Episode 1: AI Makes You Better, Until it Doesn't
from Edtervene Talks Hosted by Lydia Elliott, EdD
AI Makes You Better Until It Doesn't Artificial intelligence can make us faster, more productive, and more capable. It can help us write, summarize, analyze, brainstorm, and solve problems in seconds. The benefits are real. But what happens when improved performance begins to replace the very thinking processes that develop expertise? In this session, Dr. Lydia Elliott explores findings from recent research examining the relationship between AI use, performance, and learning. Drawing on evidence that AI-assisted users often demonstrate stronger immediate performance while experiencing weaker independent performance once assistance is removed, participants will examine the difference between productivity and proficiency, performance and development, and assistance and dependency. Using the framework of Experiential Intelligence (ExInt), this session challenges the assumption that better outputs always reflect greater understanding. Participants will explore how AI can enhance performance while simultaneously creating conditions that may hinder the development of judgment, critical thinking, and expertise if used without intentional reflection and engagement. Together, we will examine a critical question for the AI era: If AI makes us better today, what happens when it quietly reduces our ability to perform without it tomorrow? Reference Bastani, H., Bastani, O., Sungu, A., Ge, H., Kabakcı, Ö., & Mariman, R. (2026). Generative AI can harm learning. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.04721 Key Takeaways Distinguish between improved performance and genuine learning. Recognize the signs of cognitive offloading and dependency. Understand how AI can support—or hinder—the development of expertise. Explore the role of Experiential Intelligence in an age of intelligent machines. Identify practical strategies for using AI without outsourcing judgment.
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.