Skip to content
Episode 206 - We Love Lisa episode artwork

Nov 24, 2022 34 min

Episode 206 - We Love Lisa

from Sitcom Geeks Hosted by Comedy.co.uk

Part 2 of our wide-ranging chat with top comedy drama writer Lisa Holdsworth (Call The Midwife, New Tricks, All Creatures Great And Small) with advice to new writers, the joys and perils of show running and the importance of the Writers' Guild, which she currently chairs.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 206 - We Love Lisa

0:00 34:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to Sick Combe Geeks. I'm James Carey and we've got more of our conversation with Screenwriter Lisa Holsworth coming up. She started out life writing Emma Dale before episodes of Call the Midwife, Nutrix, All Creatures Great and Small, Beckend and she's done all that whilst also being chair of the Writers Guild of Great Britain and we talk a bit about that too. If you've not heard part one of this chat, I urge you to go back and listen to that.

That's our previous episode and part two of the conversation is coming up in a moment but before that I just wanted to remind you of a couple of things. The first is that the second edition of the Complete Comedy Writer by Dave Cohen is out now. Go and look for that on Amazon. That's probably the best place to start and you will find a book brimming and bristling with good advice, hacks and helpful hints to get you going and keep you going as a comedy writer.

And if you're feeling like something more like an intervention, then I'm running a 90-minute pay-what-you-like webinar on Zoom on how to make 2023 go better than 2022 in terms of your writing career. My plan is to help you reframe the whole thing so it's not this impossible burden or total piketering. It seems like it can be in our darker moments and I've had plenty of those myself so I'll be talking about how I dug myself out of the latest hole I was in. That's on Friday the 9th of December.

Go to my blog to find out more. Sitcomgeek.blogspot.com. And you'll find a link plus loads of advice there on that blog. So that's that.

Let's get back to our conversation with Lisa Holtoin. And we've just been talking about Emmerdale. I know James has written some longer script time as well but I mean the kind of leap from the half hour to the hour or so it's three episodes. That must bring more kind of complications from a writing point of view.

You suddenly realise that particularly I graduated onto BBC House coming to New Tricks. Anybody doesn't remember that was about UCOS and I can't remember what the acronym stands for but it was far old pharmacopers who'd set up for any of it investigating cold cases but it had a very comedy through line with it. So when I was at Jamesville and Alan Armstrong and Dennis Waterman with the old cops and Amanda Redmond was their boss. What a cast.

I mean James Bolum alone is an absolute national treasure. But throwing Alan Armstrong down his water in a round of red men is just like blimey. What else are you not firing blanks for that lot are you? No.

Do you know what? Because the show we occasionally make the expat in the ratings and it used to be so I think very mainstream and very clear in that you want it to be an entertaining show. You should drive as much as the BBC did big as a whole. I'd drive a couple of times the then head of throughout that same speaker, things that it's saying about what showing is proud of and then I'd just have new tricks.

I used to wear bad people. I used to wear bad people. I used to wear a dramaturge. The car should be proud of it.

But yeah, so it was quite an adjustment but actually the story planning skills that I've learned so so many good stuff because obviously you are running your big, it's because a place show you're in your big investigation so that gives you a natural structure. Why are we looking to this case? Why do we care? What's what we're going to find out along the way?

Setting up your red herrings and then paying it off justice is brought out. But then running under that is you're picking up continuing stories for your regular so there's a big story about James Wells. Why should you be killed and the crockett killed that we ran across the series? Dennis Waterman's character had a couple of ex-wives and a couple of ex-wives and some daughters and they bring family funding to it.

Amanda Redmond would do romance stories with the genetic problem about it. The show is the mom and Alan Armstrong, his wife who's actually James Bullen's wife played it, played his wife. He had a history of mental health problems and it was about their relationship that we negotiate their relationship after every time. There was actually thinking back to it a lot of the time but you run it as your biggest and then you put your other stuff in amongst it.

It was a rule on the show that we only ever saw things from the POV of our far regulars. You met a really strong little guy mid-summer festival that you have people having those half-composition well, those that thing happened. It was never happened again. So you know, just to make people suspicious we weren't allowed to do that on new trips.

I loved it and I used to and it was a show that used a picture investigation. So again, so many good stuff that had been a lot of pitching around the table over those three years. What if they saw that? So I used to go and see Tom and pitch three ideas for what the investigation would be.

One that really worked out, one that had done a bit of work on it, one that thought of the train and other way that loved it. And he always commissioned the one that thought about the train and developed it. It was like it in. Yeah, amazing isn't it?

Yeah, I know I've had that sort of thing as well. I think there's something about that. I think there's something about the fresh enthusiasm that you've been because you're sort of thinking about it as you're talking about it and you're skilled enough. You've got the hard work that you put into the other ones isn't going to pay off for those ones specifically, but it's going to get your brain ticking over so that when you have to think of a new one, it's like, oh yeah, and then this and then they say something and you say, yeah, that's right.

And then this. And so that's kind of, I was sort of thinking about that. Why is it always the Kevin Turvey as in fact? The last idea that Rick Mail pitched before, you know, on the way out and loads of other things.

It was just like, I literally thought of this character on the end of the meeting, Kevin Turvey and it's like, you know, in a way, I guess, I guess that's partly because that's that's so much more you than you think it is as that idea. And so that first idea is probably overworked. And it's your version of the idea you think they're looking for. Absolutely.

It just feels a bit, it just feels a bit like more of the same. And maybe the reason they've hired you is because you're coming with a different angle and a different take. And so that second one's kind of getting there. And then the third one's just like, ah, yeah, that's the kind of thing we were hoping you come up with.

And then two things that rise when you rise there, one is go going with the one idea. No, because I know it doesn't like that. There's a very awkward cup of coffee and everything. So are you counting it's gas for zooming to?

And two is develop the ability to think on your feet. And again, I think probably the reason it's the third, the last idea that got pushed is the picture would be incredibly sharp. And I think that's about a catcher and a pet to the pet shop sort of thing. And that would be the one that start asking questions and all, I think that is the best way to develop any story is if you can find something like, well, why do they do that?

And what's the result of that? And et cetera, et cetera. Now, you can either take some people full, they know themselves with this data, they ask, what do I think about it? Or you can be bold and know that actually everything's up for grabs and nothing that you're saying that room is saying so.

And they'll always consider this and because of that and develop it in the room. And I think Tom Trevus and Clever enough producers to know that if he kept asking me questions, I get there. I mean, what I'm learning from this conversation, and it's just reinforcing this thing, and what sitcom writers can learn from all these other genres is how the scene is pretty much written before you've even started it. There's very little about a scene in a drama or a soap that wasn't already determined some weeks ago because you've already got the characters, you've already got the story, you've already got the big story arc from this season or whatever.

And so by the time you're actually writing the scene, it doesn't write itself. Don't let anyone say that because I've had to sit there and have someone say to me, it writes itself. And I've not found that Microsoft wizard that just does it. No, come up and go, I'll do this.

Yes, exactly. Yeah, yeah, no, we're not quite there with, um, optimization and, um, and AI. But equally, I think maybe comedy writers focus an awful lot on being funny, characters being funny, saying funny things. And each scene is under pressure to be funny because, and in a way, it becomes an obsession because the scene isn't, doesn't really earned its existence.

So it's, it's, it's, so lots of, lots of scripts that we read are quite slow to get going. So the first 10 pages, it's a bit slow. And then you do get something, something important happens. And then it slightly dribbles away at the end.

And you just, and you think there wasn't really enough story here. Um, and actually what we're discovering is that actually a lot of characters are quite funny are perfectly promising if they're given a chance. But there's, there's just not enough planning in the story. And it turns out that story planning is way harder than most people think it is, including us because we've been giving lots of advice on this stuff and rather assuming people would figure out actually they don't.

I mean, you must have read scripts like this, Lisa, have you, you know, we just think, I think the next story here, it's also very round that I don't give the note. You know, you could start this five pages later. So why don't you, this is, it's, I mean, it just gets to the really exciting bit that explain what was going on. Why I'm watching this?

Why don't you start there? And really good writers go, oh yeah, I'm still to this day. I think sometimes you have to write long and I, and someone will say to me, why don't you start a page too? And again, yes, yes, I was going to, I was thinking that.

I was thinking that. Yeah, yeah. Because sometimes you were writing lots of detail and backstory and for your own logical bread to go, this is how we got there. What your audience doesn't care, just have the bet.

Okay, we're in this world. Let's go for it. So yeah, getting late and come out early is a cliche. It's true.

And yes, and really interrogate your story. Why are they doing this? What's the outcome? Do they need a long time of the soul?

Do we need to see them looking at the blessed case on the table or staring, staring out, you know, across the place of Dover or whatever it is, just to give us a moment of breath before we get really into the less active, the full doing one of it. So yeah, don't look away from it because you cannot fix it while you're writing it. And that's what I think a lot of writers do, which is, oh, it's one to start writing things will come to it. And actually, you've got to put the hard yards in on that horrible, crappy document.

No script writer likes writing prose. No one likes writing seagrades. Everybody has a single writer. I just have to say, I love this bit.

No one's saying that because the best words to write that, this script got scripts. It's the equivalent of saying, here's this joke, right? And it's really funny because what's going to happen is this man's going to fall over because it's been larmacy on the book. And it's really funny.

You know, it's like, it's all that tell, tell, not showing thing. One of the reasons we got to chat to you at this point is because a BBC writers room are opening their annual window opening. They're calling out for comedy. I'm sure they open their windows more often than that.

Sure, it gets quite close in there. It's probably not worth it. That's right. Yeah.

Well, this isn't even I mean, this is BBC writers room, which is, you know, I mean, BBC radio comedy is like the tiny is the broom cupboard and the writers room is like the second you know, it really is a tiny thing, but they do fantastic. You know, they they they encourage a lot of new writers, but the window is open until December the 7th, I think, for comedy drama scripts. And this is one of those things that, you know, we talked about a lot and I know I've talked to you about it, Lisa, as well, over the years about, you know, what do we mean by comedy drama? And it is I've still I've spent ages, I've written loads of stuff about it.

And I'm still not sure what the answer is. But how would you define comedy drama? It is a slippery little circle. Obviously the cliche is a strum.

It's drama that's not very dramatic, or it's comedy that's not very funny. And I don't think that's true. I actually think it's probably something where the again, the emotional stakes are high. You care about those characters and when comedy, you know, when Basil is beating his many with a branch, you know, character cows getting scratched up whether he's going to lose the money or the rest of it.

It's very funny. Whereas in a comedy drama, you will know that if that hotel fails, his marriage will break up, talk about footsteps, etc, etc. And it will mean something. So I would say the differences in a sitcom, you know, that civil and basil should never ever be together in the first place.

It's quite glad if they broke up in a comedy drama like care about Mr. Company, you hope they solve their problems or basil in over someone else and you hope that you're able to save them for their art factories. So it is getting put in some reality to some real emotional stakes for me. That's what a good comedy drama is.

But what you also are creating, and you know what? I always think this is very a real northern argument and the death of those comedy dramas from the north, they'll come back and if it comes back again. People say it's funny, exactly. Same funny things to each other because they're naturally funny and that's how you tell someone you love them is to be funny with them.

I tell this and I still can't believe this happens. I wrote a pilot for a major broadcast. And he was setting the mouth in his back group of older women who have been friends with a lot of gymnastics, but they've known each other for years. I have them talking to each other in for one of them, where it's a horrible word, so they were taking the mick out of each other, calling each of the names, highlighting each of those faults because that's how my non-talks were friends, how I talked to my friends.

The more you love someone, the more you call them out, the more you insult them. So it went to the commissioners who were very London's very little class and the note came back, we don't understand why this has been really such a bit at home. And it was a first, it was a little bit like, you're lucky, you're lucky. Then I realized it was because these women were talking like people due to each other.

It was such an extraordinary eye-opening moment and I do wonder if that's why comedy drama disappeared from our office. There were lots of very, very cut glass accents at the top of the commissioning trip, we're missing that stuff. And people would establish themselves, having that sort of style of camera, I think it's the perfect example. I want to say, it's been a massive influence on it.

I would say, Victoria will do the other one, you watch that and they are taking the pics out of each other through the entire show and it's glorious, funny, warm, taskmaster, I'd say, they're talking about how they speak to each other, the competition that they've taken, all the rest of it's done with such warmth and love and that feels like it's missing a bit from comedy drama at the bottom. It's going to come back because I don't, I'm Barna Velfs, I'm Barna Cereal Killers, I love my genre stuff as much as an exposive but I want a bit of humanity now and adults think we've ever needed it more. Yeah, bring back the body back affair. Oh, yeah.

Don't bring box apparently. Oh, is it? Okay. Yeah, yeah.

I mean, these people that I grew up with, perhaps absolute heroes were people like Alan Playter and Colin Welland and the idea, and again, this was the regional ITV model, was it was just not so compartmentalised. So here are writers who can write comedy and they can write drama as well. And Alan Playter did the fantastic series with Les and Orson, I remember, which was really, you know, kind of a lot of paythals but very funny as well as you might imagine. And there is also that thing which hopefully I've been sort of hoping that the people's playing, we want more comedy drama, might kind of bring back some of that kind of, well, it doesn't have to just be a sitcom, it doesn't just have to be the line of duty, whatever.

It can be, can we bring the sort of light and show, I don't think you said to me about how you've never been to a funeral that didn't end with people laughing and be the wedding that ends in a fight and stuff. I think it's a funeral that ended in Hogwarts to about, I was a Billy Connolly line, I don't think it's his line, but he says that a glass go funeral is more fun than an Edinburgh wedding, which is a fantastic part. But I think there is that, that's, that maybe that's what you need to find comedy drama really, isn't it? There's been a problem in the dramedy part as well, so obviously your experience in the comedy about Mike's experience, the drama way, when you pitch something where the stakes are people's emotions, people's lives, that kind of thing, it doesn't take, well, we love this world, doesn't take a while before someone says, but we need an investigation, they've been starting to have the dead body, basically what they're saying.

And I, for a long time, gave up fiction things that were romantic comedies or family sagas or things like that, because people would like them and then go, can we put murder in it? And the frustration, it just brought my heart every time I care about these characters, but what you want, what one of them to skip that they are, make the obit same? Yeah, and I think that comes from a lack of comedy, sorry, lack of confidence in the characters and in the story. And it's interesting that a show that does seem to have more what you're talking about, I would say, which I've not seen is normal people by Sally Rooney.

Yeah. Why does that show exist? Because it was a novel. So it's already established.

No, no, people like this. This is fine. This doesn't need an investigation or whatever it is. I don't think I've completely misread what that show is, I mean, not read it, but I just got the sense of it's called normal people.

And so if you pitch to show that it's just about people in their lives. Okay. I mean, I love that a Brinster journal down, it's a teenager amounts. And one of my most retweeted tweets was I said, if you just a bit of advice, you just watch normal people, don't look for your college sweetheart on Facebook, because that's what it's about.

Who you're finding love with the first time and how it reached out, and then you go to separate this. And it's God, he's a gorgeous bit of television. But yeah, that's those watch words that come into TV commissioning like, what's the story engine? So what we say in every week?

So an investigation of medical stuff, all that, I think he's a really good story engine. People love investigations. People love medical drama. And I thought me on the same, just the scale to say, but I would say that that fear of what happens, what happens next, what happens next, what happens next, is not believing in the writer that I don't know, what's what exciting's been happening.

I think so much because you know what, Emmer does be running 50 years and they've done an out story. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

It's fine. We're just doing six and eight. So it's gonna be okay. And then we'll do it six and then we'll do it six.

And then we'll do it six. But I guess the caveat to that is so people thinking about sending an accommodate drama to the BBC writers room, there's a temptation to just fall in love with the characters and the dialogue and have and have simply people talking for 28 pages or and it's like, no, they need to be talking about something and they need to have hopes and fears about concrete things and you do need that story. So I think, yeah, there's that wistfulness is like that, that's a show isn't wistfulness on its own, is it? So for 10 years, I've judged student grammar films.

I'll judge them for the RTS in Yorkshire. And for 10 years, I have seen a lot of films about leaving in the student house and the funny stuff that happens there. And if there are any students who are writing that, it's not funny to think, sorry to be good or fresh mate, please don't do it again. Because it is just, hey, we sit around and drink vodka and a flax mexie, we're angry over who others are.

Oh, oh, yeah. So yeah, you do need to give your character central and this is John Yox exercises on the BBC writers room website. It's a really useful thing when you're kicking off a project, 10 questions to ask for it to start, which is who's starry is it? What do they want?

What do they need? And they should be two different things. What I think you want is the girl. What they need to do is get over it and see the beautiful girl in the next room.

All those kind of things. And he doesn't mention comedy at all in his book into the woods, but I would recommend every comedy writer read into the woods because it's the overlap, I think, in comedy and drama is that every episode has to have a story and the story has to have a beginning and a middle and then and, you know, there has to be some drama in there. So it is and that book into the woods, I think is a great, it's a really good way to learn about telling stories. And although I said it's about drama, you can apply most of it to comedy.

Yeah, not least because I mean, we read hundreds of scripts a year ago for our hat trick competition. And I'm trying to think of the number of scripts where we could have said, there's too much drama in this, as in there's too much happening that there may have been two out of several hundred. Not funny enough is obviously a problem, but actually you can sort of make most things funnier, but it's stuff happening that characters care about, you know, and what emotionally invested stuff, isn't it? Yeah, I mean, and that for me sitting down and watching TV, the difference between, I've just rinsed through the bust of the sun and the devil himself in a weekend, I was like, this is good.

Am I equals? Not a fish. I'm not serious. And it's a dish because I cared about everything.

Even the good, even the good, it's and about it's in that show. Everybody has very clear goals and reasons why we do things. Good people did bad things for good reasons, bad people did good things for bad reasons. And our reputation in amongst that's the difference between two episodes into this very, very expensive elf drama.

Yeah, we're not giving a monkey about who do I care about? Who's going to fall in wealth? Who do I hear? Oh, they're all sailing to the Western a thousand years time.

It's yeah. We should we should probably wrap things up there. We've already taken a lot of your time. I just want one thing I did want to mention, I mentioned at the start that you've been the chair of the writer's guild for the last six years.

I mean, it's been a torrid time really for writers with Covid and cuts and everything else. But you have steered the ship. And I mean, membership has increased and lots of other things. But just really interested to to hear your thoughts about the kind of changes that you've seen that have taken place for writers writing out and professional writers since you since you became chair of that.

I was deputy chair for this. This is my last year. We do a four year term at this chair. So I have to do the best work at what year I got voted.

So before I read it, the words Covid, I got voted as chair. And then Covid came out and that seemed like such an existential threat to almost every area of writing in the holidays. I mean, the soap slows down, which is, I mean, that's like the raven's link of the tower. And a significant effect on those writers.

We're pretty used to a regular income no more. That was very upsetting, very disturbing. And when I talk about this, I was talking about Holby, casually, obviously Holby cancelled since then and casualty was like, you might be major. I hope it's not.

Theta, live comedy performance, et cetera. What on the positive side, the adaptability of our industry is extraordinary. The things that moved online. Comedians who found a new audience on social media doing incredibly clever satire and comedy.

I think about Larry and Paul, Michael Spicer, people like that, just extraordinary. But the reality is that the industry is tightened up and shrinking for writers and the opportunity to get in there because the projects are so enormous that the trust that is pointing to new writers is disappearing. I think it's beholden on writers who have breached the walls and are doing our right to make sure they're putting a hand back and bringing up the new writers. I'm very happy to say on my show, with Ransom, it's not easy.

It's hard to work and they have to be looked after and you have to do the job right to look after him. That's what we need to do now. And yes, we're very lucky for the writers' guild. It's a very much different organisation than when I first started as an activist and that's down to the staff who are extraordinary.

But also due to writers who engage with it on our committees, Dave used to be obviously the chair of our comedy community, did a great job there. So I'm so proud of the organisation. They're so proud of the reaction we had to COVID and this ongoing situation. And I think it's reflected in the fact that the membership has gone off.

We were braced. We were ready because it is a luxury for something quite strategic membership, but people have kept that membership going and we've looked after people who were in the struggle as well. So I would say to any member in this thing, I'm not sure about spare that they're getting touched with us. We can talk if they're doing work something out for you because we're out of the keepers and members.

But I'm taking more of that when you're out to work. Talking about an email saying your membership is up for renewal. So I need literally this afternoon, I'm going to do that. So, Andy, remind us.

Andy, very fruitful for you to do this interview, Lisa, for the point alone. Yes, indeed. One member, every member counts. Absolutely.

Yeah, yeah. So do you feel generally on a scale of one to ten optimism, pessimism? One? One?

I feel optimistic. I think we are in a period of change. For television, obviously the stream is coming over the hill like it's the Wild West and going, hey, would you like to be in a backup service for your script and we'll only forever and ever and obviously wear the front line of that. I was in Denmark a few weeks ago for an international conference of writers and nearly every country's going, they just want it all.

And every country is saying, absolutely not. You have got to make right a sustainable career because that's how we get great work. So, yeah, we are in a period of flux. We've got the people who consider themselves disrupting this for things.

But the reality is that if it was that easy to be a writer, the producers have been doing it. It's not easy. And you need the skilled geeky, annoying, windy people who are writers to do it. And so that'll never change.

But we do have to be on our gas and things like the privatization of travel for, we still don't know whether that's ongoing or whether it's being kicked into the long grass by this chaotic government. That needs to be kept on our own own. How the BBC has been treated, public service workers in general. And also making sure that you are being paid.

Do not be ashamed. So if I'm writing this for you, what I'm going to get paid. And if they say nothing, come to Guild, we'll upload with them. That's a great way.

And we need to finish this podcast. Thanks so much. Go and have a word with Lisa. Go and have a word with the Guild.

And they'll have a go. But also, but do join. Even if you're not, even if you're not represented and you've not had a professional geek, then there are ways of joining in. Yeah, because it's a bit of a collective is just when you're an individual thing, like a writer, you know, just knowing there are other people who've got your back is just a great thing.

Yeah. Great. Thanks so much, Lisa. I'm a huge fan.

I can't believe how many new tricks you've done because I've watched about 40 of those, loved it. And all we just want to thank so much for doing that and for being on our podcast. My absolute pleasure. Thanks for having me.

Now, if you want to hear us chat even more to Lisa, including a conversation about show running, which Lisa has found herself now doing, why not join us on Patreon, where you'll also be supporting us and the only podcast out there dishing out free advice on writing sitcoms. Plus, you get loads of extra audio content, early access to episodes, including next week's episode about writer's block, before we get into our Christmas episode that week after. And you also get access to our private Facebook group and Discord channel as well. So don't forget, my webinar is on the 9th of December.

Why not go to sitcomgeek.blogspot.com for more information, including how to book and have a look for Dave's complete comedy writer, which is out now. Thanks very much for listening. Speak to you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Sitcom Geeks?

This episode is 34 minutes long.

When was this Sitcom Geeks episode published?

This episode was published on November 24, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Sitcom Geeks episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.