Hello, and welcome to episode 43 of Structure Visions. Structure Visions is a space where I explore new ways of thinking about social structure. My name is Jody Clark, and you are very welcome here. Thank you for listening today.
Today's episode, I'm going to give a title in advance, and we'll hope we stick to the topic, but the title is going to be called, Bye Bye Body Metaphor. We'll see whether we actually succeed with that, saying goodbye to the metaphor of the body. Now, don't worry, we're not going to say goodbye to the body, we're just going to say goodbye to it, as a metaphor. All shall be revealed.
And as always, if you'd like to check this out on the web, it's at www.structurevisions.wordpress.com. Go visit, read the notes, write a comment, maybe I'll write back to you, it'll be great fun. So I'm going to start today's episode, we'll link it back to the stuff I said last week, but I'm going to start off by telling you something that is very cool about me, just in case you wanted to know the thing that's cool about me. I'll let you spend a second wondering what it is.
And the actual thing that's cool about me is that I remember, I've got this really unique memory. I remember not knowing things. I can remember, I can look back, normally it's over my childhood, but sometimes it happens later in life, you know, me not knowing things, but I can look back over my childhood and I can pinpoint particular moments in time where I suddenly knew something that I didn't know before or I suddenly learned something that I hadn't learned before. And I can, that ability to sort of pinpoint that moment gives me access to the not knowing, the experience of not knowing.
Now that can be a very useful thing if you are someone who wants to challenge, challenge preconceived ideas. It can be very difficult to challenge a preconceived idea if you can't get outside of the conception of it. And sometimes the thing that helps you get outside of the conception of it is the remembering, not having conceived of it in the first place. I remember once reading a book, oh I can't remember the name of the author, but the book is called A Water and the Spirit Patrice, oh something, something, Patrice something.
Anyway, he was kidnapped by French missionaries away from his tribe in Africa and he managed to see if he was educated by these French missionaries. Patrice Melodoma Sime, there we go, that's his name. See, look I remember not remembering it. Anyway, so this is the memoir of this man who was living in a tribe in Africa and French missionaries effectively abducted him and put them in their missionary school and they sort of taught him at the school and at the age of maybe his teenage years he managed to escape, which was kind of something that people didn't generally do and he made his way back into the tribe and he asked to be initiated into manhood with the rest of his peers.
And they said to him, oh no we can't do that, we can't initiate, you can't go through the initiation process and he said well why not? And they said well because you've been schooled and now you're literate, you know how to read and in order to be part of the mysteries of this initiation you need to not know how to read. Okay, so that's already a fascinating idea. And they said to him, can you forget that?
Can you release that knowledge? Can you stop knowing how to read? Because if you no longer have your literacy then you'll have access to the mysteries that make you part of our tribe. And he's just laughed a little bit, now how can you stop knowing how to read?
How could you sort of consciously decide that you don't know how to read anymore? Now in any case they allowed for an exception to be made of initiative anyways, it's a fascinating story, a water in the spirit, Patrice Melodomo, so may I think. Anyway I at the moment can't forget how to read, I can't lose my literacy. But because of this unique, maybe it's not that unique, but because of this sort of special thing about my memory I can certainly remember not being able to.
And so I'd ask you that question, can you go back in time and remember not being able to read? But not just that I remember not being able to read but I remember looking at the words on the page and seeing the black and white symbols, so the black symbols on the white background and knowing that adults and older children could decipher them, they could make sense of it. And knowing that I couldn't, it was something I didn't have access to yet. And I remember specifically being in a church service, and I don't know why I was here, but I was with my neighbor's family, the neighbor family, I wasn't with my own family, and Mrs.
Walter was there with me, so she was the mom of my friends. And there was a hymn, that hymn was about to play, and she opened up the hymn book, and she put the hymn book in front of me, and so she was sort of, she and I were sharing the hymn book. And I remember looking at the hymn book and seeing the squiggly lines and knowing that they were words, but not being able to make sense out of any of them, and thinking to myself, oh, poor Mrs. Walter, she thinks I can read, and I can't read.
She's sharing this hymn book with me, but she thinks I can read, but I can't. I'll look at the words, and I know they are words, but I cannot make sense of them. And then suddenly I didn't know how to read, not during that church service, it wasn't that kind of miracle, but I do remember that experience of it being a mystery, of something that I couldn't quite make sense of. I also remember sometimes like learning certain concepts that I didn't have access to before, so I remember not knowing the word parents.
Now that would probably seem like quite a basic word, but I remember talking to a babysitter, and I remember exactly where we were, we were outside of the side of the house, and I can't remember what we were talking about, but I remember that the babysitter said, we'll tell that to your parents when they come home. And I said, parents, I said to her, what does parents mean? I didn't know the word parents. And she looked at me a little bit quizzically, and she said, your mom and dad.
And I thought, oh, wow, so these people, who are probably the people who have been around in my life the most often, there's a collective word for the two of them. They, for me, it was always mommy and daddy. You know, they were two distinct entities in my mind. And the idea that there was a collective word that encompassed both of them was totally new to me.
And so we're parents. And so, you know, an interesting idea. There's a concept, should be quite an intimate one. You know, the parents are the thing that you come into contact with the most.
And I didn't know that word. Okay, hold that thought. That idea of not knowing something, not having a conceptualization of something, not seeing things that are quite obvious, not knowing those obvious things. And now let's go back to last week, some of the things that we were talking about last week.
I would love to summarize last week's stuff for you. There's some really interesting things in last week's podcast, but I think if I try to summarize them, I would just repeat it all. So if you want to summary, I would recommend going back to episode 42, listen to the last 10, and then come back. So I'll wait.
You can, well, no, I won't wait. You can pause it. Go back and listen to the last 10, 15 minutes of episode 42 and then come rejoin me. Great.
Okay. So everybody's back. So you'll have in your mind the idea that I suggested that we think in terms of the social body and the human body, that we have those two entities, that we drop individual in society, we drop that dichotomy, we drop that binary and we replace it with a different binary, a binary opposition. We replace it with social body and human body.
And I connected all that up with Foucault and I connected that up with my own work. But the key things for you to have this image, one image of the social body and one image of the human body. And if you remember from last week's episode that you just listened to, last 15 minutes of, the question was where does the self go? What does the self attach to?
Does the self attach to the social body or the human body and how does that work? And I reveal that in most of the conversations that I analyze, or at least in a lot of them, the self associates with or identifies with or connects with the social body, not the human body, but it doesn't know it's doing it. It's dramatic irony. Okay.
So this idea that there's a social body and that there's a human body and that the self attaches to one of them would be an easy idea to dismiss. And so I'm going to find ways to discourage you from dismissing it because I think it's a fantastic idea. And so let's start with one way that you could dismiss it, quite legitimately. You could say, well, Jodie, look, the human body is a real thing and the social body is a metaphor.
And so you're asking me to compare apples and oranges. You're asking me to sort of say that these two things are in relationship with each other, but how can a metaphor be in relationship with a real thing? And so to that, I would say, fair enough, that's a legitimate concern. So let's rework it.
Let's keep social body, let's keep human body and let's decide whether they're both metaphors or whether they're both real. We'll put them on the same footing with each other. We won't say once in metaphor in one's real. We'll say that they're both something.
So we can either say they're both metaphors or we can say they're both real. I'm kind of happy either way. I'm going to aim as you could probably tell by the fact that I've called this episode by Body Metaphor that I'm going to go for. They're both real.
The reason I'm going to go for both real is because I'm going to say something is a metaphor and then somebody comes up with another metaphor and then there's another metaphor we've been doing in this podcast. I want to latch on to these concepts. I want to work with them. I think they're really valuable.
And therefore, I'm going to go with real because, you know, people, once something's real, it's real. Once something is a metaphor, somebody's coming up with another metaphor. I don't want to do that. So I'm probably going to go towards they're both real.
But we can work on either terms. We can go with either one. But in order to put them both on the same footing, there are likely two questions that are going to arise that we need to address. And the first one is, okay, well, if we were to see them both as a metaphor, how can the human body be a metaphor?
Right? That's not really going to work. It's really going to be real, and how can it be anything but? So that's question number one we have to address.
And question number two is, how can the social body be anything but a metaphor? Right? The social body isn't real. It's just a concept.
It's just a metaphor for something else. How can it be anything but a metaphor? So since I'm trying to get towards the position of both of those things are real, like I said, I don't really care. We can go with their metaphor if you want, but I'm going to aim towards their both real because I think that's kind of more useful.
So we'll start with going with the question how can the body be anything but real, and then we'll move towards the question, how can the social body be anything but a metaphor? So how can the human body be anything but real? How can the social body be anything but metaphor? And then we're going to sort of move towards, oh, is it possible to see them both as real?
Just, you know, for fun. Because why else would you do it if it wasn't fun? OK, so let's go to the question, how can the human body be anything but real? So you might have an answer to that.
But pretend you don't. Pretend that that question is still in your mind. How can the human body be anything but real? And experience not knowing the answer to that question.
And so you say to yourself, OK, well, if you don't know the answer to that question, you might be doing things like, like I'm actually looking at a computer screen right now that's blank, and so I can see my body reflected in my face, my torso reflected back at me. And so it's like, I can see that. And then right now I'm touching my shoulders. So it's like I can touch this thing that I'm calling a body.
And very often that's the sort of tester for us, just intuitively. It's the tester for something real. Can I feel it? Right?
Which is interesting, because you're using your human body to touch a thing. So you're using your human body to touch your human body. And then you decide that they're real, because you can touch it, et cetera. So this idea that the human body is real, is anything but real, is kind of difficult to get round.
So let's go back to the idea of what it's like to not know something. Right? So you've got this knowledge the human body is real. And let's see if we can take ourselves back to a moment before we knew that the human body was a real thing, that it was real.
And so I'm quite fortunate, because I do have that special memory. And I remember not knowing the word body. This is not to say I didn't have an experience of what I would later learn is the body, but I didn't know the word. So it's a little bit like parents.
Obviously I had an experience of those people who can be given the label parents. It's not like my parents came into existence when the word was introduced to me by my babysitter. But it's that I didn't have that concept of a collective thing that could be used to encompass the ideas of my mother and my father. So I didn't use to know the word body.
And I remember not knowing it. So what did I know? I knew words like of particular what we now call parts of the body. Like I knew head, shoulders, knees, and toes.
Like every two-year-old knows head, shoulders, knees, and toes. Head, shoulders, knees, and toes, knees, and toes. You kind of know knees and toes more because you repeat that one. So I knew head, shoulders, knees, and toes.
I particularly knew elbow because I remember I used to forget the word elbow all the time and I used to get elbow confused with shoulder. That's weird. And I'll tell you what else is weird about that. There's two words that I used to get confused in French all the time.
I could never remember the word for elbow in French. So elbow must be a part of my brain that doesn't want to conceptualize itself. The other body part that I knew was that I had a kind of emotional attachment to was the word for bottom because my mom used to call it the bumpy. She'd say, oh, sit on your bumpy.
And the reason I must that word was very, very had a right lit up part of my brain because I knew on some level it was a little bit of a taboo word, a little bit of a shameful word. It was a word that it was a body part that always had to be covered up. And it was always the one that I was falling on. I was kind of falling on that more than I was falling on my elbow.
So it was kind of like potentially painful. It always needed to be covered up. And there was a kind of sense in which that word wasn't the word that the grown-ups used when they were referring to it. And it had a little bit of a kind of taboo quality sort of shameful quality.
So I knew different words about that had to do with pointing to things, to parts that I would later learn was the body. But body wasn't a word that was circulating around when I was learning language. Now, I do remember the time when the word body came into focus for me. And this was watching this television program.
And I can't remember what it was called, but there was this man who would come on, like it was a PBS, a public broadcasting, television show for children that I used to watch. And it was this man that would come on and sing songs. And one time he was singing a song, he was singing the song, my body lies over the ocean. You might go, don't I'm going with this.
And the song, I am going to sing for you so you might want to, you know, you might want to fast forward about 15 seconds, in case you don't hear it. So the song goes, my body lies over the ocean. My body lies over the sea. My body lies over the ocean.
I'll bring back my body to me. Okay, so if you fast forward it, you're back. I'm done singing. And that's the song that he's sang.
And I could not make sense of the song because I didn't know what to make of that word, Bonnie, because I wasn't familiar with it yet as the name of a person. I also wasn't familiar of the idea that you put the possessive, I wasn't thinking in terms of possessive first person but the idea that you'd say like, you know, like my mommy I got, but not like my Jodi or my Jane or my Cindy. So I wasn't quite aware of this idea that you could put a possessive pronoun in front of a name. Again, I wasn't thinking in grammatical terms at that age, but it was unfamiliar to me.
So I couldn't imagine that the thing that would follow my would be a name. I'm not sure I even had that name yet anyway. Like I don't think I knew anybody. I later knew somebody, a good friend named Bonnie, but at the time I don't think I had that name.
So I had to, in my mind, replace the word Bonnie with something that was familiar to me. And that word, you know, my half guest, is the word body. My body lies over the ocean. So at that moment in time, I certainly knew.
Now I'm not saying that's the time in which I learned the word body, but at that point the word body came into focus. So now imagine the song. My body lies over the ocean. My body lies over the sea.
Bring back my body to me. Cause you know, my friends, I didn't know what to make. It's a sense about a Bonnie lying over the ocean. So instead I imagined a body, like a dead body, floating on the ocean.
So over the ocean, you know, switch the preposition rather than over, we can make it on, you know, cause for me over, over the ocean didn't make any sense either. I didn't know what to make other to me on the other side of the ocean. Again, didn't have those concepts yet. So over becomes on and there's my body floating on the waves of the ocean.
And then there's this kind of ghostly ethereal self on the shore saying, I want my body back. Oh my gosh, how cool is it to be able to have memories like that. So think about that then. That idea of my body and my, I must have been like three, who knows?
So here's my three year old self imagining this body. And what is the body to my three year old self? Picture it in the song, picture it floating over the ocean. It's a thing.
It's an object. It's completely passive and it's mostly dead. It's this dead object floating on the ocean. That's the thing that I'm associating body with.
It's certainly not the same thing as like head, shoulders, knees, and toes, which are things that I can kind of move and wiggle. You know, the body is this dead thing floating on the ocean. So going back and thinking about that early vision that I had of body, we could see it as a metaphor. It's like, it could be a metaphor for the experience of this physicality.
We could see it as this physicality, this flesh, the metaphor of it could be that it's a dead thing. It's an object, a dead thing that you can point to. So who else has done a metaphor like that? Okay, we could go to Yates.
Maybe you've already, maybe this has already popped into your mind. So sailing to Byzantium, there's a couple of lines and sailing to Byzantium by WB Yates. Yeah, but WB Yates. An aged man is about a paltry thing, a tattered coat upon a stick.
Okay, so classic lines that are used to explain what metaphor is. And effectively it's like you've got, it's an image. And it's an image that has something in common with the thing that the image is supposed to be representing, that it's supposed to be standing in the place of, you know, metaphor, the meaning is carrying over. And so we're supposed to look at a stick with a tattered coat over it and say, what does that happen in common with an aged man?
And so we say, okay, well, we could say that this stick is the sort of skeleton and the coat is the skin that is kind of wrinkly and that there's a kind of lifelessness to it, right? And here's the other thing, an aged man is about a paltry thing, it is a thing, an object. And not only is it an object or a thing, but it is a thing that has no agency or no life to it. A tattered coat upon a stick, there is no spark of life in those two objects coming together.
So here we have this idea of metaphor being a way of re-experiencing something. So whatever you might think about, I'm an aged man, if you go around thinking about aging men, whatever you might think about of them, Yates's line through the use of metaphor offers you the opportunity to re-experience that concept in a different way. So if you have some concept of a body without the term body, then the term body might be a way of re-experiencing your experience of living in a physical fleshy realm. So you think you didn't always know that you quote unquote had a body, do you know what I mean?
At some point as a child, you would have had to don the metaphor of having a body, like having this kind of fleshy, objectified thing. And then you imagine that like in science class in school, you would have been given pictures of this body and this body would have suddenly had all of these organs and this body would have had all of these systems, the digestive system and the circulatory system and the skeletal system and whatever. And so suddenly the body is a thing that functions in a particular way. And then it's like, ah, that's the metaphor for my experience of living in the world.
So there you go. There is an idea that the body could be understood as a metaphor, not as a real thing. Yeah, you know, you can touch this thing, but you don't have, you know, this flesh or the skin or the heads and the shoulders and knees and the toes and all that kind of stuff. But you don't have to experience it as a poultry thing.
That's a metaphor and you don't have to experience it as a body if a body means an object or a thing or an isolated term in relation to other isolated terms. You could see it as a metaphor. Okay, so we spent a lot of time on that. I don't really want you to see the bodies and the bodies.
I want you to see it as a real thing. But you already see it as a real thing. So I want to challenge you, I guess a little bit. The other thing I want to challenge your idea about is the question, how can the social body be anything but a metaphor?
I spent all these episodes talking about food going, talking about this great new metaphor. We're going to see this great new metaphor. We're going to see the social body and the social structure as a body. And, you know, if you remember from your school days that, you know, similes and metaphors, and as it turns out, metaphor is actually an umbrella term that can include similes and a simile is, you know, where you use the word like or as.
My brother is like an alien, you know, and it's a simile. It turns out similes also a type of metaphor. My love is as sweet as a popsicle. That's okay to my.
So the as and the like are the things that tell you that there's comparison being made. So that's the type of metaphor we call the similes. So I've been going around saying, we'll see the social structure as a body. And now I want you to entertain the possibility that it's not so much a metaphor, but it's a real thing.
Just for fun. It doesn't matter, we can throw any concept around it. We can pretend it's this and pretend it's that. But for now, let's imagine that it's real.
Ha ha ha, if you imagine something's real. If you imagine something's real. Anyway, so how can the social body be anything but a metaphor? So now you're going to argue with me.
No, it's got to be a metaphor because say what you want about this whole touching business. But there's a felt experience of being able to touch bodies. There is something to that. Something does feel real if you like when I can touch it and I cannot touch a social body.
I wouldn't know what I was touching. And therefore, I'll be happy to see it as a metaphor. Like the head of stage is like the head of a body blah blah blah. I can see it like that, but I can't touch the social body.
That's in the realm of the abstract. And therefore, in order to kind of make it more concrete, I need to see it as a metaphor. Okay, so now we're going to say, well, let's instead imagine that the social body is real. So now we're going to go back to some young selves.
This time, not my own. We're going to go back to some three to five girls. So I've mentioned before that when I was at college, I had a once a week job where I was like, oh, God, this was so much fun. I used to go in, I think it was every Wednesday morning to a Montessori school, preschool.
So there were three-year-olds to five, or three-four-and-five-year-olds. And I got to teach music for 20 minutes. Usually it lasted a lot longer than 20 minutes because I just get going on one. But I just used to love to teach these kids.
And we go in and every week there would be a different theme and there'd be something I'd be teaching them. And I just absolutely loved it. And so one week I went in and I was going to teach them about Beethoven. And I wanted to kind of convey to them that when Beethoven was writing that last, I think it was his last symphony, the ninth symphony, that's the O2Joy symphony.
Do, do, do, do, do, do, do, do. Sorry, I didn't want you to think. So when he was writing that, he'd lost his hearing. He was deaf when he wrote it.
And he was conducting it. When it was performed, he was conducting it. So he was facing the symphony orchestra. And he was conducting it.
And he couldn't actually hear the response when he was finished conducting. He couldn't actually hear how wild the crowd had gone over that particular symphony. Somebody had to tap him on a shoulder, reminding him to turn around and look. Anyway, so I wanted to kind of present this as an idea for the kids to play with.
So I started off by teaching them how to conduct. And we had so much fun. And we created a little symphony. And so the kids were sitting around in a circle.
And I said, OK, we're going to be a symphony. And the symphony we're going to be is the beach symphony. And you are going to be the seagull section. And you are going to be the kids playing section.
You're going to be the waves section. So we had three different sections to the symphony. And the kids who were doing the waves were going, whoosh. And the kids were doing the seagulls.
And they were going, oh, oh, oh. And the kids were doing the kids playing. Ah, that was a bunch of on seconds. And they were kind of chatting and giggling.
And so what I was doing with conducting is I had my arms up. And then I would focus my attention just on the wave section. Or just on the seagull section. Or just on the children section.
And then there would be moments where I was asking them all to do louder. And sometimes asking them to be quieter. And so I was kind of showing them that one of the roles of the conductor would be to focus in on particular sections of the orchestra in order to bring everybody together, or to get people to go louder or bigger or quieter. And so he had a nervous amount of fun.
And then the kids got a chance to try to conduct this thing. And then I said, OK, now I'm going to teach you about Beethoven. And Beethoven conducted his symphony, which was the ninth symphony. And so can you imagine how Beethoven would be conducting the symphony so they're imagining it.
And I said, OK, now, at the end of the symphony, when it's done, what happens? And then some of the older kids knew enough to say, everybody in the audience claps. So we got that part. And I said, so what does the conductor do?
And then we got out that the conductor turns around and bows. Well, everyone claps. And so I said, OK, so let's play that. Let's do that.
And so I put on the end of Beethoven's nine. It's not a tape recorder. It's not a tape recorder. It's not a piece.
Put that on the tape recorder. And I pretended to conduct. And I said, when it's over, you all clap. You be the audience.
And you watch what I do. So I conducted with my back to the kids. And then at the end of it, when it went quiet, all the kids clapped. And I didn't turn around.
And I didn't turn around. And they kept clapping. They clapped. And they still didn't turn around.
And I finally turned to them. And I said, why didn't Beethoven turn around? And they didn't know. And I said, do you know?
Because he was deaf, he couldn't hear you clapping. And I said, isn't that amazing? At the end of his career. I don't use it on career.
But when he was writing this, he couldn't hear. He wrote that beautiful song. And he conducted it. He couldn't hear it.
And he couldn't hear the audience clapping. That was going to be my big moment. The kind of, oh, wow, isn't that interesting? He's deaf and he couldn't hear it.
And so we were going to end on that. It was going to be really fun. But my friend, Aaron, he was doing about three. And Aaron said, Jody, how did he do that?
How did he conduct this orchestra when he couldn't hear it? And so I was like, oh, you know, how did he do that? And so I said, well, he did it with his mind. He imagined it.
And he was looking at me like, no, I still don't get it. And I said, OK, Aaron, close your eyes. I'm a teaching moment. Close your eyes and picture a tree.
So this is so sweet. So Aaron, actually, this is the beautiful thing about three year olds. They'll actually do what you say. He said to a group of 18 year olds who are 19 year olds who are as and do something.
They just look at you like, no, I'm not closing my eyes. I'm wise enough in the way of the world, not to close my eyes in front of all these people. Anything could happen. But Aaron closed his eyes.
And he suddenly spent like two seconds. He had his eyes closed. And his eyes sprang open. His whole face lit up.
He said, Joey, I could do it. And he could picture the tree. He closed his eyes. And he could see the tree in his mind's eye.
And imagine that. You can go to witness that moment where you suddenly realize you can picture something. You can bring something into being that you can't see, that you can kind of create it in your mind. And so here we have this work of the imagination.
We've got Beethoven's Ninth Symphony, which he couldn't hear. So he's writing it in and he can't hear it. Now, to be fair, composers can't hear the things that they've written anyway because they haven't written them yet. So they hear it in their minds ear and they compose it.
And Aaron saw the tree in his mind's eye. He saw the tree in his mind's eye. The tree didn't exist as a thing in reality. So you couldn't touch them.
You can't touch music anyway. But you couldn't touch the music. You couldn't touch the tree. You couldn't hear the music.
You couldn't see the tree. But it would be wrong to say that there are metaphors for something else. Metaphors is not the right word. A better word might be images.
Like the music is a sound image. And the tree is a visual image. An image of something that's real. But hasn't actually come into the world yet.
It doesn't yet have the physicality that we associate with being real. So it's not quite real, but it's still real. It's an image. It's an imagined thing.
So metaphor is the wrong word for what Aaron was seeing when he was picturing a tree. And it's the wrong word for what Beethoven was hearing when he was composing his symphony. It isn't correct. It isn't accurate.
It isn't on the mark to say they're metaphors or that they're not real. We can maybe use other words. We could use the word image, which I just tried. We could also use the word prototype.
It's a prototype. It's something. It's an idea that hasn't yet found its physicality. It's a model, maybe?
I always said image. So it's a real thing that hasn't yet has physical existence. It's like a hologram. It's a hologram.
You can actually see, I think. It doesn't have the weightiness of the physicality yet. So what if we were to see the social body like that? Not as a metaphor for something else, but as an image or a prototype, something that is there, but not yet fixed in physical existence.
No, it's a body. It's a body, but it's not yet fully formed in physical existence. It's real. The social body is real.
OK, so what does that do for us? If we see it as a prototype, then we get to see it as something that is coming into existence. And we get to see it as something that can have lots of different iterations. So the image of the panopticon from our stuff about Foucault is an image, not a metaphor, but an image of the social body, but one among many, many, many images.
And so you could look at it and say, mmm, that crazy about that image. And you say, oh, yeah, but it does show up. OK, yeah, that's fine. It shows up.
It has a little bit of physicality. But we could also imagine image and something else. We could also have a different prototype for the social body. So we could imagine it up, or we could see where other people are imagining it.
We could see where it's showing up in people's conversations. And we can see how this social body, which might not have physicality yet, nevertheless still exists such that we can describe it. And to get back to the point that I was making last week, we can see images of a social body that is not oppressive, that is not a bully. And we can put our attention to that in the same way that Beethoven put his attention to the old to joy.
You know, thank goodness he did. What a beautiful piece of music. So the social body, imagine it's real, but imagine it's not yet formed. And we get to see all of the different prototypes.
And we can imagine that there are many, many different prototypes of the social body. And we can see it in relationship with a human body. And we can imagine a much more mutually beneficial relationship between the social body and the human body. There's an idea.
OK, that's the idea for you to sit with for a while. Next week, we're probably going to apply that to some conversations. Or maybe we won't. In any case, I thank you very much for this thing.
And I hope you'll join me again.