Skip to content
Episode 149: The PHMSA Rulemaking Process with Alan Mayberry episode artwork

Oct 13, 2020 31 min

Episode 149: The PHMSA Rulemaking Process with Alan Mayberry

from Pipeliners Podcast Hosted by Pipeliners Podcast

Alan Mayberry, the Associate Administrator for Pipeline Safety with PHMSA, talks to Pipeliners Podcast host Russel Treat about the PHMSA rulemaking process. In this episode, you will learn about the PHMSA rulemaking process, why it's important, and how Congress and PHMSA work together to go through the rulemaking process. You will also learn about the stakeholders involved in the process and how to get involved yourself. - Access the show notes and full episode transcript at PipelinersPodcast.com.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 149: The PHMSA Rulemaking Process with Alan Mayberry

0:00 31:40
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Pipe Liners podcast, episode 149, sponsored by Burns McDonald, delivering pipeline projects with an integrated construction and design mindset, connecting all the elements, design, procurement, sequencing at the site. Burns McDonald's uses its vast knowledge, the latest technology and ownership commitment to safely deliver innovative quality projects. Learn how Burns McDonald's onsite through it all at BurnsMCD.com. The Pipe Liners podcast where professionals, bubba keeps and industry insiders share their knowledge and experience about technology, projects and pipeline operations.

And now your host, Russell Treak. Thanks for listening to the Pipe Liners podcast. I appreciate you taking the time and to show the appreciation we give away a customized Yeti Tomler to one listener each episode. This week our winner is Matt McCutchen with Philip 66 Pipeline.

Congratulations Matt, you're Yeti is on its way. Learn how you can win this signature prize back, stick around at the end of the episode. This week, Alan Mayberry, Associate Administrator for Pipeline Safety with FIMSA, is joining us and we're going to talk about the rulemaking process. We're looking forward to this one.

Alan, welcome to the Pipe Liners podcast. Thank you very much, Russell. It's good to be here today and talking about a subject near and dear to my heart. So you'll look forward to the discussion today.

Great. So I asked you to come on and talk about the rulemaking process. But before we jump into that, maybe you could tell the listeners a little bit about your background? Sure.

What been in the energy pipeline business for industry, if you will, for about 39 years of that, 39 years I was in the regulated industry or the pipeline industry for 24 years. And for the last 15 years, I've been here at FIMSA. Very rewarding career. I started at the University of Tennessee in Oxford.

So I need to put a plug in for the big orange. Go big orange. Yeah. Well, I went to Texas A&M.

So when you say big orange around me, I have a different idea. But I get your point. I hear you. And I know we're playing later this year.

So I need the best team win. There you go. There you go. So how long has he been with the agency?

I've been at FIMSA almost 15 years. And what did you roll at the agency? Well, as it does, I'm the associate administrator for pipeline safety. So I'm the head pipeline safety official for pipelines regulated by the agency.

Well, that I think that makes you very well qualified to talk about rulemaking. So maybe for the listeners, we'll start. We'll just talk about what is rulemaking and where does it come from? The federal government issues, rules or regulations, if you will, we kind of use the term interchangeably or code the code.

We use it to establish the minimum standard for in the case of what we do pipeline safety. So it's a process of which is very deliberative of proposing rule, getting comments on the rule, and then ultimately publishing a final rule. But as you might imagine Russell, there's a lot that goes into that process. Yeah, absolutely.

Absolutely. And I think, one of the things I wonder about is how did we get from the Constitution to what we do when we go to make rules or regulations? Good question. Well, the process, the deliberative process I really refer to is rooted really in the Constitution, our final government, or the existence of this country.

And it involves seeking input from stakeholders on what the policy will be, on what the standard will be. And that really forms the basis for how we work with our stakeholders to ultimately end up with the final rule that you will see in part 192 or 195. Yeah, being a guy who, I guess I've been getting close to regulatory rulemaking the last maybe 10 years. And I'm always amazed at how functional that process can be when you get people from very different backgrounds and very different interests trying to come together to make things better and make them appropriate and reasonable.

And that sounds easy, but it's not, at least in my experience. Well, the concept is easy. And it seems simple, because we're all familiar with what we look at every day with the codebook, if you will. But there's a lot that goes into making that.

And a lot of stakeholders have input on that process from our own data analysis that we do, or conduct to really drive where we may need to go where we may need to tweak a policy or rule. But there are other drivers too, like the Congress who authorizes us and also funds us to other oversight agencies, such as the National Transportation Safety Board, that investigates and oftentimes we're familiar with NTSB in the aftermath of an accident that they investigate oftentimes the recommendations and that would drive rulemaking. And then there are other oversight agencies like the Office of the Inspector General, Government Accountability Office, they too also provide drivers for rulemaking, if you will. And then lastly, actually, anyone competition for rulemaking too, that is one area we look at, we get deficient all the time to say, hey, FEMSA, you need to change this rule.

And we take a look at that and that can and does drive the rulemaking process on occasion. So I think most people would be kind of knowledgeable just from high school civics about Congress and what Congress does and how Congress makes law. How does the agency interact with Congress related to how these rules are getting put together and work through the process? Sure, good question.

And just a quick primer from that high school civics classes, you'll call the three branches of government, the executive, the legislative and the judicial, FEMSA falls under the executive branch. We work for the secretary who, or I work for the administrator who works for the secretary, our cabinet official for the Department of Transportation who in turn works for the president. So we fall under the executive branch. But we, as I mentioned, Congress both authorizes our program and they also fund us.

So we partnered with Congress on pipeline safety oversight. They created the original, this agency out of the pipeline safety act of 1968. And ever since that original law that put us into business, so to speak, we go back and are reauthorized. Hopefully every four years, we work with Congress, we provide technical assistance to Congress to help guide them as they provide the legislative language that keeps us doing what we do to oversee pipeline safety in the U.S.

So I want to come back, Alan, to the comment about stakeholders because having been kind of regularly attending the G-pack and LPAC meetings for the last several years, one of the things that's always kind of compelling to me about that process is the number kind of range and types of stakeholders. Maybe you could talk to us a little bit about who are the stakeholder groups and what are their various interests? Okay, sure. Well, stakeholders, obviously, are a key part of the process and who are stakeholders?

Well, they fall under three basic groups. There is the government officials, which could include other federal agencies, it could include state governments. So that's one category. The second category would be the public.

There's a public stakeholder, which would be people that live around pipelines. People are interested in pipeline safety. The pipeline safety trust is a key stakeholder in this group and they're the organization that represents probably the main clearinghouse, if you will, for working with the public. And then lastly, the regulated industry itself, the industry that operates pipelines.

We have memberships on our advisory committees from that group as well. So they're five of each. We have two advisory committees. You referred to the LPAC and the GPAC and GPAC, the F5 members of each of those stakeholder groups.

Right. And I think one of the things you didn't mention that was kind of clarifying for me is that it's not unusual for the members of that stakeholder group around other governance to go all the way down to the city level or be somebody that's representing first responders or firefighters or something like that. That kind of on the surface, if you really want to wear what's going on, might seem a little unusual, I guess. Well, I cover broad categories, but yes, first responders we have on our LPAC, we have a representative who represents that group.

We also have representatives within the public group, actually that represent labor. So it's a very diverse group, which really is fascinating to see the process because you see very diverse groups from the industry to some of the public members, which varies quite a bit from the groups we just talked about to the government groups, which also vary. And they all have different interests. But it's fascinating to see how the process works.

It's really where the sausage making happens and how we end up with a final rule that you see in the code book, ultimately. Yeah, and I think the other thing that you've said a couple of times is this word deliberateness. I think somebody who's not familiar with the process, they're going to ask the question, why does it take so long to go from a recommendation to a rule? It's not uncommon for that to be many years.

So I think at least in my experience, one of the things that's been very compelling to me is I've learned about the processes when I really start understanding what deliberateness means. So maybe you could talk about that a little bit about how does that influence the process that need for and commitment to being very deliberate in the process. It's very important to get the necessary input to as we develop a final rule. And it's a very mention, I've mentioned, deliberate process that takes time to get the input from all the stakeholders they're involved.

There are a lot of people involved in the process from our own staff to the stakeholders that represent our advisory committee. The stakeholders should comment on the rules that we address as they go forward to, our oversight agencies to other members of the federal government. There's just a lot of input to receive and also deliberate on as we work the process. So it takes time.

It seems like it shouldn't take so much time. I can tell you I've done this for the last 15 years and I find it very fascinating because it's just it's amazing how we end up with a final rule where everyone has input. The process is very rewarding, but everyone gets their say and we end up with a rule that represents that input that we receive. It's not like creating an own implant for an operator, which I've done in my past as well, which involves a lot fewer stakeholders and probably is a bit more controllable.

In this case, while we control the process that gathers input from a variety of stakeholders, it does take a bit more time to work through the process, work through the issues to land on something everyone can live with. Yeah, there's a question I want to ask that I think is informative and that is when you put out a notice, right? When the agency puts out a notice and they get comment back, what is the volume of the comment that you get back? I mean, how many pages of commentary would you typically get?

Could you give us kind of a sense of that? Well, it could be tens of comments to thousands, literally thousands of comments. So as we consider those comments and we look at all of them, they're very important to us and we look at review and consider every comment. And many of them typically wrestle can fall into certain groups of issues and similar viewpoints.

And so there's a lot of ethic goes on, but I can assure you we address every comment and it is laborious. But and that's why, as you see a rule and you may hear that, well, the gas transmission rule is 500 pages longer or what have you. You know, what we call the preamble of the rule, which is where we do a lot of the administrative explanation of the rule, that includes the addressing of comments. So that upfront part of the rule where the rule may only be, at least in federal register text, maybe 40 pages long, the preamble part might be 400 pages long.

Yeah, it's that's kind of why I'm asking the question is, I think when you think about getting thousands of comments back from disparate stakeholder groups and having to do the analysis to go through all that and find the commonalities, you know, where we have a common issue and then where are the arguments or positions, if you will, on each side of a particular issue and get that organized to the point that you can start making some decisions around it, you begin to have a sense of just, you know, how broad and deep that deliberateness actually is. Right. And there are a lot of steps in the process, Russell. I mean, we have, but aside from just, you know, receiving and addressing input from stakeholder groups as we develop the rule, but they're very carefully crafted and undergo a significant legal review and administration review before they ultimately become final.

I mean, there are a lot of steps in the process that involve, you know, just careful checks to make sure it's really appropriate for becoming a final rule. Yeah. And, you know, having attended some of the LPAC and G-PAC meetings, which is kind of a that it tends to occur nearing the end of the process. It's interesting what even comes up at that point in the process that can cause you to take a few steps back and reconsider things that you might have thought were settled.

You know, that's really the part of the process. I find most enjoyable because you go into these meetings and I say you go in, we go in with where we think the roommate land and sort of help the committee with some proposed texts that may work for ultimately landing on a position. But, you know, that can change and it usually does change based on the input. And yes, it's part of what makes this exciting though.

You know, things can change, they aren't, you know, the meetings don't always go as you might think they go, would go. But, you know, that's what the process is all about. That's again gets back to why it's important to have the stakeholders we have that provide such great input that, you know, keeps us putting out rules that, you know, we expect are the right size and the right detail to deal with the safety issue. Yeah.

So, maybe shifting the conversation a little bit, you were talking about the preamble being sometimes much more, much more volume than the actual rule itself. I actually think that the preamble is, you know, even some of these preambles which can be quite lengthy to sit down and read, even that's a summary of a much more involved process. But, you know, it attempts to give you the context for how we arrived at the decisions we arrived. And here were the various stakeholders and viewpoints that were key in arriving at this conclusion.

I think that part of it is really fascinating and sometimes difficult to digest and understand. And that's a very good point, Russell. And that's really a secret we can sort of put out there today that, you know, perhaps people don't know it because they're so used to pulling up our regulation and reading it and scratching their heads maybe sometimes looking at various guidance that's available out there. But a real good tool is to go back to the rule as it was written and to read the preamble.

And then you'll know, why the heck did they do that? Well, you'll read in the preamble. It explains that usually pretty well and why we did, you know, what we did to address. Yeah, I would agree with that Alan.

I when I when I, you know, my first experience with things I grew up as a measurement skated guy. My first experience was when the when the control room management rule was working its way through. And I remember very clearly the first time I set down I read that rule and I'm just it was like I was reading Greek to be frank. It just it just I couldn't anchor into what it was talking about.

And it wasn't until I found some subject matter experts and some reading materials that talked about, you know, some accidents and the findings from those accidents and some things around human factor science and so forth. And all of a sudden it was like, Oh, and then I went back and read the preamble and read the rule. It all makes sense. Right.

So there's a certain amount of just you don't know what you need to know in order to know. I mean, it's a goofy way to say that. But there's a certain amount of that that you just kind of have to climb a certain part of the mountain to get to the point you have the understanding. Right.

And there are there are a variety of ways people have to get clarity or ask for clarity. You know, obviously the the different groups that are out there that share information I think is a great way, you know, ask your colleagues that work with it as well. But you know, also ask us, we you know, there are a variety of tools that people have, you know, on occasion we're asked for interpretations of the code. And so that's that's one way to do it is to write to us to seek clarification.

Right. Well, yeah, that we could do a whole conversation just on that process right there. I'm sure. I don't want to go there right now.

I want to maybe shift a little bit more. So it seems like that in the last 10 years, you know, pipelines have been more in the news than they were historically. You know, my assumption is that that's being somewhat impacted by shell gas and what's happening with in particular gathering around around the shell plays. You know, I realize that that is a member of the senior member of the agency.

You're a civil servant. So I want to be careful about how I asked the question. But what I'm trying to drive at is what are you seeing happening as as a result of shell gas and the, you know, the larger pressure, larger pipe, you know, the in the maybe oil and gas production happening in areas where it hasn't happened before. How is that impacting what the agency does?

And how's it impacting the rulemaking process? Well, I think it's amazing what a difference a few years will make. And you know, it was only, you know, 10 years ago, maybe a little bit less. I was working very diligently, I might add, on the concept of importing liquified natural gas.

And, you know, lo and behold, the shell gas revolution happens, shell gas and oil revolution happens. And now we're looking to and we are exporting liquified natural gas. I think to the Russell, if you look, you know, the 2010 timeframe, you know, number of events happened, you know, from Deepwater Horizon, a couple of major accidents, including the one in San Bruno, the one in Marshall Michigan, along with the shell gas revolution that, you know, the the area of energy and the policy, energy policy in the United States really has evolved. And certainly our agency has evolved as well out of, you know, the original small agency that was created out of the natural gas pipeline in safety act of 1968, to where, you know, there's a greater interest, you know, we're hearing more daily from, you know, major networks, for instance, news networks that may have an interest in what we do was previously, it may have been reserved more to the trade journals, it's just a lot more of an interest in energy policy and certainly pipeline policy.

So I've seen that evolve, and it's quite significant these days. Yeah, you know, I think that's an excellent point, you might call them, because if you think back just just 10 years ago, and where we were, you know, we were in that importer of crude oil, we were in net importer of natural gas, we were concerned about availability of natural gas to drive the economy. And with the shell revolution, both those things have completely reversed and in a very short period of time. And really, to some degree, I mean, to frame this as a question, but to some degree, that happens quicker than the agency can easily respond.

Is that a fair statement? Well, I'd say we've responded quite effectively within, you know, our authority, we've found that we've really had to pivot for the export market, for instance, related LNG. And I'm really proud of what we've done in the area of working with our federal partner, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, to make sure that we have an efficient process for reviewing LNG export applications. But you know, regardless of the environment of energy and, you know, the coming of age, we're talking about the show gas revolution, our focus remains on safety.

We're a safety focused agency. That's the sole reason we're in business. My dad just incidentally, the other area that sort of emerged, if you will, as an issue coming out of the shale gas and oil revolution is the area of gathering lines. And we've noticed that, you know, whereas before, before this current environment, you know, gathering lines tended to be smaller diameter short distances, but with the show gas and oil revolution, we're seeing where gathering lines now can be very large diameter, 42 inch, operating at over 1000 psi, which seems to be more like a transmission line, but yet it's a gathering line.

But that's a notable thing that we've seen is the occurrence of these lines that really are gathering, but they act like transmission lines. Yeah, and if you think about that, yeah, I think that's a great point. I want to get to a great point. If you think about that from a purely a safety and a risk perspective, you know, 42 inch line over 1000 psi, that's a very different risk profile than what would have historically been gathering with two or four inch lines running at 125 psi or less.

So, you know, as a safety agency, that becomes a material shift in terms of how you think about, you know, how you execute your mission, I would think. Sure. And that's why we're having a conversation about gas gathering. We can't, we're in rulemaking, so we really can't talk about it.

But that's really one of the reasons why gas gathering is an area that we are currently in rulemaking on. So let me kind of wind this up. I want to ask this question. What is it that you wish pipeline operators knew, or maybe even the community more broadly than that knew about regulatory rulemaking that they maybe don't know?

Well, I think a lot of operators appreciate the process. I tell you, one in particular is their input matters. I think there's a tendency to not, you know, maybe to funnel input through another group or not to engage, but we rely on input to help us, whether you're an operator or a public stakeholder. So I wish they knew that, you know, don't hesitate to provide that input.

If you see a rulemaking document, we're asking for comments. Don't think that we are, you know, that your opinion wouldn't matter or somebody's already covered it. It really helps if you provide that input. So I wish people knew that they could exercise that or would exercise that more.

That may seem counterintuitive. Yeah, it might. It might. And certainly, you know, a lot of the perspective about the government is I don't want to be in their business.

I don't want them in mind. And I can get that. But I think the point you make really, really on point, and that is that the rulemaking can only be as good as the input provided. It's the thing you don't consider.

It's not misconsidering something that came in. It's the thing you don't consider that ends up being most problematic. And that's broader than just rulemaking. That's just kind of in what we do in general.

I guess the other, and I could actually say this instead, Russell, is to consider what goes into that process that ultimately they see in a final rule that there's just a lot of good people working on it, a lot of very smart people at the Office of Pipeline Safety at FEMSA that work with our stakeholders very diligently. Just some of the best people. I work with some of the brightest minds in the business who help advance rules and help writers or engineers or scientists and just a lot of good people doing good work to work with the stakeholders and to end up with the rules that we all work with today. Well, Alan, thank you so much for coming on the podcast.

I know you're quite busy. I'm glad you were able to make time to do this and really appreciate it. Well, my pleasure, Russell, and thank you very much for having me. I hope you enjoyed this week's episode of the Pipeliners Podcast and our conversation with Alan Mayberry.

Just a reminder, before you go, you should register to win our customized Pipeliners podcast, Yeti Tumbler. Simply visit Pipelinerspodcast.com slash win to enter yourself in the drawing. If you'd like to support the podcast, the best way to do that is to leave us a review, and you can find instructions on the website. If you have ideas, questions, or topics you'd be interested in, please let me know on the Contact Us page at Pipelinerspodcast.com or reach out to me on LinkedIn.

Thanks for listening. I'll talk to you next week.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Pipeliners Podcast?

This episode is 31 minutes long.

When was this Pipeliners Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on October 13, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Pipeliners Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.