Hello again everybody and welcome into another edition of Political Beasts. A presentation of National Review can find us on Twitter at political underscore beats. For many of you to subscribe to our feed for new episodes through Apple Podcasts, Google Play, Stitcher, or TuneIn or go right to nationalreview.com. In the corner, click on Podcasts to find all the fun in our podcast including this one right here.
Listen, enjoy, share, please leave reviews for the program. My name is Scott Bertram, you can find me on Twitter at Scott Bertram. My tech team partner standing by us always is Jeff Blair. Jeff, how are you?
I've had enough of your pre-medinal ways. I've had enough of your drug at all grants. I've had enough of the way you try to constantly make us do podcasts about three subs. So you know what?
I'm hearing you from the podcast and I'm putting a horse on the next one with me. That's right. I'll kick you out and then find someone else with the same last name to actually fill in for you. Perhaps.
At Esoteric CD on Twitter for Jeff. And our guest on this program is the editor at large and editor at large reason, co-author of the Declaration of Independence, how libertarian policies can fix what's wrong with America, a PhD in American literature, and a former teen magazine editor, find him on Twitter at Nick Gillespie. He's Nick Gillespie. Nick, thanks for joining us.
Thank you for having me. I have been waiting my entire career for this because I somewhere deep in my online bio, I was a team magazine editor back in the late 80s, I go spread an advice column for Alissa Milano for a year at Team Machine. But at the same time, I was working for a bunch of lower tier rock magazines and metal magazines like Metal Edge and Metalix. It'll rock you to shreds, smash it.
It's the American version of that. And I love deep in my bio. I mentioned that I'm probably the only political journalist who has interviewed Ozzy Osbourne and Milton Friedman. So this world's are colliding here and it's going to be kind of great, even if we have to talk about David Crosby a lot.
Nick, before we get into our band today, you give us a snapshot there, but tell us a bit more about what you do now at reason and podcasts and things like that. Yeah, so I'm an editor at large at Reason Magazine, which has been around since 1968, which was an excellent year for the birds, to say the least. And for a lot of music, not so great for the country, but we can get into that. But I joined Reason Magazine in the fall of 1993.
I was coming out of an English or American literature PhD program, which I wrapped up a couple years later. I record videos and podcasts and write lots of articles for Reason. I was the editor in chief of the print magazine for years that I was the editor in chief of our website and I launched our video platform, Reason TV, which is all over the place. And I was hired in 93 mostly because I was talking about things from a libertarian perspective.
But I was talking about culture. That's my first love. I was an arts and entertainment editor at college and that's the kind of stuff that I've always loved. And nothing more than rock music struck me.
I was born in 1963, so I'm getting up there. I was in the tail end of the great rock era. And nothing was more expressive. Nothing was more fantastical.
And rock music was the genre, at least for the medium of expression, certainly for men, increasingly for women in my time. And I have a weird just as the birds, and particularly Jim Roger McQuinn, toggles between a ridiculous folk ethic and some kind of outer space, bizaritron. I am trapped between the world of culture and politics. And I write a lot of stories, unfortunately, that are the literary or journalistic equivalent of CTA 102, or just bad mixings of folk music and electronic.
And as listeners know by now, we are looking at the birds today. You might know them from their jelling, jangling guitars, their pristine harmonies, their eclectic body of work through their career. But Nick, we turn the floor back over to you. Tell us why you love the birds, how you got into them, and why other people should care about this music that they made.
I appreciate not just in this instance, but the platform that you give on this podcast to talk about that kind of stuff. For me, what I love about the birds is first off. This is what I'll probably tear up at this point. But rock music is simultaneously off the rack stuff.
It's like, up until recently, certainly you couldn't amend it. It was like buying a jacket off the rack, and you weren't allowed to alter it or make it fit you better, anything like that. It's mass-produced stuff. But it has an intensely personal connection.
I came to the birds because I had a cousin who was about 20 years older than me died a few years ago, who was a hippie. I mean, this was a guy who was the son of Italian immigrants, fought with his parents, rejected that they had not more rejected. And trust me on this, I can take both the parents' side and the kids' side. You know, rejected the consumerism and the materialism of a post-war America.
And I think about his parents who were first generation, growing up speaking Italian for a thousand years, his parents, my grandparents, had been bred to be serfs and peasants and worked less than the crops that they were raising. And so, you know, Italy, and then you get this kid who gets to grow up in this great flush material moment after the red depression after World War II. And finally, everybody was getting rich. And my cousin, that had been rejected a lot of that.
And he did so for good reasons. Like he's the guy, at some point he was getting rid of a bunch of record albums and he gave me this massive sack of vinyl in these, you know, classic 60s records where each one was about six inches thick and, you know, a couple hundred pounds. And on that in particular, what I remember is that there was a Columbia record sampler called Our Best to You. There were two albums, one was green and it was like old people's stuff.
And then the orange cover was like hippie, you know, kid's stuff, although it wasn't completely that. And on this Our Best to You, they had a cover, one of the tracks was The Birds All I Really Wanted to Do. And I heard that song and I was like, I'd never heard anything like it and it excited me. I was into The Beatles.
I stumbled into this in the mid-70s, probably about 1977, or there. And I was like, God, this sounds like a lot of music that I hear now, but it's so different and it's so fresh and exciting. And as it happened, I was listening to that. And then PBS, you know, as a good libertarian, I hate to admit that PBS, PBS is my favorite.
Yeah, where I learned, you know, I learned about Penn and Teller. So, you know, I grew up in the New York area and they were on Channel 13 all the time. There was a British TV show that was a history of popular music, although you need its love. And as it happened, I listened to The Birds All I Really Wanted to do, you know, 10 years, or 10, 12 years after it had been released as a single for them.
And then I caught the episode of All You Need Is Love. That was about The Beatles and The Birds and Roger McGwen was one of the characters talking and I was like, this band is incredible. So I went to my library and they had a copy of Fifth Dimension, the album, you know, the true kind of breakthrough album, I think, for them where they moved from folk rock to psychedelics. It was all about, you know, 8 Miles High is on that.
I went to a record store in my area and I started looking at old Birds Records. And you know, it just poured out from that. What I love about The Birds is that I think they are trying to grapple with a strong tradition because most of them came out of a folk tradition and we're really serious about that. But they also kind of like my cousin had grown up in a world where all things were possible and they wanted to let their freak flags fly as quickly as possible.
And you know, in their work. And I think, you know, you see this because they went electric with Dylan songs before Dylan did, but there's this constant toggling between traditional forms and kind of respect and knowledge of that. And then we're an experimentation and a love of gadgetry and gimmickry. We might even extend that in the social sphere to David Crosby's ill-fated, you know, early attempts at polyamory, you know, which helped get him kicked out of the band and all that kind of stuff.
But, you know, they, to me, kind of encapsulate both the promise and the failure of the best aspects of the 60s counterculture. And then they tried to be kind of communal. They had five guys, you know, from Pokedchun to the band. Most of them were songwriters, all of them were performers.
Of course, it couldn't last. But they imagined a world of Renaissance Fairs, you know, which is a time of one of their songs of, you know, kind of like hippie, communal, Monterey pop scenes forever and ever. And, you know, and they couldn't live up to that. And then I also, and we can get into this more, you know, what kept happening is that the real world kept encroaching both on their music, their collaborations.
And they ultimately did not have the talent to close the deal. I think in the late 60s, if they have been able to put out a truly great record, things might have been different. But in any case, I love their music. It's bright, it's shiny, it's happy, and it's also incredibly sad and tragic.
And in this, I think, they share something with the Beach Boys where, you know, everything they're talking about are wide open spaces and, you know, freedom and love and all of this. And somehow you just know they aren't depressed as hell, and it's not going to end well. I couldn't never find a chance to choose between them. Yeah, I get the reality of their human conditions, kept on bringing them down when they could have soared higher.
The thing about the birds for me, and this is, because I come from a much different generation, I come from 1980. So, and we grew up, of course, everybody knew about like Mr. Tamborine, and everything turn, turn, turn. These are all common places, all right?
But it was when I finally got an album called Younger Than Yesterday, just on an alarm. Somebody said, like, oh, this is the best birds album. If you really want to explore this band, that's where you start with them. I got that album, and I heard when it's not fair, I heard Have You Seen Or Face, I heard So You Want to Be A Rock and Roll Star.
I heard all these songs, and I heard Mine Gardens, too. And I was stunned by this band. It wasn't just what I considered, you know, because what's the rap has always been on the birds. Oh, you know, they were just doing cover artists, man.
You know, they didn't really do anything particularly original. They were just, you know, they covered but doing songs, and they were good for that, but who really cares about the album? My God, what a bunch of them. Yes, that is.
I got, you know, we did our Beach Boys show with Matt Welch. I talked about how I kind of had a chip on my shoulder. I've always had a chip on my shoulder about the Beach Boys once I discovered the fullness of their discography. I kind of have a similar chip on my shoulder about the birds.
I think there are, you know, I have my little personal list of, there are the five, you know, my five favorite bands, and then there are the five objectively greatest and most important bands of all time from like the post, from the modern rock years. So after Elvis and Chuck Berry and all that. And you know, it's the Beatles, the Stones, the Hoobop Dylan, but the fifth one is for me, the birds. And when I mentioned that, people say like, what are you high?
You know, you're talking about, I'm like, no, I don't think you know what you're talking about because they're responsible for not one, not two, but genuinely three of the most important revolutions in rock music, creations of, in explorations of new sub genres. They invented practically with their first album, they invented folk rock. Then as you pointed out, they invented psychedelia and you know, like psych rock with eight with eight miles high and a fifth dimension. And then, you know, just when you think they're going to be doing that for the rest of their careers, boom, they completely change directions.
And then they invent country rock, which is, you know, talk about a neck, neck, you know, neck snapping left turn for them. But it maybe it isn't as much of a left turn when you think about their actual discography. If you go back through it in detail. Just play it.
A honky-punk song. One more I keep saying. And then I'll go home. What good will it do me?
I know what I'll find. And if the bottle of broken heart and you're still on my mind. But these guys were so influential, they were so important. And not only that, if the only argument you could make for the birds was that they were influential, that wouldn't really be a very powerful argument.
The fact is that this music is beautiful. It was first six albums in particular. They're almost flawless. I think fifth dimension ironically, maybe the one that has the most filler on it.
But everything else has just so much to recommend that there's beauty just sort of, you know, exploding out of these albums. And it's kind of also a classic example of how a group dynamic can be one of the more fascinating aspects of the band. So like, how did this group come together? It was Roger McQuinme meets local Seinstur and coffee shop Jackass, David Crosby, who has all the good weave.
And that's why everybody knows him. He's got the sons that strip handing out joints to people. And then they meet Chris Hellman, who kind of comes out of a bluegrass background. He's the only one who has a vaguely country background.
The other guys are folkies. And then they find a guy named Gene Clark, who just happens to be an incredible songwriter. And what people who aren't familiar with the birds don't realize is that Gene Clark was like the backbone of the band for their first two albums. And then they literally find a guy playing bongos on the beach.
You can't play drums, but he looks almost like a dead ringer for Brian Jones. And the Rolling Stones are super cool. So they're like, all right, you're going to learn to play drums. And that's Michael Clark.
And he actually did like really drums pretty decently. So you know, give him credit. He did learn. But that's how the band comes together.
And in a weird way, you know, people always made fun of the monkeys. They were manufactured by a corporation. But you know, the birds have a slight bit of that in their background as well. But it doesn't matter.
What they ended up doing, what they ended up creating, you know, starting with Mr. Tamborine Manning going onward is, you know, a legacy that, OK, there's a, there's a, I don't know if it's a pocket or not. There's a story that like when Tom Petty covered, so you want to be a rock and roll star for his live album like 1986 back up the plantation. Roger McGwen came up to afterwards and said, like, you know, thank you for doing that, man.
I was really worried that like no one was ever going to remember this music, which is, it kind of makes me feel sad because it's like, this is music that absolutely deserves to be remembered. And remember for all time, I think this is some of the best that, you know, classic 60s rock has ever brought out. I rank it up there with everything else in the pantheon. And there are probably a lot of people listening to the show who aren't really familiar with the deaths, greatness of the birds to the sky.
I'm just wondering if you can just find what you're talking about. When McGwen made a comment to Petty, I guess it was before the time life collection started coming out because one of my first memories of the birds, of course, is hearing turn, turn, turn, be the soundtrack to time life's, you know, rock of the 1960s, wherever the collection was. And so turn, turn, turn was like the first song they played in that commercial over and over and over again. I think at a point I hated it because it was so perfect.
It was like a perfect pop song. To everything, turn, turn, turn, turn. There is a season, turn, turn, turn. And it's time to every purpose.
I do that. One time to gain, a time to lose. I swear it's not too late. But my introduction to the birds actually is twofold.
One is what Jeff just mentioned, which is Tom Petty's live version of So You Want To Be a Rock and Roll Star from Pack Up The Plantation, was a relatively heavy rotation on MTV. It may be surprisingly so around the time of that release. And I really liked that song and I thought I was the birds. And then my secondary introduction was actually not until I got to college and I had a buddy who was more of a music aficionado than I was at that point, introducing me to all sorts of really cool stuff like love and big star.
And at some point he handed me a copy of Sweetheart of the rodeo and said, you've got to hear this. And I look at it as the birds. Like I kind of know the birds. He's like, no, you don't know the birds.
And so this is not your mother's bird. And so my entry point to a deeper background, the birds music was Sweetheart of the rodeo and the very brief grand parsons era of the band. And I was talking to a friend here at the office, we were six feet apart, don't worry about it. But he said, man, I love the birds.
And I don't know why they're not quite as well known or well respected or everyone to put it. And I did say, I wonder how the fact that they were so eclectic, the fact that they were so groundbreaking in many ways, meant that they weren't considered at this point like masters of it. They weren't, oh, that's the country rock band or that's the psychedelic band or they have their hands in all these different genres as they move through their career, always looking forward to try something new to try something different. And so I hope that one thing we're able to do here is sort of tie all that stuff together and give people a pretty more complete picture of what the band was and how freaking talented all these guys were really from start to virtually fish.
Lots of changes in band members, but all those guys brought something different. And all those guys wrote songs too. I think they all worked songs at some point for an album here or there. And so I hope that's one thing we can try to do here during the show today.
I mean, I already gave you part of the origin story of the birds, which I always think the funniest part for me is always that like their drummer couldn't actually drum. They just hired him because he looked like Brian Jones. It's a hilarious little factoid. But nevertheless, he learned how to do it.
And they had been getting for quite a while and working their way up. They actually started the beef ears, you know, because it was the British invasion, right? So they wanted to be like, you know, the guys with the big fur hats, you know, stand outside talking about Alice. So they were the beef ears and they were doing demo sessions, these all these demo sessions have been released.
And they were a little bit ragged, you know, there's a lot of the songs would never come back, but some of them would. And you hear them honing their sound. But it was the moment when their manager, a guy named Jim Dixon, gives them a demo that he's gotten from a guy called Bob Dylan, a song that hasn't been released yet. It was an outtake from the other side of Bob Dylan sessions.
It's called Mr. Tam Beringman. And suddenly Roger McGwin, who had been sort of high off of watching The Hard Days Night and seeing what the Beatles could do with their guitars on stuff like that title track, said, you know what, I've got a great idea for this song. And you know, thus, you know, this is where the ubiquity of the Rickin' Bocker 12 string comes into existence.
And by the way, you know, if you think about what's one thing that the birds are universally associated with, I would say it's the Rickin' Bocker. I can't think of any instrument actually in rock that is more singularly associated with one man than the Rickin' Bocker 12 string is associated with Roger McGwin, who at that time, by the way, was named Jim McGwin, another funny anecdote. Yeah. Now, you know, the other thing that I would add, which kind of gets glossed over is, and you're getting to it with Mr.
Tam Beringman, it's not like they were doing a knockoff of Dylan's version. They were creating something totally different. I think that's even more true with turn, turn, and I say this as somebody, you know, I tried to be a good folkie. I tried to, you know, Phil Oakes and Dave Van Ronk were better than Bob Dylan for many years.
I really don't myself to do it. I couldn't quite get there, but I really loathe Pete Seger as a concept and just as a performer. And it was me for a communist. Oh, I mean, I'm a believer.
Like, yeah, you know, come on. But, you know, their version of turn, turn, turn is something very different. And it is an incredible performance that holds up. And, you know, and then from that to go on from interpreting people or existing songs to creating their own stuff, which is unmistakably great.
I mean, just on slide eight miles high, I agree with you that younger than yesterday is, you know, it's got a couple of real dogs on it. And I think we're going to argue about my gardens. I hope so. I'm thinking that argue has charm.
But anyways, like, you know, they did it all. And you know, and they created, you know, you're right. I mean, basically they laid out the template where they cleared, you know, they cleared the landing for three very distinct, very important, you know, kind of concepts in rock. One thing that I'll just say is that as somebody who's older where the birds have been kept a lot of Patty Smith covered, so you want to be a rock and roll star and her last album, and it's a, it's an Easter or a wave.
It's wave. I'm sorry. The one that's produced by Todd Rundgren and Tom Petty was a big fan and McLean covered American girl and they were playing with pals. And so they bridged into this weird kind of post hippie don almost punked them and then REM came along and REM in its early days in the late seventies, REM would be like loath to admit that they knew who the birds were.
But it's like, come on guys, like this, this is the DNA, you know, of so much that you're doing and so much of that kind of indie rock movement with the jangling guitar. And again, I think, you know, it's this combination. I think this is true. But like a combination of brightness and sadness all at the same time.
I think one thing that has to be emphasized in terms of history and the chronology because Bob Dylan's own version of Mr. Tamarini made it so famous, people don't realize that the birds version came out well before it, all right, because remember it had already been shot. That was a demo. And also they're totally different.
I don't actually like Dylan's version. I don't actually like Dylan's version. That's not much. I love bringing it all back home.
It's one of my favorite Dylan albums of all time. But I actually think that's one of the weakest moments on the record. Of course, you know, probably out of an island on that. But then Roger McQuin, as you said, he wrote something new for this.
That opening. That's just Roger McQuin coming up with that line on his own. I guess by the way, this is the anecdote I wanted to tell. His name back there was actually Jim and Gwen.
And you know, unlike a lot of people who get involved with religious cults or, you know, Roger McQuin got involved with an Eastern Indian mysticist cult and he didn't change his name to the Bagwash. He changed his name from Jim to Roger, which is about as core and is normally Anglo and Anglo. I never understood why Roger was the name that he picked. He talks about that he had come up with a bunch of his guru and it was a group called Subdub, which had a minor moment of fame.
But his guru told him to come up with some words that would describe his energy or something. And he threw in a list of weird names, all of which started with ours and had to do with rocket ships and stuff. And then he threw in Roger because that's what you say at the end of a radio transmission. Oh, yeah, Roger.
Like it's kind of like, yeah, I go with Roger. I want to alienate people. McQuin is one of those characters. And he is thriving as a performer now and he's since the late 90s.
He's been doing this great project that's online. He was an early adopter into the internet and what I call Folk Den where he posts every month a new version of a traditional folk song. And literally he's been doing it for over 20 years. But his personal journey, you know, through all of this and being a folky, then being a hippie, then becoming enmeshed in Eastern mysticism and MOOC synthesizers, then he became a born again.
Christian had a certain point. He has gone through and now he's back to traditional folk. You know, his sort of captures. 60s, 60s, boomer.
Yeah. And you know, and that's again, I say this and I'm from the very talented of the baby woman. I identify much more as a punk. So I hate all hippies.
But even the Ramones, you know, they put out an album, acid eaters covers of hippies like an elixons. You know, so you got to love them. And certainly the birds rival the Ramones for having like the shortest records out there. But, you know, there's something about that journey that tells us a lot about who we were and who we still are, I think, as a country.
Because, you know, I see like rock music and I'm sorry to go on about this too. But it's like, you know, when the birds start doing folk rock, it stops being about Elvis and Buddy Holly and Chuck Berry or something like that. And it becomes something very different. And I'm not saying that other stuff is bad or anything, but it becomes kind of what we know now as popular music, you know, rock and flop and popular music.
And that, you know, that is a story about going from, you know, just being raised for the first time in kind of existential delight where you don't have to spend most of your time looking for food. You know, you can start to explore what it means to be alive. And I think the birds went further and in many ways more disastrously, you know, than a lot of other bands. But, you know, that's where they are.
Okay. So Scott, I want to start with you first. Let's take those first two albums together. And, you know, this isn't trying to dislike them in any way.
I actually believe that Mr. Tambrianne personally is the best debut album of all the great 60s rock bands. I think it's better than please, please, me, other ones, stones, number one or my generation. But Mr.
Tambrian, in turn, turn, turn, really kind of a piece. They really feel like it's the same. I always think about them. I get confused, like, which songs are on which album, which they can go back around.
And one of the reasons for that is because of the dominance of a member of the band we haven't really talked about too much, which is Gene Clark. Gene Clark is kind of like, you know, the Sid Barrett, you know, of the birds. This fantastic songwriter who was the strength and in a really a lot of ways the leader of this band because he wrote all of their great self written music back in that day. So Scott, I want only you to go first.
And, you know, what are your opinions about these first two records? Mr. Tambrianne's a tremendous debut. I'm thinking in my head as you were talking about the best of all those you mentioned.
It certainly has a case. Turn, turn, I think is a step or two behind. I'm a bit less forgiving of some of the weaknesses. I mean, they're not perfect in some of the weaker tracks.
I'm a little less forgiving of. But there are, I mean, Gene Clark, you mentioned his work, his writing work, his vocal work on these two albums is just tremendous. I'll feel a whole lot better, which is the second track on Mr. Tambrianne, man, probably my favorite track on both of these albums.
It's one that he wrote, it's one of his sings. And is that a great song? It might be the most covered birds song of all time. I think they're original.
You know, Tom Petty, of course, I think that I'm full moon fever or something. Yep. Just a graceful rising melody. And even way back here, I mean, that guitar solo is certainly country influence.
So the more country aspects of the birds music that would rise later, not coming exactly out of nowhere, right? But at Jengling 12 String from Wind Open Things Up, Hillman from the Beginning is doing some fairly complex bass work. I feel a whole lot better. And then Clark's writing, even just that very simple chorus, you know, it's not I will feel a whole lot better.
I'll probably feel a whole lot better. There's some uncertainty to it that is an extra bit of depth. That's part of those early birds is marrying the more sophisticated lyrical content with that rock rock and roll backbeat. Something like here without you, which is another Clark to have an understanding.
Has that just thumping bass backbone to the track? This very mid-tempo ballad bittersweet memory, very strong imagery throughout this trip through the city without the person who loves it's Gene Clark writing. It's like a 19 year old songs like this. And then from Turn Turn Turn, you know, such a free this time is I think another Clark song.
There are three songs on Turn Turn written by him that just stunned me. It's set you free this time and then the world turns all around her and if you're gone. It sounds like a proto-raggadrone. And then ironically, the best song you wrote for those sessions, they left off the album because they were like paranoid about him getting too many great songs.
It's called She Don't Care About Time. And if you listen to it, it combines not only there's there's there's a rock in there, there's a rolling stone rip off on there, there's an incredible melody in there. It's the kitchen sink in, it's the B-side, it was the B-side of Turn Turn Turn. I can't even tell you how great he was as a songwriter during this movie.
But I'm sorry if you're gone, if you're gone, it's fantastic. It really shows his growth as a writer even from those months, I mean literally months from Mr. Tamborine and Turn Turn Turn the way that the energy, the way it punches up into the final verse, that drone that I think McQueen is playing where he's adding to the song and that melody that rises and falls. You might stand on, understanding what is now.
If I have been need someone to show me now, can be hidden by the sun. If you're gone, I know I will be someone. Part just a very talented songwriter and you get a bunch of covers too, Turn Turn Turn Turn is I think six covers and five are originally more covers than original songs but something like he was a friend of mine is great. He was a friend of mine is a traditional song and he was a friend of mine is a traditional and then he sneakily stuck his own copyright on it and he was written by Bob Dylan.
And then the birds didn't bother to do that but their version is much more original. They turned it into a tribute to John F. We had those lyrics. It was only two years before this album came out.
You might think like, well why? It's 1965 but remember, there's massive national trauma. It's a set in the stage for David Crafts. We're talking about the Warren Foundation.
Oh my God, we'll get to that. He has the same of such an precious time. Anyway, Nick, by the way, before I say my small thing about these two first albums, which I think are fantastic, what are your thoughts? Well, I'll just limit to one song which is on Mr.
Tamboree Man. I dislike Pete Seeger as a concept. They also covered on Mr. Tamboree Man, the Bells of Rymnate, which is a song that Pete Seeger covered by the Welsh mining disaster.
Beautiful and wonderful in this. I guess if I want to try and re-catch or something, it's what it was like to be a fan of music before the internet. You couldn't find out who was in a band because most albums didn't have it or they had bad information on them. They didn't even have the date that stuff came out.
They didn't have lyric sheets most of the time. I can remember listening to Bells of Rymnate and stopping the record player in China. What word is this? It's like a Welsh writing disaster.
It's like what the hell is it? It's kind of mean. But it's incredible. There's just something so weird and wonderful and beautiful and different going on.
For me, that's the kind of individual... It's a weird bit to say because they're a band of five people. I just want them to have all of their own personalities. But it was like an individual was a group effort and even their party.
It was just different. That was incredibly exciting. So for me, I think the aspect that I want to focus on here is because this is, as I said earlier, we talk about how the birds got this rap of like, oh, they're just dealing cover artists. That's all they do.
Well, one of the reasons why people give them that rap is because they're dealing covers are flipping amazing. And on these two albums in particular, they are peerless. So yeah, Mr. Tambrian, we already talked about that.
I don't have to say anything about it. But also on the first album, you got Spanish Harlem Incident. Stuff from another side of Bob Dylan, which, you know, when we did our Dylan episode, I pointed this out. It was just almost crying out to be electrified.
You could just tell that Dylan was going and he was writing songs that you could just sense. That would make a great electrified arrangement. But the one we also talked about all I really want to do, I'll tell you the one that really blows me away is Chimes of Freedom. It's much shorter than Dylan's version.
Dylan's version is haunting. So I don't think it eliminates Dylan's version because they're very different songs and in different towns. But I just love the birds' version of Chimes of Freedom from that first album. The that you've got the uh...
ridiculous cover of another fantastic out of the first time anybody was hearing it in the public uh... lay down your weary tune of a turn turn turn is uh... a version that is i think to me just clearly superior to the original one that don't perform i think that their ability to interpret and find it they don't just like here let's add some guitars and some harmonies that's the way like an uncreative artist or an uncreative group would cover song but what they do is they reinterpret it and a huge part of that i have to say is the sort of plaintiff tone of roger mcguin's voice there's something about the win as a singer that that fascinates me because he doesn't have a strong vocal approach you know he doesn't last you like the part of car near john leon and you even make jagger has a snarl he's kind of this we like you know the time for peace i swear it's not too late and that is exactly the kind of tone that makes these sorts of covers so moving because they're humble even as they're incredibly innovative they don't force themselves upon you simply ask you to listen to them i just think that the uh... ironically i rebel against you know people characterizing birds is that all the people's songs shares help them but it also has to just be a constant one of the most fantastic over the times of all time like their work in the city falls into the same bag every great original songs that may have been worked their way around great covers well the ocean like an organ and the crash in like symbols against you know it's a real problem i think with kind of rock uh...
you know criticism generally speaking of you know it's because of the people's because of the if the analog of the ought to a theory in some criticism like you know if you're not like a director who like you has a perfect vision that you're stating that you're not a real artist right that's the yeah it really is that you know this is something that i think the uh... you know in the wake of it up and rap we're kind of getting away from that fixation on a kind of romantic you know capital or genius who has no influence it comes out fully from their own breathless ly perfect material and you know this is one of the things that i think it really speaks to the birds uh... influence and meaning and relevance is that they were interpreting material you know they saw themselves so consciously as in a genealogy uh... going somewhere they didn't know where i think they'll do this you know more spectacularly than any uh...
you know post-war artist in any medium but that's one of the things that's heard of the birds and and for too many years i think it rock criticism was all about you know being the you know the genius as opposed to the uh... you know kind of the connector so one revolution down and now how it comes to next revolution this is why this band is so important folk rock literally get kicked off and you've got a billion bands doing this you know the animal start electrifying their music the turtles i always make jokes about the turtles on this show for some reason i don't know why they might go to punchline everybody and their brother and their sisters folk rockin it up in the birds say you know what let's trip acid and let's do something truly not let's let's bring indian instruments into this let's do raga rock and uh... basically pre-figure what the people's about the two on tomorrow knows and that is of course fifth dimension which uh... i'm just gonna come right out and say this that um...
i think in terms of like everything about what what what kind of songs you know single type of greatest introductions of all time and i'm saying that there are very few and i don't know if there's really any of the top eight miles high every time i hear that and i don't know and i don't think it's going to be finally making a contribution and then roger mcwin you know coming in with that that is you know what the idea of trying to play something that sounds like john coltrane on a guitar sounds ridiculous especially because it's like a piece of it like you know you white l a focus with the thing that they can't but he didn't he pulls it off that sounds like jazz music and it's a pop single and it's three and a half minutes long it's insane it's one of the most innovative mind-blowing advances in music uh... from that era and i kind of just like you know every now and then on twitter i was just like drop that and people don't realize how important and fantastic the song is go listen to eight miles high the uh... uh... i agree completely uh...
it's uh... you know the other thing about that album though which is amazing to me are the traditional folk balance and on its own stuff like john riley and wild mountain tide and the way they're produced uh... i don't know if you guys do like it all on on the fan on partly a family cost of the album that the mention where down the front of the the album the uh... the band is sitting on a magic carpet and you can see it like it looks like a styrofoam cup of this is a glimpse of some kind of red liquid really yeah something like that it's a word where a decade away from john's now uh...
and uh... it you know but it is those songs of wild mountain time and john riley which are you know they were real uh... work works as in any any folk cabaret act you know coffee shop acting the way they're produced and the way they're done is incredible and i have to say if you are a fan of psychedelics listen to those songs on psychedelics rather than something like a miles high eight miles high you feel like you're tripping and it's a mostly bad trip whether you're stoned or not those songs are tremendous and it's you know to me that's like a perfect melding of where they have one foot in tradition and they're going to get a going out way past food out on the side uh... you know i guess i'm gonna have to reveal some truths about myself when we get to a later album because i have my own story that relates to that relates to that with the birds uh...
but i'll tell you i've always been a little bugged by the production of those two tracks that both fantastic well no no no no not overdone at all it's just a way that there's the left channel right channel separated this is this is a technical thing but it's like you know you've got like the entire instrumental track all the band the music is in the left channel and then you have like the vocals they're kind of center but mostly right and then the strings coming on the right and it's just like the weird again maybe it was done by somebody who was tripping acid because it doesn't seem like it's a well-balanced mix this is the title of the plane you can see that on so many other right i mean i could i i think the first song that i remember hearing that too fully was uh ericens if i did someone i had whatever version of the album i had you could turn you know back when you could just toggle between the right and the left speaker one was all music one was all vocal yeah that's so it's so 60s but i have to say i do agree with you um one of the songs that people don't you actually mention a lot when they talk about this album is like wild mountain time i think wild mountain time is still achingly beautiful it's it's yeah it's trad you know like Dylan did a great version of it uh yeah and uh every other band is covered guys you said oh did those strings they're not overdone in the slightest you just it makes your heart weep and we'll all go together to the wild mountain time all across the purple meadow the eagle has to go no and you know what i love about this kind of stuff and you know i was a kid when i heard it but it's like i was like what the hell is wild mountain time like you know i only know about time you know and obviously time and various kinds of spices keep showing up in 60s folk rock again and again but you know i went and like looked up what they were talking about and then heather and stuff like that it's just they created a world that was just Scotland you know it's like and it's rare and then the other for me the other real stand-up track on that is the cover of the the hit that i come and stand at every door okay i said this on twitter yesterday and Scott you're gonna have to believe me now that is one of the most up songs ever released by a major rock group in the 60s yeah this is all about like the ghost of a dead kid who was killed at Hiroshima and it's so like weird it's like you know i come and stand at every door ghost i cannot eat because children when they die they don't grow old you know the heat it turned my bones to ash and the ash blew away Jesus Christ that is a really disturbing sentiment they say great side one closer and i really you know sides don't matter anymore in cd work the editor of cd and streaming but wow but that's the thing that's why you shouldn't trip while you're listening to the mention you think you think you're all peaceful with while mountain time and mr. spaceman and then you get to wait come and stand at every door and now you're like oh my gosh my soul has been destroyed and you're lost you lost a piece of your brain forever in seven now as i was then when children die they do not grow my hair was scorched my swirling flame my eyes grew dim my eyes grew blind it's also and i realize i'm pushing that well you know hell i mean you know music is always personal interpretation but that's also i see that um you know on uh what is it at the end of mr. tamboree they have one meet again which had been the closing song that was used for a laugh in dr. strange luck but it was a classic world war two story you know troops coming home after the war this is also kind of a screw you to the older generation and you know i find it kind of fascinating because the birds constantly you know and we see later you know stuff like a drugstore truck driving then whatnot they you know they go to Nashville and they're building bridges but they're also kind of throwing hand grenades at the same time and they have that again it just perfectly encapsulates you know what it must have been like to be young and alive and have everything in the world at your feet you know to be in southern california you know in 1965 wow you know like you don't have to work for a living you don't have to you know put up with stuff you know you can tell the record man to go screw himself and all that kind of stuff um but they they do keep throwing you know hand grenades at the older generation.
Scott? One thing that we should mention is that jin clark is gone by this point i think he contributes a little bit to eight miles high you knew he actually played the song and that's right after that that that's when he left and that's it so he's not on the rest of of of this album and so it's slimmed down a little bit version of the birds uh when you talk about the psychedelic songs the one that i don't think mentioned i see you i like uh very heavy psychedelic feel i love those jagged guitar runs and you mentioned michael clark is not uh not exactly a drummer extraordinaire but he did learn how to play and i think his work on i see you it's very sharp and washing fields kind of space i have the first nice thing i have to say about David Crosby too i actually like what's happened actually okay here's the thing i actually think that David Crosby really comes into his own on this album you know and then he also embarrasses himself which is gonna be the story of David okay you're like he does things that impress you and then he just goes face plant right on the ground you're just like oh jesus david oh god why do you make it so hard to want to be your fan so like yeah i see it was great i really love what's happening too that's a great raggle rock sound of course the title is just so like spaced out it's question mark it's a question point question mark exclamation point it's almost like it was written for twitter right um but he's still wearing that uh like butt skin tunic with the uh the leather straps that like said jumped up the end he hasn't he hasn't he hasn't gained all the weight yet right he doesn't still he's not he's not in this like is jeremy johnson but then of course those are great songs but then of course what is he has to do he has to go to hl which is one of the most embarrassing covers of all this is like you know to be like the equivalent of the beach boys doing luigi or you know like one of those things where like you shouldn't have stepped wrong and the reason he did it is because like that song had been percolating the laseen for like at least a year and he always wanted to do with the band and they're like no how really does this doesn't seem right for us and then all these other groups were scoring kids with it so they finally said all right David shut up we'll let you do it and they kind of almost put it on there as a dare to prove him wrong it's like listen this is retarded and here you go hey joe he doesn't even say where you're going with that gun in your hand he cops out he says where you're going with that mone in your hand like money even though he does you get back around like i'm going down to shoot me all lady and all that and just like why did you change that lyric Dave i don't know it's it's one of the most inexplicably perversely bad covers of the 1960s and i guess for that reason i kind of have a certain affection for it to his credit he did acknowledge that it was a terrible performance and i'm state to uh to commit to uh to find hey joe where you going that money man maybe still he still made the ban from he still made the ban perform at live at monorat anyways Scott i interrupted you so keep going make sure mr space man gets a little note i really like mr space man gorgeous melody little bluegrass in nature on the guitar when said they had heard act naturally on the veals album and said well we can you know it's okay for us to do a little bit that uh two four timing too to get mr space man this is you know again if you listen it's 1966 this is as innovative as anything else happening in 1966 and by the time you know by this time they're influencing a lot of people with their first two albums you know they're full rock and they're already moving on which is going to be the story of a lot of their career they're moving on as others are beginning to sort of take what they had already put out and put it inside their own work the last thought i'll add about this album is that i do want to actually say something in favor of the title track fifth dimension 5d which you know Roger Gwen you know is he claims that he's upset that people thought this was some sort of psychedelic song but he was really he was really just trying to explain quantum physics to people uh no i don't buy that for a second you were obviously you know shrooming your head off with this uh you know but it's still it's such a beautiful ballad it's a ballad it's not a rock song it's not eight miles high it's it's uh it's a song where you know he says like you know and i opened my arms to the whole universe and i saw that it was loving and i saw the great blunders my teachers had made scientific delirium madness but he's that great like oh he just sings out the top of his lungs at the end i actually think it's as a vocal performance it's his best single vocal on an in bird song i really think it is the best one that he ever gave and it's one of those songs that people sort of like and they respect but they sort of gently whack at me i opened my heart to the whole universe and i found it was loving and i saw a great blunder my teachers had made scientific delirium madness keep calling as long as i live or without anything and now we remember the place that is now that has ended before the beginning well now he said that i could come out to him and be still floating and never yet but i can keep on through just relaxed and playing as an adventure there is such a performative contradiction right and it is also true of mr. spaceman where you're using this kind of plotting format to talk about aliens alien abductions but let's put up this song in 1966 about alien abductions these guys were ahead of their damn time this is what is you know and again if you can you know have a bit of a you know i have this whole concept i'm trying to build i call ironic nearness as my ironic distance you know if you have a little bit of irony you can stay with these guys you know and you know this is what the six of these was about where you know we're going to love nature and nature is so important and we're going to you know take jets everywhere we're going to have this incredibly complex electronical gimmick trajectory and i've got to train everything and it's like yeah it's okay you know it's okay to you know be contradicting yourself in everything you do on a certain level and unfortunately i don't think you know in many ways we didn't resolve that tension properly in society but it just it adds to the i think to the the weirdness and the wonderfulness of what's going on in all of this so it's basically what you're saying is that this entire mindset is migrated to silicon valley in the modern era i think there's a lot of that you know and it comes and goes and this is where you know they're you know they're the kind of spirit animal i think of the entire counterculture is in a steward brand uh you know the guy who was a mary prankster and then he's he started the whole earth catalog yeah you know and he's with the long now foundation and everything he's the one guy who kind of figures out how to do this without really kind of stepping it in every you know part of path right um this is one of the things that the birds really do in a very fantastic and and at times self-conscious life yeah i guess that brings us to an album that is this the bird's greatest album of all time i don't know i i i waver i go back and forth and i boy everyone's can everyone can have a different opinion on this but this is by the way that has to be pointed out this is the moment that the commercial fortunes start to dip and it's almost kinks like in a weird way that you know as the kinks commercial performance in the charts went down their artistic achievement just went up up up up up up up and it begins for me with they started off well but uh younger than yesterday is an album that for me takes it to a whole different level this is this is still him in their psychedelic rock phase but what needs to be emphasized here is that there are so many different elements being brought in they are unabashedly now claiming you know an idea of country rock is a valid part of this sort of california futuristic rock experience they are bringing in uh you know david cross be talking about his mind gardens oh my gosh i have to we'll get to it i have to talk about that horrible song that i still perversely love but i think for me the big story of younger than yesterday which i may still say is the bird's best album of all time is the emergence of chris hillman we haven't really mentioned at all during this show chris hillman of course is their bassist he's their third harmony vocalist and at up until this point he hadn't written a single thing but not one song on any other albums not even a co-writing credit i think like you know in like the stupid instrumental it ends fifth dimension he gets a co-writing credit that doesn't count all right uh suddenly here he just dervishes forth with four songs and all four songs are amazing i'm wrong five songs he writes five of the songs on this album so you want to be the rock and roll star have you seen her face time between thoughts and words and the girl with no name uh it's it's almost like he just exploded i don't know if it was like a george hereson situation where like you know the others were holding him down and so he had his own little minor all things must pass explosion uh but he makes this album just indelible with his contributions but the thing is that everybody else gets their links into and they even do uh it's funny we've talked so much about bob dillan covers i i think that the bob dillan cover is the best one they ever did at all and in fact they'd already made it into our covers episode scott neck which if you want to go first on yonder that's not why don't you yeah i'll go because i'm just i'm gonna echo jeff jeff's comments quite a bit here i think if you're younger than yesterday isn't their best it's probably their second best um there's likely to be my two albums at the very end of the episode uh it's not without some um well jeff will cover one of those songs later that aren't exactly all my list of favorites but yeah chris hillman emerging as a songwriter is is the big thing here and all those songs are fantastic have you seen her face probably is my favorite of those um that arrangement is just outstanding very ambitious lyrically and musically it crackles that's the thing about that that in 1967 production methods were still not that great but that's not explodes into your head it's that the guitar at the beginning of that thing just the minute i heard it that was the moment i was like okay the birds are truly great there to capture all she needs no time spent on the song if your life runs right might see you to that everything inside time between is is beautiful the only pain i feel is this time between you and me um and then his contributions to so you want to be a rock and roll star that's just a fantastic fantastic song trumpet solo in 1967 in rock song sure why not the cheering crowd which is from the 1965 tour the fans going nuts for them in in Britain uh hillman's baseline just drives that song so you want to be a rock and roll star and then that bitterness in the lyrics it's really a fantastic package i think my back pages is the band's best best dylan cover uh i don't know by quite a bit but clearly is their best dylan cover uh it's better than the original better than dylan's version uh one of the songs that cross we did not want to record you want to go back to the well so to speak and do another dylan song but i'm glad they did because again i think it's their best best dylan cover um what else is on here um i think that version of why that closer things up is pretty good that that was already a b-side on the eight miles high uh single there's some jazz flourishes here that started in the last album too uh crowsby's everybody's been burned as that very undercurrent of moody jazziness i think that might be one of crowsby's very best vocal performances in the group as well uh jeff will talk about mine gardens it's not it's not you know crystal perfect it's not totally perfect but it's really outstanding and uh i think is one of their two best albums of their career you know mine gardens just i agree completely with chrys helmet who of course you know went on between his contributions to sweetheart rodeo and then with the uh uh uh uh flying grid i'm sorry yeah thank you i'm taking gilded palace of sin um is just such and then you know with manassas and sevan cells and the desert rose band later as a you know as a really influential country band later just a phenomenal uh you know performer and contributor to the to the birds and to rock music and country's in general i'll fix it a little bit on the uh crowsby stuff here because i you know everybody's been burned i can remember the first time i heard this i was and again this must have been in you know i was maybe 12 13 and i was falling asleep and i was in a bad mood and my bedroom and i was like you know i was listening to radio and i was like you know i hope i hear a bird song because they're always so happy and upbeat and somehow like wnw or an old f-n station in new york everybody's been burned to kick off and i was like holy cow this is so dark and so beautiful and moody and atmospheric it's really a phenomenal track i know all too well i turn i'd run out of hide behind but they're all a blue but you die inside if you choose to hide so i guess instead i love you i think the real stand up and crowsby and co-read these uh at the time jim bakwina's renaissance fair which is just this vignette of being at you know a hippie festival and you know this is um it gets name checked by er fern and his version of uh in his song about the mantra at paul festival it is um just a phenomenal evocation of you know in a magic possibility of like a world where we were all you know walking around wearing david crowsby singlets and you know playing the loops and uh you know people with shimmering fabrics everywhere uh it's beautiful and there's a reason there's a reason that the refrain is i think that maybe i'm dreaming yeah i think that maybe i'm dreaming i smell cinnamon spices i hear music everywhere on a lighter school of color i think that maybe i'm dreaming it's past gracefully i mean that's the thing you wake up from the dream you know but it's like wow it is just so incredible and you know it pairs well with mind gardens because i think the problem with mind gardens in a lot of ways and you know i realize we're kind of doing a psychodrama city fixated on david crowsby right now but that you know mind gardens is about crowsby the individual it's all me and i and you know him deciding whether or not he you know to have sex with somebody no no no no nik nik nik i gotta tell you i i gotta cut your mind gardens is about nik is about david crowsby's attempt to do a scotish accent but okay well this is that looks dant the mind guard all i'm saying is renaissance fair what's great about it is that it's not about any one person dominating it's it's about a you know a community and you know a commune and it's kind of beautiful and wonderful mind gardens you know that wall that he's building it's it's ego baby and you know it never does well mind gardens on you if you get the younger that you get the first of all when you buy these albums and you should buy these albums you should get the reissued albums that have the bonus tracks on them they're wonderful they're well curated they're well done and they're basically you know after you've gotten them it's really not a lot of stuff that you need to go hunt down um there's an instrumental version of mind cards and it's just it doesn't have david singing on it and has got a little crazy psychedelic you know ragarot guitar from roger mcguin and it sounds beautiful it's wonderful but then of course david has to give you that stupid stupid lyric on top of it and it isn't even just a lyric which as nik i well pointed out it's like so self-involved it's so indeluted but it's the vocal performance that just drives me up a while there's this one guy you know like there were high heels and then there's this great one he quotes oh it's how pretentious this he quotes friggin hamlet and from the slings and arrows about rages forch and he trills his art go listen to it he trills his art why oh david why why this is what i mean like all these birds albums all these these you know from fifth mention to yangar to notorious you have like wow i'm so impressed with you david you're a great artist and then you're like oh my god you just crapped your pants in public oh but there came wind and i feared for the garden so i built a wall and i built another and rused it over the canthorn and kept it from the slings and arrows about rages forch and the killing cone could not get in when the sun came that's my only objection to this album in any way and it's it's it's the silliest thing but you know the but on another level you need that right like you need that that's right that's why i need to make it you know it's the drop stitch in an indian blanket or something you know like that's why i love it okay as i said i hate it and i love it whenever he trills that art i literally just i like literally i twitch i twitch and i also like feel like a little visceral thrill like oh man that sounds like genuinely great badness you know you know you gotta have some badness you know that's why i like bad films now like i like washing mystery science data three thousand this is the mst 3k birds on my darits um i just want to say a couple of other things uh you know we talked about hillman so i don't really need to cover that i think you talked about how great everybody's been burned it so i don't have to mention that i want to just point out that my back pages i talked about this once on our covers episode so if you want you can go back and hear something similar but i'll just mention again what impresses me most about this is that um just like Roger McQuinn did with mr tamarimand he essentially rewrote this song musically you know mr tamarimand he created that that big opening you know pentatonic riff on the rickenbacher and he does it again with with my back pages except he does it twice over because he not only comes with that great opening which is become iconic he also changes the time signature and the original Dylan version is awkward it's a that it's a waltz it's three four it was like i don't know one of the strangest decisions that Dylan ever made uh and then you know he was like well okay great song great message bad time signature and so he puts it into four four and he turns it into rock and that's the only way you'll ever need to hear my back pages okay no more to knee leg deceive me into making i had something to protect how do you find these terms what clear no doubt somehow i'm so much older than i'm younger than that now i think that that's my favorite favorite uh Dylan cover that the birds ever did is uh my back pages and that what leads us to uh 1968 and the notorious bird yeah and can i just point out though that from uh fifth dimension which came out i believe in july in 1966 and we're in the thick of it now right they had like a two-year period and were partway through which rivals like in american literature you have to look at Faulkner's productive period where he wrote all of his master works in a few years this is an unbelievably compressed moment of just incredible uh you know an explosion of genius and possibility and new forms i mean because they're cycling from folk rock to psychedelic and they're moving towards country you know we're at an amazing clip so sorry i just i i didn't until i went back and listened again most recently to this i did not even fully appreciate how freaking great the birds were from 1966 through 1968 i mean this is actually to me a 1967 album and all but named it came out in like january or segia so it was obviously i'll record it long before then um and uh this is the album famously where uh you know david crawes begins fired in the middle of it and and you know for years uh in fact until this day he said that he hates the cover of the notorious bird was which is my favorite bird's album cover of all time because okay so there's michael clark there's chris hellman there's roger mcguin and then in the fourth they're like you know posing in like a stable and they're looking at the windows and the fourth window of the stable it's a horse and crosby always said he's like you know like oh man they're doing that because you know they fired me in the middle of the sessions and like you know that's a commentary on how much they hate me and of course mcguin's famous right post of this was like listen david if we were really trying to represent you we would have put the horses ass in there not his face um but this is also like an album where he makes all of his greatest contributions and you know as i started my discussion of younger than yesterday is this the birds greatest album i think i you know and i completely agree and other times when i would agree as well but there's one thing that always wrinkles me about it wrinkles me immensely and this is the point where like that fighting within the band became so toxic that they made they started making bad decisions and that for me is the decision to cut off david crosby's single they had a non-album single this is i guess what i want to talk about first they had a non-album single between you and the yesterday and notorious it's called lady friend um it's david crosby's number it is the single greatest thing that david crosby is sleazy as guy you know this is something in rocket is lady for his lady friend you know we just like to hang out we just sometimes we spend the night together you know of course david crosby eternal sleazy until you know he cleaned up a little later until we needed that extra liver you know we needed to do that probably amory because he wanted to have a bigger feel to get work in the transplant oh god that's terrible not hilarious all right but here's the thing um that's the greatest song that the birds ever recorded full stop i'm not kidding i think that is their best ever song and everything about it thrills me the minute i heard it it was actually it's included as a bonus track on yonder than yesterday it should have been on the notorious bird ros as the final song but they cut it because they fired crosby and they were just like well screw you don't get royalties you know this the single didn't chart that well anyway so you don't get anything you need um this song is everything about the birds that thrills me it's horns it's harmonies it's happiness the thing explodes out of your speakers when you hear it in stereo it has these fantastic vocal arrangements crosby comes up with this great melody line that here it comes again i should have learned to duck it's like a wave coming in a tsunami coming in to like swallow him up um this is their best recorded song in my opinion and there are so many contenders uh and the only reason that i don't sometimes think that notorious bird brothers is the best birds album of all time is because it doesn't include itself i am sorry that i can't go there i i actually find lady friend kind of uh uh recression to an earlier ear that i don't find interesting and i i think we may have been fighting about this by email or or the fight was a brewing um i wish they had included triad the other great controversial thing for us we saw on the south and i think it perfectly fits with that it's a disturbing and excessive song which got plenty of treatments by you know a greater you know or a better-known band than read a little bit um but i do think that the tori's bird brothers is a phenomenal record and that is largely not completely but largely due to take across these contributions uh his uh you know the variety of songs that are on here in the soundscapes i mean this is where you know that dream you are in deep REM sleep REM sleep and you know that you're gonna get woken up like you finally realize it's a dream but it's uh you know songs like natural harmony draft morning wasn't where to follow get to you tribal gathering um you know i mean they're just so lush and rich and beautiful then of course then it ends with space honesty which is so jarring by the way i had to get the you got it uh yeah i'm sorry go back you know you just have to give it credit for actually like doing a better job in 2001 of like capturing the arthor clark novel but like oh the last song this album should have been lady for an i think it should have been um i think it should have been triad or not none of they shouldn't have been the last either way i think you know it's often smile or actually i think draft morning should have been a final song because draft morning is this beautiful soundscape with a you know with a kid waking up and dreaming and then realizing like he's gonna go to Vietnam and that's you know there was so much violence brewing in the country both you know overseas and domestically that's what you know that's what wrecked the dream that gets kind of uh you know given voice and vision and that's not fair also on a musical moon i'll just point out that roger water is totally ripped off the baseline of draft morning for us and them on pink florid star excited moon it's literally the same thing totally stole it and uh nobody else seems to understand this except me i'm uh going through like you know like grind my axe right here while i have the chance scott i don't think it's their best album but i i understand the argument and i think it is pretty amazing they were able to create what they did both with with the myriad of of sort of genres that they're that they're experimenting with but also with the personnel issues cross beat fired michael clark leaves the band jean clark comes back for about three weeks and then leaves the band again uh clair's white is around playing some guitar here and there and through all of this you have these songs that that incorporate folk and country jazz psychedelic stuff and even a little bit of soul i mean like artificial energy i just really take that horn section on artificial energy which is the first song of the uh of the album uh song about the dark side of amphetamines they say um but this really is we've had too many songs celebrate right you know we really needed a question i think it's almost like they listened to the velvet underground he said we need to counteract this this horrible change i thought over here yeah no no no i'm waiting for the man stuff come on artificial energy which is the first track in space honestly uh which is the last track or those could be deleted from the record i think i think artificial energy you know god like do we really need particularly you know at a moment in 19th january of 1968 do we need a rock band telling us they you know amphetamines you know speed kills i don't think so you know or somebody to explain uh you know uh 2001 to us the the track that i love and that i guess is on all of the outtake things and stuff is uh the mood raga uh which is also called universal mind decoder and that i would love i would have been happier just to have like leaps and loops uh close out this record you know with with that kind of and again this is like oh look we're going back in time to where civilization began with some kind of rip off of ravi shankar but we're gonna you know put it to a synthesizer beat that kind of weird contradiction i just love but you can i do kind of get what nik is saying though about uh how you could delete i like i actually like artificial energy quite a lot uh but it does feel like weirdly like dissonant from the rest of the album and space out of the also feels dissonant but that just sucks it's just it's like not a good song and then everything we won't fail on that but stage is first out right that's like why is it there other than to make the other songs look seem better it's because you know roger feels like he liked the end of every one of these albums or at least one point on these albums he wants to like to pay tribute to sort sci-fi futuristic visionary kind of thing actually i admire it but like you know you could have left this one off but everything in the middle there from going back to dolphin smile it flows it flows like an oceanic group. the crossby of course famously refused to sing and play on going back because you know because you know because you know because you think he realized that it was it was that or triad that was gonna make the album and he's like i want my song about you know me coercing you know college girls into three sims to make the album um the discovery of rokiknoll or something and jalcom i think first of all pharmacopion you know the other dolphin king song yes it's what important to follow which ends up showing up in on the easy rider soundtrack and um i think that is actually one of their very best tracks because it's you know it's i mean king and dolphin are you know effectively bro building songwriters i mean they're great i don't mean that it's a disservice them oh yeah commercial we did a monkeys episode we phrased them to the skies yeah no i mean you know in their commercial hit makers this is a weird song for them to write it's his pay into individualism it is you know it's kind of countryish but it's also kind of psychedelic and it's just weird and it's so beautiful and then it works i mean easy rider to me and again you know they go back to the you know the way i think about the birds and stuff they show the promise and then the failure to deliver fully you know i guess what nothing was delivered as a song yeah that's on their next album uh but you know the failure of the sixies and that links them to it like you know they just couldn't they couldn't make it real and uh wasn't part of all i just think the connection with easy rider which they have a couple of other tracks obviously and they have an album called the ballad of easy rider it's just it's a beautiful beautiful hunting song wasn't born to follow is uh is a great study in in juxtaposition right because you have these lyrics about independence and kind of almost a hippie independence sort of sort of set of lyrics as Nick mentioned you have also this not conflict but existing at the same time country western with the psychedelic lens you have pedal steel sound with that very dissident electric guitar sound it's really a well constructed song i would want to have any little white casketing water she may beg she may bleed she may argue with her logic and mention all the things i lose that really have no value in the end she will surely know i wasn't born to follow oh no no we also the fact that it follows draft morning right so like you're being drafted right i mean like complete with sound effects like literally i mean this is i think there's an alternate version on the reissue which is much better it doesn't have like this stupid like machine guns and explosions in the background cross me hey like they recorded the backing track when crowns were still in the band then they fired him and then they rewrote the lyrics and sung the lyrics without him which is just like it's just a great you know great f-u move they were just so petty back at that point but then yeah wasn't born to follow seems like an answer song to it i will say this that the heart of the sound for me and the thing that makes me love it so much like love it with a kind of a pure golden glow or the three songs that follow that it's get to you changes now and then old john roberson get to you is a song that again this is something i've done on twitter man you can look it up i just think you don't know the birds like you don't realize that here's a song just this beautiful lilting kind of a country waltz about you know getting on an airplane flying across the ocean to come see you you know standing in the airport i am waiting on a plane such a beautiful little well song and then also and it goes into this like freak out psychedelic moment where it's like you know that's a little better that's a little better their feeding rogers voice through the Leslie speakers of a ham and organ which is a trick i think they picked up from the Beatles god it's such a beautiful canneo i always love to use that word because it's like it's two minutes and 30 seconds and it's never been included on any other box sets perversely in my opinion and then another one that has never been included on any of your compilations perversely is the song change is now which i told Nick earlier that i was going to have my own embarrassing revelation about my experience and it is listening to notorious bird brothers and uh just as he said the um the something i did in college like a couple of times i'm not really like you know i'm not you know i'm not turning i'm an old man i'm a father i'm boring now but back in college man when i put on changes now and i listen to that guitar solo first of all the entire concept is so hippie trippy you know zens you know changes now changes now things that once seem solid are not i mean you can almost see like oh the walls are melting around me and indeed they were as i did this and then it hits that guitar solo that guitar solo is my favorite guitar solo in the entire bird's discography clearance white did a lot of fantastic folk and country rock stuff later on but when mcguin goes into i guess you know is it outer space or is it inner space with that guitar solo i to this day i don't have to you know i can just be like sitting around you know drinking coffee or water for that matter and i listen to that and i moved it actually moves me the harmonics are moving they're yearning it seems like as it's kind of a theme that nik has gone back to again it's like it's striving for something better uh not quite reaching it not quite reaching it but it's almost there it's within its grasp that's changes now that is one of the best bird songs of all time that's definitely in my top right i have looked you know that's a strong argument it's it's a beautiful style i mean this album for me is when they um you know it's it's in a way it's not the most representative uh but as i guess we've been discussing there is no fully represented bird's album but it's just so well done and you know one of the things i i think you guys would be able to speak to this with a lot more expertise than i can gary usher is the producer he also produced younger than yesterday and he's not super does don't worry baby yes like yeah well this is i mean he collaborated with bh2as and he was gonna produce their next album but he spent too much money on chad jarrimes of cabbages and kings and so not bounced because he was he you know columbia didn't trust him anymore but the production on this and younger than yesterday and i don't know if it was usher or somebody else but there are those weird moments like the slashing guitars and the discordant um solos and things that come in and you know it's something like get to you where it's this beautiful song of yearning and then it gets weird changes now gets weird and disruptive it's you know it's it's just fantastic um because you know right when you're about to you know get with it and just go with the flow you get yanked out of that it's like a brechtian alienation effect you know through sound and i i just want to you know really really powerful stuff and that leads us to a abrupt shift as nichos talking about abrupt shift something out but abrupt shift in in personnel and abrupt shift in style for the band's next album which is sweetheart of the rodeo i mentioned earlier this is my this was my really introduction to the the deeper catalog of the birds past like that initial greatest hits album and it's all due to the addition of a guy named grand parsons and jeven i did a whole show about grand parsons not too many weeks ago with ben jigobes in which we went very in-depth on sweetheart of the rodeo because it is in many ways a grand parsons album grand parsons is is hired by the birds by roger bragwen ostensibly to play like jaz piano and it turns out that he was able to a change roger bragwen's mind on the entire direction of the next album the gwen wanted an overview of american pop music i think it's like a two album idea to do this and parsons said yeah what do we do this country uh rural soul kind of stuff and eventually uh got mcguin to agree and then took over i mean grand parsons 21 years old uh nobody hired into play piano is now changing the shape of the band now these country leanings were there uh in the birds but parsons brought everything to the forefront and his force of personality was just huge in the band if you listen to sweetheart of the rodeo uh mcguinsing a good number of the tracks but parsons you can hear parsons vocals on some of the uh tracks that are available on the expanded versions i mean parsons was on vocals on virtually all these tracks on sweetheart of the rodeo before he gets he gets the originally he would have sung like six to five uh and then uh chris home against one and i think he's only on he's now on three of them but um you know nevertheless his influence is all over this again we did we did when we had ben jigobes on our show to do grand parsons we spent like i could like 30 minutes 40 minutes on this album so i think one of the reasons that we're not going to cover the territory that we've already covered with it again is because you can go back and hear what we said um but it's just as you know i said there and i will repeat again it's like hilarious this this kid just like kind of like got a bit of a name on the right scene it only comes in one of the biggest bands on the planet and says you are now a country band and and roger mcguin bless his heart he was just like okay all right you know i think he was persuaded a lot by chris home it who was very you know again the one guy in the band who came from kind of a bluegrass country background um and uh this is the album for me that when i first got i got all these albums kind of serial sequentially i mean i had but even the greatest hits it only had one so i had you went going nowhere right i was a glass nice very country but it's nice um then i actually got these albums in a row and then i got the sweetheart of the rodeo and uh yeah you know like you know like you know like insert jiff here my head a float uh this is nothing like anything you'd ever heard from them before yes the country influences were prevalent in a lot of their earlier albums notorious birds brothers in particular you hear a lot of it and stuff like wasn't born to follow and get to you and to changes now and things like that old john robertson but this is like we're going to Nashville and we're gonna have some serious ass pedal steel they look like i did right i mean he even convinced them a guinder right he said like you know not go very well they didn't know what i mean the music is great when they did performances uh in Nashville they were not particularly well they were received because it was like who are these hippie long hairs to come here and play our music to us and think that like they can come in to our territory uh but what they didn't realize is that Parsons was entirely sincere about his love for this music and the band and this is the thing he permanently altered the trajectory of the birds that is the thing that has to be understood from this album and everything onwards he changed their fundamental sound uh he gave them a country sound and i think he convinced mcguin and a fundamental even though grand persons as i said on our other episode it's like the one the last person on the planet you would ever want to rely on everyone to have a band member he was the most shaky dodgy person sketchy as dude on the face of this earth um uh you know he joined the band he spun their head around 360 degrees and then he left before the album was even released because thanks gram uh and uh you know this album was a commercial flop at its time and now it is treated as one of the greatest albums in history and i still for this day can't imagine what people must have thought when they turned on their radio or put their on the table and they heard you went going nowhere which is all to cover it's uh you know and i think we would all agree and certainly the critical kind of consensus this is the last great birds record and it closes out it just an incredibly creative period um it's also you know the one thing i'll say not to spend too much time on it but you know it opens and closes with dylan covers and i think it didn't just influence or change the direction of the birds and a lot of music i think it had a major influence on dylan as well obviously it comes out with national skyline and you know kind of more contrified stuff later um but you know this this is the type of album you know where you whether you like the birds or not this this is a major fork in popular music and i think it expanded things and expanded you know it made things possible with national that hadn't been possible before too so it's just a real incredible record particularly listened to after you know when you go through the discography it's just it's both a revelation and uh you know and a turn point i have to say this it's an album that i hated when i first heard it no i didn't hate i didn't i just didn't like it like this isn't enough for me i listen to it now and i absolutely adore it i think there are weaknesses i don't think like the it ends a little weekly i don't think like the blue canadian ronkeys or life in prison those two don't do anything for me but all the original material works uh i really do like uh roger mcguins uh you know that this is very clever because you know you know you know get me you know grand parses is guiding this thing basically it's for you's force of personality but they give uh mcguin pretty boy florid uh that great little outlaw rebel song you know about you know a bank robber uh who you know robs you know some people rob uh six gun and some with a with a fountain pen right which you know i think nick was talking us pre-show and he's like i did a research on that and that's not actually true and the people actually rob you with a gun and robin real people you know but it's it's it's a woody guffin song and it's a great woody guffin song and mcguin just does a fantastic job on it.
if you really want to go to you know hear our appreciation sweet harlot roger you can go back to our our episode on gram uh but everything on this album other than those last those two songs that i mentioned it's just glorious i i love listening to whether it's roger or it's gram singing about the christian life i love chris helman singing about how he's a pilgrim in the strange land and he's going to go see his family really dies and crosses that big river i love the two dillon covers and i guess you know the one thing to say is that nothing was delivered is a great way to end this album and i think the symbolic thing um you know for me you know nick was talking about this is that nothing was delivered is a way of saying um that you know dillon is country dillon is rock rock his country it's all cosmic soul music nothing was there ever and it's up to you to say just what you had in mind when you made everybody pay now i hope you won't object to live giving back all that you know that's why they do you don't miss your water that wasn't the country song that's a stack's full soul it's fantastic right yeah exactly you know this is all one sound and that was the ethos that the birds would embrace that was the ethos that grand persons fully and wholeheartedly believed in despite whatever his personal flaws were and uh you know that's that's kind of where they go from here on but the problem is is that what comes from here on out is uh is a lot more flawed and i guess we'll probably take this one uh this bit a lot more briskly the post-parsens career of the birds is incorporates uh what we have six out five albums um and uh it's a lot better than people say it is but it wouldn't claim that any of them really gonna rise to the level of anything that had come before and i think a lot of the reason for this is like poor decisions made on what songs are what albums so dr birds and mr hide that's from 1969 it's like dr bird they they they they they went out with sweetheart erudio it flopped massively they not only didn't gain a country audience they alienated their rock audience they're like well what is it just because like all the good the rock kids in los angeles there's a famous story of them you know getting booed it just became a song there's a song on dr birds called bad night at the whiskey where they're playing it whiskey a go-go which is like this you know famous la club and like they're getting booed and cat call people are throwing bottles at them because they're playing country music um uh so they lost their audience that they had and they didn't gain the audience that they were hoping to get it and now they're just stranded out on an island and i gotta give credit to roger mcwin for leading this band and actually creating some pretty good music throughout the rest of their career although the last two albums are pretty problematic i think dr birds is a better album than people give a credit for as long as you take off the two stupid soundtrack songs which are child of the universe and candy i like the last grand person song i like drugstore truck drive and man which they wrote about their bad experience with the tenacity dj a national DJ i really like king apathy in the third of the past recent the oh now yeah you know what i'm a secret prog man what can i tell you i love my hippie stuff um and i even like you know what i'm this is embarrassing i like that stupid song about the dog oh blue the big dang the big dumb dog that died and nobody died he like created a crack in the my old music and hearing louder and louder when i get the hippie first thing i do grab the morning all the new what do you guys think about this one and i guess we can probably fold up that easy ride or end it as well yeah i well i you know if we're looking at the most interesting thing about dr birds and uh mr hide is the travel logar the you know the the schemata whatever on the back where i believe the birds land as spacemen and they take their space suits off and put on country western here um and you know that tells a story that's more interesting than virtually anything on the opens with uh cover of this wheels on fire the rick thank god bob jon saw which is bad there's alternative takes that are better uh this is the album where gary usher got bounced because he you know spent too much time with the money with jad and jeremy and they bring in bob jonston who you know bob jonston who had that ben dillins you know basic producer for like five years at this point and has done a lot of great stuff but it's totally bad for this because you know as you're saying like they had alienated country people and alienated their own rock you know kind of crowd and so you bring it somebody like bob jon's none of it makes sense i think johnson bob jonston can produce like a spare kind of country stripped down album but he can't produce a band that's trying to rock no and and you know this wheels on fire is that you know what it shows is actually their treatment of it that appears on the record is that it's a ponderous song and i think i'm not a band fan uh particularly but it's the type of song which you know it seems to be deep and mysterious but it's actually just big and ambiguous um and i think you know that comes through on this i don't like songs about dogs um so like old blue and they thought that becomes a mini show from a bird song decline right now right that you glare the you know like how to hope you're a doggy heaven um you know that this is not a it's not a good album truss or truck driving man is an interesting song but again you know that's it's a weird emanation of like you know we love country music we love tradition and by the way you're all a bunch of scummy racists literally he says he says he's a drug store truck driving man he's the head of the Ku Klux Klan yeah you're not gonna really win a lot of friends when you're you know you're taring the biggest famous and beloved DJ of all country music i've always said that though if we're also talking about the ballad of easy rider which came out a couple months after i guess because i think uh dr bird since on february ballad of easy rider comes out in october of that year and it has a bunch of stuff that mikwin did for the soundtrack of easy rider this is and i i i don't want to jump over any more discussion of dr bird's but ballad of easy for it is a very it's a minor record it's like you know it's like a minor novel of a great novelist but it's it's a pretty phenomenal record that really hits um a lot of the tracks i think are traditional uh traditional songs like um jack tar the sailor which is you know like a sea shanty type song is great um Tulsa county oil in my lamp uh their version of it's all over now baby blue uh which is their second take on if they had done a fast-paced version that was left off it or was left off it it was left off turn turn turn yeah i like that earlier one a little oh okay yeah this one is just it's a beautiful long so and it's like you know the sixties are definitively over and you know and easy rider there's a minor there's a minor peter fonda who's big fan of the birds um looks over at us on a certain ability we blew it like you know that because they were retiring based on drug money so the whole idea of the sixties dream had a bad foundation that's gonna it's gonna lead to you know a bad end and i think this album perfectly kind of captures that moment of like where man we look the river flows it flows to the sea wherever that river goes that's where i want to be flow where the flow let's walk down take me from this road to song well he wanted was to be free and that's the way it turned out to be flow where the flow it's what's washed down take me from his road to song another town it's filled with sadness uh it's a very interesting deep routine uh deep routine that you know what he got through song is beautiful it's i mean it's fair uh wonderful songs but also really depressing back to dr bird's mr hide for one moment because i actually agree with jeff i think ken apathy is a it's a pretty great song uh it feels like a union of of country and inside and i got start stop groove and echo laden country picking kind of liking apathy but i also agree with neck i think ballad is my favorite of these late career birds uh albums uh terry melters back in to produce it sounds a whole lot better than dr birds and mr hide to start with um but you've got some interesting stuff here i'd like tolssa county uh cover with with gwen on vocals um my favorite song the album though is that is that hard country approach on there must be someone uh jeep harsons no relation sings that one and it's a song that was written by verne uh goston from from country he returned home and found his wife left him and took took his kids with him and so it's delivered in an appropriate manner for that kind of uh that kind of set of lyrics very haunting uh melody and at a great leave vocal by jean parsons i think there must be someone is the best uh song on valedee's writer all my soul call friends have turned their backs on me they were looking for someone i just couldn't be let them go and have their fun for the harm they don't there must be someone i can turn uh this has uh i hope it's any truly like outstanding standout tracks but it's pretty consistent oil in my lamp i like it's very early early 70s kind of beach boys feel very harmony laden harmony laden arrangements um on oil in my lamp um so this this is my favorite of the other late career uh bird records i think it's not my favorite of the late career bird records the next one is actually my favorite of those but i i think i will say this this is the period well there are two things i need to point it out uh the first is that this is the period where i think every one of these records would have been vastly improved if like some of these outtakes or alternate takes substituted or included instead of the stuff that made it on the album that's band politics that are that are going on there the things decisions that of course we were not there to witness we don't know what happened but man if they had included the alternate version of oil in my lamp on valedee's your writer that would have made it a lot better if they had included the alternate version of all the things on on title coming up oh my god that would have just been the highlight of that album the other thing that actually has to be pointed out that we haven't discussed is the massive personality changes in the band so after sweetheart of the rodeo what happens is that not only does his grand parsons leave but that that that little that damn thief that damn thief he steals chris helmet away from him as well all right so chris helmet and grand parsons leave and then they of course form the flying burrito butters which is a great thing for the history of music because that gives us the gilded palisas in which is one of the greatest country rocker oh yeah we talked about it on our episode of parsons oh my god i love that record but that leaves me going as the only original bird in the entire band so who does he get um he gets a couple of other guys that the person else are gonna change gene parsons is the genre fit until the end uh as as scott said no relation to gram but the most important addition and this is the one that really needs to be emphasized is that they get a guy called claren's white claren's white had already been playing with this band for years and on several albums you can hear them on younger than yesterday you can hear them on notorious bird blowers he plays on wasn't born to follow i believe any plays on changes now oh you can hear them on uh sweetheart of the rodeo and at this point it was just a natural idea okay you know what you're gonna become a full member of the band uh one for me at least the highlight of the later era of the birds is claren's white he is a fantastic guitarist and the irony is is that as compromised as some of these later period albums are he also made them uh they were almost an incompetently bad live band during their early Crosby you know clark you know uh you know hilman years and then once claren's white joins the band and the albums can weaker the live stuff and i've got a ton of live birds boolegs from this era they are a crack band they are absolutely fantastic band um so it is added that the tragedy of claren's white's career is that he's not with us anymore and it's not because you know he did the standard rock star thing where he overdosed or you know he was driving too fast you know in his car high on cocaine or anything that he was literally loading amplifiers into the back of a truck after a gig with his brother in 1973 and a drunk driver hit him and killed him uh which is just you know one of those things that just makes you just feel really glum because he's a guy who's one of the most influential guitarist certainly like top 10 in country rock of all time and he contributes so much to these albums parsons though i think does a pretty good job too gunga din is a song on bat with a easy rider that i really like it's a very simple kind of a low-key easygoing song uh it just sort of uh you know like it goes low-key it's about their basis john york being refused seating at a restaurant because he came in wearing a leather jacket he was going there with his mom for mother's day or something like that one other thing is that we have to put out that this is this is the best version of jesus is just all right by me that you're gonna hear you know this is of course a song that was made this was a single for the for the birds it was actually a hit for them and they played it but then of course the doobie brothers like took it into the top 10 or something are we are we united in our dislike of the doobie brothers you know what i'm always gonna i'm always gonna like taking it to the streets and i'm always gonna like uh what a fool believes that's later other than that dial there i like they're unerring and undying belief in the music you know that somehow if you just listen to this uh you know that the music can cure cancer in their bad 80s come back so the doctor you know it's well you know what listen i'm gonna tell you nick if you just if you just play that funky dixieland then little mom i'm gonna take you by the hand you know we could beat this uh carotovirus if we just listen to the music okay listen though jesus is just all right was of course made famous more famous at least by the doobie brothers but the birds version just quarks it's so much better there is and also on bird maniacs and we should also probably you know that we're skipping over there's the ballad of these right or untitled then bird maniacs the names of the albums get worse with dr birds and mr hi but they you know they start doing more kind of christian uh you know kind of gospel uh heavy chorus up which also i think later down the road influences dillen a bit and some of his winter 70s stuff but um because it's all part of the tradition i think it's the idea yeah yeah yeah yeah you know if we want to talk about untitled which was something of a return to form the double apple neck and that's 70 and a head of live disc and a studio disc and for me the standouts there um uh or chestnut mayor the uh roger mcwinchock's levi song which is pretty great i mean just again evocative of a world that i i showed up thinking about it and i love the live version of eight miles high that's 16 minutes long i knew a couple of older people who were into you know kind of FM radio stations when they came out and they were like you know that and a couple of other long tracks that covered an entire sign of an album they would wait to listen to that on the radio and it was so you know kind of weird and wonderful and you know what you know we hit ground up in this cookie kind of world and suddenly you know if the birds are playing a 16 minute version long you know version of eight miles high which really you know like if you stick with it man when they come back and it's just one of the most uh powerfully beautiful kind of porcheastic moments of rock as far as i'm concerned i think that's that's a pretty great live performance although i will argue that nobody needs to hear a four minute long skip baton bass there in the middle of it because you know he's just going like a british it's not the most it's not john n-spussel or it's not like it'll actually be curious it's like it's like that's what's great as it has to be that long so that it means something stuck it out i think it's untitled is an album that is a return to form and yet i kind of like you know it upsets me because i think it could have been so much better if they just made some better decisions on what to include the live album this is kind of like it's like a sort of alternate universe version of pink floyds umaguma which you know i i open we would have Anthony Fischer on our show i joke it's like is this the worst double album ever made but i also included it as one of my two all like you know definitive records at the end of the show because the live disc is the most it's like one of the highlights of pink floyds career and the studio disc is one of the worst things they ever did you're shrinking the parameters on both sides the live disc isn't as transcendent as maybe that pink floyds but it's incredibly good this band was so hot live and the studio disc is not nearly as bad as for it but it could have been so much better just not mayor you know this is by the way this is the moment when Roger Mcguin is writing a rock opera you know pig towns and p-towns and you know probably did some bad things to rock music because everyone was writing rock operas with a guy named jonke leavey who we last saw on our bob dillin episode you know doing stuff on desire but right this is five years earlier and he's writing us rock opera based on tenric impson of all things henry gibson's pure gint you know we appear gint this is like this nor region play where the guy is like obsessed with chasing this one white goose that he wants to kill well it's a chestnut mayor in this one and uh you know of course it's also a metaphor for like an unattainable woman it's just hilarious and fun and a beautiful beautiful beautiful chorus melody where like you know i'm gonna i'm gonna i'm gonna rope that girl i'm gonna get it one day and you know it's um it's one of the great truly great studio birds songs but i will say this that there are um there are songs in here that i do also like like there's this okay yes it's dumb because it's about reincarnation but you know what yesterday's train i love it i love that song and i like clairains white's vocal on it and i'll even say that like you know um the normal album version of all the things is sort of mediocre kind of country rock but man if you go find that alternate version that's on disc two the reissue disc two it opens it holy christ i don't know why they didn't include this it's it's a throwback to younger than yesterday or notorious it's this rickin bacher 12 string thing with these intense three-part harmonies uh i don't understand where this came from and why it was excluded from the album but again you know a title is an album which to me basically stands on the strength of its if it's live disc and it opens with of course another one of those um you know levi and uh mcguinsons lover of the bayou where he's you know it's not a bunch of nonsense he's like you know i know i was you know i got the mojo hands or like you know like i'm a lover of the bayou but man he's uh he's uh running into uh john sogony uh people like that somewhere with that swamp rock yeah it's oh wait wait wait you say you're a lover of the bayou i was born on the bayou son of a bitch exactly it's good bayou it's not good bayou it's not good bayou it's good bayou catfish by the greek with that i'm a lover of the bayou rock you don't stand with a hamlet ride i'm a lover of the bayou reason's when we're the crocodile uh yeah you know uh this is one of the things i highly recommend uh if people have the opportunity to see roger mcguin live and he has you know over the course of his career has really polished a set that is pretty good and something like all the things i've heard him do live i don't know if he's currently doing it and it's pretty incredible and also just the season um you know where his uh you know he's a great performer in a strip down like in a solo band um and i agree with you there's something we're going on with their song selection and the production and you hear stories if you read about the birds like where they cut the tracks and then they like they're hiding from their wives so they can't stick around in the studio to kind of come up with a finished version and they put it in the hands of terry melcher or something and like an album comes out that's a disaster and they claim they have no understanding what's being done you know it doesn't quite add up but it doesn't add up i mean it has a lot of excuse making yeah you know melcher is fascinating you know it's a character he's you know one of the inspirations for the uh peter fonda character in the limelight that's the people yeah you know just you know and he obviously i assume uh whenever matt welch was not the peach was i always try to bring it immediately to uh charles manta terry melcher of course since the you know it was the uh lynch panel no no i would actually argue that kim fowlie is the lynch b actual actual actual like child rapist kim fowlie oh god we've talked about that kim fowlie is you know i i don't even want to talk about it he's folded right i'm sorry sorry it's warm all right scott your thoughts on untitled before we move on to these last few albums you guys covered a lot of untitled for me it's a passable album especially on the um on the studio end i do like uh just a season which is one of those songs that was written for the musical this wider sort of full crack reality with much heavier lyrics and uh other thing i want to say about chestnut mare quickly and jeff telly i just don't remember if we talked about this on the elvis castello episode but elvis castello wrote a song for a roger mccwin called you bow down which uh is on all this useless beauty and it's totally it totally sounds like chestnut it's just ripped off that melody i mean not rip off borrowed whatever right but it's the same melody from chestnut mare and uh you bow down exactly same kind of line right and it's totally it's totally birdsy so it's not like he's trying to high anything it has the same sort of rick and bocker sound he wrote it for roger mccwin i had it exactly but but obviously took some of that melody from chestnut mare for you bow down which is a fantastic song about it so what do we want it to say about i i don't even i okay not only there are three remaining birds alms but in my life there are only two i don't consider that final reunion album to be referred to we need to discuss that a little bit but why don't we talk about then the you know bird maniacs bird maniacs are okay listen i'm gonna say like these are universally treated as like just like you know disastrous i will just say this about bird maniacs if you only listen to the first three songs yes you go through them and you're like with this yes yes yeah glory glory pale blue i trust my trustable strings great soul and gospel song i trust i trust is you know and this i guess is one of those records you know more than any of the other birds ones where what went wrong with the production uh you know i'm gonna talk about those first three songs are pretty phenomenal all of a sudden oh my good lord god this is our two-family who we won't speak of like really you know you get a tunnel of love it's five it's five minutes long it's five minutes long and it's it's stupid fat domino like 50 it's like it could there be anything less relevant to the birds than this i don't you think that's bad oh buddy you think that's bad let me give you a citizen cane okay now we have goofy horns oh god i want to die but it's not an old hollywood right in power politics in 1920s yeah okay because there's nothing there's nothing about that bird the birds there's nothing more relevant to the birds country rock or futuristic sci-fi folk rock psych rock sensibilities then old hollywood and citizen cane it's just like kimfali just wanted some freaking record royalties i'm so upset about those songs they're so terrible even the one that miguinsing's that i want to grow up to be thoughtful too thoughtful it's awful it's awful so like you know and then it gets to much i mean like the the version of jamaica say you will like it's you know there are some songs and even full albums that are like this where when you listen to them you're like where's the music i mean it is unutterably bad yeah i actually i'm gonna say this i think that we did a jackson brown episode with cam joseph and we talked about jamaica say you will and we actually i think scott and i agree that we actually prefer the birds version of this to jackson browns i'm not a fan of jackson brown okay well there you go that might explain it uh yeah blood but what i find absolutely hilarious is the way that claryon's white not roger mcguyn sings the song and he sounds literally exactly like jackson brown like every inflection his entire vocal tone you would have thought that just like brought okay guest vocalist jackson brown on jamaica say you will it is the same voice the same inflections it's almost like he copied it from a demo and he just like learned it like syllable by syllable like like like a chinese person who doesn't speak english and just you know just like jamaica say you it's weird i think it's a good song it's you know it's it's just as i said the first three songs is working are okay but everything else other than that is almost unread teamable i guess you know we'll wrap it up like what do you think i think i read some critic right of joke so like so like where maniacs was like you know like ultra orchestrated crap and so then they did strip down crap with farther along um their final album uh before they did the reunion so what do you guys think of this final album i'll just say this i think that that that one of their last songs i like it i like bugler quite a bit fine the attention to the tale is so poor though that on the label of some pressing since bugler b u g l a r and then others it's er i mean it's you know i was spending more time picking their beards than you know producing music yeah they all hide out giant beards on the front cover of this album too which is another like early 1970s thing you know to point out but uh scott you have any opinions by the way on either of these albums um i completely agree i mean if you could read my notes you'd say the same thing first three songs at brit maniacs are actually promising and then well you cover the rest i trust it's good farther along um i think you know there is decent uh tippity queen things the first song of the album i i wrote it sounds like david would want to sound like like six years later um kind of that almost retro rock saw sound to it tippity queens all right farther along which which uh white sings it's really spotty at best the band ended up producing this themselves and uh like jeff mentioned it went from really poorly produced crap on brit maniacs to you know it's produced a little better but the song quality is still you know the song quality is still not there on on farther along i just want to say for the birds reunion record in 1973 uh that uh and i guess i should say i when i was a kid and i was getting into the birds i would go to this great record store in redneck new jersey called jacks and i would buy the albums by how much i can afford and so all of the crappy records crappy albums were cheaper so i actually kind of worked backwards through the birds this time because you're giving credit for that you know the ones that i couldn't take and take from the library so yeah the birds greatest hits cost more than farther along right yeah and farther along and birds may be acting you know and all of this um and the the reunion record i actually got for 25 cents on an eight-track tape uh a flea market i went to rockers uh you know this was i guess in the early eighties and uh i liked it and what i want to i don't want to make a case for it as a great record but it was the jean clark songs on that album are fantastic and jean clark he's the only one who's trying that's the thing yeah and and he you know when he left the birds and then he worked with uh dunk dillard and did a couple of fantastic records he worked with the gosden brothers uh and he had an alcohol problem and he dug young and without you know it was like in his 50 early 50s and he didn't really fulfill his potential but he you know those those songs on the birds 1973 for the new album are beautiful his vocals are great and you know again from me this is you know the birds like they showed us that we can imagine and do whatever we want we have like ultimate freedom and yet they couldn't you know get there so if you know we're kind of like the chest you know the character and chest member we have to keep trying because we we're never quite getting what we want um but you know how you know how that the birds uh rather you know how the Crosby state of nash and young light album called four-way street yeah this is literally basically this is five-way street it is it's it's not the birds in fact i think it was actually literally the title is quote birds but the actual billing is not the birds it's you Crosby gwen clark clark and uh you know hillman and that is everything you need to know about what kind of corporate spirit was going on here uh you know as Nick points out the only guy who actually brings the a-game in any way is this jean clark jean clark who was you know those first two albums his contributions to them are stunning they're so stellar uh they cannot be forgotten and he reminds you of what you missed uh by bringing good songs to this one everyone else is holding back and i think they've even admitted it yeah i didn't get a shit you know i was just like you know i was doing my solo album at the time i mean like it's a sad comment that the best song on this album is a cover of a Neil Young song uh it's uh jean clark singing see this guy about the right at the end of the song and end of the album and i also like i think david crossby wrote at least one good song as a solo tune and that's laughing so like you know like again he's too lazy to get on the news at the one where uh now i'm sorry it says cover for free where he's talking about the quick lunch stand because he started becoming obsessed with food you know his sexual urges have been satisfied and now he was just gonna eat it jony mitchell is a great songwriter but you know like the fact that we're seeing jony mitchell and david crossby solo tracks and new young tracks means that this isn't a bird's album it's a cs ny album it's just like i don't know that's why i've had so little time but i've listened to it maybe like three times in my entire life anyone have any last thoughts on this before you rap i do not have any thoughts on this album so what's wrapped buddy sorry to end with such a he fella i suppose very very i actually do want to point this out that this is the thing that nick you know when we were talking in our pre-show notes he made a really eloquent point and he's mentioned it on the show here too is that you know the birds were so great they flew so high they're like echorus right they flew to the sun and but then the wings melted and then they fell um maybe they didn't you know fall plummet directly into the ocean but that we was definitely a decline and uh you know like that album that last album it is kind of sad because it kind of represents the triumph of you know egos and agendas over its early hippie dream or the counterculture dream that you saw so brilliantly represented in those first you know five six albums um doesn't mean that we don't have to treasure all of the music that they made but it is also a worthy reminder of how kind of you know human fella you know human frailty will intervene in a band's career even a great band's career and i consider to be i consider the birds to be one of the greatest bands of all time there's the political beach look at the birds we come to the point of the episode where each of us gives you the listener two albums from the band that you most own five songs that you really should hear and we always have our guest go first that's Nick Gillespie in this episode Nick your two albums and your five songs please okay so my two albums are the first greatest hits record i came out in august of 1967 and it's a uh a very good sampler of mr chamberine lantern turn turn fifth dimension of younger than yesterday it came out in august of 1967 in january of 1968 that released the notorious bird brothers which is my second album for reasons we discussed but i think that's you know if you listen to those two things you will be you know you will understand why people and musicians and listeners keep coming back to the birds uh there's something really powerful there and you can dine out on their imagined kind of soundscape or i think for decades then my uh five tracks the essential tracks uh not a lot of surprises here but it's mr tambourine man turn turn turn renaissance fair from younger than yesterday wasn't born to follow from the notorious bird brothers and then the live version of eight miles high and i think this song sequence kind of captures both their promise and the dissipation of that and you know there's something about that eight miles high that live version where you stick it out and you realize like they still have one great chorus left in them that just even talking about a much less listening to it raises the hair on my back and it makes me feel like you know no matter how late in the day it is everything is still possible and everything is still in front of us and i think the birds uh you know do that again and again and that's you know that's for me is there uh i can meditate on what it means to be alive and to reach for the sun and try and get there as close as possible um and keep doing that it's almost like maybe not datallist and it's more like sisyphus that's what the birds are doing to get the best uh so my two albums i will add younger than yesterday which i i think is again perhaps they're their best and um and in sweetheart of the rodeo which i don't know is representative but it's hard to get representative of a band that was really so eclectic during the course of their career and i just think sweetheart of the rodeo from start to finish is extremely high quality with the contributions from grand parsons and sort of bringing mcwin and others along for the ride on the songs i um i kind of assumed people to put some of the big ones um i feel a whole lot better from that first album is on uh my list of five also have you seen her face uh you don't miss your water from sweetheart of the rodeo uh nick mentioned wasn't born to follow that one's also on my list and i figure when i come to the birds i gotta include one dylan cover somewhere so um my back pages is my fifth song i think it's the finest dylan song the birds ever did uh jaf to you uh well i mean for me and i pretty clearly telegraphed this one week you can get our discussion it's gonna be younger than younger than yesterday and atarias bird brothers uh i really just need to emphasize that mr tambereen man turn turn turn fifth dimension um and uh sweetheart of the rodeo they're all equally needed i just don't understand how you can think of yourself as like an informed consumer of music without having all of these albums they're all great but if i had to just pick two it would be those i neck you cupped out you got the greatest hits and that was a very it was a clever move my friend i guess i'll leave you it's a sign of weakness no no i think it's a sign of craftiness uh my five songs i'm gonna you need to have for me at least you know any discussion needs to include at least one gene clark song for me that's actually gonna be a song that didn't make an album it's she don't care about time the b-side of turn turn turn just a fantastic song he wrote so many great pieces of music for the birds but during those first two years and that's to me is actually his best uh he actually co-wrote another one of them uh which is one reason i don't think it's his best is that i think you know mcguin and krausby also like contributed significantly to this and that's eight miles high eight miles high again everybody in the band contributes there clark mcguin kra's b they are singing and playing their asses off and i also will point out that everybody makes fun of michael clark as a drummer listen to michael clark's drum track on eight miles high that is as crazy as he ever got that wasn't some studio pro that they got it and they didn't hire some like you know wrecking crew musician that's michael clark just going crazy on the trap set and it's amazing stuff and it's a song that kind of revolutionized the sound of music my third song will be from younger than yesterday it's my back pages uh scott already mentioned it and of course i've mentioned it in past episodes don't really need to talk more about it changes now from naturias bird brothers um changes now is uh just a song that it means so much to me from what i heard back when i was a kid and it still means so much to me now i still like you know there's some sort of inner hippie and you waiting to get out who wants to dance to the day when fear is gone um yeah i love that song i love everything about it um and i guess my final one is uh the song that should have ended in torius bird brothers uh and that's lady friend that's the greatest song that the birds ever released in my opinion and i know nicholas greeben sorry neck uh host parega dev i get to overrule you and i think it should have been lady friends lady lady lady lady friends we can hear you know that you're into that whole triad scene and i'm not i i'm just i'm just into the part where the birds go bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop bop that is uh their most compact pop melody and uh it almost kind of drives me nuts to acknowledge that it came from the mind of david kraussby uh but you know what you know you just have to tip your cap sometimes it's like game respect game like this man actually wrote a fantastic song and uh it's uh sort of to me what epitomizes everything that the birds meant to me as a sonic phenomenon that sort of you know rush the sort of pure rush of joy and almost incomprehensible you have to go back and listen to it again again and again to figure out how great a song it is that would be my final show there is the political beach look at the music and career of the birds we thank our guest for today's episode uh nick lessby editor at large at reason co-author of the declaration of independence how libertarian politics can fix what's wrong with america phd american literature 14 magazine editor and uh now political beach guest find them on twitter at nick the lesby nick thanks so much for joining us it's really been a huge pleasure and thank you for helping me read us cover the birds uh they meant so much to me as a kid and i go back for the number of years and this is uh it's a good they're grateful listen to during a quarantine yeah and thank you for joining us man this has been so fun good episode jeff stay healthy stay safe well i mean i you know i have to take my kit out for strolls so uh you know i you know i hope some guy doesn't cough on me at esoteric city for jeff you can find me on twitter at scott's birch ram remember subscribe to our feed for new episodes apple podcast google play stitch tune in and national review dot com click on the uh podcast tab and find all of the nr podcasts we've got us on facebook at political beach and at political underscore beats on twitter this has been a presentation of national review this is political beach