Welcome to the Pipe Liners Podcast, Episode 192, sponsored by Rosen, the global leader in cutting-edge solutions across all areas of the integrity process chain, providing operators the data they need to make the best integrity management decisions. To find out more about Rosen, go to rosen-group.com. Thanks, Russell. Pleasure's online.
So before we dive in, would you mind giving us a brief introduction? Tell us a little bit about yourself and how you got into integrity management. Yes, so Corey Richards, I'm working here at the Rosen Center for the Rosen Group. I've been working in the oil and gas industry for about 15 years.
Twelve years of that has been in Rosen, field technician originally, then working into technical sales, and then to my current role, which is challenging pipelines or in Pigable Pipelines, started this in Lincoln and Germany at a research center, for a number of years, looking after Asia Pacific and Oceana, and then moving back here to Calgary about two years ago, still focusing on on Pigables. And I really got into this industry like many other people following my dad's footsteps, so he's an old pipe liner and followed that same direction. So what did your dad do in the pipeline in this place? So my dad originally started out as a welder and then worked his way into welding inspector, chief inspector on the construction side, and then construction management, and also worked in the Ili side of it as well too.
And then, yeah, he's working for Nova and then he's trans-Canada, I guess, at the time, and then also consulting for the last couple years. So I was working with him in the pipeline, and I was working with him in the pipeline. And then he was working with him in the pipeline. So I was working with him in the pipeline, and then he was working with the chief inspector on the construction side, and then construction management, and also worked in the Ili side of it as well too.
And then, yeah, he's working for Nova and then he's trans-Canada, I guess, at the time, and then also consulting for the last couple years. Awesome. Well, you know, this is a business we tend to inherit from our parents, and they pass the gene down. Yeah, whether we like it or not, right?
So I was half like myself, we have to search out this industry, and then once we find it, we don't leave. We're fortunate we find it through our parents. Well, that's exactly it. And it's a diverse industry.
It's quite interesting. It's engaging lots of different avenues to work into. And kind of once you're in it, you know, if you get bored, you can always go somewhere else and still be within the same industry. Well, I can support your comment that it's diverse because I have found that, you know, doing this podcast, you would think after 200 episodes, almost that I would have covered everything there is to talk about in pipeline.
But I am quite certain that is not the case. It's a lot more diverse than what you could cover in 200 episodes. Yeah, it's a big domain. It's a big domain.
You must be on your way to be an industry SME at this point. I know a whole lot about a couple of subjects and a little bit about a lot of subjects. The mill rate, the mill rate of the pipeline industry. Right, exactly right, exactly right.
Well, I asked you to come over and talk about Unpigable, so I'll just start with the simple question. That is, what's unpigable? What's the definition? What does that mean?
Yeah, I think when we look at Unpigable Pipelines, most people are maybe not aware, you know, we have our pickable pipeline network. And what we mean here is pipelines where we have standard launching and receiving facilities, where we can insert an inline inspection tool that is free swimming that will run through the line of products. So we'll put it in the launcher and receive it at the receiving end. Now, these tools are going to be running with conventional operating parameters.
So each one will need a certain amount of flow, a certain amount of pressure, some require products, some require no product or medium independent technologies. And a lot of these lines, I'd say, large part of them, the main line network at least is pickable. So you can put the tool in, it runs with the flow, it's no problem. We have a large section, often I hear the word 40% of the world's pipelines are considered unpigable, but we have this large section of pipelines that are unpigable.
And why, you know, could be we don't have launchers and receivers, maybe we don't have the ability to add launchers and receivers, or we don't have flow or pressures that we would need to launch conventional inline inspection tools, or maybe there's just some mechanical design parameters in that particular pipeline, which would inhibit a conventional IELI tool to run through it. And is that typically the older pipelines that would be unpigable, or are there other kind of categories of things that are unpigable? You know, you do see a lot, I would argue in older lines, you know, simply these weren't set up for conventional picking. But I mean, it's not uncommon to build new lines where you might have operational conditions such as, you know, high flow, where you can't run conventional technologies, or extremely high pressures, or maybe you just need to, you know, work the pipe through a certain area and conventional tools wouldn't be able to run through that type of pipey network, you know, pipe radius bends that are back to back to back, or even often see these miter bends these cause some issues.
So yeah, I'd say like I said, more often older lines, but we still see these as common issues in new lines as well. Yeah, so I want to frame up this conversation a little bit too, because I think at least before we started having the conversation getting prepared to record this episode, you know, I kind of, you know, I kind of thought, unpigable just meant you can't inspect it. But that's not really the case. I mean, it's really, you have these things that you can't run a tool through, and then you have things that are more standard, and then kind of this whole room in the middle where I can run a tool, but it's going to require some extra work or thinking.
Is that a kind of a fair way to frame it? Yeah, I know. I think that's exactly it. I mean, for a number of years, we always just had the kind of these two categories, you know, pickable, unpigable.
And the pickable was just that, the stuff you could just get after. But then you had this other network of pipe that you just didn't really know what to do with. And for the most part, that stuff often got shelved, which is okay, we'll look at that another time where things are when we have time to look at it or, you know, regulatory demands drive us to that direction. The reality is a lot of that pipe is pickable.
It's just more of a challenging type of inspection where we have to use specialized technologies or maybe modify operating parameters or even small modifications on that particular asset. So what are some of the strategies or techniques that you might use for these challenging situations? So if we look at free swimming tools, for example, all of these tools, they're being essentially pulled through the pipeline. So the product pushes it from the rear.
We have some bypass around the tool, which then pulls the tool through the pipeline. And what we do is that particular tool has some ceiling elements. So polyurethane will then seal it to the pipe wall bolts in that product and then we pull it through the line. Now, in a non-conventional pipeline, we need to look at things we can do to that tool to modify it to make it run a lot more smoothly.
So if we start to look at a low pressure pipeline or a low flow pipeline, we focus on certain tool elements such as tool centralization, you know, ceiling capabilities, friction reduction, weight optimization, all with the goal of, you know, reducing the overall friction components of the tool, it makes it run a lot smoother. So you have a smaller differential pressure requirement across the tool to push it, makes it a lot easier to go through your bends or through certain types of installations, which would cause speed excursions, which will then, you know, cause them to create a data issues. And then so we can apply these types of technologies in low flow pipelines or low pressure pipelines. Pipelines we typically wouldn't be able to even discuss putting a tool in years ago.
And if we did, the data would just be terrible. And nowadays, you know, we can get these lines inspected with a conventional free swimming tool, sorry, non-conventional free swimming tool will still give us ideal data quality. And then we still have lines where we have no flow, no pressure. And we look at more like robotic self-repell solutions.
So talk to me about self-propelled because that's, that's, frankly, that's a brand new concept to me. What does that mean for a tool to be self-propelled? And how is that accomplished? Yeah.
So as I mentioned, the typical tools are going with the product, the product is pushing it to the endpoint. Now with the self-propelled tools, you rely on a propulsion module at the, typically the front of the tool to actually pull the tool itself to the line. So it may have wheels and may have some tracks designed. Anyway, something that will grip onto the pipe wall and essentially drive and pull that tool to our designated endpoint.
And within these types of technologies, we have tethered and untethered technologies and tethered being something with a cable. So we can either pull that back or use that for some type of communication. And then the tethered list tools, of course, don't have this, but they also don't have that out of contingency as well. So, okay.
So you said pull back. So what, I have, you know, you gotta kind of slow down a little bit, Corey, and help me because I'm a bit of a novice here, right? So when you say pull back, are you talking about, I load a tool, let it run out and I use the tethered to recover it? Yeah, there's a little bit of both.
So some of the tethered solutions in the market, or some of the, we actually utilize as well, you would drive the tool to the endpoint and then we would pull it back with the tethered on it. Other tools have drive mechanisms in the front and the rear of the tool so that it can actually drive back to the starting point. However, these robotic and these autonomous solutions are still relatively new to the market. So the question typically arises, okay, what happens?
Where would happen if something fails? If the tool fails, how do we get this out? Conventional ILI, we can, we have some strategies there. We can try to push it out with some more product, maybe put something behind it to bump it and then try to push it back up.
But when this fails, what do we do? One of the most common ways to get one of these tools out now is with the tether. So we have this contingency tether often on these tools and we can now, okay, tool completely fails. We can now pull this out to the entry point.
And how long of a tether can you run? Load a question. It's a, it weighs a joke around, you know, you get that answer. It depends.
And this is definitely one of those. It depends. You have a lot of different factors. So you have your dry lines and your liquid lines.
When you have a liquid line, we can, we can, we can typically travel farther distances. And the reason being is we can have elements within that tether itself, which make it usually buoyant. So it floats through the pipeline because what happens is when you're, the crawler is pulling this tether, it's in a dry line, especially dragging this, right? The longer you have to drag the tether, the more weight that tool is going to see and it's going to get more and more difficult to pull the further you go.
Another issue we tend to have, of course, is bends. Every time we add another bend within the line, we're going to add more tension onto that cable. Eventually, we're going to get to a point where we can no longer pull the, the cable itself. It's just going to get caught up in these bends.
In a liquid line, you know, again, we can have cables that then essentially float through it. So we have higher bend capabilities as well to go through more bends. Tether floats through the line makes it much easier. We go farther distances.
So we have tether units that can go up to 12 kilometers and we can also loop them together to go up to 24 kilometers. And these would be liquid lines, you know, with a low volume of bends. And we can typically see these distances. When we started looking at a dry gas line where we were trying to run these types of tools, you're fairly limited.
I'd say you're probably between five and 10, depending on if the bends are horizontal and vertical. Interesting. So you mentioned that some of these, some of these have drive units on them and some of them have drive units on both ends. I would assume those drive in units are also battery powered.
And then that also becomes another limiting factor is how far can you go before the batteries run out. This is exactly it. Yeah. So you have, this kind of goes back to the tether to non-tether tools.
When you have, with a lot of the tether tools that we're utilizing, we do have some, some copper wiring in there to either charge the battery units as we operate through the line. Or in other cases, we use this to solely operate the tool itself. So it's running off of short power. In the tetherless systems, of course, yeah, you're going to be limited to the battery vessels you have on board of it.
I've seen some systems in the market that have some external power charging stations that's outside of our wheelhouse. So I can't really comment on how well that's working. But for the most part, we see these running with the tether or just off the batteries. Interesting.
Yeah. So I'm, you know, I'm trying to process this course. I'm listening to you talk. And so I have this whole kind of thought in my mind about, well, okay, so there's a, there's the issue with the tether itself and how long can I run out the tether?
And that's going to be dependent on the fluid that I'm working with and the nature of the tether itself. And I would assume that a tether that I just used to pull and retrieve is probably lighter than the tether that I'm using to provide power or communications. So it's like everything else, right? I mean, I start knowing some of the details.
It starts getting pretty dang complex. Yeah, it's quite complicated. I mean, these are, these systems, I would say, are fairly niche. They're typically being utilized for shorter lines.
I would say more common, at least more common for us initially has been in offshore applications where you simply would only have a single access point and then you're going to, you know, sub C plan or something like this. And this is initially for us where we would use these more commonly. We do use them on shore as well too. They have very, very niche, very niche situation where we're using them.
Yeah. Yeah. No, no doubt. No doubt, right?
It's very, very niche. So that kind of addresses kind of one whole domain of challenging is, you know, places where I need to run a tether tool either because of how I have to load the tool or how I have to recover the tool or how I have to drive the tool. All those things would be issues that might drive me towards something that's tethered, I suppose. And then what other kinds of strategies might there be beyond what we've talked about so far?
Are there other kinds of approaches that people might think about when they're looking at, you know, how do I get this particular piece of five inspected? Yeah, I think one large common issue we've seen, especially over the years and now with some of the themes that changes and towards the may out validation has been, you know, how do we manage these lower flow and lower pressure lines? And what we've established are low friction based technologies for these types of systems so we can run in extremely low pressure environments while reducing speed excursions that we see throughout the line. Sure, and better data quality.
And we can start applying these through different types of technologies as well, too. So primarily we see with MFL, E-Mat is making some investments in here. And then we've also started to broaden these out into multi-diameter pipelines where we have, you know, 16 to 20 inch, for example, ranges we're working in or even dual diameter lines, 10 and 12. So we're building up a lot of these technologies.
So kind of expanding on what was typically available in the free swimming market and pushing that through to have a larger portfolio, so to say, with these solutions. So, okay, I'm going to play this back to you just so that makes your understand what you're saying. Basically, what you're talking about tools, which the diameter of the pipe that they will work within is dynamic. So I could start in a 20 inch pipe and then the tool will actually make it so small and move into like a 14 inch pipe, that type of thing.
Exactly. Yeah. So we have, we've had these technologies at least within within rows and for a number of years to handle multi-diameter pipelines where we're seeing further advancements in these are now we're adapting those similar types of technologies into more complex operating conditions in lower flow and lower pressure lines. Okay, I got you.
Yeah, that would make sense because the minute you start trying to do that in a low differential pressure, you're when you get into the narrower line, you're moving a heavier tool. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And what happens commonly in these low pressure lines, for example, is that it's not uncommon for tools just to get hung up on random things in the line.
And then they have to build up this differential pressure to of course push through it. In a higher pressure line, you typically have a lot of cushion in front of the tool to slow down. And you have a lot of pressure behind it to push it through. In these low pressure lines, you know, as soon as you get hung up on something, you lose that head pressure.
It takes you a little bit longer to build up that differential pressure behind it. And then you get the speed excursion on the tool shoots out at a high velocity. And then we end up having, you know, degraded data once we hit a certain peak of velocity. And depending on how high that goes, you know, of course you'll have your downward trend for when it slows down back to its normal velocity range, operating range, where we can collect better data quality again.
Yeah, that I'm just thinking about just kind of the operating realities of that. If you go to all this extra effort to run one of these tools and then you have a bunch of speed excursions or whatever because it's getting hung up and then you analyze the data on the back end and you go, yeah, well, that's not good enough. We got to run again. That can't be fun.
No, and that's how it that's to be fair. I guess that's how it had been for a number of years, right? This was kind of an accepted issue. Just in gas lines in general, you know, speed excursions are an everyday thing.
And this is something you've kind of just grown to, let's say, accept is in the right word, but they were fairly common place. But you know, as these technologies have now evolved, evolved, you know, the speed excursions and normal operating gas lines, we can, I can argue, we can more or less solve that. And now what we can do and what we've seen in these extreme environments has been extremely impressive. Interesting.
So what is driving the ability to be able to do this and do it with more predictability? I guess just in general, just overall evolutions in tool design. So, of course, as things have evolved, we've been able to do more with the tools, lighter weight kind of designs. We've been able to slim down the overall weight of the tool by doing this.
We've also added certain low friction elements. So the tools are primarily running on wheels. So we only run on rolling friction. You know, just things that we've learned over the years, adapting them, putting them in different applications and just kind of building on that knowledge base and kind of advancing the tools every time.
You know, we get some more data from the previous iteration. How much of it is just dropping the weight of the batteries and dropping the weight of the materials you use to build the tools? Some of that for sure is significant. So when you start to get to small diameter tools, 12 inch, for example, it's common to have three or four body tools, right?
So just developing more smaller electronics that are pulling less battery life and putting this all into a single canister and dropping their weight is significant. All your thing is also a large contributor to the overall friction and run performance as well too. So optimizing that has actually made a big difference. Yeah, interesting.
Just confirms my, again, confirms my notion that everything is easy to know enough about it. Right. Yeah. So what are the, in general, what are the fems or regs around, you know, so-called unpigable or challenging run types?
So, and it's not my strength isn't the US regulations, but sitting on the Canada side. From what I understand though, fems is more or less defining unpigable as if the operation limits of these particular technologies, including operating pressure, low flow or availability of technologies for certain pipe diameters can prevent the tool from running through the line safely or accurately or perform to perform the assessment. They categorize this as an impigable. It seems like it's defined as, it's not even really defined as more of a left as this is an industry term.
They're not redefining it. So it's kind of leaving it as how is the industry play. This is an unpigable role, which I think then leaves a lot to how do you then justify or how do you then assess these lines as an operator. This is quite difficult, right?
So it's, I don't want to say easy. That isn't the right word. But you know, you can put a pipeline into the unpigable category and say there's not much I can do with it. But, you know, I think the reality is there is a lot of technologies, especially now for gas operators, they're looking for this mayo validation that they'll need to be performing here.
You know, previous pipelines, you know, you wouldn't be able to run an MFL tool, for example, because of pressure and flow, well, these technologies are here nowadays. So I think it's going to push a lot of operators to start looking more into, okay, what is non-standard? What can I do for these lines? Can I develop something?
You know, companies like Rosen, for example, it's not uncommon for us to build a custom tool for a particular pipeline or a particular network to meet the challenges of those lines. So these things are available. I think there's going to be a lot more pressure to look at these types of solutions in their around. Yeah.
So I guess the, I guess I'm getting kind of muddled in my thinking here, but what I'm kind of, what's washing through my brain here is I have those things that are clearly unpigable, just taking a simple example, just jumping through. Just taking a simple example, just geometry causes it to be unpigable. Then I have to have some other kind of program to, you know, other than running ILI to do my inspection, either digs or materials properties or something to allow me to perform my risk assessment on that portion of my system. And then it becomes a question of what is the more effective way to manage that pipe, come up with a way to pick it or continue to do whatever I'm doing other than picking.
I think that's accurate. My understanding, I think a lot, I could be misinterpreting. My understanding is that if you're unable to do any type of inspection work, then you're pushing to do any type of a doing a hydro test or something like this, which is typically that makes most gas operators cringe for for a reason, right? Yeah.
So I think when you know, when you start looking at the availability of some of these types of technologies that maybe people weren't aware of, you know, they come a lot more attractive, especially when there's a lot more understanding that they're available and they're here. Yeah. So that kind of leads me to the last question that I wanted to ask you. And that is, what do you think a pipeline operator ought to take away from this conversation we're having?
What are the key things that a pipeline operator ought to be aware of? I guess it's the thing that I always throw out is that, you know, when you're assessing any of these lines and you're finding it that, you know, there's the non, maybe maybe you're a selective vendor can't inspect it. Search around, speak with other vendors or even work with that particular vendor to see if there's something you can develop or if there's modifications that can be made because I think a lot of people would be very surprised on what's available outside of maybe that preferred vendor. Or maybe what your vendor is doing or maybe what your actual vendor or preferred vendor could be doing for you.
So can they develop something? Can they modify something? There's a lot more that can be done simply just having more detailed conversations and supplying more of this data to your vendors, letting them understand exactly what your problems are and really working together to try to solve that solution. I think it'd be surprising.
What can be done for these unthinkable lines. Perfect. Yeah, I think that certainly might take away here is that like everything else in integrity management, you know, the things are problematic. You've got to understand what's the risk associated with this particular line from an operating perspective and then what is my approach to inspecting it.
And I think one of the things that's really clear to me in this conversation is there's a host of tools out there that are outside of what you see in 80 or 90% of the cases. Yeah, for sure. Yeah, I'm being promotional here, but I feel fortunate at Rosen where we have a lot of these technologies and I'm spoiled in the sense that I'm able to look at. Okay, we have a lot we can do on the traditional side.
And then when we start to focus on the impactables, the amount of solutions that we have available that I have available to me to utilize is fantastic from robotics and self-repelled to these low friction technologies. And then to the different types of measurement technologies that I can incorporate into these, it's pretty impressive what we can do for these types of assets. Awesome. Well, listen, Corey, this has been a great episode.
I have to tell you've made my head hurt my head hurt a little bit. So hopefully this has been educational for those that are listening. That's been great for me and my wife says the same when she talks to me. So I don't know how to take that.
I appreciate it. I mean, this is a great experience and I really appreciate you giving me the time today. All right, Corey. Well, we appreciate it.
You take care now. Thank you. You too. I hope you enjoyed this week's episode of the Pipe Liners Podcast and our conversation with Corey.
Just a reminder before you go, you should register to win our customized Pipe Liners Podcast Yeti Tumblr. Simply visit Pipe Liners Podcasts.com and any yourself in the drawing. If you would like to support the podcast, best way to do that is to leave us a review. And you can do that on Apple Podcasts, Google Play or wherever you happen to listen.
You can find instructions at Pipe Liners Podcasts.com. If you have ideas, questions or topics you'd be interested in, please let me know on the contact us page at pipelinerspodcast.com or reach out to me on LinkedIn. Thanks for listening. I'll talk to you next week.