Skip to content
Episode 90 - Steven Moffat (Part 1) episode artwork

Oct 11, 2018 41 min

Episode 90 - Steven Moffat (Part 1)

from Sitcom Geeks Hosted by Comedy.co.uk

Part one of a fascinating interview with the great Steven Moffat - one of our most successful writers whose work includes Sherlock, Coupling and a certain Doctor who he discusses with Dave and James.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 90 - Steven Moffat (Part 1)

0:00 41:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome to SickCon Geeks, I'm James Caring. I'm Dov Cohen. And we are thrilled to be joined by a wonderful guest. Would you please welcome Stephen Moffat, hello Stephen.

Hello. Thank you very much for being on the show. Thank you. And we have so many questions for you.

I feel like you overwhelmed because you are the writer of numerous sitcoms before, you know, three even. Yes. Well, three's pretty good. A lot of people are one and finished.

Yeah. So, or one forever, you know. Which is impressive. Yes indeed.

And one of the things that struck us, so the three sitcoms are sick that we'd like to talk about, but also we'll come on to Doctor Who and Sherlock and other things too. And of course, Prescott as well, which was actually in its own way. It's the fact that we sometimes, we're slightly torn between right what you know and right what you don't know and right what you like. And actually just looking through the sitcoms that you did in Jake and your past and chalk and coupling.

Reading a little bit about what you just think. These are quite autobiographical in some way. Do you feel that you're sort of world writing what you knew? That was a conscious decision or it's just, I've got to write something, it might as well be this.

You've got to write something and might as well be this. You know, it's sanctifying laziness, isn't it? I mean, that's fine. You don't have to write what you know.

Obviously, if you put on the new, we'd have to conclude this Shakespeare was a Danish princess. That's absolutely nonsense. You're writing, you're making stuff up. That's fundamentally the job.

You're making stuff up that's not true. Now, some of it may contain some eternal truths, settling on anything, either the written. But fundamentally, it's not true in its job is to entertain people. So it's all right.

What if Stephen King stuck to what he knew? What was out of the Christie's attitude on checking into a hotel? Did she assume they would be a murder? Yes.

Of a complicated nature? No, you don't get to. That's just what's in front of you. That's why you mostly set things in the present day.

Because that's where you live. It's easy. I think also, and we were talking a little bit to Jack Docksy about this, the idea of that, that obviously you are your best raw material. No one else has lived your life.

From that point of view, it's great. But then it's the kind of giving yourself permission to lie. I think obviously that's where... Well, it does.

The thing is, in that sense, you have an alternative, but what you know, even when you're lying. Because those are your lies. Those are the particular lies you chose. So you're just writing from inside your own skull.

That's not something I have to make an effort at. Is there a danger? Because I found this when I realized that a part that I was trying to write in a radio sitcom I did was basically me. I was sort of going too easy on him because he was the reasonable person at the centre of this mad world.

And I'm wondering, for example, in joking apart, a comedy about a stand-up comedian. A comedy writer. A comedy writer, isn't it? Yeah.

Actually, it was quite hard. You sort of were too... And also Robert Baffers is just lovely, isn't he? He's such a lovely man.

Whether you're sort of trying to make his life a bit too easy, not making him enough of a monster. Did you find that? Well, I think he was a bit of a monster in that show, especially in the early episodes. He's a...

You know, I certainly cite myself against myself in my divorce. Which was the comedy I kind of. On the other hand, I later realized that was the ultimate in narcissism, isn't it? It was assuming that everything that went wrong with my marriage was about me.

But I was left. She didn't just find somebody she preferred. It couldn't bear that narrative. It had to be a fault that I possessed and that could feature heavily at the centre point of a sitcom.

So I don't think necessarily you go easy on your comedy surrogate. But on the other hand, we do all seem to end up creating the same hatplers, lovable, always makes a silly and a state character that is the stand-in for every single person who ever picks up a pen, ever, whether it's a newspaper columnist, or a sitcom writer. We're all that guy. It's all an identical character.

That's sort of true in Britain, I think. Lovable loser kind of character, I suppose. Obviously things have changed now. But it's kind of going through the 80s and 90s.

As we were carrying on creating our lovable loser characters, but in America, you still had the kind of, they're not losers in America. I mean, there is that slight difference. They are successful people like Frazier or whatever. That's not that sort of, I don't know, that kind of British sense of disappointment.

That hangs over a lot of our comedy. That's the kind of one thing. As we imitate the other comedy we grew up with, which is really our sense of loserness. But even Frazier is kind of hapless.

He makes silly mistakes. He's well meaning, but all the cool happened. I mean, it's quite rare to have something. Bracing in my office, someone like Battlefaulty, who's just completely unreasonable person with whom he sympathies with us more.

And all those hapless losers that we always portray ourselves at. I think that's another thing as well. I know when I'm trying to write something invariably I am the main character. Unfortunately.

So, and I find this when we're reading scripts from other people as well, is that it's not necessarily that you're going on your stuff on yourself. It's just like, oh, this person in relation to me is that easy comedy archetype that I can have a lot of fun with. So you end up with a group of people around you who are sort of funnier. And you're almost, you know, obviously in a show like Seinfeld, that's kind of pretty fantastic.

You've got it beautifully clear there, but sometimes I think it's more that kind of, you almost know yourself too well. And then you put the funny bits into the other people. Do you have that? Yeah, I mean, yes, I think other characters sometimes have an easier time being funnier.

The ones that aren't you, I suppose. But then that's because you're, that's because you're simple. I don't know what that psychology is. And I haven't done it in a very, very long while.

I have always wondered where we're all basically James Herrias. We are. I mean, James Herrias, that's every comedy lead in everything. Well, meaning basically decent sort of chap who makes silly mistakes and no one really understands, but he's occasionally very wise towards the end of half an hour.

You know, it's not, I mean, that's not a tool what I like in real life. So I don't know why I used to portray myself that way. No, yeah, there is a sort of comforting kind of narrative to that sort of character, isn't there? Is it maybe partly, we say it's that, is also just trying to make some sort of every person, some sort of person sits at the centre of it all, and is your guide on this journey through this comedy nonsense?

Just as, just as Sherlock Holmes has Dr. Watson, because Sherlock Holmes would be an intolerable main character. He's not really the main character he's not really the main character he's not really the main character he's not. You know, just a doctor who has to have a companion who really takes the lead role, because Doctor who's an intolerable lead character, you have no idea what Doctor thinks or feels or imagines you have to experience it through somebody who's sort of calibrated to be a reasonable representative of the human race that most people could sympathise with.

I guess it goes back to again the Doctor conversation about he quoted somebody else who says, is it Monty Feldman or someone saying that every comedy is either a normal person in a mag world or a man person in a normal world or something? And then he used that to say he did a show called Mr. George, which with man people in a mag world, because why didn't work? Because 30 years later he now realises, oh that's what we did wrong.

I think that's very true, there's another one I read, I forget, was it in conversations with my agent Rob Long's book, which is either Bugs Bunny or the Bugs Bunny? And we all want to write Bugs Bunny but we all got off and write Mickey Mouse. And the net won's Mickey Mouse but you want Bugs Bunny. Absolutely, but he's our monster and Mickey Mouse is nice.

But both work. There's another two times of writing as well, we've talked to John Pinnemaw about this, and it comes up a lot. The kind of writer you are, are you the sort of writer that enjoys writing or are you the kind of writer who enjoys having written? I think everyone's at a different place on that scale, but do you actually like the writing of pages or do you hate writing pages?

I like the last few days of a script I think. I mean I'm not saying it, writing is really hard work. Do you mean by hate if it's taken away from me, I'd be miserable? It's not our job to be happy.

So we can't judge things as whether or not they make you happy. I think we always get that wrong, we always think it's the weekend that makes you happy because you're happy at the weekend. It's not, it's the funny days of work you pretend that makes you happy at the weekend. So no, writing mostly does not make me happy, makes me frustrated and I'm always always stuck and I always find it in humanly difficult.

And I never, ever think I'm ever, ever going to finish it. I always think I can't finish this one. But I also, at some distant non-visceral way, realize that's what it's like, that's the process. You're not supposed to go into a room and flatter your fingers off the keyboard and now script emerges.

That's not what it's like, if it was like that, you wouldn't need writers, you could just turn the computer on and leave it warm. Yes, well when the police say that one writes itself. I'll try in there. It's weird, there's no algorithm so far.

My son assures me that AI will get to that. He says, yeah. He's very convincing on the subject. Yeah, well maybe, but we'll be entertained by robots.

I already am. Robots are great. But I think it's interesting to know though, I think because a lot of people who listen to this show are starting out wanting to be writers. And I think one of the secrets that you have to tell them is there isn't a secret and it's hard when you start and it's hard as you get going.

And it's hard when you get older and it doesn't get any less hard. And every week it's not, how am I going to write this one now? And actually the only thing that gets easier is you just know how much more work it's going to be. Did you remember John Cleese's thing about that?

He said, around the time of 40 Towers when he owned all comedy. He said, it's kind of modest thing, but very clever thing. He said, I think my advantage is I know how hard it's supposed to be. And that's exactly right.

I think because writing doesn't, because writing seems like a sort of mystical thing, people think it was a mystical thing. People talk about inspiration, and vision, and all sorts of words. I mean absolutely nothing. The use words like talent, again, e-word that means absolutely nothing.

You could take a human being apart at a Manhattan by a time and not find talent to exist. It's simply work. It is simply work. And if you're working, I mean, it is, I think the good and the bad news is, it is infinitely more achievable than people think it is.

It is utterly achievable for anyone who's got a reasonable, a reasonable and average brain, and the opportunity. But it is far more arduous and far more about the taking of pains and the rewriting and the suffering. It is far more arduous than you think. There is going to be no moment, no moment where your vision leads you through.

The muse will never visit, or rather, that moment of inspiration that you talk about in the interviews, because you want an anecdote and because they cut everything before that, in spite of the interview. That part of the inspiration was when you discarded every other option for this scene, over a period of three weeks, where you've been frozen over two lines of dialogue, and then suddenly you have an inspiration. That sounds great. You get inspiration, you wait for three weeks.

You drive every other option, and eventually you open the right door and the other is that one. Well, it's the same thing. That is the Sherlock Holmes option, isn't it? You exclude everything that it can't be.

Whatever you're left with, however impossible is the solution. It sounds like a lovely thing that Sherlock Holmes says, but there's an awful lot of things it could be. Yes, that's right. Yeah.

Yeah. Yes. It's less re-remantic, I was writing. There is nothing romantic about it.

It is like a job. It's a very, very good job. But he's a very, very difficult one. Anyone looking for me outside, but not that many people do it successfully.

And it doesn't look like work. No, it just looks like, because the script that comes out of the end is a word document. It doesn't look like work to me, and I've been doing it for a moment, it is. I have great difficulty in persuading myself.

What I've spent a day, and all I've done is cut ten pages. Suit comes on and says, how do I say ten pages less than you've done when you left? It's very hard for me to persuade myself that I've been working hard. I have been working hard.

I have been working hard. I'm also for that matter. Yes, I'm as soon as a very impatient and anguished when I say things like that, especially if she's very often the producer. But that is the word.

That is the word. Those misread days where you put your stuff in the writer's block. There isn't anything else that you need. I find that moment that I'm looking out into the middle distance and I ask the question.

And then I say, I'm working. You're not. You're just staring into space. Well, that's what it feels like you do, doesn't it?

It doesn't feel like work. It's just, and I'm contemplating the vacuum at the heart of his own brain. Just pick up on that thing. I probably hadn't really thought of that since you mentioned Sherlock Hand Doctor who.

Kind of in the same breath as you mentioned, you're on the sitcom characters. And that's something that you talk about in your writing partner about. It's not so much how they see themselves, but how the people around the season see them. Which is something that you kind of mentioned there.

I hadn't really thought of that. It's obvious now in terms of Sherlock and Doctor who. In terms of the sitcoms, then, that you do, I suppose, a lot of what you're saying about your main characters comes through. It's just the person who came to mind as the Jeff character in the couple.

That is a kind of, you know, who always has these sort of crazy ideas really. Are you sort of conscious of feeding the stories through to the main character from the other characters? Well, very much so. And one should not underestimate the still point at the center of comedy because another thing about a joke is so often the case.

Especially in comedy as drama, which is what I think is. It's sometimes it's not the line. Sometimes it's who you say it to the laugh if you watch on the grammar of television. The laugh comes, not when the person says the line, but when you cut to the person, when you cut to Jack Davenport or the level.

That's the thing that, or the absolute master of it is Martin Freeman. He's an absolute genius actor. So Benedict can go on for a three or four pages of continuous monologue. That is very hard to remember and very hard to say.

Because it's meant to be the words of a genius, come to an intuitive to learn. You've got to get to the end of this huge monologue and Martin will have one word or not. Not even a word, he'll just do a look. And that's the whole laugh right there.

That's his saying that he's mum. It's the longest setup in history. It's only quite a generous actor to be able to give those a word. The reaction is the joke, isn't it?

Yeah, of course it is. But then it flips the other way, as well. When Watson's being eminently human and reasonable, then the says you have to respond to those things. When he talks to someone like they're a human being and there's nothing.

I'm sure Benedict won't do it this much. He did have the four pages to learn for that. Yes, that's all that. That's all that.

We don't think of it. He's the bit we don't think of it before. As he said, we would have learned it in advance of that. It's like, I think it's what we as our doctor who's.

That's why they last about three years. The amount of learning that I never thought of Mass Smith had to do. At the end I had lunch with him just on his second last day of a drink. He was talking about his week and saying, you've got to learn it on Sunday.

You've got to learn it on Sunday. It's the only time you can learn it. Then you learn it again the night before. Because I've been asking, why do you never normally come out for a drink?

Because I'm working. I'm working every night. Learning not just a small amount of material. But a whole lot of, you know, absolute gobbledyg are you written?

That's why I talk about it. And the energy you need to do it in terms of it's very much. It's stuff here. And it's like, right, we've all got to go over there and do the next thing.

The energy you need to, you know, it's interesting talking to him. It was instructive. He said, it's not enough to know it. You've got to know you know it.

So there's no part of your brain is worrying about whether you know your dialogue. Not one tiny piece. You have to be able to be nudged and just say it. And he said you have four ideas about it.

One of which you'll use. We have four ideas. That's what you do the night before. Or the Sunday before and the night before.

You put so much, so much work into it. We don't ever think about it. We don't ever think about it. We don't want to have a great respect for actors.

I think that's what we do. Hello, James here, buttoning into the interview. We're grateful to Stephen for not only taking the time to talk to us, but allowing us into his home is very kind of him. And we want to give you every last stop of this interview.

So we're spinning into two and you can hear part two next week as we're going to go weekly for a bit. You can also hear part two of this interview, but loads of other interviews if you join us on Patreon. So we've got one with Al Murray and one with Julie Bauer who created CBBC hit show. So awkward.

We talk to artists and seriously funny tweets and moose, Alain, Gail Renard from the writers, Gail. They're always putting up loads of new stuff that gives you different ways into the world of writing comedy and sitcom in particular. And we're also going to be launching a new Patreon only series called Sitcom Soup to Nuts, where Dave and I create a sitcom, a new sitcom over multiple podcasts from beginning to end, taking you through all the steps from thinking of an initial idea to characters, story-lining, scripting, rewriting and finally recording. We also offer Patreon only first 10 pages podcasts where we read the first 10 pages of your script and then do a podcast that only subscribers can hear.

Enough, you say. You want to hear more Moffit and not me. Fair enough. So do I.

Here we go. But it's me first and then Moffit. Sorry about that. You mean, but obviously you work with a ton of really brilliant actors.

I mean, how has that affected the way that you write compared to the young Steven Moffit? I think there's a, when you're young and arrogant, and thank God you're arrogant because the only thing that gets you through, you'll just give up if you want to ask. You think it's all about you. You really do.

But you're a script or whatever. You start to realise as you get older, the difference between a writer, however fast they have to write, and the director and the cast is that they do their work real-time. They've got to do it that day between this hour and that hour. They don't get it right.

That's it for ever. That's why they're stressed. I don't know if you wander on, so I didn't really think. That's why they want to kill you.

That's why they want to kick you off the set. So you know, the big tip is, which I'm always giving to young writers, and I'm an old man, is be useful on that set. Be helpful. And then they'll want to cheat.

Then they'll write to only get kicked off sets of the pains and the arse. If they come along and be useful to the director and helpful to the actors, they'll never be able to leave the set because they'll love you because they're stressed. And because they're doing their work in real-time, you have to remember that when you're typing. The stage directions have to make sense.

They have to make sense. Every detail has to be possible for this room to have one door, yet two people exit at different times and all that. You really have to provide them with a document that actually works under fire in the trenches when you make this thing. Writers don't quite...

We work in a different kind of way, which has its own particular hell at four in the morning. But writers and directors and producers and actors, they're not your enemy. They're not trampling over your vision. They're trying to get their work done in a ridiculously small amount of time in the knowledge that if they can't rewrite it tomorrow.

That was the big thing. And I wonder if writers in so many ways are our own worst enemies in terms of... We do make things more adversarial. But I think trying to remember that we all want to make a good show, I think, is paramount.

And I think in other interviews that come up that trust is really important. And I think maybe, therefore, one thing that some people do find difficult is when you're still at the script stage and the show doesn't exist yet. And there's sort of an art enough jokes here. And you just think, I know that I could sprinkle some one liners that will feel zingy, but actually I know that this will get a laugh because it's a reaction.

I know that will get a laugh. Particularly another example of that, as only recently I realized this, if you go back to one foot in the grave, which is one of the great sitcoms all the time, there are so few jokes in it. I can't really think of any one liners other than catch-raisers and when he picks up the dog and says 1491. Because they run again in a sense, you're similar, I suppose, in the sense that the stories are paramount.

I was reading up some... I did read something where you talked about, I think it was coupling where you said sometimes the jokes got in the way of towards the bigger punch line, which would come ten minutes in. If something got in the way of that, then you got to do it. Oh, yes.

We all have that nerve in policy. We're talking about a moment ago to sprinkle more jokes in. It's a comedy. It's the besetting sin of comedy, is you're very aware how long am I allowed to go without a funny?

And if you have a reasonable facility to be funny, which probably anyone who's writing a comedy script does unless they're really bad at it, which is rare, then you can add more jokes in. But sometimes you're making the audience laugh too early, you want them to take it more seriously. Some ways writing comedy as part of drama is very useful because you never feel that obligation. I think I'll be funny if it comes up, but not if it doesn't.

You're clearing a space for the jokes. I think the running is fearless. And he's also genius. He probably helps me be fearless about making you wait.

There's going to be a conversation. It might be mildly amusing enough that you know that it's a comedy and that you're half-smiling, just keeping a slight half-smile on your face. But he's going to deliver an absolute gobsmacking laugh at your number ten years later. Mrs.

Warboys has been on the roof of the car the whole time. And also sometimes, you know, if you trust yourself, you can... I can't remember who else I heard talk about this recently, but an article is put down on a table with a joke to think, Oh, the reason that they've done that is to do that joke. I can now forget about that little tin of something.

And then in 15 minutes time it's smacked. Oh my goodness, the tin is there. And it's got the thing in it. And I just thought it was there for a joke.

And it's not. And it's brilliant. I talked about that. Right?

There you go. It's a few months. And this works well in comedy. I'm quoting you to you.

Oh, yeah. Sorry. Sorry. Sorry.

I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.

I love being quoting me. Maybe somebody else thought that. It might be correct. It works well in comedy that if you deliver a punchline on something that you...

It doesn't hang at the back of your mind as an unresolved issue. What's that going to be about? And then you get another smashing of your go, my God, it works in drama. Because people who have never written comedy don't know that trick in drama.

Where you pass off something as a self-supporting plot entity, a little moment early on, you think, Oh, I know why that's there. It made me laugh, hooray. And then I know a later you bring it back. And you think, why didn't I spot that?

And the answer is because you thought you knew why it was there. And that's not why it was there. It was brilliant. I recently put a salutated joke to a script I was editing where I was so excited that I was able to cat all of the jokes.

I just sort of said, guys, there was a joke here all along. And I can't believe I'm the only person who exported this. And they all went, it was there all along. How do we not see a hiding in plain sight?

Let's talk briefly about the mechanics of the comedy in particular, by which I mean, as I mentioned an email to you when we were assessing this up. There was a bit of coupling that literally made me jump out of my seat with a shriek and a laugh of joy and ecstasy. Which also happened once in an episode of Friends where they end up talking about the backpacking story. But in your episode, it was where Jack Davenport's character, I think, has there's a phone call that is taken and then he realized halfway through that scene that this scene is happening.

Exactly the same time as the previous scene that you've just seen. And the person on the phone, you've just heard the other conversation about that. And it made me just jump in the air with delight and joy. And then as I was thinking back to copying, how often actually the star of the show was often the plot.

Because you know, you used lots of it in like nine and a half minutes as well, all those sorts of shows. And thinking, wow, that really set you up for Doctor Human Show log. But to what, you know, to what extent, how are you approaching those sorts of shows where you thought I have an idea for a show. Or are you thinking, I've got an idea for a story and you can do it in three different ways.

What were your sort of stories? It's interesting. I mean, it's probably meant by setting Sen that I'm tremendously interested in quirky narrative structures. If people say, oh, negatively, all the movie, all these, full of tricks and traps, you never quite know what's going on half of this dream.

I've always had to watch in the film with that. Great time. It's coming from the rain. Awesome.

Stylover's often, as you say, bring it on. So I do actually, I love all that. I absolutely love it. And, you know, I do think on coupling, I might sort of formal experiments with narrative.

If something left off the poster. It could sometimes swamp it. And I did think, as it went on, I probably got better at making you slightly more emotionally engaged with the characters. I'd always worry about that kind of thing.

But I can't resist it. I can't resist any of that stuff. I love it. We did a nepsis, it was half of it.

It was in Hebrew. Most of the audience left, it has to be said. That was intimidating. I never had.

But again, it's holding your nerve, isn't it? It's holding your nerve as a comedy writer. You just go, trust me, trust me, just hold it back. Wait until you see the lights in the eyes.

Okay, go. Because people are so clever. That's the thing. The audience is so clever.

There's no possibility you're going to leave them behind. There's a possibility you might occasionally get out a little bit in front. But there is no possibility. They've already got three options of where this one's going to go.

There was a spell when I was doing it. Well, it's far too complicated for other people. That's what people would say. And you would come on by and say, well, I didn't understand the thing.

I'd say, well, eight year olds are doing fine. I don't know why you're both. But you know, we read in the main room the same time. Really?

Really do it. It's not something we have a problem with. We can deal with complexity. Very, very easy.

As long as the payoff at the end, which there was a point. You have to know why. I was discussing what enough flashbacks with Russell T. Davis, the other day and say, Flashbacks are great.

We've had disagreements with flashbacks over the years. I know it's something we started doing them brilliantly in the Jeremy thought, but three part of the perspective. And we were discussing flashbacks were, if you know exactly that it is a flashback. And why is flashback is relevant?

No. So you're absolutely secure. We're flashbacks. Well, you're not quite sure if this is a flashback.

And you're not quite sure why I'm having told this. I was fine where I was. That's horrible. That's confusing.

Not because you don't know what's going on, but you don't know why it's going on. You have to at least tell people a convincing reason as to why you have suddenly knit back in time to this bit. You may have lied about it. So long as I feel absolutely secure in what I'm being told now and when this happened.

I think it's deadly important. I do find that when I don't know how many scripts you read that are not directly relevant to the show that you're doing, but occasionally we read people's scripts and you do think, oh, you've tried to write some kind of mystery thriller. And actually that's going to fight the comedy because you've left so much. The audience is now worried.

One of my catchphrase is confusion is the enemy of comedy. And the audience can't laugh if they're confused. And if you're trying to confuse them, they're trying to make them laugh. Well, that's fine.

I think it's fine to confuse an audience as long as they know they're supposed to be confused. I mean, that's why you're meant to be confused with it. This is enigmatic, which means really that Doctor Who turns to the camera and says, I don't understand this either. And they say, oh, that's all right.

Doctor Who doesn't understand this. No, my job. But, you know, so mystery is fine. Anycomos fine.

But if you think, if you have this creeping sense, and I'm sure I've inflicted this on many audiences, was I supposed to get that? Was that? Is that a thing I was meant? I don't know if I'm in?

Nobody knew what the shadowy man was. Cool. I'm okay with you. Yeah.

Another thing I think is the enemy of comedy is ever splitting the joke at all, which is what you have to fight and sit on rehearsals. I'll make this even funnier by adding another joke at the same time. Yeah. And it never works.

No. You do a funny thing seriously, or you do a serious thing funnily, but you never try to do a funny thing funnily. Yeah. He just died, doesn't he?

You don't know which bit is meant to be serious and which bit is meant to be serious. Yeah, I guess he'll find himself saying in a technical realm or something to say. Well, that joke will only work if we've already given the audience copies of drafts two, three, and four. Yes.

I think we've attended at least two Jackrabs. Yes. So, yeah, no, that joke creep, especially when people around just sort of saying, oh, this scene doesn't feel funny. It's like, no, you've forgotten.

It doesn't feel funny anymore. I thought it was funny on Monday, but no, it's Wednesday. I'm finding it predictable. Well done.

If you're still finding it funny now, there's something wrong with you. Or you'll pull me a key archer who just laughs at everything because it's a wonderful human being. He works to encourage people. He's doing your show in Edinburgh.

It's just a good one. Oh, great. And we need to get him on this to show you to talk about it because he was like a bit of a mental figure for me. Yeah.

Of all people I thought would be going to go, I'll stand up routine in Edinburgh. He was the last. Yes. That's a good guy.

Yeah. Yeah. I'm looking forward to seeing that. I suppose my catchphrase is character and story.

You can't have one without the other. So, in the sense, one of the things that why your story's working the way that when we get scripts where people have written very complicated things with a ton of backstory is that we know we're so clear on the character. So, you can take that character anywhere. We know exactly who, I'm thinking again of coupling, we know those characters.

We get who your two main characters are straight away. And so, then everything that happens around them still happens in relation to the character. You have that even more so with a lot of characters. Curious with Doctor Who, which is a sort of evolving character.

Do you find with the different ones that you're kind of inventing new character aspects? Oddly enough I've been aiming the different doctors. No. Oddly enough you don't.

I was discussing this with Chris not long ago. The doctor is very much the doctor. I know we've had different doctors. I mean make a great fuss every time we bring in a new doctor.

This is an all new approach to Doctor Who. Secretly it's not. Secretly it's just somebody else playing it. And we've got a brilliant solution to our fairly central staffing problem.

But in fact each actor comes in and reflects a different way by the doctor. The doctor is intimidatingly unmoved by everything that ever happens to him. He pops back to her, Tardis. And Rush is often she has another adventure.

And doesn't appear to remember anything from the previous ones. That's why you need the other character. You need Bill Potts or Rose Tyler or Sarah Jensmith to actually live through the adventure. Because the doctor is kind of...

One of the things I was thinking for as a writer, this is sort of an interesting thing to have. It happens very rarely but I think it's happened with friends as well. Do you find as a writer that because the public are so invested in your show. And they have extremely strong opinions about it and there are millions of them.

Does that ever kind of intrude on your process? Yes, it hasn't until relatively recently. I mean I used to do really quite successful shows. But people weren't stopping in the street about coupling.

Maybe once every six months I would do that. I'll wait a second. Yes. I'll wait a second.

A bit like me. But you know, with Doctor who already being a... What has always been since 1963 and with Sherlock becoming very quick what we thought would be our little art house project on the side becoming this rock star of the show. Even more so people feel entitled to their version of that show.

And you are accused of arrogance because you say well no we're just going to do our version and you can do it. You're accused of arrogance for thinking that they shouldn't write your show. Which I always think. Actually that's not arrogant, that's my show.

You can go and do your show. Audience expectation is everything I was in it. Even just on a micro level. I was trying to explain to someone how I got into this position.

Trying to explain to someone the third act of your sitcom episode is taking all of the expectations. And you're trying to come up with an ending that is believable but also surprising and yet retrospectively inevitable. Exactly, that's exactly it. You're also doing it on a macro scale now with all the expectations of what the next series of Sherlock is going to look like.

So now your act one is sort of feeding into that audience expectation which must prove an interesting new challenge. I'm never quite sure how seriously we should take any of that because most of the audience watch it, like it and never think about it again. That's the honest truth. There is an expression often used about fridge logic which is that you watch a show you really enjoy it.

You watch the fridge and realize it didn't make sense. The only reaction any writer should have is they were still thinking about it when they got to the fridge. If you took that long to work out the doctor who doesn't make sense. How far away is your fridge?

That's an uncensical thing. But I think one of the differences is if you keep the audience in the palm of your hand throughout the episode, because they're just watching it, then that payoff works. It can be more difficult if you have a mystery extending over weeks where people get together and talk about their solutions to the mystery of Setta. One of the dangers of it, unless you're as brilliant as Agatha Christie perhaps, but even for her if you extended it over time, is that it's not that your solution will be disappointing.

Your solution will be fine probably. But one solution is nothing like as exciting as 400. Up until the point you nailed it down, there were 400 possible solutions and some of them are great, some of them are dumb and some of them are hilarious. And then suddenly boringly you had one.

That's not as much fun as thinking about it. Of course it's not as much fun as thinking about it. Of course mysteries are more mysterious than solutions. That's not something that should surprise any of it.

I think the glory of comedy is I don't think your comedy punchline would work over it six weeks. You'd have too much time to think about it and anticipate it perhaps. But the comedy punchline where things come together in a disastrous yet perfect way. When you realize that the impulses of the main character which have been delineated so carefully have led to their own downfall in the most hilarious just poetic way.

And everything goes perfectly wrong. Which is almost what defines that kind of comedy. In a drama you say nothing goes perfectly wrong. Things go nearly wrong or things go wrong or than you expected.

For something like faulty towers where everything goes perfectly wrong. You know you're in comedy land. You know you're in the not so much what really happened to Basil faulty. As what Basil faulty thought about thought afterwards could have happened if he hadn't got it together a bit better.

You know I was there that's the nightmare of a stress man. It's not the real story of a stress man. That gourmet night probably went well. That was a night.

That was that nightmare he had afterwards or before. You know what I mean. It's perfectly wrong. Everything just collapses in a glorious time.

Yeah and exists almost in its own world. Yes. As it's so often the way sitcom gigs never goes far away from faulty towers. And if you are very interested in faulty towers you can hear us speaking to Al Murray about faulty towers.

It's very very sick. If you join us on Patreon you can Google sitcom gigs Patreon and you'll find us. You can also find us on Facebook and Twitter. And also if you join us you can hear Stephen Moffat's interview without having to wait a week to hear part 2.

So do have a think about that. So until then, speak to you next time. Bye bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Sitcom Geeks?

This episode is 41 minutes long.

When was this Sitcom Geeks episode published?

This episode was published on October 11, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Sitcom Geeks episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.