectively own half the market and the index managers of course each of them all is the same portfolio but the active manager is the same place. And then I would say okay before cost the market is down 12%. Before cost what did this passive manager earn and they've said 12% what did that one earn near the 12% now over here on the active side what did this one earn 30% brilliant on this one or minus 12.
What did the average dollar earn on the passive side before cost and they think about 12% what did the average dollar earn on the active side it takes a little while it got to be 12% okay then we take cost into account in general audiences when you play that little game they say wait a minute what if you do it wait that can't be right mean forget data and standard deviations and equilibrium and all that just that argument from pure arithmetic and the money managers hate here that because they don't want to have to have that discussion with their clients. It's a paper I published a two page paper with with the come back at management.
Sharp's math I'll link to that in the show notes for our podcast listeners they can check out that paper by bill there have been attempts by many managers writing articles to say well but there are new issues we get them the good ones first and there's this and there's that those are minor perturbations realistically and that argument for indexing I mean it's so self-evident actually everybody in the bubble that knows it. Let's move on to some questions on model portfolios next this one is from username exit sinc from the bocal heads forums who writes a general principle is that people who are much different from the average investor as waited by portfolio size or trading activity those people should deviate from the market cap awaiting to take into account their special differences does bill agree and then we had a similar question from username Tom 76.
Let me break that in the two pieces one is less risk more is and in the theory you can do that by borrowing a lending and in the theory you can borrow and lend the same rate of it those are very strong assumptions there's one market portfolio levered up or down and of course people don't just take one market portfolio levered up or down they tend to shade a bias towards less risky funds for bias towards more risky etc. The real world is more complicated than the simple models that economists create people cannot borrow at the same rate at which they can lend or risk mostly invest there are arguments there and I would not argue that life is as simple as in our simple models and again you need to take your whole portfolio into account your assets if you have a whole unoccupied whole that's an asset if you're on the mortgage that's a liability except on I sort of think of that as more a bond stock issue now in the simple theory you know there's the market portfolio includes bonds and stocks and you lever that up or down at the riskless rate well let's
face it we really don't do that I think a lot of those issues can be addressed by changing the proportions of bonds and stocks and that I think is the lever that I would prefer to see people pulling and pushing to get a balance and that goes back to that basic bocal expressible which is take the right amount of risk and you can do that by adjusting that lever how much you want in bonds first stocks yeah that would certainly be the place to start at the very least I wonder if Exodus is asking about factor investing in this question some people favorite strategy of overweighting small stocks for example you knew that would end exponents I don't advocate overweighting small stocks because you think they're under priced more risk for the chance at higher return those higher returns are not guaranteed when overweighting small camps let's talk about tips treasury inflation protected securities these are inflation adjusted government bonds we have another question from Olga's forums this user writes now that tips have positive real yields should individual investors who have enough space in tax effort accounts be using them exclusively instead of regular or
nominal treasury bonds it's certainly nicer now that they have positive if not so nice for those who help them and need to sell them yeah definitely an important sense tips for somebody in the US are the riskless security or its riskless as you can get in terms of consumption let's return to a question that we touched on earlier on factor investing such as those factors found by farm and French do you believe in those factors well believe is perhaps to an onward are they useful yes for some things they are but do I believe that it is clearly true that people should overweight like closer to a small factor or a large gross factor or whatever factor of your choice because it's something wrong with the markets no what your thoughts on international diversification should investors be only investing in the US total stock market or should we be investing globally I'll have to tell a story here I was on a non-profit investment committee and one of the members was a semi-retired private
equity guy and we had a consultant who was helping us et cetera the usual story and at one point we were discussing a foreign investment and he gave a little speech as far as I could tell was not kidding said well if he had his brothers we wouldn't have any foreign investments because they don't have to run businesses over there and I thought well surely okay haha this is a joke it wasn't he was serious that's one view it's not mine my view is international diversification should be a good bank in theory as long as people can without too many problems in terms of repatriation and all the rest and divergent tax systems I believe in globally diversified portfolios there is a sense of diversification that said there is an argument for investing at least more than market proportions at home because that's where a lot of your consumption originates you know if in fact the company that you have traditionally purchased
goods at the grocery store does very well because they raise their prices a lot you at least have a balance well I'm paying more but my stock went up that's a trivial and sort of silly example so I think there is an argument for home bias but I don't think it's totally offset by the advantages of global diversification so there's a happy point in the middle somewhere there for those who aren't investment nerds know that the global cap waiting is roughly 60 40 that's to say roughly 60 cents of every dollar invested around the world is invested in US companies and the balance of that 40 cents is invested outside of the US so that is the global cap waiting if we have a home bias we'll invest a little bit more than that roughly 60% compared to international for example Rick Fairey the normal host of this podcast frequently suggests two thirds one third in favor of US stock markets giving us a little bit of a home bias he talks about that in episode one of the Bill heads live podcast I'll link to that in the show note for our podcast listeners to check that out bill what do you think is a reasonable mix for home bias whether or not you go to world market proportions which is
what I would favor as a default ask yourself I don't buy it only companies in California I've got companies in the US and I don't buy only companies in the US I think you need to really think a little bit about what are your other holdings you obviously have a disproportionate holding in the US if you own your own home so if you take your old raw portfolio including things like equity in your home then that gives you a difference you certainly if you've got real estate your primary residence maybe even some investment properties and then that further tilts you towards that home bias even if you've got that global cap waiting portfolio for your liquid investments that is a phenomenal point there was a time there was some investment that would say I only invest in things that are close to home you think no wait a minute that's from a diversification standpoint you went a lot of stake in California or what is happening from your property let's talk more about bonds bill I'm curious about your thoughts on the following the risk of equities shows up in corporate bonds therefore if I'm trying to manage equity risk I don't want to hold bonds that are subject to equity risk
in my portfolio that means opting exclusively for US government bonds for the bond portion of my portfolio as advocated by David Swenson the late chief investment officer over at Gills Endowment I haven't bought off the issues that way why should it matter in what manner you invested in the company it's out there it's part of the market broadly construed there is obviously the risk issue did you take the simplest of a very when scary you should deal with combining the overall market with riskless securities to deal with your risk version and you should get everything that's out there in the market if you get it that reasonable expense now on some issues you're raising are more subtle theory is not subtle enough to deal with it my first impression will be whatever the company's issue would well buy our proportion of share of everything and then leverage to move the overall risk of the portfolio upward potentially down burrito lever from the book that's forums asks is chasing higher yields
via a lower duration bond in the current environment a viable strategy well I would just say generically anything that assumes that you can exploit somebody who's dumber than you would not be recommended if you believe in efficient markets what are your thoughts on changing bond maturity over time that's to say right now short term yields are really attractive therefore I'm going to hold a short term bond portfolio and then maybe when rates normalize I'll update my bond portfolio going farther out on that yield curve what do you think about market timing your bond portfolio with respect to interest rates yeah in general I don't think much positively about market timing because market timing means the other people in the market are stupid or at least not as smart as you are and there are a lot of smart people in the market that's not at all clear that you know significantly more than is embedded in the market maybe you do make you know more about the future is in the average investor and you have to think the average investor is dollar weighted not the average investors you know down the street with a small portfolio the average investor is pretty informed and pretty smart if you're
doing it underweight or overweight anything because in fact the market is quote got it wrong then you're betting against a bunch of folks many of them in terms of dollars invested know a lot about some of these things I do not believe that game and I would not recommend it to the average investor what are your thoughts on foreign bond holdings this question is from username and queue for the bull edge forums who asks about just holding the US bond market on the bond portion of their portfolio well there's an argument you should overweight that would shoot eat in other words you live in the US you buy things from the US predominantly well they're not exclusively of course there would be an argument for doing things that are closer to your consumption basket but I mean economists terms and I think that's an argument worth thinking about of course we consume a lot of things that in whole or in part come from it elsewhere but home bias you know maybe make some sense but you have to think about it that way I would argue have you make the decision let's talk a bit more about what you
got real estate this question is from username abbas368 from the bull edge forums who writes what are his thoughts on private real estate investing such as fun rise and rent cardone as an alternative asset class to invest in alongside the diversified low cost total market index fund portfolio I think you should certainly get market proportion think about market proportions of real estate in the sense of things that are traded on security markets we've got liquidity etc not in the underlying asset but in the security when you start talking about direct investment in real estate that raises a number of other conditions I mean you're not going to try to get a piece of every shopping mall I think it's a practical matter there are traded securities on major markets that's definitely something worth considering in proportions on those markets abbas368 goes on to say these funds typically have high fees such as 1% and are illiquid does that liquidity increase the probability of achieving alpha well I would not argue that
anything with certainty increases of the ability of increasing the actual I think there's a pretty good argument that the truly average investor should consider liquidity you know obviously don't do it when you buy your own house you buy real estate that's illiquid because you can live in it but to buy on the illiquid asset as an investment period and say you should give some thought before you do that let's talk about publicly traded REITs investable using vanguard's low cost rate index fund vnq these were highly recommended 10 to 20 years ago by bert malkeel and david swenson I think you should consider investing in the in market proportions in the risky part of your portfolio again if they're highly liquid and traded and reputable and such shares when you invest in vtivsax that low cost vanguard total stock market index fund you're already getting everything in vnq to your point let's pivot to annuities this one is from username a fan from the forums who writes can you discuss the role of annuities versus bonds in a retirement plan annuities versus what well there's a really big difference
when you die your kids can tell there's a difference or your universities and that when you die and holding annuities there's nothing for anyone else that's a major difference and the whole issue is should you annuitize should you partially annuitize is one that takes an awful lot of thought there are very very important things that transcend investment discussions on whether you should annuitize or not one of the questions is whether or not you can even make it to a very old age which you have some probability of reaching and do you want to play the probabilities or just say I'm not going to bet that I'm going to die soon it's a very complicated decision that involves many issues that transcend or at least overwhelm the economics involved a single premium immediate annuity that's the type of annuity you described just now you know let's jump to some questions that you suggested about asking artificial intelligence AI how to invest it's pretty interesting first of all of course this you well know everybody knows the answers it's astounding what kind of answers you can get answers to differ I asked the arithmetic of active management
can the average dollar invested in the market portfolio after costs outperform the average dollar invested in active strategies and one of them said no period the one has to think about what the role of AI will be and investment advice whether it will replace some humans or it's just given by some people who otherwise didn't get it and what the impact of that might be we need to find a way to make sure that the AI reads some of the things that you and I are talking about and such certainly at least for the short term it's buyer beware if you're using those AI platforms for investment advice amen yeah bill thank you so much for your time I really appreciate it as I'm sure as do all the boogleheads any final thoughts you'd like to share with the boogleheads my against this the boogleheads are pretty much the right course if they're truly following you're interested in I appreciate it I appreciate it I appreciate it I appreciate it I appreciate it listen still whatever the edited version of this will be for spending the time and that wraps up our interview with Dr. William Sharp don't forget you've still got time to take advantage of the special
room rate for the hotel for the 2023 Booglehead's conference go to booglecenter.net slash 2023 conference for more information I'll be back next month returning as guest host for the Boogleheads on investing podcast until then you can check out a wealth of information for do-it-yourself investors at the johncy booglecenter for financial literacy at booglecenter.net and check out boogleheads.org the boogleheads twitter boogleheads wiki the boogleheads youtube channel boogleheads facebook boogleheads reddit the johncy booglecenter for financial literacy on linkedin and local and virtual chapters and to you listening right now yes you I'm talking to you if you could please take a moment to subscribe and to rate the podcast on apple spotify or wherever you get your podcast and also be sure to leave a review the more listeners who do that the more other folks will find this resource for do-it-yourself investors thank you for checking out this episode of the boogleheads on investing podcast if you want to submit questions for next month's guest check out the boogleheads forms we have a thread going for questions for johnson clemets of the humble dollar who will be
our guest on the next show all link to that thread in the show notes so you can drop your question for johnson clemets until that next show have a great