Hello, and welcome to episode 44 of Structured Visions. Structured Visions is a space where I explore new ways of thinking about social structure. My name is Jody Clark, and I'm very grateful for you listening today. You are very welcome here.
This episode is provisionally called We Got Everything Back. And I'm gonna be picking up on some of the ideas that we were exploring last week and in previous weeks, specifically this idea that I was trying to put across, which was that the notion that it's really helpful to think of the social body. And it's really helpful to think about the social body in relation to the human body. So if we're gonna be exploring the social world and we're going to be exploring social structure, I'm saying a really good way, I think, to look at it, is to see two terms, the social body and the human body.
And there's lots of reasons why I've chosen those particular terms, which all of those reasons are intertwined in my various podcasts. But if we just focus now on the social body and the human body, and last week I proposed that we see the social body not as a metaphor, but as a real thing. Now, we could spend loads of time under the influence of our favorite substance, I don't know, a pint of beer, a glass of wine, a hair go sweets, anything that you want to do. But we could spend lots of time discussing the nature of reality and whether anything is truly real and all the rest of it.
I'm using the term real in a particular way. For me, the term real enables you to do things that you can't do otherwise. So I'm not trying to convince you that anything's real, but in as much as we sometimes think of some things as real and some things as not real, I'm asking everyone to think of all of it as real, all of the ideas, if you like, that I'm putting forward here, specifically the social body and the human body. So I'm just going to explore a little bit today about this notion, the social body is real.
And then the other idea that I would like to put forward is an idea that I hinted at at the end of the last podcast, which if I were going to summarize it is to say, the social body is real but has not yet formed. So last week I used the image of a prototype, something that is real but hasn't yet emerged in all of its concreteness. It isn't finished yet. It's emerging.
It's incipient. It's like a stem cell. It has all these possibilities, but they haven't necessarily come into fruition yet. So real but a prototype, real yet not yet formed.
So those are the two ideas that I'm going to focus on today in this episode. Now, I'll start with this notion of the social body is real. And I'm going to talk about this idea. First of all, that it is a body, and that body is a real thing.
And I'm going to compare it to how that's slightly different from a lot of social theory. So the social theory that attracts me the most is work in which theorists are critiquing social structures. You can imagine that's the, I look at social structure and think, oh my gosh, I really want it to be different. And so I'm always drawn to social theorists who look at the social world and say, no, not good enough.
This is not what we want. And even though I don't necessarily agree with every single aspect that the theory says, and I don't necessarily agree with their way of imagining these worlds, or I don't necessarily agree with all their arguments, I like their intention. And their intention is to say, I'm not going to accept those things that we're all expected to accept unthinkingly. I'm going to pull those things out.
I'm going to make people aware of them. And I'm going to question them. And I'm going to be critical of them. So feminist theories do this.
Queer theories do this. Marxist theory does this. Critiques of Marx do this. Foucault does this.
So all of these different types of theory all engage with the social world in a particular way. They all describe social structure in a particular way. And they all critique it. So for instance, for Marx, his critique was, look, there are particular structures.
There are particular economic structures at different points in history. And these structures determine potential ways in which groups are oppressed by other groups, and that these take on different forms. So in a capitalist system, if we look at a capitalist system, you will see the people who own the means of production, the people who don't own the means of production. There's an antagonism between them.
So there's an image of a social structure. And when we look at the world with that image overlaid, then we can see how oppression works. But then you might have a feminist theory that has a different way of understanding the social structure, which is to say, look, it's a patriarchy. And the patriarchy, when you overlay it over the world that you see, you recognize that there are particular ways of knowing.
And there are particular ways of doing things that are acceptable. And others that aren't acceptable. And the ones that are acceptable are all masculine. They're all masculinist.
And so there are all these ways of knowing and doing, experiencing that are put in the shadows, and that are seen as unacceptable in various ways. And then those are ways that are associated with the feminine. So that might be, that's not the only feminist way of looking at it. Or somebody like Butler, whose work is often used in queer theory, and she says, if you look at the world and recognize that overlaid over that world, or underpinning that world, is something that she calls a heterosexual matrix, which is this requirement that everybody be either male or female, and that if you're male, you desire females.
And if you're female, you desire males. And if you see the world as having that requirement overlaid on it, then you can see how certain groups of people, certain identities, are completely denied by that world. They're not intelligible. Or you have Foucault, who says, oh, we're living in a disciplinary society.
And its structure is the panopticon. And each individual is being consistently observed and has surveillance over them. And they're expected to command their own self and to be self-disciplined. And that is the operation of a particular type of power.
OK. So that was a kind of whistle-stop tour of various theorists. The idea there is any one of them could argue with any other of them. So a feminist theorist has said, oh, Marxist theorist, yes, you have this vision of the world, and I don't completely disagree with it.
But it doesn't take into account my vision of the world, which is how women have been oppressed over the years. Or Butler could cheat the feminist by saying, OK, yes, you have this image of the world, but your image of the world actually keeps the heterosexual matrix in place. And if you see it through my lens of the world, then you'll see something else happening. And so it seems to me that these theorists are all describing particular oppressive structures.
And each theorist has their own image. And I've been using the word overlay almost if you can imagine those overhead projector. Back in the days when we all used over, not everybody, but when teachers would use overhead projectors and you'd have that sort of thin film. And you could pretty much take any image, and you could draw another image on the thin film, and you could put that over top.
So if you had a picture of a teddy bear, and you drew horns on your overlay, you could put your overlay on top of the teddy bear, and it would suddenly have horns and turn into a double-ish teddy bear. You could take that over the off and put another one on. So effectively, that image of the overhead transparency, you could draw a structure on that. You could overlay it on the thing everyone is seeing.
And it would give you a different image. And again, I'm so grateful for that, because it does give you a new way of seeing things. And again, another image that I've been using is the word lens. It's a lens through which to understand the social world.
However, people could always argue about what lens you're looking through. And it seems to me that the best way really of dealing with that is by saying, OK, well, this is the lens I'm choosing to look at the social world through now. And for me, the problem is, OK, so when you look through a particular lens, the social world does look pretty bad. But it looks bad in a different way, depending on which lens you're using.
And if you were to try to say, please, really perse it word, if you were to try to fix what's wrong about the social world, the thing that you're fixing is determined by the lens you're looking through. So if you look through your feminist lens, you might fix something. And then if you put on your Marxist lens, then something else might have gone wrong. So that's in a nutshell, something that troubles me a little bit about social theory.
Now, the way that is dealt with, if you like, within the field is through the notion of a dialectic and argument and a debate that these things are in tension, that these things are in struggle. And so you could have a feminist position that might be in debate with a Marxist position. And then there might be a synthesizing that two different lenses to come up with a third lens, if you like. And that does tend to be the mechanism by which people engage with social theory is through argument and debate, which we like argument and debate.
I'd love to throw another mechanism into the soup, if you like. And that mechanism would be less like argument and debate, although argument and debate are certainly welcome, and more like something like discovery. And for me, that's the value of seeing social structure not as an overlay, not as a lens through which to look at the things that take place in our world, but instead to see this social body in the same way that we see our human bodies. And we say, oh, OK, there's this social body.
We don't really necessarily believe in it. We don't necessarily even know what it looks like. But wouldn't it be fun to discover some things about it? OK, so you've seen me.
I've had to kind of remove that critical in the sense of pessimistic and negative, that idea. I had to kind of put that to the side. And I've had to open things up a little bit and be a little bit naive. So I'm doing a willing suspension of critique and a willing openness to naivety, if you like.
So I'm not doing this unconsciously, but I'm doing it with a willing meiveness, naivety. And I'm proposing that we look at the social world with the spirit of discovery and curiosity. And for me, the social body, oh, there is this social body. I'm curious about it.
I wonder what it looks like. I wonder what shape it takes. I wonder what various shapes it takes. And for me, it's not like, OK, I'm going to propose that the social body looks like x, and you're going to propose that the social body looks like y, and then we're going to argue about it.
Instead, I'm going to say, I'm not going to propose the social body looks like anything. Instead, I'm going to look in the places where I think the social body reveals itself. And the weird thing for me is that I think the social body reveals itself in these everyday, tiny little conversations between people having a cup of coffee together or in little snippets of language used that you would otherwise completely reject, or really anywhere that people are using language, I think the social body reveals itself. So that's perhaps a difficult idea to get your head on.
But I'll just let you know that's kind of where I'm coming from, is that I'm looking at these little bits of language use, these little conversations. And I'm saying, if I look at this, if I look through my microscope at these little conversations, I'm seeing the microcosm of what the social body might look like and how it might be shaped. And that we also need to allow for the possibility that the social body hasn't yet emerged. So every time I look through my microscope, I'm going to see something slightly different.
I'm going to see a slightly different shape. And in some cases, I might see something that's in the process of emerging even as I'm looking at it. Right. So I'm being a little bit abstract.
So let's get concrete. So let's say I'm looking through my microscope at a particular conversation that I'm going to share with you now. And I'm going to put the transcript of that conversation on the blog, which is structurefissions.wordpress.com. And this conversation also is something that I analyze in my forthcoming book, I use the name I can't remember it that I've got.
I forgot this book coming. Cell Spodies in the Grammar of Social Worlds, is what it's called. And in this conversation, this is a conversation between three students. They're all about 20 or 21 years old.
Their names are Beth, Mariam, and Andrew. And in the bit of conversation that I'm showing you today, or that I'm sharing with you today, we just have Beth and Mariam speaking. And this conversation references another conversation that Beth had with her two friends. And I discussed that conversation in a talk I gave in Liverpool.
And you can find that talk under structurefissions. It's episode 35, Language and the Gendered Body. And in that talk, I described Beth's experience of being in school as a child and how she was bullied. And how effectively in the talk, I describe how her human body served as a kind of protective barrier to keep herself, if you like, protected from these people in her friendship group, who were being physically and emotionally abusive to her.
And so that conversation led on to Beth describing getting a new group of friends, a group of friends that didn't bully her. And in fact, not only did they not bully her, but they were also enormously supportive. So if you've been listening long enough, you might think, OK, I can see why J.D. likes this conversation.
Well, I like the conversation because Beth is not being bullied. And that's one thing. But I've also sometimes described the social body as a bully. And the social body bullies the human body.
And in the conversation that I'm going to share with you now, the social body is not a bully. And this moment is a really transformative moment in my discovery and understanding and exploration of the social body. Because to me, it offers a new perspective, a new emergent type of body that might come through. So what I'll do is redo the conversation.
Like I said, if you want to follow along, it's in structuredvisions.wordpress.com. And so here's Beth. And she's talking about a new group of friends. And mostly it's Beth.
And there's with Mariam and me contributing with minimal responses from time to time. If you're unfamiliar, by the way, with conversational transcripts, if you're following these, you'll notice a few little signals that come through the codings that you might not understand. So if you see a number like 0.3 or something in parentheses, that says how long in seconds the pause is, if you like. So 0.3 is 0.3 is 0.3 second pause.
And if you see sort of square brackets around something, that means that the things are being overlapped. So in lines 13 and 14, I've set at the same time that Mariam says, yeah. So there's just a little bit about hint on conversational transcripts. OK, so here's Beth talking about her new group of friends.
That group, they will do anything for me when Lewis died. OK, so just as a side. Lewis is a friend of Beths, was a friend of Beths, and he died tragically. And he was part of that friendship group.
So she's talking about the way they responded when they're a friend Lewis died. She says, that group, they will do anything for me. When Lewis died, I had two friends in London. I have one friend that were in York.
I had one friend that were in Leicester. Another friend that was currently abroad in Canada, they all came back. The day that we got a phone call, because Lewis's sister rang Rob, who's my best friend, and Rob rang me straight away. And I got in touch with Sam, who were in London.
Alex, who were in London. Aaron were away at Silverstone doing stuff for Formula One. So we got everything back. By the end of that day, Sam and Alex were on their way from London.
Nicola were on a plane from Canada. And everybody were back in Maysquiff, because we'd lost someone. So you don't mean it's like I've got such a good group now that I cannot look. We're a horrible time when I were getting believe everything that's happened since then, up until like a few years ago.
But I cannot look at that time to regret anything I did. Or even be angry at the people that hurt me, because they've made me who I am. And they've made it so that I've got a group of friends that can stand by through whatever. And I know they'll stand by me as well.
So here she is describing this group of friends, and she's describing sort of how supportive they are. So that's already a relief. She's got to be group of friends, and they're really supportive. But there's something I want you to notice about.
Well, there's actually lots of things I want you to notice about this. And we might not even talk about all of them today. We might explore some of them in an upcoming podcast. But let's think about this world she's describing, and how she construses it grammatically.
And let's imagine that grammatical structure gives us a window into a type of social body. And let's think about what are the constituents of that social body. So the first thing I want you to think about is, line one, that group, they will do anything for me. So one thing that we can talk about is the ways in which the concepts come forward.
And we've got two different noun phrases. There are two different representations of people in line one. That group and me. So that group is also referred to as they, third person plural, pronoun.
That group, they. So that's one side of the conceptual notion there. And the other is me. That group and me.
So we've got two components. We can even see that as two components of social body, if you want. We've got two entities, two elements. Now, the interesting thing is back when Beth was talking about being bullied, she talked about that group and me.
And again, you can go back and listen to me discussing that. But she never divides up that group. That group in the bullying extract is all about the group as one single entity. We see, look at this conversation.
That group gets further differentiated. That group does not remain as one solid entity. It's an entity that has lots of different constituent components of it that are grammatically represented in a number of ways. So how is that group represented?
OK. Well, right away on line one, when Lewis died. OK, so Lewis, the proper name Lewis, is the sort of lexical component, that one name, proper name. We have an individual self here, Lewis.
So already the group is being understood in terms of its different components. And then we keep going. I had two friends in London. I had one friend that were in New York.
I had one friend that were in Leicester, another friend that was currently in Canada. So this is interesting. That group gets further differentiated into friends. So here we've got an eye.
And then we've got friends. I had two friends. I had one friend. I had one friend.
I had another friend. So we've still got a binary between the eye, the first person, self, and another human constituent, the friend. But interestingly, each friend is differentiated. Now in this little series, the friends are not named yet, but they're still distinguished from each other.
And they're distinguished by virtue of their location and space, right? So I had two friends in London. So we've got a prepositional phrase that says, you know, in London. So two friends in London.
Those two friends are distinguished from other friends. One friend that were in New York. So we've got that were in York, which is called an embedded clause. And so the one friend that were in York is grammatically distinct from, say, the one friend that were in Leicester, right?
And those two components are grammatically distinct from the two friends in London. And all of them are grammatically distinct from the other friend that was currently abroad in Canada. So what's interesting here is that in this social body, we have individual constituents of it. And they're all related to Beth through what's called a relational process of possession, the hat.
I had, I had, I had, I had. So she has these friends. And not only does she have them as a kind of clump, she also has them as individuals. And she grammatically construes them as distinct from each other, and yet part of the wider group.
And she is in relationship to that wider group. So we've got a self in relationship to a wider social body. And the social body is composed of distinct components. If you remember a while back, I was having a conversation with society, and I said, I just don't think that you allow for individuality.
Well, here the social body does. The social body does allow for individuality. In fact, the structure, the grammatical structure in this account is one that enables them there to be both the image of the wider group and the individual constituents that are in relationship to each other and to the wider group. So then what happens?
It keeps going at line six, starting at line six. OK, that day we go to phone call. We're going to come back to that day. We go to phone call.
Lewis's sister, Rang Rob, who's my best friend. So we've got a couple of proper names now. So not only do we have individual constituents, before the individual constituents were identified, construed syntactically, through syntax, one friend that were in York. And now they're going to be construed lexically through the use of proper names.
So using one word to show that they are distinct entities. So Lewis's sister, OK, so there's an entity, Rang Rob. OK, so we know Rob is distinct as a distinct component, because Rob is a proper name. But then Rob gets even more flavor to him as a distinct entity.
Who's my best friend? So we know who Rob is, and we see Rob as a distinct entity in relation to the self, in relation to the speaking self. Rob, who's my best friend? And Rob rang me straight away.
And I got in touch with Sam. And so then Beth gets in touch with Sam, Alex, Aaron, Nicola, et cetera. OK, so now we've got proper names. So here we have a social body with unique individual entities in it.
And those entities are construed as a relationship to each other and in relationship to the body, as a whole. Now, watch this. OK, I got in touch with Sam. Sam, who were in London.
Alex, who were in London. Now isn't that interesting? Before we had two friends in London, and now we've got two distinct friends who are named. And Beth isn't worried about the fact that she's going to be repeating herself with those embedded clauses who were in London, who were in London.
Because what's happening here is that they are getting distinct. They're getting their distinctness through the use of their proper names. Sam, who were in London. Alex, who were in London.
Aaron, we're away at Silverstone doing stuff for Formula One. So we got everything back. This is interesting, right? It's not just that these components of the social body, these individual selves, these individuals, it's not just that they're individual, but we're being told where they are in time.
We're being given their sort of static location in the world. London, London, Silverstone, Canada, York, Leicester, right? We're being told where they are. So we've got a spatial dynamic.
We've got the notion of the different component entities, but we've also got them located on a geographic grid. And then what happens next? You're picturing them in the various parts of the world. No, Leicester, York, Canada, London, Silverstone.
You're imagining it in all these places. And then what happens next? They all move back to the home village, which is MhCliff, which is in real place, but I didn't want to say what the name of the village actually is, for a sake of anonymity. So by the end of that day, line 10, Sam and Alex were on their way from London.
Nicola were on a plane from Canada, and everybody were back in MhCliff, because we'd lost someone. So you have the image of the social body. It's spread out geographically. You have the image of the individual distinct, unique components of it, and you have them all moving back to MhCliff.
And they're moving back there in relationship to each other, in relationship to Beth, but also in relationship to what has happened to the social body, which is we'd lost someone line 12. So the social body is suffering a wound. The individual components of the social body move, and they go to where the wound is, because healing needs to take place. So this is interesting, a social body that's structured in a particular way that moves in relation that accommodates, that emerges in a different form, because something has happened to the social body.
Now, here's another really interesting thing that happens grammatically. If you were going to describe somebody traveling from London to MhCliff, which is this village in England, what would you say? They flew, they traveled, something like that maybe? They flew, they took a flight from London to MhCliff.
And so, sorry, from Canada. Because they're traveling from Canada to MhCliff. They're flying from Canada to MhCliff. They took a flight from Canada to MhCliff.
If you were using any of those words, fly, travel, take a flight, those are material action processes. And one of the things about material action processes is that they indicate that the person doing the action is the one who is putting forth the energy in order to do the action. So if I walk across this room, I'm the one who's putting forward the energy to walk across the room. Now, that's not the way it's considered in this transcript.
That's not the way Beth says it. She says, Nicola, we're on a plane from Canada. She were on a plane. She was on a plane.
So being on a plane is not, we're on a plane is not a material action process. It's a relational process. And one thing that can happen within a grammar, and this is something that MhCl without an input of energy from the key participant in the relational process. So Nicola were on a plane.
She isn't construed as the one who's putting forward the energy. Now look at the rest of them. Sam and Alex were on their way from London. They were on their way.
They didn't travel from London to MhCliff. They were on their way. It's expressed as a relational clause. So this construes the idea that there is change without Sam and Alex being the ones who are doing the change.
Everybody were back in MhCliff. Again, a relational clause that doesn't show an input of energy from the people who are involved in the process. And so the way I want to look at that is the way it's been construed here is not so much that individuals are moving. But instead, the wider social body is compelling a movement of the whole social body.
It's compelling the individual components to shift their position. It's not so much that the individual components are deciding. It's that they're shifting their position. So here we have this idea of a social body with individual components in it who are in relation to the body as a whole and they're in relation to each other.
And their movements are compelled by their relationship to that social body and the social body's sense of loss and need for repair or healing, of getting everything back. We got everything back. Where's that? That's on line lines 9 and 10.
We got everything back. So she's not even saying everyone. It's not every individual person. Suddenly it's like the body is restored because we've lost someone.
So I love this image because not only do I love it because it shows this image of these really supportive people but because we can see a construction of a type of group that is a group that is consisted of individuals who are in relationship to the group. And to me, it resembles the healing processes, if you like, of a human body or of anybody. It's the kind of emergent network that we see when we start exploring the ways in which bodies work or natural processes work if you like. And the other thing that's interesting about that is that we got a phone call.
It's not like the whole body got a phone call that Beth is construing it as if the body got the phone call. And we're going to explore that idea a little bit next week because we're going to look at how the self is construed. Excuse me because I've said that the self can attach itself to the social body or the human body. And here we're going to talk about the various ways in which the self flickers in and out of the social body here which we'll talk about next week.
The thing that I most want to draw attention to is if we see this as an expression of a potential social body, one prototype of the way a social body might form, then we can look at this, we can compare it to other prototypes that show up in different conversations, but we can notice about this that it's a prototype in which bullying isn't happening. We also can see in which there's a prototype of a social body in which the individual is recognized and acknowledged and that the individual is seen as in relationship to the group, to the body, to the social body, and that relationship is not antagonistic. And what's more, we can see the social body as emergent taking a new form. And I think this offers a really lovely window if you like to go back to that lens metaphor of understanding the social world as a whole.
So thank you very much for listening today and I hope you'll join me again next time.