Welcome to the Pike Liners Podcast, Episode 350, sponsored by SolarCraft, providing high-quality engineered solutions for powering, sheltering, and operating critical field automation infrastructure. Find out more about SolarCraft at www.solarcraft.net. The Pike Liners Podcast, where professionals, bubba-geeks, and industry insiders share their knowledge and experience about technology, projects, and pipeline operations. And now your host, Russell Treet.
Thanks for listening to the Pike Liners Podcast. I appreciate you taking the time and to show the appreciation. We give away a customized JD Tumblr to One Listener every episode. This week, our winner is Dan Floden with Aliasca Pike Liner.
Congratulations, Dan. You're yet. He's on its way to learn how you can win this prize. Stick around to the end of the episode.
This week, we welcome back André Schultz from SolarCraft, and we'll be discussing optimizing battery life in remote systems. André, welcome back to the Pike Liners Podcast. How are you doing, sir? I'm doing great.
I'm doing well. As I always do, why don't you introduce yourself? Tell us who you are and who you're with and what you do. My name is André Schultz.
I'm the technical director of at SolarCraft. We mainly build remote installations where we integrate people's control systems with power systems for the oil and gas industry. So maybe 75, 80% of our industry is Midstream Pipeline. Sorry, I mean revenue.
So in my role as technical director, I'm head of the QA QC department. And I also head up the sort of SME work we have to do with the salespeople as we bring in new work to determine what is it that needs to be made. In a nutshell, exactly. What I do.
Yeah, so we've already done a couple episodes. We're doing a whole series. So we've covered some information about building systems and building UPSs. And what I wanted to talk to you about this session is optimizing battery life.
I think one of the things, for me, kind of a notional understanding of this type of stuff is that I know the technology around batteries is changing very, very quickly. And it's not, when you're building an application, it's not as simple as just pick a battery and plug it in. There's more that needs to go into it. What are the key considerations people ought to be thinking about when they're looking at batteries and they're trying to figure out how to get the optimal life out of a set of batteries?
Yeah, that's another one of those loaded questions. It justifies the podcast, I feel. So what you have to add to the question of how you optimize battery life is for its intended purpose. A battery that you would put in a car, whose main purpose is to crank the engine and keep some lights and bits going when you're waiting for the wife to finish this shopping and you don't want to idle the car is very different from what do you put out on a pole in the desert to maintain a radio.
You wouldn't use the same type of battery at all and the consideration for how to prolong the life of that battery is very different. So the place to start is what is the application, what's the intended use of the battery, select the correct chemistry for it and then you roll out what do you do to make this battery last longest for what its intended deployment is. So, Andre, you mentioned battery chemistry. So what are the battery chemistries and what do I need to know about those as it relates to optimizing my battery life for a particular application?
The two biggest chemistries that people are talking about these days is lead acid batteries versus lithium batteries. Each of those have some differences among them. Lead acid batteries for instance could be flooded batteries or valve regulated batteries. Lithium batteries may be lithium ion or lithium ion phosphate batteries.
You would usually use a lead acid battery when your installation may be subject to really cold weather. Lithium batteries are not that happy charging under really cold conditions. Lithium batteries have the advantage that they are very light and they can take very large charge currents. So you may want to use those in applications that are mobile or have very requirements for very short discharging times.
Right. So, in my experience, most of the stuff that you find around field automation and field control systems tends to be lead acid versus lithium. What's the reason for that? Why is lead acid preferable in general?
I know there's a difference, but general why is lead acid preferable? Out of the 10 reasons I reckon the top two is a cost and availability that are more expensive. If properly deployed, a lead acid battery can live very, very long. And the second bestest reason is that lithium ion batteries do not like to get really cold.
So, in remote applications, very often in the middle of winter, the batteries get below freezing and these batteries suffer to be charged when it's that cold. So you would probably rather choose a lead acid battery for that application. Things are changing though these days and some options are emerging and we'll get into that in a little bit. Well, that's one of the things I wanted to ask you about because I know there's a lot going on with batteries and people are looking at different things.
Are there any promising new chemistries that you guys are looking at evaluating? You know, most of what we do have to be ridiculously reliable. So we would tend not to deploy the newest technology as soon as it emerges. We wait kind of selfishly to see other people make the mistakes first or watch whether new technologies are actually reliable as people use them like we would use them.
So I am starting now to, for the first time, consider lithium ion phosphate for our sort of field deployments because the charging temperature in really cold weather seems to be going lower and lower. The cost is also coming down significantly and the battery management systems are becoming cheaper and cheaper. So it's at a tipping point. Of course, we'll offer both for the longest time.
But lithium ion phosphate or LIFE PO4, I have to say that probably is what we would probably end up using in the field. That's interesting. I always find it interesting. You're commenting about you're ridiculously concerned about reliability.
That's so for me in my experience, that's so on point, right? Because you really want these remotely deployed systems. I want to be able to install them and leave them and forget about them. I don't want to have to go out there and do much with them, if anything, to maintain them and keep them operational.
That's a really important part of the lifecycle cost of this stuff. Yes, it's cost a lot to put a person to pick up truck, go visit a site. Yes, it costs a lot. It's very tempting to pay less for a system early on.
But it's very expensive to deal with the problem you caused. It's the logic of crack and it uses for this year's financial statement. You have to look at the cost of rolling a truck so what are some of the other considerations? We talked about chemistry, talked a little bit about temperature.
How does temperature play into what you need to do to optimize your battery life? Let acid batteries in general and every variant of them do not like to operate in i.e. in a place like say Kuwait where it's always 130 degrees days, the batteries tend to stay really hot and die very young. If you do it properly with a set of really hot batteries, good batteries, you can expect maybe three or four years of life on a nice big battery bank.
How can you stretch that? Well, one thing you could do is you could shade your entire system. Really good use of shade. Shade is free.
Batteries do not follow the temperature of the air. They're very heavy. They follow the average temperature between day and night. If it's 130 during the day but 80 at night then the average temperature of that battery will be whatever is in the middle of those two.
Keeping the batteries cool by insulating them, keeping them shaded is the number one first thing you could do to prolong their life, easily by double as opposed to putting them in a box that's in the sun. There are certain chemistries of lead acid batteries that they call high heat batteries but those tend to not cycle well. So in the application of a UPS where they are always fully charged, they live long just fine. Your favorite brand of battery manufacturers will have a range of high heat lead acid batteries.
But don't use those for solar applications without talking to them first. Some of the applications absolutely need to discharge and charge and discharge and charge very or every day. High heat batteries, that's not the thing. Another consideration to make them live longer for lead acid batteries in particular is you have to keep an eye on how deep do you discharge a general rule of thumb is if you put about double the battery capacity then you need, it'll live about four times as long.
If you put three times more battery than you need, it would live nine times as long. It's exponential like that. Always install more battery than you need and that way all of it will live longer. It is the cheapest, most highest dollar per hour job that you could possibly do is put more battery than you need and keep the depth of the discharge now.
So it's actually an exponential function, battery capacity versus link of life. Yes and that's true for just about any battery. They should get the hard work. Yeah, right.
You also mentioned we were taking up this episode the idea of unit voltage being a consideration. What is that and how does it play in through this? Yes, that's a big deal. One would try to keep an installation of batteries to as few parallel strings as possible.
A thermal runaway is very real. It is a complicated subject that we don't have time for a year but please go look it up on the web what causes it and what the effects are. But as a rule, one way to mitigate thermal runaway in large battery banks is to keep the unit voltage low and have more series strings than parallel strings. Try never to have more than four units in parallel.
If you have to have a really large battery bank, choose units with a lower voltage and get those in series rather than using smaller ones and many of them in parallel. The lowest voltage you can get in lead acid batteries is about two volts per cell and you can buy a 1,200 amp hour two volt battery. Nice big thing. If you have to have a very large battery bank that is 48 volt, you would use 24 of those batteries all in series as opposed to a mixed match of parallel and series of smaller denominations.
Interesting. So that raises the question for me, why is parallel more of a problem in series? I'm probably not going to be able to understand the answers. I might have to ask it twice.
Yeah, it's complicated. It's ugly head when you float batteries that have different chemical properties and different internal resistances and they are in parallel. A battery and I may be saying this the wrong way around it does get warmer when its internal resistance climbs over time as the battery degrades. In a parallel string, if his internal resistance is higher, it would cause him to get hotter, which means his internal resistance is climbing some more, which means he gets hotter and pretty soon you got a spectacular fire.
So in series installations, you do not have that problem. You just have the battery chemically failing, not violently. So to speak. Right.
Right. So the other thing I think it'd be helpful to talk about it. We've kind of alluded to this, but when you think about battery life, one of the things that you've mentioned in some of the other conversations we have, you've got to understand the application. What do you want the battery to do?
You've got to understand the load. And are the considerations different when you're looking at how I select and size batteries for something that is a constant base load versus something where I need to push a surge of energy, but the rest of time the battery stay dormant. It is less of a consideration with lead acid batteries than with lithium batteries. A lead acid battery, imagine a hundred hour gel battery, about the size of what fits in a car under the hood there.
They are probably good for delivering about 600 or 800 amps without damage. They kind of don't care to do that. You can melt a wrench by touching the two terminals together. Many people have seen that.
Whereas a lithium battery has a battery management system or BMS built into it, whose job it is to balance the cells carefully within the battery. They are all in series and also limit the charging and the discharge current. So a typical number for a hundred hour lithium battery is about 100 amps. Sometimes 50.
You get different flavors. Whereas a lead acid battery, you can crank them all the way up to five, six, seven hundred amps for a little bit and they'll do it. When it comes to, say, take the example for the battery in your car. That may be an 80-amp hour battery, but every time you start the car, you have to stick about 200 amps on it to crank the start, especially if you've got a big engine.
If one day you decide lithium is better than lead acid and you put a lithium 80-amp hour battery in there, its BMS would stop the discharge current at 100 amp, maybe pick a number, and it wouldn't be able to start the car at all. So for installations that may have short bursts of really heavy draw, like, for instance, hitting the lock road to current on the valve actuator in the middle of nowhere, you would probably want to select lead acid battery. Otherwise, you would have to put a tremendous amount of lithium batteries out there to be able to deliver that car. There are other lithium batteries that are fine with heavy currents, such as you find in vehicles, but at the moment they're not practical for remote installations.
Interesting. So the last thing I want to talk to you about is testing. So how does testing play into optimizing battery life? You know, I'll digress just for a second there.
When you install a battery bank, it's very important that all the batteries, if there are multiples of them, say four or eight batteries, that are set. They all come from the same batch. You bought them all at the same time. They have about the same age, not about strive for exactly the same age.
And don't replace some of them. So what happens is over time, as batteries degrade, they chemically change where they may not be able to deliver their rated current anymore. And also their internal resistance as they self-rate an age of it may not be the same anymore. So a healthy thing to do if you love your battery bank is buy yourself a battery test that can do a cranking test on a battery and also test the internal resistance of it.
You don't necessarily have to buy the most expensive one out there. The yellow testing equipment will sell you something for about, you know, four or five thousand dollars. You may not need that. You just need to benchmark.
And it's a very healthy habit to, when your battery bank is new, you measure the internal resistance of these batteries. And you take a sharpie and you write on the battery the data that you measured it and what was the internal resistance number. And after maybe a year, you do it again and you check, do they all still track the same? After two years, three years, year by year number five, you may notice that one of them, because there will always be one, will start going south.
You will see it where when you pull a large current on him, his voltage drops way lower than his brethren. Also, that battery you will notice will have a higher internal resistance than the other guys he's with. So, meters like that are not expensive. If you have multiple installations with batteries, just buy a tester that can do a cranking test and the internal resistance test, test your batteries, give them numbers, write their number and watch, do they track the sun.
And then when you see one of them going bad, if it's early on, replace that guy. If it's after seven or eight years, replace the entire bank. Just one more thing is a solar installation. If properly executed and the battery stay nice and cool, should be good for about six or seven years.
But a UPS, if you do it properly, should be well over 10 years. So, you don't necessarily have to test really hard in the first couple of years. You may want to leave it fully. So, what happens if I take a five-year-old, six-year-old battery bank and I've got one battery that's going bad and I replaced that one battery with a new one.
What does that do? What is the adverse effect of that? Yeah, that's a very interesting analogy for that. Imagine if you build yourself a little manifold from little pipes.
Let's say one long pipe that you weld four little pipes into, you close it off. Now you've got a manifold. You put a balloon, a new balloon that came from the same packet on each of these little tubes coming out of that pipe. This is a silly analogy.
Just forgive me. So, you'll blow in one side of the pipe and you'll notice that all four balloons will inflate at the same rate. You'll have to blow pretty hard. If you leave them inflated like that for a period of time and you deflate them, you'll notice they don't return to the exact shape when you took them out of the packet.
They're going to look a little bit more low. But when you re-inflate them, they'll still all go anything right. So, you can now inflate and re-inflate this balloon array of yours. But soon one will pop or something will happen.
If you then take a new balloon out of a packet and stick it in the old one's place, he is tighter. So, you will find that when you blow on the one end of the tube, that guy will not inflate at all. But the remaining three, which are nice and limp by now, will over inflate. And all four of them will now be out of your spec.
In terms of batteries, one new battery, especially in a series string, will the new one will always have the lower voltage. And the old ones will always go to a higher voltage. And both of them are out of spec now. The charger thinks they are all at the flood voltage, so he doesn't care.
And meantime, both of those just die early. So, you better off replacing the entire array of battery rather than just one. Yeah. So, basically what happens is if you put a new battery in with a bunch of old ones, you kill all of them quicker.
Yes. That's kind of the net outcome of that conversation, you kill all of them quicker. You kill the old ones quicker because you're overcharging them, and you kill the new one quicker because you're undercharging it. Yes.
I'll come up with a bit to story for that one day, but until then it'll be the balloons. No, it's actually a really good illustration. I can, it helps me visualize it. It's really good.
Well, look, we've kind of come to the end of the time for this conversation. We'll go ahead and wrap this up. I want to tell you, I want to try and summarize, if you will, considerations for battery life. The first is, select the right chemistry for the application.
And we talked a little bit about one of those, some of those considerations are typically for most of what we do and remote operations, you're probably going to be looking at lead acid as the desire type of battery. Secondly, look at how you're discharging those batteries, how hard you're working them. More batteries in the bank will call us all the batteries to last longer. Thirdly, hook them in series if you can.
And then lastly, as you get to the end of life, you know, would lead acid probably at the four-year point or so, start going out there and monitoring those batteries so you know when to replace them. I think you may. So, yes, that, or I guess you can also put that into your automation system and automate the process of measuring that stuff. You can.
Yes. So, yeah, interesting. Thank you. Well, so how did I do that?
Did I do a pretty good summary there? Yes, I think you made it. All right. Well, we'll pick this up with another conversation.
And what we're going to talk about next is powering remote valves kind of picking up on an episode we did a while back and adding to it. Nice. Thank you very much. I hope you enjoyed this week's episode of the pipeline podcast or conversation with Andre.
Just a reminder before you go, you should register when our customized pipeline or podcast yeti Tupper simply visit pipeline podcast network.com slash when and in yourself the drawing. If you would like to support this podcast, please leave a review on Apple podcast Google Play wherever you happen to listen. And you can find instructions at pipeline podcast network.com. If you have ideas, questions or topics you'd be interested in, please let me know on the contact us page at pipeline podcast network.com or reach out to me on my thanks for listening.
I'll talk to you next week.