Skip to content
Episode 18: They Lied to Us episode artwork

Nov 13, 2015

Episode 18: They Lied to Us

from Structured Visions Hosted by Jodie Clark

Social structures are like spider webs – interlinked strands of assumptions about the social world that form conceptual networks to support us as we navigate our daily lives. What would be the effect of exposing social structures as oppressive or unjust? On the one hand, we might feel completely unsupported and ungrounded, like Boris the spider … Continue reading Episode 18: They Lied to Us

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 18: They Lied to Us

of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, and welcome to episode 18 of Structured Visions. Structured Visions is a space where I explore new ways of thinking about social structure. My name is Jody Clark, and I am very grateful for you listening today. You are very welcome here.

I'd like to begin today's episode by talking about a visit from my husband's sister and her daughter. They came over a few days ago, and Isabel was sort of playing with us in our living room. And she was talking about her pet cats. She's two years old, and she was talking about her pet cats.

And I turned to her and said, we have a pet. And she said, looking around the room, she doesn't see a pet. And I point up to the corner of the living room where there's an enormous spider on the ceiling in the corner. And I knew it was there, because it's always there.

And I pointed to her, and I said, that's our pet spider. And my husband said, yes, yes. His name is Boris. And Isabel was hilarious.

She put her eyes, got wide. She put her hands over her mouth, and she started to giggle at the absurdity of our pet. Boris didn't seem to mind too much. But Boris was on my mind, because the day before Isabel and her mom came over, my husband and I made the dramatic, but highly considered decision that we would actually clean the house.

Which we only do that under lots of deliberation and consideration. I think the last time we cleaned it was about six months ago. So it wasn't due. We weren't ready for it to be cleaned.

But we thought we were coming over so clean. So while I was downstairs with a big stick with fuzzy bits on the end, trying to decide whether I was going to actually tackle the big spider web in the corner. And then finally, I decided I'd go ahead and do it. And so I took this big fuzzy stick mock thing.

And I tried very hard to protect Boris. I made sure that he was safe. I ripped away at the spider web that he'd clearly spent lots and lots and lots of time and energy constructing. And I was absolutely astonished at what happened when I took it down.

You could hear the ripping of the multi-layered fibers that had made up this spider web. I mean, it was a rip. It was astonishing. It took several times of me pushing this mock through this dense network of silken fibers.

And Boris sort of moved out of the way. I don't know what a shocked spider looked like, but he did look shocked. He looked disappointed. He looked slightly terrorized.

And he moved closer to the center of the ceiling of the room and he stayed there. So Boris was on my mind. And I was able to sort of talk to his about our pet spider because he was way and heavily on my conscience. Now, when I was ripping away at those fibers, those multiplex network that had been so carefully constructed over a period of time over and over and over again, it called to mind as things often do for me images of social structure.

And I was thinking about social structures as these sort of networked patterns, the sort of ways of seeing the world, ways of thinking about the world that become, they overlay each other, they're networked to each other, they kind of combine. And not only that, they're also like a spider's web invisible. And they also form the almost like our base level of understanding of the world so that you don't actually notice them as you're going about your world, even if they sort of form the kind of underlying layer of your existence. And that idea, that kind of pain or agony of imagining it being ripped away.

And I was thinking about, you know, why are people often resistant to me talking about social structures and things that might be wrong with them? Now, you might not be resistant because maybe you've listened to these podcasts and maybe you enjoy them, but there is often resistance. Anytime I mention that there might be something wrong with particular views of the world. And sometimes I often spoke in this podcast about how comforting social structure is, how important it is, how we kind of can't operate without one.

And that sense, that the ideas that you have about the world, that if they were to be kind of ripped away, that you might be without ground, that you might not be able to operate in the way that you operate, that you might be free-floating and that that might be actually quite frightening, and understandably so. And some of those ideas, some of those sort of social structures, for instance, some of those that I've been talking about in this podcast, like even the idea that cultivating delayed gratification might not be the best thing. You know, I talked about that last week. Or the idea that we're sometimes acculturated into this idea that we need to be at the top of our game all of the time.

You know, that you have to be quiet in class, you've got to learn the stuff, you've got to learn, you've got to get high SAT scores, you've got to go to a good university, you've got to get a good job, you've got to earn lots of money, you've got to live in a nice house. All of those types of things. And the recognition that maybe that isn't the best way to understand how the world should be structured. And if I put it in more personal terms, if we think about social structure in terms of a set of underlying assumptions, for instance, if I'm a good person, I'll be rewarded.

So that underlying assumption, if I'm a good person, I'll be rewarded, which is a kind of common underlying, it's not always conscious assumption that kind of gets generated quite earlier. It becomes embedded in our consciousness quite early. Sometimes if I'm a good person, I'll be rewarded. And imagine if, you know, someone were to sort of make it clear to you that that wasn't necessarily the case, that it isn't the good people in society that get rewarded.

And it's like, rr, the spider-wed rips out from under you and you think, oh, where am I? Or this other element, if I do what's expected of me, nothing will go wrong. I'll be safe if I do what people want me to do. If I adhere to the norms of society and adhere to the social laws, and I do what is expected, nothing will go wrong.

And then suddenly in whatever fashion it becomes revealed to you that stuff still goes wrong. And there wasn't anything you could do to prevent it, rr, rr, rr, rr, rr, rr, rr, rr, you know, the social structure, that assumption gets ripped out from underneath. And it might take quite a lot of work to rebuild an assumption that you can sort of live by. Another one, if I fit into this tiny box that you're asking me to fit into, I'll be safe.

So if I decide I'm going to live by your rules and you give me your marshmallow and you tell me if I wait 15 minutes, then I get another marshmallow. I live by those rules. It's kind of antithetical to the way I sort of see my life. But if you're telling me that's the rules and if I live by them, then I'm safe.

And then imagine the safety disappearing in some fashion. And the social structure goes away. So all of these ways of understanding social structure and all of the ways that if we rethink them, even when I was talking several weeks about the notion that fairness might not be the best way of understanding social structure. And it's like, well, come on, we've invested a lot of time and energy into imagining that society should be fair.

And you're telling me that I should think about it a different way, rip, rip, rip. So it's potentially a problem to rethink social structure. And so I'm doing it all the time. But in some ways it's like, okay, I'm doing it.

But I'm not always completely taking on board all of the ramifications of what would it actually mean if these structures were sort of being ripped away from me. Now I want to just also talk about the clarity that sometimes comes when you recognize a social structure or an underlying assumption is ripped away. And to illustrate that, I will have to admit, I don't have a television. And so when I do watch television, I'm absolutely fascinated by it.

Because I think if you have a television and you watch it all the time, then nothing kind of seems new to you. You're not surprised by anything on television. But you don't have a television. And then you watch something on TV.

It's like new neural pathways develop. Really? That's what they're doing. That's interesting.

And so that's kind of what happens to me when I watch TV if I'm a hotel or I'm somebody's house and I watch TV. And so I must have been a hotel or somebody's house. And I watched this show called Supernanny, which I don't even know if it still exists. I don't know how many people watch the show.

It was a British show. I don't know if it's also in America. But it was called Supernanny. And the premise was there was this woman who would go into people's houses where the kids were behaving badly and it was upsetting the whole family structure.

And usually it was down to parents not quite knowing how to instill enough discipline. So Supernanny, who was dove for us, would go in and effectively set up new ways of doing discipline in the household. Often encouraging the parents to see the parenting and the family structure in a different way. So the one that stuck in my mind that I watched was, I think it was a single parent household.

So there was a mom and then there was one daughter. And I think the daughter might have been about eight. So I'm going to say she was about eight. And she was getting, she was kind of a little terror.

She just simply couldn't be still. She wouldn't listen to what her mother said. And she was quite actually angry and violent. You know, she'd come home and she'd just be this explosive ball of rage.

And apparently that was also a problem in the school that the teachers had complained about how she'd she'd just act out constantly. And it turns out she's being bullied at school. And you know, so you know, the analysis was that she was being bullied at school. She was having to deal with all this and she simply couldn't contain it.

She was so angry about what was happening that she simply couldn't contain it. But then that made it even worse because then not only she'd been bullied at school, but she's also kind of being criticized by her teachers and it's a big problem. And there was a moment in which Joe Frost was speaking to this little girl. So she said, Joe Frost is on the floor looking at the little girl sort of eye to eye.

And the little girl is talking about what's happening at school. And she says, she kind of reveals that they say mean things to her at school. And Joe Frost turns and says, what did they say? And the little girl said, they say I'm ugly.

And I didn't really know what Joe Frost's response to that was going to be. I thought I think in the instance, I thought what she was going to say is, well, here's what you should say to them when they tell you you're ugly. But she didn't say that what she actually said was, sweetie, they're lying to you. And I thought, oh, that's an interesting thing.

She tells her they're lying to you. And the little girl said, oh, and there was this revelatory moment whereby she didn't have to believe it. She didn't have to believe the thing that she was being told. And they couldn't have occurred to her to think that when the children tell her that she's ugly, that they're lying.

And it wasn't, Joe Frost didn't turn to her and say, oh, sweetie, you're not ugly. She didn't turn to her and say, oh, they think you're ugly, but I don't think you're ugly. What she said is, they're lying. Now that's an interesting moment.

There's a moment of clarity there, that idea of they are lying to you. On the one hand, your social structure, your set of patterns, your patterns of beliefs, the way you fit into your world. Here I am in this world, and I'm ugly and they're not. And it's mean that they're telling me that I'm ugly, but in this world, there are some kids that are ugly and some kids who are pretty, and I'm one of the ugly ones.

That's the social structure. That's the consciousness that she was operating under. And for the pretty ones to tell her she's ugly isn't nice, but it's the harsh reality, right? That's the social structure.

And then Joe Frost comes in, rripp, that social structure is gone. But what comes with that social structure is a kind of freedom, a new way of understanding things. They're lying to me. So on the one hand, aye, I can't trust them, but b, why would I want to?

There's a new way of seeing this. They're lying to you. And so social structure, I understand it, especially when I think about it in terms of assumptions, ways of understanding the world, ways of seeing ones placed within the world, it can be comforting. But when you are actually oppressed by it, when it is, when the structure is actually bullying you, and you recognize that the problem is with the structure and not with your place in the structure, then there can be this real moment of clarity that I think that child expressed with that.

Oh. And I want to bring up that idea as a way of exploring an idea within social theory, the idea of false consciousness. And the idea of false consciousness came from Marx's theory. So it came from Karl Marx.

And Karl Marx, he was exploring the ways in which people become oppressed by other people. So he's writing, he's doing his philosophy, he's a student of philosophy in the 19th century, and he's exploring all these philosophical ideas. And he's in Berlin at a period where massive industrialization was happening and he's watching people becoming more and more alienated from their lives and from their families. And the way that alienation was happening is that as the world was becoming industrialized and as more and more wealth was being produced in factories and cities, people were working were no longer able to sustain their families by living out in the countryside and working on farms and they were having to come into city centers to work long, long hours in factories and not see the light of day to get pittance of wages in order to support sort of wider capitalist scheme where someone who has set up the factory who owns the needs of production et cetera hires individuals to work within the factory doing incredibly alienating labor for small amounts of money.

And then the owner of that needs of production gets all of the benefit from all of the work that they do and gets an enormous amount of money for the huge host of workers who are only getting a minimal amount of money. And so my image of Marxists watching this happening, I always imagine that he has this enormous empathy for these workers and for these experiences. I don't know, that could be my own projection. But I imagine that from within empathetic lens and the question and the idea there is there's something wrong with the social structure and the question from Marxists, why isn't anybody doing anything about it?

If you've got a factory full of people who are whose lives are miserable, who are separated from their families, who are working in cold, dark conditions, who are hungry, who are producing goods that have no connection with their own lives, so they're producing these things, they have no connection with their own lives, they're getting a pittance, they're effectively selling their time and they're eking out in existence, but they're not situated in their lives. How does it happen? Because there's no need for it to happen. Because all of the people in that factory are more powerful than the one person who owns and runs the factory.

Or even if you just look on the factory floor and you say, ah, all of those people could unite and thwart the person on the factory floor who's their boss. They could overpower them and they could say, no, we're not doing this. And so Marx was saying, why wasn't that happening? The system is, there's so many people, most of the people in this society, in a capitalist society, he says, most of these people are oppressed and there's only a few people at the top who own the means of production who are actually getting anything out of it.

So why is that happening? When the numbers don't add up, and his understanding of that, the way he theorized that, was to say people are participating in false consciousness. People are operating under false assumptions and he used the image of the camera obscura. So when you think about the lens of the camera and the fact that the light goes through the lens and the image is produced on the, if you think about the retina of your eye and you've got the lens on your eye and you've got an image of a person that's hitting the lens of your eye and on the retina it's upside down.

And the explanation is that your brain just turns it right up. So the image that actually hits your retina is of an upside down world and your brain has to turn it right side up. And what Marx was saying is that when people look at the world, when they look at their social structures, they're seeing it upside down and that is what keeps them oppressed. They're living within a false consciousness.

And that false consciousness might consist of any number of assumptions. One of them might be, well, I work in the factory because that's all I'm capable of doing. The people who make the money in the factory are the ones who deserve to make the money for whatever reason. They deserve to make the money because they've got an investment in it.

They deserve to make the money because they're cleverer than me. They deserve to make the money because they have, there's more at stake for them, there's higher risks. I wouldn't want the responsibility of owning the factory. I actually quite like being able to send money back to my family.

This life isn't too bad. All of those things, it's a false consciousness, which is to say effectively I don't really deserve any more than this. And the people above do deserve more. So upside down, that's a false consciousness or even that sort of alienation.

Well, yes, okay, I'm alienated, but now I'm not really alienated. I quite like my job, you know that type of thing. And so as long as there's a false consciousness in place, then the ruling classes according to Marx can stay in place. And he called that false consciousness ideology, you know, sets of assumptions that keep everything in place.

And if you start pulling away at those sets of assumptions, it's like a rip, rip, rip. But for Marx, that was absolutely essential. The whole point, the whole way of counter-veaning false consciousness was through consciousness. And it was to say, look, the conditions you're in are terrible.

And that relationship to work could be completely different. And that working is worth doing, but you need the people who are doing the working, also need to be the ones who own the means of production. It needs to be something that you're not alienated from, but you're a part of, he's saying. And what needs to happen now is that people need to gather together and they need to bring about a revolution.

They need to act. They need to change it. They need to turn this thing back right side up. And so here, again, with the notion of false consciousness, there needs to be this moment of, or there can be, this moment of consciousness.

If we think in terms of false consciousness, then we can imagine consciousness, that moment, ah, rip, they lie to us. They lie to us. There's something going on. They're lying to you.

And that, oh, they're lying. They're lying. They're lying. Clarity.

Consciousness. And then from Marx, the next stage, action. Do something about it. And there's a famous quote from Marx, you know, when he's contemplating his own studies and his own philosophical sojourns.

And he's been steeped in all of this philosophical literature that he's been reading. And you know, he, one of the things that he writes is philosophers have hitherto only interpreted the world in various ways. The point is to change it. He's effectively saying, stop this naval gazing.

We've got to change the world. There's no point in coming up with all of these ideas, because ideas just contribute to consciousness and consciousness is rooted in the material world and the material conditions of the world. And the second you float up above the material world and you start playing around with ideas, well, you're contributing to false consciousness and giving people a false sense of security about the world they live in and not asking them to change it, to take action. Now what I want to think about today is this idea of taking action and this impulse to take action or potentially that idea that, wow, if I notice that things are wrong, are you going to ask me to act on it?

And it's very interesting because sometimes in various classes that I've taught, I've asked students, when we talk about feminism, I ask students, do they consider themselves to be feminist? What's their definition of a feminist and do they consider themselves to be feminist? And I very often get students very thoughtfully responding by saying, I believe in the principles of feminism. And by that they sometimes say, you know, I believe that women have not been treated on an evil, even playing field with men.

And I think that's wrong. And I think it's still a problem. But then they say, but I'm not a feminist because I believe that to be a feminist means you're acting in the world. You're acting as a feminist.

And since I'm not involved in feminist action, I don't consider myself a feminist. And I think sometimes it's like when I talk to people about social structure, it's like, okay, yeah, whatever the system sucks. But what am I supposed to do about it? Do you want me to stay to revolution here?

Is that what you want? And so sometimes it's a sense of, do you see something wrong and you need to act on it? You know, something's wrong and act. And that's a kind of, you know, a reductionist way.

But it kind of marks us to way. There's something wrong. Let's not think about it. Let's do something about it.

Now, I want to propose a different way of responding to the idea that something's wrong with social structure. And to illustrate that, I would like to tell you about an experience I had when I was living in Paris at the end of the 1990s. And there's a tiny, I don't know if it's still there, but there's a tiny little Holocaust museum in a section of Paris in the, I think it's the third Arentissimo called Le Maché. And there's a little Holocaust museum there.

And I went inside this museum and I was really touched by the museum because of its simplicity and because of its lack of grandeur. From what I remember, you walked from kind of exhibit to exhibit. And when I was there, there weren't that many people there. And the exhibit was sparse.

And there was a sense of not overdramatizing the Holocaust. And so each exhibit displayed itself in a kind of emptiness, a kind of almost a strange calmness that made it extremely poignant. And there was an image, there was a framed letter. There was this letter, well, not even a letter, a note that was written on a piece of card, a tiny piece of card and it was scrawled on this piece of card.

And they framed it and they put a little tiny, they put it on the wall and they put a little tiny plaque underneath that said that this card, that had something scrawled on it, that they'd found on train tracks of a train network that had been carding Jews off to concentration camps. And so clearly somebody had thrown it out of a carriage, you know, so they had found some way to scroll a note on a little piece of card and throw it out of the carriage as they were being transported to a concentration camp. And the note only had a few sentences on it. But the thing that I remember from it, and I don't know if this is exactly what it said, but it was something like, you know, newsomonti, you know, newsomonti, they lied to us.

And effectively the note was saying, they told us one thing, we were obeying the law, we were doing what we were told, but they lied to us. We're being taken to a concentration camp where we will meet our end. If you get this note, will you please send it to this address, to family or to friends or whatever, and then there was an address at the bottom. And I just looked at that note and just wept.

They lied to us. Because, rip, you imagine it's like here you are in this world that's falling apart around you. And how do I operate in this world? And so you think, you know, during 1940s, France and Germany, and you're Jewish and you're trying to figure out what to do, and you're following the law.

So there's these laws in place and you think, okay, all right, yeah, I need to have a star centered on my coat, and I need to have my kids have stars centered on the coat. So I need to register, and okay, and now there's these signs that say I can't go into these buildings, and okay, and now I'm being carted off into a ghetto, okay. And now they're putting me in a train and telling me we're going somewhere. And then at that point when you realize I am being taken to the place where I will die, they lied to us.

A moment of devastating clarity. The social structure is ripped out from under you. There is no escape. And the reason I bring it up is because I want to point out that here that moment of the clarity, the moment when you recognize that the social structure, the beliefs, the things that you were clinging to have all just been taken away, and there is no action you can take.

There is no action available to you. There's no possibility of the prisoners in the carriage revolting because they will be shot down. There is no possibility for revolution. There's no possibility for action.

And the thing that struck me so much that I found so poignant is that even when there was no possibility for action, nevertheless that person needed to tell the story, they needed to communicate it. They found a piece of paper, they wrote it down, and they threw it out effectively into the abyss. Was it ever going to be found? I don't even know how it was found.

They wrote it down, they threw it out, and they knew it wasn't going to save them. And that moment, that recognition that someone's impulse would be to write down, they lied to us, to write down, to document it, and to throw it out into the world without knowing whether it was ever going to be read. I thought there's something happening there that isn't about action. It's about telling a story.

It's about communication. Now, the reason that this is so important to me is because I've been exploring the idea that when you notice that social structures are problematic, when you notice that social structures are oppressive, and I don't think they need to be as oppressive as the whole of us for us to notice that they're oppressive. I think sometimes they respond to, oh, well, it could be so much worse, it could be so much worse. Am I responsible?

It could be so much better. It could be so much better. We don't have to necessarily assume that it's going to be as bad as a Holocaust for us to recognize that something isn't as good as it could be. And so the research that I'm doing now, I'm just finishing up a book that's contracted with Paul Grave, an academic book that's called Cells, Bodies, and the Grammar of Social Worlds, Reimagining Social Change.

What I'm doing is exploring people talking about their social worlds. Sometimes when people are talking about their social worlds, they recognize there's something that isn't fair or isn't just about their social worlds, and they're talking about that. And sometimes people are talking about their social worlds, and I think, oof, the social world that you're describing is not just, it is oppressive, but they don't necessarily see it from that perspective. And what I've noticed is that if you look closely at how these social worlds are described, and you look at it doing the kind of grammatical analysis that I do, and you kind of squint your eyes, and suddenly what comes out is a different way of imagining that social structure.

If you look at the way it's described, if you see the grammatical structures, and you look at it closely and you squint your eyes, then you see a little window into a new way of looking at it. And if you remember a couple of weeks ago, I was talking about, let me know, I was talking about desire and the desire is thinking more than you can think, thinking outside the structure. I've noticed that when people describe their social worlds, you can often, if you squint your eyes, notice that there's a desire for a different alternative social world. And I've made it my task to see what that looks like.

And what I'm saying in this book is we can make it our task to recognize oppressive social structures when they show up and imagine new ones based on the descriptions of the oppressive ones to see little lights coming through of seeing what new structures could be in place. And for me, the idea is you don't notice an oppressive social structure and act right away. You don't have your social structure get ripped out from under you and say, ah, I'm acting now, I'm going to, I'm going to, I'm going to revolt. You don't respond to, they've lied to us with some big action that opposes that lying.

Instead you think, ah, this social structure is not a good one. It could be so much better. And then you imagine how could it be better. And you work towards that new one rather than battling the old one.

And so from that, I think we can learn something from Boris the Spider. So Boris the Spider has a social structure, his web ripped out from underneath him. And for the last 10 days I've noticed he's been sitting in the same spot on the ceiling without moving. And everyone's going to look up at Boris and I wonder what you're doing.

You're imagining your new web, you're imagining it. And then seeing it will come into being. So I look forward to seeing what new web Boris will be building. And I thank you very much for listening today.

Frequently asked questions

When was this Structured Visions episode published?

This episode was published on November 13, 2015.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Structured Visions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.