Skip to content
Episode 24: The Gift episode artwork

Dec 25, 2015

Episode 24: The Gift

from Structured Visions Hosted by Jodie Clark

A story of a Christmas miracle involving a pink Huffy Sweet Thunder bicycle leads to a discussion of whether Santa Claus is a social fact. According to French anthropologists Emile Durkheim and Marcel Mauss, ‘social facts’ are those forces that maintain the integrity of societies – forces that transcend the needs and desires of the … Continue reading Episode 24: The Gift

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 24: The Gift

of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, Merry Christmas! Welcome to episode 24 of Structured Visions. Structured Visions is a space where I explore new ways of thinking about social structure. My name is Jody Clark, and I'm very grateful that you're listening today.

You are very welcome here. So what I'm really hoping is that you're all listening on Christmas Day, and that you are sitting by the fire with your mulled wine with the Christmas tree, and the light sparkling on it, and everyone's all contented, and it rests, and you've already exchanged your gifts, and everybody's happy, and maybe you're still wearing your pajamas, and you've decided, that the best new Christmas ritual will be to listen to structured visions while you sip your coffee or your mulled wine or your cuffs of tea. So that's kind of what I'm imagining, so I'm hoping that you're going to hear me in that, and I recognize that not everyone has that exact same tradition on Christmas, but I really don't see why it should be part of your new December 25 ritual to listen to structured visions in the company of your friends and family. So today's Christmas episode, I would like to embark on a scientific study of Santa Claus, which I know everyone has been waiting for.

Now, I would have very much appreciated a scientific study of Santa Claus, when I was a bit younger, when I was about five years old, because if I am totally honest, when I was five, I didn't believe in Santa Claus. I just, I could recognize kind of the genre of the myth, and Santa Claus seemed to fit within the genre of the myth, rather than in the genre of sort of scientific reality, and so it didn't really seem like it could be possible that he was doing all these things that everybody said he could do, and like any myth, not all the elements were consistent across the tellers, and in my five-year-old mine, I suspect I was picking up on those inconsistencies, and it just didn't seem plausible. Now, let's think about this in scientific terms. Let's imagine my five-year-old self carrying some hypotheses.

So one hypothesis, let's say I didn't believe, let's say I'm just entertaining the hypothesis that Santa Claus didn't exist. Now, this hypothesis was a little bit problematic for me, because I really, really, really, really wanted something, and what I really, really, really, really wanted when I was five was a pink, huffy bicycle. I knew exactly the bicycle that I wanted. It had the words, sweet thunder written on the top.

It had this enormous, cushy seat, which I've since learned. I think it might be called a breadloaf seat, and it had this pink seat, and it had a sort of like, I think it was, I can't remember what color the actual bicycle was, but when I looked at it, it always sounds pink, and I really wanted this bicycle. And Christmas was coming, and you'd think, okay, well, you know, naturally, you would expect that maybe I would ask for that pink bicycle. Now, the problem is who do you ask?

Well, obviously, when you're five, the person you're supposed to ask is Santa Claus. But of course, I'm working on the hypothesis that Santa Claus doesn't exist. That isn't, however, the reason that I didn't ask him, because you can go to the mall and sit on Santa's lap and ask for something without really worrying about your belief system. However, another hypothesis that I was entertaining is that my parents couldn't afford to buy me a pink huffy bicycle.

I was under the impression that we were pretty strapped for cash, and therefore, I didn't want to ask Santa Claus for the pink huffy, sweet, thunder, beautiful bicycle that I could just see myself running. I didn't want to ask Santa Claus for them. And so we say, okay, well, why didn't I ask Santa Claus? You know, and well, think about that in a second.

Let's get straight to the miracle. Didn't ask Santa Claus, didn't mention it to anybody else. Christmas morning, wake up, and what am I wondering I was to appear, but the pink, huffy, sweet, thunder, bicycle, sitting next to the Christmas tree, it couldn't be for anybody else. I was the only girl in the house.

There it was, could not believe it. We went outside and out by school, it must have been like, who knows, minus 10, it was cold that day. We went outside and I cycled around the neighborhood in this pink huffy bicycle. It was amazing.

Now, I was entertaining two hypotheses. One that Santa Claus didn't exist, and two that my parents couldn't afford to buy me a bicycle. The question now becomes, if we're going to do this scientific study, we might imagine that the question becomes, did I revise the hypotheses? Did I suddenly start believing that Santa Claus existed?

Or did I revise the hypothesis about, you know, my parents being able to afford a bicycle? Now, that second hypothesis, if I were to revise that, turns out they could afford a bicycle, does it quite explain all of the variables? Because how did my parents know that that was the bicycle that I wanted, given that I hadn't asked anybody, including Santa Claus? Who knows?

So even if I realized that second hypothesis, maintaining the first hypothesis that Santa Claus didn't exist, there was still some unanswered questions. Now, the point I would like to make today is, at the point in which I got the pink huffy, sweet, thunder bicycle, all the hypotheses went out the window, and the only thing, the little five-year-old man could think was, bike, bike, bike, bike, bike, bike, bike, bike, bike, bike, bike, bike. And I loved that bike. Now, let's ask a different scientific question.

Let's ask a question that goes in a different direction. And the question becomes, why didn't I ask my parents? Okay, so we know that I'm saying I didn't ask my parents, because I knew they couldn't afford it. But I could have just asked them and found out whether or not they could afford it.

But I didn't. Okay, so now let's think how we might frame that question scientifically. Yeah, scientifically. Why didn't I ask my parents?

Okay, well, we could go down a whole psychological route, and explore the psychological causes, what was going on in my life, what was going on in my mind, that type of thing. But I'm not that interested in that particular question. I'm actually more interested in the sociological question. Why didn't I ask my parents?

How could we look at this from a sociological science, from a social science perspective? And the thing that I think that points to is that if I were to ask my parents, or more importantly, if I was to ask Santa Claus for a pink bicycle, then I was putting my parents, or I would have been putting my parents, under an obligation to buy that bicycle. And if they hadn't fulfilled that obligation, there would have been all sorts of trouble in the family, and all sorts of sense of, oh, we can't provide our daughter for what she wants, et cetera. It would put them under the obligation to give me what I asked for.

And so interestingly, from a sociological perspective, the notion of Santa Claus exists in terms of a particular sense of obligation from parents to children that is different from the simple obligations of going about their day-to-day life, or even getting them birthday presents. So the kid says, oh, I really want a pink bicycle for my birthday. The parent can say, can't afford it. Sorry, what else would you like?

Whereas if the kid asks Santa Claus, the parents say no, they're in a tricky situation, because they can't say, can't afford it. Because the kid says Santa Claus will bring it. And then the parent doesn't have that difficult situation where they're going to say, oh, there is no Santa Claus, and all comes down to Mom and Dad can afford it. Or what do they do then?

And I know that this is a real sociological issue, because I was talking to a friend of ours, kind of my partner's in mine, who lives nearby. He's a builder. And his daughter's apparently asked Santa Claus for some unicorn that has real fur, or something like that. And they kind of asked Santa Claus that late in November, early December, when all these unicorns are not to be had.

And their cost is going up enormously. And he's talking like these things were like 1,000 pounds, like $1,600 each. And we're like, you know, Paul, you'll never, you'll never be able to buy those. You could buy new equipment for your business before you could buy those unicorns.

And he says, yeah, I'm in a pickle. And because he's operating under an obligation. If we're studying that notion of obligation, scientifically, social scientifically, we can use the term social fact. Now, that term is something that comes from the work of some French anthropologists in the late 19th, early to mid 20th century.

And these were anthropologists who were concerned to make the study of the social world a scientific study. They didn't want the study of the social to be all about people's impressions or about people's insular morality. They wanted it to be a positivist science, something that you could look out into the world and discover what they call particular social facts. Now, the anthropologists are talking about what is called Inuldurkheim.

And they're just called Marcel Mos. Marcel Mos is about MAUSS. So again, both French anthropologists, it turns out Marcel Mos is a nephew of Inuldurkheim. And they do collaborate on a few things.

And this notion of studying society as if it were an object that you could observe in the same way that scientists of the natural world study objects in the natural world as objectively. These anthropologists were interested in the social world objectively. And Inuldurkheim had this idea that there are certain forces akin to physical forces in the physical material world. There are particular forces that actually hold society in place.

He says that people have been actually drawing upon a kind of magical thinking in terms of their understanding of society. They're acting as if society just magically holds itself together. And he said, that's not a scientific way of looking at it. He says, actually, there are forces in place.

And when you look objectively at any social structure, then you can explore how those forces operate and how they connect. And for him, the most important thing was you need to understand the social world in terms of groups, in terms of collectives, rather than in terms of isolated individuals who sort of go about their lives trying to accrue things and getting the best for the individual. He said, no, there's a social world in place. And the social world is held in place by forces that we can actually study.

And some of the earliest anthropologists, Durkheim and most weren't the only ones, obviously, but the idea for a lot of them was let's explore societies that are in their least complex forms. So if you think about sort of French society in the early 20th century, you think it's had so many influences. It's developed so much in theory as a society. It's complicated by all these different religions and all of these different economies and all of these different things.

Let's look at areas that haven't been influenced as much by external forces. So the idea was to go to indigenous societies, tribal societies. And the idea was, let's find these tribal societies that have had as little influences as possible by European influences or by Western, the influences of quote unquote Western civilization. Now, Marcel Mos was exploring some of these ideas as well.

And he wrote a book that's appropriate for our Christmas podcast. It's actually an essay, an extended essay called The Gift. And his idea was let's explore some of these indigenous societies and understand how gift giving happens because he says gift giving is a type of social fact. Now, social fact, what is a social fact?

What does most think of the social fact or does Durkheim think of the social fact? Slightly different things with the two anthropologists. But in general, the idea is a social fact is something that in a given society constrains people, transcends their individuality, constrains them, constrains them and requires them to operate in accordance with the group mentality. mentality is probably the wrong word.

But it requires them to act in certain ways that bind them to the group that they're a part of. And these social facts are the forces that keep the society in place. So Marcel Mos is looking at gift giving. And one of the things he, one of the studies that he looked at was a group of people, numerous tribes of people in the Trowbriand Islands of the Costa Papua New Guinea.

And so he's relying on a study that was conducted by Moanowski. The Polish anthropologist. And so we're in Melanesia, we're all Papua New Guinea. And we have lots and lots of different collectives, lots of different indigenous tribes.

And one of their ritual ceremonies is this elaborate rite called the Kula, K-U-L-A. And it's a kind of elaborate gift exchange. And it requires sort of the noble peoples of each of the tribes to sort of get in these ships and travel in a kind of circular route to all of the different islands in his archipelago. And so they take these sort of like epic journeys, you know, see these different islands.

And what happens in these journeys when they go from one island to another is that they exchange gifts. Now the gifts are always exactly the same. There's two gifts. One is called Mulwali, which are bracelets.

They're these beautiful bracelets. They're carved and they're polished. Sorry about that. I had to interrupt that podcast appropriately because a gift was being delivered to our door.

So to get back to the Mulwali and the Kula and the Trowbriand Islands. The Mulwali are these beautiful carved polished bracelets that they place inside these shells. They're these absolutely beautiful bracelets. And then the other type of gift is called the Suleva.

And these are necklaces. They're mother of pearl made from the sort of red mollusk. They tend to only be worn by women. And these are these bracelets and these necklaces.

The Mulwali and the Suleva are only worn on sort of high occasions on ritual occasions in this type of thing. Now, some interesting things about these gifts. It's always those that are given. When they're given, it's always in a highly ritualized act.

There's a whole set of ways in which these gifts are given. There's the blowing of a conch shell. There's a particular way in which there's a particular attitude. There's a dot.

We sort of throw the gift down at some of these feet. And there's a whole kind of elaborate display that goes on. And they also, it's also imperative that the gifts travel. So if you're the recipient of the gift, first of all, you have to accept the gift.

The gift has to be given and the gift has to be received. But you are also required to pass the gift on as part of this Kula. And so what that will mean is that once you've held onto the gift for quite some time, once you've held onto your Mulwali, you then load it up into a ship and that ship then takes it to the next island at an appropriate time and then it's given away. Now, the other interesting thing about the Mulwali and the Suleva is that they each travel in a different direction.

So the Mulwali travel from the west to the east. And the Suleva travel from the east to the west. So you give the Suleva, it goes from the east island to the west island, and then the new recipient holds onto it for a period of time before then passing it on. And then it goes to the next island to the west, et cetera.

So there's this direction of travel of these two types of gifts and they travel long, long, long distances. Other aspects of these gifts, they themselves, so you think to yourself, okay, well, what's the value of these gifts? Well, these are highly prized, valuable gifts. So you might think, okay, well, wouldn't you want to hold onto them?

Well, maybe you do want to hold onto them. But the obligation of the Kula ceremony is that they have to be passed on. So here we have this element of social fact, the force of the gift, the force of the ceremony, the force of the ritual requires that they be passed on. Another aspect of this is the recognition that the Mulwali and the Suleva themselves are imbued with characteristics and personalities.

It's like, Marcelo says, they have their own almost magic force to them. Like when you're in the presence of one of these beautiful gifts, you're appreciating it not only for its beauty, but also for the sense of calm that you feel when you're in its presence and not only do you feel calm, but there are blessings bestowed upon you by virtue of these gifts, by virtue of the Mulwali and the Suleva and they're bestowed upon you and your kid and all of your other possessions. So to be in the presence of these gifts, these gifts themselves are understood to be more than just objects. They have a presence.

They have power. They have personality, if you will. They also have names and sometimes children or people in the various tribes will take on the name of the bracelet or the necklace. So all of this, most description of this is of course not to say, what silly people, they imbue objects, just banal objects.

Yeah, they might be beautiful, but they're attributing them with all these kind of magical powers. How weird and primitive is that? No, that's not the point. The point is to say, this ceremony, this gift giving ritual is a social fact, meaning it requires people to behave.

It compels them to behave in a way whereby they recognize their obligation to others. Now interestingly, the obligation, this element of exchange requires them to maintain their integrity as a tribe and also to enter into communication and interaction with the tribes in their area of Melanesia, some of which are very, very far away. So it requires them to engage in a particular type of commerce, but importantly, the commerce is not just about the trading of goods that might be necessary. Now that also does happen, according to most when the ships are running on different islands and they are participating as Kula ceremony.

The Kula ceremony is the reason for actually traveling to different islands, but while you're there, you can also engage in some trading of goods and bartering and doing some marketplace stuff and making sure that you get your various fruits and minerals and material from other islands, but that's not the point of the travel. The point of the travel is to engage in the Kula and the Kula is a social fact because it is a requirement for tribes to maintain their integrity as tribes, as collectives, and to enter into interaction and communication with other tribes. So this is interesting. We now have the idea that there's a scientific way, there's a kind of social science, a science of understanding, obligation, and constraint, and the forces that make societies operate as societies.

Now this is very, very different from a kind of psychological science, which is to say, why is that person acting under those delusions? And why is that person doing that? What's going on in their mind? It's not about individual minds according to these French anthropologists.

In fact, for them it was very important that we move away from the idea of the individual mind and we start thinking in terms of the collective and the way that society is structured and the way that people within the collective are constrained by the rules of the society and recognizing the importance of operating as collective, operating as a society of whatever form. Okay, so you can imagine why all this stuff is really interesting to me because I'm so fascinated by social structure and I'm also reluctant to want to believe that it's all about individuality, although individuality fascinates me. But let's now move this all towards this notion of the Christmas rituals that you're hopefully engaging in today because hopefully you're listening to this podcast on Christmas Day. And the question is, can we consider Santa Claus to be a social fact?

I think we probably could. You know, Santa Claus is, first of all, this is a ritual that you're engaged in today. We're all sort of exchanging gifts. You might say to yourself, you know, people might be at your house and you might have spent loads of money on them.

You just think, why do I spend all this money on all these people? You know, and here you all, everybody's gathered together and then you're engaging these sort of ritual acts. You know, we pass over the thing. Why would you bother wrapping up the presents?

Who knows? You unwrap the presents. There's an obligation. There's another obligation in place you can't refuse the gift.

Somebody give you the gift. You can't fit. Mm, not really interested. You can.

But it has to be really ritualized. So for instance, if that's not the right size, I kept the receipt. Okay, well, I'll just hold on to the receipt. I'll check to see if it's the right size.

And everybody knows that you're going to take it back to shopping by something totally different. But the ritual is you can't refuse the gift, right? You've got to give the gift. You've got to accept the gift.

You can't refuse it. And Santa Claus, when the kid asks Santa Claus or Father Christmas for something, the parent has to provide it. And so here we have a force. We don't even have to believe in Santa Claus for that obligation to take effect.

Parents probably don't believe in Santa Claus, but nevertheless, there he is, social fact, producing some kind of requirement. And then the other thing is this notion of objects with magical powers. So we tend to imagine that we move through our world and objects are exchangeable and they have money and values attached to them. And the idea of an object might have some kind of power or some kind of personality or some kind of attribute or calming influence seems a little bit odd.

Not that odd to me. That bicycle certainly had some magical powers. So we can make connections between this notion of the social fact and some of our Christmas rituals and some of our own gift-giving rituals and Santa Claus' and bicycles and that type of thing. But the reason I'm introducing this all to you today is because I'm thinking about new ways of doing social science.

And I want to just tell you what they are in the last minute, the last couple of minutes of the podcast. And I want to point to you back to the story I told about me wanting the bicycle and all of the different things that we could have explored in that anecdote. So the notion of hypothesis and the testing and the other, the notion of Santa Claus' social fact and the obligations that are required by these things, etc. And there's a particular thing that we didn't talk about that I want to build a whole social science around.

And that's the fact that I had a desire. I had a desire for something. The desire I knew perfectly well was not enough to get me the thing that I wanted but I didn't stop desiring it. It's turned out to get me whatever that's not the point.

The point is I had a desire and I didn't express it. I wasn't going to be able to get it. What was the point of desiring it? Now, normally social science looks at the things that are there.

Any kind of science looks at things that are there in order to prove the hypothesis that water boils around in degrees, you need to have water, you need to believe it's there, you need to believe it does a certain thing under certain conditions. It's about the stuff that's there. If you can look at society, then you explore societies as they actually function. In reality, you look at a society and you say, there it is, now I'm going to study it.

I'm not going to make stuff up about stuff it's not doing. I'm going to look to see what it actually does. Well, I'm suggesting that we use science not to see what's there but to see what possibilities there might be. We could use science, we could use social science to explore the ways that social structure works.

We could explore the ways that the social world puts particular obligations on people. We could explore the way in which people are constrained by social norms. We could explore the ways in which they're constrained by ideologies. But for me, I don't think that's enough.

Why? Because I don't really like the way social structure works at the moment. I keep saying that. I wonder if there could be a scientific way of exploring new possibilities.

We're not just dreaming it up as scientists. We're looking to the social world. We're looking at something that exists in the social world. We're using that to see what new possibilities for social structure might exist.

The reason that this is interesting to me is because I notice something in people's everyday conversations. I've already said to you that I notice that people describe social worlds and that you can look at the grammatical structure of their social worlds and you can recognize that within that grammatical structure you can see social structure and the structure of the self and how those things interact. But there's something else that I've noticed when I look at these carefully at these conversations and these descriptions is that people often implicitly describe a desire for alternative type of social structure. People in everyday conversations describe their social worlds and they also hint at, imply, suggest alternative social worlds.

And I think they are hinting at their desire for something different. And the type of social science or linguistic science that I would like to get engaged in is one that identifies those desires and notices the new types of social world that they point to. And that for me would be a great way to spend a career. Thank you so much for listening.

I'm very glad you joined me. Have a very Merry Christmas. Have a very Merry Whatever Holiday and enjoy whatever form of ritualistic gift exchange you decide to engage in today or whenever. Thank you very much.

Frequently asked questions

When was this Structured Visions episode published?

This episode was published on December 25, 2015.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Structured Visions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.