Welcome to the Pipe Liners Podcast, Episode 118, sponsored by IPIPE, an industry-led consortium advancing leak detection and leak prevention technologies to eliminate spills as pipe liners move towards zero incidents. To learn more about IPIPE or to become an IPIPE partner, please visit ipipartnership.com. The Pipe Liners Podcast, where professionals, public eks and industry insiders share their knowledge and experience about technology, projects and pipeline operations. And now your host, Russell Treet.
Thanks for listening to the Pipe Liners Podcast. We appreciate you taking the time and to show that appreciation we are giving away a customized Yeti Tumblr to one listener each episode. This week our winner is Scott Bro with Glaise Services. And Scott, if I didn't get the company name correct, I apologize but I figured because it's an occasion last name, it's an occasion company name.
Just guess it. To learn how you can win this signature prize pack, stick around to the end of the episode. This week we have a first time guest with us, Mike Comstock, who's going to be coming on to talk to us about operator qualification, the subject I've been wanting to learn more about. Mike, welcome to the Pipe Liners Podcast.
Thanks for having me. I appreciate it. Well, it's really a pleasure to have you. One of the things I've been trying to do is get more people on to talk about subjects I don't know much about and happily operator qualification kind of falls in that domain.
So I'm glad to have you on board. I appreciate the opportunity to talk about it. I'm looking forward to it. So maybe as a way to start, you could tell us a little bit about your background and how you got into pipe lining?
Sure. I started in pipe lining in 1984 because I got laid off at a copper mine in Arizona. So I was looking for a new career. And I came upon an opportunity at the City of Mesa in Arizona.
When I went to work there, they gave me a shovel and said, dig a ditch. And I was pretty good at that. So I continued to work my way through over a 30-year career at the City of Mesa and really took the opportunity to learn about what the pipeline industry is about and how it services the needs of the American consumer. Awesome.
So you can literally say I started out as a ditch digger? Yes, sir. In fact, my first boss gave me a shovel and said, don't look up for six months. So I thought that was a pretty good training program at the time.
Yeah, I would say that probably still is a pretty good training program. That's literally taught learning the business from the ground up. Yes, sir. That was a good way to do it.
So how'd you get into operator qualification? Long about the mid-90s, as you recall, there was a series of incidents that occurred around the country where it appeared that either a lack of training or a lack of ability to follow procedures was one of the root causes of those accidents. After there became a discussion nationally about what does it mean to be qualified or trained in the natural gas industry? There was on the job training at that time, but really no formal process put in place.
I happened to be affiliated with the American Public Gas Association and they gave me an opportunity through our city of Mesa's membership with them to participate as a representative of the American Public Gas Association on the committee that was put together by the federal government and the state governments to explore what it meant to have a qualification program for natural gas operators around the country. So I'm familiar with the incidents that occurred in the mid-late 90s and in particular with Bellingham and I think most people in the pipeline business are. What I'm not familiar with is how did that or those incidents spawn? Okay.
I mean, you kind of alluded to that as you're talking about how you got into it. What was the connection between the events and how did operator qualification kind of get invented or defined? That's a pretty good question. And just remember that Bellingham occurred later on in the sequence of events that transpired in the early mid-90s, there was a couple of incidents that centered around the lack of following procedures and processes in an operator's operation and maintenance manual.
And the discussion became is are people adequately trained to follow those procedures or is on the job training sufficient enough to move information, transfer information, and have an understanding of about process and procedures for the work on the natural gas industry. So that that propagated the question and the discussions over the course of the next couple of years, probably from 93 to 94, 95. And it was found that although there was some training out there and actually the code part 192 talked about training and some aspects of identifying how people do their work, but there really never was a formal rule in place. And so the onset of that was organizations like FIMSA and the state, Napster groups, the national or the state chiefs of pipeline safety around the country and then organizations like the American Gas Association, the American Public Gas Association, INGA, and so on got together with representatives to start putting together what this qualification or training rule might look like.
And you want to be careful about aspiring or defining qualification as training because there's different components to the qualification process. It's not just the training rule. So what are those components of qualification? Because I think a lot of people in the business notionally understand OQ, but don't really understand how it came about and why it's put together the way it's put together.
So maybe you could break down the components for us a little bit. Sure. Thanks. I like to describe it as a four-legged stool that's comprised of a knowledge-based component that has the ability for an individual to understand the procedure and to be able to process that procedure while it's being used in the field or in their daily work activities.
There's a skill component or a skill leg that says I have to be able to not only understand the procedure, but I have to be able to apply it. And the ability piece, the third leg of the stool, would be not I have the knowledge. I have the skill. Now I have to demonstrate my ability to perform that procedure or as the code calls it a covered task on a pipeline or pipeline facility.
So I have to be able to demonstrate that ability, giving the knowledge, skill, and ability to do that once I've identified that. I have to be able to identify abnormal operating conditions that may transpire around a procedure or cover task while it is being performed. I have to know what's not right. And I have to understand that and be able to take corrective actions to make sure that the procedure is done correctly.
So just go ahead. I'm sorry, man, but when you when you when you're laying that out and you know, I grew up as a measurement guy, I started out in the business and measurement, the idea of having knowledge, having skill and having the ability to perform that skill, that to me is pretty linear. It's kind of step by step. But when you start talking about the ability to recognize and respond to an abnormal condition, that starts getting exponentially more complex, at least in my experience.
And as they as you apply as an operator or an individual representing an operator on the pipeline, as you apply those skills and abilities, part of the knowledge based component that you gain in understanding those procedures is the recognition of what those AOCs may be. If I can use that acronym, the AOCs, maybe around the procedure that you are actually performing. So it isn't something that you just blindly walk into. It's part of the knowledge based component of the process in identifying and understanding those.
And then in your ability testing or the evaluation of your skills, that component is listed as a criteria for being able to pass or to be able to perform that cover task correctly. So before you actually perform as a qualified operator in the field, those those abilities to understand and react to the terminology is recognized and react to an AOC in the field is well honed and well schooled through your evaluation process in being qualified to perform that cover task. So what kinds of things were initially covered as the OQ rule was being put into place and how has that expanded over time? And just to make sure that the audience understands the OQ rule went into effect, operator qualification became effective in the late 90s.
So it is a mature rule by definition. It's been out there 20 years. There's been some changes to it, but not really significant. If you go back and look at what the federal code outlines as a requirement for performance of an operator qualification process, it centers around a four part test that the operator applies to determine if what the functionality is that the individual is working on is a cover task.
And that four part test is it reads straight out of the code. Is it performed on a pipeline facility? Is it an operation or maintenance task? Is it performed as a requirement of the part?
In other words, part 192 that gives you the guidance for operation of a pipeline or pipeline system? It does finally, does it affect the operation or integrity of the pipeline? If you answer yes to all those questions, you're performing a cover task and the qualification of that individual performing that task is required as part of the regulatory activity followed by the operator. So this may be a little bit out in right field.
So when I think of my experiences, it tends to be more around the control room. And I tend to think of operator qualification as those things that we're doing in the field physically on the pipeline. So am I missing something or is that? The operator qualification piece encompasses a lot of the activities that are found or encompasses all of the activities that are found in part 192.
Control room management certainly has its own separate set of requirements and procedures and processes to follow. But ingrained into the actual qualification rule itself is let's use, for instance, a control room operator. If they're performing a function that is answered yes by all four of those questions, then they would be needed to be qualified in that task that they are performing in addition to the regulation that they're following under control room management. But to your point, a high number, a high percentage of the tasks performed are by nature in the field.
That's where a majority of the work is done. And remember, one other thing, maybe we'll get into this a little bit later, these procedures apply to the operator as well as the contractor who is doing work for the operator. And there's a few nuances regarding that. So if you have a chance to explore that in a little while, I think that'd be a good piece of the conversation.
Yeah, so yeah, we can kind of migrate right to that now, if you like. Yeah, so I think I think, you know, I always try to simplify these things, right? It's so so easy for those of us that work in a particular discipline to kind of get, you know, used to and understand our own jargon. And I try to break that down and kind of get it outside of jargon and get it into kind of normal language.
So I'm going to try and state this in normal language knowing that it's not exactly what's in the code. Basically, I need to be qualified for anything that I'm going to do related to operating or maintaining a pipeline. And to be qualified, I have to have knowledge, skills and ability and the ability to do the task in a way that I can see when the task is going sideways and correct it based on it. Yes, no, you're correct.
You've summarized it very well and and and use the language that is appropriate to the definition of operator qualification. One thing I would I would say the rule itself never addressed new construction activities on the on a pipeline system for an operator. The original rule did not remember that it centers on operation and maintenance tasks. However, over the course and the maturity of the rule, there has been a lot of discussion about inclusion of new construction into the activity base for qualification.
And in fact, two states have gone forward and required new construction to be considered for qualification process. Ohio and California have led that charge over the years though. That's been a point of discussion on how new construction is affected by the activities of individuals putting the pipeline in the ground. I, you know, from my standpoint, given how important construction and in particular, all the record keeping around construction is for the lifecycle maintenance and operation of a pipeline, I think it's pretty easy to make the case that we'll be qualified for doing those tasks as well.
And, you know, there certainly is people that are on that side of the debate or folks with that opinion, there are a lot of processes found within part 192 that require testing and documentation of the pipeline before it becomes active and delivers the molecules of gas to the end user. So you're right. There's a lot of folks who would talk about new construction being added. And then on the other side of the debate are the folks that say, well, we already have mechanisms in place by the code that requires testing and validation of the pipeline service ability before it comes effectively an agent of transferring energy.
So again, the debate moves on. The rule hasn't changed to include new construction, but states have taken action to include that. Yeah. So let's talk a little bit about contractors because you were talking about how this applies to contractors as well.
And, you know, in my simple mind, a definition, I said anyone who's going to do something on the pipeline and that certainly would include contractors. But, you know, I appreciate what you're saying. Operator qualification is not a difficult concept. It is pretty straightforward.
It says that the operator who has procedures for performing work on the pipeline has to apply those procedures through knowledge, skill and ability evaluation. That goes for the contractors who are working on that pipeline system for that operator. They need to be qualified in the operators' procedures or they have to be able to include their own procedures into the operators' O&M manual so that they can be accepted by the operator as a performance of a cover task on items that they qualify to. So again, the contractor has to be qualified to the operators' procedures and follow the same process that is done by the operator.
So what's the, you mentioned earlier that this is a mature rule and it's been around for a couple of decades. What's the status of the rule now in terms of how it's being adopted and utilized? Maybe you could talk to that a little bit. Well, it has been adopted by the operators that are in the US.
They have to follow the procedures in order to and follow the regulation in order to work on the pipeline system and provide natural gas to their customers. The future holds some opportunity for maybe inclusion of new construction as a criteria of the rule itself, making sure that the new generation of pipe liners that are coming on is the Baby Boomers exit and the new generation comes in to perform those functions that they are well-trained and well-qualified to perform those cover tasks as their predecessors have been exposed to. And I find that as I go around the country and work with companies that they focus on assuring the qualification of the individual is significant. There are locations and test locations and site locations that have been set up that mimic the operational process of an operator in the systems that they own and that they train to those before they actually put folks out on the pipeline.
I don't think that on-the-job training is dead. I think that will always be a component of learning the industry. For what it's worth, giving somebody a shovel and say, dig that ditch so we can put that pipe in there is probably a pretty good way to determine how an individual perform in the field or the course of a career. But giving them the knowledge and the skill and the evaluation ability to perform those tasks as they grow in the industry I think is an important concept that needs to be continued by the operators and the contractors around the country.
I think that's absolutely right. It's kind of radical when you think back 20 years ago or longer when most of the training was on the job training. It was kind of passed down. If you're a person that studies safety and you study safety performance, tribal knowledge is always problematic because you don't see how the knowledge transfer changes over time.
I think what OQ does, one of the things it does is it establishes some standards and some baselines for what is the knowledge and what is the transfer. It does. That's a very important aspect of this. It's not the only thing.
No, and I agree with you. It establishes that formal process that goes on. Just my own opinion is the gentleman that taught me about natural gas probably forgot more than I'll ever know. He was a good man and he helped a lot of folks acclimate to how natural gas works and the properties around it and the functionality of a pipeline system.
But there wasn't a formal classroom training. That's what's changed. What's changed from the field into the classroom? Classrooms are an important aspect of it.
We, in our measurement training company, we used to do training on live gas. One of the things that was always interesting to me when you brought in a brand new green technician and you had them working on a meter on their desk. That's all very interesting. You can learn a whole lot.
But when you walked outside and you're going to blow down a 325 psi piece of pipe, that's a whole different experience than working on the bench. There's an aspect of this where the OJ, as you mentioned, the OJT is important. You actually got to see how these things actually work in practice and get some experience with that. Couldn't agree more.
You blow down that size of pipeline and it's like standing next to a jet engine for a little while and it will make a believer out of you. It will. It will. It will.
And for some people, 325 psi is not that much pressure. No, that's service delivery. This is kind of a funny side story. I was doing a project many years ago with a group that was doing natural gas capture off of a trash facility, a dump.
They were capturing the methane off of that and they were talking about the high pressure and the low pressure side of their compressor. I'm like, well, how high is the high pressure side? And they go, oh, it's 20 psi. I'm like, what?
Yeah. Well, it's all relative, right? Everybody has their position. That's for sure.
Well, it's all relative to your experience. That's right. Part of it. So if I'm a person who's kind of doesn't know what operator qualification is and I was trying to put a program in from scratch, what would be your advice?
Let's become familiar with the section of the code, Title 49 Code of Federal Regulations, Part 192, subpart in, qualification of pipeline personnel. Read that, understand it, read the interpretations that are found on the federal website at the FIMSA website. The second thing I would do is address your state regulatory body to find out if there's any nuances that the state has integrated into the qualification of pipeline personnel as part of the regulations to adhere to as an operator. Third, I would talk to individuals who have backgrounds in the qualification field.
And there are a number of very good ones around the country who have spent the better part of two decades defining and understanding how OQ works, how qualification of an individual goes beyond sitting in a seat in a classroom and looking at power points for eight hours and how they have integrated the skill and ability testing into the knowledge base of those procedures. Well, that sounds all very straightforward. It's not a difficult rule. It just takes a little time to enact.
It is a pretty straightforward rule. Well, and I'm guessing you've done this once or twice before, because that all just flowed right off your tongue like you've done it a hundred times. You know, you got to be prepared for the elevator speech. You never know when you get to use it.
Ha! So true. So very true. Well, Michael, look, I appreciate you coming on the podcast.
Before we wrap up, how would somebody get in touch with you if they wanted to ask you questions or reach out for some help on their OQ program? The easiest way is to call me on my cell phone 480-250-0241. My email address is m as in Michael Comstock, C-O-M-S-T-O-C-K, the number one at CoxCOX.net. The company that my business partner and I own is called C-N-M, regulatory pipeline consultants, and we're in Tempe, Arizona.
Great. And you guys, you guys were obviously work on the gas side. And of course, there's OQ issues for the liquids guys too. It's not just the gas guys that get to deal with this.
So do you ever do any work on the liquid side or you pretty much just a gas guy? No, we do. Robert Miller is my business partner. And Robert is the former chief of pipeline safety and the manager of the pipeline safety program for the state of Arizona.
So we have a pretty wide and varied background when it comes to this process. So we collaborate whether we're on natural gas pipelines or the liquids that are out there as well. Okay. Well, great.
Well, look, again, thanks for coming on. And I appreciate it. I certainly learned a few things. I think I actually understand a little bit about what OQ is and maybe even a little bit about how to go about doing it.
So I appreciate you coming on. Perfect. It was an honor. I would appreciate you asking me to be on.
I hope you enjoyed this week's episode of the Pipeliners Podcast and our conversation with Mike Comstock. Just a reminder, before you go, you should register to win our customized Pipeliners podcast JETI Tumblr. Simply visit pipelinerspodcast.com slash win to any or so from the drawing. If you would like to support this podcast, please leave us a review.
You can do that on Apple Podcast, Google Play, Stitcher, SoundCloud, whatever app you use to listen. You can find instructions at pipelinerspodcast.com. If you have ideas, questions or topics you'd be interested in, please let us know at the contact us page at pipelinerspodcast.com or reach out to me on LinkedIn. Thanks for listening.
I'll talk to you next week.