Welcome to sitcom geeks, I'm Dave Cohen. I'm James Carey. And today we are going to be looking at an area we've looked at before many times but we're going to delve a little bit deeper, we're going to talk about characters but not just sitcom characters, we're going to talk about the relationships between characters in our sitcom and I know James this is a subject of much interest to you and what maybe you want to do this particular episode. Well if you go, well I did a webinar on characters a while ago and if you go to my blog you'll find some links to that.
If you've joined my mailing list situation where you can get hold of the video on that but I went back to be the basics on characters and thought anew and actually stumbled across some stuff that I guess intrinsically implicitly knew but hadn't realized and it all about characters projecting who they are onto other characters. And so and I mentioned it again recently on my sitcom geek blog as well so I've been mulling on this for some time and I'm excited to be able to just chat about them now because I think one of the problems that we get when we see scripts and I read one the other day actually or at least an outline of a script which was that you've actually got characters, potentially funny characters, maybe 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 characters. I had one up to 19 the other day, it was just an outline and I said you might want to get rid of half of those but it just felt like each character was in their own show with their own little quest and it felt like the characters were basically not even talking past one another but missing one another completely. Is that a problem that you found with scripts that you've read Dave?
Very much and this and you know kind of in parallel I've been having similar thoughts because I'm just currently rewriting the book that I brought out three years ago I think in the second edition of the complete comedy writer in which I spent a lot of time, a lot of chapters on character and there's one chapter on odd couples but then there are about five or six or seven chapters on this is a character, why do they do that? What is it about a character they can do that? and I realise actually I'm partly guilty because I've often written about characters in that kind of singular form and the more that I've been looking at scripts and thinking about that in relation to the book the more I've been thinking yeah I've got these characters and they're all kind of moving in parallel and they're not interacting and really the old couple which is like one chapter in my book. I mean that's every sitcom is about lots and lots of different odd couples and there's so much more that we could really be looking at I think.
Yeah definitely and I think I've got two sort of solutions here one is a plot based solution and one is a projection solution so my solution number one to this is to come up with plots that throw characters together and option one is a fairly obvious one which is have a plot which pits characters against each other so let's say you've got character Andrew A character Brenda B you can give them a contest between each other or you can Andrew wants to do something Brenda wants to stop them or Andrew wants to do something and Brenda wants them to do something else or Andrew wants to do something and Brenda wants to do the same thing and only one of them can do it you know one of them wants to be the first to climb Mount Snowden that day and raise the most money for the charity so so now we've got Andrew and Brenda competing against one another and because they're different characters they're going to go about it in different ways and sometimes and one of them might be a cheat or whatever it is so that's kind of solution one subsection one is put characters against each other and then the second one is actually to have characters sort of having to work kind of together against another character so you've got Andrew and Brenda achieving up against Colin and now Andrew and Brenda are going to have to work together and are pulling in slightly different directions because they are different people and actually Andrew and Colin and Brenda and Colin have have a different relationship with each other and at some point it might turn out that Andrew might betray Brenda to Colin because Andrew and Colin go back years Brenda's not worth throwing that away for or whatever it is so I think just really bedding the characters so that they are the they are the linchpins the endpoints however you want to put it off your plots rather than Andrew's trying to do one thing Brenda's trying to do something else and Colin is trying to lose weight and none of them really have anything to do with each other actually you know Andrew's trying to get Brenda to lose weight and Colin is actually picked the wrong time to start making an apple crumble recipe and bake you know what I mean so you and he's very offended that no one's his crumbles and now Andrew and Brenda have to pretend that they're eating them they start hiding crumbles in various parts of the kitchen and the house and the potting plants and all that kind of stuff and start you know I've gotten to see a bit like um uh the greatest escape where they're wandering around outside with bits of crumble going down their trousers as if they've been taking a tunnel I think of the classic sort of um shows with the kind of suburban alcoholics and they're kind of you know they've hidden the whiskey bottle inside the uh the third cupboard down below underneath or in the goo bend of the plumbing or something you know so that's uh that's a that's a there's a phrase that springs to mind actually listening to you mentioning um the characters there and Brenda uh and Andrew and Colin all of them that's uh my my enemy's enemy is my friend which is a sort of well-known phrase but also just talking there about couples you know all sitcoms are about mismatch couples but they are also about triples and there is an episode we did record actually that was uh about it's you know it's not just about um Miranda and her mum it's also about the kind of the three-way relationship with Miranda and Mum and Stevie that's a separate uh that's a separate thing that you're working on when you're kind of working up an idea it's like what are these what are these two people like in an ordinary situation uh and now we're bringing a third person in and what what are they you know as soon as you have three people in a relationship you start to see where the alliances are where the conflicts are and you know it just it just automatically becomes more interesting and it offers more dynamics and there's some good exercises that you can be doing I mean a simple exercise uh that I have again mentioned this uh a couple of times before but it's someone once said to me um what what newspaper does your character read and this simple idea excuse me and this simple idea like uh there's a scene quite early on in the last time go in Hallipax which is a great show about an old couple in their seventies who get together though after 50 years when they nearly got married and didn't and now their romance is blossoming but he reads the guardian and she reads the daily mail and they almost split up just on that just on that one little piece of information uh you read the mail oh god that's so you know how can you how can you believe that rubbish oh well you know listen to you with your bloody trade unions and all that yeah you know that actually they're sitting in the church on their own thinking oh this is going to be the nice place they're discussing the wedding plans it's huge wrap and it's just one little piece of information one little exercise obviously it helps to be slightly right one of the greatest contemporary comedy drama writers now but uh you know it is from those kind of relatively simple straightforward sorts of exercises you can develop very interesting dynamics between the characters and that's really what this episode is about isn't it's about what goes on between them rather than just what are their individual uh needs absolutely and these things evolve as shows go as well but if you can look at go back to friends i mean take any episode of friends and work out what the plots are and who's involved in each one and how the different characters and different attitudes to that thing really makes all the difference to that plot um you know that i think that's uh you know there's um i just for some reason remember an episode where Joey gets Chandler and himself and a bracelet um and to Joey this is the coolest thing and Chandler kind of hates it but has to wear it and they both feel completely differently about jewellery it turns out um and so you know there's a bit where i think Joey just says hey they'll call us the bracelet guys or something like that and Chandler's just like yeah that's what they'll call us and that kind of oh my goodness they're gonna call us that and that's awful and so Joey that's cool so you know you've got that you know people feel differently about different things so shove things in their way to which they will respond differently but they're going to need to figure out how to get along despite the fact that you know they feel differently about this thing that's coming along and that's exactly the same joke as you know in the pilot one of the first things that Joey says you know he says Ross and uh he says oh hey Ross are you split up with your girlfriend you know uh you know what the solution is now strip club and that's just so not the solution for Ross i mean we don't yeah no Ross hasn't actually said a single word in the whole show yet but you know they know the character's well enough to know that Joey's gonna say strip club and that for Ross strip club is going to be the worst possible answer yeah and i think that leads us very neatly onto the second thing um with solution two your characters walking past each other um and talking past each other is how they project themselves onto the others both in terms of character and story so in terms of character it's worth thinking that there are three things more things than that going on with your character you've got your character let's call him Andrew again how does Andrew see himself he sees himself as someone who's well read and intelligence maybe how do we see Andrew well we think Andrew is probably a little bit pretentious how does Brenda see Andrew well if Brenda's not very bright maybe she thinks that Andrew is a proper intellectual for example and so her attitude to him is one of slight reverence and awe and there's another character Colin who's very down to earth who may be not the brightest but his attitude to Andrew is well this guy's stuck up this guy's pretentious and so we can see that there are different shades of interpretation and this goes back to the the saw us thing doesn't it though well yes and that's another thing that i noticed and i'm reading your blog about this one of the many things that impressed me about this blog well one of the main things that impressed me about this blog was your ability your gardening ability actually there's a yes um you not only do you get great sitcom advice but you also get to see how James managed to turn a kind of an unwanted unloved section of his garden into a very nice little little kind of patch rose bush raised bed very nice um so but also in there and i did again i did this chapter about three years ago in the complete comedy writer the the saw us i did let's say and in my example i had a character who sees themselves as a clear rigorous thorough and i said and but the look at the look at the words that also mean that look them up into the your the saw us and you'll get things like you know control freak and um you know kind of um fastidious i would say yeah over fussy and all that stuff but actually again i've been thinking more about this and thinking actually well that's only i had like everybody she sees herself as this and everybody else sees her as that but even that's over simplistic because as he points out how x sees that character is going to be completely different so how y sees that character and again i was thinking about a show like um the office for instance and you know we we the audience um see David Brent pretty much in the same way that tim sees him but Gareth sees him in a completely different way Gareth sees him you know he's his hero isn't he so yeah there is always more than one way that a character to how a character sees themselves and how there's always more ways that other people see them and again this is all about extra layers this just brings you extra layers of comedy extra interesting uh roots for your characters to take and and roots to kind of raise the stakes and you mentioned there about how it works for for character and story um we had this interview recently with John voorhouse uh great american writer about comedy writing as well as being a very successful sitcom writer he says he he doesn't actually think about the character uh he he starts when he's coming up with a new character he comes up with the stories and that's how he develops the characters which i think is is great and bold i'm still a little bit married to the idea i'd like to have a little idea about the character without it being set in stone but with the minimum amount of information and knowledge that you have about your character you will start to push them with the stories and these stories will come from all of this that james is talking about now how a character sees themselves how are they see them what it's like when you put them in a room with the other character and that's where all your stories are going to come from yeah i mean just going back to what you're saying about a character being being thorough you know i just looked up for stidious uh and uh you know there's for stidious scrupulous punctilius painstaking meticulous some of those are positive words and some of them are negative words you know exacting demanding hair splitting pedantic so you've got you've got a very big range of options within that kind of character that different characters will see so some will see your thorough character as scrupulous oh he's got a real life of detail you know he's absolutely invaluable to have this guy around and for someone else it's like he's demanding i actually think that he's a bully i think that this person is using their high standards to control other people and this is maybe someone who also likes to psycho analyze everybody so you know this character is always trying to say what kind of person people are so you've sort of got lots of possibilities for characters to suddenly look at sconce at each other or look in order to each other or you know suddenly we've got dynamics we've got relationships rather than four characters all doing their own thing yeah and um if you're kind of still struggling with this a bit if you're kind of thinking well how do i make my characters work uh again you know think think about relationships in your own life um and i'm not saying use it i'm not saying use all of them and i mean i do sometimes uh see scripts where the story is too much the person says this is what happened to me yeah well the thing is this is a fictional show you know if we want a story and it's more important that it tells a story than it's than it's absolutely true to however the note on that this story actually happened to me my note i don't care yeah it's what what does matter though what happened to you and you know when james and i asked this question about what is it about you that's going to make your sitcom different uh and only you can write it the answer is not well it's set in a supermarket and i worked in a supermarket the answer is i am bringing relationships the way that i felt emotionally in relationships i am bringing those things that were unique to me incidents that happen that unique to me but these are universal feelings and so look at the kind of relationships that you have you know kind of step back if you can from the emotional baggage that there may be with them look at your relationship with your parents say or or if you are a parent look at your relationship with your children siblings is another one just look at your and not to judge or anything but just think how how did i react when this happened or how did they react when i did that and you will find there something that's unique to you but everybody else you know the way that you reacted in that moment but it will be a feeling that other people will you know we will relate to that as we'll all relate to that we'll all see that even if we've never had that ourselves you know we may know we've got siblings or we've got children or whatever friendships you know what were your friendships think about what your how uncomplicated your friendships were when you were like seven years old you know and think about some of the friendships you have now you know and and and enemies you know we all make enemies when we're you know all through our lives and what why did you fall out with that person what was it about and you know usually it's not about a terrible thing it's about a kind of a vibe that you've got but then you know you'll fall out of something really petty and that's where a lot of comedy comes from neighbors you know relationships with teachers or if you are a teacher relationship with pupils people that you work with these all are really good starting points for you to think about the relationships with your characters so think about and these fictional characters that you are creating you know that they will have these elements of your your feelings and your emotions stick them into these foreign invented people and they will bring them to life that's really helpful one yes and one caveat I really like the idea of just thinking about family relationships because you you know what they did you know what they really like you know what they used to be like and also they know about you and what you did so those relationships that go back a long way there there are people that there are one or two people that you'll just do anything for even though you don't necessarily know them very well anymore so for example we got Andrew Brenda and Colin Delia turns up and Andrew can't can't do can't do enough for Delia and the others are a bit puzzled by this because she can do no wrong and yet she's clearly a truly terrible human being but actually you know Andrew's known for ages and he always feels bad about the fact that you know he used to bully her at school you know he used to call her names he's realized what a terrible thing that is and so he's always sort of playing catch up on that or a sibling you know that a sibling is deeply resented because they always got preferential treatment they were the one who was allowed they were the one that got a car when they were 17 and I didn't get a car when I was 17 or whatever it is so I think you know thickening it all up nicely with those gross injustices of the past or those terrible bits of guilt I think are worth considering so that's the yes and but the caveat is we don't want characters being retrospective and if a character is being falling over themselves to be nice to a character for a whole episode and we have to wait until the 23rd page to find out what the reason for that is that's going to be annoying in that's retrospective so in a way you just want to use this as sort of writing exercises and sketches and ways of giving your fuel fuel to your characters so they're always going forward and looking forward as opposed to explaining at the end why everything is the way that it is that's not a sitcom episode that's not a compelling story that's a mystery show you've written and it's not going to be funny because it's going to be confusing and I've not said this for a while on this podcast confusion is the enemy of comedy that's a very strong point I'm laughing as well because somebody who I've just been working with actually who listens to this podcast a lot and they gave me that very note about something in the sitcom that I'm writing at this point so sorry about that come back they quoted me to you yes oh dear which was fun the one other thing I was wanted to say just before we probably wrap up very soon is going back to what you said earlier about Joey's solution to Ross's problem Joey's solution says everything about Joey and kind of says nothing about Ross and so it's worth thinking that you you project solutions that you like onto other people so the example I've given this webinar that you can get hold of is you know if you're an eco person and somebody's car breaks down your solution will be this is great this is the time to get a bike and you know now is the time to do that and that bikes are very reasonable these days they're not they're like two grand if you want to get a decent bike but they're going to sort of go all in on this advice and it's entirely motivated by their own passions and it's obviously not the right solution for the person but this but your character is going to believe in it as a solution and somebody else is going to say oh finally you get rid of that stupidness and micro you can get yourself a real car you can go and get yourself a Mustang oh look there's a second-hand one here absolutely cheapest chips you should totally get this and so again the solutions they're offering say everything about who they are and they have very they have scant regard for the character that they're talking to so you know what I can say I think you'll find that the person who's trying to help by saying get rid of your car and get a bike is actually has the planets concerns particularly particularly but that's clearly not going to be helpful it's like oh what I'm going to take three kids to school on one bike you know has that yeah yeah you can get four four-person tandem just like get real that's not happening but you get the idea that people have these usually well-motivated solutions to these problems but they're the wrong solution or at least they appear to be wrong and you know so they say oh it's all right I've got you a bike already and now I'm in hot to this person who solves a problem with a solution that I didn't want and suddenly we've got comedy because we've got just a whole load of people in the wrong place with the wrong stuff and they can't kind of you know address it properly because they've already got this sort of friendship going so I think it's a way of rather than just people being against each other and making jokes about each other to their faces all the time this is a way of having characters sort of positively dragging each other along into funny places I mean an obvious character like that would be Leslie Nope from Parks and Rec who is boundlessly kind and enthusiastic and always trying to help her office workers but she's often you know and everyone knows it's coming from a really lovely nice place but but she's kind of unstoppable once she gets going and the same with Beverly in the Goldbergs as well she's the mum who just loves her kids too much and so she can't be stopped yeah I think that's I would add one caveat to your caveat as well one thing that I would say is no no the backstory you know the backstory between these characters but you are not going to put it into the you're not going to put the actual story into the episode but you are going to put the consequences of that backstory in there and so if the consequence is that one person that if it is siblings you know one person felt that the other one always got the more favored was more favored and then the other one might say well you know I was the older one I was expected to be more responsible I mean I think those are okay they're not actual yeah and you know when you were four years old I got this and you didn't get that that definitely you know that we that's a no-no but the feeling of you know I was always to be responsible for you and I was a bloody idiot I didn't know who I had to be responsible for you you know I had my own issues and whatever so that's kind of that that sort of way of bringing the past up is okay I think yeah as always it's kind of a situation rather than a kind of specific story and I think a really good example of that is go back and watch the very very first five minutes of Only Falls and Horses where it's super clear that Delboy is the big brother and basically had to be the dad and the mum to some extent because his mum died their mum died when they were quite young and so and he he's obviously making the most of that fact that because I was there for you you sort of have to do what I say and there was no one specific thing they're referring to generally but it's just a it's emblematic of the relationship so I think anything that you can do to give these examples and then throughout the series they can go oh blimey this is the this is my eighth birthday party all over again and another episode it's like oh great okay here we go this is this is Christmas 1986 is it you know and it's they're all basically the same thing because it's a sitcom so it's basically the same joke but framed inside different ways rather than this sort of enigmatic story where people are acting either out of character in ways that don't make any sense and then it's all explained um I'm really but you'd be surprised at how many scripts you read where information is withheld and then presented in a ta-da kind of way and that doth not a comedy make that's not a twist that's a revelation and again we're often getting into this creeping comedy drama stuff which is one for a whole other podcast episode yeah and I think for me the characters the stories that work really well are where a piece of information has been withheld and it's a piece of information that you the writer know but it's something that has dawned on the character over the course of the episode they have worked it out in the same way and they're like they are just they are just one step ahead of you the audience but that's all that's all they need to be it's just one step ahead in the working out and you know working out something that may be completely wrong and and and and bad and you know but it's still it's um to to feel it happening in a script is a great thing whereas as as james says too often it's uh a character doesn't say anything and at the very end it was all uh-huh my plan was this you see I may do you think that but then you know it's all tell tell tell tell and no show show show um but let's just um let's just got to bring this uh sort of conclude with this um conversation I think because there are uh some very important points to make and it really is uh something that people need to think a lot more about uh there's plenty there's loads of information out there about characters uh how to make them proactive how to make them own their mistakes all this kind of thing how to make sure they never learn from their mistakes um but there isn't quite enough yet and hopefully we're starting a good uh conversation here about how they are with each other yeah I think one other thing just to throw in as I thought I happened to stumble across an episode of Modern Family the other day I think my wasp and re-watching series eight because we watched it such a long time ago we sort of forgotten and we don't have sky at the moment anymore so we haven't we haven't watched series nine or ten or whatever it is at the moment but the thing they do really well on that and I know it's an extended family show so it's it's easier than most but they're really good at landing every episode in a kind of moment where they're sort of all together how they managed to find 24 different things a year which is oh it's so and so is birthday party oh it's sounds like anniversary party oh it's Manny's graduation ceremony oh it's uh lilies um bike demonstration oh it's so but in a way I use an example just to say they're really good at just bringing the characters together so that everything is heading towards an event where all is revealed and sometimes the characters don't intersect the the ab and c plot don't necessarily overlap but they all kind of come together in the same place and they're there for each other um which I know that you know if you've got a family show that's probably what you're aiming for and there are other shows where that's not possible but it does feel to me quite often that some sitcoms now have sort of characters on some completely separate quests sometimes they've done this in the gold book they appear to be happening on different days you've got a running plot where one plot sort of happening at night on a weekend and another plot that sort of appears to be broad daylight on a Tuesday um I don't know have you seen that thing I've kind of given up on caring about that because a number of times I've seen something and you know often in favorite shows like Gilmore Girls or something and it's like um there's like sort of 20 minutes of an episode takes place seems to take place over you know sort of from from 8 p.m. till midnight and the next 10 minutes seems to take place from 4 p.m. earlier that day through to the 4 p.m. the next day so it is okay I'm just I'm using too much my own uh my own kind of knowledge here about that just one one thing I think and again it's a year since I've watched Modern Family so I can't remember exactly but I think one I think a point where Modern Family was always always a great show but I think roundabout series three or maybe like halfway through series two it started to be it wasn't just about and here's Cameron and Mitchell Family and here's Claire and Phil and his um uh Jay and so like the three they started to be the sibling thing like the uh the ritual claire relationship started to they started to explore it and that for me was a really kind of interesting moment because that's when which goes ties in with what we've been discussing it it stopped being just about each of the three separate families and through it being partly about Cameron and Claire that immediately made it about all three families because it was about their families each and their relationship with their dad and that's whatever stories came out of it you just had that kind of three so much of that was about how how dad treated you compared to how he treated me and you know mom in the background and all that stuff but that that was a point for me at which Modern Family really kind of over uh you know kind of went off into the stratosphere I think yeah no definitely it's still an amazing it's an amazing show and it's their level of quality is incredible so I think we'll we'll leave that one there um just to let you know it is towards the end of August as this at broadcast is landing and is dropping we're recording this slightly ahead of time but I can tell you in breaking news that uh very soon I will be running a couple of workshops in fact I think they are on Monday the 30th of August and Friday the 3rd of September they're called right to sitcom in a day so either do one or the other the subtitling is you obviously can't write a sitcom in a day but you can spend a day making a plan and working out how to get a script written essentially so this is me walking you through the process it's an all-day zoom webinar and you can you can join in with that you do need to buy a ticket unfortunately so so go over to my blog and do that sitcom geek dot blog spot dot com or there'll be links to it on my Twitter handle at sitcom geek and you can find out more about that so that's write a sitcom in a day with the subtitle you obviously can't do that but that's kind of it's spending a day with me you can ask me anything there are loads of questions I'll be walking you through the process telling you as much as I can in the time that we have available and taking as many questions as you've got and we can sort of cram in to that day so that's on August bank holiday Monday the 30th of August and Friday the 3rd of September you buy a ticket and you can turn up to either it doesn't matter to me which one you come to you can sneak into both if you want I'm not going to throw you out but you could write same stuff you could write two sitcoms you could write two sitcoms in two days one on Monday one on Friday so um so there's that sitcom geek dot blog spot dot com and you can find out more about that and there'll be links there and you can join in that that'd be great Dave what are you what do you up to well I've got various things I may have a much more modest course which is about building a sitcom writing a sitcom in eight weeks so it's a much more later that's not more modest I mean that's that's sensible yeah but you do actually physically have to write the whole sitcom I've got a course starting in October and also but I am booking as well for one in January but also I am very excited in November I've got this course where I'm going to be working with writers who've already written their first draft and we're going to be working on rewriting so you can find out information about all of these courses on my website DaveCohen.org.uk excellent DaveCohen.org.uk and also you can join us on Patreon to be part of an extra monthly podcast where you can show up on zoom and ask us anything you like so do do that it'll be great to have you on board you can also join the facebook group as well if you're a patreon and there's lots of chat and sharing of information and generally cheering each other on okay well that thanks very much for listening and we will see you again in a fortnight.
Cheerio