EPISODE · Aug 7, 2026 · 42 MIN
Episode 222: The Midnight Man: Worst Houseguest Ever (An After Dark Rerun)
from C3: Crystals, Cauldrons & Cocktails
Let's Chat!! Don't knock. Don't invite him in. And whatever you do... don't let the candle go out.This week we're opening the vault and revisiting one of our favorite After Dark episodes: The Midnight Man.Is it just another internet creepypasta... or is it based on something much older? We dig into the strange history of the Midnight Man ritual, the terrifying rules of the game, why it became one of the internet's most infamous paranormal challenges, and the chilling stories from people who swear they played... and weren't alone afterward.Whether you believe it's psychological, paranormal, or just a very bad idea, one thing is certain...Some games aren't meant to be played.Support the showWe'll be back! Until then, Stay Witchy!!River's Etsy Store: www.batsandbaublesinc.etsy.comWebsite: www.c3witchypodcast.comMerch: www.c3witchypodcastmerch.comOur wonderful logo is done by: www.nellamarinadraws.etsy.comIntro and Outro Audio:podcast intro & outro music:Góða Nótt by Alexander NakaradaLink: https://filmmusic.io/song/4754-g-a-n-ttLicense: https://filmmusic.io/standard-liceSound from Zapsplat.com – Witches Cauldrons bubbling
Embed this episode
What this episode covers
Let's Chat!! Don't knock. Don't invite him in. And whatever you do... don't let the candle go out. This week we're opening the vault and revisiting one of our favorite After Dark episodes: The Midnight Man. Is it just another internet creepypasta... or is it based on something much older? We dig into the strange history of the Midnight Man ritual, the terrifying rules of the game, why it became one of the internet's most infamous paranormal challenges, and the chilling stories from peop...
NOW PLAYING
Episode 222: The Midnight Man: Worst Houseguest Ever (An After Dark Rerun)
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.