Hello and welcome to risk chats with a firm. I'm your host Paul Marshall Today on the podcast we revisit with USAID speak with Marcus Howard And we're gonna talk about how they have operationalized their risk appetite statement As well as an integration with internal controls and some of the things Marcus is doing over there So I hope you guys will enjoy this one. Let's talk to Marcus Hello and welcome to the podcast today. I'm happy to have with us here Marcus Howard from USAID Marcus How are you doing?
Doing good doing good and very happy to have a USAID back on the podcast And we talked with you guys a you know while ago at this point about risk appetite and I guess we're kind of revisiting some of that subject and Going a little deeper, but yeah, thanks for joining us today Why don't we start off Marcus? We could just give us a little bit of background about yourself You know, what do you do over there USAID? Yes a little bit of Some of you traditionally started my career as a financial statement author helping them off to a client's nine in a federal space We a career a transition from all in our two help the DOD sector and all those other magazines, you know become a body ready Some that you just learn a lot of best practices more cost beneficial approaches to implement our controls And areas and also help you know we create long-standing systemic on our control But then you know how large a six like a DHS receive clean opinions on what first time and also saying it those opinions So kind of fast forward to present time it landed with USAID For the last eight months now So I'm over here. I'm the division director for enterprise risk management from controls under the oldest of financial chief and Okay, very good.
Well, we get into some of the internal control stuff as well in a minute But why don't we start off with um, I think we want to talk a bit a little bit more about risk appetite You know kind of how how would you guys operationalized? You know your your program as far as the risk appetite goals and statements that you put out there? Yeah, great question You know it's fairly new to the program and also USA So one of the approaches we we undertook as agency was to provide a risk appetite statement To you know pretty much provide some guidance, you know some of them other stick in various, you know Sectors throughout the agency to look at things holistically not just a mobile network perspective looking at things from a legal perspective operational perspective Repetition perspective down the program level well. So one of the things that we did was to you know receive feedback You know from the programs were also to know targets to your marketing how to re-operationalize There was not a site down to the program level with understanding of the programs defined objectives So then allow the program to determine based on those objectives understanding Risk threats, but also opportunities to then further determine their risk appetite and or risk tolerance It's to accept certain risks, but also to then drive a decision making one developed in the program risk mitigation plans In agreement turn up a tool that then to effectively contain a two-month rose plans So in all that help, you know better operationalize, you know the risk outside So that's something that you actively work with the program offices to kind of help them out or how do you get feedback?
You know from them as far as I was going Yeah, absolutely. So we developed some of our yar and core team mobile working group, you know Director to you know open up the line of communication to get that feedback so it could vary from Program consultation with my team and also colleagues at the headquarters level of the agency to provide that feedback when there's a specific scenario and how to do The risk outside So they are program and then so then we would basically communicate their scenario how to know document with a level of precision Which to consider was the criteria to develop to then drive their understanding of their objectives that are trans-rechieved instead of context and then how to Those risks with the risk of how those risk indicators will then drive decision making and understanding in many about between a certain risk also when the To gain with USA mission we're in opposition to where as we provide mentorship a whether and you know funding or Services we provide You know an opportunity for developing countries to You know to become so polite so turn that we use and in an opportunity we try to seek Based on our overall mission with the journey to so relies on we provide those countries for the countries is to Identify areas of the path you're building so that translates into potential opportunities So to accept certain risks inherently to our mission that should ideally have a return investment And so then in document information that provides us a just plenty of decision making opportunities to invest in other countries Right and I'm guessing to some extent when you guys did the appetite statement It was kind of just documenting what the risk culture that already existed there So like you said, you know, you will take some risks for these for these programs to be successful But I'm also curious have you seen other effects maybe on how programs do budgeting or things like that? You know, how is that been affected by the risk appetite? That's kind of a put out there?
Yeah, so with within a budget, you know, resource budget resources human capital is always a factor You know could be a performance indicator or could be a risk indicator in the nature and maybe become a barrier or something to overcome a challenge So you know, look at you know at the time and you know, of course, there's amount of budget resources that's provided So we think that into the reason to to how You know how quickly or how efficiently can we get closer to achieve those objectives as well too? So that's rather our decision making as well to one the program level of risk that we want to date case endpoint is Current, you know pandemic situation that's affected, you know, and the technical effect You know present itself as a you know, opportunities for the AC to Really, you know, look at things in different manner. So then we Look a ways for efficiencies on current processes to provide a little more flexibility in doing that a chance You know, this is our site to give a answer a to those other countries to address All that you know Yeah, makes sense and that's good that sounds like you guys are flexible and kind of you can have to adapt to the environment, of course Yeah, yeah, so you know something a little kind of tangential this but I was curious You know, what do you guys do as far as you know, like some tools to help you out with your program? You know the kind of track, you know How progress you're making or the the risks and then the mitigation and that's happening, you know, what have you guys explored in kind of a you know kind of tools?
Yes, great question. It's one of the things that we're in the process of knowing is exploring We're gonna reverse reporting as a unit tool that are known as a co-herence Reporting in a client school with in a form of a license application. You know, we're looking at that options and vendors to see if There are technologies that would basically allow us to capture data, you know, holistically across agency on various restrictions Set various tolerances on crit workloads as well. I'm also going to help identify opportunities, you know, from those of us that create, you know, just a various Also a lot of dashboards that we can use and track in and tell our needs our performance needs as well And also one of the things we're looking at is how to You know create feedback loops such as how we can create Terp patrols to provide a feedback loop as well and then try to automate, you know, a lot of our business processes That may be heavy depending on these other cells where you can be able to So that's definitely one of the things that we are scoring now as a part of our overall ERM maturity model planning Right.
Yeah, I mean, I'm assuming just like other agencies you find that once you get to a certain maturity level You kind of got to get to something a little bit more, you know robust than just a spreadsheet or a email Absolutely. Yeah You know, I don't find calls fave and then and you know, just enabling the agency from the staff and management to the senior levels senior leadership levels to make you know more timing and And then to be proactive so then you know using such tools that maybe other in the marketplace allows us to then Become a little bit more savvy, you know with the ERM members management to then do some scenario Planning when that particular analysis goes together, you know data to help drive some of the decision-making Those tools will focus on, you know Those those best practices that we see in a private sector Yeah, have you guys already started playing with some dashboard ideas with your existing software or what do you guys think in as far as that goes? Yeah, so we're still in the early discovery stage with frame it. Um, so To to you know, potentially perform market research one would would uh technology will provide us the biggest thing for the buck So to speak and then from a business process level, what we're doing is, you know, tightening things up a lack of better word, but uh getting organized on how our uh, y'all are in process flows work Um, what are the you know, the key data descriptions that we need to you know, lock down uh, some of the things like technology, um understanding the sources of uh risk management data as well and then how to best integrate that we were to then deploy a application of some sort uh to create a, you know, an efficient effective workload Um, understanding um, you know from our users and customers, you know, and so you understand what would be most beneficial for them to see You know, different levels as well Right when you mentioned data, obviously, so you know, a lot of podcasts, you know, we've been kind of talking about this Um, you know, a lot of agencies I feel are starting to really dig into they want to gather some data that make, you know, make decisions here for their yorem programs You know, what what are your guys?
What do you guys think as far as data analytics, either things that you're doing or things that you would like to do To better utilize data to analyze data to really kind of tie your goals or your strategies to what's actually happened another Yeah, no great question. Um, and that's you know, that definitely ranges in a wide scope. Um, but really, you know, just identifying Um, I think from the strategic planning stage understanding You know, when objectives are being set, uh, performance measures are being developed, uh, to marry up that same strategic planning with risk, uh, indicators as well That means we'd be inherent to the mission overall, but down to the programmatic level as well Um, and then help identify what data within validate, you know, um, those risk indicators, um, what to do, how to react to that What additional information and maybe needed to inform those risk indicators, but also um, feeding into the higher probability of achieving those performance measures as well So using that as a framework to really drive, you know, just the data in the versus just, you know, just having a, um, you know, kind of a just, you know, uh, ad Hawk, you know, a structure of the data, just pull data out of the sky from anywhere, but really not knowing how it ties back to the strategic objectives Um, so we're, you know, taking that, uh, we will be taking that structure approach, uh, then from there, um, understanding the scriptures of that data, of course, the sources, um, the Our, um, our existing, uh, across wide systems that we've got our own, such as our accounting systems, procurement systems, uh, fiber systems and so forth Um, and then looking at, uh, how that feeds into, again, those are future objectives at the program level and how that should then marry up to inform, um, you know, effective risk mitigation strategies, um, risk treatments, and then how to also target our internal systems as well Um, one of the, that will leverage as well to, um, force will, uh, leverage the reports from the, uh, and auditors, uh, such as OIG and GAO use those, um, those mechanisms, um, permanent advisors, uh, probably standpoint, uh, to inform, uh, lef it's known as well as a part of our data source Right, yeah, so have you, uh, already found that, you know, in, in looking at some IG or other kind of reports that you guys already use that to reevaluate maybe your strategy or how you want to do certain things? Absolutely, uh, so one of the things we've, we've done, um, just want to start is to, you know, integrate the, uh, OIG within our, um, existing, you know, our economic governance structure, um, from a collaborative, collegial perspective.
Uh, so often we may have IG, you know, briefest one, various advisory reports, um, things such as top management challenges that AC that may, um, you know, create barriers of challenges from achievement objectives and just having those, um, you know, frequent consultations on, uh, with their hands, you know, able to see, you know, missions, um, so then, uh, you know, to inform with our remediation actions and to ensure that we have, um, um, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, um, uh, uh, so, um, uh, um, uh, the um, um, we have a, uh, building a sort of business presence where we need our board to have access to them. perform targeted versus assessments, considering fraud as well, and those are assessments too, then they're from, okay, what are the risk of inherent across agency? So then really I was focused on keeping goals in the day, so we just have overhand-laden certain things we have, logical, methodology, and structure into formals versus assessments. So then the form on trauma-flow assessments.
And then once we identify those key controls, then of course we accept those on a periodic basis across agency. Use the results of those assessments to inform management on areas of improvement, or the new stories as well to provide assurance, obviously. And then provide feedback on whether the risk of a type is being maintained as established, leveraging those controls. However, in certain cases where the results of our assessments identify the you know, the term of fraud efficiency is to provide also a feedback loop to inform management of additional risk mitigation steps that may be needed, and how fat and membership take action as well.
Because then on the various levels of the very open-term controls, the business that we've made it by the part refraid that one. That's okay. Well, so let me ask you this, I mean, back from the beginning, I know a lot of agencies have something that is good to have ERM and internal control is kind of part of the same program, and some like to keep it separate. I don't know, what is your opinion on that?
Do you have a feeling either way? Yeah, my professional opinion, but that is, I don't think it should be separate. You know, understanding the language of the expanded won't be circulated once 23. I think the heart of the ERM is to, you know, to break down the silos.
So that's been the USA way. So to speak, so when doing that, you know, in practice, you know, like what does that mean, right? You don't have a separate ERM program and not allowing internal controls from your ERM decision-making practices. So, you know, looking at internal controls, you know, could be framed as, again, as you're developing that, choosing plans at the cafe down to the program level, you should rely on your internal control system to, you know, mitigate majority of those risk at various levels.
And which, you know, we take into account, you know, the DAL green book, start from any level of controls down to the business process level, and everything in between management, service providers, and so forth. So with that, you know, looking at internal controls as their potential risk indicators, you know, to give you an indication that, yeah, everything is going well based on the results, your assessments, or everything is not going so well, and you should take it action in doing that. So I think, you know, our approach again, is to have, you know, really getting ready in programming with internal controls being a key component of the strength and effectiveness of that ERM program. Right, you know, I think some of that early, you know, feedback probably was because, you know, I guess folks might have thought it was an issue if, you know, because internal control program standard is just be out of CFO office concentrating on the financials and ERM's supposed to be, you know, much wider scope, of course, but it sounds like, you know, agencies like yours, or you really are looking across the entire enterprise, you're going to have to focus on the financial statements, right?
Absolutely, and as you mentioned earlier, and that's where I was advertising, I really articulated that, you know, we're looking at, you know, in perspective, holistic perspective, not just the financial perspective, but all the upfront properties that, you know, proceed the financial reporting. And then it allows us to really focus on who calls issues as well, you know, whether it was some external orders, but also our internal control assessment to really tackle things again holistically. And I just, you know, focus on the band-aid fix, or that what I call the whack-a-mole approach of, say, you know, one issue that may be identified, you know, kind of series of, you know, amounts of treasury, you know, unbacking to our items, but what is it we call it that, you know, or is the contract and officer community, you know, well-trained in their resources, and are they able to, you know, manage their contracts as a ratio to contracts, a personnel, you know, really effective for the overburdened. So it really allows us to do a deeper dive.
So when we do put, you know, remediation efforts to, you know, strength and risk mitigation strategies, those strategies want to deploy, and we have confidence that are sustainable and not to the band-aid fix. Good. So I kind of want to loop it back to the beginning a little bit. We started off talking about risk appetite, you know, you guys put out your statement a while ago.
You know, some of the inputs that you've seen so far, you know, is that something that you guys are thinking about adjusting your risk appetite or how often would that happen? And what would cause you to want to adjust to maybe your risk appetite a little bit? Yeah, no great question. So one of the things, you know, we're evaluating this.
Of course, the impact to the pandemic COVID-19 has on the agency operation. So then in response to, you know, our mission objectives to provide a mandatory, especially, you know, when it comes to global health objectives and programs as well, to, you know, we want to get VA to the urban country as soon as possible. And those circumstances, we have to evaluate, are we willing to, you know, accept more risk in order to achieve those objectives? But in doing so, understanding what is the health of our internal patrol system to do that?
Do we feel confident doing that to, you know, provide assurance that again, you know, the risk that may be identified won't create the risk of, you know, the effectiveness. So then we can have mechanisms like the teams that are in the sector, and we're expecting this out, they get into the proper risk of the end. But that's definitely one major, you know, area that has impacted our evaluation of the risk appetite, but also just doing normal transformational efforts across the agency, constantly evaluating and balancing the levels of risk. You know, we say, hi, we do have a high, in a certain scenario that we should be, but after that, we should be very risk.
You know, the bill is a scenario that's a way of caution. So, if you're in COVID-19, some of the risk appetite could be, you know, kind of a near-term, short-term basis, and it would be, you know, source peak, tighten the buildup again. Understandings of objectives that need to be, you know, be made in a time of error. So, it's some of the fact that we definitely get to her as we, you know, adjust our risk appetite, and then make it more of a, you know, kind of a, other than, you know, practice and document, again, using as a guidance document to follow, you know, key disciplines and principles, but using it to our advantage, again, to achieve those objectives.
But not just having something kind of, you know, a different zone that maybe, you know, somewhat stale, but potentially having conversations with our agency leadership on how to best deploy those different risk appetite and tolerance of that support zone, that's right. Right, yeah, and you made a really good point, actually. You know, you were saying, you know, if agency's already got really good internal controls, then you can kind of, you know, maybe in an emergency time, you can kind of loosen some things up, but you have some confidence that you have strong controls. You know, maybe strong systems or procedures to review things so that, you know, you'll still catch stuff, or you can quickly take care of an issue if it comes up after the fact that you do have a strong internal control core, right?
Right, exactly. The thing that we do factor in that, and again, you know, different scenarios will vary. So that's where we really take a deeper dive evaluation of various circumstances to adjust our risk appetite accordingly. Understand that we're trying to achieve, for sure.
And then going back to the earlier discussion point of, you know, using data to help make those decisions as well. And that's where the point of data always comes into play, and it grants me the things. Right, yeah, that makes sense. Yeah, all these core fundamental things are strong, and you have good data, you know, way to analyze the data, then you can take advantage of more opportunities or whatever you want to think about it.
That's good. Exactly, and then Jessica, we can, you know, be somewhat adaptive to change the scenarios, again, in fact, with COVID-19, and then as well as how, you know, the impact of the playa chain management, you know, as well, and impact our operations. So, you know, look at things of that nature as well, how do we adjust, sort of, return the decisions and so forth, to put it in a better position. Great, well, I just had one more question for you.
A little more about the community in general, but I understand your part as some of the OMB working groups on ERM, and you're just curious, you know, what you guys have been working on, anything interesting to share with us as far as the work groups? Yeah, I think the value of the work group has been great. We have frequent work discussions just brainstorming to share best practices, how to navigate through certain OMB audits or certain things, any barriers that certain agencies may be, you know, certainly with, you know, good news stories, about like, what's the best practices. So, one of the key outputs that have been official recently has been our discussion, in conjunction with OMB as well, development ERM maturity models.
And it becomes from that, taking some of the best practices from our colleagues and the office of the chief college officer, you know, swim lane or business lane throughout the federal government, and how they conduct, and collaborate with the OIG to conduct the annual physical always as well. So, I use a, you know, following this standards and guidance and OIG metrics, you know, using maturity models scaling as well too. So, kind of taking some of those best practices and applying it to the ERM approach as well, has been, you know, I think will serve very well for you, I think, as I think across the government, and in the public, if that's one of the, again, one of the, the variables that we're, you know, we're working towards now to implement and then to a lot of reason why, you know, about ADC. Now, is that, so that maturity model, I heard you guys are working on that, is that something that's already done, or if not, when do you think, is that something that you would get out there and publish to the community?
Yeah, so I think for the working group, and I think it's still going under review, and I think the plan is to publish that sometimes this fiscal year, so some agencies have, you know, leveraged some of the draft language information to determine various models, various attributes, various maturity levels, how to best score it and scale it. So we'll be done at USA to celebrate just some of the basic principles of the model itself, articulate the value of that to our innovative leadership, gangsome sponsorship with doing so, and then really tailor it to our agency's operations and to how to, you know, make it intuitive. So some of the maturity, scaling, and attribution, and attribution attributes, you know, different to it, certain things from how we integrate, you know, you got to remember with the by-disribution process, how we integrate the R and with the by-chain management or cyber security, the sort of those maturity model levels, we use that to then define those attributes to give us some of the indication of the four cards, you know, areas that we want to continue to focus on against our mature, you know, our programs, particularly to some people, from a people process, and technology perspective, as well, too, so we can't wish to. We're going to allow those provide, again, feedback to our leadership in which to best and best, in those core companies, you know, capabilities that support those maturity models, that in terms of capability to our TDA, our overall mission practice, to develop our overseas as well.
We can turn, then, you know, allow them to then transfer that enough to develop in countries that we're providing aid to, to mean our overall objective with the journey of self-realization. Yeah, and that's the whole point at ERM is to support the mission, right? So I think that's a good thing to go out on. So, well, great, Marcus, I mean, thanks a lot.
I really appreciate you kind of taking some time to speak with our firm community here. And thanks again, I hope you're doing all right during all this stuff. Yeah, you too, I hope you, you're doing all your families with me today. So, definitely appreciate your opportunity, any kind of look forward to, you know, paying your conversations and the procurement to the ERM community at all.
Great, thanks again. Good night. That's our show, thank you for tuning in. Check us out, firm.org.
All our lovely podcasts are there. We're trying to keep these coming. Any suggestions, please let us know. Send us a little email there.
Any topic you'd like to talk about? And amazingly, some it's coming up, not too long, just a few months, so time has definitely flown. But, you know, this is a time of risk. So definitely a lot of things to talk about.
So, people have some more topics for you very soon. And until next time, this is your host, Paul Marshall, signing off for RISP Jets for the firm.