Hello again, everybody, and welcome into another edition of Political Beasts, a presentation of National Review. Fly this on Twitter at political underscore beats. Also on Facebook, look for political beats there. Subscribe to our feed for new episodes through Google podcasts, Apple podcasts, Stitcher, TuneIn.
I believe we're on Amazon podcasts now as well, and you can go to nationalreview.com, click on podcasts in the quarter. Find all the fine in our podcast there, including back episodes of this one right here. Political reviews, political beats, not reviews. Listen, and leave reviews, we ask you to help others find the show.
My name's Scott Bertram, fine to be on Twitter at Scott Bertram, my tag team partner standing by, waiting for this day, his whole life. Jeff, how are you? It's been so lonely, Scott. I've been waiting here for so long, and all this time that's passed me by, well, you know, it hardly seems to matter now.
We are about to get to it. At Esoteric CD on Twitter is where you find Jeff. Our guest for today's program is Patrick Fry. Blogger since 2003, he says he's still committed to the forum, even though it has been dead for years.
Find him on Twitter to at Patarico. It's Patrick Fry. Patrick, thanks for joining us. It's a real pleasure to be here.
This is an honor. We bring you on before we get to our band introduction. We'd like to let you say a little bit about yourself. Patrick Fry, tell us about you and Patarico on Twitter and what you're involved with.
Sure. Well, as you said, I've had a blog. Old-timers might know what those are, that of Ephesians 2003. And it used to be early on, a critic of the LA Times, and got a little bit of minor internet fame doing that.
Broke some stories over the years. I was, I think, the first person to break the story about Anthony Wiener talking to underage girls. That's one of the big ones. And then something that a few people know me for is, I met Andrew Breitbart and he and I or his site and I both wrote about a convicted domestic terrorist who had set out some bombs in Indiana in the 70s and then had become a lefty political activist.
And so that got attention because after a few of us criticized this guy, we ended up getting swatted. Yeah, he law-feared you guys too. Oh, yeah, sootas and everything. So and people know what swadding is, that's where somebody calls the police and reports of shooting at your home.
So I answered the door at about 12, 3 in the morning, staring at a bunch of cops pointing guns at me. But so that got some attention and then I wrote for Red State for a couple of years, maybe 2016 or so, but was fired as part of their effort to clean house to get rid of all the truck critics. So I'm just kind of wiling away my days and obscurity at this point. But please to be with you guys.
It gives you time to join podcasts like this. Exactly. That's the important part. We welcome Patrick on today for the first part, part one of our two-part series, usually reserved for summers, but doing it's a special Halloween double-pedition, I suppose.
Hey, you know what, COVID screwed everything up. It's all haywire these days. It's just like our American politics for that matter. It is a two-parter on Genesis, as you well know if you've clicked on this program.
And as you well know if you've listened to this program previously, Jeff's favorite band. He is ready and waiting to go. First, though, we turn things over to Patrick once again to tell us why he loves Genesis, especially this era of Genesis. Today we take the Peter Gabriel era of Genesis.
How you got to know them and why people should care about this music from Genesis, Patrick? Yeah. So I probably owe my love for Genesis in particular, the Peter Gabriel era to my lifelong friend, Tony Slagel. He is the person who first showed me when I was a teenager and he popped into a VCR, look it up, a VCR tape of Peter Gabriel in the band doing the musical box.
You can find this video on YouTube. We'll talk about it later. But it's the version where he wears the old man head at the end. And I found that incredibly compelling.
And until probably age 15, I really, I was actually a classical music fan. I really didn't listen to rock music until I was age 15 or so. But kind of my path towards meeting Tony was, in part, it started with this thing called the RCA music club. You guys have never heard of this, right?
This is too old for you. Why is it in the Columbia house? It's not the same idea, right? You buy six CDs for like a penny and then they have to buy six more and they cost $18.99 and that's how they get you.
Exactly. And then at least they would also, they would make you opt out. So you would get something if you didn't opt out. And I think one of the things that I failed to opt out of was a rush album.
And then I thought, well, I'll go ahead and listen to it. And I loved it. And I became a rush fan. And then that album was called Roll the Bones.
It was not. I was trying to think of the worst rush album. Otherwise we wouldn't be here. Yeah, no, I got lucky.
I think it was like 2112 that I heard first. So actually became a rush fan, met Tony and going to my first rush concert. And he and I were sort of a lot like the guys from I Love You Man, the big rush fans and music nerds. So he was definitely the one who got me into that.
But I want to say even though I'm here for the Peter Gabriel version, I like the Phil Collins Genesis. And in fact, that's some of the first rock music that I ever listened to. I got a handheld radio for Christmas in 1983. And among the songs that were popular at that time, including Synchronicity 2 from the police in modern led by David Bowie was a tune called Home by the Sea by Genesis, which I really liked.
But I didn't become fanatical about that until I discovered Peter Gabriel, Eric Genesis. And I think it just sort of appeals to the classical music fan within me because there's so much complexity to the music that you can always come back with in time something new. You know what, Scott, I could tell stories. I could tell stories all day long.
I could tell stories like Peter Gabriel trying to cover up for an electrical malfunction on stage during an early Genesis show. So maybe you go first and then I'll tell him my story. That's a good idea. Because I have a feeling and it's just a hunch that I will be the host on this particular episode you hear the least from.
I know that Patrick is a huge Genesis fan and this is Jeff's baby. And I actually know the Collins era pretty darn well. One of the first Twitter interactions that I think Jeff and I had was me making the, this is sort of throwing it out there that you could make the case that Genesis was the greatest mainstream rock band of the 80s after going back through some of the early 80s Genesis albums. And so that era I know if you remember agreeing with you and then saying, well who's that guy and then a year later we ended up hosting a show?
And you found out. But this Peter Gabriel era, this is this is really new to me. A vast, vast portion. The only song that I can guarantee that I knew from this era before stepping in and beginning to eat through these albums was the title track from the Lamb Lies Down on Broadway, which was played a little bit on the classic rock stations in Chicago.
You never heard I know what I like? I had never heard I know what I like. The other reason the Lamb lied down on Broadway is because on one of the Chicago sports radio stations they had done a parody song to that for the Bears called the Bears Lie Down on Sunday. So that's the song I knew from this era.
So stepping into it essentially fresh. So I've not clearly internalized a lot of this music the way the book Patrick and Jeff have but at least can give the perspective of a Genesis fan. I mean truly a fan of that Collins era sort of stepping back through these earlier albums and clearly it's excellent music. And I had emailed earlier this morning and saying, I'm not sure what my two albums are going to be in the five songs.
This is really through the entire era really consistent music too. Each album has clear highlights songs that really stick with you. Patrick's point it is complex. There's a bit of classical influence in some of these songs and some of these albums clearly.
And I think that someone walking in essentially new to this era, this Gabriel era of Genesis is going to come away with a lot of songs that they like and a new appreciation for how this band was constructed. You know, Collins had solo success and Gabriel had solo success and Mike Rutherford had solo success with Mike and the mechanics. And Steve, I can really great solo success too. I'll put it out.
People had solo and Tony Banks made solo albums too, not quite as successful, but they're all super talented. They all bring a different edge and a different perspective to the way the music was written and performed. And so I'm looking forward to hearing Jeff and Patrick talk about Genesis in school a bit, but also tipping in with some of my observations and likes. And yes, even a few dislikes here and there too.
I'll be blunt. I'm going to put the slug line right up front. They're my favorite band of all time. And if you follow me on Twitter for long enough, especially if you can pay attention to what I've been tweeting over the past like four weeks, the minute we booked this show, I just went on a binge.
I'm just like, here's a really great version of throwing it all away. Hey, you want to hear Peter Gabriel kick in the crap on the Supper's Ready in 1973? Here's your take. I've just been posting rarities left and right, reliving my childhood.
And of course, that's, I guess, one of those things that can never be omitted when you think about the bands I mean the most to you. This is me truly relieving my childhood. They're objectively, I've had this list and if you've listened to the show long enough, you know I've talked about it, objectively the five most important and greatest artists ever. Like the Beatles, The Who, The Stones, Dylan, The Birds, Velvet Underground, that kind of stuff.
But my favorite artists? Well, you already listened to our Radiohead episode, I hope so. You know that they're basically, you're nearly tied. But and this has been the case since I was, you know, I would say it was since I was 18 years old.
But the truth is it's actually because it's actually from when I was seven years old. Genesis has been my favorite band of all time. And maybe that's a story that I'll tell on our second half of the episode when we come back because like both of you guys and it's inevitable. I mean, it's just about when we were born, I started with the Phil Collins era, Genesis.
The first CD I ever bought in my life from a guy who would end up becoming one of these insane music fans was Abacap. And then I sort of left them when I started like getting into like classic rock. I was like, oh, they're so in cool. Phil Collins is so gosh.
You know, I it's almost like, you know, this is long before, you know, American Psycho had been made. But like I still like felt that vibe like, oh, Phil Collins, you can't like that stuff. It was only at the end of my senior year when I never let go, never really let go of those deeply embedded memories that I had of Abacap of the self title album of Invisible Touch. We can't dance.
I got all of them when they came out. But then I was just like at the beach week, my senior year and I decided to go into a store. It was like one of these like consignment stores where it's like, you know, remainder band albums. And because the new remaster series had come out recently, that just saw a double album version of the the Lamb lies down on Broadway by Genesis.
And I know, because I also liked Peter Gabriel's solo music, but and this is the thing. This is the thing because for if you were kid, I was born in 1980. If you were kid born in 1980, it was like almost inconceivable. I think about the idea that that guy was in that group and they were making that kind of music.
And I knew that it was true on an intellectual level because you know, I can read, but it didn't make any sense like, you know, on an emotional level, on a gut level. So I said screw it. And I went and bought the Lamb lies down in Broadway and I drove myself home from Ocean City, Maryland to Potomac listening to that album all, you know, one hour and 40 minutes of it. And I'm not gonna lie, I was thrown for a loop.
That is one mess up F of weird ass album. It started with the title track, which is Scott Manchin is great. And then everything else about it challenged me. And then suddenly it would hit a wonderful pop moment where Peter Gabriel is talking about trying to lose his virginity.
And then it would go into like weird like songs about having sex with snake women and eating their dead bodies. And then it would go back into like, you know, things about having your penis cut off. This is the Lamb lies down. It threw me and it compelled me all at the same time.
And then I had to get into the rest of them. And so I've already rambled on too long. This is what I meant when I said this is my baby. This is my band.
I went and bought all of their stuff and at this point collected like literally not only all of their official stuff, but I mean, I've been, hasn't been released. That's when I'm releasing all their bootlegs online. I want to explain to you why Genesis is my favorite band of all time. All right, you know, for a long time I told myself that I didn't like prog rock.
It was kind of like I felt like, you know, it's the obvious and lame, but unavoidable comparison. I was closeted, right? I was a guy who said that I don't like King Crimson and yes, EOP. But then I just realized, you know, I'm listening to all this stuff.
Well, I guess I really do love prog rock. I seem to be able to name every song on every album of every one of these people's discography. But Genesis, I love more than anyone else because their mood compelled me in this Gabriel era. And even afterwards, but particularly in the Pete years, they were more pastoral, dreamy and English than any of the other prog rockers out there.
That works in their advantage because instead of like that faceless, airy fairy mysticism, like yes, like, you know, as soon as in which we'll call you from the depths of your disgrace, what the hell does that mean? We're arranging your liver to the psalm and grace. No, or, you know, like a weird, like anonymous devilish foreboding on King Crimson. Genesis are evocative in a kinkish sort of way of like that idealized England that maybe never was even and modern England or the days of your but the atmosphere is so effortless.
And the other big thing, and this is so important for Genesis was their instrumental prowess. And I mean that in a way that cuts both ways. They were not the best technically skilled prog rockers of all these people, you know, all these big major groups. And in fact, they were considered to be the run to the litter back at the time.
The funny thing is that the two guys who really worked top of the chops were Steve Hackett on guitar. He only joined a little bit later. And the other guy who joined at the same time is none other than a man named Phil Collins, who people think of now as the guy who does Tarzan Soundtracks and sings about another day in paradise. But this guy could drum your face off best, my favorite drummer of all time, in fact.
But the rest of them, they couldn't play nearly as well, maybe as maybe some of their contemporaries. Gabriel himself was just sort of like an impassable floutist. That's what he played on stage. But that was to their benefit because it never let them lose their souls.
They couldn't, they could play well enough to be convincingly progressive, but not well enough. And I believe this is really important to lose their pop souls. They were never technically amazing outside of Hackett in Commons. So that means that they were never really in danger of taking off into that super complex soulless programmatic style that ELP and yes lost themselves.
And they were a prog band that never ceased being a pop group either. I think it's the last reason is that they had a sense of humor. And this is the one thing that I think changes forever at the end of this era that we'll talk about that ends with Peter Gabriel leaves. Peter Gabriel is his solo career.
I mean, someday I pray we will do a Peter Gabriel episode of political beats because I think his solo career is just about as amazing as what he has done with Genesis. The only thing that Genesis really lost though when Pete left was that sense of humor, that wit, that sprightliness, that lyrical touch that only Pete was capable of bringing to them. He got more sober and mature and sort of almost like you can compare on a chart like as his voice got horseer, his lyrical conceit got more mature. But here he was playful, weird, strange, maybe still a bit of the old British school boy within him.
But this music makes me laugh and it moves me and the music moves me. I have basically now spent 10 minutes boring you. This is my favorite band of all time except we have to talk about that first album which kind of sucks. I also want to mention of course that they have lost the lyrical touch of Peter Gabriel that they gained an invisible touch.
Thank you. But I'm but I'm bing. All right, last thing and I'm talking so much. But I always have to be the whole stage setting.
Who are the people in this band? Who are these people? You know them. You've basically been encountering them in your pop lives whether you knew it or not or whether you liked it or not for the past 30 years.
Tony Banks is the one guy who never had a big solo career but is kind of in a lot of ways the backbone of Genesis, their keyboardist. Michael Rutherford, their bassist and acoustic guitarist Peter Gabriel, believe it or not. What was his instrument in Genesis? It was flute.
He's more kind of a keyboardist and it's hard but of course Tony wouldn't let him touch the keyboard. So you've got that and who are these guys? Well they and another friend of theirs named Anthony Phillips who was the original guitarist for Genesis. Ant Phillips, all went to like a British private school.
It's basically like Saint Albans in Washington DC. Patrick, I don't know what the equivalent in Los Angeles is, like a really Tony prep school. But they went to this place called Charter House in sort of the London suburbs which is like where all the best middle class people send their children. And then they were middle class kids just trying to play at art and make music.
What they did is kept the attention of a guy who had been a couple years older than him, Jonathan King who had like a hit single in the British charts saying like, hey, here's our demos. We're making this music. Hey, do you like us? Because you know they had that school connection.
King noticed them and he got them a record contract which is how they ended up releasing their first couple singles and their first album from Genesis to Revelation. And the thing about this is mine, if you're a super fan the way I am, I can find some things. In fact, this is how pathetically super fan I am. I can find a lot of things to praise about it but I can never in good conscience recommend it to anyone else.
You guys please go first and then I will actually try to highlight what works here and what fails. Well, I want to follow up on something that you were saying earlier about. Yeah, go for it. Sort of their lack of super duper instrumental chops.
And what I think is really at the heart of what kept them interesting all along is that they really were at heart songwriters more than performers. Right? That's what they always say too. They're like this original album they wanted to write it for other people but nobody wanted to perform this silly music.
Exactly. And with themselves. Ocean of motion. And so they start out with this first album sort of trying to write the kind of thing that is popular at the time, sort of BG's style stuff.
But you can kind of tell their heart isn't really in it and it's when they get to trespass and they start to really branch out that they get to the stuff that nobody else was going to play. But yeah, on this, I think of this first album, it kind of reminds me a little bit of the transitions that you had with, like I don't know if you've ever heard the really early David Bowie stuff. Oh, you mean the really embarrassing Anthony newly inspired 1967 David. Yeah, I'll tell you that.
Like please Mr. Grave Ditter. What made him a soul child? Yeah, it's a bombadoe.
Yeah, it's a awful stuff. Yeah, exactly. And so for people who are big fans of David Bowie, it's interesting to listen to that stuff. For people who are big fans of yes, it's interesting to listen to their really early stuff where they're covering the Beatles and the birds and Simon and Garfunkel and stuff.
It seems like when the 70s come along, like all these acts sort of get their act together. But what we're talking about now for Genesis is sort of their sort of pre-70s, you know, sort of junior period when they really, you can only hear just the little kernels of what's to come. It needs to be emphasized that this is an album they literally made when they were still in high school. Yeah, like 15 to 17 years old, I think, right?
Yeah, something like 17, I think it was more like 17, 18, right? They've been doing demos for the past two years. Right, right, right. So that fourth disc of the Genesis box, the archives box, you can hear like the, there's no electric guitar, yeah, they own an electric guitar, much less know how to play one.
But the songwriting is still there. Like they can write a good chord sequence. The first everything they recorded is song called Patricia, which became in hiding from Genesis to Revelation. That's a good chord sequence, right?
There's a song that the early demo is called, you know, she's a model, right? She is beautiful, very beautiful. She's a model. And they turn it into the serpent because, you know, like it was beautiful women, they're like servants in the Garden of Eden, right?
And, but it's actually a fantastic little song. Manatee arrived with fame. How she loved to see her name. She has beautiful, very beautiful, look at her.
Now she's a model. Oh, listen to what I'm trying to say. Thanks for having me now. Don't throw your love away.
I also do need to point out that the ridiculous thing about this album, this is only, only schoolboy pretension, you know, it could explain how ridiculous the premise of Genesis to Revelation is. It's the story of the entire friggin Bible from start to finish in 13 songs. And of course, there's at least three of them that have nothing to do with that premise, right? But like, yeah, this is not exactly a fully baked pizza.
Nevertheless, and it gets even worse too because they threw strings, they're producer John thinking put like strings and horns that really inappropriate on top of these songs. So many of them are actually compromised. One of the reasons Genesis, I think, wanted to release that box set is that they gave you like early demo versions and alternate versions that didn't have the strings and stuff on top of them and they're much, much better. There's a song called In The Wilderness that on the album, it's like horrible left channel, right channel separation, but there's like horns and strings in the right and it's just so gauche.
And if you listen to the actual original version of it without it, it's a damn fine pop song. Peter Gabriel is just singing music. All I hear is music guaranteed to please. Wonderful little track.
This is the sort of thing that however good it was was obviously not going to be their future. It's your favorite Genesis album. If it were, it'd be a weird episode. No, Patrick mentioned this.
It's very hard to even pull through to trespass some curdles of musicianship that appear on Genesis to relation. They're not doing things they want to do. These songs are essentially three, three and a half minutes long. They're writing a theme that they weren't necessarily chosen by the band.
The producers suggested the biblical theme to the album. The orchestral strings as Jack pointed out were added by the producer to Bandit Montthos. Peter Gabriel's voice is clearly nowhere near what it would be in a couple of years. It's very timid.
And heck, there's a rumor that won't be there in a few years. And Jeff, they even broke up after this album before they decided let's try again with trespass. They kind of did and they kind of didn't. And by the way, there's a great apocryphal story.
I don't know if it's true, but I prefer to believe that it is. That when they were recording this album, Peter Gabriel was constantly taking cold showers and puking in the bathroom between takes because he was just so nervous and terrified about singing on record, which is really funny when you think about how to monster Peter Gabriel has since become as a performer. Like this shy young kid just like literally spill it his guts into the toilet in terrifying like fear of having to sink the conqueror. But you know what?
I'm going to tell you right now, the conqueror, that's a banger of a song, man. That would have been a just as good if it were on a nursery crime or a fox trot. And it's here on from Genesis to Revelation. What happens of course is that they kind of break up.
It's what happens because they graduated from school. They didn't graduate from high school. What do they give you? They got to college.
Tony Banks went to college. All right. You know, like some of the other guys went to school and they didn't know what they were going to carry on. It was Aunt Phillips.
And I'm like one of these people who was, you know, because he left so early in the band, doesn't get the credit that he really deserves for shaping the early Genesis sound, who was really keen to carry on and really keen for them to like stay together. And what they ended up doing is doing this kind of thing that's almost become, if you understand like British rock tradition, kind of a joke, which is getting it together in the country. You know, like they went to a cottage out in the farmlands or in the woods and they just giggsed by the fireside on a winter's night. Christmas cottage is what it is.
But you know, it's a joke, but it's also so, so, so important for the history of Genesis because nothing else explains how this band turned from what they were into what they became. This is that I've used this line a hundred times I'll use it again. It is one of the most magical caterpillar into a chrysalis into a beautiful butterfly transformations that you'll ever hear. And all the more so because there really isn't much evidence on tape to document the spirit.
You have the last thing you heard from them is from Genesis Revelations, like your high school kids, it's like 17 year olds playing in their orchestra room. And then all of a sudden you get trespassed. What happened in between? Well, what happened in between is them giddin endlessly and particularly Mike Rutherford and Ant Phillips working together playing 12 string guitars and playing them together to try to come up with like weird chord sounds and chord shapes and just and also them just drawing on everything that they had read.
The joke about early Genesis is that it is definitely like in the literary lyrics written by kids who haven't had a lot of life experience but have just read a lot of books. They definitely passed their classical education so you get the fountain of psalmosis. It was like talking about her miffer, died of son of gods. You get the musical box, you get things like white mountain which is obviously repurposed Tolkien kind of stuff.
You get that kind of an approach which I have to say to me is maybe because I'm a nerd just like they were. It is so appealing. The musical approach is so appealing and you end up with an album like Trespass which is completely different from everything that had come before and is a rebirth of bandiness and they consider it to be their first real band of their first real album of their career. Now is this a good place to talk about the Genesis plays, Jackson stuff that's on the block?
Yeah, it's exactly where it is because you hear all these early themes that they were working with that they just set aside and then when it had to suddenly write a double album later on they were back. Exactly. Part of why I think the first album isn't that great is just because they had really gotten together as a unit the way they did in the Christmas cottage but part of it is the songs that they're writing and they clearly had some other material but it wasn't the Bee Gees type material and some of that comes out in some of the demos from the box set. Like there's a demo of dusk in there which ends up on Trespass where you can kind of hear okay this is this is a kernel of what's to come.
That was literally the song that gave him the courage to continue onwards. They were still kind of just breaking up and then they recorded that demo at Regent Studio and specifically that song dusk and they thought okay well you know what we're actually doing something that other people don't do. It really is. It is.
It is not all those demos it is a standout but then when you get to the Genesis plays Jackson stuff and with these names you know like resignation and manipulation and frustration and provocation but you're the one who introduced me to this stuff but there's you're hearing the beginning of the musical box and you're hearing you know the. You're hearing anyway from the Lamb lies down. Absolutely yeah it's pretty crazy. It seems like there's a lot of these sort of riffs that it feels to me like are probably Tony Banks inspired in those songs a lot of keyboard stuff and I think for me one of the themes in going back and listening to all this stuff again is realizing and this might be a bit of a split between yourself and myself Jeff but to me Tony Banks is the guy.
It's his music that I tend to gravitate towards. I think it maybe because keyboard I believe the keyboard is because I believe he had classical music training where the other guys kind of came from a little bit more of a soul or rock and kinks type background but I really gravitate towards the stuff that he wrote and you hear a lot of those riffs in those Genesis plays Jackson songs and you hear I think his influence and dusk too. So anyway. You have two key influences here you have two different forces you have banks and Gabriel who are best friends.
He'll play all these keyboards and Gabriel likes to compose on piano but he's not allowed to play. That's why he will dress up in masks and kick a kick drum on stage in frustration but he does lyrics but then the other parallel pole is Ant Phillips and my brother first. The 12th string they literally just do adding with one another and like part of sitting eye to eye after night after night, beer after beer. It's just like playing various chords and figuring out what can work and that's what leads you to trespass and the thing I love.
It trespass is an album that is on the street and it's like well this is the beginning of Real Genesis. Their least album. I don't think it's their least album. I love this album.
This album may actually make my top two at the end. It is very different than the rest of the Peter Gabriel Eure Genesis material but there's a unique feeling and a spirit to it that I love. You can hear the fusion of all these voices so well. Every single song more or less has, you know, like okay, this is, you can see that everyone's contributing.
Like visions of angels that's an entirely, that's an Ant Phillips song. That's the one one that's completely his and I actually think that's a fantastic song. And then, but then on up the knife that is clearly Tony Banks, Peter Gabriel. That's a stagnation.
That's everybody just throwing out ideas into a pot, figuring out what works. Dask, that's Rutherford and Phillips, you know, White Mountain looking for someone is clearly Gabriel brought the idea in and then like banks add a lot of keyboards. It's one of those things where the longer time you spend with his band the more you're able to see how all the pieces work and fit together. And yeah, this is, again, they're not children anymore.
This sound of this from the ending of a place to call my own on from Genesis to Revelation to Peter Gabriel saying looking for someone sounding like, you know, you expect Peter Gabriel to sound even if you only heard him from the 80s, you just realized that things have changed forever for this band. Looking for someone, trying to find a memory in a dark room, dirty man, you're looking like a Buddha, I know you will. Yeah, I don't even care. It is such a sudden maturation and I just think this album is wildly underrated.
Yeah, I think it's excellent. I really do. And I was a little surprised by it because it's not one of the albums that, you know, I've generally heard about when listening to other Genesis fans talk or read about some of us earlier material, but it's really very, very good. You mentioned, you know, and Phillips, who is such an influence on Rutherford with his 12 string, they play beautifully together in many sections of this album, especially on stagnation, those 12 string guitars and composite chords, they're playing together the way they think you guys have over beer, eye to eye playing the 12 strings.
They really became a force early on in the way those things were put together. And certainly Tony Banks is right toward the front of the sound in a lot of these places, Visions of Angels, which is a Phillips track, largely as Jeff mentioned, just a beautiful middle section there that thanks really drive with his organ touches and these big drum fills. Speaking of the drums very quickly, John Meihy was the drummer here on Trespass. And it's probably my biggest criticism of the album is that the drums are relatively weak and I don't think it's...
Yeah, I feel bad saying it. I don't think it's just in relation to Phil Collins, who actually is one of the best traumas of his generation. I think just overall they're weak and they're held back in places. I think the knife is a fantastic song clearly.
But I think that he was drumming his holding it back a little bit from what it could be and perhaps later would be in more live settings with Collins behind the kit. Looking for someone that Acapella vocal entry for Gabriel Trick, they'd use a couple of times starting the album. It's a great, great introduction to Trespass. These are now guys, they're no longer students, they're 21 year old or so, but they're doing what they want to do.
There's six songs on this album and five of them are at least six minutes and 45 seconds in length. They're spreading out and finding what they want to write in the songs they really wanted to do two years ago, three years ago, and from Genesis to Revelation and doing it here in a full album version. I think looking for someone is a fantastic track, Visions of Angels that build up to that simple chorus, Visions of Angels all around. And the knife, which I'm sure you guys will talk more about here in a minute, but that's so nearly as hard as the band would get, maybe up until the lamb, which has some very harsh edges, but the knife is just a very dark, up-tempo, heavy track and especially towards the end when you have that riffing on top of the drums and bangs filling in with its color on the organ.
And there's so much tension built up through the course of the knife that then gets released in that very last minute when Gabriel looks loose on vocals. It's a great demonstration of some of that push and pull tension being created in release that I think they really get close to Master Gun, Nurse Recon, the next album, but as a new beat listening to Trespass for one of her songs, I would never say that this is one of the lesser albums of this game in Europe. It's really quite good. There's five songs that are largely acoustic based and have your piano based, right?
Visions of Angels is clearly a piano too, and I think Ant Phillips says that it was inspired kind of like by that Beatles with that little help from my friend style. And then at the end of the album, you have Peter Gabriel literally just screaming at you, some of you are going to die. Martyrs, of course, to the freedom that I shall provide. It is literally a psychotic story of violent revolution, like blood in the streets.
We just did the doors not too long ago. There's blood on the streets, it's up to my angles. That's the knife. That's the vision of horrifying murder.
I mean, there's a line where he says, I want you to gather their heads and carry them to Trafalgar Square. Hang them high, let the blood flow now. When I say the word, do it now. It's just a wonderful transport of imagination.
I think Gabriel, I didn't even know this until I saw the interview that was on the Genesis box where he said that the original version of the knife was named the Nice. It was named after that early Keith Emerson band, Davey O'Lisc, Keith Emerson, and sort of one of the progenitors of Progrock before ELP and King Crimson came into it. I guess it was like a really cool underground band back at the time. So they had a very keyboard heavy sound because if you have Keith Emerson and your band, you're going to be having a lot of people.
That's just a rule. And so that was Tony Banks' attempt to do an impression of that. And then Pete, on top of Tony's, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, da, gave this psychotic, psychotic lyric. And actually, you know, one of the things that I've always loved about Peter Gabriel as a lyricist is that he does seem to walk that fine line between brilliant art and mental illness.
There are lyrics he comes up with that tread that line so carefully on a knife's but a big edge where like you think about stuff on the land lies down on Broadway or Peter Gabriel for that matter. He is in touch with his darkest side. Without ever actually losing his mind. And he's obviously a fairly well grounded person, but you first hear that on the knife.
And I think that the way that that song ends up the album and kind of the contrast between the other songs and that one is reflected well in the album's cover, which is sort of the sort of gentle, you know, sort of pastoral scene through the... There's a cadence that's a cadence staring out of a castle window on the blue, you know, or as... and then turn around the back cover. Yeah.
But it's just like a giant slash across it with this knife. And that's kind of what that song does with the album. But I agree, you know, going back and listening to this, even as a Genesis fan who'd heard it many times before. It'd been quite a while since I listened to this album.
And it was really one of the joys of getting ready for the podcast to listen to it closely again. And I thought, wow, I really had forgotten about this album. And it's it is really underrated. And a lot of it is it's a function, I think, of the fact that they'd been playing on the road, right?
And so they were actually... You were banned at this point. Yeah. And so, you know, even though the songwriting wasn't as collaborative as it would later be, it was just it was a little bit less of kind of an adventure for them just doing the recording because they're just coming into the studio and doing what they've been playing live.
And so they all knew this is how the song goes and this is how we're going to play it. But the drumming, it is a little bit on the weaker side. They kind of gone through a little bit of a spinal tap sort of episode with the drummers. Three drummers, they had three separate drummers going through it.
But my favorite song on this album is stagnation. I think it's really the one that shows the collaborative writing at its best, where you've got the 12 string guitars, but then you've got everybody gets in on it. Yeah, I completely agree. Especially like the way, again, you were at the 12 strings, but then there's like Tony Aziz weird, kind of weird, loopy, loopy organ sounds.
And then on top of it, Pete is singing this completely inscrutable lyric that has never made a lick of sense to me. Right. But I love every single time it gets to that climax, man. I want to drink water too.
I love it. And I think, for me, I like the knife, but it's a little bit more of that type of frenetic Genesis song that's not really my favorite style of song. I really prefer the sort of contrast and kind of melodious stuff in stagnation to the harder edge of the knife. Although it's interesting, and I do like it.
I just don't like it quite as much as stagnation, which I just consider to be the masterpiece of the album. Well, then maybe you are going to die as a mother of course, free of the opera vibe. I have a question for you guys. What happens when the most important driving member of your band quits?
And he quits because he has stage fright of all that. And you then decide that, well, you know what, instead of breaking up, which we might have done, we're going to carry on, but we're going to get a little two for one tray. We're going to get ourselves a new drummer as well, because that's what happens with Genesis, Anthony Phillips, who would be a core member of this band. And in fact, a lot of whose musical ideas would end up showing up on the musical box and even the Lamline is down on Broadway many years later.
He quits, he quits at a stage fright. He got sick. He got sick and tired, really. But it was a psychosomatic thing.
He just hated the gigging road. He hated that entire grind. He left. And you listen to all of them.
You listen to Pete and Tony and Mike say, we consider him to be our leader. It's a strange thing to say now because you think of Genes, you think of Peter Garebro, you think of Collins, right? You don't think of Anthony Phillips, but he was the guy who drove them in the early days. And he quit.
And they said, okay, we're going to just do this because we only have one chance to do this. Let's just keep trying and see what happens. And these guys, this band were the luckiest sons of bitches on the planet. Because what happens?
Who do they find? First, as a drummer, and then second, as a guitarist. They found Phil Collins and Steve Hackett. These guys, and this is funny because these guys who joined the Genesis after, they're like your first two albums, Phil Collins is literally my favorite drummer of all time.
Steve Hackett is my second favorite guitarist of all time. And I've heard a lot of drummers and a lot of guitarists. And I'm willing to grant that there is a certain amount of bias because this is a band that I love. But I can argue for both of them.
And it's just extraordinarily, almost incomprehensibly lucky that this band would pick up within this band of six months, two of the most singular talents on their instruments to basically ever live during the Rock Era, which leads us to their, not their second, I guess I have to call it their third album. I never like to pick up for Genesis to Red Elation as their first album. But they leave the nursery crime. And this is Genesis as we know them, the five piece.
From now on, this band would only shrink. It would not grow. People will leave, but they will never rejoin. This is the beginning of High Prog Genesis.
This is where people's heads get severed with croaky mallets. Her maverickites get sucked into fountain springs and giant weeds take up angry alienates. And in life like a scene out of Day of the Triffids, this is nursery crime. What do you guys think of this one?
It's incredible. I mean, the musical box is one of my favorite Genesis songs, period. And again, coming out of those sessions where they had all those little riffs. But it's just, especially for somebody who comes from a classical music background, you know, and when I was growing up, my favorite musician was Beethoven.
And what I liked about him was the way that he'd write these long pieces of music. And every single note just felt inevitable. And that's what, when you listen to the musical box, that's how you feel. You feel like it's a long piece.
But every single, the instrumentals, the singing, everything just seems logical and inevitable. And without a bunch of repetition, like you sometimes have in some of the other longer pieces, it just flows from one thing to the next. It's, it's, it's, uh, it's, there's so many different parts to it. That's the thing about it that shocks me.
So there are a couple other long ethics on the album. Hargweed, they're good songs, really, really good songs. But they have a more kind of, I don't know if you want to see conventional format. You have a verse, a chorus, a verse, there's a little middle section, whatever.
The musical box is a sweet, it's more of a concerto. It is something, and I love the comparison of the classical music and musical box because it begins in one place and it ends in an entirely different place. And like it starts with these things and there's these repeating sections, but it keeps developing and developing and developing. And then all of a sudden you have Peter Gabriel wearing an old man mask, like doing terrible things to a small child saying, touch me, touch me now, now, now.
God, I don't even want to try to explain to people what the premise of this song is because it's the most perverse thing in the world. Okay. I'm going to do it because I'm going to do it for the landlines now and Broadway too. My favorite action of that I'm going to have to do is well, but here, here's, okay.
So two to two, a young boy, young girl are playing croquet and I'll, you know, the little game with the mallets and the stakes where you try to hit the balls through the stakes. And instead of doing that, the girl takes the mallet and literally swings it at the boy's head and decapitates him, killing him. Yay. Because, you know, she's just screwed up like that.
That's the cover of the album in fact. And it's about the boy's spirit then disappears into the musical box that the girl has. And for some reason, don't ask me to ask Pete, I don't know why Peter Gabriel wanted this to be the case. He then ages like, you know, 75 years overnight.
And then when the girl actually ends up playing the musical box later, emerges from it to as an angry old man, Ray Per. There you go. That's it. That's the story.
Welcome to early Genesis. Well, I mean, is it really, is it Ray Per wise? He doesn't, he doesn't ask. He says, why don't you touch me?
Yeah. He's an old man. All you're still like just feeling like basically this compressed lifetime of desire that's all spilling out. All he ever wanted was for her to play him old King Cole.
Well, okay. It might be not just that. Yeah. The thing is, you can joke about it.
But I have to actually give some credit to it. It's dark, so messed up. And as you pointed out, there is like a point like imagine having all of your life compressed into like a box and like kind of suddenly being freed for a second. And like all those desires come out like Gabriel still young, but like he was tuning into some really weird dark stuff that he I think uniquely alone among all of the progressive rock lyricists of that era and really most eras was capable of tuning into.
I think time York sometimes gets at some of what Gabriel does at times in a very, very different way with Radiohead. But like I'm impressed by that song, even as I'm disturbed by that song. And I've always loved art that kind of gives me, you know, that raises the hackles on my neck that kind of messes with my mind. Well, that's exactly what I was going to say almost exactly, which is that the period in the song beginning around like seven minutes and 45 seconds in something like that where it begins with the lyrics, she's a lady, right?
Or he's the old man. That entire section, almost every single time, especially when I watch the video, just sends a chill down my spine. There's something visceral about the effect that it has on me. And I really want people to know, you've got to see this video, the version, there's different live versions on YouTube.
I think if you type in musical box 1973 remastered. It'll pop up and you'll see the old man head there. I think it might be on the most recent box version of the box. I think it's from the Rainbow Theater show, I believe, from October 20th, 1973, which is a very nerdy thing for me to say.
But you've got to watch that. And if you're not a Genesis fan after watching that video, then I don't know what to tell you. Just go and embrace the weird. Let me handle perhaps two other songs.
Well, first, Jeff said this, but it's true how much luck is involved. Maybe they're just really good at picking out the right guys from rehearsals. Hackett and Collins were just the right guys for this band. Hackett probably, well, Collins do a different kind of instrument.
Hackett's guitar is really innovative and interesting with his parts. It's a good fit for what he adds. Collins, of course, brings a light touch at times and can sing. And we'd hear him do some dual vocals with Gabriel and take a lead on a few songs, including one on Here for Apps and Friends, this first league vocal, a slider track on the album.
But those guys fit in perfectly, perfectly with what the band is trying to do. Two songs I wanted to mention on Nursery Crime, there's not a ton, of course. But Return of Giant Hogweed, again, the weed has the oddness of... It's the day of the triphids.
For people who don't understand their 50s sci-fi schlock, this is a film about nuclear radiation hits the planet and all of a sudden, weeds become sentient. And that they can sting people and blind them with their horrible spines. And that's the return of the giant hogweed. This has no friggin' right to work, but it works so well.
It's so hilarious. But it's a real thing, though, the giant hogweed. Right. It's a...
It's a... It's actually blind people with its terrible spines? I don't know that it's... Has a mighty hogweed been avenge?
Does a human body soon will know our anger? There's like... They all need the sun to photosensitize their venom. How does Peter Gabriel get away with singing that?
Their immune to our all our... Yes. Or a recital battery. They are invincible.
They are immune to our all our herbicidal battery. How do you get away with singing that? You know what? You've got to be Peter Gabriel.
And you just have to have the balls to not care about like singing multisyllabic words about sentient weeds that are strangling the human race. It's just funny and stupid. This is the kind of thing that you can get into that botnet early Genesis is for your... And it helps with the music, really.
It's fantastic, right? Steve Packett at the beginning. I know Jeff has pointed this out on Twitter, the recent passing of Eddie Van Halen, being known for his tapping technique. He popularized it, but as Jeff has quick to point out, Hackett's the guy that essentially invented it.
And you can hear it on the beginning of Return of Giant Hogweed, a tapping technique from Hackett. And I like Hogweed a lot because I feel like it's the first time they really get into a nice groove. Bump, bah, bah, bah, bah. I really enjoy that through Hogweed.
The lyrics are off the wall. And speaking of off the wall, Harold the Barrel is a great song. A duet sung by both Pete and Phil. One of these character stories from Genesis in which Gabriel's voicing 16 different people through the course of a song.
Harold, the title character is on a ledge, threatening to jump. All his friends come by, tell him not to. Were your friends come down and talk to us, Harry? Well, it's not just that man.
You know, look, remember, up on the ledge beside him, his mother's making some extra press. And come off the ledge, dear. If your father were alive, he'd be very, very, very upset. You know why you just can't jump?
Because you're sure it's all dirty. And there's a man here from the BBC. That makes me laugh every single time. It's just so British.
It would be so awkward. The BBC cameras are going to watch you jump to your death. No, that's not done. And of course, what I'm Harold Bell to do.
He caught off all his toes and he served them all for tea. Harold the Barrel, by the way. I have to say, I think it's actually in a funny way. There are so many great songs on this album.
Musical Box is fantastic. That one song is fantastic. I actually think this is my favorite song on it. Because what I love is that it's the miniature version of Supper's Ready.
You take a 25-minute long ultra-vlog epic and you collapse that entire son of a bitch into two and a half minutes. And then you get sheer sensory overload. You're just be pelted with rocks, like Tony Banks, Peter Gabrielle, and Steve Tacken. You're just rocking at you, bonking off your head while these different musical ideas and the fast-moving lyric.
But once you finally absorb it, it's just wonderful. There's that small pause in the middle where Pete says, If I was many miles from here, I'd be sailing on an open boat in the sea. Instead, I am on this window ledge with the whole world below. And then it goes back into wackiness.
Up in the window, look at the window! Jump, jump, jump! It's just nuts. It's nuts.
And Patrick, you were right. I do love these frenetic geniuses. I love, I love just the garbage compactor. You can take a car and compress it into a cube.
This is the cube of Genesis songs. Two minutes and 45 seconds. All of those ideas into one piece. God, I love it.
I love this many miles from here. I've been sailing on this window. Thanks, piano is fantastic. Jumpy-pouncy, piano through.
The lyrics mentioned, yes, are my favorite. The mother and the reasons she does not want him to jump. I love you, please don't know. You're dead.
We're still here. Your shirt's dirty. The BBC is here. It's a great little portion of the cover song.
Yeah. I just want to say too, since you're highlighting Steve Hackett and Phil Collins, How about that melody maker? Which one? The publication.
That's the publication that was responsible for both of those guys joining the band. Phil says he'd always been looking in the back of the band because the band that he was in wasn't up so much. What is this crap band, Genesis? They always seem to be playing gigs.
Who are these idiots? They showed up to the audition and he's joking. He showed up an hour and a half early so we could see everyone else in front of him fail. Right.
And learn how to do what it was they were doing. And then of course he killed it. It was like swimming in a pool or something. Yeah, he was just hanging out while they're all drumming out on the deck.
And he was slowly paying attention. And meanwhile it was completely different story with Steve. With Hackett, they actually found him. He'd been placing ads asking for people to join him.
He was like, I'm interested in a band. There are people who want to do interesting musical things with me. Peter Gabriel came over to his house, watched him play, brought Tony along next time. So this guy, I think he's the guy.
And really, I can't say enough about Steve Hackett. I think he is, as I said, Phil Collins doesn't need a lot of, sort of, doesn't need to be built up. Everyone knows who Phil Collins is. Maybe if you hate him, you hate him, but you still know who he is.
Steve Hackett is one of the greatest guitarists to ever wield the instrument. And he was so perfect for Genesis, precisely because of his personality. He had such great technical excellence, but he was also humble. And he was so willing to just be the colorist to play in the background and play a guitar solo, to play strumming things, to play things that you might only hear out of the corner of your ear.
And then when you pick them out, you're like, holy crap, that's amazing. That's Steve Hackett. He's one of the best guitarists on the planet. And yet, I know he has an ego, because everyone has an ego.
But he was always in, even in his solo work, he's just willing to be working in service to whatever the music asks for. He's not the guy who needs the big solo spot. He's not Steve Howe. He's not Edvin Hayland.
He's Steve Hackett. He's unique. He's one of my favorite guitarists. And one of the stories that I like that illustrates his shyness is the reason that Phil Collins is the one who sings for Abs and Friends.
Apparently, it was a song that Steve Hackett had written. But he was too shy to present it to Peter Gabriel because he's the lead singer. And it's like, here I am this new guy. Should I really be presenting a song to the lead singer?
And he sort of felt like, well, Phil is another new guy, so I can kind of take it to him. And then they worked on that song together. And that's basically why Phil Collins ends up singing that song and the album. Inside the arts, where the priest meets them when the purchase is not his host to go.
Which by the way, I think it's, I really like that song. I know it's not one of their big epics, but it reminds me of sort of the Beatles, like sort of a She's leaving home kind of feel. And I think it's a really nice little song. There are a lot of little cameos on the song that are really hard-looking.
For example, it's like, okay, it's a little fru-fru, right? You know, Harley Quinn, Harley Quinn, very medieval Renaissance. It's Renfasc stuff, right? But I like it.
I like it, I like it, I like it, again. It's very clearly feels like it was something that was written with Ant Phillips and Rutherford before Ant up the band. That dueling 12 string thing, which Tony took over for Phillips. But like, yeah, it's still a good song.
What I think we should be emphasized though is that as good as nursery crime is, especially for a debut for Hackett and for Collins, is that everything is going to change forever with their next album. Because this is when they basically just decided to go for it, to break the barriers, to be as prog as a friggin can possibly be. Do you do that thing that all good self-respecting progressive rock bands must ever do? Which is, that's right, the side-long song.
Of course, Genesis being who they are, it wasn't even quite a side-long song. They have that Hackett little horizon thing in front of it. But of course, we're talking about Foxtrot and of course, we're talking about Supper's Ready, which is the conclusion of this album. Before we get to the conclusion of this album, perhaps we should address the first half of this album.
Maybe take it in its totality. This is Genesis sinking into what it was that they do and do best. And this is a lot of people's favorite Genesis album of all time. I don't know where you stand, Patrick O.
Yeah, I think it's probably going to be one of the two that I pick at the end. You know, if, if for no other reason that it has Supper's Ready, but the other songs are fantastic. And I really like a Watcher of the Skies, the beginning to that song with the crazy chords, you know, and it's all melitron. But I think there's a story that Tony Banks tells about, kind of, they had, I can't remember who the guy was, but there was a guy that briefly had as a producer.
And he plays the opening of that song for the guy, and the guy says, well, let's not use that. We don't think we want this guy producing our records. Dark, dark, dark, dark thunderheads on the horizon. When you see those clouds rolling in, I live in Chicago, so I can see them rolling in off the lake, or down from north, and they're black as hell on their up north.
And I just know that like in 15 minutes, I'm going to be drenched here where I am. And I hear every time I see that, I hear those opening chords to Watcher of the Skies. Yeah. And then also...
There you go. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. That rhythm too. That Morse code rhythm. That rhythm sells it.
It reminds me of, you know, Rush would do with YYZ some years later, that is just such a driving portion of the song. Watcher of the Skies, it might be my favorite Genesis song of this era. I think it's just majestic from the Metal Tron start, which at least the story goes. It's one of King Crimson's Metal Trons that Genesis bought off.