Skip to content
Episode 85: Pipeline Permitting with Tom Magness episode artwork

Jul 23, 2019 30 min

Episode 85: Pipeline Permitting with Tom Magness

from Pipeliners Podcast Hosted by Pipeliners Podcast

This week's Pipeliners Podcast episode features Russel Treat and retired Colonel Tom Magness, founder of Eagle's Leadership, discussing pipeline permitting from a Corp of Engineers' perspective. Listen for how the government decides what projects and permits are in the best interest of the nation and how to balance both environmental protection and sustainable development. Tom also explains the jurisdiction Army Corps of Engineers has and why and how he has arbitrated conversations between stakeholders that were in deeply divisive positions around a particular project or permit. As a pipeline professional, gaining insight into how the government works and operates can help you when going through the development process of permits and projects. Download this episode now to help further your industry knowledge.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 85: Pipeline Permitting with Tom Magness

0:00 30:40
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the Pipe Liners podcast, Episode 85, sponsored by Gas Certification Institute, providing training and standard operating procedures for custody transfer measurement professionals. Find out more about GCI at gas certification.com. The Pipe Liners podcast where professionals, bubblegeeks and industry insiders share their knowledge and experience about technology, projects, and pipeline operations. And now your host, Russell Treet.

Thanks for listening to the Pipe Liners podcast. We appreciate you taking the time and to show that appreciation, we're giving away a customized Yeti Tumblr to one listener each episode. This week, our winner is Kayla Lepica with EOG. Congratulations, Kayla.

Your Yeti is on its way to find out how you can win this prize back. Stick around to the end of the episode. This week, we have Colonel Tom Magnus, US Army Corps of Engineers, retired, coming on the podcast to talk to us about pipeline permitting from a core of engineers perspective. Tom, welcome to the Pipe Liners podcast.

Thank you, sir. Good to be here. So glad to have you. I've been looking for somebody that could talk to us about pipeline permitting.

And I think we have found the guy. So if you would, Tom, tell the listeners a little bit about your background and how you got into and have experience with permitting. Yes, sir. Well, I am a 26 year Army veteran retired in 2011 as a colonel.

West Point graduate. I went from West Point into the engineers. And the engineers had among my 26 years of service had the opportunity to serve in the Army Corps of Engineers, three different assignments with the Army Corps of Engineers, two years in Detroit, three years in Los Angeles and a year in Afghanistan. But those five years state side with the Army Corps of Engineers, among the missions they did was the opportunity to permit some very important infrastructure projects in some important areas of our nation.

So why is the, why would the Army Corps of Engineers be involved in and permitting? I think it's a question many might ask because it doesn't seem like a logical fit. What's the muddy boots Army doing in a business like permitting development and infrastructure projects? But it is something legislatively, the Clean Water Act, has made it a requirement that this mission be accomplished.

The EPA typically does environmental projects. But in this case, the EPA has agreed that the Army Corps of Engineers is best positioned to be an arbiter of what are often some very difficult issues. And when you think about it, who bettered perhaps then the Army to look at the nation's interests. And that's really what we do in our permitting purview is to try to look at what is in the best interest of the public and in our nation as we permit projects that balance both environmental protection and sustainable development.

Yeah. And I think you just said a mouthful there, Tom. You know, there's a lot there to balance. So you said nation's best interest.

So how does that actually play out in practice? So what is maybe the way, maybe a better way to ask that question is maybe you could give us kind of an overview of what is the permitting process and how does it work? Right. Well, you know, first with regard to the nation's best interest, when you, you know, when you put an Army officer in this decision-making role, it is not going to be something that could be swayed by a political interest or by the interest of one stakeholder group or a community or a state.

It is what is in the nation's best interest. And I think, you know, having an Army officer make that kind of decision is appropriate. When an applicant comes forward with a project, I think the first thing we do in the Army Corps of Engineers is determine whether or not we have jurisdiction. In other words, is this project something that falls under the permitting authority of the Army Corps or does it not?

If it has any impacts on water, usually it is going to be an Army Corps of Engineers overview. But if not, then, you know, our first determination would be this does not require a permit from the Army Corps of Engineers. It may require it from someone else, but not from us. So step one is to do that jurisdictional determination.

And then step two would be to determine what is the appropriate way to move forward with that project. These regulators and the Army Corps of Engineers are truly professional. And they, you know, they've been doing this their whole lifetime. And they really, you know, embrace this balance.

They know they have a stewardship responsibility with regard to the nation's aquatic resources, but they also know that we have to allow reasonable development. And they're the ones that are, you know, going to make that fair and balanced decision and find a way to permit activities to happen. And so when you look at what are their options, they have several. I mean, if it is, you know, a unique sort of project, it may have to go through a very detailed analysis to get that permit completed.

And there is a, you know, a methodology to go through, but that very detailed analysis looks at all the environmental impacts and could take, you know, years and years, but there's, you know, other ways to permit activities. We have some national permits already in place that if a developer or an outfit can fit their project underneath those guidelines, they can get to yes, very easily. So when you're working with a regulator, that regulator is going to do all they can to help you find a way to get this project through. So you mentioned jurisdiction.

So maybe you could elaborate on that a little bit. Where does the Army Corps of Engineers jurisdiction kind of begin and end? Well, that is actually a question that has gone several times to all the way to the Supreme Court. And, you know, when I was in Los Angeles, I found myself standing in the middle of a, you know, a dry riverbed where water had not been for months, maybe even years and trying to understand how that really falls under the purview of the Army Corps of Engineers.

Traditionally, our responsibilities are with regard to navigable body weights. And when you look at a dry riverbed, that certainly doesn't look navigable. But waters of the United States has, you know, a pretty broad definition. Then that has gone all the way to the Supreme Court recently to, you know, to make that determination.

If it has some connection to a navigable body of water, it is likely to fall under the, the jurisdiction of the Army Corps, some connection to a navigable body of water. Interesting. It's, you know, I'm just listening to this and I'm thinking, why wouldn't the Navy be taking care of the Coast Guard taking? What else?

Don't get me started on that. You know, there, there, this is something when I was a young officer in the, in the lieutenant colonel, I think Rumsfeld was the secretary of defense. And there was a lot of discussion at the Pentagon about what the heck the, the army or the military at all was doing in this business. And, you know, I mean, the secretary of defense does not like to receive the kinds of phone calls that he inevitably is getting about permit issues.

But here he is, you know, I'm sure getting all these kinds of questions and, you know, poking about permits. And, you know, that's the last thing you'd think the army would be. But again, as a nation, I think we have to take a step back and ask ourselves, who better than our military? And I think, you know, the Navy's about the water.

This is beyond the water. This, you know, this extends to wetlands and areas around those navigable bodyways. And so I think it's appropriate for the army to be in this business. Yeah.

Well, I think, you know, being a being former military, being an engineer in the Air Force, I'm quite familiar with the Corps of Engineers. I think what maybe a lot of listeners might not know is that for the US military, much of the heavy infrastructure capability that exists is in the army. And there's only limited capability in the other branches of the services, all that kind of heavy infrastructure development maintenance and all that kind of stuff exists in the Corps of Engineers. You know, if the Army's got to go someplace and set up a camp, then it's the Corps of Engineers, it's to an heavy engineering to do that.

Right. The Navy has their own engineers, but the Army Corps does the, you know, the bulk of the engineering work where the Army and the Air Force. Yeah. Well, and even even in the situation with the Navy, there's there's been cases where, you know, the Navy has substantially more capability than the Air Force.

But anyway, I'm getting way off in the weeds here. Let me read it back in. I just find this conversation kind of fascinating. So one of the reasons I asked you on is I know you have some personal experience with some rather challenging permitting situations and particularly around pipelining.

So maybe you could talk a little bit about some things that you were involved with and maybe just from a standpoint of letting the listeners know, you know, what that looked like, what you learned, you know, what what should a pipeline or maybe know about the process? Well, you know, some people in my, in that position of being the district engineer or the district commander, and that's a, that's a role for a colonel, you know, to take a step back, an Army Corps of Engineers district is the basic unit across the United States. There's some 40 plus districts, geographical districts around the United States. And those are led by either Lieutenant Colonel's or Colonel's in the Army, the larger districts and more complicated districts are generally led by Colonel's.

They're, you know, they follow watershed boundaries for the most part is how those district boundaries were created based on the various watersheds in our nation. And as a lieutenant colonel, my initial introduction to the Corps of Engineers was in Detroit, Michigan. And man, what a difficult issue anything having to do with water in that part of our nation. And they love their lakes.

Don't you dare touch them. And I found myself, you know, I had come from the muddy boots army, a combat engineer, and this was my first taste of this kind of stuff. I had never served in the Army Corps of Engineers before this assignment to get that introduction into some of the complicated, complicated regulatory issues. You know, we had to deal with one, for example, it was not a pipeline project, per se, but when the lake levels went down on the Great Lakes of our nation, levels are up, levels are down, they're probably up now.

But at the time I was there, the levels were down. And when the water level went down, it exposed what used to be people's backyards as they backed up to the lake. And as those water levels went down, these wetlands that were once underwater, now were above ground to any of us. When we see a wet land, we might say those are weeds.

And the average good old American sees weeds and wants to do what? Get rid of them. These are wetlands. And so, you know, here's, you know, a young lieutenant colonel, myself being thrown into this position when an American who has purchased this lot and whose deed says that, you know, they own all this property all the way to the water's edge.

And then here comes the United States government saying, you can't, you know, remove those weeds. That's a wet land. And to do so, you're going to have to go through a permitting process. Oh my gosh, it was, you know, I mean, you can imagine the passions that are there.

And, you know, all the issues that you might think about taking people's property, which is nothing we were doing. We weren't taking anything. We were permitting activity, but to do it in a logical way that preserve the wetlands of our United States, just, you know, incredibly, incredibly emotional sort of issues, I would go to permit, you know, public hearings and have my driver park backwards in the spot. So if I had to come running, he'd have the engine going and we could get out of there fast because there were definitely some, some emotions there.

In California, certainly we had any number of pipeline issues. You all you have to do is drive the coast of California and you see the various, you know, off shore rigs and those are all permitted activities. The rigs themselves are permitted. The pipelines to transport the products to the shore and then from the shore to wherever they might go.

All of those are Army Corps permitted projects. So what, what was, what would you say in, you know, getting that experience? And I can, you know, you use the crusty or the muddy boot combat veteran coming into the, one of these, you know, charged situations. Well, what would you say you learned from that?

What, what did you learn about actually working with people and getting to conclusion on some of these issues? Well, nothing's easy. And, you know, you're trying to find balance. And when you're trying to find balance between issues that sometimes have the appearance of being, you know, in complete opposite of one another, that can be a real challenge.

What, what is important is, you know, we've got to find common ground, you know, for better or for worse, I always like to start my public hearings and, you know, many permits as part of the process, there's a public hearing component to it. And usually the district commander, the colonel is required to oversee that public hearing. And so, you know, you get people and they're going to say whatever they want to say. And as a professional, I've got to listen to them, but I would always try to start those public hearings with the Pledge of Allegiance.

And let's get on the same page here. We're all trying to do the right thing for our nation. And, you know, now let's move forward. But these were, these were some difficult issues.

And the first thing that I would tell you is we should all feel very good about the professionals that we have doing this business, you know, they've committed their life in the Army Corps of Engineers. These are civilian, you know, regulators that have, you know, put themselves oftentimes in harm's way to be the face, the public face of the Army Corps of Engineers is our regulatory program. And these folks are true professionals and they, they understand, you know, the need for balance. They're going to make decisions based on science and based on the facts and their judgment, I think is solid and they do the best they can.

You know, they're the ones that present the decision to the colonel. And then the colonel is the one that says yes or no. And we should feel real good about the people that we have doing that job. Yeah, that's certainly consistently been my been my experiences that, you know, the people who are who are called into that as a career path where they kind of stand in that in that scene between the various stakeholders in a decision, they have to be there.

They have some purpose behind what they do. Like it's too hard a job not to. It is. And, you know, I loved going to battle with those people.

I mean, it was one of the great joys of my time in that role was to be able to, you know, stand side by side with those folks and make some important decisions. One of the guys that I worked with early on put it this way. I had come to him talking about permits, you know, with the emphasis on the first part of that word permit. And he said, I want you to think of it this way.

Permit our job is to permit to allow for reasonable development. And we need to work with these folks and find a way and do that in a way that, you know, preserves the public interest. Now, you know, I think when you understand the meaning of that word, and we're not there to say no, and these regulatory folks, they get it. You know, they want to be good government to a man and woman.

And they want to say, yes, if they can find a way to have it make sense and and to find that balance. I think the other thing I'd like you to talk a little bit, Tom, is is how you, how you arbitrated the conversations between stakeholders that were in, you know, maybe maybe deeply divisive positions around a particular project or permit. How did you arbitrate those kinds of conversations? Yeah.

I mean, sometimes you have to see beyond the emotion and, you know, the emotion of some is not no, but heck no, that there's no possible way that we would ever allow, you know, let's take a pipeline project. There are some who are opposed to the project just because of what it is and the fact that it's moving carbon products and that there is no alignment. There is no location. There is no construction technique that would ever satisfy them if that is their position.

No, you know, I found it important to let's put this on the table. We've got to find a way. Can we all agree that there is a way we may not know what it is right now, but that there is a way that we could get to yes, that would balance our requirements for environmental stewardship and sustainable development. Can we all agree we're going to find that way?

We got to get all the parties to agree to that. Otherwise, you're never going to move forward. There are some who start and end with it's a no and that is not helpful. Yeah, I think that's right.

You know, the interesting thing is I, when I went to the API pipeline conference earlier this year, I went to one of the presentations was a panel of pipeline operators, consultants and leaders of First Nations. It was really interesting. I mean, I think the primary thing I took away from that is when you find these emotional adversaries, okay, they're standing against doing projects, that it's very important to listen and try to understand what's behind the emotion. That's right.

You know, what's the reason? What's the intellectual, you know, understanding that is driving the emotion because it's in that that you find the opportunity to, you know, find the way to work together to do what's in, you know, everyone's best interest. Yeah. And for me, that meant we need to have a relationship.

You know, I remember my two years in Detroit that, you know, I spent a lot of time working with people on the other side of some of these issues, you know, just to build a relationship. You know, what I what I don't want to happen is, you know, we get to the end of, you know, a process and then somebody jumps in with an objection that is going to cause us to go back to the beginning again. We got to get all these people at the table from the beginning. We've got to establish some trust.

There has to be a relationship. I want people to pick up the phone and call me if there is an issue. And I worked hard to build, you know, one-on-one relationships with the leaders of all those agencies so that we could, you know, have enough trust to move the process forward. We got to trust the process.

Sure. Sure. So what are you, what are you up to now that you're out of the army? So what are you, what are you up to these days?

Well, I do a number of things. One is, you know, I am a consultant. I do work with a firm. We do public relations stuff with regard to the pipeline industry.

I want to be, you know, an advocate for the Army Corps of Engineers and the process. I want to help educate people on the way the process goes. We want everyone to have confidence that, you know, the final decision is going to be one we can all accept because we trust the people who made that decision. And so as part of my consultant, Roloid, I help educate people on the process.

I also do leader development programs. My company is Eagle Leadership and we do leadership development programs for public and private sector organizations around the world. And essentially I've taken what I learned in my 26 years in the military, four more years of West Point, tried to take those lessons and make them, you know, something that a person in any position could, you know, use to their advantage as a leader. So how did, how did being a district engineer with the Corps equip you for doing this type of stuff?

Well, it's a unique part of our Army. The Corps of Engineers is all civilian. And you know, each district is its own business unit. You know, you kind of have to, you know, within legal parameters, you have to develop a budget and, you know, develop your own projects.

You've got to work with stakeholders. You've got to do all the kinds of things that I found once I left the Army was what everyone else was already doing. And, you know, that you don't have the ability to bark out commands and people jump down for pushups just because you say so. And I learned, you know, through two years in Detroit, three years in Los Angeles that there is a way that we can use what I've learned in the military, but to make it work for people that aren't necessarily in uniform.

And that is serving pretty well. Well, that's fascinating. You know, as a former district engineer, if you were going to impart some wisdom to the people working in the pipeline business, what advice would you pass on to them? Well, if it's a new project, you want to get on the phone right away and find your local Corps of Engineers regulator and explain your project.

And that regulator is going to help find a way through the process. It's not something you want to try to navigate on your own. And it's not something you want to, you know, do have an ad, you know, be on the opposite side of the table. You want to have a colleague that will work with you.

And that should be your first phone call. Two, you should trust those people. They're going to help get to yes. And you got to believe that they're going to do it in a way that is truly in the nation's best interest.

They're great, great Americans and we should be proud of them. And three, I think this administration has worked hard to simplify things like permitting. And we don't need the kind of government that frustrates every single American. You know, when you can't navigate through the hurdles, you don't understand what they're doing.

It makes no sense. It makes your head want to explode. We don't need that kind of government. We need, you know, the kind of government that's going to help people.

And I think this administration has made that a priority. And I think that the Army Corps of Engineers has embraced that and has found ways to simplify the process. And I think that when it comes time to getting these important infrastructure projects done, they are getting them done. And they're working through the process, but we've got a process that can find that balance and do it in a pretty quick way.

Yeah, I think, you know, one of my takeaways from this and several other conversations I've had recently is that it's really interesting just, there are some very good people that work in this business, both, you know, with the operators and in government and in the other stakeholder communities. And they, I think that that's one thing that we may all differ greatly about what it looks like, but we all share in that we want to see this nation grow, be healthy, and we all want to do what's in the best interest. So it's just a matter of, you know, if you can get there with that everyone is coming from that place, then it opens up some possibility. No doubt.

I mean, nobody loves the environment. Nobody loves our nation's aquatic resources more than the people that you'll find in the Army Corps of Engineers. Yeah, there's a reason they're there, right? That's right.

I mean, they have signed up for this role because they want to preserve and protect and to do all things right by our environment. And yet they all know that we've got to, you know, allow for reasonable development and they are doing all they can to find that balance. Well, Tom, thanks so much for coming on the podcast. I sure appreciate your time.

And thank you for your service. Yes, sir. Thank you very much. Really enjoyed it.

I hope you enjoyed this week's episode of the Pipelineers podcast and our conversation with Tom Magnus. Just a reminder before you go, you should register to win our customized Pipelineers podcast, Yeti Thumbler. Simply visit pipelineerspodcast.com slash win to enter yourself in the drawing. If you would like to support this podcast, best thing you can do is to leave us a review.

You can do that on iTunes or on whatever smart device podcast app you happen to use. You can find instructions at pipelineerspodcast.com. If you have ideas, questions, or topics you'd be interested in, let us know on the contact us page at pipelineerspodcast.com or reach out to me directly on LinkedIn. Thanks for listening.

I'll talk to you next week.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Pipeliners Podcast?

This episode is 30 minutes long.

When was this Pipeliners Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on July 23, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Pipeliners Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.