Episode 51 - Sarah Goode: A Night Out Turned Nightmare

Episode Description: In the quiet town of Medford, New York, 21-year-old Sarah Goode was a devoted young mother, full of laughter, promise, and love. When she disappeared after a night out in June of 2014, her friends and family knew something was wrong. What followed was a desperate search, a devastating discovery, and a heartbreaking trial that would expose a predator hiding in plain sight. In this emotional and powerful episode of Total Conundrum, we tell Sarah’s story—not just the crime, but her life, her legacy, and the people who continue to honor her. From childhood memories and her deep bond with her daughter Jocelyn, to the haunting forensic trail that led to her killer, this is a case that will stay with you long after the episode ends. Inside this episode, we cover: Sarah’s early life, motherhood, and deep bond with best friend Nicole Lucas The night she disappeared and the panic that followed The shocking discovery of her car—and what police found nearby The forensic evidence that brought justice The courtroom showdown and the judge’s chilling words The complicated aftermath of Dante Taylor’s prison death and lawsuit A heartfelt tribute to Sarah’s legacy and the loved ones who still fight for her memory This episode was recommended by listener Summer Rain. Thank you for helping us share Sarah’s story with care and compassion. Watch & Listen Everywhere: YouTube: Subscribe Here Patreon: Support & Get Exclusive Content Bonfire Merch: Grab Your Conundrum Crew Gear! Follow Us for More Creepy Content: Website: https://totalconundrum.com/ Instagram: @Total_Conundrum Twitter/X: @Total_Conundrum Facebook: @TotalConundrum #SarahGoode #TotalConundrum #JusticeForSarah #TrueCrimePodcast #MedfordNY #DanteTaylor #TrueCrimeCommunity #RememberHerName #ConundrumCrew