Hello again everybody and welcome into another edition of Political Beats, a presentation of National Review. We invite you to follow us on X at Political Underscore Beats. We'll also run Facebook as well and subscribe to defeat for new episodes through Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your audio, find us too at nationalreview.com, click on the podcast tab where possible. Go ahead and leave reviews, help others find the program.
We also direct you to our Patreon page, patreon.com slash political beats, support us there, help the show stay ad free as it has been. We have entry level for your support and some voting privileges from time to time, mid level for early access to our programs and at a higher audio quality and our upper level best friends for early access, the higher audio quality, monthly exclusive content episodes, the Ask Us Anything show coming up later in December. Remastered episodes, playlists and more, all of that patreon.com slash political beats. Now the part of the program where we thank some of our Patreon supporters personally for their efforts over the years.
Thank you to Jack, Mark and GR, Mac, Michael, Jim Peterson, Phil C, Captain America, James Tucker, John Rosenblatt, Darren and Andrew Howard. Thank all of you for helping us make this happen here at political beats. You can join them by going to patreon.com slash political beats. My name is Scott's Bird Trampine, me on X at Scott Bird Tramp.
My tag team partner, standing by as always, Jeff Blair. Jeff, how are you? Well, I can tell you I'm certainly not standing. I'm not doing so great.
I'm not going to lie, Scott. I got a little bit too into preparation for this week's episode and try to do a mid-air splits. And all I'm going to tell you is that I used to be a lot more flexible than this. Oh boy, well, we hope the recovery is swift and you'll be back to hanging from the rafters in no time.
I'm walking funny. Yeah. At Esoteric CD for Jeff on X and we welcome our guest for today's program. We'll tell you more about why we're doing it in a moment, but Sean trendy's back with us.
Senior Elections Analysts Real Clear Politics, a visiting scholar at AEI and co-host with another political beats guest, Jay Cost, brand new podcast called Stubborn Things. We'll hear more about that in just a moment. Sean, thanks so much for joining us. Oh gosh, thanks so much for having me back.
You sound better this time. Wiser, older. Sean. Eight years wiser.
Yes. Certainly. Was that really eight years ago? Eight years ago, man.
August, I think more than that actually. August 2017. So a little more than eight years ago. Oh my gosh.
Wow. Sean, tell us first before we get to our ban today, a little bit about you and your work at Real Clear Politics and in particular, the new podcast Stubborn Things. Yeah, so I've been with Real Clear Politics since 2010, so 15 years now. And my day job, my primary job is analyzing elections, electoral trends, writing about demographics and trying to do quantitative analysis at a level that average people can sort of understand.
The podcast is actually through American Enterprise Institute. Jay Cost and I have been friends for a long time. He was at Real Clear Politics with me when I started. And we are trying to give a more historical and grounded view of elections.
Both of us have PhDs, so we do understand this stuff pretty deeply. But I think what makes this unique is that we think that's the least important of our credentials. We want to have the knowledge base to be able to get down in the weeds and understand the arguments on both sides. But we think what's really most important is an ability to kind of communicate that and to be willing to apply some common sense when appropriate.
And that's available now Stubborn Things where you find your fine podcasts. Jay not Jay Jay's your co-host Sean. Sean is back with us this time. You might remember his voice from the very first episode of political beats ever recorded and we'll give you a bit more on the background of that in a moment.
But suffice to say, there are reasons we have decided to reconvene today to talk once again about the great American rock band Van Halen. And as we begin, we turn the floor back over to Sean who can tell us why he loves Van Halen, how he got into the band and why people should care about this music we're going to discuss today. Sean. Sean.
Sean. So my story with Van Halen actually starts back in eighth grade and I was on a band bus. I just started playing guitar. I had a little cheap acoustic guitar that was so poorly out of tune.
The 12th fret, which is supposed to be an octave above the open key was actually a full half step higher. If you played the 12th fret on the E, you actually got an F. It was regardless. I loved it.
And I was on the bus I think to a band concert or something and I was talking about with my friend, Ken, who was a drummer and he said, oh, you got to listen to this. He got an older brother. So he was always passing along the cool music to us that way. And he played, I took the cassette tape and put it in my Walkman and Spanish fly was up.
And I just listened to that and I was like, what in the world is going on here? He was doing things I didn't even know were possible on the guitar. And so over the course of the next six months or so I use my allowance to collect all of their cassette tapes. And they were just they were my favorite band for most of late middle school in high school.
All right. Well, I guess it's time for me to explain why we're doing this episode over again. And this is a story that I guess we may have told once or twice perhaps on our Patreon, but I don't think we've ever discussed here. So I will begin by saying that episode one of Political Beats marks the first and last time that we've ever taped an episode of our show where I've never actually listened to the music before recording the episode.
And I was been haunted by that ever since we went over how this thing came together. As I said on Patreon, it was very last minute for the first episode. We had been fumbling around trying to find a time trying to find a topic trying to find a cast. And then all of a sudden it came together.
I think it was Scott who might actually know the specifics about this. He said, Hey, well, Sean said he wants to do Van Halen. We can do it right now. And I mean, literally right now, as in three hours from that moment, we taped our first episode of Political Beats.
And I had about that much time to try to go back and remind myself of some of the greatest hits. And I don't know that the show sounds nothing like the rest of our episodes, not a single one of them, even our second episode. We've got a little bit better about sorting out the format and I can at least assure you that I was familiar with the band I was talking about. I'd had time to prepare in that case.
I had no preparation time in this case. And it really has always haunted me because I later on went back to listen to Van Halen and all the stuff that I didn't know anything about. The albums I never heard of, the songs that I never discussed, well, that really actually turned out to be a lot of a meat of their musical legacy. And so there are only two show episodes of Political Beats that we have ever rerecorded.
And I think those are the ones we ever will really rerecord. And I suppose it's got to be some sort of cosmic irony or coincidence. But the other person we did this with was Jay Costes with the Kinks. Okay, we did that one at the beginning of the year.
And we had to do that for a couple of over-determined reasons. It should have been a two-parter. Jay had to leave early a lot of things. And this is a similar situation where I felt like I was not prepared.
I felt we did not do the band justice. And I guess that actually brings me to what it is I like about Van Halen. What is it that I wanted to do justice to about this band? Well, it's funny because by the way, I've not gone back to listen to that first episode.
I don't know what I said there. So I'm later, Peter. I don't recall anything. I mean, that thing was recorded in just a blur.
And again, at the last second. So I repeat myself, forgive me. But Van Halen to me as a kid was just a phenomenon of MTV and the radio. My brother might have bought a couple of their albums, but I was never into them at that time.
At that age, I was probably more into like radio pop and Phil Collins for that matter. I wasn't into the hard stuff. I went for unlawful carnal knowledge come out 1991. That puts me in sixth grade as an 11-year-old.
So imagine the kinds of things you're listening to at that time. My brother was into the ACDC who's a year-old that I was, but not me. So when we recorded that episode, I was thinking, what did I know? I know the big hits from the first album I knew right now, some of those Sammy Hagar songs.
But I didn't understand what it was that this band brought to music, how important they were in the late 70s, were basically kind of cementing a sub-genre of music. It eventually grew into hair metal, but it really didn't describe Van Halen themselves in a curious way. Because Van Halen themselves, of course, we know, you know, it's Van Halen brothers, it's David Lee Roth at first, and then it's Michael Anthony. You know, you've got the Van Halen brothers and it's the guitar technique that first jumps out to anybody.
The advances that he made in a turn that I'm frankly unfit to discuss on a technical level, but you just hear instantly, you hear the sound of a eruption and that's Eddie Van Halen. That's a style that everybody on their mother was going to try to be imitating over the next half decade. But then, you know, what you'll also find out about this band is that they had a lot of personality in between the groups. They did a lot more than just the big, stadium rockers.
They did cool, like little side, you know, bluesy, folksy stuff, group vocals, like little, that zettling tribute that kind of poking it out of their material. The group had a ton of personality, and that was just with David Lee Roth. The biggest thing that people will discuss about Van Halen is the break between David Lee Roth and Sammy Hagar. And the other thing that I've really come to appreciate now that we're coming back to rerecord this group, rerecord this episode is that Van Hagar has a fair amount to recommend it.
There are some good songs. There's actually one pretty darn good album in that run, and I understand exactly why people roll their eyes at it. Every criticism people have made about Sammy Hagar's lyrics, remains perfectly valid. Some of the music is far too generic and keyboard based.
They evolve into a very different and radio ready proposition, but a second half of Van Halen's career is actually also still pretty great, right up until they end it, basically with balance. And then everything afterwards is like, you know, zombie dragons, you know, that's a weird, weird afterlife of Van Halen's career is something we can at least briefly discuss at the end of the show. But really, the story ends for the most part with Hagar. I appreciate it.
None of this when we originally recorded the episode. I do now, and that's why I'm really eager to actually talk about what these guys brought to rock music. I just didn't do this band just as clearly in the first episode, but that's largely because we didn't know what the show was going to be in the first episode. We were fumbling around and thought, well, we just skim over some of the highlights, but our strengths are doing much more than that with our with our bands.
And so Van Halen needed to be revisited for a number of reasons. I did love Van Halen growing up. You know, MTV played a huge role, Panama, and hot for teacher, and jump being on constantly. I remember David Lee Roth's, you know, crazy from the heat solo, EP in the California girls video and the just remember that video and then the split and Sammy.
And so I mean, I own 51 50 on cassette. I own 1984 when I was, you know, in the single digit of age, wore out for unlawful carnal knowledge. I mean, these songs, a huge number of these songs are just part of my DNA. I've heard them.
I don't know how many dozens or hundreds of times over the years. And so this is this is a band that I have not conflicting opinions about, but certainly, I think I'll probably be tougher on the Hagar era than the Jug will be. We'll see every I didn't say I was going to praise it. I was just going to say that things to praise the balance.
And you know, the split is so interesting. This is what is interesting because around that time, my dad owned a synchronicity by the police on vinyl and he owned Heartbeat City by the cars on vinyl and then 1984 was everywhere. And so when I'm starting to grab these records, I'm probably, you know, six, seven years old. And my first thought is, wait a minute, the police were hugely successful and this album's great.
Why would they break up the cars? Heartbeat City sold a billion copies and they broke up and why would David Lee Roth break up with Van Halen? Why would he leave Van Halen? I was very confused about why successful bands would implode in this matter.
They were making great music and they were really successful. Why couldn't they just go on and do that forever? Well, there are many reasons we'll discuss today about why Van Halen couldn't work with David Lee Roth and then Sammy Hagar and then David Lee Roth and then Gary Sharon and then Sammy Hagar and then David Lee Roth and then David Lee Roth. So we'll talk about all that during the course of the show today.
But really, you know, we'll talk first about where Van Halen comes from because, and I think we'll discuss when we get to the first record of the debut, you know, trying to find the roots, the core of where Van Halen comes from musically is maybe a bit tougher than you'd expect. It's a band that doesn't sound a whole lot. I mean, you can hear elements, you know, I can identify a few things for you here and there, but this Van Halen sound that they produce, that they came up with is their sound. I don't think they're really trying to grab from others necessarily.
It's something that they developed themselves because they had the ultimate weapon in Eddie Van Halen, who would do things that no one else could do. So we'll get to the debut in a second. How about I fill in a little bit of backstory, a little bit of history of the band as we build up to the first record? Famously, the Van Halen brothers are not from around here.
They're born in the Netherlands and moved out to California in the early 1960s. Their dad was very musically inclined when they were young Eddie learned piano first actually and was extremely talented on the piano so that the move to synth and piano later in the band's career shouldn't have been unexpected. And the brothers started playing Eddie on drums, of course, Alex on guitar, just like we've always known them. At some point, they switch.
Alex picks up the drum kit while Eddie's off and develops a passion. Delivering newspapers or something like that. Isn't that the story? Like he'd be up slinging newspapers at doorsteps and Alex would be practicing on his drum kit and he's still trying to pay off.
Yep, and got pretty good at it. And so at some point Eddie said, okay, okay, you take the drums, I'll take the guitar and we'll go from there. They formed a band in 1964 called the Broken Combs, I love those 60 bands names, 60s band names, play a lot of parties and high school functions. They changed the name to the Trojan rubber company, then to Genesis.
Genesis didn't know the British band. In 1972, by the way, they should have known by that. Come on. And later changed from Genesis to Maneth and Mammoth stuck around for a while.
And he was singing at this point and playing lead guitar and Alex was on drums that a friend named Mark Stone on bass around this time they started renting a PA system from this dude named David Lee Roth for 10 bucks a night. And eventually sort of collapsed and gave in and let David Lee Roth join the band to save on money from renting his PA, even though he had failed like multiple auditions. Now you're not good enough for us, but we do want your PA system. Roth claims he convinced the guys to change the band name from Mammoth to Van Halen.
I have no idea if that's actually true or not. They played clubs, they played all over Los Angeles, played all over West Hollywood, and people started to really dig the sound. Later in 74, Michael Anthony joins the band, replaced Stone, who was kind of ambivalent about actually continuing in a career in music and playing bigger places playing Whiskey a go go getting people out getting people excited. At some point, Gene Simmons of Kiss is introduced to the band.
He likes them a lot and he puts together this almost 30 track demo of Van Halen songs in 1976. That doesn't get the band a record deal and eventually Simmons has to go play and kiss and drops the idea of trying to work Van Halen into a money making proposition. But others are still enamored of the band and somebody convinces this guy named Ted Templeton, Templeman, excuse me, to come out and watch the band. And Templeman comes out along with a Warner Brothers exact and they see him play.
He's a big head. I'm sure. I've seen his name over everything from my band, the horse and records that do be his everything. Yeah.
And they love it. I love it so much. They write up this agreement on a napkin to come back next week. They nail it down and they give them a two record deal with monetary points that were very much in favor for Warner Brothers.
But that's the case for a lot of bands when they start out and then they have to sue their back catalog renegotiate. But that's how Van Halen makes their way to Warner Brothers records who would release this debut album recorded late in 77 in just a couple of weeks released in February of 1978. And I'm certain I don't recall specifically Jeff, but I would imagine that this one was included in our greatest debut albums of all time episode again. Way, way, way back when in our exclusive content shows, because this first Van Halen album is an absolute grand slam from start to finish.
One of the greatest debut of all time. It's Van Halen. Van Halen won, you know, a couple things I think back for a little bit for the back. You left out my favorite part of the G-Simmon story, which is that he had an idea for name as well.
He wanted them to change their name to daddy short legs. And he had a little like mascot drawn up. It was a spider and a top hat with like short legs. And so we imagine the world might be a very different place had jeans, cinnons.
For those of you who believe that all things in life happen for a reason, like I think this is a pretty strong argument in your favor. Yeah, I also kind of think Van Halen's not the sort of band that would have looked great in stage make-up. With like, but like, so the thing that strikes you about Van Halen won, and it's a big picture thing about the band that maybe I should have done part of why you should listen to them. But so, you know, I listen to, I have a musical background and I love the like, Furtu Wosobans, right?
Like, if you ever want to do a Dream Theater episode for some reason, like, I can be your guy. But, you know, Dream Theater, Rush, early Genesis, like, they're all, it's incredible musicianship, but it's not terribly accessible, right? You couldn't play this at a party unless you wanted everyone to leave. No one wants to hear Count of Tuscany except me.
But Van Halen is different, right? Like, it has arguably the world's greatest guitarist. It has one of the world's greatest front men of all time. Not so much vocalist, but great front man.
Great drummer, good bass player, but the probably in the conversation for greatest like background vocals, but they're a party band. Like, they're at their core band, you could go, you could have gone to a frat party and like heard playing, because they did come up through the clubs. And that's what comes through on Van Halen one is you put that cassette tape in back in the 80s and press play, and it starts out with like the horns coming out, I guess like someone actually drove their car past the speaker to record. So that's an actual Doppler effect that's kind of mixed up.
Then Eddie puts his pick across the strings above the nut, so it makes kind of this like high pitched clanking sound. And that just goes into this like rocking guitar riff. And that first song, like, if you heard he was the greatest guitarist of all time, you might be listening to it and thinking, okay, like, I like the riff, like, it's got a great sound, but it's got a really straightforward guitar solo, two great straightforward guitars solo. And then that song ends.
There's your like two second song break. And then the drums come in and he launches into eruption. That is just a two minute escapade of stuff no one had done on the guitar about. That's where he introduces his famous two hand tapping technique.
And so he the way he puts it, he went to go see Led Zeppelin in concert. And I left hand a guitarist, I have to think about the hands so I can flip them over. But yeah, so Jimmy Page was doing this thing where he was just going with his left hand up and no hammering on it's called hammering on and pulling off where you bang your finger on the fretboard, it makes a sound and you pull it off and you get the open note string. And he was going up and down the fretboard with his left hand.
Then he took his right hand and he put it behind his left hand. So he was effectively like acting as a capo on the string, kind of moving that bass note up and down while he did his normal thing with his left hand. And then he thought to himself, you know, that's kind of a weird way to do it. What if you use the two fingers on your left hand and then hammer on with your right hand above?
That gives you a lot more flexibility. And you know, people say, well, people have done it before. That's fine, but no one had done it like any band hailing did. And he ties in, you know, you can use that then to kind of play chords, you know, like the first third and fifth really easily and minors and everything.
And he then used his musical knowledge from playing piano and playing violin. He actually works in a little bit of a famous violin a to the da da da da da da da da da da. But it gives this kind of classical feel to it. That was just it had never been done.
Your peggiation in particular, those core progressions as he goes to the climax of it, that's a very classical run. It doesn't sound like it sounds for the first time in 1978 of a sort of classical style that you'd associate with people like Steve Vi or Ying v. Malbstein and kind of a competitor of his later on. But or maybe even Zappa, Zappa in the 70s, the late 70s, one of the very few people who was playing in that form.
But Eddie Van Halen just did something completely different with it. The thing about Van Halen, it comes to mind when I'm listening to you discuss them, is how the chops like the incredible like fiery guitar sound and also the classical chops are one thing. But there's also such a formalism to the way Eddie Van Halen actually constructs these songs. Now I say him, I don't know these things are all group credited, but I don't really know who does most of the song right and you have to assume the classically trained musician is the one who's doing it, right?
The guy who has the ideas, the vision guy, right? But he does great prog songs, right? Every Van Halen song is a rock song. It's a basic song.
They have great chord changes. They have really interesting kind of middle eight or something like that. But they all stick really within like you know the basically the 40 yard lines of what you would consider to be hard rock to be. They don't ever try for something like Genesis as you say.
And that makes this sort of flash both remarkable and self-contained and basically undeniable. It turns it into candy. This first album like the only problem with Van Halen one is the fact that almost all the really great songs are on the side one. Like the first side is so famous that the second side songs feel a little bit more anonymous except for Jamie's crying, which is a really great famous pop song.
But like it begins with running with the devil. Then it goes to eruption and it goes to you really got me, which is probably actually my least favorite of their big famous covers. I don't know if they do the kinks that well. I guess it's something that David can sing.
It's right David Lee Rothkin sing the vocals. So you really got me and Eddie gets to do something completely insane that of course Dave Davis never had a chance to pull off whether in 1964 or any time in his life. But the real one that just jumps out to me on that record that I heard by the minute in Man of All People first is ain't talking about love, which is has that furious opening riff. It just sounds like it doesn't even sound like it sounds like the invention of a sound.
Boston didn't make that kind of noise when they put out their album a year or two before. No one sounded as thunderous as Eddie Van Heyland did on ain't talking about love, which to me by the way explains the overall virtue of this record, which is that it sounds really live. It sounds like they're playing in a big like an empty stadium. Not a stadium, but an empty theater, right?
But you've got that echo that room echo. You don't even feel like you hear a lot of overdubs. I know there are them because they can hear two guitars and some of the songs, but it feels like a very kind of a spare stripped down album. There's not a lot of pop.
There's not a lot of like syrupy keyboards that's something we'll talk about later on in their career. It just feels really raw and not pumped but just like and doesn't have any of the glamor or the pretense of what hair metal would later grow on to become. This stuff's the real thing. So the thing about getting Van Heyland is that you know what we can talk about this will come in a little later on too, but he's not a very pleasant person.
He's kind of a jerk. All these people except Michael Anthony were difficult to get along with. Yeah, yeah. And so that overdub thing actually like was a nonstop fight during the recording of this album because Eddie did not want to use overdubs.
He wanted he was just insisting like this is how I play live. I want to play it like I play live. I'm like, but this isn't live. This is an album.
And you can get a fatter sound and keep the riff going that you solo. Anyway, so that's part of why it's so spare is because that's what that was like to play Kate Eddie. And it's not the first time that play. It works through the benefit like running with the devil.
That's a rhythm track. Right. He doesn't really play lead until he gets to like the solo part. But like the whole song itself, the verse of that is just him one guitar playing it with such like, you know, fury that it just sounds like it could be three different guys else coming at the same time.
Yeah. Well, you know, the other thing about that album and I agree with these side two is the weaker entry, although I do still love it. But it also shows off some of their diversity that a lot of bands didn't have. You have that you have ice cream man, which is like an old 1920s John Brim.
It starts out with like a boogie, woogie acoustic part. Then it goes into like the rock part, but it's still bluesy. One more. You have to remember too, this album drops at the height of the disco era.
You know, I think you can make the case that like this saves rock and roll. You know, I mean, yeah, you had Boston and there's still plenty of rock and Leonard Skinner playing a rock band. Here's the thing actually that occurs to me, this might sound blasphemous, but I was thinking who was making anything remotely sounding like this back in the 70s in American music? And it was actually probably Aerosmith until they fell off the wagon.
They they peaked with rocks that would be like 76 and then like their next album, which is 77 draw the lines and atrocious. They fall in it. They fall straight into the drug ditch at that point. And then here comes Van Halen a year later to just pick up the torch and carry it somewhere else.
Yeah. I mean, it's it's really I mean, it's a musical masterpiece in a milestone, because like you said, everyone kind of takes the classical feel in rock and metal guitar for granted now, but like this is where you first have it coming in and Yang Vay, Momstein builds on that and and Randy Rhodes and you know, but they're building on that. It's a foundation that any Van Halen laid. I also want to point out that this album peeled to everybody back then.
Everybody who was young and into music and was kind of cool, loved the first Van Halen album. There was nothing that was thought to be like corporate or kind of lame about this. This was hot and fresh. I mean, as I said, some of the songs in this album, I heard first from like, like crazy, math rock, post-punk bands, like the Minuteman on Double Knuckles on the Dine.
They do a great version of me talking about love. They don't play guitar as well as any Van Halen does, but they've got the spirit of that in there. I found these songs in all sorts of places before I even encountered them on this album. And of course, the thing is they also had like what four years to prepare for this record?
Those songs had been germinating for a long time. They played them on stage. They knew what they, that was why he was so insisted obviously, because he knew what he wanted to sound like. He knew what these things sounded like when they got across live.
And then they had about like, you know, four months to record their second album. And that brings us to Van Halen too. Watch me know what Scott, have you seen anything about Van Halen first yet? No.
Sorry. Maybe we shouldn't pass over you. I'm just listening. I'm just listening.
I'm just listening. You know, it is, it is, I wasn't even planning to say much because I just listen and experience. Like so many of these songs, as I mentioned, have become part of DNA and talk about love, of course. But even beside two ones that you guys say aren't quite as good.
I mean, feel your love tonight is one of my favorites on this record. No one was sounding like this at this time. No one at all. And it doesn't sound like it kind of grooves, but it shakes in the right way.
And those backing vocals, like Landry leading at a Van Halen, begging you baby. That's, you know, how many times throughout the course of the show today that the backing vocals actually sing the chorus, right? I mean, they're the ones pushing things forward while Dave does is yelps and jumps around. Those backing vocals do a lot of heavy lifting on a song.
That's gonna come up on a motorway on the next. I think I'm the one is fantastic. I'll actually, this will be my segue into this. I know if you guitar players, one of them told me that actually I'm the one is the hardest Eddie Van Halen thing to replicate, especially the intro on the one.
And my friend, my friend, Ivan Pongrassik is an economics professor here at Hillsdale, but he's also a very successful respected surf guitarist. He's played with a number of bands over the years. And he was coming of age of guitar right around the time Eddie was exploding. And I asked him, look, you're an actual guitarist.
I'm not. What do you think about Eddie? And so I'm just going to read a little bit of what he wrote. He said, Eddie is by far the most important guitarist of the past 50 years.
He revolutionized how guitar was played and sounded even what modern guitars looked like and the features they were expected to have. I'd go as far as saying that he basically single-handedly was responsible for the explosion of guitar sales and the profusion of pop-hair metal bands of the 80s. Van Halen shaped the hard rock music of the 80s for better or worse. Pretty much all rock metal guitarists started using Eddie's techniques and stylistic characteristics.
I started playing guitar in 83 84 and he was the king of the entire guitar scene that no contest. I opened the doors to the much abused and aligned guitar shredder scene of the mid 80s, though he was not really about that. He was always first and foremost but he inspired many young hot shot guitars to play faster and more technically. We haven't seen anybody that has had even a sliver of Eddie's impact on the guitar playing world since Eddie.
I don't think we ever will again. The man was a miracle and I really mean that. And the best way to experience that is just to listen to the staview album. As you guys were saying previously, it's a specific way that Eddie wanted the songs to sound and they had been playing them and he knew exactly the way he wanted it.
And so much of this is how he plays guitar, how the guitar sounds, how he manages the rhythm parts with the lead parts and that sound, how that sound comes together makes Van Halen one the debut so special. What do we think then of Van Halen two? The album that they had to do with all that preparation for their debut album, they came up with this one and I think it's like six or seven months. They're under pressure to follow up a fantastic record, a record that had just not only put their name on the charts but certainly created a new sound of guitar.
What are they going to do for a follow up? Well Van Halen two, keep it simple, they just give it to, it's like Led Zeppelin two. I think that's by the way quite intentional. You're going to see Van Halen stealing a lot of cues, paying a lot of tributes to Led Zeppelin.
But they come up with this record which is universally treated as like a step down. Oh that's a bit disappointing. But I have to say this is the point where I was not familiar with the band's music at all when we did the first episode. Almost all of these albums of three 1984 are pretty new to me honestly.
I'm hearing this music largely for the first time and I've got to say that I see the obvious flaws on Van Halen two but I'm really excited by this record. I'm excited by the way it maintains that nice spare live sound from the debut record but now it introduces some interesting pop turns as well. We learned something about Van Halen on a song like Dance the Night Away which is that they're not like just petty metal. They're not hard rock.
This is some sort of pop metal or pop rock but we use that term to like pick up something more like the Hollies. This is actually like hard rock but with a very melodic sound and I remember you were talking earlier about the importance of backing vocals. Well you talk about a song that is defined really in a lot of ways by Michael Anthony. It's Dance the Night Away.
That glorious chorus where he's just singing in the background. Dance the night away and then he is doing his nice little arpeggiated like geometric figures on his guitar. That's a pop song. You'll never convince me in a million years that that shouldn't have been a top 40 hit.
It's actually actually the only one on this record that is clearly that poppy but this is obviously a direction that they would go in the future. I'm gonna hand it over to you guys who want to offer your thoughts. Yeah I'll go. This album has always had kind of, by the way I looked it up I'll do the music bro.
Oh actually Dance the Night Away went to number 15. Oh we did. So it was a big hit. So top 20.
Yeah but they only had two before 1984 with the other one being their pretty women so which I like a bit actually. I do. We can talk about the video game band. But yeah we'll get there.
Look this is the first album I own so it's always going to have a warm place in my heart. The one thing that I want to mention about it is it's less defined by like the big chunky rock riffs like Van Halen One was but one thing that you know this was alluded to a little bit by Scott's friend but you know Eddie was a genius not just because he was a great guitar player and been talented but he was like a mad scientist with the guitar. He would get guitars and he would just take them apart and put them back together in ways that no one it's why his sound is so unique and no one can really mimic a sound but every album he brings in a new technique and so with the rupshion you get the introduction of two hand tapping and actually when he had played live in clubs whenever he would tap he would turn around so no one could see what he was doing. What he's doing is pretty genius and I just hard not to slip up but Spanish fly you know the first instrumental I ever heard what he introduces is tap harmonics and so when you listen to a Spanish fly you hear that intro.
And it's all harmonics so with the guitar if you lightly touch your finger to a string at certain points you get a note that's harmonic it's higher up and we could get into the physics of it it's really cool but what Eddie figured out you know that you're limited in the number of notes you can produce that way but what Eddie figured out was that so the 12th fret harmonic is you know two octaves above or it may just an octave no it's two octaves above the open string so what Eddie figured out was that if he put his left finger down on the second fret he could then tap on the 14th fret and get so he got he had unlimited harmonics that way because he would get the second fret two octaves up and if you had his left hand on the fourth fret and tapped on the 16th fret you'd get the fourth fret two octaves up and probably makes no power to play with music really. Yeah yeah it probably makes no sense but if you don't play but when you listen to Spanish fly the instrument you can hear this like weird ethereal sound it's something that he invented for this album. Van Halen II so the first half of this record I'll speak about the way you talked about the back half of Van Halen debut I think it's good and fine and like somebody get me a doctor sounds like a little black Sabbath in there very Tony I only kind of kind of riff bottoms up is like you know as much as you don't think of them being a southern guitar band like that's just the grain and ZZ Top. Oh don't say ZZ Top yes it's in my notes it's Alec ZZ Top.
Turned inside out but for me Van Halen II is all about the closing kick that starts with Spanish fly and runs through three of my favorite Van Halen tunes. DOA, Women in Love and Beautiful Girls. That trifecta just slays me every time. A DOA, chunking riff, and then of course Alex pops and boom boom boom.
It's such a dirty riff and I think David Lee Roth knows because how many times does he say what? Dirty face kid, broken down and dirty, down and dirty in a garbage can like it's all grimy and greasy and DOA specifically speaks to the genius I think of Ted Templeman the way he produces where Eddie's guitar is shoved over to one channel. That is so distinctive in the way that Van Halen's song sound and I love it. I don't know if everyone does.
I love it. DOA specifically sounds that way. Women in Love is when I came to appreciate more prepping for this show. I can't get it out of my head.
It is as wild and crazy and riftastic. This is restrained in a very nice way and it has touch and feel and you know even the lyrics are really about losing a woman to another woman which still fits in the Van Halen Cannon but man when again those backing vocals Michael Anthony kicks in. And that chorus is so strong. I love it.
How they play! Beautiful girls might be like the apex Van Halen track. Everything. That indelible riff that starts it off there.
So one of the all-time great intros and then that goes on to the babbling bass and Alex and the drums. It's brilliant to slow that down just at the halfway point to allow the riff to reestablish once again. And of course David Lee Roth talking about he's on top of the world. He's got a drink in his hand, toes in the sand.
All he needs is a beautiful girl. And this is used to such perfection in the great ssl commercial parody for Schmitt's gay beer with Adam Sandler. But it works because they picked this particular song to use in the Schmitt's gay ad because it conveys everything and just horrific and just that sound. And again Michael Anthony's beautiful girls, the backing vocals and the cherry on top of the sunday when Roth gives you a big the smooch at the end of the song.
That is so Van Halen. It is so Van Halen three and a half minutes. You said that all perfectly. I love Sigh 2 of this record.
You mentioned all the songs. The one you didn't actually. It's the first one on that side. I like light up the sky is interesting.
A really interesting melody line. That kind of weird pop idea that gave you a hint from early on in their career that any Van Halen had strange ideas about. It's a group vocal. They're singing like, I don't even know what the actual lyrics are.
Oh no, it's wolves and fireworks and yards. Well, but I'm telling you, it works. It's the last thing you would have expected from a dumb hard rock band. And this is the album where ups and downs are, I don't think out of love again is anything other than generic, you know, and I never much cared for bottoms up myself either.
But I gotta tell you, this is the one where they actually show that they are, aside from being you know, stadium giants, which they're going to continue to be. They've also got a lot of fun, weird quirks. It's not a five star album, but it's a good four star album at least. I was very impressed with this one coming back to it.
I guess I suppose unless you have anything else else to say about it, Sean, this takes us to women and children first. Yet another one of these records that I just didn't listen to when we first did the show. But now I really enjoy it. I can pick out some flaws on this record.
There's at least one of the worst tracks that David Lee Roth, Aaron Halen, and Ever recorded is on this record. It's called Loss of Control. And it's like the band has lost control. It is a complete waste of the time.
I can't even, you know, they have some pretty stringent quality control standards because the last album they ever put out called a different kind of truth is basically just demos from this era that they didn't think were good enough to go on to the album at the time. But this one, this one has some really fun stuff and the Cradle of Rock is the only song that most people know who aren't in Van Halen bands, but I have to mention Chuck Kosterman's incredible observation. You wrote a piece about the most accurately rated bands of all time and at number one he put Van Halen. He said, this is the most accurately rated band of all time.
They were supposed, they should have been the greatest, you know, stadium rock act with the early 80s and they were. Everybody thinks that they, you know, everybody claims that they've got a little bit worse after Sammy Hagar joined the band and they did. And he then identifies and the Cradle Will Rock as the most adequate song of all time. In the specific sense that everything worse than it is a bad song and everything better than it is officially a good song.
This is just the most crumulent piece of music that has ever been made. And he's right. I actually think he's unfair to what I really love and the Cradle Will Rock. The one I really like from this album and then I'll give it back to you guys is that the really strange country song called Cut This Be Magic.
This is clearly a tribute to Led Zeppelin's Brony R. Stone. You know, hey, so all you smiling and that means someone's on Led Zeppelin on three. They're clearly on kind of a Led Zeppelin three mode on this record.
They're trying out some funny stuff, including as I said, a failure in loss of control. But I love that sort of group, choral magic in countryish focus sound on Cut This Be Magic. That one's one that no one ever talks about that. I never would have heard of unless we'd gone back and done on the show again.
But it's a real keeper. And I see lonely shims of I know harder. Better say the women and children buzz. Say the way with someone's daughter.
Better say the women and children buzz. I hear music on the land and then there's laughing in the air. Just could be your boaters coming in. They get back and that foot tapping and got your head right.
There's a pulling out tonight. Baby, that's the end. And she said, Cut This Be Magic. I'll give this be love.
Uh oh. And I said, Cut This Be Magic. You know that magic on fiendom. I say, don't wish him to find the one.
This is not a bad album, but I just stepped down. It's my least favorite of the Roth era. This first Roth era. It's my least favorite, which is not to say there's not highlights.
But you know, I have a really light room. We don't delight all that much. Jeff already mentioned loss of control. I don't love Good This Be Magic.
But there are a few things here. Everybody wants some, which I think we just talked about in the 1980 episode of the exclusive content episode. That is so much the tribal drawing from Alex and David Lee Roth acting like a monkey and ooing eyeing in the open. The way that song builds and blows up and builds and blows up and Roth's throwaway line, which like only he gets away with at the end.
He's like, and the beauty thing for radio stations is it's so late. You've already faded up by this point. Roth says, Okay, I mean, it's, everybody wants a book I'll pay it for. You know, what the F he says.
Everybody wants a book. So I mentioned the band sounding like a Southern band. So let's take your whiskey home. That's just a skater song.
Give me back my bullets. Yeah. Scater song Southern bogey. Sounds like Ross and Tim Collins kind of solo.
Even has whiskey in the title. Like that's not the scared song. The one I want to make sure that I mentioned is the very last one, which is again one that I came to like more this time around in a simple rhyme, which you could argue is their first kind of attempt at a power ballot. It's not quite a power ballot in the 80s definition, but they're slowing things down and they're actually, Roth is actually singing about like being in love and it not working out.
And that's not something they had explored very much. He even sounds a little vulnerable as he delivers the lyrics of In A Simple Rhyme. I love that they do at the end of every chorus in this song. They do something a little bit different.
They do, they do, they go somewhere else. They try something different at the end of every song. And in a simple rhyme is my favorite. I think it's my favorite song on this record.
I'm in love the first two, but in a simple rhyme is rather very, very, and gets lost a little bit. That's one very worth going back to and hearing from women and children first. You think you can share this? So all their early albums I love for different reasons.
I have a very hard time when we get to like ranking things because this album is like Van Halen 2 is kind of poppy and this is kind of a return to the meaty riff driven rock and roll that I think hits its apex for me in the next album we'll talk about, which no one knows except for fans. It's like the fan favorite. But I agree, in A Simple Rhyme is just a very well put together song. The song writing is off the chart.
Take your whiskey home. Yeah, it's skinner, but it's one of those things where Eddie takes a skinner song effectively and shows how he's going to do it better than anyone else. That acoustic guitar at the beginning that he plays is insanely difficult to play and it's insanely difficult to play as kind of cleanly as Eddie does. So I do, I agree in the early catalog if you have to place it's on the weaker end, but in kind of the big picture of seeing how the band comes together, I still love it.
A bad band, Halen out is still a good one at least in the 80s. Oh, I'm a whole lot of trouble. If you take my whiskey with that miffle in the back time, I'm a beat strange, then I'm on the beat. Okay, so this brings us to the one where I feel like I'm about to say something vaguely blasphemous because you know, as I said, I really gone back and reviewed all these early albums for the first time.
You know, it's certainly in sequence in a way I never had the chance to do before. And I'm going to confess to you that 1981's Fair Warning to me is the clear week one of the bunch. I know, I know, apparently the fans feel differently. You've certainly made it clear that I'm stuck wrong here, but I'm going to tell you it's the one with the fewer songs that really actually leave out to me.
And before I even mention which ones those are, why do you guys just start first and explain to me why I'm a fool? So it's background, you know, at this point, the band has quite a bit of money. And so Eddie builds being the mad genius that he is. He builds his own recording studio in his backyard, as one does.
And he basically locks himself in the studio for three months with a bag of cocaine and writes the as one did in the 80s, if you were a rock artist, and comes out with this new sound. This is the first album that really where his quote unquote brown sound comes into full view. And he writes these songs that are just, I feel like every band in like the 70s or so has their album that like didn't generate any hits, but that the fans still love. And that's what this is.
This was not a very popular commercial hit record, but the song. So first off with Mean Street, that introduction that plays this is another like Eddie introducing so basically like bass funk bass players do something called slapping and popping. It's like the sound, the sound field sound actually. Yeah, exactly.
And that fast thing that he's doing, he's slapping and popping on the guitar, which is insanely difficult to do because the strings are way thinner and doing it so fast in the same way. They're not technically coiled. They should snap them. Yeah.
And as fast as it's just like, most of Eddie's songs I've been able to play at one point. I've never been able to do the intro to Mean Street. It's just crazy. Joe Sentry and he's got the same thing to Howard Stern about two years ago when Sammy put that band together to do the residency.
And I think Sentryani said that actually that intro to Mean Street is the toughest thing for him to try to learn. He still can't really do it. Yeah, it blows my mind. But one other fun thing that just kind of like the most fan-halo thing ever is that women and children first ends with this hidden song called growth.
It's just like 20 seconds of a drum part and then guitar written. The idea was going to be that the next album was going to open with the song that that was built off of, which is a really cool idea and they just didn't do it. So go ahead. I totally didn't clap that.
Like I listened to that album about like 20 times in the past two months and I just made no connection at all. That's funny. Yeah, it's like there's like mysterious 20 seconds at the anyway. You know, it's got some unchained I think is one of their classic, like all-time classic Eddie that riff and unchained.
It's a good song. It's got some of the humor his little back and forth with Ted Templeman in the middle of it. That's like Saturday afternoon in the park. That's that sense thing.
I have no idea what that is. That's me. It's like a huge, huge, huge, huge, I mean, there are quite a few great bandhalo and instrumentals, right? And in fact, the next album has a number of them as it'll turn out, but this one I just don't understand what it's doing there.
I just have to say I'll turn it over. I know I could do this entire podcast for like two hours. I love this band so much. So this is love is a really underrated song.
The tar solo in the outro. Just I love this album. I would guess so this is love is yeah underrated. I'm trying to actually pick up on a lot of stuff.
I'd say unchained I think is one of it's just straight fire. That's such a fantastic riff. And everything centered around that. Roth gets to have fun.
It was Templeman bit one break, common up. Unchained is again one of those just signature Van Heywin songs. I think I think there are any movies that second one and you know Sean had mentioned the idea of him to have like a funk bass player. There are a couple songs here that have that funk feel.
Mean Street certainly dirty movies. Push Comes to Shove has that sort of almost not disco, but sort of disco funk kind of feel to it. It's just a it's a darker, dirtier, nastier album from start to finish three months of cocaine might do that to you. What I wanted to make around this time as I listen you know album after album after album is that by fair warning to me it's crystal clear that Eddie Van Heywin is really the only person in the band with any kind of musical ideas.
He's not getting any help from Alex in composing writing song. He's not getting any help from Michael Anthony and bringing new ideas to the band. They really have some ideas but generally they're kind of ice cream and or you know big bad deal sweet will you know and those are ideas and they work okay in the context. You do well in the context of yeah right but but that's not what Eddie's trying to do.
So much of Van Heywin is simply Eddie working things out whether it's a new guitar tone or a new approach or or crafting this riff. I can't think of another mega band in the way that Van Heywin is a mega band. So so completely reliant on one guy creatively like that no one else is really bringing any ideas to the forefront here. It's all on Eddie and this would be a source of conflict when the other guy starts saying no we don't want to do the thing you want to do and I'm sure it's like what the hell are you talking about?
I'm doing everything. I want to play the synth. Let me play the friggin synth. But but to on fair warning I think that begins to become sort of at least obvious to me like Eddie is driving every single thing this band is doing at this point.
I think it still works well on fair warning and actually on the next album too but yeah this is this is this is all Eddie Van Heywin stuff. Okay so I think that you write about that assessment and that's probably why I see the strange show up on this. You guys said pretty much everything I would have said anyways yeah unchained to me is clearly the best thing on this record. So this is also really good.
I think push comes to shove nice little slinky number and that theory's playing two guitar simultaneously one against the other in different channels. That's all really nice but again there's nothing really just jumps out to me on this album. Maybe if I spend more time with it it will eventually emerge as the Dark Horse favorite but I'm about to be controversial two times in a row because the next record is one I think the fans don't like and I know the band doesn't let it get that much either but I'm gonna just lay it down straight right here. There's a very good chance that Diver Down makes my top two at the end of this episode.
1982's Diver Down and I did actually find the story about this one. They didn't want to record a record. What happened is that they wanted to record a single. So somebody said hey you know with the old Roy Orbus and song Pretty Woman it actually kind of would be a really good fit for David as it turns out it was.
They recorded a really fun version of it right. But then because the single was so successful all of a sudden we got to have an album to go with this and they ended up just continuing to record and they came up with Diver Down. Two or three instrumentals has three cover tunes. It clearly seems like it's kind of a get me a cross-patient in terms of the amount of material on the album.
As you said there you know if Eddie has to do this all by himself well at this point he's flagging clearly because it just aren't as many songs but I'm gonna tell you the songs that are there are among my favorites of Van Halen's and discovering them for this episode again has been great. The covers you know I think Wither and Volga Time's Gone. Another Kings cover is probably my least favorite on the record just because I don't think they actually add too much to it. They only add David's attitude which is something.
It's a Kings cover but as I discovered in our Bowie episode they're actually covering the Bowie version of the Kings version. They're not covering the Kings version so it's a different cover. And it's a defined song because you can't ruin this song you actually can't ruin that Bowie version either but it's probably the least exciting one. Oh pretty woman though I love their version of pretty woman.
That is David Lee Roth his attitude his charisma just amped up to 11. That's the appeal of DLR on a Van Halen song and it isn't even one of their own. But the other one I really love is the Dancing in the Street cover which I thought I'd hate that one was new to me for this episode. I had no idea that they'd done a version of it and I thought well this is something that can really be lame.
I love that weird forward sounding guitar riff that Eddie comes up with on that thing. That is nothing that I would have expected from a Motown cover and they give me a cool part. They give me a new wave sound out of it. I think it's really good.
He gets the original material. I'm just gonna say right now little guitar is probably my single favorite original Van Halen song of all time and I don't know why it isn't on their greatest hits. I don't know why I never heard it on the radio. I don't know why I did not know that song but it is incredible melodic power rock.
A fantastic verse that repeater guitar tone that he gets that he gets on it but then the chorus is just one of the maybe the most rhythmically great melody ideas that Eddie Van Halen ever had. This is not about chops that is about him writing a great set of chord changes and a really great guitar arrangement. That is the one that I wanted to focus on for us. Now what do you guys think of Dibras Down?
Do you love me as much as I do on my island? Am I a diver now? I got jumped in. Little Guitars is also gonna be my final five for any era of Van Halen.
It's interesting you say that you know it wasn't a hit, wasn't it a radio. It's true but the reason I found Little Guitars was my very first radio internship. One of my jobs was finding songs that were exactly four minutes long. We couldn't sell enough commercials so we had to cover a break from the satellite feed of rock music and so we had to find these exactly four minutes songs going through.
They would have these things they were called gold discs and they would market to radio stations where there were songs that were ready for air. They had to be edited. They were edited. If there were words that we'd taken out right everything.
They were ready to go with gold discs. Only the best stuff. And I found Little Guitars on this gold disc which meant at some point someone did block this off of Dibras Down and said you know what this would make a good song for a classic rock radio station. It didn't really happen because yeah that song is not played very much but I found out about it only because it was on this gold disc at the radio station.
And since the very first time I heard it it's been one of my absolute favorite Van Halen songs. I love everything. I love the way that guitar dances on top of a melody and that quick it's quicker and quicker and then you know catch jazz catch catch catch. That part where David LeGroth is going crazy.
The very end ends with just him playing that staccato guitar melody just those no fah fah fah fah fah fah fah. And then even the intro was the intro is like a flamenco version of a rough version. Yeah the little yeah the instrumental that begins it right. I always think of it as one song.
Yeah I don't even know if it's quite a different thing than the album. I think it is. They split up into two tracks with that for sure. I mean it's always the same.
I mean Eddie's the king of his intros. It is all one piece. Yeah right. So I mean yeah.
I always I don't think there are any bad songs on the sound. The other two instrumentals the cathedral is just like this really interesting guitar tone that he gets and he gets kind of a churchy organ he sounds out of it. But then the intruder. Intruder is actually almost as good as the Peter Gabriel song called.
And if you know how much I love Peter Gabriel 3 that is high praise of all things it goes into pretty woman and I wonder if that was like Eddie's statement. He's like okay we're doing this hack single it's you know it's a cover you've heard of a force of crowd pleaser and then he puts this really frightening instrumental right in front of it. It sounds kind of like the light pours out of me by magazine. That's a bump bump bump bump.
Bose sounds really hitting somewhere dark and then all of a sudden it turns into a happy little two three woman. I love this album and I don't understand why fans and the band treated as a real disappointment. Otherwise I can see because it's a lot of covers and there's a lot of instrumentals. It works.
It's funny as I go through the crack list. I'm like oh yeah that's a great song. That's a great song. That's a great song.
For some reason the album's just never worked for me. But I think we should we should step back and just kind of marvel that in five years this band has recorded five albums. All of which are classics. And not only that this is not the Beatles like holding themselves up in the studio.
They're going on these major stadium tours at the same time. They're one of the biggest rock bands in the world and it's just like the output and the consistent quality is amazing. I don't have too much to add. I think you all have hit the highlights but I do want to say on little guitars he is actually playing that entire guitar part himself in one take and it took me forever to be able to do this.
But he's he's tremolo picking the hot that that seems like picking the open B and E strings and then he's taking his left hand and tapping that he's doing that with his left hand. The melody line at the same time. That's just amazing. You know by the way we have mentioned Van Halen's live act at any point throughout the conversation yet.
I guess one reason for that is that it's very curious that there are no albums. Van Halen never released a live album from their David Lee Roth years. Now maybe that's because he wouldn't want to hear David Lee Roth sing in line. Maybe they had a rap that's sometimes giving you a pretty shady show but these guys really did dominate.
Like the latter half of the 70s the first half of the 80s as a composer proposition. Where you go? You wanted to have fun? You wanted to have excitement?
Does anybody want to buzz? Has it become too cliché but or should we do the nodal green M&M's story? I think it's worth doing. All right.
Who wants to do their favorite version of it? Scott do you know the legend of this well? I mean I know it as well as I think I should know it. I mean so Van comes to town and plays a venue and they're going to send you a writer in advance.
The writer says we are going to ride at four o'clock and we need five parking places and when we get there we're going to sound check at exactly this time and this is the kind of you know if we need extra amps or we can't provide us this or we need a grand piano. We're not going to own grand piano. In the dressing room we need four packs of beer and six packs of barblower lights and you know all the stuff that you need to provide for them as the talent. And so Van Halen was infamous famous for having a writer in the contract that said you know can provide us with a bowl of M&M's but no green M&M's.
You have any green M&M's in the big M&M and it's you know at first you say well that's that's ridiculous. Why would someone ask for no green M&M's? They all taste the same. It's just a big rock star thing to get on your horse and say don't give me green M&M.
So Van Halen says and it makes sense to me which is they include that portion of the writer and no green M&M's to see if the person responsible has actually read the writer. So they get to the dressing room and they look at the M&M bowl and there's no green M&M's. They can say okay this these guys actually read what we wrote. We can be reasonably certain that things are going to go well tonight and we'll be taken care of.
They're particularly worried about their concert stack like the amplifiers they had to use. They're really heavy you know had to be put up on risers and a lot of work to make sure they didn't tumble over and kill people. But if they got in the dressing room and they saw a green M&M's work no M&M's at all then they knew there might be problems. You got to double check this.
You got to make sure that's secure. You got to make sure this is in place. So it was just an indicator a signal as to how much they had to be concerned about the way that night might unfold. And that brings us to the album named after the year it was released very early in that year in 1984.