Skip to content
Episode 124 - What's Your Sit? episode artwork

Oct 16, 2019 40 min

Episode 124 - What's Your Sit?

from Sitcom Geeks Hosted by Comedy.co.uk

It's half of our name but we don't talk often enough about the situation. Dave and James talk to producer David Tyler (Cabin Pressure, Dinnerladies, Milton Jones and loads more) about what makes a good sit, plus James's chapter on this from Writing That Sitcom.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 124 - What's Your Sit?

0:00 40:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to SickCon Geeks, I'm James Carey, you'll be hearing Dave in a moment when we speak to David Tyler who is a producer extraordinaire at Positive Productions and we talk to him about things that he looks for in scripts and how to get on and Dave also talks about the importance of the situation that you pick for your situation comedy, seems pretty obvious but having a funny one might be a start. So let's have a listen to that now. So here we are with David Tyler and he is the producer of All Things Wonderful on the radio. Let's begin with Cabin Pressure but also Marcus Brigg's stock shows and Milton Jones shows and all those sorts of things.

The news and yes, Parliament. Absolutely, yes, that's right. Two of the few shows that you haven't had a hand in on. So David, you have been a radio producer, you've been doing this for 30-35 years.

As to Mark Coney said to me, this device is actually since writing for Weekending which was the news Jack of its Day in 1985, and producing the radio active thereafter. How long did you do the obligatory short live stand up career for? About ten months. David was very good, I remember.

A regular performer. I wouldn't have booked myself though. The answer was producing Carrie Offstairs with early inclinations of your very good host here. I'm going to go and put on Jeremy, I'm going to put on Jeremy, and I'm going to put on Tomas when they were all children.

I would have booked me. Oh, I see. That's how it's done. The other thing I heard is the people who are fundamentally writers or producers rather than performers when they're doing stand up.

They keep changing the act. They keep writing new stuff. That wasn't the case. I think it's that once you've got half of these.

I argue sick with it. Yeah, it's that they tend to, an instinct of writer will just go, that joke didn't work. There's something wrong with the writing rather than just like, no, it's probably fine. It's the delivery.

Yes, and also I think it's a great combination of a writer who regards themselves as mainly a writer, develops a stand up persona that's actually a credible whole rounded thing. So if you see Dylan Moran, for example, or Mark Steele, or Jack D, their stand up persona is a whole creation. It's them. Whereas say, Ben Elton is probably the perfect example of a powerhouse writer who performs his writing at high pace as a stand up, but it's not visceral.

It's not visceral in the way that's often taught with Rick Mel or Alexi and they're visceral. Yeah, of course, writers as well. But I think that's an example of a division by life. Yeah.

And so in those days, people, if you wanted to, I think Ben Elton always wanted to be a writer and he sort of said, well, if I become a performer, then people will notice my writing. I think he wanted to be Alexi Sale. Okay. That was the performer he wanted to be.

And that was very much who he was when he started out. He was, and they used to sort of take him to one side apparently, say, hang on, you know, the material's great, but you know, lose the, lose the Alexi, lose the, being Alexi Sale bit of it. But then, performance often needs something like that to get them going. I mean, Jeremy, we knew was always, he was Norman Lovitt by his own admission when he started.

I never really thought of that. That's what he was. He was Norman Lovitt. Yeah.

Victor Wilger. Yeah. So that was his way in defining him, defining him, the person he was with the next 30 years or so. Yeah.

But, and so at that point, the way into writing also was stand up and performance, whereas now there are a zillion other ways where you can make your own podcasts, you can make your own YouTube video and all that kind of stuff. So what extent are you as a comedy producer who is also open to receiving scripts? Yeah. So, you know, you're not going to be able to make your own content out for other forms of media to which might become a starting point for something?

It's sort of impossible not to because the, the, the, the penetration of all media into one's, it's just your own social media feed. Just, you know, you click on a link in that comes up in a tweet without batting an eyelid. So that's a terrible mixed metaphor, which is why I clicked without batting. But so I probably do even more inadvertently than I do consciously.

I mean, you go and see, standard, you go and see shows, you know, there is the Edinburgh cycle, which is still paramount. The sort of lines become increasingly blurred between single stand up, sketch pairs, sketch teams, three people who've left university together and done the unfunny one. It's a, you know, a police, a strong, police, a member thing because it was sort of always like that. But now it's just delivered into your lap far more easily.

Right. That's a very mixed answer. But I think the answer, yes, I do keep up. It's hard not to.

Because one of the things we do tell people on this podcast is to make something, do something previously I was a bit skeptical about, you know, if you're push for time, write a script because you will be able to set yourself apart. If you've got limited time, spend the money making a really good script because a really good script will show you what will show a producer what you can do. But I don't know whether that's particularly good advice anymore and actually just creating a bit of a calling card or doing something and then having a script. Just what we've been talking to, Bill Jones and advice that he gives is just do something, do anything that gets you noticed.

Yes, and it used to be, I would say, it's about five years ago. So computers were invented in, you know, whatever it was about eight years ago. And there was a big period where the advice would be, don't do it because it's never quite as good because it's cumbersome and expensive with computers to sort of go and shoot some sketches and... This sounds never any good.

Yeah. And so as you say, sort of as better to do it on paper and impress someone that way. That's now sort of changed again. Yeah.

But it can be short. I mean, yes, it's a calling card or on, you know, it's getting hits and getting retweets. And that is effective. And you do notice it.

It's changed again as computers become... Computers don't computers anymore. They're now phones. It's all very fluid.

Yeah. And so everyone's... That's the new normal now, isn't it? It is, isn't it?

And I mean, that's wonderful because it means you don't have to get about your chair. But still for you, your job primarily is to sell half hour episodes of shows to radio comedy. Yeah, hold on. That's what I love to do.

So the podcast form, exciting, vibrant and all dominant though it is from producers' point of view or from this style of producer's point of view isn't such a thrill because you've got to produce it in enormous amounts and you've got... That much physical production to be done and to use it's got effects or fine editing of dialogue to bring out the psychological truths of the characters. So from my point of view, yes, it's still very much like 50 minutes occasionally in a half hour form on Radio 4 which still appears to be the only sort of national speech network that is willing to pay money that allows you to pay writers' performers to just about within an inch of their lives and produces the same. Yeah.

I mean, I guess there are slightly more... I guess audible is a bit of a... Yeah. It looks like it has a future in the commissioning stuff.

Yes, absolutely. I mean, I've not done anything on Audible yet but for no specific or particular reason other than just the right thing hasn't emerged that I want to do and they would like me to do. Yeah. If people want to send you a script, they can go to the Positive website which is your production company and find the email address and send it to you.

Yes, I mean, I can quite happily say the email address is davidattipositive.co.uk with 2z where you'd expect an S but hardcopy is delightful because I only really read on hardcopy so when it's emailed I tend to send you a hardcopy or sneakily if I really want to know I printed up and read it properly. Yeah. I'd much prefer reading on paper. Something about the screen makes it a little disposable.

Yeah, interesting. Obviously when I'm working on scripts that way actually making their various situations will be all screen based after that. I think when something's on the screen there's also so many other things on the screen that could distract you. Like, oh, I could just, well, I'm reading this I could quickly answer the Gmail.

Yeah, I mean for years when we delivered our programs to not the broadcast of the executives and so on I didn't put them on CD. I gave them a tape because I didn't want them to play it on their computer. Right. For exactly that reason I mean those days have gone now and it probably didn't make any difference.

But yes, I don't know reading you stuff on a screen. Yeah, you can't get notifications on a script. So when you are reading that script what makes you sad and angry? I could be playing Tetris on my scripts.

So what things excite you? What are some warning signs? Jokes are just bloody great Trojan horses, aren't they? I mean, I know everyone will say this till I'm blue in the mouth.

But you read a joke and you go, hello. Oh, look, they can write a joke because they have to be able to write jokes if it doesn't work. So that's a very surprising question. I think you surprised how often, I'm sure you wouldn't be surprised but we often notice that in the excitement to get the story going or the characters going even very successful comedy writers forget that they have to have jokes.

Myself included, I'm sure. Well, I mean jokes also. Okay, so sitcom is sort of playing the piano while driving, isn't it? Because you've got the plot, the characters and the jokes all in some vicious type sort of cycle where they will have to influence each other.

Absolutely, impenetrably, you mustn't be able to get between them but they must all logically grow out of each other and involve each other. So that's hard. But I suppose one of the big things I'm looking for, which we don't think talk about enough, is the com needs to be embedded in the sit. So what I mean by that is that you can read a lot of scripts where there's a situation and there are some people in it snarking away at each other.

So it's a garden centre or it's a run down theatre or so. And there's lots of people who are discontented and they're all moaning about it and then there will be one elder person who could be almost 50 who likes to work there so they're visible as the default setting. And they're all talking about what they're going to do and they're not there. Or how they can get away, or what a banging party they had last night, etc.

And you think, right, that's not a sitcom then that's a com. Right. But it may not be a com. Yes, it's not a sitcom.

So the biggest, biggest thing and amongst the other eight biggest, biggest things you need to do for a sitcom is find, hit on something that is intrinsically a funny place to be. So pick the pockable story of the pythons dining in this hotel and how grim it was and so on. But please realise that it was actually a funny situation, funny situation because hotels have to be lovely to survive and what if they weren't? Funny situation.

Dad's army was funny because they thought, what if you got all the soldiers who were two shit to be soldiers and made themselves? So these are fantastic. They're so into sort of life experiences. Yeah.

Well, I suppose to take an example, like say cabin pressure and planes off themselves or airports or whatever aren't intrinsically funny, but the sit is so solid in that. And the world that is then created around that is to add to what you're saying about it. It isn't just where it is. It's how you invest in that place.

So it isn't just the world's worst soldiers. It's the world's worst soldiers in this dilapidated church hall. And that's yes, and that all flowed out of, you know, they thought, what's funny about this? So what's the first intrinsic tension in cabin pressure?

It's you have very intelligent people cooped up. Right. You know, somebody said that's because the world didn't need a comedy set in a light haul which company really, but it turned out it liked it. But again, not only in a cooped up place, in a cooped up place that we believe exists, we know what a cockpit looks like.

Flight deck. Flight deck. I didn't produce it for a year. But I can already see all the dials and all the bulbs and all the hand.

So we have a grammar that's available. If you've been on a plane, you know that there is a pilot. But I think does the situation have intrinsic fun in us? Yeah.

Because if it doesn't, it's people snarking at each other. And I think that's a huge thing. I mean, space, you know, which is a very different, very personal kind of sitcom. You can't get a flat.

So you have to pretend you're living together. People forget, make a big note. I forgot that that has a really solid sitcom premise. They have to pretend they're a couple.

And yes. So yes, make the comm has to be part of the set. In the old days, in the 50s and 60s, it was easy because everyone's at work. And they'd work for the gas board or a sausage factory or a department store.

And they were always funny. They were intrinsically funny, stupid. Stupid is about rank and class. And so, you know, classes, it was intrinsically funny.

And so you always do a sitcom based on class because it's intrinsically funny because the smart person might be underneath the class of the thick person. Yeah. So that's easy. So that's obviously different now because everyone's just a bit of a dream.

Yes. But also, it feels like we've really lost our nerve with regard to work sitcoms. I was talking to Richard, my writing partner about this and how I said, you know, could we... I think he observed that if something's going to be a pre-waltish-head studio sitcom or even just a studio sitcom of any kind, it obviously can't be set in the workplace.

It has to be in somebody's house. And the idea that it would be... It almost feels unthinkable. And the closest we've got, I mean, ghosts with Ben Wilbond and all those lovely, extra-able history people, that feels like it almost.

It could be a studio show. But the idea that you could do a yes prime minister now in front of an audience. I think if you wrote that studio script and took it to some folks, they would go, why have you done... What is this?

I don't see why either. I don't see why. It just feels like there was something strangely... Well, it just explains to me as a TV producer we are talking about a work sitcom.

The work sitcom doesn't work anymore because we don't have those kind of... Exactly what you were just saying. We don't have those shared work places so much. And we don't...

People don't work on our own or we work from home or whatever. We don't have the factory floors anymore. Maybe the office killed it because it's... It's an active, deliberate, commissite.

Thank you. Because it said... I don't know, it gives a paper thing. But it said it's deliberately about nothing.

Nobody wants to be there. This is the last knockings of communal office work for most of Britain. You all recognise it and it's the end of it. Yeah.

And the... Yeah, Wernham Hogall, the paper that it's a begufting of, like, this is a meaning. Yeah. It's a widget.

Widget Fern is in. Yeah. Okay, so that's... So the sit intrinsically funny sit.

That's the first thing. I think it's a really interesting point now. I think the idea that not only... Would it be helpful if it was intrinsically funny.

It would also be helpful if every single person there didn't deeply resent having to be there. Yes, that's a real default, particularly... I say particularly for younger writers, like I'm 973, but it does it. But obviously one of the greatest pieces of advice, I think, that comes in with every writing course ever is...

Don't make every character yourself occasionally yourself with a hat or a wig. Because the reader will spot it. They all have to have massively strongly divergent attitudes to a particular situation. I mean, when I say different, I mean, you can, if you're bunch of geniuses, do what's phrased in, and have the posh knob and then the even posh-ous knob.

Yeah, but that's... But then that's a whole continent of writers converging on one. Absolutely. But in general, yes, you have to make a concerted effort as an act of imagination to create a whole world of different characters.

Again, easier, in the old days when you were doing all your being served, there was sort of a parent craft, because they would experience a shop floor with the eight different types that they could boil down. Or the summer camp, or the... Yeah, or Mr. Boy, no, for a minute.

That's right. So first of all, yes, they will have to have wildly different attitudes, which of course then would roll in before, so what you were saying. People not wanting to be there. Yeah, because these things, these workplaces all have a grammar of their own.

So, you know, I guess I have written a workplace sitcom, it just happens to be Afghanistan. The moment we discovered, the moment we knew it was going to be about bon disposal, you just go, okay, so you need an ammunition technical officer. He's got a number two. You've got somebody who does the signals.

You've got an arm-deskord. You've got a guy overall in charge, technically not in charge of them, but nobody knows that. And a pardry. There you go.

And then it's like, well, what sort of pardry? What sort of number two? What sort of... And we need some of them to be girls, right?

Okay. So that... So actually an awful lot of the heavy lifting is done for you. Well, your options are shut down, whereas if we don't have workplace sitcoms, and now you've got a sitcom about a young lady in her 30s who thought she was going to get married and had kids, but that hasn't happened for yet, or whatever, you have to populate that with people.

And it could be anyone you like. It's actually the choices all feel much more difficult and bigger. And I think that feels like... If you're a novelist, you might relish that challenge.

But it strikes me that then you're losing all the advantages of it. If you have found a funny sit, in the word funny, I'm rolling in the concept of some of the relationships being predefined and absurd. So, personally, it's about person being one that should be the other way around. So, in Kevin Presher, the first officer is junior to the pilot, and it's a much, much, much better pilot.

It's that's only. It absolutely is. You know perfectly well that Mannering has spent his whole life straining to get into the golf club. And even when he does, there will still be snooted him, whereas Wilson can stroll in.

Wilson's also living in sin. Wilson is living with Pike's mum with an unmarried woman, which can you imagine the social death if Mannering did that? But people of Wilson's class were loud. Sounds like a bit of topicality being brought in there for a conversation.

Not a dead time, sure. But, yes, in fact, Harry Thompson consciously did that with the Have I Got News. The Paul character being far cleverer and which you're in funnier than the posh, the Angus character. And he also died actually being a sort of staple of British comedy as well.

So, there are lots of ways in which scripts can go wrong, I guess, in other warning signs that's like, oh dear, or what makes you want to pick up the phone and say, oh, I've read your scripts rather lovely. Well, if lots of jokes make me laugh, then that writer is a miraculous and wonderful person. It's already in the top 5% of scripts you receive. Yeah, how many people can write jokes that make you laugh?

Seven? Nine? So brilliant, fantastic. I mean, that's such an achievement.

That's a brilliant thing. If I could do that, I'd do that for a living. So, that, it would be amazing if it was in a situation where, yeah, where you got it, it was intrinsically funny and those strings were played upon during it rather than just a plotting along behind. But, in the end, if the plot's the right size, if it's got a plot, if they aren't just sort of nurdling around for a bit, it really is.

It sounds so basic, but in Dinellade, they all come in, they switch the to the toaster on, they do the milk bloke comes and they put the milk in the fridge. They all talk about how they got there and how crap the boss was, and then two and a half or three minutes after Victoria would jokes in, which is never bad to. No, absolutely not. No, no, no.

The memo arrives, they never want to wear the funny tabards. Or the royal is coming for a visit. The plot arrives. So basic, and then the plot unfolds.

And when the plot arrives, all the characters, even the ones who aren't in vision at the time, react to it in the way the viewer knows they're going to and loves it thereby. And the jokes just tumble out at that point. So even character, the character's not in it. The character's not the other person is going to react to it.

And that becomes funny. In Men Behaving Badly, when Martin Cleans has to wear, no, he has to wear glasses. He knows Martin Cleans is going to take the mick out of it because British men take the pittany of British men wearing glasses. There's a scene where he's trying the morning front of the mirror and he looks quite funny in glasses, but the big glasses, he's going, no, no, it takes him off again.

It's like a reverse pretty woman kind of. Because he knows Cleans is going to mock him. So, character isn't even on stage, but they're reaction to the situation. It's a joint.

Yeah, you're already off the races on that. And then our experience, and we say this again and again, and yet so many scripts that we read when we do first 10 page challenges and that kind of thing is you get to page 10 and then the story starts. No, you've got to start the story on page three. I mean, ideally page one would be good.

But the story just starts very late. And then if you read the whole script, sometimes the story finishes on about page 23 and you've got seven pages of wrapping up. Is that your experience of reading scripts as well? Usually if I'm not sort of gripped, then the last half passes in a bit of a blur.

I'll be very... Or you don't even read past page 5 or 10. The first five pages are to get you to page 10. I think it depends.

Some people are unable to write. That's all right. I can't play the bassoon. Not yet.

Not yet. Or indeed definitely. But usually the vast majority scripts are fine in that they're written in the English language. They have a coherent smattering of the different verbs and gerunds and so on.

So you can read to the end without sort of going what's just happened to my head. But it's of no benefit and it can have any number of different forms. It can just be sort of not funny. That is a big crushing weight really looming over a lot of scripts.

It just turned out to be not funny. I don't know. I think the ones that are more depressing, I think to read are the ones that are funny, but they just aren't about anything. But then I would usually ring the writer up.

If they genuinely funny and have got good jokes, according to levels of how far it falls short of being a sitcom at all, you would get in touch and go, these are great jokes. What else have you got? Do you want to come in and talk about it? Or if it's near near near sitcom, but not quite or it's like something you're doing already.

How many times a year are you having a meeting with someone who sent you a script? Okay. And you're reading how many scripts? Probably now about four or five weeks.

It used to be about a dozen a week. Really? Yeah, it used to be a lot. But then I don't know what the big companies get, although they may have a policy of not reading anything.

They mostly do. Yeah, which I find baffling. You do read every group. I do, but with the sort of proviso that I may not get through to the end of it's fruitless.

And occasionally I get past the title, but that's a very interesting question. Okay. You can't, top hint. The title can show whether you're a good writer or not.

I mean, this is, I don't stop the title, but there are scripts where the title is so mangled or strange or odd, you think, but then you don't have an ear at all. Call it something bland if you're stuck. Yeah, yeah. You know, capture is fine.

Praise it. Yeah. But with the thick of it, which is, you know, one of the most extraordinary titles, but, you know, if that's just been called government or turmoil or something, it'd be fine. Yeah, fine.

Yeah, absolutely. Do you have other specific things that you think for radio scripts that are, that you're looking for that obviously visual gags don't go down well, but other ways in which, you know, we tell people, you know, get lots of visual gags into your TV scripts, but how do you think sort of getting audio into. Funnily enough, I wouldn't say that that statement is symmetric. I wouldn't say, you know, I don't say, I mean, it's only a radio script if there's explosions and people falling into vats of custard and not to control.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I mean, that's actually not massively necessary. No things, you know, it's not a script. It's also a script.

There's also a script. There's also a script. It's pretty much the first two minutes. Yeah.

Every episode. So I think, so the answer to that is no, I don't think there's anything specifically audio that you go, if it doesn't have that, I don't want to know it's boring to produce, because, you know, great radio scripts. Can be, I can be in my log, but they can certainly just unquote be dialogue. I mean, I do a school John Finnham was double acts and that's, you know, they're occasionally elaborate sound effects.

I mean, there was one called the Queen's Speech where we had to reproduce an early form of phone, a screen recording, Queen Victoria. And that's a very long time to make the sound of it and involve Mccano, as you can remember. But, but they can be very, very simple. So the answer is no custard required.

Cussard delightful, if it fits. Have you enjoyed this interview with David Tyler? We've got one more question for him in a moment, but before that, just want to remind people that they can join our Patreon scheme and hear lots more of this kind of thing, because we've got a lot of questions. And this kind of thing, because we have tons of audio that's just for Patreon subscribers, including Ciptonuts, where we're going through and creating a sitcom before your very ears, and there are at least six hours worth of podcasts on that.

And then lots of other things. We refer to the fact that we just spoke to Milton. That interview is going to be up there as well, very shortly for Patreon subscribers before it is eventually released, possibly in an edited form to everybody else. So loads of reasons to join.

There's also a private Facebook group and also lots of other benefits, including getting in the know about various things that are coming up and also copies of our book, including my book, writing that sitcom isn't available as an audio book to Patreon subscribers. It's sort of appearing in the private RSS feed for that. So tons of reasons to join. I hope you're able to get along and have a look.

Go over to patreon.com and look for sitcom geeks and you'll find us. And there are three or four levels of getting stuck in. So anyway, I hope you enjoyed that. There's also the script competition that we're doing.

Do look on BCG Pro for that. That's an accordance in association with them. So look up that and the winner of that competition will get a full script set of notes and also be on the podcast if that doesn't fill you with horror and we'll go through the script in more detail. But anyway, here's the last bit of that interview.

I had to pop out so it's just me and David Tyler and here we go. And then the last question is, and we've had a conversation about this offline with regards to other things, the temptation because you can do anything you like with radio is that you can set something in the past or in the future or in a science fiction universe and the demand and market for those seems to be very, very limited. Is that fancy think? I think with Radio 4, it used to be the case.

It's probably still the case that they do something specific. Genre, like science fiction or Jane Austen, everything. Then they won't do another one while it's running and they probably won't do one for some little while afterwards and as a star sort of decides they want to do it and you can't. It's actually it.

And so I think that's been true. My entire life up to about 10 minutes ago. Now with other outlets, say Audible or your own podcast or BBC sounds, it's probably the demand for that. It's probably unlimited because the demand for everything is unlimited.

I don't think anyone in the podcasting world will go, you see we've got a science fiction one now so that's it. Which is precisely what Radio 4 do quite rightly. So the answer is absolutely go for it. Yes, I mean, but not for Radio 4.

You really should listen to what's out there and go, I'm not going to do, and then I'm going to take my one about disgruntled author because they've been running Ed Riddenswee for quite a long time. For quite a long time. Yeah, absolutely. So the possibilities are there aren't they in terms of these other markets?

Yeah, they're not going to be paid. That's the problem isn't it? If you issue exchange that for actual sort of coinage that you can spend, then no. In return for housing slash mortgage, it's very difficult.

Calorie is also a Mersel's pyramid of needs, a sort of warmth shelter in it. Calorie is even that is not going to be available if you do. Yeah, so the advice is ideally, do anything but become a writer? Well, obviously that first.

Yeah, clearly. That's a given. If you take nothing else away from this, it's simply don't do it. But if you're full enough to do it, if you must, as they say, if you would die rather than not do it, if you take the notebook to the beach and irritate your loved one by doing so, then radio for fantastic place.

They do pay properly. And I'm using properly and not even ironically, they do pay properly. It is real money. You can make a living.

You should make a living. But then you do have to study the landscape and go, okay, they've done one set in medieval times. They've got to say they've got to sci-fi one running. They've got one set in recovering alcoholics.

Or a political one. So they're not going to have another one about parliament. No, so. And also you're very unlikely to be the sort of person that they would commission to do that, given that you don't seem to have a particular insight or access into that world, I guess.

Yes, so right what you must, right what you know and you don't do either of those things. Yeah. We'll be right there. Excellent.

David Tyler, thank you very much indeed. Literally a pleasure. I mean, not even metaphorically, I actually enjoyed it. Thank you.

We've got a little bit of time left here. So why not have a small snippet of my audiobook writing that sitcom? If you're a Patreon subscriber, you already had this turn up in your private RSS feed. But have a listen and if you like what you hear, then go to Patreon to find out more.

Or you can buy the book via my website, sitcomgeek.blogspot.com, or by looking for it on Amazon. Here we go. Part one, creating your sitcom. 1.1, the situation.

It's unlikely that you've decided to buy this book and don't know where the word sitcom comes from. For the avoidance of doubt, it's a shortening of the term situation comedy. What you might not have considered is that it's not a particularly good way of describing the half hour narrative comedy form. Success in this genre rides all falls on the characters rather than the situation.

But the word charcom, carcom, whatever, just sounds weird. It's easy to see how the term sitcom arose. Until recently, they've been filmed more like a play on a few sets, usually in front of an audience. As a result, the situation is the most striking thing about the show.

So one might assume that the trick of thinking of a new sitcom is thinking of a workplace that hasn't been done before. Thinking of an original situation, in itself, is hard enough to do. Since 1950s, Britain has produced a myriad of sitcoms set everywhere imaginable. Funeral parlours, fun at the Funeral parlour, Billy Lyre and in Lubbock memory.

Space ships, Red Wolf and Hyperdrive. Vicarages, the Vicarif Dibley. Rev. Hospitals.

Only when I laugh, surgical spirit, doctors and nurses. They've all been done plenty of times and plenty more times and for longer in America. A new situation might be appealing or feel funny, but be careful. A funny situation might sell the show, but people will watch it week after week because of the characters.

We're drawn to people in stories, not situations. The best jokes are normally funny because of the character and the story as well as the situation. Falling over is funny. Sure.

But it's much funny when the guy falling over is Delboy out with trigger trying to be a yuppy and impressing girl having said nice and cool. The characters are the key. If you can, think of characters first. Having said that, the four sitcoms I've created or co-created have all started by thinking of the situation first.

But each time the bulk of the development was spent working on the characters. Purely for illustration, let's look at each of the shows, the first three of which were sitcoms for BBC Radio 4. Think the unthinkable was my first sitcom. The starting point was realizing I wanted to write a show about management consultants.

In my early twenties, I'd noticed that people I'd been at university with, people with very little experience of business or life were telling people three times their age what they were doing wrong. That felt both insane and funny, a fruitful situation for comedy. The more I thought about the show and developed the idea, the more I realized that it was all about change and differing attitudes to change. My original three main characters were all happy about change in their own different ways, and they insisted on inflicting this on other people who were more resistant, for a mixture of good and bad reasons.

I worked really hard on getting to know my characters inside and out before I worked out the storylines, even though I knew the storylines would probably be funny in their own right. The pits. My second radio foresight comments notable only in that it starred the now very famous John Oliver. The pits has disappeared into obscurity and I think I know why.

It wasn't really about anything. It suddenly appeared to be about something. It was about professional musicians who worked for the British Opera Company, a fictionalized version of the Royal Opera House. I researched it a fair bit.

There were some decent classical music jokes and funniest characters doing funniest things while saying funniest lines. Three throughs were fairly jolly. The audience who turned up to recordings quite enjoyed it, but ultimately the pits was all about setting, not the characters. I didn't do it properly because I was ever confident, having done quite well with The Unthinkable, which had won Silver at the Sony Radio Awards and was on its full series.

I knew how to write scenes and jokes and stories, but I hadn't figured out that the characters and the central idea behind the show, naughty. Cut 33. In cut 33, I really wanted to write a show about Cobrech at In Bleckett in Bleckett's Park. The obvious angle didn't feel like it was going to be all that funny.

Cut 33 was full of boffins and therefore being clever was not at all that remarkable, and a show full of super smart people didn't seem viable. This was a few years before Big Bang Theory turned super smart people into billions of dollars. It felt like the show had to be about something else. But what?

Through talking to my wife who was much more interested in social histories and guns and bombs, I know who we are. I learned that World War II brought together people from very different social classes. Everyone saw how the other half lived. Poverty and privilege living cheek by jowl.

It's why Churchill won the war but lost the general election that year to Atly in a landslide. People realized that Britain had to change. Cut 33 became a microcosm of that desire for change, so the show was about class and a potential upheaval in the class system. Robert Bathurst played an over-educated Oxford professor who, like many on the social scene in the 1930s, had been on very friendly terms with the likes of high-ranking Nazis like von Ribbentrop and Rommel before the war broke out.

Tom Goodman Hill played a working-class Trotskyite from Newcastle. Gordon played by Fergus Craig was a 17-year-old naive genius stuck in the middle wishing everyone could just be friends. They were forced to spend all day, every day, together in a cold confined space because there was a war on. Bleckett was the backdrop and playground for their stories.

If it had been set in a hospital ward, Hut 33 would have been almost identical to only when I laugh. Lou Stonefall 2. Richard Hurston and I met working on Miranda. We had a few ideas for new shows but wondered if there was anything in a show about soldiers.

Nothing new there, given Dad's Army, Ain't Half-Hock-Mum, the Phil Silvers Show, Bill Co. or the Truly Great Mash. There had been a lot of drama and documentaries about the British Army covering the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan but nothing comic. Our understanding of British soldiers was a sense of humor is extremely important, so we were interested in thinking up a show that reflected that.

A section of Squallies would be broadly similar in background and outlook and all males, so we looked for an army unit that would bring different people, perspectives, backgrounds, genders and expertise. We arrived at the idea of a bomb disposal squad, partly because it was an interdisciplinary unit which performed a function that was very easy to understand and show on the screen. There's a bomb, deal with it. We started with a guy who does the long walk, Captain Nick Medhurst.

We imagined him to be a copchial rogue who did a job that made him irresistible to women. Okay, he's Sam alone from Cheers. And then we thought of a character, Mary, who would try harder than most resistant because she's a Padre. Okay, she's Diane from Cheers.

And we built the rest of the team around that scenario. But the show developed from there as the last three episodes of Series 3 contained neither Nick or Mary because the show was ultimately about something. Why soldiers love being soldiers? A situation can be a good starting point.

It can be the reason your characters are together. It can inform the underlying philosophy or the point of the show. But a sitcom is not a comedy about the situation. It's all about the characters.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Sitcom Geeks?

This episode is 40 minutes long.

When was this Sitcom Geeks episode published?

This episode was published on October 16, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Sitcom Geeks episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.