Skip to content
Episode 32: A Thought That Thinks More Than It Thinks episode artwork

Feb 19, 2016

Episode 32: A Thought That Thinks More Than It Thinks

from Structured Visions Hosted by Jodie Clark

Last week I staged a tug-of-war between Society and The Individual, and I let Society win. This week I explain why with reference to a friend’s response to my first book. As I said to my friend, the book analyses homophobic attitudes in a women’s university field hockey club. I told him one of the … Continue reading Episode 32: A Thought That Thinks More Than It Thinks

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 32: A Thought That Thinks More Than It Thinks

of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello, and welcome to episode 32 of Structured Visions. Structured Visions is a space where I explore new ways of thinking about social structure. My name is Jody Clark, and I am very grateful for you listening today. You are, as always, very welcome here.

This week I would like to pick up on the idea we were playing with last week, because I was finding it so much fun. I had said, let's imagine that this dichotomy, this binary, that we've set up between society and the individual. And over the last several weeks, it's like I've been encouraging you to personify those two characters as if they were characters in a drama, and imagining what these characters would look like and ways that we can think about their interaction. And we went vague with it, we went general, we went specific with it, we've illustrated in all sorts of different ways.

And last week, I asked everyone to imagine that these two concepts, society and the individual, are at war with each other. Specifically, I was asking you to think in terms of them doing a tug of war, where they're tugging on a rope. And I said, let's just tell the individual, and I said the individual has a broken arm, the individual is struggling, the individual is fractured. Let's just tell the individual to give it up, let it go.

Let's just give up the ghost, if you like, give up the ghost of the individual. And so the individual and society were tugging away, and we said individual let go of the rope. So the individual let go of the rope, and then all we had left was, excuse me, society. And so here we had society on its own.

Now the question that I am going to ask this week is, why did I let society win that game? Because I could have let the individual win the game. And instead I let society win. And there might have been good reasons for letting, I mean we're just playing a game and it's just a good organization.

So there might have been good reasons for letting the individual win. And I'm just going to give you an explanation for why or an adjustification, for why I let society win in this particular scenario. And I'll illustrate that by telling you about a time when I was talking to a friend from school, and he'd heard that I'd written a book and he was asking, what's the book? What book have you written and what's it about?

And I said, okay, well the book was an explanation of an ethnographic study that I did. And I explained that it was an ethnographic study of the University Women's Field Hockey Club, and it was a way of me teasing out what I noticed, which seemed to be quite severe homophobia on the club. The women participants that I spoke to were all very troubled by gay players, gay people and sport, gay people at university, gay people in hockey, specifically lesbian, so gay women. And I was interested in this, I was a bit troubled by it, very troubled by it, and I wanted to see how that was actually happening.

Why was there all this homophobia in this particular environment? And I realized that it wasn't just a straightforward case of some people not liking gay people, but instead that there were some structural components to it, and there was a way in which the participants I was talking to were structuring their communities, and they were organizing their community in a particular way. So their community of, let's say, hockey players and their sporting world at university, they were organizing in a particular way, and they were dividing up gay people from straight people, and these ways of thinking about it. And so one thing that came out was that if somebody wasn't out lesbian, they were almost always represented as not being as good at hockey.

And so one of the ways that they would do that would be to say, well, this was the case that there were four hockey teams, and they were ranked according to ability. So the first team were the really good players who were playing in the top competitions, and then you had a second team, third team, and the fourth team were less competent hockey players, and then they played in different competitions with hockey players who were ranked or with other hockey teams that were ranked at a lower level. And so very often it would be said, oh, there really aren't any gay people on hockey teams. Well, there might be some in the fourth team, but there aren't any in the first team.

So that was one thing that was interesting, that it was always organized in terms of the first team, everybody's straight, and the fourth team there might be some gay players. And then there was also this sense that if there were going to be gay people as a gay women among their circle, their social circle, they would always be kind of depicted as being part of other teams. Oh, well, they were rugby players. So the rugby team is very gay, or the football team is very gay, but not hockey.

Hockey generally is a very straight, you know, hetero game. Okay, so, and then the other thing that I picked up on that I thought was really interesting was whenever the participants I was talking to were discussing sex, or they talked about sex a lot, but they had this interesting way of dividing people up. And I noticed that anybody who was straight, or who was a hockey player in the stories they were telling never actually was depicted as expressing any kind of sexual desire. So they have sex.

I mean, they would talk about having sex, but they would never depict hockey players as having sexual desire, but they would depict gay football players and gay rugby players as having sexual desire. And it's like they were problematizing desire. Like, desire was a bad thing if being gay was a bad thing. I thought, well, this is just interesting.

The way all of these different connections are being made, ways of categorizing things, and that the homophobia is part and parcel of a bigger, more complex dynamic system or structure. And so I was explaining this in an excited way to my friend. I'm glad that somebody was willing to listen. And he said, okay, that is so interesting.

He said, I was like, that's like, that's like, that's what's the truth. And he said, I'm going to take away from this. It's so helpful to me. He says, because I actually have lots of women friends who are gay.

And I'm just going to let them know that they need to be really careful about expressing desire, that they really shouldn't do that, because that's going to cause negative evaluations of them. And I was like, hold on. What are you going to do? What are you going to do?

You know, my lesbian friends are already, you know, they're already experiencing so much stigmatization and already so much prejudice. I'm just going to make sure they don't have to experience anymore. And they might not be aware. So I'll let them know that when they experience desire, that gives people a reason to judge them.

Or when they express desire, that gives people a reason to judge them. I said, dude, no, don't do that. That's not the point of the book. And that wasn't the point of the study.

That was never what I planned to do. And he's like, well, I'm just trying to make their lives better. And I'm like, well, no, no, because it's not fair. What I'm trying to say is that that system is unjust.

It isn't fair that someone would have to curtail their desire. It isn't, you know, there's nothing wrong about the idea that people wouldn't be able to express their desires. You know, that tells us something. But it's not something that you should go tell people to change their behavior.

And I'm like, the problem is with society. It's not with these individual people. They should, it's not about individuals changing their behavior to fit in with society. It's about society changing.

Okay, so do you notice which two characters showed up? We've got individual and society again. And here we've got my friends saying, I'll just get these individuals to change their behavior so they fit in with society. And then you've got me saying, no, society needs to change.

Now here's what happens next. My friends says to me, I can't actually change this. I can't think of a way that I can get society to change. Society hopefully will change, but I personally don't have a way of making that happen.

But I can get my friends to change so that their lives are better. So would you tell me not to do the thing that I can actually do? And so I spend a lot of time thinking about that. And that kind of sense of, look, you can critique society all you want.

But what if it doesn't actually bring about the kind of change you want to see? So isn't it a better use of your time and isn't it a better use of research to orient towards people who want to change, want to make their lives better as individuals? Isn't that a better way of thinking? Isn't that a better way of operating in the world?

And my response to that was now, actually. It's not a better way for me to operate in the world. Because if I'm telling individuals to adapt to orient to society's needs, I feel more like part of the problem and part of the solution. So I need a different way of dealing with this.

Now, here's the good news. The good news is I have a different way of dealing with this. Because I have personified society. I'm a personified individual.

So I've got society in the individual. I told the individual, take a break. You know, you've broken your arm. Don't play tug of war.

Go get yourself a nice piping hot cup of cocoa and sit over there for a while. And I'm just going to talk to this person that I've created that is society. I have personified society. So I get to have a conversation with society.

So this is very exciting. So I call society up. And you know, personified society, why shouldn't society have a mobile phone? So I'm calling up society.

That's society on speed dial. I'm like, society, why don't you come over. Let's go have a cup of coffee. I've got a few things I need to chat with you about.

Society's like, yeah, all right, but you're buying the coffee. I'm like, okay, I can buy coffee for society. I've got no problem with that. So I'm talking to a society.

And we get through the pleasantries. We're sipping on our lattes. And I say listen to society. I've got to talk to you about something that's my beautiful conversation.

But you and I need to have a chat. And I've noticed that you don't allow for the possibility of a lot of people. You don't allow for the possibility of the unique individual. You simply don't let that happen ever.

You don't allow. It's not part of you yet. You don't allow for the possibility of individuals as unique. Society says, well, you might need to buy me another coffee, you know, because you're really hitting me with quite a big critique here.

But it doesn't matter. It's okay. So society, you know, I can address this issue. And the answer is, you know, you're being short-sighted.

I do allow for unique individuality. Okay. So let me just let you know right off of that, that your accusation is unfounded. I do allow for individuality.

But what you need to realize, Jody, is that individuality is a complex thing. You can't just pop out with individuals. You can't just have somebody exist as a unique individual. You have to build up to it.

It's like to have a unique individual. It'd be like the punchline without the joke. You need to build up to the individual and society says, and there's a procedure for it. So I take a sip of my latte.

Are you kidding me? I say, there's a procedure for the concept of individuality. He says, yeah, yeah, yeah, we can do individuality. We can do individuality.

But there's a procedure. It needs you to build it up. And I'm like, I have absolutely no idea what you're talking about. And the next coffees are on you.

So society knows that I work best when I'm looking at conversational transcripts. So society says to me, why don't you look at a particular conversational transcript? And why don't you look to something that comes directly from your book, since you're so familiar with your book? I think you always want to talk about it.

He says, why don't you take a transcript? There's a conversation between some first-year players on the team. So there's Ali, and Sammy, and Chrissy. And they're talking about fresher's trials.

So this is one of the procedures by which the freshers get selected. So freshers being first-year students, they go to the sort of trials, and they are judged according to their abilities, and then some people are selected to be on the team. And I said, OK, well, I'll have a read of that transcript. So here I am now looking at the transcript.

And I'll just read to you bits of the transcript and I'll put it on the blog. So Ali is talking to Sammy and Chrissy, and Ali says the trials were quite good, weren't they? And then she says, I thought it would be a much higher standard than it was. And I said, oh, really?

And Ali says, yeah, I think it's because most of the people who like the better players had already gone to pre-season training, and so they didn't have to go to freshers' trials. And so we came to fresher's trials, and half the people were just like secondary school level. So just to unpick this a little bit. So there was a pre-season training.

And if you went to pre-season training, if you were selected there, you didn't have to go to fresher's trials. It's like, OK, we've watched your play during pre-season. You're fine. You're on the team.

But for anybody who didn't go to pre-season, they got to go to fresher's trials, and then they were kind of selected in that time round. And so Sami says, so we came to fresher's trials, and half the people were just like secondary school level. And of course, it's not even county. So these different levels of being able to play hockey, and some of them were secondary school level, which isn't very good.

And a lot of them weren't even county level. And then Ali says to Sami, she says, we spoke to each other on that first day, didn't we? And Sami says, yeah. And then Sami says, I looked at you and thought, oh, yeah, she's a good hockey player.

And then Ali says later, there are some people that you were just like, no way love. And Sami says, yeah, we were talking about half the people went home halfway through. They're just like, I'm not going to get in. So they just went home.

So here we have this description of the trials. And we've got two people who are at the trials talking about their experiences of the trials. So we've got Chrissy and, sorry, Ali and Sami. And we have them depicting through their sort of grammatical constructions, they have them reconstructing, construing that experience.

Okay, so what society says to me is like, look, okay, so just put yourself in the image. So society is personifying these individuals who are talking about the story. And so society is saying, okay, what you need to realize, Jadi, is that they're, think about all of the people who were at trials. They were a whole bunch of them.

Now, you can't have all of them as unique individuals because you would not be able to tell that story. You need some kind of context. You need to set the scene. And so society says, so in this story, in this sort of telling, in this construal, the scene is set by saying, by sorting people through.

So we'll just start with the better players. So I thought it'd be much higher standard. Most of the people, the better players, had already gone to pre-season training. Okay, so here are the people who weren't there, the better players.

So now what we've got is a way of understanding the people in this situation. We've got the better players and we've got the worst players. So I'm drawing little circles in the air, which you can't see, but we've got a group of circle with the better players and we've got a circle with the worst players. So we've got the worst players who are in the trials.

And then we're focusing in on that second group of the not as good players. And then half the people, so Sammy, half the people were just like secondary school level, not even county. So in that circle of the players who aren't as good, half of them are even worse. Half of them are so we can discount those two.

So society is saying, look, when we're structuring the story, we can filter through the various people because we can't deal with every single one. There's too many. So we'll just filter through and we'll get rid of half of them. And then, Ali says, I spoke to you.

And the I is Ali and the U is Sammy. And society turns around to me and says, look what I've done there. I have out of that big cloud of people, you know, all we had to do was get to line 14. That's all we needed, get to line 14.

And then I've got two individuals. And I use personal pronouns in the singular to refer to those people. So we've got our individuals. And not only that, society, but I've got the I speaking to the U.

So I've got two individuals in interaction. What more do you want? But what society says to me? But in order to get those individuals, I need to create a context that they must emerge out of.

And so if you keep going, they spoke to each other. And I said, yeah, but Ali says, she doesn't even remember what they said. And said, it's okay. And society says, it's okay.

Sammy says, I looked at you. I looked at you and thought, oh, yeah, she's a good hockey player. Okay. So Sammy, I looked at Ali, you.

I looked at you. So there's an interaction between them. And then I had a thought about you. And the thought was, she's a good hockey player.

Okay. And so out of all of those people, one individual emerges and that individual singles out, singles out another individual. And those two individuals, it's like if this were a film, there would suddenly be spotlights on those two individuals. And one of them to be individuals, they need to emerge out of a mass.

So society says, I've got this nailed. I create the mass. I give you a context for the mass. And out of that, I create these two individuals.

And the individuals are an interaction and they're having thoughts about each other. So that's the process, so society. I can do individuality. I got no problem with that.

But there's a process for it. And what you do is you create a mass of people. You specify the terms and then you pull out the best ones from that term. And in this case, it was like, all right, I got bad hockey players.

I got less bad hockey players. I got less bad hockey players. There are two very good hockey players. And one of them looks at the other.

And thanks, you look like a good hockey player. She's a good hockey player. And I say, ah, very convincing. This is when I say to society.

Very convincing. But not convincing enough. And what I say to society is you haven't created individuals. You've created little spotlights and you've created your personal pronouns and you've created this interaction.

But those aren't individuals. You've created tokens of a type. What you've created is a type of person that's a good hockey player. And you've created that type of person by setting up a framework, which is there's good hockey players and bad hockey players.

And then out of that group, you've singled out one person. But that person is not a unique individual. It's just a representative of a group. It's just a token.

We've talked about this before, a token relationship. This is just a token from a type. That's not a unique individual. You haven't created a unique individual.

You're just sustaining the notion of the mass. And you're sustaining this notion of the framework and the overarching framework. And the one character, the one individual, isn't even recognizable to the other individual, except it is much as she fits in with the type. She is a good hockey player.

And then you'll raise everybody. Everybody else who's not a good hockey player, you just get rid of them. In fact, even in the story, they go home. Half of the players knew they weren't good enough.

And they just went home as a grant group on mass. None of them is individuals decided to go home. None of them is individuals agonizing and wondering about this whole system. They all just went home.

So I don't believe that you've actually constructed individuals there. And society says, OK, maybe I haven't constructed unique individuals in the way that you seem to want me to. But here's the problem. If I'm going to go around personifying social structure, if that's what you're saying that's what I'm doing.

I'm going around personifying social structure, creating characters out of social structure. So if you're saying, OK, social structure in this particular instance is comprised of ways of representing the world such that there's good, bad, and worse ways of playing hockey. And if I'm creating that structure, then I'm personifying that structure by having tokens of those different types. That's OK.

I can do that. But you're actually asking me to create something that I don't have access to. You're asking me to create something, an individual out of something completely new. If a second I personify something and I make it a person, and then I identify it with it, I can't think outside that category.

I can't have any way of creating an individual outside of the social structures that I already have in place. I can't do it. It's impossible. It's like saying to you, here's your whole crayon box.

Now, draw in a color that doesn't exist yet. You can't do it. You can only use the colors in the crayon box. I'm a society.

I've created all the social structures and then you want me to make characters out of something else, some other material. I can't do that. That is asking me to think the unthinkable, to think beyond what I am capable of thinking. And I can't do it.

So you're asking the impossible society says to me. So it's starting to get a little loud. We're having this little difficult discussion in the coffee shop and we're starting to draw attention to ourselves. So we just quietly sit for coffee for a little bit longer.

And then I play a little bit of dirty pool. And I say, yeah, but you've got to remember in 9-11-0s. Society's like, I said, look, in 9-11-0s the French scholar, remember him? So I just said, yeah.

I said, okay. And manual 11-0s says, a thought that thinks more than it thinks is a desire. It says, you do have a way of thinking outside the thinkable. And that is by orienting to desire.

So what I'm going to ask you to do is tell me a story that's unthinkable. Tell me a story about desire. So society's a little bit being down by the smile. So I said, okay, look, yeah, I do.

Desire does show up in my frameworks. I do create characters. You know, the characters emerge in my structures who have desires. Yes.

Not totally crazy about it. It's a little bit embarrassing. I'm not, don't love to talk about them. I don't love to create them.

They're a bit repulsive. But I am capable of creating characters who are repulsive. So I will tell you a little bit. I will be happy to tell you a story about desire if you want in which the characters desire.

And so here we go. And so society actually directs me to a conversation between some others who have popular. So we've got Sandy again. Sandy's in this conversation.

She's having a conversation with another first year player called Nemo. And both of them are having a conversation with a second year player on the same team called Sarah. So we've got Sarah, Nemo, and Sammy. And this is very interesting.

The society would direct me toward this conversation. And I'll put it in the blog and I'll also read it to you now. Sarah says, I tell you what, there's a girl. She came to hockey trials.

Didn't get in. So is joined rugby. Now this is interesting. Right?

Just that first line. Let's look at the grammar of this. Let's find out where the characters are. Okay.

So we've got the eye right at the beginning. So first person reference, the eye. I tell you what. Okay.

So there's a kind of colloquialized term. I tell you what. So the speaker is positioning herself in the position of the narrator. So the eye actually isn't going to show up again.

It's like the eye is saying, here's me telling you a story and then the eye disappears. And then we have these other characters. And the first character comes through through an existential clause. There's a girl.

There is a girl. So the existential clause sort of posits something and puts something down. There's a girl. Right?

So we're orienting towards this girl. Now, the interesting thing here is it's one girl. Now we've got the, we've got the indefinite article A. There's a girl.

So out of all the girls, we've got this particular girl, one girl. And then we'll then thematize the she. The girl. So in the third person pronoun, singular female, she came to hockey trials.

So positive the girl. And then I'm going to tell you about the girl. She came to hockey trials. Okay?

So there's a girl existential clause in the present tense. She came to hockey trials. So now we're in the simple past tense. So we're going to be relating events that happen one after the other.

And we imagine that these events happen in chronological order. She came to hockey trials. Didn't get in. Okay.

So here we've got something called ellipsis where she could have repeated the she. She came to hockey trials. She didn't get in. But we're, we don't need that she.

So we're leading the she. And we're recognizing that each of these different processes, each of these events, each of these verbs in the past tense is going to have as their subject she. She came to hockey trials. Didn't get in.

So she came and then she didn't get in. So both cases, past tense, second, first one is positive, second one is negative. Didn't get in. Came back to trials first, didn't get in second.

So has joined rugby ellipsis again, she has joined rugby. Tense is slightly different. Tense is something that insists on a professional grammar. You would call past and present.

Past and present, yes. So she has joined rugby. But the interesting thing there is the conjunction. So, and in order to understand that, I would ask you, what's the relationship between in the story between the girl joining rugby and not getting into hockey trials, not getting into the hockey team?

And the relationship is one of causality. The cause of her joining rugby was that she didn't get into hockey. Right? There's a relationship between them.

It's not a case of, you know, the reason she went to rugby is because it is a case of the reason that she joined a rugby team was because she didn't get into the hockey team. So we've got that in terms of the implicit chronology, which first this happened, then this happened, then this happened. And then that's so, which is the reason she joined rugby is because she didn't get into hockey. Now, what are all of the implications of that?

That you have to understand her to make sense of that. She, that rugby isn't as good as hockey. Because you tried, she tried hockey first and then she failed, so the rugby was her second choice. She was good enough for rugby, but she wasn't good enough for hockey.

So already we've got this story with this girl. And we already know the most important thing, the beginning of the story is she didn't get in hockey. So if she was one of the same people who was in the trials that the other three were talking about, Ali Sami and Chrissy, she would have been one of the half of the people who went home. She wasn't good enough.

She was part of the group that wasn't good enough. She's not good enough, but she's an individual. She's a girl. And she has a first person pronoun to describe her.

Now, here's the next line, Nemo. Oh, Jen, yeah. Okay, now we have a girl. She's got the third person singular pronoun.

She, and now she's got a proper name. Oh, yeah, Jen. Okay, so we've got her name. So her individuality is coming through more and more.

And then the next thing is a relational clause. She was a relational clause. She with the subject in the was and then something that's going to be some attribute we presume that is going to be associated with she. She was a lesbian.

So Nemo says, oh, Jen, yeah, she was a lesbian. Oh, that's interesting. Why do all those things go together in this story? There's a girl.

She came to hockey trials, didn't get in. So has joined rugby. Not good enough to be in hockey. Joins rugby.

She was a lesbian. That's interesting. Little bit odd. And then the next line from Sammy.

She always like speaks to Ali. Now, Ali is our hockey player that we heard about before. So Ali is, you know, Sammy's friend. First year hockey player.

She was in the previous transcript transcript. She always like speaks to Ali and says, all right, gorgeous. And you look really lovely today. Nemo says, she tried it all with Ali once.

Sammy says, yeah. And Ali's like, I'm not having any of it. She was just, oh, she was really scared of her. It was so funny.

And so there's the story. And society says, here you go. You wanted a story about desire. You've got a story about desire.

You wanted a story that incorporates somebody as an individual who was rejected from the hockey team. You got it. Here she is. She was rejected from the hockey team.

I've given her some individuality now. And she's experiencing desire. And so she was experiencing desire for somebody from the hockey team. So this is interesting.

Here we have these two individuals. And one of them doesn't fit in. And that particular one who doesn't fit in also experiences desire. So isn't that interesting, I say, to society?

It's interesting that the desiring character is one who doesn't fit into the desirable category. And it's almost like you're using that character who desires to get into this team. It's like you're using them to point out the desirability of the category of being a hockey player. And society's like, yeah, okay.

Yeah, I'm doing that. I've got this kind of individual. I've got this desiring person. And the best way I can do that, the best way I can do desirance is to say that person wants something from this hockey team.

And I'm thinking, okay, this is the way we're going to go forward then. We're going to see what's making it so difficult for this individual to emerge from social structure. And in order to do that, we're going to need to go to those characters that society doesn't want to quite own or identify with. We're going to go to those characters or those persons or those personages that disrupt the natural, comfortable order of things that sneak their way in without necessarily society being happy about it.

That is what we're going to look at. So thank you again for indulging in this pretend conversation between me and society. And I'm having a lot of fun playing with that, so I appreciate you indulging it. And maybe next week we'll have a look at some of these quote unquote undesirables and see if there are any new possibilities.

So these new ways of thinking about social structure that society itself hasn't thought about yet. Thank you so much for listening. I hope to talk with you next week.

Frequently asked questions

When was this Structured Visions episode published?

This episode was published on February 19, 2016.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Structured Visions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.