Hello and welcome to episode 20 of Structure Visions. Structure Visions is a space where I explore new ways of thinking about social structure. My name is Jody Clark and I'm very grateful for you listening today. You are very welcome here.
And speaking of gratitude, I would like to wish a happy Thanksgiving to all of my American listeners. I'm actually recording this on Thanksgiving, but I won't be uploading it until tomorrow. And to all of my listeners, all of them, all over the world, please share with me in celebrating this American holiday. And the way I would like to celebrate it today is by talking about a video that caught my attention this week that made me laugh so hard that I cried.
And I watched it several times now. Excuse me, and each time I watch it, I do shake a little end tears come out of my eyes. And I'm sure you've seen it. It's the sign-in-it-life sketch called a Thanksgiving miracle.
And in it, you've got a sort of classic set up of a long table with family members sitting around all adult family members of various generations, except for one little girl who looks like she's about eight or nine. And so they're sitting around the table and they're about to talk into the turkey. And somebody mentions that they're grateful and thankful that everyone could be there today. And one of the women says, you know, I am thankful that our governor's not going to let those refugees in here.
Okay, so right away we recognize a sort of potentially typical family gathering situation where someone says something political, provocative, and likely to cause disruption. And so then a woman sitting across from her looks at her and says, oh my God. Okay, and then the next thing that happens that flashes up is a kind of piece of text. The screen goes blank and there's a piece of text.
And it says Thanksgiving with the family can be hard. Okay. And then someone else joins in with that was a Kathy who said that someone else joins in and says, you know, I heard the refugees are all ISIS in disguise. And then the woman who was sitting across from her, Kathy says, no, no, no.
And then Kathy goes on to say, oh, yeah, that's true. I actually saw an ISIS in the AMP today when I was picking up the yams. And Kathy's niece sitting across from her says, no, you didn't, and Kathy, that was an Asian woman. Okay, so and then the next thing that comes up that the screen goes blank again, more text on the screen that says everyone has different opinions and beliefs.
And so the fact that you've got this kind of classic Thanksgiving scene with people expressing different beliefs about this of current events and people getting very offended and the situation getting tense classic scene. And I hope you didn't experience it yesterday, but you might have. And so the little girl, the nine year old gets up, moves over to a CD player and pushes play. And then suddenly we have Adele singing hello and that sort of piping through the dining room where they're all eating.
And then all of the people who were just extolling these beliefs and these views and these world perspectives and these controversial ideas start lip syncing in perfect harmony, in perfect synchronization, the lyrics to Adele's hello. And the scene progresses where the comments become more and more provocative and people keep pushing the CD player button. And each time Adele comes on, people become more and more united, they're lip syncing hello with more besto. And they start transforming into Adele.
And the situation starts transforming, the context starts transforming into what I assume is the video for Adele. And it's, for me, I just find that so hilarious because what it does is it shows what a beautiful solution would be to all of that tension. I mean, as I once said, I hate conflict. So in a family setting or any kind of setting when there are different ideas and opinions that are being thrown at each other, I would just love for everyone to start singing.
That would be great. A phenomenal joy. I think in some situations I've actually tried to start singing, but it never works. And there's a beautiful moment at the end where the nine year old turns to the camera and says, thank you Adele.
So what I want to talk about today is this notion of what is actually going on when people are presenting different views. Is it the case, you know, like the overlay, like the text on the Saturday Night Live sketch says, is it the case, the implication is that Thanksgiving dinner is hard because everyone has different opinions and beliefs. So that's an interesting idea is that the reason it's difficult is because people have different opinions and beliefs. Now, stop for a second.
And I think that's a sort of common assumption that things are different, difficult because people have different opinions. And stop for a second and think, why should that be? Why should the fact that me, for instance, as an individual, has a different opinion from you as an individual? Why should that necessarily make things hard?
Okay. So then you think, okay, well, I guess it would make things hard if you didn't voice your opinions. Okay. But now let's imagine, why should it be hard if we voice our opinions?
What if I actually voiced, you know, my opinion on something and someone else's voice their opinion, why, what is it that actually makes that so hard? And to explore that, I want to go back to something that I discussed a whole bunch of podcasts ago, which is this notion of politeness theory. And I've done some research in politeness theory. And I talked about the fact that one of the reasons supposedly that we need politeness, we need to sort of lubricate social interaction with politeness forms like indirectness or like not saying things at all or like using, you know, attention to the other things like, you know, oh, well, you might think that by it respectfully, I would suggest blah, blah, blah.
You know, why do we even need that at all? And the argument is it's not because we're not rational people, but it's rather because everybody has face. And what politeness does is a way of orienting to the face of the other. And so what happens when Kathy says, I'm thankful our governor is not going to let those refugees in here.
And what she's done from a politeness perspective, her comment is a face threatening act. It is threatening to the face of her niece who's sitting across the table from her. So it's not just that there's two different views. You know, you assume that Kathy's niece doesn't think that the refugees should be kept out.
So we've got two different views. But what's actually happening, if we look at it from a politeness theory perspective, is that she's offended her niece's face. And she hasn't done anything to attenuate that. So often in politeness theory, we talk about FTAs or face threatening acts.
And politeness theory suggests that what you do if you're going to commit a face threatening act, and we all have to commit them to sort of move through society. You know, sorry, how about that pen just for a second, you know, recognizing that to take some of these pen away from them is a face threatening act means I've got to somehow attenuate it. And so I say, I say, I'm sorry. I ask it as a question.
Can I? And then I maybe diminish it. I say, just for a minute, I promise I'll get it straight back. So this notion of being offended.
But I guess the question I would ask is, is it because it's your personal opinion that you are offended? What is it that's actually offensive? So let's imagine that you're Kathy's niece and you're sitting across the table from her Kathy and she says this thing and you're offended. Is it because she's offending your personal opinion?
Or is there something else that's being offended? Now, I wrote an article in, I think it was published in 2011, 2012, I can't remember, and I proposed that the idea of face should be thought of slightly differently because this notion of face has often been criticized because it assumes that we live in a culture where the individual is sacrosanct and every individual has a face and every individual has an opinion. And it's that individual identity, it's that individual self, it's that individual opinion that's actually being threatened when we talk about face. And when we talk about face, we assume that there's kind of like one face for each individual, you know, and that face can be threatened.
And what's being threatened when your face is threatened is your sense of individuality. And the critiques of that notion says, well, it's a bit Western. You know, this idea that every individual is a kind of deity. That's the term that the sociologist Erving Goffman used.
And he said that's actually quite a Western idea. That's a Western ethos that each individual has treated as kind of sanctus, sacrosanct. Each individual is treated as a kind of deity that we worship. So it's not like we worship other people, but we worship the individuality of ourselves and of other people.
And I thought, well, I don't know that that's necessarily the case. I'm not arguing that individualism isn't an important ideal in an ideal in quote, unquote Western cultures. But I don't think that when an idea or when offense is caused to me, it's only because I see my opinion as my personal opinion and I don't want you to upset it. And so in that particular example is a really useful example.
I'm thankful that our governor is not going to let those refugees in here. And Kathy says, and her niece says, oh my God, and it's clear that she's offended. And I don't think it's that it's her personal opinion that's offended. I wonder if it has something to do with her vision of social structure.
In other words, she wants to live in a world, perhaps, where refugees are welcomed in. And Kathy doesn't want to live in that world. And so then what we have are two different worlds that are in conflict, not just two different selves. Like I said, I wrote this piece that was challenging the idea of face and proposing a new way of looking at it.
And I said, let's not think about face as something that's intrinsic to each individual. Instead, let's think about face as a kind of boundary. And you can have an individual boundary. But you can also have a boundary around other levels of social structure.
So in the chapter that I wrote, which is called redrawing boundaries, I suggested that face could be seen as a boundary formed around different levels of social structure. So again, we see the individual as one level of social structure. But we can also see the community or the family or the nation or the institution also as having a boundary or a face. And within that boundary are all of the ideals and assumptions and truths and ways of seeing things that coincide with that particular level of social structure.
And so what can happen is that boundary can be threatened. Now, looking back over that chapter, I think now I would revise that to make an even more radical claim, which is to say that face isn't just the boundary, but it's actually the manifestation of social structure itself. So for instance, if we analyze a piece of interaction and say, ah, this individual is protecting the boundary around the individual, protecting the boundary around the self. You can't protect the boundary around the individual unless the notion of the individual is present within the social structure itself.
OK, so let me just say that again. You can't protect the boundary around an individual unless the idea, the notion of the individual, is part of is a constituent of the social structure itself. So it's not like we can look out into the world and say, ah, yes, ah, yes, there are all these individuals. That's clear.
That's true. And some people think that individuals are more important than the community. Now, actually, the notion of the individual is a component of a particular social structure. And as I've been trying to show that these different types of social structure emerge, and there are some social structures that divide the world into individuals, and there are some social structures that don't.
But what can sometimes happen is that if you see the world only in terms of individuals, then you might ignore the way in which social structures influence your sense of self as an individual. OK, so that's a little bit complex. And so let's maybe see if we can make that a bit more grounded and a bit more concrete by looking at some of the conversational data that I was analyzing in that article, that chapter that I was just speaking about. So the conversational interaction that I was analyzing in that chapter came from the work that I've done that I've spoken about a number of times on these podcasts, which was an ethnographic study of a university hockey team.
And a particular conversation came from three first year field hockey players. We went in, we were about 18. And they were all very new to the university, and they were new to the field hockey team. And they were kind of getting their bearings.
And they kind of come to university and noticed that things were different from where they had left. And so there were sometimes in which you notice these kind of provocations or clashes, where for instance something that you would say in your own community, that would be completely accepted and it wouldn't even be noticed. You come to a new community and it's challenged. And something happens there.
There's a little bit of a clash. It's a little bit like Thanksgiving dinner. And so one of the hockey players that I want to talk about, and her pseudonym is Ally. And she's talking to two other hockey players, again.
All of them are 18. All of them are white British. And she's an alley and Sami come from the south of England. So Ally comes from south of London, and Sami comes from Devon.
And Chrissy comes from Leicester. So Leicester, if you're not from Britain, Leicester is kind of right in the middle of England. And so they've all come sort of north, but this university is actually in the Midlands. And Ally's commenting on how surprised she is at the behavior of the other women in her Hall of Residence.
She says, they're really brazen. She says, they're really rough. And she says, they're really northern. And so to contextualize that a little bit, there's a kind of common concession in Britain that the south, where London is and there, is kind of seen as refined and posh.
And that is sort of the farther north you go, the less refined and posh you are. Because it's a kind of common assumption in itself, in the suburbs, this is north-south divide. And the material experience of that is that salaries tend to be higher in the south, that material wealth, people are wealthier in the south, that the poshest, some of the poshest universities like Oxford and Cambridge are in the south. Some of the poshest boarding schools, for instance, are in the south.
And there's sort of less economic wealth in the north. So there's some sort of material connections with these conceptions. And so here's Ali coming to the Midlands from South London. And she says, gosh, where are the girls?
They're so brazen. They're so rough. They're so northern. OK, now, Sammy doesn't have a problem with that.
Sammy's from Delhi. But Chrissy, who comes from Leicester, who comes from nearby, is a little bit puzzled, like where is this coming from? And the main thing she wants to do is say, well, we're not in the north now. We're not in the north.
And I was like, well, it feels pretty north to me. So what she's saying is, to me it is. And so what she's effectively saying is, I'm in this place that to me feels wrong. It doesn't feel like people are behaving appropriately.
And I associate that behavior, or I have perhaps begun to associate that behavior with being in the north. And therefore, this place, to me, is the north. OK, so it starts being about geographic coordinates. And it starts being about sets of behavior and assumptions and appropriateness.
So this is very, very interesting. So here's Ali as an individual indicating that she's actually offended by the behavior of her friends and her hall of residence. So as an individual, to me, it feels northern. As an individual, she's offended.
But is it really Ali as an individual who's offended? Or is it instead her social structure, or the social structure in which she's situated that is offended? So let me read to you what she says. So transcribe the conversation.
Let me read to you what she says. She says, do you know what I mean, though? Like, down south, you'd never, none of my friends, you'd never catch anyone drinking a pint. Do you know what I mean?
And since it's now, same here. Ali says, it would just be so wrong. All the boys would just be like, what are you doing? OK, so she says nobody would drink a pint.
So what she means is, it becomes clearer through the conversation. What she means is that the women who are halls of residence drink and pint of beer, they drink a pint of lager. And Chris is like, well, I would really, I'd only have a half. So of course, in Britain, you either have a pint of beer or a half pint of beer.
But what Ali's actually saying is, no, no, no, no, no, no. Women don't drink beer. You drink alcopops. You drink wine.
You drink what else would you drink? I don't know. Cocktails. But you wouldn't drink beer.
And so here she comes. And so imagine if it was just a difference of opinion. Right? Ali comes in.
She's like, oh, I don't like beer. And they're drinking beer. You see how she could be offended by that. If they're not forcing her to drink beer, how can that actually be a face threat?
But instead, what's offensive to her is her sense of appropriateness and what it means to exist within a particular social structure. So what social structure is Ali describing here? Okay. So it's a social structure that she's associating with the south, down south.
You'd never catch anyone drinking a pint. So when do you use the word catch? Well, use the word catch when you're describing somebody getting caught out, somebody being apprehended in the midst of doing something wrong. Right?
You'd never catch anyone drinking a pint. It simply wouldn't happen. And if it did happen, then it's because they're being caught out. And then she's more explicit about the fact that it's inappropriate.
It would just be so wrong. Okay. And then she says, all the boys would just be like, what are you doing? So one thing we can see about the social structure, the social structure has a set of norms that Ali is explaining.
You know, the set of norms are, you don't drink pints. But it's not just you. We notice as well that the social structure is divided into boys and girls. So there's a gender divide to the social structure.
And the gender divide defines the differential appropriateness. So the boys and girls are divided up and boys get to do things that girls don't get to do and vice versa. Presumably, boy, you wouldn't catch boys drinking alcohol. So other she doesn't really talk about that.
So girls don't drink pints. And here's the next bit. If they do, they would fall under scrutiny from the boys. All the boys would just be like, what are you doing?
Okay. So what's this idea of the individual here who is offended by the behavior that she's seeing in her hall of residence? From my perspective, it isn't Ali as an individual, but it's Ali as she situates herself within a particular social structure that has particular norms and particular notions of appropriateness. And so what's happening when she sees women drinking pints is not that she as an individual is offended, but that she as an individual within the social structure, she knows the whole social structure is offended, right?
And so similarly, if we look at Cathy and her niece from the Saturday Live Sketch, it's not so much Cathy that it's offended. That's offended. But her sense potentially of where she fits within a social structure. And so there might be lots of different ways in which we can understand her fitting within a social structure.
And one might be that she sees her experience as being part of a social structure. What's important to her about that social structure is that it's welcoming to people who are less well off, for instance. That might be it. But it might be something else entirely.
It might be that she sees herself as fitting in a social structure with a group of people who have a certain set of received ideas. That could be it as well. Who knows? But the point is that the offense is not because everyone has different ideas and opinions.
But the offense comes because in order to express ourselves, in order to be people, in order to be individuals with their social structure, we are the face of the whole social structure that constricts us as individuals. And what happens at Thanksgiving dinner or when you come to university or when you move into an environment that's different from the one you're in is that you recognize that the whole social structure comes in conflict or in, well, in conflict possibly with another social structure. And then suddenly you understand how there's a lot at stake. So this notion of face as being the manifestation of social structure itself, which is different from saying that it's a kind of individual thing.
And I want to link that back to an annual Levinauss who I commented on a number of times in the podcast. And I spoke about Levinauss in terms of his notion of desire and the idea that his work sort of hints toward how could we be imagining other ways of being that go beyond a sort of set, closed, totalized social structure. And the interesting thing is that Levinauss uses the notion of face. Now, Levinauss was not in any way aligned with politeness theory or notions of face that I know of, et cetera.
And the idea of there's things that came out of different philosophical backgrounds. But let's explore how he describes the notion of face. And what he says is if you look at the world from the perspective of just you and your ego and you come into contact with another person, there's sort of two things that can happen. One is you treat the other person in terms of your own kind of closed social world and you see that other person as kind of like just an extension of yourself.
So if you've got a particular way of understanding social structure, then you will recognize this other person as part of your social structure. And so if my social structure is one in which I believe that the refugees should be welcomed into my state and that if Kathy has a different perspective, then I see her in relation to my perspective. I'm not seeing her as someone who's offering anything new. I already know who she is.
She's that woman who's got that stupid idea, right? The same with that Kathy. She's doing the same thing with her knees. What Lettinger says is if you actually recognize the other as truly other, meaning not part of your idea of what the social world is, if you see the truly the other as being exterior to your way of seeing things, then you're coming into contact with infinity, meaning something beyond your finite system, your finite understandings.
And then he says, okay, you're under the requirement, the obligation thou shalt not kill. You're not supposed to kill that other, right? And so he says, that doesn't mean that you can't be in a power dynamic with that other individual, but let's see how it works. Here's the way Levinaus describes this kind of encounter.
The other, he writes, is exposed to all my powers, succumbs to all my rooses, all my crimes, or he resists me with all his force and all the unpredictable resources of his own freedom. I measure myself against him. So here is the one, the ego, you know, living in this kind of closed system. And along comes this other person.
And the other person could succumb to my sense of power and rightness, but the other might also resist me. And then I see the relationship between us in terms of, you know, who's going to win. And then this is what Levinaus says next, but he can also, and here is where he presents me his face. He can also oppose himself to me beyond all measure with the total uncoveredness and nakedness of his defenseless eyes, the straightforwardness, the absolute frankness of his gaze.
He can also present me his face that is opposed himself to me beyond all measure. So it's like, okay, if he comes to me and I'm not going to recognize that he's outside of my way of thinking, and I'm just going to see him as an opponent. Okay, well, that's kind of just him being a kind of shadow version of me, right? But if he actually, if I actually encounter him and see him how incredibly other, how exterior to my way of seeing things, this person is, then I'm seeing his face.
And in this face is this complete nakedness, this complete newness, this like access to infinity and access beyond the sort of finitude, the finite, closed social world that I'm in. And so I love Levinaus' notion of face, but I'm thinking to myself, do we still need to be thinking in terms of the individual encountering another individual? And what if instead, if when I'm presenting my ideas, when I'm presenting my view, when I'm expressing myself, I'm actually presenting the manifestation of a social structure? And then when I encounter something that seems to threaten that, then we have the encounter, the two faces of two social structures.
And at that point, one or two things can happen. One manifestation of social structure could win out, the other one could win out, we could have somebody come in, hit a button and we can just ignore it for a while and we can listen to a bell. Or the potential element there is that we might have a glimpse into a different way of understanding social structure, a different way than the two versions that come in contact with each other. And so the idea is that if social structure can have a face, and if for Levinaus the face is the doorway to a different way of understanding things, then when two social structures come in contact through the face of individuals, then there's the potential for new way of seeing things.
So some pretty heavy ideas. I thought I would put them out there. Happy Thanksgiving, happy holidays, thank you for listening.