Skip to content
Episode 14 – Linking science and policy episode artwork

May 20, 2014 29 min

Episode 14 – Linking science and policy

from Naturally Speaking Hosted by The Naturally Speaking Editors

FEATURED: Our most visited post of 2014 – in this episode we chat to colleagues across the Institute about how they've successfully communicated science into policy.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 14 – Linking science and policy

0:00 29:16
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Naturally speaking. Hello and welcome to the latest episode of Naturally Speaking Podcast. In this episode, James Grecian and myself, James Buckley, chat science and policy with five researchers associated with the institute. Naturally speaking.

We're just going to quickly get around the table and allow everyone to introduce themselves briefly with just a few lines about who they are and what they're doing inside the institute here in Glasgow. I'm so glad you're a PhD student, we're in this institute looking at a Gadot hapto association. I'm David Bailey, I'm a Sophie's PhD supervisor, I'm a marine biologist working here in the institute. I'm a beard, my background in economics but I work within the institute on disease modelling.

I'm Lisa Bowden, I'm a epidemiologist, I'm working in the vet school and work for Centre of Expertise and Animal Disease Outbreaks. I'm Katie Humpson, I'm the College of St and I work on a disease rabies. So given that science and policy is such a large subject, we thought we'd talk about it in a broader scale, start with a maybe see how the discussion goes and focus on a few points towards the end. So we're going to start with Sophie and Lisa, in policy making, what is it with science that you're really looking for, is it specific ideas or general topics?

I think it's quite topic specific. I worked for a government Quango on marine conservation and we were working to develop a network of marine protected areas and also working to develop targets and indicators under the marine strategy framework directive. In our case it was quite specific to those two areas. Was the idea brought up by the policy makers in this case say we wanted to develop marine protected areas or were the scientists perhaps suggesting that this was necessary?

How did that think about? In my opinion it comes from legislation being put in place, this will be implemented through stakeholders and public and then my role at that time was to help the organisation forward and develop this into a policy so it was understandable. A key example was that we look at scientific research on fishing impacts and actually working in the community to see that was quite difficult information to get hold of, especially case specific information. So that when you come and talk to scientists, try and get science involved?

Yes, we organise meetings to discuss such, for example, we look at impacts on marine habitats and yes we have to organise workshops with scientists. I guess it's one of the interesting things that we have the science policy interfaces that scientists will often think that they have the most and the best information that they've been collecting. It's really detailed and really specific but actually from the policy and if you like the kind of point of view, the scientist is just one stream of evidence that you've also got in the case of the marine framework, you've also got fishermen that are going out and have stakeholder interest, you've got members of the public. There's a whole range of other bodies that have the feed into this policy framework.

Anything we produce we'd have to be up to public consultation so you would get both the NGOs and the fishermen commenting on the, you know, it was reduced saying that there wasn't enough evidence or there wasn't enough being done. So it's perhaps important to realise that you're not necessarily going to be, you're not as important perhaps as you think, you're going to have your scientific evidence maybe reliable, robust, informative but it doesn't necessarily mean that that will directly influence. It could influence. It could influence and it does influence just as more going on than simply the science.

It seems that the fishermen are getting a lot more switched on about looking for holes in evidence as well. So there's organisations, some of them employ their own scientists as well. So they're very clever about spotting gaps and where a policy is supposed to be evidence led that can identify places where it's opinion led rather than evidence led. They're quite people to identify those and pick them up.

That could be the basis of a legal challenge to a policy later on. And that's been a big deal in the English, MPA, so a reputated area system where they had a whole load of reputated areas which were identified but then there wasn't an evidence based on tobacco or the map and they knew that they would get jumped all over by the fishing industry if they went ahead with a policy that couldn't be completely backed up. So it's part of your experience in this area. Have you been discussing, involved in organisations and groups or people or a policy, or meetings for example where you end up discussing these issues with lots of people?

I've heard some more dealings on the Scottish reputated area project which is... They're just some problems. Yeah, certainly. I've been looking at the Scottish White Fish Producers Association.

They're all over the MPA proposals. You know, saying, well, this isn't it. I don't really trust the evidence on this. This evidence will be produced by people who are biased.

They're expecting the Scottish Government not to use evidence in provided by NGOs. They want to move on evidence from hopefully impartial people. And so they quite switched on to this sort of stuff, the fishing and all. Intelligent group people, they would have a lot of knowledge in their able to spot dodgy data pretty well, I think.

It must be kind of looking at the policy point of view, must be kind of an interesting place to be or probably quite difficult places to be because especially over the last few years there's been massive public pressure for the marine protection to see. It seems to be something that's quite a lot on the public consciousness at the moment. So I can imagine that maybe historically the fishing lobby's been huge, but the public lobby's been made just like less, but in the last couple years, especially things like huge fish fight, you've got loads of people emailing the NEPs emailing the local MPs saying that this legislation has to go through special things with this cutting balance, for example, that they really want to see something done. And it must be difficult with the given time frame to try and fit in the policy or science evidence in place to actually provide the evidence to make sure that those policies are done correctly in the front time frame that say the use given.

Yeah, the time frame for the marine strategy frame I directed is very, very ambitious. It's a good environmental state as much 2020. You know, we don't even know what the current status of all these systems is. It's a really incredibly tough timescale.

But yeah, whether or not the public awareness of marine conservation is really like, I don't know, I don't really deserve a conversation with somebody who was generally interested in environmental things, who lived right on the shore of rock fine, you know, but he done creels out, you know, actually, I was really interested in the environment. I said, no, this is going to be a reprotated area soon. He said, well, it's a reprotated area. He said, no idea.

It was just not on his radar at all. So exactly who is getting, you know, how interested or knowledgeable people are in Scotland about repotected areas and repotivated areas. I don't know. It's only the polling suggests that people are more concerned about pollution than they are about fishing, for instance.

When pollution is, you know, in a lot of ways, it's not declining problem or fishing. Well, it says it's not a declining problem. I don't agree with James, however. The public awareness has increased a lot to the media, the reason is yes.

So it seems very important to be able to identify the different parties involved. So we've been a lot of people around the table of scientists and a few of you have been involved in the policymaking, but there's a whole range of other parties involved in the decision-making process and we're all members of the public. We also, there's also a public opinion about these issues as well, which is very important. I was wondering, I know that Lisa and Rodney are both involved in a group and organisation which is trying very hard to sort of establish good links between science and policy.

Lisa, do you want to tell us a bit about that organisation or that group? We're one of the three centres of expertise in Scotland. So it's a centre of expertise on animal disease outbreaks. It's called EPIC, so it's epidemiology, population, infection and disease control.

I was trying to work out how that acronym worked. Yeah, there's a small letter and big letter there. We were funded specifically to respond to both emergency and non-emergency disease outbreaks. And in that context, we directly provide advice to Scottish Government when they require it.

And the challenge, I think, what you were saying before to come back to is the time frame, is the tension between sort of, if you like, the time frame of a policy cycle, which I think is somewhere between three and five years versus the long time scale of research, and sort of balancing that to be able to provide emergency advice. So how the resilience of scientists to be in place you can respond to those short-term questions that are policy-relevant questions. And yet at the same time also be doing interesting cutting-edge science that balances out of science tests career, which is really difficult. So do you then, do you have scientists there who are conducting research and then pick out that research and then sort of feed it to the place that makes it a digestible way?

Or are the place that makes it the same? You know, we want the science done. We can get someone to work on this project for a while. Is it those ways or is it?

It's dialogue. It's very much a dialogue. So we have a situation where as a Rodney can come in on this, I think, but where you have different groups of scientists who are all working on very long scale projects, the policy makers will have a specific policy question and maybe that's something we can come back to later because framing that question is very different from a policy maker. The scientist question might be quite a different question you want to ask.

And then we have people like myself who are embedded in government to establish those communication links back and forth so we can then change that question back to the researchers, people like Rodney, and then Rodney can then frame those answers and we can help translate that answer from say a high-level science answer into a policy-relevant answer in the form of policy breach. It's quite a different output. So Rodney, how are you linked into this sort of organization's culture? Well, I guess there's two ways in which the policy side fits in with the science.

So I'm working on combining science with social science to look at the spread of disease, which is interesting for the scientists because it changes the advice that the scientists would give to policy makers. And it's interesting I think for the policy makers because it focuses on how people behave in the face of a disease outbreak and behavior of voters is going to be one of the things that politicians are, for example, particularly interested in. So you're involved in not just conducting the War Science Center and having that link to policy but also trying to understand perhaps how some of these other parties might respond as well with these such changes? Yeah, so it fits right between, I mean we're working teams of both scientists and social scientists and we have meetings where we have government policy people attending meetings who are getting their views as we go along on what we're doing and what direction we're going.

So it's very much an integration of these different communities, the policy community, the straight science community and the more social science community that sits in between policy and science. So I say, we're going back to some of the stuff we talked about before, the meeting today is, are they, is there a thing that's set up? Is there something that they sound this organization, the epic thing seems to be quite focused on mixing this science and policy? Is there anything going on in the marine science world?

There are a number of stakeholders, workshops, how many were there five in the end? Those are the questions we talked about. Yeah, five workshops that were supposed to bring together the scientists and the industry people with the government. There's not a sort of center of expertise for the marine environment in the same way as there is for disease and for climate change and for water resources is the other one.

So there isn't anything really equivalent. There is a new one coming on fisheries management which maybe will have this sort of role but there isn't something that's directly equivalent for the marine conservation. This is in Scotland, European libraries. So you go to the policy groups of the nice and sweet.

So what's the next? What's the next? International Council for the Exploration of the Seats. So there's regional grids within Europe that are set up for particular fisheries and every year there's an IC meeting where people get together and discuss particular issues with the training group.

That's trying to bring together lots of these different parties and policy makers and scientists and trying to get them to interact more effectively. I imagine it's been very fisheries as I would have thought from the start. For the deep water environment there are two on the water fisheries. One is a deep water environment, one which is more to do with these vulnerable marine ecosystems.

But it's mostly focused on what the effects of fishing would be on those ecosystems. Probably a less science than one or more stakeholders. One is the RACS regional advisory councils, we're fishermen NGOs and policy makers get together and discuss problems. So it sounds very easy instead of these groups.

It seems a lot of them. It becomes very quickly. If you're interested in how to see Katie is working in not necessarily in the UK but other countries and developing particularly. What do you find, how is it similar, how is it different, what you've been hearing on the table?

Well some of the structures for communicating science or communication between science and policy makers are definitely similar. So for example I was involved in science that was trying to inform the Indonesian government when there was outbreak of rabies in Bali. And FAO, the Food and Agriculture organisation, essentially the technical advisors and providing various financial assistance to India. Was that UK over?

No FAO is a world-time international organisation. So they basically organised meetings between scientists, the national government of Indonesia, the local government of Bali which is comprised of about seven different local governments. And various kind of NGOs and non-governmental organisations and so on. And local important stakeholders, politicians and so on.

Where we had to communicate the most effective strategy that we think they ought to take in the next few years and there was very good interactions between the whole group there. So in terms of the science that was the audience you're trying to provide was that evidence that had been looked at as well. So we had to focus on Bali for a while and then after a couple of years you set up the afternoon. So we tried to, we've done previous research in other countries which definitely provided a lot of guidance.

But one of the problems was when we went to Bali, we were asked because of our previous research to help in Bali. But when we went to Bali the first thing that people said was that Bali is different. There's no way the rest of the world is going to behave like Bali. So they wanted evidence that was really context specific.

And so we actually worked with local people there, local providers of data and analysed that information and tried to guide them. But it was interesting how the context really changed the way we communicated the science and the kind of messages that we really needed to get across. So that seems like a very good broad discussion of the different areas or different interactions between science and policy. We thought now because many of our listeners are probably not directly involved in policymaking or probably not conducting a lot of science acting directly in inference policy, it'd be interesting to know and get a feel for how scientists can go about perhaps having an impact.

So perhaps a good starting point is just to ask is it enough to simply just do your research and at the end of it try and get press attention. I know, and it's probably enough to wait to the end. I think you need to have a good sense, even if you're doing something that's very cutting edge, I think you have to have a good sense of what your main messages are. You need to be able to express them clearly in a way that's very accessible to the public and to other stakeholders and you need to have a good sense of who your audience is.

And by that being quite strategic about how those audiences can then take your message into the policy sphere. So you do have to think about it quite carefully because people couldn't perhaps misinterpret messages or perhaps not quite get the right thing. So I've got a good example of that from Indonesia where our aim as scientists to work on rabies control is ultimately to eliminate the disease. But in, but has Indonesian, the word elimination basically means to kill all dogs.

So in the context of rabies control, that's what that word means, which definitely doesn't control rabies. So we had to completely change our language and learn how we could communicate the messages of our science and also not use a word elimination obviously. But think about the local social context because it was pressure to kill a lot of dogs because it's a very immediate and visible thing that the government can do. But then again, lots of people didn't want their dogs killed.

So there was also a kind of positive and negative interactions between people who've been affected by rabies, if you didn't want their dogs killed and then trying to get the science in an objective way to this audience who are feeling very motive about the subject was difficult. That's a very interesting point, isn't that? Perhaps even if you wanted to just use the media as having you have your own care about the message you send out and also perhaps when you're also saying quite realistic about what you can actually achieve through having a victim message. So if you're not speaking with them, so if you have a message you want to send a policy maker, is it easy to do?

How much do you have to think about it on route to that point? There are a couple of different ways that this has happened with me. Sometimes you get to work with the policy teams and actually ask you to do it in the first place. And that back and sometimes come from them having pressure from their other stakeholders.

So a cabinet secretary for the environment in Scotland, he was getting a lot of pressure from the fishing industry to sort out the fisheries on the west coast. So he was getting lent on by the fishermen. So he lent on Marine Scotland to then convene a group of people to try and help them come up with answers for that. So in that case, you know that the stuff you're doing has been commissioned by the policy people.

So it's going to go straight back to them and they'll do whatever they want with it afterwards. You can't help but work to the people who need it. So what they're doing with it afterwards is a lot of questions. So I think the science in getting into the decision where they come to you and ask is how are you involved in such a way that they know about your research or let them know about your research so that they knew that you weren't a good person to be honest and that it was easy.

It wasn't because my particular expertise in that subject but I was known to the people who were convening me as being okay. Which is weird, I know. They're very, you know, in my experience they're not quite careful about who they go with. They like ex-government scientists for instance.

They end up working a lot with people who used to be in government who are now in academia. Other people that they know through another context or something like that. That seems to be quite important. Is that you think through like a shared language if you've got people that are very, very closely related to policy or ex- kind of policy makers you've got that ability to communicate much better than someone who's a complete blue sky scientist that has never dealt with a policy maker in their life?

I think so. There's a certain amount of trust about how they're going to act with the results. I guess understanding the context a bit more of that sort of thing. In my case I've just worked with somebody senior and Marine Scotland on a completely different sort of project.

And as a result when this came up he recommended me as being part of the group. And since then there's been a succession of other marine Scotland funded projects as a result of that. So it definitely comes from being known I guess personally rather than just through your publications. It's relationships isn't it?

It's relationships that you have with people because that's what allows you then because you trust each other and it's established in that relationship early on even before you have something you necessarily want to share. It allows you to be able to share it when the timing you hit the right timing and then there's some sort of zoned-upity in that. I guess that's the case for my PhD in photos. Recommended by someone from Scottish Natural Heritage to Government and a lot of some funding from PhD through that mechanism.

That's quite a nice direct example of how these interactions can facilitate science as well. And it's obviously a lot more than just simply as a scientist saying here's a message. So you actually do have to think about establishing these links and interaction with people who could make policy better. It's not just the government as well it's also these sorts of big organisations as well I think isn't it?

You can think of it as you mentioned you also have to try to sort of alter the policies or influence the policies of big organisations. Yeah, yeah so like the World Health Organisation, Food Agriculture Organisation, if we can get taken seriously by them then they write guidance documents which national governments all around the world pay attention to and can kind of form a basis of their policies. The question is do governments really pay attention to all of these? So an example here is the World Bank recently released a report just at the beginning of the month that shows that only it's 31% of any reports that are written whether they download.

And I think I figure that it's like 87% of their reports were never cited. So I think that I can understand the resource just to sit on shelves and get the seat. But that's definitely again where the personal relationship really helps because you have time to talk to the person who's influential in government or in an organisation. And what I would say about that is typically you have a message that you want to convey your science says this is a thing that you should do.

And you need to find as many ways of saying the same thing as possible. Because each time you say it, maybe someone will listen or someone will take it on board but a lot of the time it won't be. But once you've said it enough times in enough ways, hopefully someone gets the message. So if you've got a message from your project or a message from a particular paper, it's a case of going round and saying that message as many times as you can.

And I'm thinking you know not just the policy makers but other research groups and just getting things out there in attempt to try and disseminate your research. And I guess that's one of the main things that we're trying to do anyway. Not just with science and policy but with science in general, it's the better we can disseminate our message. And if people get here about our work, the more kind of exposure, the more impact you'll get.

Yes, that's true. Well governments becoming much more sort of reflexive and they're very interested in stakeholder values and interests. So if you have things like these types of podcasts where you're disseminating a message that really taps into one of those things. And the right person here is that they track that back and all of a sudden that becomes stapled at a meeting at a stakeholder meeting because governments always trying to bring those things into their policy making.

It might be good to sort of begin to tie things up. Is there a key message we can take away from this? Apart from that it's complicated. I mean that's understandable.

But say again for the novice scientist, the new scientist, the someone doing their PhD, who might be interested in the policy, what do you think might be the key message? This is what it is. I think it's important to make sure you separate our opinion from fact and that's really difficult. When you're asked your opinion on stuff, it's very flattering.

No, I think I'm so clever. You know, it's very, very dangerous I think. Very difficult to separate out your opinions and your wishes for how something might be from what you can actually back up with the facts. I think that's the major pitfall of a guilty obvious as anybody else.

But try and avoid going from being an independent academic, which is very privileged position to be in just another person with an opinion. I think it's not off by keeping things simple, but also enable the details to be accessed as well. Anything else? Just communication, good communication.

That's how it is. There's a really good advice I think. And on that note, we should probably end and thank the people around the table for the contributions and hopefully if you're listening, thank you for listening and we'll be back again soon. Thank you.

Thanks for listening to the Naturally Speaking Podcast. If you've got any ideas for future shows or want to get involved, please contact us. We'd love to hear from you. Our email address is naturallyspeakingpodcast at gmail.com.

Naturally speaking is a podcast from the Institute of Bardiversity Animal Health in comparison to the University of Glasgow. For more information, you can find us on Facebook. You can find us on Twitter at the NSPodcast and you can download future episodes and find more information at our blog at naturallyspeakingpodcast.webpress.com.

Never Alone Infertility Morgan and Madison Never Alone is a podcast for women navigating infertility, loss, and everything in between. We’re two friends whose paths intertwined during our own walks through infertility, and we understand how isolating and overwhelming the process can be. From the uncertainty of IVF to the heartache of miscarriage and the patience required in moments of waiting, we’re here for you.Join us each week as we have real and raw conversations about the challenges and emotions of walking through infertility and loss – both from our own experiences and speaking with other women. We’re glad you’re here, and hope you feel seen, supported and most of all know that you’re never alone. The Regular Man Podcast The Regular Man Podcast Welcome to the Regular Man Podcast, where we celebrate God's gift of masculinity in the life of the Regular Man. Here, there are no pastors, no pretense, and no pandering. Just interesting conversation, realistic expectations, and practical advice for the regular man. Steve Cruz is the host of The Regular Man Podcast, created specifically for the regular, hard-working, blue-collar man. He’s a husband and father who believes men should embrace God’s gift of masculinity and live a life of Christian virtue. Steve learned the value of hard work, integrity, and respect through an upbringing of cars, construction, and a cadre of strong hardened men. As a military veteran and law enforcement officer, Steve understands the value of speaking directly and plainly on subject matters that are, far too often, nuanced to death by the modern-day Christian Church. As the host of The Regular Man Podcast, Steve has down-to-earth

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Naturally Speaking?

This episode is 29 minutes long.

When was this Naturally Speaking episode published?

This episode was published on May 20, 2014.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Naturally Speaking episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.