Skip to content
Episode 24 - Interview with Gill Isles episode artwork

May 19, 2016 38 min

Episode 24 - Interview with Gill Isles

from Sitcom Geeks Hosted by Comedy.co.uk

In our final episode from this year's Llandudno Craft of Comedy festival, Dave Cohen talks Baby Cow, Car Share and more with top producer Gill Isles.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 24 - Interview with Gill Isles

0:00 38:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, welcome to Sitcom Geeks. My name's Dave Cohen and normally James Kerry is with us but we're actually at the Clandered Note Craft of Comedy Conference and this is one of the first of our special Sitcom Geeks interviews and fittingly James can't be with us because he's actually doing a session about how to make podcasts. So I'm here with producer Katie, Katie Story and also joining me very pleased to have here Jill Ailes. Hello.

Jill is a producer and she's been heavily involved in car share, one of the great successes of the last year, great Sitcom successes and at the time of recording nominated for numerous baffes for Baffes. If you include the people's choice. Either way we're very excited and to have to, we'll talk about car share quite a lot but actually because of Jill's very interesting career producing comedy over the years. Would you like to just fill us in a little bit about how you got into comedy?

Well my first comedy job was on the 11 o'clock show which you were on. That's right. I was a researcher, a lonely researcher at that point and it was the last ever 11 o'clock show. I don't think that was anything to do with my researching skills.

Or my writing skills. No, no, let's better make that clear. So yes, it was my first job with Phil Clark as a producer. Who is now Head of Scric2com and the channel for?

Yes. Will Smith and Sidedelik. So that led me on to my second job as an AP with working on Sidedelik on their show with Mark and Barry. So I did various bits and pieces in London working for BBC in house on occasion.

Just as a researcher in an AP and then the BBC opened their comedy department in Manchester and I am a Northern person as you can probably tell. What did you say? No, which Northern chap went to a good school? Oh, we haven't got a chap.

We've got a lady with a Northern accent. Exactly and I did not go, well I did go to a good school but not a good school in the terms that you're talking about. I went to a very character building school in Castleford. Oh yeah, I'm a lead school.

Oh well there we go. There we go. So as you'll know, Castleford with its chemical works and its mining industry. And quite dirty rugby league team as far as I can.

Yes. I use to watch Follalloo's rugby league. This is completely going to the point. This is kind of a point.

Yes, last time, last podcast or two, we had Mark Evans and James discussing the cricket team and now he's doing the night discussing Northern rugby league. Absolutely. This is what it's about. This is what it should be about.

So I moved back up north to Manchester and I used to come in and offer an AP and talent kind of manager, producer, which meant me going out to comedy clubs and just finding new people that were out there and bringing them into the BBC and developing scripts with them. And I was really lucky at the time, being the people that were coming through at that time where people like Jason Manford and John Bishop and Sarah Milliken, Alan Carr was still doing the circuit in Manchester when I first moved up there. So there was a real raft of people who were brilliant and you could see from a mile away that they were going to be great. And yes, I did that for a little while and then they were looking for a producer to produce a pilot which was a hybrid entertainment comedy pilot with Rufus Hound and Tom Price called The Flat.

It was never meant to be broadcast but it was, I think they were both presenting on BBC Choice at that time and so we got a writer to write. A sitcom flat share that wasn't a sitcom. Was that the idea? I don't know.

It was kind of very much, we were hoping it was very much in the vein of the yawns. It was really good but it was a pilot we were trying to experiment a little bit with the genre and it was great but it just didn't get picked up like so many pilots. It was really cheap to make and Rufus and Tom were brilliant in it but it was one of those things. This conversation, we've been having a few of these conversations already at the conference where people automatically assume if you've worked on, if you're lucky enough to have worked on a successful show.

And they think, oh, so you must only ever work on successful shows and you remember with a bit of tears of pain and frustration and all those favourite ideas that you had and that they kind of, if you're lucky, you'll get a pilot and then nothing comes up. There's a lot of stuff. Yeah, yeah, it's true. It was great for me because it was the first thing I'd ever produced and it was a really small team of us and from a producer point of view, you're learning your craft as well as everybody else on the team.

So it was great to be in that kind of environment where it wasn't ever going to be a broadcast pilot that you think, okay, we can take a few chances and I can make mistakes and learn how this process works because until someone gives you the job as being the producer of a show, you can never explain that feeling of when it's all going wrong and everybody just turns to you and goes, right, what do we do? And that first time I had finished, I was like, oh my God, what do we do? So yeah. So that's, I mean, it's interesting to talk about being a producer.

We've had them build air on the show before he basically, he is a writer who produces, you very much myself a producer, what does that mean in the sort of day to day, the all day to day existence? Yeah, well, I am very much a producer who produces, I know I'm not a writer, I know I'm not a director and I think a producer's job is really, it's really important and I know I'm not saying that obviously, but I think you always need that person. So basically everybody always asks me what does a producer do and that's a really good question. We thought we'd have to click the seagull sound there, so we're actually in a studio in London.

We're not really in a clandered note also. Turn the seagulls off. So yeah, so my job, I kind of see it as the person that pulls everything together. So how we usually start is it starts with a script and a writer, all writers, and then I will get attached to a project and then it's my job to build that team around the project to make it happen really.

So I'll work closely with the writer and I've recently done the per share so working with BTK who writes and directs and is in it. But I've also just done a short with Goss Khan who is a brand new first thing that he's done writer and so I kind of bring skills to a project depending on the level of project that it is. So with BTK for example, I don't obviously do script notes or anything like that. We talk about stuff and talk about scripts and there's something that I can contribute in terms of is that working well or whatever.

Then I will but someone like Goss who's brand new, then I'll get more involved in the scripts and give script notes. But I'm very working with BTK was a brilliant training ground for me I think because they are so talent-centered that everything, every decision, every final decision has to come from the writer or writer performer. And that is right. So that's absolutely right.

I completely adhere to that. Bob Cow used to be the only one of the big independent comedy companies that took unsolicited scripts and I don't think they do that now. What would you say? We'll talk about Karsher in a minute but because you mentioned BTK, what would you say to the writer with the new writer with the script?

What are they supposed to do? That's a really good question and that when we were taking scripts at BTK, you just get overwhelmed because there are so few people and companies doing it that you just get completely swamped by scripts and there was one person whose job it was just to read scripts. I can kind of say that when I was at the BBC, a comedy-nought reading script and inviting people to send things in, I don't think we ever got anything that ever got made from an unsolicited script. I think the only, I'm sure probably wrong about this, but the biggest, greatest example and case in point was Comte Fite that came in as a spec script and got picked up but it happened really, frequently.

The best thing when I was taking in new scripts and reading new scripts was that you get to meet a writer or if you like something in the script, then you get to meet them and then you get introduced to them. I think for new writers, getting a producer or someone from a production company interested in your work in the first instance is the best thing that you can do because I think if you're a new writer, unless you're a genius, write your first script, send it to a production company and then get it made. As I'm saying this, I'm just thinking that that did happen with Jason Cook and Heaven. But Jason was established as a stand up at that point.

Yeah, absolutely, absolutely. I suppose, and James and I do often say on the podcast, we're teaching that your sitcom script is almost certainly not going to get made but it will be, if it's a very good script, it will be a calling card. Did you ever find the writer, you didn't necessarily make their sitcom but you'd find a writer who you thought, oh I'd like to meet this writer and work with them. Yeah, there were several writers that in Manchester, in the Manchester and in the Midwest, that I met, I don't remember any names at this point.

What would you suggest people do then, if given that baby cow doesn't, is that how option is not available? No, no. So the thing I was supposed to mind is just the writer's room, the BBC writer's room. No, I mean, do you have experience dealing with the writer's room?

I don't say it on the BBC writer's room but I don't really know. In terms of knowing that people have written to BBC writer's room and that they do get the, they have to respond. Yeah. And that's something that I've had, I don't have personal experience with it, sending a script there.

But yeah, I mean that's generally the BBC or for radio scripts as well, that's nearly always the BBC has to be the kind of main core. And you have to say as well that I think it is very, very rare, even for established writers to write brilliant scripts, the first draft of a script that you see often you don't necessarily know if that's going to work or not. But if I could actually just move on to car, anyway, because I think that's what you're saying about your job, it starts with, it always starts with a script. But I presume with the car gen, having seen the talk you gave last night, very much it started, it started began and ended with Peter Kay is interested in making this programme and that's kind of enough, isn't it, really, for a commissioner to say.

So you kind of didn't really start, you've started with Peter Kay, didn't you? Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then how did the scripts kind of evolve? Yeah, so the Paul Coleman started, he came up with the idea and he started writing it with Tim Reed, they worked together quite a lot.

And they took the script, six episodes to Peter, and both because Paul's a friend of his and he really loved it and wanted to make it. So I really went, this is what really unusual, it's not the usual way but I think the thing that's really good to know about this process is that if as a writer you know someone that has kind of leads in the industry or talents that will open doors then it's a really good thing to introduce yourself to them and try and make that relationship work. I think it's a good thing. And obviously Peter is just incredible, he took that script and he was the one that suggested a charm, Gibson to be his co-star in it.

And they both took the scripts and improvised around it and just made it into the show that you see on the screen. Which is interesting, again this is a development and we've talked about this before, how it's been written and now with the rise of the writer-performer you do have much more of an element of scripts being written, semi-inprovised, presumably at the end of the year you had a script and they learnt the scripts. Yeah, yeah, there was a script that when we were driving up and down the A6 there were scripts that they had and knew and did the words. And then we do another up and down the A6 improvising as well.

So we always had the script but we always made time in this schedule to see if we could have any added extras that would, you know, and that works because of Peter and Charles relationship. And you know, when Peter and writer challenged it to be in it, he knew that that would work because of that naturalness that they have between them and that natural ease that they have that I think comes across on screen is very much based on their friendship. So I think a lot of people kind of think that improvising is the easy way to be funny because your friends think you're funny, just in the book or whatever. But I really think, you know, if you're going to improvise then you have to be really, really good at my Peter and Shana.

How much did much of the improvisation find its way in? Yeah, a lot of it did. I'd say, yeah, I'd say maybe 20, 30% of each episode is improvised. Have you saw the show dedicated to that?

Yeah, but it was like within a structure. So you know what you've got to get out of the scene. Absolutely. Yeah, yeah, I'm off the rails.

No, and we always, as I said, we always had the script. So at the end of the day, we always knew that we had 29 minutes of fully stuff and then any improvisation would always be bonus to that. And then it's kind of what works in the edit. And again, that's another amazing skill that Peter has to build the show in the edit.

One thing actually that I was interested in, and comedian Simon Evans last night, he was talking, he said, oh, great thing about it. He said it doesn't really feel like a sitcom. And you in the panel, Paul the writer and Shana agreed that he didn't think it was a sitcom. But for me, the central, one of the sort of central things about it, it's a sort of will they won't they, classic will they won't they romance it.

And Peter's character is very much, you know, a classic sitcom character who you sort of really know deep down would like to go out with this woman. And the six episodes, the whole thing is that's the kind of underlying thing. And when you talked about it, you said that was not really the idea, wasn't there at all at the start. And so there was always the sense of they will they won't they.

So it was always there. But how that transferred to the screen, I think in our minds it was always there and always there in the scripts. But the way that it came through in the performance is just, and the way that everybody has really, I think that's what people love about it. I think that not just they will they won't they, but the way that that is played out on screen, I think you have a real love for those characters.

And you really, because it's really delicately done, it's not kind of forced down your throat and it's not just about that. So I don't know if I suppose if the car share was meant to be like that at the beginning of the idea, then maybe it wouldn't have been so delicately woven through the episodes. One other thing I was interested in came up last night, Paul Coleman said that he sort of came up with the idea. One of the reasons to come up with it was this idea of how, because it's so expensive to make comedy.

How do you make something cheap when you set it in one place? And so it's the set comp, set it in a car. I mean is that, I guess it became quite expensive in the end when both of the cameras in the car and everything as well. But for a new writer starting out, do you think that kind of something people should be thinking about?

Yeah, I think so. I think it's whatever makes your script more saleable really. And I think so if you read the script and think this is going to be really expensive, then that's kind of one mark against it in the room to get something commissioned. You kind of think, well, it would be an expensive anyway.

So to have a photo of a commission to take a risk on something that they know is a risky business. And so if there's many more money, then they're less likely to take the risk. Especially on a new writer that it's, you know, taking risks and trust are the key things really for a new script. And I guess that's how the commission's kind of look at it, is how funny is it?

And because obviously everybody wants hits and as we know, it's not easy to write a hit. Or to know you've got one. Well, absolutely. Yeah, I mean, that's, because everybody says that they're always looking for the new hit and everybody's also saying we need audience, we need audience.

And that was another interesting thing last night, watching an episode of Car Share with an audience. Yes. And being, it was like being in a studio audience. And I guess if not really done much generally, you're not doing studio.

No. I'd love to do more studio stuff. I did, I produced in with the flims. Oh, yes, yes.

For the BBC one. And I really, really enjoyed that experience. It's completely different. It's not completely different.

But you know, you have the same kind of building the team around, but it's a different team. You know, a different team of people with different skills. I would love to do more audiences as it comes. They don't seem to kind of come along.

And I think they're kind of directors and producers that specialize in that kind of thing. But they're even more expensive, aren't they? So they're even more risk. Yeah.

And people, again, when people don't like it, more in peace, they just say, oh, more in peace. But if they don't like it, then the flims. They're really good. Yeah.

It's really, really hard to, everything, when you're making a comedy, everything has to hit. Every part of the process has to hit. Otherwise, it's just kind of lame. Or it doesn't work or people think, like that.

And that's from the casting to the direction, to the locations, to the editing. You know, every process has to be grounded. What are you looking for when you read a new script? It's funny.

And it feels original. I know that's really cliche. You ask anybody here to tell you what they're looking for. That's what they'll say.

And you ask any commissioner, and that's what they'll say. But it's true. In the first instance, it has to make you laugh. And it has to feel like, because there's two heads of when I'm reading, and I have two heads on.

So when I first read something, I just read it. And I know how kind of instinctive does it make me laugh. And then if it does, then you can read it again with your producer head on, thinking, okay, well, how comfortable is this? How, you know, the channel's looking for this kind of thing at the moment.

Is it too derivative of something else? Is the writer experienced? You know, what level are they at? And so all the production questions are raised.

So it's, yeah, the first thing is, is it funny? And you give a script to 10 different producers, and however many will find it funny or not funny or so. I think it's important to find someone who kind of gets you as a writer from a producer in producers' terms. But, you know, I think that's what I was saying before about the producer being the role of being quite underrated in the whole process, because it's such an important relationship between the director, producer, and writer.

And I think those three key people have to have the same vision for Project. Otherwise it's an on-starter, really. And I think the producer is the person that has to not bring their own ego to it. I don't mean ego in a bad way, but I just mean the producer should be supporting the vision of it and not be trying to influence by putting their own jokes in or, you know, or steering it in a creative way necessarily.

That's what the project means, if not, it's not exactly. So you would, again, build, basically describe two types of producers, which is the creative producer and the producer who's very good at reading contracts and helping save people. Yeah, actually, I don't really know. No, because I think there's somewhere in between, because, you know, I as a producer have things to add to a project.

But that doesn't mean that I'm going to sit there with the writers and think that I can write a script because I can't. But what hopefully I can do is focus the writers into thinking, asking the question, can this be funny yet? That's not me writing, but that's me not just reading contracts, do you know what I mean? So there's definitely some way in between that's...

That's outside that isn't it? Yeah, isn't it? Absolutely. Yeah, and it's that thing of, you know, there's so much more to...

This is where some writer producers, they're only interested in the script, and I'm not counting build out as this kind of person at all, but I've worked with producers, the script is all that's important. And in terms of the teletons, the script is the most important thing, but everything else around it has to be important as well. And I think it's a producer's job to see that. So everything around it feeds into the script and makes the script work the best it can.

But all those things have to work as well and have equal attention paid to them. And you know, so if they're writing the script, I've got one eye on that, but also I've got one eye on casting, one eye on what the channel wants. That's three eyes already. Exactly, exactly.

And that's just a fraction of the eyes on anything. But that's one of my's really important to have. And my philosophy is just whatever decision I'm making, it has to be, it does make the show better. So all the decisions kind of fill through that filter in my head.

Is that just that customer member make the show better? Does spending £5,000 on that joke make the show better? It has to be all of that, as well as balancing the budget and making that work, because who wants a producer who goes underground over the budget? So it's keeping, it is that person that's kind of, hopefully, getting the writer to do what they do best, which is right.

But also making sure that practically the program gets made, comes in on budget, he complies with all the standards from this channel. There has to be a person doing that. I consider that to be quite creative. So if you haven't got an understanding of the writing and the script, and how important that is and what doesn't, that's a creative head, I think from a producer.

Do you see the future more kind of being, the writer performer being more of the kind of where we're heading now? I just think it's easier for the people making the decisions about commissioning to see if something's going to work or not. Because if you, for example, with God's Khan, who I mentioned before, he's working with. You can see, he does YouTube videos, and that's where he was found by Christian Smith, who suggested him not for a project that I was doing, who's a BBC commissioner.

And you can just see that he's funny. He's a funny, funny man. And so it's easier to work with, and it's easy to see. If you start with someone who's funny, then brilliant, you know, where it is with the script.

I don't know if so many more things can go wrong. Right, yeah. And it depends who's in charge, if they can see the funny in the script, you know, as well, which is, just because a writer thinks it's funny doesn't necessarily mean that it is. And that's, I'm sorry, I'm just sorry to be chasing by now.

It was meant to be chasing. But I mean, there is, the other side of that is, on the one hand, yes, performance, I mean, especially stand-ups, you know, are very good, can play any audience. That's their sort of ability. But we do seem to have lost the kind of performer who, again, wanted to wallow in nostalgia and then there is a BBC sitcom series.

But the kind of people, the sort of Leonard Rossiter, Ronnie Barker, Ronnie Corbett, type of people, they're not, we don't see that kind of person, the person who's kind of come through theatre, I suppose, rather than stand-ups, who could be, you know, I mean, you see something like, car shed. And it is the Peter Kaysha, which is, you know, and he's a brilliant, massively successful performer. And that's a great show. And that's him being himself and something like not going out of these, obviously.

It's the Lee Mack show. But you can't, you wouldn't see Lee Mack suddenly appearing in somebody else's show as, you know, like a piece of prisons in one sitcom and shopkeeper in an up. You don't get that kind of characterisation, I suppose. It's not quite as prominent.

Yeah, I think that's fair. And I think that it's interesting what you're saying about coming through theatre because, you know, I know obviously the money back out route was using ret for years and developed. And I think that is the thing of developing your own skills. You know, like, a mock and wise spent years doing clubs and, you know, summer seasons and honing their craft and their skill.

And again, Ronnie Colbert, you know, doing nightclubs and all that. And so, I don't know, I think it's, I think stand-up, a lot of stand-ups, I know, got into stand-up to be noticed so that they could be cast in, you know, other roles. And so I primarily act as a book to stand-up because they can do it. And I'm good at it, but it gets them noticed by TV people and everything.

Oh, well, they're funny, so let's put them in a funny thing. But yeah, I think it's, TV now kind of really gobbles up people. They think, oh, right, definitely, great, let's get them in. And then if they don't necessarily work, it's like, okay, well, that didn't work.

So let's get to the next thing. And I think it is this thing of looking for hits rather than growing ideas and, you know, it's easy to see, you know, say isn't it, you know, in an ideal world that you would always try and nurture people and projects and things. That's not the way the industry works in it. I mean, one thing also, I'm just sort of looking for your TV and things, the work with Baby Cow and Car Share.

And the thing that seems to be in a lot of Baby Cow sitcoms, the ingredients, which is also there in Car Share in Spades really is a pay-thos. And that's something that's not, that was kind of neglected for quite a long time. And I just, I wonder, is some, is ever-decreasing circles? Do you have to have a degree in ever-decreasing circles to get a show on Baby Cow or is that...?

The thing about Baby Cow is really about them is that they will only make stuff that they like. So they will only invest in projects that they like. I know that sounds mad that you would not do that. But a company, you know, other companies that I know and I work for, look at, we can sell this, great, we can make money from it.

And see, say, and see, and think of it more of a business, which is absolutely fine, obviously. But Baby Cow, to have the view, and other companies do this as well, to have the view of, we want to make sure that we want to make sure that we can create this. to make we want to make shows that we really love and so it's kind of that love for a project that permeates through everything that probably has that element that they've lost. It's just really life as well isn't it, that's the thing.

It's just reflecting and that's what all good comedy should do is reflect real life and you know it's that old adage of you write about what you know and that hopefully comes across on the screen. Right okay well that seems like a suitable fitting and this is very fascinating thanks a lot. That's great and thanks Katie as well and so that was our no special. I love your accent it's like a native.

Yes I spent several hours trying to get those plans right now. I know, I know, I know, I know. So yes apologies for that, we're approximating with the microphone there but thanks very much Jill and thank you Katie so thanks very much and see you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Sitcom Geeks?

This episode is 38 minutes long.

When was this Sitcom Geeks episode published?

This episode was published on May 19, 2016.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Sitcom Geeks episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.