Skip to content
Episode 119: Noam Blum / Tool episode artwork

Jan 31, 2023 2 hr 20 min

Episode 119: Noam Blum / Tool

from Political Beats Hosted by Scot Bertram, Jeff Blehar, Noam Blum

Introducing the Band: Your hosts Scot Bertram (@ScotBertram) and Jeff Blehar (@EsotericCD) are joined by Noam Blum. Noam is Chief Technology Officer at Tablet Magazine and co-host of the Ambitious Crossover Attempt podcast and of All Crossed Out on the Callin app, both of which deal with pop culture, media, and politics. Find him on Twitter at @neontaster. Noam’s Music Pick: Tool Since Political Beats dealt with one of Gen Z's niche musical obsessions last episode in tackling The National, we've decided to double down in the new year and finally go after one of the Millennial generation's more beloved (and also, as we grant on the show, derided for their sincerity) bands with a discussion of Tool. Driven by the lyrical vision of Maynard James Keenan, the guitar geometrics/visualizations of Adam Jones, and the drumwork of Danny Carey, Tool was/is (though "is" is notional proposition, given that they've slowed their work pace to one album a decade) progressive heavy metal in their approach, a genre we haven't covered at all here on the show yet. We have dealt with many of their progenitors, particularly King Crimson (compositionally and musically) and Husker Du (lyrically and spiritually). And one day we'll get to Metallica, we promise. But Tool in many ways represents the final flowering of that line of intellectualized hard rock that began in the '70s, became unfashionable in the '80s, and then reemerged in the '90s. Their heavy sound and emotionally involuted lyrical obsessions would become endlessly imitated by many lesser groups seeking to recreate the intensity of their music, but those would be pale imitations. Here's the genuine article, a tool to use for yourself. Use wisely.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 119: Noam Blum / Tool

0:00 2:20:55
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello everybody and welcome into another edition of political beats a presentation of national review Find us on Twitter at political underscore beats. We're also on Facebook Subscribe to our feeds for new episodes getting through Apple podcast Google podcast stitcher to an oral right to national review calm Listen leave reviews were possible and help others find the program. We also asked for your help over at patreon.com political beats support us support the show help it stay ad-free as it is right now We have entry level support for voting privileges mid-level for early access and higher audio quality on the programs and our upper level best Disfriends for early access higher audio quality monthly exclusive content episodes remastered episodes playlists and much more all of that over at patreon.com Slash political beats we now come to the part of the program where we thank our patreon supporters specifically and individually for helping us Keep the show on the air stay ad-free. Thank you Simon Goldstone also Anthony Velasquez Richard Anderson Chris Coro Brian Roach Susan B CJ box a long time first time Charles Evans Zach Galleon and Vin Thank all of you for supporting us over at patreon.com slash political beats We could not do it without you.

My name is Scott's Bertram Bond Beyond Twitter at Scott Bertram my tag team partner standing by as always Jeff Blair Jeff. How are you? Could be better Scott be honest with you. I got a little bit enthusiastic last night and I opened my third eye here at home It's not going so well There's a lot of blood.

I'm not gonna lie and you know the worst part of all is I'll tell you the worst part of all is This one needs a contact lens prescription as well Jeff is on Twitter at esoteric CD And welcome our guest on today's program He is chief technology officer at tablet magazine Cohost of the ambitious crossover attempt podcast and of all crossed out on the call-in app both of which deal with pop culture media and politics All fun things he is on Twitter at neon taster. He is no I'm bloom. No. I'm thanks for what you're joining us.

Thanks guys Thanks for having me on it's been a long time coming well Yes, we're episode 120 or so we finally got down to this part of the list No, I'm first we get the floor to you tell people a little bit more about your podcast about tablet about how you got there and how you became involved in the Political ecosystem Well, I mean I kind of come from a different kind of world I I come from the music in kind of production world But politics is sort of like my family business to to kind of roll your eyes at a phrase And when I eventually life brought me to DC my Twitter Which was sort of political kind of started to mesh with my professional life And that's kind of how I got into that's how I met Jeff And that's how I ended up at tablet and in this kind of world of both sort of political social tweeting and also working It's a weird space we live in isn't it? Yes Yeah, and I also I think about the the people that we would you know would have drinks with back in like 2017 And how few of those groups would tolerate each other at a bar table now five or six years later? It's pretty strange I mean that was the entire idea is that like yeah, let's forget about all that Let's let's talk about you know, let's talk about Stinkfist instead. Yeah, exactly and my podcast the ambitious crossover attempt And also the all cross out which is just like a live an additional live version of that show is about you know The news of the day But we try to keep it interesting and fun and funny and also Pepperine you know TV or movies or whatever's going on just to keep it not super dreary And no one is here today to talk about well tool tool a band with many fans We've had a few calls for two episodes through the years on Twitter and Boy, there's a lot of ways to come at this band and we'll cover as many as possible throughout the course of the show But no, I'm back to you.

Tell us how you got into tool why you like them and why other people should care about this music We're about to talk about today. Okay, so the story of how I got into tool is a little bit The story of how I became more of a general music fan and not just a proper or metal head We're talking about early to mid 90s. I grew up in Israel and not just in Israel specifically in Jerusalem Which isn't wasn't it wasn't and isn't the sort of cultural hub of Israel that is more sort of the Tel Aviv area It's not the center of the universe in terms of like hot new musical trends Well, but also like a meaning if I the thing I'm getting at here is that for me to buy my first tool I will not to go drive to another city to buy it out of like a specialty music store but But I actually got into tool through the fact that in about 96 or 97 that thereabouts I was a huge fan of creepy interesting music videos That was sort of the angle that brought me into tool because they're sort of famous for that as well And staying up late at night watching alternative music blocks on like MTV to which we would get in Israel and coming across out of the video for sober Just being completely mind-boggled and blown away by this bizarre HR giger-ish stop-motion night-marry kind of thing The music wasn't really what I was into at the time But then I went as I got more into them. I discovered that their newer materials Which were brand new at that time were a lot more kind of in line with what I liked and that sort of snowballed from there Now before I move on, you know, I'm gonna talk you guys about I have a long complex thesis about what a tool where tool stands for me And this sort of the legendary of music from this era, but what do you think no?

I mean, I mean, what why are they the band that speaks to you? I think they've the beauty of tool is that they've always or at least for the past, you know, 20 plus years have existed in Essentially the same kind of state, right? They never and I don't I don't want to talk about this in sort of the cringe way But like they didn't quote unquote commercialize and they didn't they didn't you spoke out weezer on this podcast recently, right? Yes, it was a memorable episode.

Yeah, tool is not gonna be covering Africa by total anytime soon, right? We're gonna talk about the tool cover later, but I didn't want it was a memorable one. Yeah, yeah And so and so they've always existed in this place where they didn't need big radio play They didn't need the traditional form of fame They always existed on the backs of like a really dedicated fan base a devotion to their own style and authenticity And the thing that drew me into them. It's somewhat of a complete experience Right art music as art and here you have a the visual component was always so integral much more than I almost any other Musical act that I can think of and it is expressed not only in their live show But yeah, you're sitting down and you're looking at this amazing artwork in an album as you're listening to the psychedelic soundscapes And it does provide the sort of a multi sensory experience.

I Have I mean, I'm sure Scott when he goes last it is going to drop a giant bomb on the party here so Before we get there, I'm gonna try to explain a little bit about what what tool means to me or at least the way I think about them This is a band that I was aware of I'd say 96 97 now that was when Anna I came out But I probably didn't come to you know to know them until the era of 2002 I went lateralist hit and then that was hanging out on the radio I had for us remember I was like I was normally isolated from music You know during this era given my my classic rock proclivities I heard that music and I liked it actually and the reason I liked it is because I had been prepared for it If I had heard it at its time I never have gotten it. I never I would have actually run screaming from it in fact because you know This was I was into the like you know, snap you put pop, you know I can like really like clever little kinks like songs about village greens Do you do you remember Walter when you were star struck and went off to become a star? I got a stuff and now you know if I'm listening to like stink fist or something like that That would not have been my mood in 1997 But in 2002 I had heard King Crimson and that's important because King Crimson is probably tools greatest or most important at least sonic Progenitor King Crimson specifically during the 1972 74-year-of from Larks tongues and Aspect through to red We did a show with Dave Wigle about them way back in the day Got three years ago now it was great episode and I love that band so much I actually think Crimson is the greatest one of the three greatest live bands of all time But that hard metallic and avant-garde approach is something that prepared me for what I guess is a genre that I've really had No other entrance into up until that point. I'd like to punk and I'd like speed core and hardcore stuff like Oscar do You know black flag stuff like that from you know the early 80s, but I really have a lot of time for the metal stuff I respected it.

I knew my Metallica, you know I'd grown up with master of puppets and stuff like that just in the household But of course they turned to like you I guess pop slop after the black album So I wasn't really paying attention to their recent releases and that made the genre even seem like that much more of a joke So I never had clicked with it until I understood what it was they were doing tools doing something different than what those other bands were doing They were taking a lot of the influences by the way, you know If you think to came out of nowhere and you think it's just King Crimson then listen to some early Metallica albums You know listen to Slayer and Pantera some of the more thrash stuff that is messier and it's not as precise and as tight But those are the sounds the guitar sounds, you know, you know that explain this band Um, and I really love that I really love their fusion of hardcore and you know Heavy metal sounds with progressive styles and a willingness to experiment with different kind of solid sonic palettes You'll notice as I've talked about tool here I haven't said anything about major James Keenan or his lyrics because that of course is a very divisive part of tool and their music Their legacy. I have to tell you I've never really been on board with this trip I know there are many of our fans who grew up with this music and it helped them through their adolescence The way like the people of Nine Inch Nails for similar reasons the way that frankly I love Radiohead, okay Radiohead was that band for me. Everyone's got to have one of those bands growing up, right? Something like that that they relate to there's like oh man Jeremy spoken class today Like I'll imagine the kids in 1982 who were thinking that oh that would have been so cringe but that that void had been filled for me So when I came to tool I wasn't really into the lyrical trip of Manor James Keenan as a very personal one and we started write these inspirational songs two at times and he's Exploring you know spiritualism and mysticism, you know with his politics all folded in there.

It's just like interesting. It's window dressing I love him as a singer. I think his voice is fantastic I think it's one of the things that makes tool stand out just as a sonic proposition that Manor's voice can be that loud metal Streets that you associate with frankly a bunch of other bands which are about to become really mainstream Unfortunately, but he's delicate as well. He's got a touch a light musical touch with his voice He isn't afraid to sound vulnerable and frail at times He's got beauty in his voice and I do appreciate that and I really love the guitar work of Adam Jones But before I stop rambling from one I just gotta say this is like Danny Carey's band to me This is one of the best drumming bands that I've heard in the last 30 years And if you're gonna ask me one reason why I still jump to all the time it is just to hear his incredible drum work Well, I mean if you look at if you look at the place that each of those band members play in the world of people who Practice that skill right meaning if you look how manor is seen by vocalists and how Adam Jones is seen by guitar players Danny Carey out of all of them is someone that everybody who plays the drums knows Danny Carey like that's not even it's not Like every guitar magazine People make fun of like oh man like you know I just couldn't carry the way people used to like you know like you know crazy over You'll hear a frosh.

It's the same kind of a thing, but he's just I can't I can't mock it man He's so good, but you don't even need to be I watched a really cool video There's you know how they have those like a X reacts to Y kind of things right? Right and so there was a channel where they take like a really good drummers and Chambers chambers was like one of the greatest fusion drummers ever to and he knows who Danny Carey's but he's never heard of Our of tool music ever And so yeah, he's he's that and I so I understand why you say that Video is great because you hear him like working his way through it like on the fly like he's never heard it before He's got to like come down with the track. He's like yeah, this is really good technically It's not my style of music and yet. He's such a gifted trouble.

He can still sort of like you know man It's just way it's a really unbelievable unbelievable and yeah, and a thing you said about me and I think it's interesting to think about Is that I think people don't understand this is something I learned when I was studying production I didn't learn like in a book learned through experience Seeing the vocals the lyrics and the vocals there's more to it than just the words you sing and whether or not you're on pitch because there are a lot of Secondary skills to it that I think may not excels in for example like meter and and finding things that sort of sound good lyrically You know the Mars Volta And also Seaboross two examples of bands that have songs that are in gibberish Yes, he was literally sings in a made for those who don't know they sing in a made-up language called Hope Landick instead of Icelandic It's weird, but it kind of works. Yeah, it's about creating something abstract and yeah Cedric the singer of Mars Volta has Occasionally made up words peppered in if you listen to the Mars Volta song elevators most of the lyrics There are sort of made up portamento words that are just meant to make you feel a thing Right and so and so that's not he's not that's not you can't say like the lyrics of it or good They're evocative, but they don't really mean anything which is interesting and so he's This is nothing new John Anderson. Yes another band everyone makes fun of for having like ridiculous lyrics They didn't by the way John Anderson's lyrics are far worse than Maynard's they're lyrics are all very slick thought out and sincere They're very coherent, you know, they're actually very intelligent But it's bad bling nonsense about witches and livers and his point is like it's just supposed to be almost like a vocal accompaniment to the music Think of it as another instrument in the mix and when you think of a voice as an instrument in an ensemble and not just singing its own words Then it takes on a secondary meaning in a band I think that also explains why Keenan made it a point to not actually put the lyrics to any of these albums on the actual albums All artwork instead. Yeah, I like I think he I just only found this out my research.

He looked it up He's like now he did you just print it online later You go find it because he's like most people aren't gonna get it anyway, which I also I owned I used to own all of the special edition releases of the two albums until my mom threw them out Right and so I can go I can go down the line and tell you what so the the animal went the undertow one did not have something super Spectacular to it, but starting with Emma that one had like a lenticular cover so that when you like, you know Those things that are pretty yeah, you kind of tilt it left and right and it showed like a kind of a burning flame thing The latter Alice one was a series the booklet was a series of transparencies that each had like a Like a layer of like the human body and you would like peel it away to reveal like the meridians and the chakras underneath Then 10,000 days had like a view master kind of thing where you would you kind of prop it up with like these two lenses and a Piece of Alex Grey's psychedelic art that you kind of look through and fear an oculum the current one I'm looking at it right now They they shipped it with a there's a little video player inside the CD box that plays this weird animation psychedelic animation and music like on a loop I know like that's really best spoke. I had no idea I just listened to it on you and that video to my the last time I checked nobody had managed to like extract that video from that So you can't like go on YouTube and watch it like you need this thing to do that which is very kind of cool in this era I actually really do like that actually So actually I'm glad that we spent a lot of time talking not only about you know the nature of you know You know Keynon's lyrics, but also the visual aspect to which is so Adam Jones primarily controls that we'll talk about the videos a little bit later As we go before we move on before I try to say I'm set the scene Scott you want to run on the parade I'll do my best. No, this is a this is a band and someone made the point last night before we take this last night on Twitter It doesn't seem like it's really upscot-sounding and they're right You know progressive progressive metal not to the genres that you know I'd check the box office being too terribly interested in and yet It's two tools credit that there are bits and pieces here that I really did grab onto when going through and listening back through the catalog I had mentioned in our initial email there two things I really knew about tool before we died in here And I knew I knew the general shape of tool right before I listen to each of the albums prepping for this episode But the two things I really knew is when I was a radio DJ in college tools one of the three most requested bands that people would call in to Here so telling it's amazing rabid fan base and if you want the other two it was fish and Dave Matthews band So rabbit fan base and then the way I was introduced to who I am quite certain is through beavis and butt head Right their reaction to the sober video in which but had says whoa if my hand moves that fast. I'd never leave the house That was my introduction to tool.

I also know exactly what shot in the video Just talking about where the creature kind of looks at its own hand and it's like shittering really quickly right near the end So that was my initial introduction to to tool now on the band it's not long time Let's know I love drummers and so I automatically have this affection for a lot of what they do because of how talented Carriers and lyrically Jeff is right in that there are there are there are times I have no idea what's going on There are times I have no idea what he's trying to say there are times early in the career where I'm actually kind of I want to say repulse but I'm pushed away by by the I have a story about that I can't tell him to continue and but but there are times when I know exactly what he's trying for and I think he's really got something I think there is something kind of deep in what he's trying to get to and there are whole albums in which there are these sort of themes He's trying to explore it works in places. I really find myself liking those lyrics in many places I like the fact that I don't care right that they don't care what you think about them They don't care how often the albums come out. They don't care about radio play very much They don't do interviews made or just more interested in his wine business and promoting that in various places And I like what no one said about music is art and art in music these guys really care about the way things are presented They care about that's why I hate it when people call them just quote pretentious I'm like no no they're not pretentious. They actually they're trying for something that's hard They should be allowed that kind of pretentious and they mentioned that a wine if you watch the documentary that was made about Maynard's wine journey called Blood Into Wine I walked away from the wine of course of course I walked away from it feeling like a lot of his pretension is an act I'm just saying they get it they're in it in a way.

Yeah. Yeah, I think so at least a little bit because this is more of a perfect circle thing It's a tool side project that went very political at one point Had an entire album that was like about the rock war and Bush should be cover album That was a cover album remember it well But unlike the wezer one they actually did they actually have some a couple of like just all time great covers there The Imagine a cover of the worst song ever written imagine by John Lennon somehow made amazing by turning it into like a dissonant song And when the levy breaks really good cover on that album, but yeah, but but yeah with tool it never got To the to the level of like explicit current thing politics. I think I mean their biggest you know Their biggest political target was around Hubbard near as I can tell They really took a piece out of them on me. Oh, gee, by the way, we'll get to that You know, I just I just you know a fair assessment of what tools flaws are as I said, you know I'm not into his lyrical trip So I can't rate that as a flaw or a virtue simply because it's just not for me, you know It doesn't sing to me, but as a vocalist I like them a lot I think uh tools flaws generally fall down to repetition and then I think repetition maybe a flaw that that lies at the core of the Entire of heavy metal genre, you know, the you know the hammering riffs is like Do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do do it.

It has a very physical effect on a listener Which is almost like intoxicating which is why adolescent boys go crazy for it But when you're not on a lesson boy, you're like, okay, don't bore us get to the chorus, right? And that's one of the things that king crimson made them a singular band Which is that they never wasted your time a song like fractured 11 minutes long that it went through like seven different progressions It had every reason to be that length Toolbar less disciplined than king crimson are I will say that and then you don't get it's just it's not even really a knock-on tool Because it's saying you're not as good as like the Beatles or a band that I consider to be like really like competing in their sphere The effect is a little different like if I'm listening something like dream theater, right? Which I didn't dare bring up thank you. I'm Scott is thanking I was thinking like porcupine tree.

Oh, no, I mean porcupine tree are also very closely linked in my mind with both tool and drink But we can of course they get into that but not but dream theater move through like you said 15 different iterations of something throughout an 11-minute song and tool Don't but the effect is different like dream theater is like you got to you got to concentrate It's like right it's like the difference between an ass car track and a formula one track, right? You know you could just tune out and just kind of flow with this like rep repetitive riff Whereas with dream theater, it's like if you don't pay attention There's a right turn all of a sudden you're like in the you're in the divider, right? Exactly that's a really great analogy. All right, listen now We've set this whole inch a lot of up let me just basically introduce and there's only one other thing I want to say is this is by way of trying to understand tool if this music sounds alien to you One thing that helps to understand who they are is to understand where they came from musically And I think also maybe to understand the scene that they were on which is Los Angeles in the early 1990s And these are people who very tellingly all pretty much drifted out to LA because they wanted to be a part of the entertainment industry Adam Jones was working.

I was doing like set design stuff This is how we ended up doing meat puppets for the videos later on he acquired these skills I know that Keenan was doing it too I think they got Dan Carrey in the band because he just happened to be living down the hall Like while they were doing auditions and like you know he showed up to drum for them They're like okay, I'm a mowy-headed how often that's the story like how often the guy upstairs the guy down the hall ends up being a perfect Make for the next 30 years of your life. How does that happen? Well, and also like you know with with a with a hindsight of decades You see what kind of soup it was it was like a hate ashberry kind of situation and if you look at their history Yeah, it's like oh they rubbed elbows with bands like Green Jelly and Tom Morello and a Machine I mean apparently made it was like the guy that the ever thinking would be the you know They were like are we gonna go with Morello or we're gonna go with Keenan and then with Morello There's always those and if you look if you ever do if you guys have you done Queens of the Stone Age I don't know no we had if you ever do that's also a whole other world of like these people knew these people and desert sessions And they played a little bit with these people in this EP It's this whole cross breeding of people and they were also assuming in the same milieu He's which is rebellion against what was currently you know commercially dominant mind-deadingly dominant in the charts And of course if it's 1990 in 1991, what is it's how about the power? No, it's also but if you're playing the kind of music that these guys are playing it's guns and roses And I sure what it's white snake and poison and it's the hair metal stuff that of course Nirvana would be the ones to actually sleep away But it wasn't like they were the only people rebelling against it They weren't the it wasn't the firm it was not brewing merely in Seattle All right people in Los Angeles had their discontent as well and those who were in this metal scene took it in this direction Instead of going for like the glam dump sort of pompous November rain kind of stuff which I did I still love all that slop We have a great episode on GNR What these guys wanted to do instead was go back to it But they thought it was like early Metallica and it's almost like a comically appropriate handoff point because this is right when Metallica Was with themselves going for like the big chart success and we're ceasing those prog epics and that that 80s era We think of like Kill them all right the lightning master puppets They were turning into load and reload for God's sakes tool fill that gap They wanted to do something more intellectual and more sort of clearly ambitious progressively ambitious and the funny thing about it is that They're earliest stuff.

Yeah, there's an early demo tape which we don't really have to talk about Incredible enough but all those songs reappear between their first EP and their first album So we should start with their first album which is called opiate and it's 1991 and they already sound clean as a whistle tight As a tick and already have all the kind of lyrical texts that are gonna make some people roll their eyes guess what the opiate is people That's right. It's religion. I mean as is predictable as it gets it's you know sort of you know very predictable like you know Counterculture slogan hearing the early 90s Los Angeles scene, but it doesn't matter I think this music is actually shockingly well for it's a mix of two live songs which might as well be studio You would never know the difference except for the moment where he's like good that bar Yeah, too. We have to we have to get out of here Yeah, and by the way you want to talk about how fully formed they sound the the final song on that opiate the sort of the the Try the title track right they re-released it this year.

They sort of redid it. Oh, they did It's called like opiate squared. I don't know if you want how you would how you would verbalize it It's opiate with like a little to two super script to and it's it's slightly slowed down It's slightly heavier on the guitar because that's what they sound like but like the song is essentially the same But what I was gonna say about the live tracks is it also shows this kind of um affinity for Like a black flag Rollins band hardcore Shows, you know like I actually in the mid 2000s I went to a metal festival in Belgium and there were a bunch of like New York era hardcore bands are madball stuff like that and And that vibe reminds me a lot of this the way Yeah, the energy that they kind of command in the shows and stuff it felt very much like that and they play stuff like 15 BPM quicker live than they do on the album just as they want you to go absolutely nuts Yeah, that's something about tools audience is people always talk about how I be the intensity of a tool fan base can sometimes be creating But the sincerity is real and the reason they're so serious because this band does tap into something on those live shows which ironically enough The live evidence on record is very scant and almost intentionally mysterious. They do not have a lot of live stuff out there But uh, yeah, you get the intensity the purity of it has that punk purity I think of like, you know, like minor threats straight-edge hardcore kind of stuff It's like we're gonna have and again, you know, updated to the modern era We're gonna have a religious experience here, but we don't believe in religion.

Um, by the way I'll just say for the studio tracks here the obvious highlight for me is part of me that is a pop it I mean, that's a damn catchy chorus. That's a damn catchy hook. Uh, they stopped writing, you know, this briefly This concisely very quickly. It's kind of a shame because they actually had a knack for a catchy hook I don't think that first one sweat is all that bad either.

Oh, no, this is good. I mean the thing that strikes me about this is the The lyrics and the lyrics and the lyrics that's why I tell my story. Okay, you go first I just the lyrics in a way that's hard to ignore because they are in your face They are juvenile. They're mean and they're not kind of as they would down the road a little bit the kind of funny You know in-joke sort of mean this they're just really mean and not insightful and Look, I can I can maybe do like one or the other when you pair these juvenile profane lyrics with sort of the the the the Rollins sort of speed metal attack It sounds like you're actually trying to hurt someone.

Yeah, and I man in my entire life I've never actively sought that out when I'm trying to listen to music. That's I've never ever ever like Live track jerk off when I should play gone and shoot you myself because I'm tired of waiting or uh even on hush Which thematically is about censorship, you know in a pressure in a way Is presented so over the top in your face lyrically that I still have a hard time listening to it and getting to the message Okay, so the story I'm gonna tell you and it actually does have an interesting follow up a little bit later in the episode is that You know as always, you know when we're preparing for these shows I play this stuff as you know around the house Right I put it on my my wife will walk in and out doing things she walked in and I had this ep on Like it's like a week ago. This is the first time this has ever happened a lot of times she'd be like, oh you're doing willy Nelson this week. That's nice.

She was a little offended She was like that is horrible. That's a horrible thing to say to anyone I've never heard her do that like I watch not a blue nose But she was actually taking a back by the viciousness there you could never you wouldn't nobody would ever describe tools music as a Pleasant right and I said that is actually a I think to be quite dreamy But you're never you're never far off from like an avo a sonic avolin. She doesn't like a quiet songs. You're like you don't Yeah, be careful.

There's a right here and going up But yeah, it's funny that you said that because I've never had I've never seen my wife have that reaction to any of the stuff We listen to um and I kind of had I was I brushed it off I was like wow, whatever, you know like you know I'm a guy who can listen to the reeds singing about heroin Junkie murders all day. I'm into it, but uh she had points And it's something that they actually moved away from pretty quickly not immediately but sort of in steps over time now that they're old Man, they're not doing that. I just has 90s edginess. I'm sure he would I'm sure if I'm sure manor It has probably even spoken about this way.

I mean that was actually why it was important for me to locate them within the context That the rest of the music going on around them because you have to understand this is almost an adolescent y'all Of rebellion it is just like ha ha ha we're gonna shock the squares But we're gonna shock the squares with with shockingly well put together music and chops And that's the thing if you could just imagine this is an instrumental album where it's just a voice You're not gonna have a problem with it. I least if you like if you have my tastes Um, but yeah, those lyrics do do sometimes get to you But this was just the beginning for them because what they were really doing is working on at the same time really that this came out They were working on their debut album. They're never gonna move this fast again between releases Um and that of course is 1993's undertow now. I have again a lot of thoughts about this one This is one I came back too much much later in life.

I didn't hear this one. It's like 2010 I heard enema and lateralis. I always say lateralis. Is it lateralis?

Do you think it's lateralis? I think yeah Well, I guess I'll have to change it on the fly lateralis because it's kind of Latin, you know, it sort of has that I get it like I heard those at the time. I didn't hear undertow I went back to undertow and surprise surprise, you know early tool It's more concise and consistent as a virtue as you know with me. What do you guys think?

I also sort of go back to it after it. I mean again sober was the song that I kind of got me into tool But because at that time enema was already out and then came stinkfist and the title track from that album Both of which really great songs and had the exactly the type of music video that like I was craving at the time I then kind of moved forward with their stuff and only then went back to listen to it years later And it was talking about that sober music video right now Let's let's just talk about Adam Jones's propensity to insert bizarre enough setting beat puppets into videos and H.R. Key Gressed puppetry heeps. So there yeah, so there's there's a there are a few tool videos So I think there's five or six of them.

I could I could kind of offhand name them It's there's sober. There's stinkfist and enema then there's a parable and parabola Which is like a dual song and also schism from that album also has a video of it and then for 10,000 days there was Um Uh there was one too that I'm not I'm not lining up right now, but uh, and by the way, we're gonna get to we're gonna get to it We'll talk about that but yeah like that video again. It's sort of stop motion Has all these very bizarre. It's think of think of like a low rent the nightmare before christmas except very nightmarish Right like jack right yeah.

Oh Scott. Did you watch this thing? Oh sober? Yeah, I've seen the video.

Yeah. Yeah, I mean I was new to me So I mean I was just like oh great. That's one of these views of fun and fun. I guess Oh, what was he a guy was I missed that and the thing is is that like this is now We've completed the trifecta of 90s bands offsetting video Discographies because we did afghan wigs and we did nine inch nails and now we have two and they really just like messing with our heads I am just an embassy.

I will only complicate you trust in me and fall as well I will find a center in you. I will show it up and wait I Two videos one of the few times. I was like one of the memorable times MTV actually had it involved in censorship Tom Petty's you don't know how it feels. They've emerged out the joint and when the stink fist video was released MTV Just called it track one they would not use the term stink fist when promoting that video Well for good reason yes Well, what do we think about undertow though because this is an album where I have to say they're still writing songs that well I mean I guess I could imagine here it's always gonna sound fun to our largely conservative audience when I say well The two of the hottest tracks on this are called prison sex and sober Really flaming grooves.

I recommend them highly. Oh, pretty accurate prison sex boy. I actually great one also has a fantastic music video I apologize to prison sex for forgetting Amazing now one reminds me of the scary part of Toy Story where they go to the bully's house and he has all the weird Frankenstein mannequins together. That's exactly what that is a bunch of Frankenstein mannequins evil toys Yes, it's very nightmarish um and yes It is it is hard to get into some of their later tracks like a hooker with a penis You know and I said it's that's always the dichotomy of tools you have a song about Opening your third eye to the chakras of the universe followed by a track like that So what do you think of this album debut?

How do you rate it? Oh, are we doing a re-rating things? Are we doing things comparatively? I mean, you know, I'm going through these one by one.

You know having having circled back to it I think as a like if you want to judge that as their like debut album I think it's one of the strongest ones that I know just in terms of it being like a An artistic statement that they never really back down from they only took further right? They never were like oh our next album is gonna be three and a half minutes songs because we want to do something more basic I don't know whatever like they that was there like a vision statement Uh, and yeah, they're still they're still doing that I would say one of the differences from the EP to under toe is an understanding that they could control themselves in the way the music is presented beating So that rage and rawness and fury that they wanted to release could be controlled until it detonated And there's some of that in silver right the the verses are are somewhat language And then you sort of get that explosion of the pre-chorus into the course and there are a few places here Where you sort of have that dynamic working not quite the soft loud dynamic like we would associate with some of the grunge Axon and nirvana kind of perfected but just just being able to control What they what they wanted to accomplish controlling that anger or rage or the musical explosion that was sort of just waiting around the corner lyrically It's not as profane. It's not as juvenile as the debut or as the EP But they don't quite move all that far away. There's stuff like swamp song which to just point I think swamp song musically Might be my favorite thing on undertow Lyrically, I'm you know less impressed about this song about how easy it is to get lost in a ball And I hope it sucks you down and sort of wishing this this badness upon someone else Negativity of it.

Yeah, right If you understand he had a really miserable shot out of it Those who aren't aware apparently is you know, he's really unhappy relationship with the stepfather his mother died He was very young and all this this actually was in a coma for a long time. That's where it can't that's where 10,000 Exactly, but to my point earlier, you know right after that a very soon after that is a song that four degrees And there's some really I think beautiful sentiments in here locked up inside of you Like the calm beneath castles is a cavern of treasures that no one has been to let's go digging And it's a theme that would be returned too many times the idea of finding yourself or finding You know peace or enlightenment, but you have something like swamp song coming just before something like four degrees in which I think You know, manor is getting somewhere is figuring out where he wants to go with the lyrics again musically Something like bottom or crawl away. It's almost grungy and it's riffage Now the bass placements and the prominence of the bass riffing is certainly more on a tool song than say something like stone-toupled pilots But the riffage on bottom or crawl away is kind of similar A waste of Henry Rollins. Yeah, no really I was gonna I was gonna push back into that I actually like a lot well that's how because and Scott's on a control actually think this reminds me first of all I like I artists like Henry Rollins and like Keenan himself I like seeing them show up on other projects There's a one of the the deaf tones one of their favorite songs of mine has Keenan on it's called the passenger But uh Henry Rollins has a song called liar Liar This has this has a lot of that liar energy to it and you set self-control that reminded me of it because They kind of they slow it way down in the middle and they have this like Henry Rollins intellectualizing kind of section But and it's meant to like it kind of builds and builds and builds and then it just comes back into like this sort of screaming uh refrain And I like that I thought that was because yeah, it is a it's a weird and when you're coming from like a metalhead Background that idea of like all of a sudden in the middle of your like grind you gotta stop No, no, hold on we gotta make a quick point quiet now back to your energy It's got to interrupt you all the time.

No, I think that was about it in terms of points I wanted to make it's it's a more muscular in places I still think that the production on the EPM here is not as muscular as it would be later on I think they figured out the way to make themselves sound even better and really highlight the individual Instruments and and how good most of them are on those instruments the base player would be replaced I think just after this album um, but I think the production here is a little it's a little not soft but It's not as dynamic as it would be on future albums Well, I mean speaking of the production idea Before I get to the production, I would like to say one final point about undertow Which is that one thing you can really appreciate it about it is it's it's uh, you know intelligent brevity You know, it's at 69 minutes. This is as short as a tool I will ever be This is going to be a recurring theme of one of my complaints about the band is that you know anything about me from listening to this show You know, I really like albums that do not go on too long I also like albums that have the courage to take time to you know calm things down give you a little A pause in the inter musical interludes which tool does a lot of and yet, you know Every one of these records coming up is an 80 minute proposition if not more, okay So that it makes all of them rather dense, um, you know a dense slog and this is the end A thing we've talked about during the show many times is the curse of the 90s the curse of the cd age Where you know just the expansion to that capacity, uh, maybe forced or helped bands indulgence some of their less You know impressive instincts in terms of throwing everything they had onto it instead of you know less being more Interestingly, like I always felt like that length almost lent itself to like a side B side listening experience where you would listen to half the album Right take a break and then look at the other half Well, then there you go. That's the way you think about it. Fine.

They just listen into two records Yeah, that's all you're doing and of course this brings us to two tools follow up album The second album which is really the landmark record for them. This is the one that broke them big It took three years and one thing they did and just talking about this Scott was mentioning how their production would improve Well, it proves a lot when they get David botryl who is the producer of many many things It's been involved in a lot of great art throughout his career But had most recently done king crimson's reunion out frack. So we're gonna be discussed on our episode It's a great reunion out a lot of great stuff in there with Adrian Baloo singing and um He comes in and he gives tools next album enema a sound that is first of all both in keeping with undertow But a just an obvious step forward and it's a step forward that matches the ambition of the band So this is as I complain just five minutes ago like 70 months 79 minutes and 13 seconds or something like that It's ridiculously long. I don't actually mind it on this album This is my mind.

They're clearly their greatest album and even though I have no Purchase with whatever lyrical themes that may not is on about when it comes to like whether it's you know frankly You know third eyes enemones or stink wrists or if you know, you know How many chromosomes the human body might eventually evolve into or yunging in shadows and all the stuff it sounds like you know A guy who never went to college. Certainly dropped acid started reading books at the library It's it's got a bit of that to me lyrically if I'm gonna criticize it But everything else about this musical is so impressive and I think first and foremost what leaps out to me is how they have developed an ability to create textures This is an album where like a lot of the best songs Beguessing with me with two minutes. It's just a slow build just percussion And I don't know if it's Carrie who does it or if it was you know He was given the ideas of samples were done by other people But some of the percussion work on this record is some of the best and most interesting stuff in the entire 1990s Yeah, the tabla drums which is like indie and indie instrument. Yeah, he I think tool did for the table is what the Beatles did for the sitar Yeah, no, I know but it's less it's like it's less associated people here sitar now They think like oh Beatles right um This is really well put what you said now like the idea of textures and the idea of all sound like it's almost like a transition from mono to stereo Which it isn't but you know, it has that kind of it's always A sonic palette so much that it doesn't feel repetitive when they get heavy They've got another mode and a gear to shift into which is really quite fascinating And I can think of two other albums that uh two other bands who made a similar transition I mean a radio had made it not from Pablo honey to the bends but from the bends to okay computer I think and I love the bends but they they kind of step up their ability to do a soundscape You know like on a major upgrade and I think muse did that as well between showbiz and origin symmetry From just a band that had guitar and a bass and a drum to this where you're thinking like what is what's making the sound even right?

That's scott before I you know I dive into this will look now I'll say this that I get why the lyrics and it's almost like it wants to be aggressively Offensive right the thing is called anima. Anyway, okay. I know what that means of course What you don't mean it also means anima which is the Latin word for spirit Which takes us into that weird union obsession that he's pursuing right now And then of course what's the elite singles called stinkfist crying out loud track one cooker with a penis is a major highlight of the record Uh and you think to yourself Why is this just something that kids buy to offend their parents or like, you know, is this just needless provocation? And I say I could get why that just would push people away from the outset But I'm telling you the substance musical here is superb Especially when the song anima is about how l.a.

Should fall into the notion Well, but I mean everyone's having these Warren's even was writing about that back in 1976. Anyway, scott Yeah, what are your thoughts to start? I agree with you. I think it's their best album and there's a lot I like on here And I think in the way it's the fulcrum From where they go from you know What what they began as and where they came from and where the lyrical aspirations have made it Aren't quite As far away from as grasps as they would be And you don't get some of the I have some critiques on some future albums in terms of length and how they go about Oh, yeah, how they go about organizing some of those songs here.

It's not uh, it's not over the top I think most of the time has earned some longer songs are very very good So I think this was their best album. I like Uh a few things are so eulogy one of the cool things about eulogy is how it opens in my mind the first time I hear this song It is the song so the song sold eulogy I hear the the hammering of letters into a tombstone You know like a hammer and chisel hammering letters into a tombstone. That's what I hear and that it evolves from there It's like cans Ethological forgery series. That's a pretty obscure reference, but if you're a prog fan you'll know it I mean it's seriously they would do these things where they made it sound like imitations of like tribal music you hear in documentaries Like this sounds like tribal drumming in the background.

It sounds very almost for a eulogy There's something very I don't know very primitive about it. That's the power it draws on Yeah, it's very weird. It's a very weird sonic thing. There's a little horn.

It's like a zirna horn and something like that You know that thing and I'm not listening to this is so fascinating and interesting Scott we cut you off. Okay. I got it. Uh hooker with the penis We do that occasionally around here at the old radio station with power so I know what you're trying to do Um, so sorry it is it is a it could have been if this were on the EP it would have been just an out and out Screen right and there are still it still is it away But the points that made it makes when when making the larger point about you know people calling the band sellouts, right?

It's essentially what it comes down to selling out laying down sucking up to the man And and addressing these people saying the band has sold out I you know interesting things in here like before you point that finger you should know that I'm the man So you can point that finger well up your ass but the point being you know He's who decides about the future of a band or an entity right? And also how do you know what kind of an impossibly demanding audience could be accusing exactly of selling out for god's sake That's the hilarious part. I think near the end in 97. There wasn't even internet You know there was even like a youtube comment section in my head How would you even know that your fans were mad?

Yeah, but I think the last verse are posted all you know about me is what i've said about I've said about I sold out long before you've ever heard my name Saying all you know is it's a secret band it's a private band They don't sure about anyway, and so you're putting yourself ahead of people who would know better This is this is our thing it goes back to what I said at the start about them Just not caring about some things and I think in the span of making that point There are actually some sort of interesting philosophical points that made it makes in those lyrics A lot of ways they've kind of been epitomized as the way they've carried themselves throughout their career Yeah, I hate to say that hucker with a penis is kind of a singular song that represents the tool aesthetic, but it does It does let me talk briefly about push it and then you guys can finish off That's another one of my favorite songs on this album and it deals with a very very sensitive issue It's it's talking about domestic violence and the idea of love versus being in this very dangerous situation Both on eulogy and on push it I think it's one of the first times that the band is really not in a hurry to do what they're going to do Eulogy stretches out and push it you have this entire midsection that has this eerie calmness to it And I think reflective of why assume exist in a lot of these abusive relationships and that you go through good times Calm times and then of course it explodes right near the end There's very sharp guitar riffs that ends up as frenzy in the line. Remember, I will always love you as I claw your throat away Um, that's a really powerful song both lyrically and musically. It might be the highlight of the album for me I would say that it's the single greatest song I ever recorded for me at least and you know, I Know most of this music for a while now. I've really only came back to it recently But I know this one's you know has I said since 2002 or so it'll be really jumped out of me It's like they're on a musical level.

You know, just leave aside the thematics, which are I said I think he really clearly seems like he's speaking from experience there I mean, but uh the musical journey on that is amazing. It's like an intergalactic exploration of inner space So it's like you know, let's go inside our own minds and find this this strange torment and it's both Heroing and beautiful. It's never ugly and it is again Abandoned I will complain constantly about how they don't edit themselves and how like they they over indulge, you know with repetition This earns every second of its 10 minute running time I was gonna say after all these complaints about brevity are like oh tools best song 95 seconds I mean and irony is what it is man because it's because the I mean I almost kept why they kept that making everything else so long Because we did this we gotta keep trying to do this because how are you gonna top that? I mean, I think eulogy actually which is similarly long eight to half minutes.

Yeah, that comes very close I think that's that's a fantastic song. The other thing I want to give credit to this record about is actually You know again, I was talking about pacing this for an overlong 80s 80 minute album It's pretty well structured like it has a nice flow and ebb and flow between it opens with like three really big epics But then you've got like a little instrumental interlude you got like it fades in and out from things In fact right after hooker with a penis, there's this little like keyboard ditty called intermission Which is just like 57 seconds of Booker T like keyboard which sounds totally out of place on a tool album It's actually pretty nice little group It's a wide there, but I'm glad it is and then of course it goes into an all-harrowing nightmare called jimmy Which is uh, another one actually that I think is a highlight for the record that one's a rather personal song I'm assuming because that's his name again not having explored the mythos of tool and Given the fact that this guy even though he's putting himself out there in public is intensely private I'm not gonna speculate on what the meaning of some of those lyrics are. I'm gonna let other people film him in But yeah from start to end, you know, the one thing I'll complain about with tools album So what one thing I'll complain about is they always have this thing where they have like an incredibly long final track And then there's like two minutes of silence, you know, and then there's like some like wacky little bit at the end Uh, but instead they just made the whole thing third eye Which is obviously a major track for them And I do like it a lot and yet I don't need to hear bill hicks Like suddenly telling me stuff that I had already heard on comedy central in 1992 One where he's like really Exactly Well, like I already draws that out. You don't exactly know what you're hearing.

Oh, yeah, I remember like I mean it's funny I mean the hicks is pretty great comedian obviously Um, but you know, it's just a very 90s thing both the secret track at the end and the idea of like all I'm gonna best specifically Build it. I'm gonna turn you on to this all comedian right exactly telling it like it is man No, which by the way while we're here while we're at it kind of explains why tool ended up on mr Show of all pigs playing a band called mr Show for those who aren't aware mr Show star mr Show with bob and david who's a creation of bob oden kirk and david cross Of course we go out to you know later greater fame and various other things like arrested development, you know, yeah Obviously i'm better call song breaking bad and all that right, but um, you know, this was their sketch comedy show It is quite literally I don't get into it. It's the greatest american sketch comedy show of all Yeah, it's a spiritual successor to the monty my thought blinds circus. Yeah, it's just it's just as that is the best that you know Britain ever did this is clearly the best american they revived it later on Netflix, but I wasn't as good You can go watch it.

It's from 1995. It's a holds up But in the very first episode like one of their sort of running bits that they also then did a movie about was a ronnie dobs Ronnie Dobbs it was a guy who kept getting arrested on cops in every state And uh in that in the first episode which is from 1995 tool appears singing the ronnie dobs theme song They're credited as pussifer in it, which is a current uh tool side project with them He's still the name and use it later, right? Yeah, which is very it's that's very weird But yeah, and he there there adam jones has his famous guitar already in it But gives him less paul silver burst like that he's sort of famous for it. They all have like weird uh trucker hats and uh Also, maybe by the way, I just like watch every every single episode of mr.

Show, please but now we return you to your previously scheduled programming and we ask no To talk to us about edema Oh, just okay. So I mean again this was the I was just tackled all at once but This is the pivot point album for him like you said it's an album that's comfortable Like being included with like their earlier material, but also super comfortable like lumping it in with their later stuff Uh, it is uh the place where I mean most of the people that I know that that like tool or no tool casually Will know stuff from this album I think this is the closest they ever came to being on the radio being on MTV again my experience with MTV is a little weird because I Wasn't I consumed what they called MTV Europe at the time Which wasn't even MTV UK Like McDonald's and China doesn't taste at all like McDonald's in America A little bit because they had MTV UK, but then there was MTV Europe which was mainland Europe But in english so it was like we are Scandinavian countries french acts that sang in english But also like some american stuff some british stuff, but it was a quote unquote MTV Europe Um, and so there was even less of it so there was like midnight blocks of stuff Yeah, the the um the videos that came out of it were the ones that You know made the most uh got the most attention I think it was also probably the one that got them the most like mainstream press and stuff I think they were like they got they were nominated for a Grammy for it. I think um And uh and and that so the next we're gonna talk about lateralis in a second That was the album that I the first their first album that I like waited for it to come out Right so when it came out I was already a tool fan I became a tool fan in the period between sort of this and that Before we move on to lateralis, I mean I just want to point out that there's there is a certain Mathematics to how tool assembles songs on this record and I think maybe it was like a routine they discovered here And then we're gonna carry for it because you're gonna hear a lot of these things moving for one of them is is is they find it's like very very Compulsively memorable like little riff. I'm thinking of something in particular like 46 and 2 which is you know I mean I can't I mean how you all that right?

I'm gonna grab my guitar. I can write if I had a bassier I could fumble through it Yeah, exactly it's a beautiful figure right and it carries through the entire track And of course, this is one of the ones where we're making this deep into a very weird place about human evolution and transcendence And I'm not you this is you know if you came to this podcast hoping for me to like sort of be the guy who was going to talk to you About you know the deep meaning of those lyrics. I'm sorry go go no further because I guess that being into your shadow and looking at yourself from the perspective of your shadow I mean, I mean, you know, it's night. By the way, I don't think it's cringe.

I want no I don't think it's cringe or embarrassing. I just cannot relate to it because I came to it too late in my life and maybe from the wrong perspective But that music is Compulsive and it is that trait where you'll find those figures that they kind of keep reoccurring through songs This is how they sustained sometimes these over long running times as we'll see is by the way they find these figures But that to me, of course, sometimes also speaks of sort of sloppy execution when it comes to song construction because you shouldn't have to just sort of fade out Like do some other thing and then come back that to me is too much like early rush And if you guys remember our rush episode I went all the town on you know I count how those early rush prog epics are to sound like they staple five things together without figuring out how they're supposed to flow Tool does a much better job at making things flow not only within their songs, but within the album as a whole I don't actually think they would ever do a better job than this And I kind of wonder whether they did as well because it took them like with five years to follow this up Now, no, I don't know. Do you know why they just took their sweet-ass time coming up with a follow up to the album that broke them big? I actually do not I think that there is I think that there are Different circumstances that caused the you know like the time to pass between each album, you know like in the next one This might have also been the time when a perfect circle Started to become a thing that then also took up some of his time Yeah, it's also put out the box set in between those two albums, which I do want to discuss a saliva Which is this okay?

They call it a box set but folks free back home when you think of box sets you're like who four CDs chock full of rarities No, no, the box that is actually mostly our installation. Yes, it's what we see It's a one CD set but not one CD is pretty great And also and it had the collection of all of their music videos up to that time, which again, thanks for throwing that on mom Um, but uh, yeah, I was gonna because we're gonna talk at the end. We're gonna recommend songs and I was gonna go start talking about cover versions And yeah, I am one of my No, I'm gonna just keep it away right now. I'm gonna recommend this album.

Okay. That's all cool because I like it that much I think it's great. We're gonna recommend to song because I because one of my all-time favorite covers of any band ever of any song ever Is the tool cover for Zeppelin's no quarter, which is on this box set or whatever you want to call it Um because uh the thing that I don't like is a cover that's just straight Weezer's cover of Africa already Right, this one gives the the two theories a lot in our show actually so you're on the same page as us Yeah, a good you know what? I'll I'll reduce it to this a good cover makes you go that was a cover that sounds like a song that you know this band wrote Yeah, and the way that they kind of wrapped no quarter into their own kind of sonic style is so seamless here It's just brilliant.

No quarter. I'm not gonna lie about this. This is obviously making my top five at the end of the show Uh this validates the song I never as you can hear if you go back to our zep apple Or zep apple or zep Epilosode wow that's a tongue twister or zep episode you go back there even there. It's like four years ago Like I was pointing out like you know, yeah, I really don't like no quarter It's like a long draggy slow thing.

I mean you were wrong back then and Tool saves the song tool revitalizes it they do something with it without like it's fundamentally no quarters Like if you know that song you'll be like all right, that's not right but they expand it in a really intelligent way By like building real dread and there's so much harder. I know I'm sorry zep It was just it was 1972 tool in 1998 or whenever it was they recorded this or chest bringing so much more fury to it It is I'm not even gonna lie if we had if I'd known about this before we had recorded our best cover songs episode I'll put it on there No, and it takes a while to it has a long intro and the minute that it hits you that you're listening to something special is the The way the song works is you know, there's like two there's like an opening line right closing dark What am I and then when the when the guitar enters it hits a really discordant chord It's this really dissonant sound instead of it like kicking into a song. It's this like bad You know like wow, okay. Wow now this is interesting and like you said I think I mean I like the original version But I think this gives it a an emotional heaviness because yeah the term no quarter, right?

It's supposed to feel like something oppressive and and kind of scary and they really lean into that it really fits there Yeah, so whoever said like let's do this song good good call I gotta give keen and credit as a vocalist too because you know you're interpreting Robert Plant which is never easy to do He sings this better. I mean, I'm a big fan of Robert Plant's voice by the way I mean at least before you shout it out. I really love there's a delicacy and there's a thought to the way he sings the song He's you know that you get that that high roar sometimes But it's much more vulnerable at a lot of times because of that melody the melody demands it By the way, yes, I'm very impressed by this this cover and by the way, I think the rest of this album is really great It's a lot of stuff basically They're all really good like a couple of like weird instrumental overshores like their segways between songs or they're like improv That were just cut out from songs and then they have like these two giant live versions of push it and third I am the live version of push it is it's almost comical because it does begin with that like whole like We're gonna do something special here in a different way kind of thing like and then once that fades out You would never know that it wasn't a live track at all. It's a completely different version of that song We've been we've been trying something a little different this tour We've been looking at one of our songs from a different angle Under a different light So we can hopefully kind of see it almost for the first time We'd like to try that for you tonight.

Is that okay? We're gonna need your help Your permission So we need to find a comfortable space It's not only comfortable To shut your eyes go there This is a really impressive little Oz Saws release Scott. Did you get a chance to listen to it? I did not No, it's not I know music so I did not see it Oh, yeah, it is again.

It is a it is a an oddity like again I know people who are even more than just randomly casual tool fence who have potentially never heard of it Yeah, I mean some of you should check out but of course it is sort of a a little time marker on the way to the album They spent five years doing which is just well in college radio by the way There's a secret track on the end of this called the anards dick Got a lot of play on college radio, but they called it Maynard's dead That was like the that was the the clean name that they assigned it It was always these little airplay gigs pearl jam kit trying to do this to get the f bomb on the air during that year as well The red hot chili pepper song pee off of one odd minute. Oh, yeah, exactly another one Well, this brings us a course to uh an album that I would have called until today a lateralist But I suppose I will now call lateralis Yeah, which is we wanted talking you know five years to make they're taking time off and doing a perfect circle They're doing other things. I think he's doing pussifer as like a joke act For people who don't know pussifer as it as he said it was like a thing they did on mr Show but then maynard sort of like you know did it as like a gag hardcore thing Like where he like put on a blonde wig and like just get up and basically use it as an excuse to be silly and not be so damn serious All the time because I think maybe he was feeling a little bit trapped by the like the huge chance seriousness of his image And uh say like I gotta do something else The place that it's the way they came to my attention. This was big This was so big that it was able to break through my otherwise complete isolation From music in the charts at that time and I have to tell you something because that at that point I was a big snob And it's a pretty great record now the question is is as good as enema and I do not think it is and that's where i'm gonna piss off a lot of tool fans But before I do anybody else want to start Uh, Scott, you can uh you can uh, I'll let you go first.

Yeah, let me well We did not play the the mainer's dick song on the radio, but we did we did play we did play the hella skism and That that bass riff that memorable bass line that starts is lodged in my brain for now until the end of time And uh the beautiful thing about skism is it's not just that riff but man Made it as an amazing job of playing inside that riff and the way that ekka uh no one had said earlier You know the way he delivers his lyrics and finds that the nooks and crannies and plays with the music That's really evident in a song like skism If you know a tool song it's you know probably that one or sober I think and this is I don't like this as much as the last album But I do think it's still a very very good album They're still discovering that sort of formula that works for them Which is you know that that push and pull through the album that tension and then release and they're still experimenting or using this very interesting Interesting instruments and non-disturbance invocal there are monk sounds on here. There are chimes. There are these droning interludes They're really good at making industrial noise. That's just a side observation.

Yeah tool and uh, trendarazzner Two greats in the concept really interesting sounding industrial clatter It's it's a further it's a further step towards sort of the progressive rock Genre and it is a lot. Jeff has been mentioning the time the length of these albums This one is exactly two seconds short of the absolute maximum You can place on one compact disc at 78 minutes and 58 seconds and in a future album that even blow past that mark and just did it digitally Put it 80 seconds a minute to wherever that it is. So it is a lot it is a lot of music is a lot of songs It is a lot of in places weird sort of lyrical Side roads, but the strength here of the music still shines in a lot of places mentioned skis I'm already I really like really like that parabola. Uh, and in the pre-song though.

I guess what parable parable is on now in the future They just combined those and they could one song 13 minutes, right? But they cut it here music video as well for them because it kind of needs to be well for them, right? It is a two-part thing It's a really great song a really solid groove and again lyrically one of the places in the album that made it get so little It's spiritual and it really is recognize this as a holy gift and celebrate this chance to be alive and breathing Actually, this is actually the best lyric he ever wrote in my opinion. It's very well could be it very well could be and and it's married to I think the best music on the album The title crack I love because I have a soft spot for the Fibonacci sequence.

It's fun fact about me. 1 1 2 3 5 8 Yeah, and and not just musically by the way And that was when I was when I was saying that stuff about me and her and his second meter I was thinking about that because not only is the music built like that, but yes The syllable syllabically it follows the the Fibonacci sequence black then white so that's one So it's black then white r so 1 1 2 all I see in my infancy red and yellow then came to be reaching out to me Uh And that's uh, there's a lot of thought that's put into that that I find very interesting There's actually a really good video on youtube that analyzes the uh the way that it moves up and down the Fibonacci sequence Because then he does that in reverse where he where the syllables retract down to 2 1 1 I'm gonna tell you right now. No, I'm the greatest trivia you can pay to that song is that it does that trick and yet you don't know Not necessarily, right? It's not giving me I give because if it was so blatantly obvious it would be like a hand waving look at me and it would sacrifice the actual group The songs group is good.

It works and then only lady you think like wait it did that and it was the Fibonacci sequence Yeah, well I did press um I did see another one of those youtube videos where some musician was listening to this and he literally went like 15 Second thing went wait, are they doing some kind of wait? Is this Fibonacci? And I was like god damn it I'm like god. I'm like jazz prodigy or something like that immediately spotted My thesis about lateralis is that if you uh if I could take Manard and Adam and company into the studio and hypnotize them open their third eyes and become their Sven golly You know open their heal their chakros, I guess And let them listen to me and say this album should be 45 minutes It would be the greatest tool I'll never make it would be a landmark of modern music in the way that we think of a kid A is being a landmark of modern music because if you boiled this down to its best parts without Sacrificing any of the greatness or even some of the really good weird interludes You would have the best thing they ever did instead you have that's got pointed out 79 minutes and 58 seconds when alas there should be 45 And if you're asking me to listen to 45 great minutes and then you know You know 25 30 of stuff that I just don't really think should have made the record That's when I start to have problems and sometimes they come in the middle of songs sometimes these songs just get too long Sometimes it's about sequencing like this is a band that didn't exactly release b sides to be fair But triad that should have been a b side That's a nice clever instrumental, but it doesn't really make sense as a conclusion to the album Nor does that last little like random like sound effects thing that you're on at the end that's all bull anyway But like there's too much good music here for me to ever say that it's anything less than like a b plus record But there's just too much music that is time filling that is you sort of almost speaks of oh I had five years to think about this and I couldn't choose And so I just decided to put everything on or we decided to put everything on when I think that you know It's something like the patient which I really like it doesn't have to be seven minutes long I could have been five the grudge is so great and yet I don't think it captures the same trick You know that end of a dead even with you know, you know, by by by by or you know, like it's something like you would you or stink system I find myself wondering why They Trying to be fair here because I'm realizing they're tool fans out there that'll murder me I'm trying to understand why they didn't have the courage to go less instead of more Oh, yeah, maybe I don't understand his bare head.

Well, look, I'll once again This this this is all about the tastes and how you approach listening to albums Right if you do it like the way you said where it's like it's it's two album experience side one go have a sandwich and then go What's the site to maybe it's different but for me? It's a single thing. Yeah, this hit me again. This came out in May of 2001 and that is a prock.

You know, that's pretty much when I bought it Hit exactly what I was Into at the time both in terms of like length and complexity and in terms of like, uh, you know loudness and and how much it Kicked ass. Um, and so it this specifically resonates with me personally more than any of their other albums, but that That's not their best work. I mean, excuse me. So great that the whole the parabola sequence is a highlight of their career And it's like basically kind of almost an ideal of like a great kind of a would you call hardcore metal suite?

Okay, I love that stuff, but then it isn't easy listening. It isn't easy listening. It's okay. Sure I think I'm gonna I'm gonna lean more into your criticism as we speak about 10,000 days because I think it's way more guilty of this No problem than this because here yes, Scott.

I would agree. I think oh Has points, but I think they're probably better pointed toward the next yeah No, yeah, because that one does some of the some of the edits feel like they could be Much less noticeable than here like I feel like I would miss some of the stuff even if it was maybe repetitious You're not there are things to be said like I said, this is not an easy listening album It hits you really hard right off the bat and then you know like eight tracks and comes ticks and leeches which is as intense and hardcore Yeah, and so it's relentless the album is relentless Ticks and leeches by the way another highlight of the record absolutely. That's so good That's they sound so great as a band playing on that song. Oh, this says yeah It's just so brutal.

I mean it's the same reason I love listening to like who's could do on something like I'll never forget you or pride It's just like devastating. It's just like being bludgeoned over the head with a bat full of like angry emotions And you know earlier when he was just saying you know, you know go to hell that kind of stuff I wasn't into it. He's a little more eloquent here Sound almost that that that course part right? This is what you wanted that feels like a good fit on opiate like just that one section feels very early tool to me Exactly.

I think that's probably why I made the association with that earlier stuff Yeah, absolutely. So what do we do to explain this weird seven your five year another incredibly long layoff between albums Is this when Maynard gets into winemaking by the way? I don't remember when they take that's a good question I actually don't know that but he this is definitely when a perfect circle becomes a big thing big Yeah, judith which I think was their first single which just briefly explained perfect circle It was basically Maynard and the bit tools guitar tech started a secondary band like this guitar tech I've you're a guitar tech you can play guitar. So you got it's right.

Yeah for a for a band like cool sure And yeah, they've had a couple of albums they've had a somewhat of a rotating cast of musicians Including by the way Scott likes drummers Josh freeze when I all-time favorite. I love Josh And so yeah judith from their first album called mered and i'm really good Album their second album saying that we had to like speak up from air to calm and say it's a good greatest debut of all time. I love it that much I like it 13th step which is the second one single album I would I would be impossible for me to leave it out of like a top five tool albums I still like it has to I got to sneak it in there I love it so much But yeah, like that started to like occupy because because marinam's came out in 2000 and 13 step in 2003 So like they put out and then emotive in 2004 they put out three albums in between Lateralis and 10,000 days. So at least that's part of it, right?

So I mean actually this is probably the time to talk about if you want to talk about 13th step I think is better than the second album But these none of these three records have really done much for me or the cover album cover about okay cover albums intriguing as always And I have a couple of good songs on it like I said, but it's not and it's it is too Again, it was very much about the rock war Have you ever heard a perfect circles version of what's so funny about peace love and understanding? Yeah, it ain't great Yeah It's pretty pretty and I think the end of all things like fiddle in the drum which is a song that jonnie mitchell performed acapella Okay with just her voice it has no guitar. It's only her voice and they don't you know So it's a very strange decision to like you know, you know, I mean Nader actually sings that one like, you know without anything else like behind him But he's not jonnie mitchell it is a strange like you know interesting anti-worth thing And I guess maybe it enabled them to or him at least to escape from you know tool or whatever thought tool was supposed to be I think one reason for that is because like he'd been writing these sort of extroverted lyrics And then maybe he was my guess is he must have been doing therapy or something like that because that's the only thing that explains 10,000 days, right? This is the final the final final to ladder Alice in 2006 and uh, I mean There are multiple theories about what 10,000 days means he himself says always about those Saturn in revolution or something like that But apparently the most common theory is that it is about the amount of time that his mom was in a coma before she passed away Which gives you a sense of the the lyrical content of this record.

It's very sort of personal Even though spoken oftentimes through metaphor sometimes rather directly so you know, you're in for a personal trip I will say this much though. I told you guys that I would have a follow-up to that anecdote I told you earlier about my wife, but you walked in and listened to the opaid page She was like this is offensive She said she walked in this morning and I was I had this one on she's like listen first time You've played anything the last two weeks that I've walked in and thought that's nice So that might also tell you something about maybe coming a little softer I don't want to say softer It's not like it'd be like you know, like whooshed out in the older age But this is a more rumored available But I think I would normally like that if I was talking about a band like top-talk But I think this also helps them become a little more a little too perhaps self-indulgent So I don't know what you guys think about 10,000 days Yeah, those critiques that you had for the last album apply and apply Even even more to 10,000 days the pace is slower. It's more meditative in ways Uh, your wife's saying that yeah, it's kind of nice. Well, there are places in which you'd say that um She's walking in just the right time The vocals in a lot of places here I feel are even actually more buried in a mix And I wonder if that's because it is a little more personal in a lot of ways It seems for native that it didn't want to be quite so up in front Um, you know, I took some notes here But I got to say one of the things that happens here is the songs start to melt into one another absolutely There are only a few things that really stuck out here.

I think uh, the pot is pretty darn good Um, Rosetta Stone, I think Daddy Carey plays is bought off Not that he always is not but but he's playing in like seven different times signatures all over the place on Rosetta Stone That is a workout behind the kit very good. Um, you know something like uh, intention Has that call meditative energy at me and or so that too much? Oh, here's that I was looking for this My note says they're never going to rush to get anywhere, but maybe they should get there faster Um, that's sort of my my my note back to them on 10,000 days I did not have a lot of good Thoughts about the songs on this album and the only one that I think really sticks with me is is the pot I respect they're playing there's never there never not technically sound clearly But despite the fact that his perhaps his lyrics are more focused I almost feel like this is a less focused less focused musically album in the ones that came before Oh, yeah, I agree. Do you have any thoughts on before I uh, I So, uh, so I mean I I I love parts of this album to death, right?

There's a whole bunch of songs on it I love I think we're again Rosetta Stone is a is I have a strange sort of issue with it a little bit It's just a it's hard for me to it's hard for me to verbalize my my issue with it exactly But I do think that yeah, the pot is an amazing song and so are the first two vicariously Oh, guys your objection to Rosetta Stone is it is it the music is it the drumming or is it the incredibly goofy frigate lyric? Oh, conceit about meeting alien Sure and I there is something about tool music that I need to kind of carry there's something very not There's like a lack of flow because it's just a sort of rapid fire spoken word that you can't really understand Yeah, I think this album excels when it's uh in that sort of sonic escape I could tell a story actually saw them live on the first time I saw them live was on the tour for this at the uh at the uh, the Comcast Center in Camden, New Jersey Uh, and uh as they were playing the song 10,000 days it started to rain There was like a thunderstorm and start to rain and it there is a thunderstorm in the song and it was this amazing experience of like uh, you know like closing your eyes and letting the music kind of surround you and I do think it does it well in this and also in uh Right into which is maybe favorite song on this album Maybe even though like you know, it's not it's less or known in the other songs kind of especially the pot is one that kind of everybody knows Um, but I really do I really do like love it in in sections It's hard. It's the hardest out of all of their albums for me to listen to like all in a row I think I can explain my criticism 10,000 days with one song that perfectly encapsulates it and that's jamby Or yambi, which you know has a little clever little trick behind it that I only learned like last week Which is playing with iambic contaminant or whatnot But what I think when I heard that song long ago was that that's a really good riff I really like that. Now.

Why is it seven and a half minutes long? Why does it not change? Why have they run out of ideas and variations? This is a band that always used to surprise me by going to new places and different places in their music No matter how long their tracks were at least they throw something else into the mix Even if it wasn't well integrated here they're generally becoming a little bit too repetitive And when they do change courses and something these long songs the pieces don't fit together as well I guess obviously the whole way so you're saying you know the pieces don't fit.

Yeah I didn't need to try to do that. Okay Um, the point is as I say creating a schism in this show right now, you know, stop it with a pun. No. Oh god But the point is it's like the self-indulgence here really becomes a problem It didn't really I think cripple a lateralis because that's still a great record But here I'm trying to find like Scott said I'm just not finding too much that that stays with me and I love the way he said like I really wish they take You know, they take the time getting where they're going they could speed up.

That's beautiful Um, and of course they did the opposite. They spent the next 13 years in hibernation 13 years I complained about radio ed taking too long to release albums I mean, even if they haven't broken up and they come out with a new one It'll still have only been since what 2017 I'll take five years between records 13 That's a lot manor does now a winemaker for the best of my knowledge I have no idea what the rest of the guys in the band are up to if you happen to know no no, I mean you can educate me Danny Carrey probably just doing drum clinics You know making garbage and that's money off The kids come in like all the want to be like, you know boomers or like 45 years I got to drum with Danny Carrey man. Oh, not even that just like oh no He does like master classes. He I know he has like a entire lines of gear that he better You know that he's our his branded his all that stuff I think they also go and play with other bands and it's you know They'll be like oh and tonight with us our friend Danny Carrey, you know and whoever's watching that show that night gets a treat, right?

I mean, it's amazing. It took so long But they finally I think he didn't I read an interview actually about the you know before the release of this next album We actually admit it's like yeah, I was a little bit frozen I had really know what to do I know what to come up with because you know you spend that much time off and that you don't know what you know I'm gonna repeat myself. I'm gonna come up with anything else What they came out with was fear inoculum, which is a very ironic title because it came out about a half year before covid Yeah, and it doesn't out and it does deal with it sometimes It's literally a vaccine for fear Again, 80 minutes long More than that it's 80 in the cd but if you get the 86 I don't have the digital version. I guess I'm glad I'm only familiar with the old cd No, this is this is out of all of them.

This is like listening to parts for real like listen up to So at this point I have to say like I really like this band in a lot of ways. I really appreciate the conceits they're going for Um my patience is being tested sometimes. You're like every casual and ray tarkovsky fan. You're like, oh, I'm gonna love this That's hilarious.

I was just Andre rublev crap. He's painting an icon. What a big deal is that you know But I mean that's how I feel about it sometimes too. You're like I love this but like I just like I love tool But at this moment in time I cannot listen to a tool song You know like there are there are many bands like that where I'll be like I can't listen them right now I'm in too much of a mellow mood My promise is almost too darnello Yeah, it doesn't have it doesn't have the discipline and the tightness again I'm a predictable man and you keep seeing me return to these things is it in their earlier career perhaps before they got more itself indulgent or perhaps They had the ability to indulge themselves They were playing tighter structures and they were being a little bit more careful about how they they broke things up But now like I guess if you're playing only to your fans This is fan service and I am not that level of a fan and I hope I'm not making anyone angry by saying I think I describe it differently this to me feels like a little bit of uh an attempt to strip down a little I mean not in terms of length but in terms of the yes the impact It feels it reminds me if you want to compare it to something reminds me a little of a year zero the nine-inch nails album that uh that uh Trent resonated after he heard the john kash uh cover of her yeah, and he decided that he wanted to make a more stripped down album But that's not a great album.

Uh, and sorry not your zero. I'm sorry people gonna Know it's not that way. It's with heat. Um, I like it.

I like it But it's it's very simple and you either you either connect with that or not It's definitely not what you expect your zero for example is way more uh sort of what you think of nine-inch nails with like thumpy beats And all of like these pads that surround you and this is more like very simple Small beat small little piano vocal that's it Uh and this feels a little more of an attempt like an attempt to maybe recreate undertow But with the every song is at 12 minutes That is my major aesthetic critique and I will keep hammering it until my heart ceases beating Which is that if you're going to go back to simplicity, this is the same mistake that artists always make REM did this with monster two in its own way if you're gonna go back to simplicity The mistake you make is like oh, I'm gonna go back to like the simple rock simple constructions But I'm still gonna be as lengthy and self-indulgent Uh, the simplicity only works if you're still writing four and five minutes songs Yeah, it's like trying to figure like 11 and 13 minutes songs and they're all you're trying to fit into an old pair of pants Right. Yeah, I mean There's a point here where they're like was it like five 10-minute long songs in a row? Yeah, I wrote this down. I wrote this down as I was listening to this album.

There's a pattern. There's like a tool by numbers Start very slow Ad lyrics some difficult rhythms Stay quiet now wait tees at explosion. Don't get there Been a long section with lots of sustained notes on the guitar then with two minutes to go the big release and there's It's a tool there on this album. There are two or two or rhythm There are at least three or four tracks that follow that to the T and I'm not saying that did that intentionally It's the way they're writing and it's what separates jeff had mentioned much earlier in the show this comparison between Tool and kincrimson and certainly there are lots of similarities And he mentioned the one difference and I think it's nowhere more evident that on this album is that ginkrimson doesn't waste your time And it makes sure to do something interesting even on the tracks that they end up spacing out to 15 minutes or 18 minutes or whatever it might be And I can't say the same thing about these 12 and 13 and 14 minutes tracks on fear and not get them It's not that there's not good parts or good songs.

I think invincible is pretty darn good real thick groove on that track I think tempest or whoever you want to say that you know seven tempest tempest Sampest that's that's 15 minutes long, but I think it earns it there's a lot of interesting things It's a pattern breaker too. It's the one that doesn't start out with three minutes of sort of dirge before they They do something next it starts very hot right away and it's adam jones really with an all over the place tempest is a great song But there's just too much on fear inoculum that that follows the template that I laid out It doesn't mean it's not nice to listen to but it doesn't really give you anything new or different or say something that makes me want to grab this album No, no, I'm just worked in a line there that I need to spotlight because it's the funniest thing I've ever heard We have to call it the toolgur rhythm Yeah, that's beautiful. That's beautiful. That's what it is.

Isn't it? I mean, I I think you know to your points Scott I think of some like larks tongues and aspik part one which is the thing that opens that album by king crimson and this is the weirdest thing I remember when we did that episode. I was like Scott's gonna hate this That's just like because it's so avant garde and so bizarre That's again, that's my favorite songs of all time because for 15 minutes it never gets boring It's always riveting and bizarre and haunting and strange and there's no repetition and repetition is death for some of these things Especially when you're working in repetitive patterns like the way hardcore music often does and yeah, the toolgur rhythm is Is the Achilles heel of this album? I think I'd do that.

It's been of the band ever since you know Probably it was quickly being noticeable as early as lateralis Yeah, I mean there there again. I see value in repetition, but it's not for repetition's sake. No, there's another band opeth Oh, yeah, I was I said I'm aware of all these these these And the thing opeth will do was any other band will do like eight bar, right? We'll repeat something for eight bars and they'll repeat it for 24 bars like cycles of that but it and they make it work, but they're also a band every song of theirs is like 13 minutes long Clearly music could be stone to it's like and shell xing in half is like Right, and it's the same guy doing it.

It's but you need to you need to be a person who's into that stuff Right, it's not exactly an album that I can like just give it to somebody like hey check this out while you're jogging I often wonder what happened if I had encountered all this music when I was a little bit younger, right? Or if I'd been born a little bit later in life because yeah, that whole thing is obviously a trip I am very much into but at this point, you know, I'm kind of I've got a little bit of the berry gordie And me if don't for us get to the chorus or get to the weird avant-garde point, you know, I doesn't have to be a chorus I mean, I think I might have been like three years too young I it took me years to get back around to stuff like Allison chains sound garden They were still like we like it was like, you know My friend's older brother who was like, you know in sixth grade when we were in third grade He liked all that stuff and you're like you I mean Scott I think that kind of wraps up unless we have any final thoughts Well, the thing is that we're thinking it's 2022 tool hasn't released now and I obviously just assume it could be another 13 They put out a single in 2022. They read the redone vervope It's not 40 we can reconvene and talk about the next You know, like they keep asking us to do like political beats episode follow up on like all the artists We've covered who've released albums since we've done the show and you know, we're waiting until 2040 to record that show because we want to get to You need a user poll. What's gonna have a weirder name Elon Musk's next kid or tools next album?

I like that All right, I guess I was like a brain gas that's amazing We've we've come to the part of the show where we now present to you all three of us The two albums from tool that you must own the five songs that you should hear and we turn it over to our guest on this program for his list First the two albums the five songs no am blue. Please give us what you think. Okay, so the two albums I mean, there is there's it's hard to escape naming Anima and lateralis because to me that is the apotheosis of tool those two albums together Bring like the tail end of the old tool into the sort of the steps of going into the beyond where you people are kind of Kind of fall off a little bit. So those two are if you're gonna if you just want like a truncated experience with them I think those two albums will give you truncated being a really weird word to use with regards to tool But if we want to get into the songs my songs are as follows Our number one is bottom from undertow Just a strong song and as I spoke about before I had Rollins's appearance always welcome no quarter from salvo which we discussed a Just an amazing cover of of lights upland 46 and 2 from anima just a Unamazing It doesn't do all of the things that we now spoke about there later things not doing it It's never boring.

It always keeps you interested. It has this whole kind of arc to it And it's just an engrossing song number four lateralis off of lateralis as we said Fibonacci sequence and all of that watch There's a youtube video. We should go Search you two for lateralis in the Fibonacci sequence and write in two off of 10,000 days again a song about How humans are dumb apes that hit each other with sticks and why that's bad All right, yeah My choices are the exact two same albums enema and a lateralis are the two I would recommend and then for the songs I think eulogy and push it are on my list parabola and you can even throw on the song before Play them together and the pot That's four right yeah, it's four and tempest from the last album again It's not that was not what I've good moments and tempest I think is the best of them. That's how my list of five Jeff over to you All right Well, I think I'm gonna obviously have to pick enema is one of the two and I'm gonna be a weird guy and say is it again Is it salvo or is it alive?

I thought it was related to saliva to be spitting on you You know, I spit on my fans by giving them 80 minute albums every I really actually do like that for a little odds and sides record It's it it it tends to be a cohesive statement It works well The live cuts are great Reinterpretations of the songs that are different from the originals and it has no quarter on it Which I just said is making my final five which are as follows. I'm gonna say one from the obi adp part of me It's early early early tool, but I think it's got yeah, I got a good hardcore riff It's kind of like you know them at their most alison chains in some ways I really love the riffing on that I guess sober from undertow You have to talk about that if only because everyone loves the meat puppet video if only once watch that once not twice once From enema if you're gonna pick any one song it would be push it that there's a lot of great music on that and I think Ulogy almost competed here, but I had to go with five push it is my favorite tool song of all time I think it certainly my favorite one that they ever wrote by themselves because it's just this beautifully constructed piece that goes in and out of places And spaces without ever boring you and it also carries off its its lyrical conceit with dignity Of course, it would be my favorite for that damn core that no quarter cover I just it's a joke that I didn't really know this and so we did this show. This is such a good one I already talked about why I love it so much I'm gonna add and with my fifth and of course because I'm a cheater and on the host I get the cheat It's obviously a two part. It's parable and parabola.

It is the two part of from lateralis Which is really the centerpiece of the record the whole thing It's the hinge point 13 minutes of tool at their longest and most sort of you know, probably medally self-indulgent But I think it's a beautiful song with again I think also a pretty decent message to a VOE coated inside of this That is the political beats look at the work and career tool And we hope we do a good enough job if we don't get the backlash from the passionate passionate fan base We hope we hope you'll prove our guess we certainly do use chief technology officer Wow, I was the I was the most harsh so I'm gonna get the most blowback of anybody Uh Go for me because I got the bigger account that's the way it always would Get in the black sky chief technology officer Attached for you man. Come on also coast of the ambitious crossover attempt podcast and all crossed out on the call-in app Both of which deal with pop culture media and politics at neon taster at twitter No, I'm blue. No, I'm thanks for joining us here on the program. Thanks so much guys.

This was great Yes, we have a lot to look forward to This coming year 20 first full episode of 2023 I give only one instruction to Scott and I have no idea whether he's actually gonna honor it folks I said for February give me an artist that I don't have to study that I already know a lot about so inevitably We're gonna be doing like the pet shop boys or something like that as soon as we're done mixing this one my next assignment is defined that BAM that you know so well and I'll work on that at soteric CD on twitter my name is Scott Bertram at Scott Bertram Don't forget patreon.com slash political beats help us support the show entry level mid-level and best friend upper level of quadrants Not quadrants. There's only three of them, but you can pick your level over at patreon.com slash political beats Also subscribe to do episodes apple podcast Google podcast or elsewhere national review dot com click on podcast find all the final offerings there We're on facebook on twitter at political underscore beats. This has been a presentation of national review. This is political beats

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Political Beats?

This episode is 2 hours and 20 minutes long.

When was this Political Beats episode published?

This episode was published on January 31, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Political Beats episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.