Episode 7: Making the Case (FULL)

Vik and Jacob are joined by special guest Noah Averick to trumpet the Hall of Fame cases for three borderline candidates. Jacob's nominee was an icon and a machine when it came to 30 homer/30 steal campaigns, but the advanced metrics don't quite reflect his impact on the game (3:32). Vik touts the résumé of one of MLB's quietest stars of the 2000s; a player whose baseball-reference page would shock most visitors (30:48). Finally, Noah surprises even the hosts with his mystery wide receiver: a noted head case whose statistics stick out even in the golden age of the wideout (1:06:00).