Hello, and welcome to Episode 80 of Structure and Indigenous. Structure and Indigenous is a space for exploring new ways of thinking about social structure. My name is Jody Clark, and I'm very grateful that you're listening today. You are very welcome here.
Now if you're new to this podcast, welcome and thrilled that you're here, I'll just tell you a little bit about myself. I am an American as you can probably hear, but I've lived in South Yorkshire in the UK for quite a lot of years now. I moved to Britain over 20 years ago, and before that I lived in France for five years in Strasbourg, and in Paris. And before that, I lived on the East Coast with the United States in the State of Maryland for actually less time than I've lived abroad.
So I'm not exactly an expert on what I'd like to live in Maryland anymore. I'm currently a linguist at Sheffield Hall of University, and recently I've started becoming a fiction writer, and I've been combining my love of language and the study of language with my love of creativity and storytelling, and it's been wonderful. And my fiction explores the intimacy embedded in the structure of the language. So I use these podcasts as a way to unpick that notion of intimacy that I believe is embedded in the structure of language.
And I also use these podcasts to explore the idea that this might be part of the Earth's evolution. At the heart of all my work, this is my fiction work, my podcasts, my teaching, my academic work, is that when we inhabit language, worlds are transformed. And I often like to start the episode with a question for you to ponder, to put you in the center of the episode. And this question today is, is nothing sacred.
You don't have to answer the question about whether anything is sacred, or you don't have to answer the question is nothing sacred. I would just love to know what that question, and particularly that tone, conjures up for you. Have you ever heard someone say that to you? Have you ever felt that?
So bubble up for it inside you is nothing sacred. And in what context does that emerge? So have you ever been in a situation you felt like something, there was one sort of sacrosanct thing, one sacred thing that it was sort of impossible to breach the sanctity of that thing, or that experience, or that event, or that symbol? And then someone breaches it, or it is breached in some way.
That might be it. The language that was up for me is when I first went to uni in the late 90s. And I was in a hall of residence, so we called them a dorm, where there were sort of like men and women were on the same corridor. So we shared rooms.
You didn't share with a, you wouldn't share with someone who wasn't supposedly your gender. But you would, but we all shared the same bathroom. So you'd be showering next to people who were the same. I mean, there'd be curtains and stuff, but you're still looking down and seeing feet that weren't necessarily the feet of someone who shared a gender with you.
So when I told my aunt that, now she was, she's 96 now, and I don't feel like doing the math to figure out how old she was then. But she was someone who had sort of very strong principles about what, you know, just what was right wrong, but not necessarily in terms of morally right or wrong. It's just like what makes for a smoothly functioning society if you want. I love, I still do love talking to my aunt about these things because she's perfectly happy to tell me how she feels.
And she's also perfectly happy to listen when I disagree with her, which is very rare, and lovely. But in any case, when I told her that we had these co-ed toilets, she said, wait, so you share bathrooms with the men and the women on the floor share bathrooms, I said, yes. And she said, that is number one on my stupid list. And I asked her why, and she said, it just takes away all of the mystery.
So it was very clear that my aunt held a kind of sanctity, that she sort of imposed a kind of sanctity, a sacredness around the idea that men and women are separate, so that she had a sort of, the notion of a kind of binary gender system and also kind of heterosexual desire. For her was, there was, in that moment, it might have changed, but in that moment there was the sense of sacredness there, and also the idea that men and women were supposed to see each other as mysterious. And I also, the idea is also that mystery was supposed to be part of a, coming together through heterosexual desire that you're supposed to not know that much about the nakedness, of the other person, I guess, I don't know, because we're putting words in a way, and does mouth now. But hopefully that story is kind of making you think in terms of when people have said, oh, it's nothing sacred, which Aunt Duck didn't say, but that's the way I interpreted it.
Because what it reveals is what we consider to be inviolable and how we feel when that inviolable thing is somehow violated. And it shows us kind of our set of principles, and it shows us our kind of societal ideals. And so it's a very helpful question to ask, but it can also make you feel a little fragile perhaps in terms of, oh, wait, I have these sort of set of ideals or a set of morals that other people might share, might not share. And so that's always a potentially troubling situation to be in.
And it's a situation that a lot of us have found ourselves in a lot of the time. So just ponder on that for a moment. But I would also, as you're pondering, I would love for you to ask the question, what does it even mean for something to be sacred? So just pop that in the treasure chest of things that you're pondering as you listen to this podcast.
And then I'm going to ask you another question, and please don't feel you have to answer this one even at all. Because this question, the next question makes it seem like this is a self-help podcast, which it absolutely is not. But question number two is, what are your aims? What are your goals?
What are your values? OK, so I'm not even going to pause to allow you to answer that question because I don't want you to suddenly mistake this for a self-help podcast. But the reason that question has come up, I have found myself asking that question, particularly of students. And this year for the first time I'm teaching on a module at Sheffield University for a second year students called Ideas into Action.
And this is such a great module. But don't tell anybody that I enjoy teaching on it, because if you tell anybody that I enjoy teaching on it, they'll probably give me more teaching. It's what, if you tell people you enjoy what you're teaching, they end up giving you more. So keep that, let's keep that between us.
Anyways, this is a fantastic module where students actually get to do projects or do enterprises or work as emplacements. And they spend lots and lots of time doing the types of things that we don't often get time to do when we're kind of immersed in quote unquote real world stuff, which is to reflect, which is to think about how what they're doing is meaningful or to think about the mistakes they're making but not seeing them as problems that seem as possibilities for change and possibilities for growth. So it's really fascinating and it's great to watch the students as they move through these puzzles week and then week out. And it's also really fascinating to find out how they're engaged with the world because they've got some really, you don't have to wait until after university to actually make change in the world with one of the things I've learned.
In any case, as an exercise, I've been asking the students to look at other enterprises and other, other, like, entrepreneurial exercises, look on their websites to see what their values are and to see what their mission is and to see what their aims are. And then we've been working on them, formulating their own values and aims for their particular projects or their placements. And what's interesting about that is, first of all, how willing they were to do that because I thought it was a little bit of a hokey exercise, but they were all like, yeah, and then they did it, they did it quite quickly. Like, they were able to really hone in on what their values were and what their aims were, which was very impressive because I'm always working on my aims and values and it normally takes me quite some time.
But they did it very quickly and they really did seem to resonate, which was great. Now, and then they were able to really think in terms of what action needed to be taken next because it was like, what action will best align with my values or my aims? Now, as I said, this is not self-help podcast, so you can do that or not do that, that's completely up to you. But I did mention to them that I have aims, I said, you have aims for your project, but that might be different from your aims for being a uni student or it might be different from your aims if you're a parent, you know, that type of thing.
And I tend to have aims for all the various things that I do because it does help me focus and think about what matters most to me and sort of fill throughout things I don't want to do. And when I said that, if I had been a student in the classroom, my hand would have shot up and I would have said, well, Jati, what are your aims? Luckily for me, none of the student's arms shot up to ask me that question. I was actually very happy they didn't because I do have an aim, specifically an aim for teaching, but teaching kind of writ large, not just teaching at university.
And that aim, I didn't want to voice because, again, it sounds a little hokey, but I will voice it for you because we're going to keep you because you're safe space and because you're not going to share with anybody else, we're keeping secrets today. We're keeping the space secret. And that leads me into the actual aim, which is to honor the sacred spaces where new ideas emerge. And the only word that makes me blush a little bit about that aim is the word sacred.
Okay, it feels a little bit maybe a little bit new agey, which I'm totally am that I never want to admit. And it feels like I'm kind of bringing this sort of grandeur to something, which is really just about sort of creating space and about innovation. But if they had asked me, I would have had to leave that word in because it would have been dishonest, not to. That word is pretty important to the things that I do.
So this is why I'm asking you, what does the word sacred mean to you? What does it conjure up? What connotations does it have? And we'll discuss what it means to me as we go through the podcast.
But one person whose view on the word sacred, I would like to sort of bring to our attention now. And this is the French sociologist in Dauchheim. And for him, sacredness is a key, key, key concept. It's fundamental to his understanding of religious life.
And Dauchheim in 1912 wrote a book called The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life. I think that's what it's called. And studying religious life was key to him in his pursuit of a science of the social. And he is the one who actually formally established the Academic Disciplines of Sociology.
So this was the moment where I was like, look, you can study society in the same way, you know, with the same vigor and rigor that you study in the natural world. So treating society as something that was worthy of study and developing principles for how this could be studied and exploring some of the foundations of a study of sociology at work for Dauchheim. And so in 1912 when he wrote this book about religious life, a lot of his philosophy, if you like, around society, I believe comes through that. And what he said about religion is absolutely fascinating to me because, and he comments on this, people often have this notion that religion is about having faith in some supernatural.
So by supernatural, we just mean anything that we, you know, can't sort of see with our senses or we can't, we can't sort of explain the logic of with the data that's presented to our senses. So if we can't see God, then God is a supernatural being. So I think probably most people would accept that. And so religion for most people is about whether or not you believe in God or a God, or it might be also something like whether you believe there's life after death.
It's something that we can't ever experience without dying ourselves and we can't come back and tell each other about it most of the time. And so that's another supernatural about this idea that there's this world beyond. And so these are the types of things that we might think of when we think about religion, like if you ask somebody, if they have a religion, you're effectively asking, what do you believe? What, who is your God, right?
What supernatural forces do you believe interceded in our sort of natural world, if you like, or even if they don't intercede that they witness our natural, just exist. And what Durkheim said was actually, no, if you go back to the fundamental forms, like if you go way, way back to sort of the like earliest forms of religion, and he said, and you can, you can do this by looking at societies that haven't been westernized, right, that haven't had lots of influence with, you know, sort of like first world, if you like, the religions that have probably stayed in place from when these societies first formed. And he uses the word primitive, which I've been trying not to use that word, but I did just use it. In any case, he says, if you look at them, they weren't actually their religious life.
Their whole existence was sort of imbued with this religiosity. And it wasn't actually about the supernatural. It was about the natural. Like everywhere you look, there's this kind of religiosity with looking at the natural world, like trees and clouds and eclipses and that type of thing.
And it wasn't so much about making up stories about supernatural beings, although that could be part of it. And he said, instead, what's at the absolute root of any religious life or any form of religion is a distinction. And the distinction is between the sacred and the profane. The sacred does not have to be supernatural.
So you're so a maybe a clan that had a kangaroo totem. The kangaroo is sacred, whereas maybe the wombat isn't sacred, right? So that so it doesn't have to be a supernatural being. It doesn't have to be, you know, like the Messiah that we don't that we don't have or doesn't have to be God or doesn't have to be angels or things that we're not seeing all the time.
It's just the recognition that there are some things that are sacred and some things that are profane. And so effectively, the importance of their being, this distinction between sacred and profane is that they are diametrically opposed, right? They're not in linguistics. We say these are not scalable or gradable adjectives.
The things that are not sacred are profane. And you can profane the sacred, but what it says is that in society that carries with it huge sanctions, especially in religious societies. And his argument is that all societies are religious, right? So to actually profane the sacred, you cannot do that without consequences that are more or less severe.
And so the idea is, and so when we start thinking about what's sacred, we don't have to be religious, but it might be something like, you know, from an academic context, it's like maybe graduation feels like a sacred moment. And maybe you're watching, you're graduating and you're watching a friend walk across to get their degree and to shake the mic, and you're thinking about all of the horrible things that they did to you. And you would not stand up and say, that person slipped with my boyfriend. To do that would profane the moment.
It would take a sacred moment and make it profane because effectively you've kind of brought your dispute about that person into a sacred space. So it doesn't have to, it's not about the religious beliefs, it's about the rituals. And so anytime society is creating rituals, what they're doing with those rituals is saying, we are doing the work to keep what is sacred, sacred, and to keep it separate from what is profane. Now what is profane is not bad, right?
Having a conversation about boundaries around your boyfriend is not bad. Or even an argument is not bad, that type of thing. But it's to be kept separate from your housemate walks across the stage, for instance. And you can shout it out, there's nothing stopping you from shouting out, she slept with my boyfriend, but it won't be without consequences.
People will probably judge you for quite some time if you do that. People will have huge social sanctions for you, which is why you probably won't do that. And so if we look at, if you do look at your actual religious moments or anytime you've been in church or anytime you've been in something that feels like a church, like maybe you've been to a wedding, but it wasn't a religious wedding, there are still these moments of sacred and profane. But all of our social life is infused with these things.
And what Durkheim says about this, he says, this is the fundamental element of religion. So all religions across the world and across time are bound up in this distinction between sacred and profane. And he also says that the idea of society is what's kept in place by this religious distinction. So he says, what happens when people are respecting the distinction between sacred and profane?
In other words, what happens when people are engaging in religious life is that they are all acknowledging that there's something bigger than them. So all of religion, all of the sacred and profane, all of this worship, all of that is about individuals recognizing there's something bigger than them. And the interesting thing is that for Durkheim, what's bigger for them them is not God or the Pantheon or the cosmos. What's bigger than them is society.
And so he says the idea of society is the soul of religion. He says, and I can't quite know how Durkheim explains this next part. He probably does, but I don't think I understand it perfectly. But effectively he says with human beings, it's almost like human beings can't exist without this other societal world.
They can't kind of coexist without thinking that there's this society that's bigger than them. Animals do it, he says all the time. Animals sort of move by their instincts and they know how to sort of get to the food. Where human beings need each other in order to get what's necessary for them to live communally and for them to survive.
And in order for them to actually coordinate their movements and coordinate, let's say they're hunting or they're gathering or they're home building, etcetera, they're child-wearing, they need to be not in total harmony with each other, but they need to be cooperating with each other. And in order to do that, they need to all acknowledge there's something bigger than them. And that bigger than them is society. But the way the society manifests itself is through religious life.
And so effectively, it's like if everyone can participate in the rituals that keep the sacred sacred, then that is everyone involved in the kind of collective. Everyone is oriented towards the same task, which is keeping the sacred sacred. And that is a kind of practice whereby people are practicing being part of their society and they are honoring this thing that is bigger, which is society. So I am absolutely fascinated by this.
I guess the one thing that fascinates me the most is how splintered our society actually is and how we can kind of keep functioning in a Durkainian way. When you read Durkain, it's like a celebration of society. It's like a kind of, wow, it's amazing that we have this thing that's bigger than us and that we recognize that. And yet, normally when I think about society, I think about it and I think I'm not alone in this, I think about it as something that is oppressive, that forces you to do things that might not be in your best interest or that it puts you into some kind of box that you have to go counter-cultural to get out of or you have to somehow reinvent.
For me, a progressive society is one in which people are able to constantly reinvent things. So we can reinvent what gender means to us and we can recognize that we don't need to have a binary. That was something that is no longer required for whatever purpose or the purpose that it was required for is not there anymore. The reason for the gender binary was to keep one gender higher than the other and to justify that.
So I just look at these kind of societal things and I don't want to sort of bow down in various societies that Durkain does. And so, but I still value society. And so when I think about the different ways that society is kind of splintered or it's that so many different people have so many different things that they hold sacred and it makes me think, well, maybe we need to think about ways, new ways of thinking about social structure, right? Maybe we need to think about society differently.
We need to think differently about how society is structured. And I think to do that, I would love to hold on to the notion of sacred, even though the word sacred feels a little hokey to me when I say it. What I think we can do with society is recognize that holding something sacred could be a recognition, it could be an element of intimacy, which is to say, I honor the thing that you find sacred. I acknowledge it.
And I honor the thing that I find sacred and I acknowledge it. And I recognize that those are two different things. And this is what I'm talking about about this notion of the intimacy embedded in the structure of language. Here we are, the societies maybe all have some form of religiosity.
They also all have some form of language. And for me, the heart of it is the language. And for me, the understanding of the sacred can be understood through these kind of like everyday uses of language. And not only that, but that sacred actually is created by our everyday uses of language.
Okay, so that's just through a lot of stuff out there. So let's now think just about language and think about all of the things that you've said today and heard and everything that's come through your radio and your television and your social media and your conversations with your partners and your kids and all those things. And if you think about language in terms of the distinction between sacred and profane, what would you say is like sacred language and what would you say is profane language. Now profane language as it happens is a term.
We can think in terms of profanities, right? So there are words that we're kind of not supposed to say. So the question is, is that profane language? And if so, what counts as sacred language?
So is that like literary style? Is that, are those prayers? Are those, is that a particular register? For me, it isn't those things, but I was just trying to draw things that might kind of come to mind.
Now I'm just going to now share with you a story that I have recently published. It's a piece of flash fiction on my Grammar for Dreamers blog. You can find it at grammarfordreamers.com along with lots of other short pieces about language. And this story is called The Determiners and I will read it to you now.
The Determiners. All Gwyn had ever known was a world where your fate was determined at the age of 11. It would be more precise to say it was determined at the moment of birth. Something hung on what the mother said when her newborn took its first breath.
Once recorded, the maternal birthword was carefully consigned to the archives until the child's 11th birthday. At this point, it was passed to the panel of determiners who examined it, rectified any ambiguities, and assigned it to a word class that would establish the child's destiny. Some pregnant women could afford the costly anti-neal glasses that trained them to call out an auspicious word at just the right moment. Verbs held the most prestige, but their subcategories varied greatly even so.
Finite verbs ranked first, with the more complex, tense aspect combinations coming out of the very top, nouns came second with adverbs and adjectives sharing third place. New mothers rarely uttered pronouns, prepositions, and conjunctions, but the determiners were prepared for all eventualities. Interrogatives came low in the rankings. Explletives came last, which was unfortunate for families who could not afford pre-breath linguistic training.
Poor women were the ones most likely to utter a contented, ahh, or a blissful, oh, at the sight of their healthy baby. Wobotied the child, his enchanted mother whispered, oh wow, at her child's first breath. Gwyn was well acquainted with her own birthword, her mother's capacity to produce six different expletives for her elder siblings had been a source of much more than among the extended family, but the seventh took the prize. Still, Gwyn indulged a hope in a future full of possibilities.
Her mother's call need not, after all, be interpreted as an expletive. Jesus was also a proper noun. Prophet noun. She murmurs gently to herself as she stands before the determiners.
Messiah, Savior of Words, Savior of Worlds. Okay, so this is a story that talks about quite a lot about the sacred and the profane, and I just want to make it clear that this is a piece that I wrote when I was thinking about the tradition of word class. Like, okay, if we can class words, are there some words that are hyperclass from others, and if so, can we use those words to determine the class of the people who are using them? And so that was the kind of play, and I'll show you how that plays into the sacred profane thing in a second.
But so I also just want to point out that expletive is sometimes understood to me in profanity, but in linguistics, expletive is anything that kind of doesn't fit within the syntactic structure of what you're saying. So it's anything that can be inserted that doesn't have a specific assigned space within the syntax, that's what I could put it. Sometimes they say it's used to sort of fill things out, but another way of thinking about expletives is that they can't be identified by any other word class. But so it's not just profanity, but in Gwyn's case, when her mother shouts out the word Jesus, I remember as a kid just being confused about why that word, I was raised as a Christian, I was like, why is that word considered a swear word?
Because it's supposed to be like the person that we worship, right? So why would the name be a swear word? And this is just such a beautiful example of the business of sacred and profane. It's like, if Jesus is a sacred word to Christians and to other people of other religions who acknowledge Jesus.
And so there's a sacredness to that name, which means that it should be used reverently, it should be used in prayer, it should be used with a certain level of honor and respect and humility. When we shout it out, and so you can imagine sort of shouting out to Jesus in a moment of extreme crisis and Jesus helped me type of thing, which is still sacred. But to shout it out in the same way that you would drop an F bomb, for instance, is to profane the word. So it's to take a sacred word and to drop it in the middle of you simply not being conscious of what you're saying.
Because this is when we use profanity and we use expletives in this way, it's like we're not conscious of what we're doing, we're just shouting something out. Sometimes it's a little bit embarrassing. And so this is that moment where if you were to profane the sacred, this is why using the lords name in vain is supposed to be such a big sin. So this is the prohibition about profaning the sacred.
And so the reason that I had this happen as a kind of childbirth situation is because childbirth is not something that I've never experienced myself, but I've heard lots of stories about it. And the pain from what I understand is excruciating. How could you not, how could you possibly be expected to monitor what you say in the moment where the pain is at its most excruciating, right? So when you think in terms of being in pain, you're not really, you can't really be expected to be the most polite.
And so in this kind of dystopian world, you know, mothers giving birth were expected to kind of withhold all of the just raw pain and emotion, because it wasn't just pain either, because I was talking about mothers who wanted to say, wow, or oh, just the raw kind of primal emotion was expected to be completely hedged in and modulated and policed because the whole child's fate was going to depend on what word you uttered. And so here they are in these anti-natal classes, the anti-natal linguistic classes where they were effectively trained to say a finite verb with a complex text, tense aspect. I don't know, like exhausting or something like that. But the idea that you've got to like train your response so that you can give a response that's going to give your child the best chance in life actually struck me as pretty much what happens here, pretty much what happens in our society, which is if you are honest about your embodied emotions, if you express them freely, you are sanctioned.
And if you don't control your language regularly, and I don't just mean by not swearing, but also if you don't speak in a standard form, if you don't speak in a way that other people decide is correct, then you will be judged and your fate will hang on how people judge you in terms of your quote unquote command of the language, right? So this is one of the ways in which we can understand language is being seen as sacred, like, and I don't approve of this, but there's this idea that there is a right way to use your language and there's a wrong way to use it. And if you use it in the wrong way, it's like you're profaning the language, like if you use slang or if you use non-standard forms, or if you use a lot of hedges or fillers because you've got a lot to say and you want to make sure people are on track, then you're somehow profaning the language. And this is not the way I understand language to work now.
What I am going to do now, though, is just give you a flavor of someone who studied Durkheim, who also did some work on what are called response cries. So this shouting out of a word, perhaps when you're in pain or when you're disappointed by something, but usually this is like you're not speaking to someone else, you're just seemingly responding to a situation and shouting out a word, or even just saying a word like oops, ah, so all of these expletives that have the lowest class in the world of the determiners. And so Irving Goffman is the author of this article called Response cries, which was written in the published in 1978. And what he noticed when he was sort of hypothesizing about these words that people uttered, like when they trip on the street or whatever, he didn't talk about child birth surprisingly enough.
And in any case, he said the interesting thing about them is they're not, we think that they are like a kind of instinctive response, but they actually take shape in terms of the language. They, you will utter a word from your language. So even if it's not, you know, you'll utter an expletive. So, and this is something from living in France, but I became familiar with the notion that, you know, if you hurt yourself and you're, you speak English, you might say ouch or owl.
And that doesn't really feel like a word, but it is a word because it's only people who speak English who say that if you're French and you hurt yourself, you say, aye, okay. And so what you have to do when you're like, like me, when I was learning French, I had to remind myself to say, aye, when I hurt myself rather than owl or ouch. And after a period of time, I started to, to give myself a big pat on the back because when I was hurting myself, I was saying aye rather than owl. And so what we're doing is we're kind of, we're shaping our response cries so that they are culturally constructed so they fit within the cultural norms and the cultural norms in this case would be the language.
And so what he's doing is saying, this is not just a kind of primal response when you say something, when you say, oh darn, or owl or oops or wow, when you have these seemingly spontaneous responses to things, you're actually doing something that is a social ritual, okay? And the, what you're doing is acknowledging that whatever it is, especially there are people around, you're acknowledging that whatever, whatever just happened was unintentional, that was potentially negative, although it doesn't have to be negative, relevant to you, but you're letting other people know you're response to it if you like, because it might also, you're acknowledging that it might also be relevant to them, but you're explicitly not engaging them in the conversation. So therefore you're allowing them to keep their distance. So you've just had this embarrassing thing happen and socially it's kind of embarrassing for everybody when something embarrassing happens to one person.
So when you say oops, what that does is it creates this kind of boundary around you that says I see what I just did, I'm going to show you that what I did was embarrassing and I'm going to be giving you permission not to respond to it. Do you see what I mean? That's effectively what GoFundMe was saying we do with response cries. It's a socially situated act with a response cry.
And even when there aren't other people in the room, it's almost like we're rehearsing. It's almost like we're socially situating ourselves in case there's ever an audience. So we're practicing it because rituals require practice, they require repetition, they require rehearsal. And so the response cry is a ritual.
Now what did Durkheim say about rituals? He said rituals are ways of maintaining the distinction between the sacred and the profane. And so one of the things that GoFundMe explored in his work was that even though in sort of like the 20th century, many people don't define themselves as religious, they don't, they may be agnostic or atheist, they don't celebrate a particular religion, they don't believe in God. And so the religious society, GoFundMe said, he says, but what we worship now is the individual.
We have a kind of cult of the individual. And he says, when you watch all of the rituals that people do in their day to day interactions, all of this careful politeness, all of these careful politeness strategies that we use to maintain our sense of self in relation to other people's sense of self, these are all rituals that we engage in as if we were keeping the notion of the self as separate as a sacred notion. Right. So you say oops or ow or drop an F bomb because you've just done something embarrassing, you're ritually drawing a boundary around what you did and who you are and allowing other people to witness it without engaging in it.
And these are rituals and these are ways of keeping this kind of sacredness intact. Now what I kind of like about that is that it's a little bit more dynamic than the notion of where everybody's worshiping all of society. Now the problem with the notion of us worshiping the individual is that that can descend into ultimate narcissism, egocentrism and complete dissolution of shared values. And it can result in a lack of compassion and it can result in power plays and like I said, narcissism, just people, other selfishness.
However, I think that's the risk of that we're being asked to take if you like as our society moves more and more towards the sanctity of the individual. But I would like us to not actually think in terms of individual people. I think there's a way that we can understand society as there being a dynamism or a dynamicness around sacredness that we can all jointly recognize and honor. And I think it has to do not so much with the individual human person who lives inside or believes they live inside a flesh and bone and sort of suit.
And I think instead it has to do with the structures that are available to us from our language. Okay, what do I mean by this? Okay, well, I'm going to share with you what I think is not the most sacred aspect of our language or of a language, but an example of a type of word that creates sacredness. Okay, so it's kind of like meta-sacred.
The word itself or the words themselves aren't sacred, but they create sacred spaces. Okay, so they have a function of producing the possibility for sacredness. And those are the determiners. Okay, so I named the story, the determiners.
But in my story, the determiners was not, it was only ambiguous. But the determiners are like a sort of group of bureaucratic people who make decisions about people's lives. When in fact, the determiners are actually a word class. And this word class is part of a set of language that's known as deictic or shifters.
So they shift depending on who you referring to. So with something like a determiner, so a determiner in noun phrase is in English as something that comes first. So like the yoke tree, right? So the other is a determiner or an oak tree and is the determiner or this oak tree or that oak tree.
Or these oak trees or those oak trees or my oak tree, your oak tree. So this is all the ways of doing determination. And what, and when I say they're shifters, if you take this oak tree, it shifts depending on who says it, the reference, the possibility of what you're referring to shifts depending on who says this. So if I say this, I mean this oak tree that is near me.
So like this is proximal, it's a proximal determiner. But if you say it might be this oak tree that's near you, it doesn't have to be actual space in terms of proximity. It could be this oak tree that I've just mentioned in my conversation. So it's like, it's nearby in terms of our thoughts.
Or it might be this oak tree that is dear to me. So it might have a kind of psychological proximity. But the point is the this changes depending on who says it. Same with a determiner like my.
If I say my, I mean somehow relevant to me, possessed by me. Or if you say my, it means possessed by whoever you are. So these determiners, because they're deiptic, they're constantly shifting and changing depending on who's saying them. But the other thing that they're doing is that they are focusing your attention on the boundary that you're drawing or the way I like to say it instead is the membrane that you are describing around something that might not have existed before until you put the membrane around it.
So if I say this idea I've been playing with, right, even the idea that I was playing with an idea might be new to you. And if I say this idea that I've been playing with, I'm inviting you to stand outside of a space that I've simply surrounded with a membrane and the membrane is this. The membrane is formed by, in my opinion, it's formed by the determiner this and inviting you to look inside. Or if I say this problem I'm trying to solve, then I have created a space and I've invited you to look at it and I've invited you to look inside at a thing that didn't exist before I said those words, because you might not see whatever design describing as a problem.
But for me, it's a problem. And so I feel like these determiners, and they're not the only things in language that do this, but these determiners create a sacred space. And by sacred I simply mean they draw a membrane around a particular way of seeing things that invites you to see it the way I'm seeing it for that moment. And then we also have a determiner like that.
And so therefore I can talk about something as being distant for me, that either distant come psychologically or distant in space. And effectively with language we have all of these mechanisms for creating these sacred spaces. Now, the thing about this, that and the other determiners is that they can also function as pronouns, meaning they are replacements for noun phrases. So I could say this problem that I have been trying to solve, or I could say something like this is a problem.
And when I say this is a problem, this then it starts being a determiner and starts being a pronoun. I hope I'm not losing you with a grammar. Pronouns are also, in my view, things that create sacred space. Pronouns are shifters.
Pronouns are elements of day access. And we can take the personal pronouns. I, me, you, she, her, him, he, it, we, they, right? Our personal pronouns.
And we realize that they shift depending on who's using them, right? So these are fluid. Pronouns are fluid. There aren't that many of them, but whoever uses them changes the meaning of them is what it means.
There's only a shifter. When I use the word I, I have created a space in which I'm inviting you to see something inside. And what I'm inviting you to see is potentially everything that I am embodying, but it also might simply be my perspective or the thing I'm saying or my point of view. Every time I use the word I, I've created a membrane and inside that membrane is a self.
And I've given you the opportunity to engage with that self in however that membrane surrounds it. And the same with you. So when I say I something and then use something, I've effectively drawn two membranes. You know, so if I say I kissed you, right, then there's, we, then inviting you to see two cells, the I and the you.
But if I say we kissed, then the membrane shifts and we realize that what I'm inviting you to look at, the self within the membrane is togetherness. It's an unseparated unit. And I think the terminors do this. I think pronouns do this.
I think all of language does it to a certain extent, but pronouns and determiners are the ones that, that, that mega do it. You know? What we can see here when we start thinking about these elements of language that create these cells and that create these spaces, I think we can potentially get to the point where we start to recognize that the space is created by language could be seen as sacred. But the important thing about them is they are always, always shifting.
So in the moment, there's a sacredness. And then in the next utterance, there's a different sacredness. So the ritual is not about maintaining a sort of pardon the pun God given sacredness. One thing has to be sacred for all time.
It's about engaging in the practice of recognizing the sacred and how the sacred changes and how the selves shift. And the point there is that if we can see that it's the space itself that is sacred or that we're practicing, making sacred, in my mind, that's where new ideas emerge. It's within those spaces. It's within the nothingness.
Right? So if I say this problem that I've been thinking about and you're saying, I don't even know what problem that is, well, then you're, then you're engaging in that sacred act of recognizing that even though you don't know what it is, you're prepared to see it with that membrane around it. And this is, this is a new way of thinking about social structure. As ever shifting membranes and ever shifting sacredness with the space inside those membranes being the space where new ideas emerge.
So to go back to the original question is nothing sacred. For me, the answer is beautifully yes, nothingness is what is sacred, the constant shifting. So when you create the membrane inside that membrane is nothing. And it's the nothing that is indeed sacred.
And I think it's our language that lets us do this. Okay, I'll stop there. I really appreciate you listening today. I, and thank you so much for engaging in this sacred ritual of hopefully creating some new ideas or watching new ideas emerge.
If you'd like to connect with me further, you can go onto my grammar for Dreamers blog. That's at grammarfordreamers.com. That's where you can read the determiners and all the other linguistics inspired fiction that I've posted up there. If you go to grammarfordreamers.com slash connect, you can sign up to some of the other stuff I've got there for you.
There's a free course called writing through the lens of language and you can join the newsletter and you can read the screenplay. I wrote all those different things. And if you'd like to connect with me on social media, I'm on Instagram at grammarfordreamers. I'm on Facebook at grammarfordreamers and on Twitter, I'm at Jodie Clark-Ling-L-I-N-G.
And if you listen to the podcast and you enjoy it, they can not go once a month. And if you subscribe, you will automatically be notified when it new ends out. And if you rate and review it on your podcasting platform, then I will be very, very grateful. Thank you so much and I'll talk to you again soon.