Skip to content
Episode 92: Mark Hemingway / Nirvana episode artwork

Feb 15, 2021 2 hr 37 min

Episode 92: Mark Hemingway / Nirvana

from Political Beats Hosted by National Review

Scot and Jeff discuss Nirvana with Mark Hemingway. Introducing the Band: Your hosts Scot Bertram (@ScotBertram) and Jeff Blehar (@EsotericCD) with guest Mark Hemingway. Mark is is a writer at RealClearInvestigations and RealClearPolitics. Find him on Twitter at @heminator. Mark’s Music Pick: Nirvana Perhaps you’ve heard of these guys. With a single song, Nirvana knocked Michael Jackson off the top of the charts, essentially killed the hair-metal genre, and laid a blueprint that would launch “grunge” nationwide and influence an entire second wave of knock-off bands. Nirvana was, of course, more than just one song or one album. The three-piece from Aberdeen, Wash., first made noise with Bleach, released in 1989. Kurt Cobain and Krist Novoselic were present, but the band was still churning through a series of drummers, a merry-go-round that would end in late-1990 with the addition of one Dave Grohl, who has been featured previously on the show via his work with Foo Fighters. That’s the lineup which would create the iconic Nevermind, an album that some on the show argue owes as much to The Beatles’ brand of pop/rock than any burgeoning Seattle scene. “Smells Like Teen Spirit,” “In Bloom,” “Come As You Are,” and “Lithium” are still played on rock radio stations everywhere. Heck, Sirius/XM directly named their 90s rock channel after the latter song. Amid spiraling drug problems for their leader, Nirvana pressed on, releasing the caustic, abrasive In Utero and recording an iconic live performance for MTV’s Unplugged. That album would be released following Cobain’s suicide, which occurred on April 8, 1994. The argument is made on the show that it’s one of the best live albums in history. It’s a short, yet fulfilling, career and we cover all of it on this episode.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Episode 92: Mark Hemingway / Nirvana

0:00 2:37:50
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello again everybody and welcome into another edition of political beats a presentation of national review By the song Twitter at political underscore beats or find us on Facebook as well We invite you to subscribe to our feed for new episodes through Apple podcasts Google podcasts Stitcher tune in or go right to national review calm put on the podcast tab there find all of our episodes available Listen enjoy share and leave reviews also invite you to check out our patreon site patreon comm slash political beats You can help the show stay ad-free and just support our efforts Why not entry level for supporting and voting on episodes like this one which was voted on by our members Middle level for early access to do shows and higher audio quality and then the upper level our bestest friends with exclusive content once a month Remastered episodes through months with new entries and Spotify playlist a frequent request from our fans with our end-of-show choices all that at patreon.com Slash political beats my name is Scott Bertram find me on Twitter at Scott Bertram my tag team partner standing by as always Jeff Blair Jeff How are you? I'm just sitting around here bored damp be flanneled Waiting for things to happen, but you know whether it does or it doesn't it's really not that important I wouldn't get too excited nevertheless here. We are to entertain you now to be fair You'll be flanneled only because it's to in Chicago right now. I'm sorry I go I go by windshield it's negative Jeff on Twitter at eso tarrick CD and we welcome back to the program a guest from way back when a writer at real clear investigations and Real clear politics by the month Twitter at ham andator mark Hemingway is back on political eats mark.

Thanks for joining us Hey, glad to be back if you go into our archives You'll find our episode on the replacements a fine early episode in the program's history where mark was also a guest He returns today to talk about Nirvana we'll talk more about that in just a moment But mark the floor years to begin with as we ask you what you're doing over it real clear and how you got there? Well, you know, I do a number of things Journalist journalism wise these days, but my main thing I do is I'm a senior writer of real-tier investigations So that allows me to write sort of peeper died pieces on, you know various important issues and news I mean I've done pieces and everything from Iran to my last piece was about impeachment in the last year or so And you know I do enjoy that because I sort of come out of the magazine world I was at the weekly standard prior to working at real-tier investigations back for the late-quake weekly standard folded and then I also write for real clear politics Where I do semi regular column on you know just tends to focus on media criticism and What else I mean I write for lots of other places on the regular washing examiner law and liberty But that was obviously where my wife works and yeah, just stay pretty busy And mark you're running us today again to talk about a selection that was voted upon by our patreon members We said hey, what do you want to hear next and there are two artists that were right at the top and Nirvana was one of them It seems like it might be a short discography I mean the official releases are a few but there's lots to discuss as we get into this band and mark again We turn the floor back to you tell us why you love Nirvana how you got into them and why people should care about this music So I actually grew up in Oregon and Washington state and I graduated from high school in 1994 So you can imagine you know as much as you if you're old enough to remember what the sort of global impact of grunge was You know magnify that by about 10, you know considering that I was like living at the epicenter essentially I'm not only that I was in a band in high school at the time And you know I toured around the Pacific Northwest and it was just kind of amazing to feel like you know being from you know Worldish Oregon Washington you know to be at sort of the center of the world's artistic universe at the time It was a really strange and exciting you know thing I mean it really you know obviously made a huge impact on me You know and it was but at the time it was also interesting because it was very sort of you know I hate you sort of empowering but so it brings to mind You know the idea that you could you know the generation X thing was very much about sort of DIY and being defined by what you produce and create As opposed to you know corporate taste makers and things like that and for brief moment And I stress brief it felt like a good guys were kind of winning You know the idea that major music corporations would cut out records like Nirvana and Sonic youth and Dinosaur jr And you know the rest of the grunge that was happening in Seattle at the time really was like you know holy crap You know we're breaking through you know This is a world where you can get out there and do like really unorthodox stuff And we'll be picked up and appreciate it even if it's challenging For me Nirvana was a situation where I grew up. I was born in 1980 right I grew up in the suburbs now If you were born in that era and you were between the ages of 11 to 14 and you lived in the suburbs Nirvana was as unavoidable as you know sunlight or if you come from the Maryland DC area the 13 years to cater blooms the 17 years to cater It was just like flocked everything It blotted out the sun at that era and of course I have so many so many childhood memories related to Nirvana because you know my brother was into them We have it's funny. It's very rare that I could say at that early early time in my life before I was a music snob And you know as a collector that I had every single album in their discography bleach never mind and Seth decide in utero MTV unplugged we had them all all right And of course things got really bitter and really chippy between like the people who were fans of you know Nirvana and they were fans of Pearl Jam And they all hated one another in middle school.

This is the kind of thing that would start fights People were sent to the principal's office over this thing. This is not a joke I mentioned that back in our other Pearl Jam episode back in the day, you know what this was my personal Omaha beach frankly Um, that's a reference to a article that was just kind of went viral today on the 11th of February when we're taping It was the kind of thing that people had passionate arguments about and the funny thing about that is that uh between you know team Nirvana and team Pearl Jam. I was on team Phil Collins at the time Not proud of it. I've mentioned this in the past that like you know I was still listening to like pop and watching you know like you know number one hit videos and all that Um, but of course you couldn't avoid the influence of Nirvana because you know your first of all your brother buys That's my brother's a year old and a year and a half And so like you know down all of a sudden boosting out of the speakers in the basement you can hear Dontan, Dontan, Dontan, Dontan, Dontan, Dontan, Dontan And then you end up listening to all that music I think I got a little turned off by the bick with you Nirvana and also kind of uh by the um I think even when I was young even when I was like a 13 or 14 year old 15 I never really understood the sort of universal despair and sadness that attended Kurt Cobain's suicide Not like there's you know, it's not like you know his suicide isn't a tragedy But it wasn't like the world altering world shaking event for me that it must have been for people a little bit older than me So I knew all of that music.

I'd had all of it in my collection I'd listen to all of it But it never really made a major dent on me and I set it aside and in fact in later years I've also I've kind of enjoyed trolling or I I suppose the term in these days is posting on twitter about how like Anirvana isn't nearly as good as Pearl Jam. Heck, they're not even as good as Soundgarden for that matter Um and so coming back to them for this show. I've heard almost all of this music once already But I hadn't really given it a serious re-listen You know since what 1999 2000s so 20 years now It's the first time I've really reassessed Nirvana and I understand what everyone else saw in them and what it was that I was missing at the time because I've had so much time and that mean that span between those years to sort of add Extra musical context. I now know the meat puppets and I know mud honey and I know who's going to and I know all of the great early In mid 80s, you know punk and you know pop acts that never quite made it Like the replacements for that matter that had an influence in some way or another upon what Nirvana was trying to do I understand the nature of what the Seattle music scene was or you know, it's not just yet I was also like abradating for that matter, which is like nowhere is ville Washington It's like down on the the southern western coast of Washington I understand all that stuff that I didn't understand before so the music has so much more context to me now than I ever could have before I have to say this is not exactly a hot tape but Nirvana was actually a great band I know I'm really blowing minds here, you know with my crazy way out there You know arguments I would say that they are truly great band and I understand why people thought Kurt Cobain's death was a tragedy because you can only imagine what Could have come later on in this band's career because he didn't seem like he was falling apart musically at the end of his career I mean their final album actually thinking utero is the weakest of their three albums ironically enough But it's still a great record and you could just see more and more would be coming down the pike had he not committed suicide I think the one argument I will make against Nirvana and it was something that even as a child got to me But I didn't understand fully what I was reckoning with at the time is that you don't listen to this band for their lyrics It was why I always a slightly preferred Pearl Jam because whatever you could say about Eddie Vedder's ultra sincerity, which is not very cool Right, but you know he wrote texts he wrote actual songs that had meanings the lyrics were meant to represent certain images and tell a story There are very few Nirvana songs that actually hang together like that there are a few but there aren't a lot Most of this stuff is sort of like what sounds good coming out of my mouth and with these guitars hacking away behind me and you know Dave Grohl flailing away on the drums.

It's it's almost sort of like you know intentional gobbledygook You Your phrases that rhyme they sound good, you know, and albino Amulado and albino mosquito my libido it doesn't mean a thing it just sounds cool So I would caution those who maybe are skeptical of Nirvana or you know, God forbid if someone's listening to the show who hasn't ever heard them before Um, don't come to the band looking for the music you listen to this band because of the hooks and they were one of the hookiest Most magnificently great sort of alt hard rock songwriting groups of their era and that is where their legacy stands and falls And it stands proud to this day. I was deep deep into my classic rock phase when nevermind was released and Nirvana was breaking big And so my everyday radio listening habits weren't necessarily tied into the local all I guess what would be called the alternative station back then Although there probably wasn't an alternative station because Nirvana hadn't happened yet It was just you know the rock station And so my introduction to smells like teen spirit and and a lot of nirvana came via a friend who also was a big music fan But was a little more current with his taste than trying to go back and mine through, uh, you know, let it bleed or something like that And I remember him sharing nevermind with me And I liked it, but I couldn't say I was jumping up and down about it I think largely again because I was just so deep into sort of retracing the steps of rock and roll from years past I was more of a second wave fan of these bands and I throw a curl jam in there too and Jeff mentioning that I mean, I guess I can remember these deep arguments about whether you were a pearl jam guy or a nirvana guy And never the twain shell meet and I wonder if there were you know rolling stones beetles arguments back in the day too But I like versus and still like versus a whole hell of a lot more than I like the first pearl jam album And uh when it comes to nirvana, I was not really attracted to them, uh until in utero came out and Done that a bit more than I did at least on first listen the nevermind stuff of the nevermind stuff is so so timeless And going back now, you know, you sort of remember how brief a window these guys had of being what they were is essentially two years Two and a half years, you know post nevermind, which didn't I mean it wasn't a blockbuster out of the gates It was a slow riser for about four five six months or so before it blew up And then what from the start of 92 until mid-94 or so that and that's it and the legacy continued with the live albums and some work done by The band members that were still with us, but that's a very brief time to have the impact that nirvana had And something I hope that we can somewhat define over the course of talking about bleach and nevermind and in utero and what they did Is sort of gonna be putting a fine point on this statement phrase that always surrounds the band of course Which is you know that they changed rock and roll they killed Michael Jackson's dangerous album They took hair metal off the charts. It's all because of nirvana And if we can sort of take time I think in some of these discussions to sort of say why that was what made the different How do they sort of define or help to define the sound that was coming next and the the second third wave grunge imitators like bush or You know named your favorite mid to late 90s Grungy band I think that's a discussion we'll have throughout the course of this episode and talking about what made these guys special And why they were the ones that sort of break that door down It's important to remember that Kirk O'Bane was always really really deeply uncomfortable with this whole like oh you've changed rock and roll forever You're the voice of a generation kind of crap. He hated it And in fact if you go like you know read the liner notes to incest aside This is the besides in like rarity outtakes collection that they released which is really good We'll be talking about it Yes, you point out it's like listen like I just think of us as like you know a cheap trick for the 90s Like we're that band that was inspired by all those other bands And like we just like playing this fun music that reminds us of the music that we listen to when we were young that gave us a feeling of freedom So like it's important to remember that nirvana is the one that broke it big But they weren't the first and they weren't the only ones there You know like you know gish by smashing pumpkins We talked about this on our smashing pumpkins episode that I would come out like you know I think I got half a year before never mind it same basic style and of course It's interesting how Billy Corgan sort of like weaves his way in and out of some he ends up on some of the Seattle scene albums Even though he's from Chicago He ends up doing a lot of like Courtney loves stuff after Kurt's death and all that and I understand why now because I go back And I listen to the stuff and I find so many similarities between the two bands and the two acts even though they're obviously very different in other ways But you know it's just something to keep in mind that that coping never wanted this sort of you know He was never a megalomaniac he didn't he wasn't like Billy Corgan frankly He was he wasn't like a little like you know mini tyrant although they were you know Billy was huge and Kurt was a very short dude I think you know beyond that they had similar approaches and basically They wanted to just recreate the sounds that they had heard his kids growing up in the early to mid 80s You know and then especially in the later 80s with the pixies is coming up big I thought well I can do that too and of course they did So you both said interesting things From my perspective like one is you know Jeff saying that he had to sort of understand the full context of nirvana and you know And then that helped him really appreciate the band later on Obviously being a little older than both of you and from the Pacific Northwest at that time or whatever You know, I was kind of like, you know bathed in all of that context, right?

I got it immediately I mean of course it helped at the time that you know both Seattle and Portland had actually You know, obviously very robust local music scenes that had like you know a bunch of fantastic local bands And I've never wished never even made it out Of this, you know, seeing the time but you know was still beloved had this incredibly strong, you know, local music culture There was this, you know publication called the rocket that was like an alt weekly that was circulated all over the Pacific Northwest Like you pick up a copy of every you know records aren't it was like weekly or by monthly ever get You know that people were like rooting for all of the local music scenes and it was You know part of my thrill and fascination with their body was you know, I've listened to them since you know at least bleach So it was you know kind of you know funded like, you know, watch the rise as it were Even though you're right it did make you know coving deeply uncomfortable to like you know sort of attain that level As for what you both said to some extent about like the divides and music at the time That's a really interesting and like fascinating topic to kind of explore, you know, as Jeff points out you had one hand you had to sort of like pop You know, Bill Collins, you know era type You know, the pop music scene that was still very robust, you know, whether it was Whitney Houston or Phil Collins or whatever it was at the time And then you know on the other side of that, you know, what you were gonna listen to on the radio at the time was the whole classic rocketing And Yvonne is interesting because they somehow bridge all of those divides a lot of different ways And I think that was the source of what made coping very uncomfortable like You know, you mentioned bands like smashing pumpkins and pearl jam But those bands very much came out of a much more sort of classic rock in the case of Pearl Jam even like slightly hair metal tradition Um in a way that Nirvana did I mean Nirvana with their idols were all you know, at least locally with bands like the melvans You know more broadly bands like the proto indie bands like the meat puppets and you know, Minutemen and uh, you know, a lot of those punk rockers from the 80s And that was a very different musical heritage and culture than the more poppy and the more classic rock stuff And somehow Nirvana managed to You know bridge all of those divides I mean it had a lot to do with a slick production of Nevermind I think but it will what really, you know struck me in high school was You know, you saw this divide among clicks like in high school and it was shocking to me after years of listening to the cure and the pixies REM and I was up that all of a sudden I turned around and all the football players that were in the bandhailing and AC DC Were all of a sudden listening to Nirvana and there was a bit of resentment like hey, that's my music Not you're not about to have it because you know, you are all of a different culture that is doesn't you know appreciate what this is about Now you understand exactly how I feel when uh radio had suddenly became huge after okay computer And I was just you know, as only a teenager can be I was livid I was like you sons of bitches. That was my band you guys dismissed them. How dare you make them big I don't want to hear like, you know, the chalk listening to karma police and like bobbing his head along It's again, these are the sorts of things that feeling of your specific personal ownership over music is only something you have when you're a teenager Yeah, um that's true, but you know what happened to Nirvana was in on that level I was like times 10 compared to say what happened to radio head Radio the radio head first record got a lot of Nirvana comparisons just become the dynamics, you know alone the sort of loud quiet thing, right? Um, and you know their redheads first album got noticed and their second one got you know significant radio play So it was possible to exist at that sort of like mid-level Um and be that kind of band you know by the time radio head rolled around it with public honey came out 94 was that right?

92 92 okay, so it's a little early in my thought Um, but um so it was possible to exist at that level is a mid-level band playing that kind of music where prior to Nirvana It just wasn't like you were kind of underground Or you weren't And did not be underground you had to be in sort of a specific stylistic format you had to be classic rock Paramedel or some kind of like, you know, overt pop essentially I mean, I think that's right. I also think it's funny because both radio head and or both cited as their specific influence For their earliest albums. It was the Pixies and of course we've done our Pixies episode already Pixies of course kind of the the profit without honor They had uh, you know done all this stuff starting back in 1987 with come on pilgrim and then surf erosa and then do little and they Always had sort of like a lot of critical, you know buzz but no real commercial success And by the time they're vanna finally started, you know getting big in 1991 92 Pixies are already spent for us, but you're here just as you hear on creep, you know quiet loud quiet that that whole like style of you know Keeping up listeners attention by by by you know bringing it back You know and then coming forward was just an incredible violence That was the Pixies, you know basic aesthetic and uh so many other bands were influenced by it I just want to say you know one thing is the biography of these bands I always find it to be in most cases the least interesting aspect of it Just to set the scene briefly. Who are these guys right?

Um, it's not who you think necessarily at the beginning because everybody thinks of nirvana as uh, you know, Kirk O'Bane, uh chris nova salich and dave growl, but dave growl did not come in until their second album Uh originally it was the two high school buddies. It was Kirk O'Bane chris nova salich. They were in Aberdeen, Washington Which is as I emphasized at the beginning of the show is emphatically not Seattle It is like I guess closer to the capital olympia. It's like just a kind of a backwater It's like I think there's like you know 35 000 people live in the town It's not a big city by any means, um and of course, you know kobean had a pretty unhappy family life Uh and you know, he knew nova salich from high school.

They said hey let's start a band together eventually, you know chris said, okay Why not then they start doing demos and this is like in say 85 86 87 Uh by the time uh 1988 rolls around they have found their cells a drummer and that drummer's name is a guy that if unless you're a serious nirvana fan Probably haven't heard of name is chad channing I almost want to do one of those memes where they have like, you know, the virgin girl versus the chad channing except this time the chad loses Uh because although he plays on their first album and he does an incredible job in my opinion Uh kobean eventually got a little fed up with him and his inability to sort of you know, you know Keep on the ball, especially during live performances and fired him and then that's when they go find dave growl later But that leaves us with nirvana's first album the early era This is sort of 1989 through 1990 era Which I considered to be highly underrated and this is the stuff that when we I first got it Because everybody about never mind in 1992 right after it blew up every kid bought that album and they're like, I want more nirvana I went more nirvana and they're like, oh, they have an earlier album So you went and you bought bleach and if you were 12 years old and not prepared for that kind of music you were intensely disappointed Because it was just so much harder and which much raw edges than what of course their big commercial breakthrough was going to be I have to say coming back to it now and now with the experience of what i've already learned about music I think bleach is a hugely underrated album. I think it's their second best record Um now again, the lyrics they don't mean anything, but I think like the first five songs on that record Which is like blue is it like floyd the barber about a girl school, which I think is hilarious and love buzz Um, which is a goofy cover. I think that's not quite as good But but it is worthy of comparison to the first half of never mind with all those hugely famous hit singles and yes This is more abrasive. This is more sort of you know intentionally already material Uh, but I have to say god this holds up there are massive hopes on a song like floyd the barber There are abrasive edgy notes, but the hooks are there the hooks are there are almost all of these songs Maybe not mr.

must-action, but every other one of these songs has something to it that I would recommend Yeah, I don't think that's a particular controversial opinion among their bonnet fans, right? That bleaches their second best record, um, but but you know as you know, so many you know, even so many people have only heard they're two big major Label records and maybe in ses design which was you know put out on deafen Um, you know in between the two records although deafen didn't do much to promote that record They just kind of like threw it out there and that was partly a result that never mind actually turned out to be such a big record Like they had claimed that these eyes collection love, you know a lot of bleach era stuff, right? Um just to sort of keep the momentum going but the momentum was still going and the album was still cranking out singles And so they had this like record in the hopper that they'd planned to release, you know to buy the bands and find to put out a second record And the album was still going but it was it's it's a great record and in the sense that it does capture a lot of the things that were great about bleach Um, in fact, eventually there's probably a lot of people that have heard in ses design to have a bunch of bleach Um, but you know, who knows? I mean, I sound like blue that is a great opening salvo to nirvana's career I think it's everything that was nirvana was about you don't need to worry about the lyrics Those hooks are going to get under your skin And you know to some extent, you know, but that was a lot less serious than um, you know, I know you're your point about the lyrics or whatever But but there was a certain seriousness that underpinned a lot of you know in darkness even that underpinned a lot was happening I never mind, you know, you have you know, bleach just there's a much more of a sense of sort of like fun and whimsy or whatever and being young On that record and you know that sort of levity given that otherwise, you know crushing guitars and you know, um, you know Incredible dynamics.

I think does a lot for the band and what they're trying to do and if you appreciate that in context, you know I think it helps you appreciate never mind more Scott this bleach record as jeff mentioned Sort of provides a template right because there are there are really are these these hooks all over the place on a number of songs That provide entry points for the listener. Um, and that said I think jeff mentioned blue, which is a great song But I think there it's it's already immediate what the strengths are right? No the cell like space is anchoring that song rumbling very low I think you call it doom pop because you got to tune down another level curcovane's voice is strong Guitar player and I would disagree. I think chanting is like serviceable Fire He's the weakest part of blue right certainly There are a few songs on here like fluid the barber that jeff mentioned where there are the melvin's drummer sits in plays and The songs are pretty apparent that it's someone who's not chat chanting playing on those tracks Um, you you find about a girl on bleach Which is a song that was the first track on the unplugged album which would be a few years from now And that might be the most melodic moment on the album It's got a pappier tempo than what they would play later in the unplugged episode, but um Uh, it kind of simple.

So it's just mostly a two chord groove, but really powerful And uh, you know as jeff mentioned sometimes the lyrics don't mean much but when you have a song like about a girl And it's sort of about sort of ideal romance versus a reality romance And the lyrics are structured in a way to you know, sort of replicate the marriage vows all these I do statements I think we can take something from that. I think there's a little bit of work construction That was put in There are still some places in which I think kirk kobean is figuring out the best way to use his voice Uh that love buzz track that jeff mentioned is a lot of fun But I think it's not quite as not the best vocal right it's not the best vocal and there are a few places here where I think he's trying to Figure out how to use his voice. It's right. It's the first album.

They're still figuring those things out Um, so much scough Uh later in the album just lifts the drums from you know my shirona from the neck and even more than the drums I think there are a lot of similarities between that song and scoff there were varied influences on kirk kobean including some in places you would not Expect to find them like the neck Okay, by the way, this gets into a point that kobean himself made and I think it's really important It's sort of understanding the evolution of nirvana But yeah, that was totally lived from the neck and guess what kirk kobean liked the neck Which is not something you're supposed to admit because it's not cool right? But like you liked like you know good pop rock from the late 70s and 80s You didn't it didn't have to be like you know, you know, you know, esoteric like independent stuff And worth mentioning that love buzz was a cover Right exactly from an old Dutch rock band Right and and the thing about you know bleached I think you know kobean said it's like yeah I felt like we were kind of being forced into a style because it was released on sub-pop Which is you know the big the famous sort of now kind of like legendary? It's sort of like the way we think of twin tone records or something like that in Minneapolis Well, this is the Seattle's independent record label And they you know had a certain one call it a house style It's not like Motown, but there were certain sonic expectations for bands that were gonna be releasing music on sub-pop And kobean says like I felt like you know, he was actually quite the eclectistist He had a lot of well wonky pop, you know, you know, you know, you know impulses He loved like sappy pop music. He loved like, you know, you know goofy fun good times music But he felt like I have to like kind of put myself into this mode And so he sort of sharpened up and edited and sanded down the songs that he was writing And the hooks that he was writing to sort of get a tone and get an approach that would feel at home on a Seattle rock Independent record label, but the funny thing is is that him being forced to do that and that sort of I Oh, you call it sort of like it's a discipline.

It's a it's a it's an artistic discipline It's what creates nirvana because that's something that whether he liked having to do it or not Is kind of what would carry through for the rest of their career because you see that same approach You know, even though it's amped up to 11 on nevermind with all the very poppies, you know, very Immediate sonic production or even on in utero his love of mixing like, you know, clever fun pop hooks And memorable ones with like angry aggressive, you know, guitars and drums is something that whether he wanted to do it or not Is good end up becoming the foundation of nirvana and by the way, I don't think all the lyrics on this album are meaningless I think one of them that relates exactly to what I was just saying is a great song called school Which is hilarious, it's it's you know, you know, won't you believe it? It's just my luck It's just my luck. What is it? He's talking about it's just as luck.

It's just as luck to be being sent back to school You're in high school again. You're in high school again. There's no recess No recess and what is he talking about? He's talking about how it felt to have to sort of force himself as a square peg Into the round hole of the sub pop indie style You know, it's now we have to keep up with the scene and we have to like play the expectations Um, you know, obviously this is not something nirvana.

We're ever be accused of doing much of again in their career And yet who am I to say that it was a bad thing for the band as I said sometimes a discipline is a good thing for a songwriter And I have to say that's one of the reasons I like bleached so much I just think that it's it's obviously a prototype for the kind of music they would be making for the rest of their career But to me, this is the kind of music that I like I like angular weird stuff that has you know, catchy pop hooks Uh, but it's not necessarily gonna make the top 40 or maybe even the top 200 at any given time Yeah, that's interesting you talk about the pop books because I think you know again It was evident from the band style from the beginning in many ways It was kind of a more natural home for them Then you know being the big loud Seattle band I mean if you're sitting down with an acoustic guitar and you're playing the monestongs or whatever the clarity of the songwriting and the sort of skill Involved that whatever immediately comes through So I'm a little bit of a hack musician as I previously mentioned myself I just plain bands like it's hard and like that pop sense is really worth kind of like delving into like for instance The riff on smells like teen spirit is like from a music theory perspective like genius Basically the riff is an F chord to an A sharp chord to a G sharp chord to a C sharp chord And if you know anything about the chordal relationship or whatever, basically It's it's basically like he shoehorned two different progressions together like For air you have it you have the one and four of two different chord progressions except for the fact that the final chord is also the Fifth chord that would resolve the first chord progression I don't know if like that makes sense for this if you want to sit down but like the fret markers on the guitar that know enough That what I'm talking about but the point is is that covane basically took your standard one four five pop progression Which is it heard in everything from you know lui lui to um here? I go again by white snake with another example like that It's like the background like it is like the absolute quintessential, you know chuck berry One four five chord progression that defines rock and roll and covane took that and just growing like a completely off-kilter twist But it's still kind of a one four five progression resolving itself with an extraneous chord growing into just make sure throws your entire brain for a loop By introducing like a second chord progression. It doesn't quite resolve and it's just genius and it's very popping and intent Um and then like when you think about it from a delicious perspective Um he does this on a couple of songs and never mind where like the solo two smells like teen spirit is just the melody line that he sings And I know it's more like a great feat of musicianship to you know write a melody to write it's hard to load it's simply the melody line for the vocal But it shows that covane had a particular ear that went well beyond both the patience and skill that most bands That were just at the time bashing loud chords into you know loud amplifiers Um, you know, it's like punk rock like he he had an ear that was capable of you know picking out an actual melody that he had written And transposing that to the guitar like that was an intuitive thing that he could do and it really really shows like he had a fluidity and a vision At all times for what he was doing when he sat down to write with a guitar and that's why nirvana was huge and bands like the melvins Who I love them, you know, we're not Yeah, the discipline you had the discipline that none of these other groups really did I always think I sort of feel like the meat puppet should have been able to make it all that second album of theirs and of course nirvana did too As we'll see coming up, but like yeah covane just had a guess appearance. He was never he's not a formerly trained musician He just as he said, it's like I just sat down with a guitar and I hacked it out So we had a purely untutored genius for finding those innovative ways to sort of rewrite the standard chord changes Now scott do you have any final thoughts on bleacher?

Do we want to move on to nirvana up ending the entire universe? We probably can move on to never mind guess well They released a single in between bleach and nevermind but I don't know if we'll discuss it here or we can discuss it later on in Sesticide it's a song called sliver and I think it's just like stupid pop fun That's as close as I think nirvana ever got to like like a really fun goofy pop song even though it's still nirvana So it's you know, it's got a heavy approach to it. Um, it's a great tune. Uh, thankfully though It's not a obscurity you can find it on the on the b sides in the outtakes record So I guess really then what matters is that by the way, there's a lot of time between these records Which is interesting for a band like this bleacher's record acting mostly like 88 didn't come out until mid 1989 Nevermind.

I think the story of this is that they wanted to figure out who to do their next album with and then they went to uh Butch vig who is a great producer. He's from masson, wisconsin, you know the cheese head isn't that nice? Um, and so they're all there drinking spotted cows and recording the first version of nevermind these original songs and demos They're not really too happy with it. They're still on sub pop Uh, and they decided now we're not gonna go with this in fact We're gonna use this as a demo reel to try to get a major label deal, right?

And so they can they go hawk their wares and they get gefin records to sign them David Geffen savior and enemy to so many musicians throughout the years Uh, but they insist instead of like, you know going to get some celebrity producer They want to have butch fake do their real album with them so they go back In fact, they actually they don't go back to mass and I think they record it in california somewhere or something like that And they record like a small album of little repute uh called nevermind that as we have already said a couple of times on the beginning of the show Basically, you know was like an 8.9 on the richard scale in terms of the way it's seismically altered the terrain of popular music Who wants to go first offering their thoughts on this album? My god? I just spare a finding something new to say about it That's okay Their jump to the major label was kind of an interesting thing in the sense that one I don't think that that was expected of them in a lot of ways. Um, you know, they they they they met with the person responsible for What are two people helping responsible for them?

Sort of jumping from major level one is sonic youth who they toured with and uh, you know, Sonic youth have really taken a shine to them and like sort of seen what they were about Um, you know weirdly even though sonic youth are are in a similar vein. They're very different a lot of ways I mean sonic youth are like they're like literally baby boomers. They're so much older Um, and they I think got the pop craft aspect of what nirvana we're doing You know in terms of like their relationship with like a secure, you know, Dutch pop and other things like that in ways that I don't think They contemporaries did and they pushed hard to get the up and decide them and the other was that business manager for sound guard and alison chains They somehow knew was a huge help with them when they once they decided that they wanted to go Other major level route, but the other thing though is we got to remember like it still was kind of not cool to be on a major label Um, particularly the band, you know, making the kind of music they did I mean that suggested that they you know as much as cobain, you know, hated the limelight and all that other stuff that they were You know, very ambitious, you know, they did they really did want to go out there and write the songs that were going to You know change the world on some level and and they had some idea of what that was going to entail like Like I mentioned, yeah, they went to LA somewhere in record. They didn't just go to anywhere They went to sound city which was like one of these studios in LA We're like Tom Petty and Rick Springfield and all the other people were recording their records And like they did it up in like the whole sort of proper music industry fashion Um, and you know, they had some Regrets about that allegedly, you know, because which big it was an amazing producer as you mentioned, you know He's also in garbage And you know, the first couple of smashing pumpkins records and other things I mean he's a legendary producer at this point in time Um, they like working with which big and big, you know came out of the sort of the alternative indie world But the major label gaffin wasn't happy with the mix that Vix had done big it done So they called it Andy Wallace who is like the quintessential like hard rock guitar Do you think slayers produce I mean he's famous as a mixer like for instance everything he does sounds fantastic Like I hate Lincoln Park for instance.

I load them with a fire of a thousand sun But those records sound really good right because Andy Wallace makes them He has one Andy Wallace's interesting guy his one big production credit was he's the producer of Jeff Buckley's grace record Which is kind of plays against Hyperim because he's known for being a loud rock guy But he was he's the guy that's a fact what I just learned I would never in a million years. What did he do that? But but so big for produced what was he got great performances out of the band and again It really helped that you know, role is like maybe the greatest, you know, top five rock drummers in history I mean the guy is a human metronome with tons of energy and just a great great rock drummer Um, and so things were like clicking for them in the studio But Vix also Vix production of Nirvana like new them as you know another like fun idiosyncratic alternative band And the studio didn't like his mix and you can go online go to youtube and you can hear that Videos where they play like the original big mix versus Andy Wallace mix and like Andy Wallace came in and gave that record This just incredibly slick like rock and roll she that made it sound like a slick rock record as opposed to a you know obscure punk band or whatever from the Pacific Northwest and I think that had a lot to do with their success On the box set on the box set they have uh the butch big mix of smells like teen spirit And the contrast between that and the one that's on nevermind is just so obvious Like the thing what's the thing that you remember about the first time you heard smells like teen spirit No, it's just the opening riff, but it's not just it's the way girls drums come in But don't know but don't know but don't know it's just can and ball shots in your ears It's the most heavy massive sound you've ever heard and you don't get that on the original one at all That's exactly right and that was all the Andy Wallace I'm sorry i'm in part of that Andy Wallace man like i kind of what love that slick rock sound You know even when it's in the services, you know songs and bands like hey But you're actually right that was the other thing is that that can't be understated here was the actual like literal sonic impact of The recording of smells like teen spirit like the first time you heard that song somehow There's just like actual audio magic. I mean you're right the dynamics between that weird You know off-kilter opening guitar riff and rollcoming in those drums is so mind-blowingly heavy like to this day I don't think there are like there have been any recordings I've heard since you know, maybe it's because of the place in time or whatever I'm imagining but I think in some objective fashion of musician I can step back and say I have never heard dynamics like that captured On you know two-inch magnetic tape or whatever it was at the time.

I mean, it's just phenomenal sounding It is and that is a song. I don't know how long we can spend on it because it is so ingrained in our consciousness It's like satisfaction for the next generation The opening riff of satisfaction the opening riff smells like teen spirit the way girls drums kick in It's something that is so definitive the whole thing I I'm glad to tell you I went back to listen to the album And I have the tracklist in front of me and it smells like teen spirit is five is more than five minutes long Like I would never I don't know it seems like a three and a half bit of pop song It seems like a three and a half bit of rock song and it's 502 It's longer than I thought it was. I don't know what that means I guess it was a fish and it affected if I didn't think it was quite five minutes and like but it is Smells like teen spirit is great But you know this the song that actually really hooked me is in bloom Very much the same reason girls drums are gigantic and it's a huge upgrade from jet chanting on on bleach You know when you add one of the best rock drums of all time It will be an upgrade and and girl just punches through so many tracks on never mind He is such a key reason why it shines and the wall is mixed helps of course But you know you think of in bloom and I mean I just hear those massive Grohl fills that you know the drum roll is a sprint up to the chorus in that song That's almost a very grow you know the select sort of song the dynamic between the drums and the bass line in in bloom There are some real pop smarts That track and that's something you know listen again listening the whole way through a few times for the episode when you get to the songs And I know jeff will have some things to say about uh out of playing or drain you on that second half even lounger This is such a hooky pop rock album Okay, it's grunge. I guess I understand the labeling of that and how it became what it would become Maybe it helps that we have now 30 years of context to put to it, but Something about never mind is just so poppy It is it is meant to grab the listener and not let go and it takes you on a ride from the you know from the yeah Yeah, yeah, chorus of lithium You know again, I think drain you One of the best songs on this record, you know, cobanes vocals are sort of stacked three deep at times It's just a great great sweet pop rock song And that's what Andy Wallace did to this record to make it more palatable to the ear And this album went went uh went crazy.

It's sold like crazy, but there are just huge hooks There are big melodic shifts You have that soft loud dynamic that the band is well known for and essentially every song on this record Can grab you in a number of different ways and that's what makes it successful That's what makes it such a smash hit and such a big part of rock and roll history Yeah, it was kind of scuzzy and punky and and dirty sounding But it was really shined to a point where it was more about the the song craft and creating these songs That would be stuck in your head, which is something as old as rock and roll I wish everybody could have the same experience with never mind that I did and my and my experience with it is purely by accident And largely the product of my own pig-headed stubbornness Prior to booking the show, um and we talked about doing darvana for a jesus years now I think it's one of those ones that was been on the table as an option I the last time I'd listened to never mind was 25 years ago something like that It must have been like yeah, 97 96 up in high school in other words, right? And I figured I didn't need to listen to it anymore because I had all those songs memorized right because all those hooks are just lodged in your brain But going back just recently listening to me again was Literally a disorienting experience To go back and listen to the album and to realize that first of all you've known every one of these songs by heart since you were like Yeah, 12 years old But then to realize that every single one of them has an enormous Incredibly compelling and memorable hook and the reason you know that is that you're like Oh, yeah, damn I remember that and then all of a sudden you walk around the rest of the day and you're humming them to yourselves Is you're throwing your kid through the snow? You're like if you can't if you need I don't even care We don't have to breathe which is a strange thing to say when you're throwing your kid around Like shazam like you know, this is a classic example. Don't worry about the lyrics to winter varnissant We can buy a house.

We can build a tree. I don't even care. We don't have to breach shazam It doesn't matter. It's about that guitar with it Da da da da da da da da Speed rock stuff every single song this record literally every single song from smells a teen spirit all the way to something in the way is Great.

There are no weak songs I think that the weakest moment on this album is chris nova selich squawk Lee and off-key singing Shag powers is let's get together at the beginning of territorial pisses smile on your brother everybody get together I love that part. I love it too. And of course, and then this is a thing that coming back to it You know my head is slowed where I realized that territorial pisses when I heard that song when I was you know, 12 I didn't understand the context for it, but listening to it now It's so clearly a husk redo song it's by mole I talked in our husk redo episode that you never heard a guitar sound quite like bob molds on like zen arcade new day rising And all the sudden with bacterial pisses is like there it is there is that sound that shred and that speed it's clearly a like mid like 8485 euro husk redo kind of a tribute And I'm just so amused by how when I went back to hear this album for the second time We're back the second time, but you know the first time rather in like, you know a quarter century for me more or less I I I don't I give up. I'm no longer gonna try to resist it I'm no longer gonna try to complain about it.

I'm no longer gonna try to be a snob I don't even mind the production nirvana apparently didn't want to do another never mind for their follow-up to this album So they intentionally went with steve albini for in utero, but I love this sound And I also it's probably got obnoxious for them because every other band tried to imitate this sound So you got you know like you know all these these grunge imitators doing like the same kind of like massive drums overheated guitars You know ultra compression kind of a thing But you know when you have it more to songs as good as come as you are or lithium or stay away Or you know cobein is just shrieking his voice out. You know on stay away I don't mind. I think it's a beautiful album with not a single happy or upbeat song It's all ominous dark, but inevitably memorable pop grooves Um, I guess you know scott did mention this the one thing i'll say is that yeah on a plane might be my favorite song on the record Um, which is not to like down on you know breed or lithium or poly or in bloom or anything like that But I like on a plane because that is that might as well be a john lennon You know 1968 beetle saw that that to me feels like it could be happiness is a warm gun Basically it has that same sort of a harmonic and melodic approach and a vibe to it And I even love those little backing vocals by the end by the end by I think it's girl who's singing them But the way that the song fades out and the backing vocals still keep carrying on that's such a beetle pop moment That is not a like a punk or a hardcore moment that is straight up tribute to pop sensibilities and pop stylistics And uh, yeah, it's all over this album Remind away in my life and I'm glad it's back in it Um, I just I want to make a couple of observations here like when is we talk a lot about like covane songwriting and yes I mean well a huge part of my success is that he was incredibly talented, you know guy who wrote very durable songs But when I think durable what I mean by that is like they were so melodically well composed that allowed for um What so great about nevermind which is to say that you know, there's so many hooks that are sort of packed into this Like you can take each drum part in each baseline, you know separate from the song and they are you know memorable catchy You know phrases on their own and then they come together in the service of a much larger thing And that is what really makes a great albums that you can sort of pick them apart on that musical level Where like everything is hooked that comes together in the service of a larger song and I think Nirvana does that in spades here I mean it really does help that you know, I mean, I don't think I'm saying it's crazy here But like far and away the worst musician in the band here is curcovane It's not say he's a bad guitar player can't pull off what he's trying to do He certainly does but I mean they've rolled a phenomenal drummer and christmas have a lot of sense You know just to have come up with these, you know straight ahead bouncy baselines that like perfectly certain song You can't see enough good things about the sidemen here and you know, unfortunately, Nirvana a lot of ways have become the curcovane show Now secondarily to what um, uh, you were saying about how you know, this is you know, a lot of these songs are sort of like negative And I totally get that but what's interesting about this record and I also think space with success is that they It exists in this nether world of this like strange space where yeah, there's a lot of like negative and dark songs that all somehow Involved catharsis so you're listening to a lot of like, you know angry songs that somehow make you feel better when you're done listening to them Because it's a start. It's not like a downer.

It's not like negative and like, you know of some kind of like weird heavy metal sense It's meant to be crushing it you it's absolutely cathartic Yeah, I mean I think of a song like comment as you are which of course has that that sadly now immortal a middle-late Where's like and I swear that I don't have a gun of course that took on a whole completely unintended meaning later on after curcovane committed suicide But you know that whole melodic progression there, it's all dark and murky and mysterious and unfortunately I must say it is totally ripped off from a killing Joke song, which is another thing I would never have realized back in 1992 But I'm a big killing joke fan these days and so I totally understand how they're kind of pissed off about how it cribs that the basic idea of 80s Which is one of their great classic mid-80s songs But yeah, the thing about it is they still keep the sort of I don't know the melodic and harmonic sensibility is still positive simply because You can sing all of these songs and the murk never captures it It never ends up suffocating in its own darkness like a song like lithium actually Isn't that basically to the extent that any of these songs have any lyrical like true through lines Isn't that basically about like you know, I found religion and that's great for me because that will keep me mentally sane This is my lithium basically in other words And I don't think Kobe meant it in an insulting way I think he meant it is like you know Some people really just do need to have gotten their lives so that they can keep the darkness away And that's always the way I've interpreted that song. I have no idea whether I'm wrong about it or not But yeah, it's like a dark song with that horrible that angry screaming chorus Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, but I don't actually take like a sad vibe away from it It's I mean if you take some kind of darker depressing lyrics and put them to most Instrumental Beatles tracks. You're not gonna come away dark and depressed generally because that craftsmanship is so strong Melodies are so strong. They still are buoyant in a way And I think that's the comparison to bake here is you do have in many places this negativity or dourness world weariness Call it what you will in the lyrics and even in the evolical delivery in places, but the songs are so good and again It's hard to sort of draw a straight line, but somewhat Beatles asked Jeff mentioned not a plane Is very people says there are a number of places where you make that comparison.

I think it holds true But those songs are so strong Songpolly sounds like I'm so tired off of the white album, you know, I think of John Lennon up at 3am You know just sort of muttering like I'm so tired And then I think of all he wants to crack her of course That song has got a really dark backstory behind it and notably that they had covered in many different ways I think that one dates back to the bleach sessions They usually they usually played it like a big up tempo electric song And then for whatever reason I think Cobain just decided to take it up as an acoustic number But those nagging backing vocals in the chorus they just they stick with you these these they're almost like It's going to a minor to diminish to a minor It's such an impressive act of pop songwriting But you know not in the way that we think of like tears for fears sewing the seeds of love pop the hooks are there though They really are So So the question is does anybody have any final thoughts on nevermind or do we move on to wait We're not going to move on to in utero. We're going to move on to their b-size record Which is which is kind of an odd move I always think about an album like this as the album that a record label puts out when they don't have any confidence that success will be repeated Right, I just kind of think of uh, you know, Ben Foltv and whenever an enem And a light kind of Right, I'm not sure they can replicate the success of the park charts Let's let's get while the gettin's good and do naked baby photos and put that some unreleased and be side some life tracks Seems like it was clearer that nirvana was going to have a future of some sort after nevermind And yet until we get in utero we get this incesticide this again collection of though Go ahead mark I was gonna say I don't think the future at the time in the band was as clear as you think it was Yes artistically and commercially sure But the question was is you know was the band going to self-destruct because of Cobain's heroin addiction And according love entering the picture and all the other drama that was going on at the time Did they have a bit royalty dispute as well? I think about like going back to right The band of us broke up basically because um cobain basically demanded a much larger share of the royalties because once he realized what publishing was all about You know the the royalties were being split evenly and he was like, hey, I wrote all the songs and lyrics And the funny thing is is that that no bizelik and uh, bro were cool with him taking a much larger share of the royalties But the problem was is that cobain insisted that he wanted all the royalty money retroactive to the release of Nevermind So if you basically wanted to take money away from them that they already heard Um, and so that's what caused a lot of drama in the band You know plus the drugs for the love and then there were a couple of other ancillary factors here But the beside collection one is that um grunge blew up into a global phenomenon like just it was just truly massive by 1992 I mean like you know fashion designers had you know supermodels, you know walking down the capwalks wearing, you know flannels and stuff It was it was so crazy in omnipresent time. It was truly the most unfortunate era for fashion I think I love the music, but then my god, I don't know how you could like that Well again as somebody who grew up in the in the Pacific request who understood what was happening there, which is that you live in a damp rain climate and you're fishing old Pendleton, you know, we'll ensure it's out of the bins at the thrift store because that's what's comfortable to wear in that environment Right, nevermind that they're produced locally.

Um, you know, it was it was a strange thing to be adopted as a uniform Well, in fact, it was just what people wore out of custom locally Um, but anyway getting back to this Um, so so the demand for anything grunge was already huge so anything they put out was going to be like snatched up right Um, and then on top of that you have a situation here where um Uh, um, um, gaffin bot and their body out of their contract at sub pop, right? So, you know, a lot of these songs were from the sub pop catalog and so it was like really mutually beneficial for both record labels To take basically a bunch of pre-existing songs that were out there, um, and just throw them out there and just, you know, pure profit from that point in time They didn't have to deal with any bands, rama, you know, they didn't have to spend, but they didn't have to put them in a recording studio for months at a time in LA Where it was, you know, they're gonna run six-figure tab and it was just it was just a no-brainer essentially Um, but what is true is even though they planned that like as I pointed out the moment earlier the momentum for nevermind was like so huge at this point in time They didn't even though it seemed natural to like put out the record they were kind of shocked they were around late 92 with the album having come out in what was it September of 91 that the record was still like producing new singles, you know, that were getting major radio play So it kind of got lost in the shuffle. I mean, I think nevermind is certified diamond and it's just the side only went cold or something like that But um, I mean it did make a big impact and every kid I know we now thought it. Yeah, we had it too And I have to say I really like this album a lot is of course It's much more similar to bleach than it is to nevermind and so it was a bit of a shock when we got it We didn't know it was like a B-size album the same that we had described the similar phenomenon when we did a smashing compkins with Pisces You know, okay.

Why why are this smashing pumpkins doing a fleet with back cover? And what I didn't realize is that there's a BBC session and this album also has a bunch of BBC sessions on them But they're all great, you know, they're really great. I love the version of a poly that they did at the BBC I think it was back before grow even joined the band and you know, it's the up-weight the up-tempo electric version But the thing ends with this this song called aneurysm Which is very close to making my top five at the end of the show I'm not sure whether I prefer this one or the actual studio version which can be found on the box set But just like another one of these completely thrown away never on an album Not even officially released is a B-side to the best of my knowledge songs This record is one of those great little sort of dumpster dives where you know, yeah, you know, some of the covers I don't think Molly's lips is that great But they throw in sliver there and dive and stand to start the album off And then you realize like yeah, no, Vanna was a band that didn't just have its album tracks They had a real depth They had a real depth and these are secondary songs but secondary only in the sense that they haven't been polished to that sort of diamond-hard Yeah, this album is like a result of what you have when you have sort of lightning in the bottle here Like this is a place where you know, Nirvana and both as you know, the avatar for a little phenomenon And in addition to their own incredible songwriting they can kind of do no wrong, you know And you're right in a lot of ways this record is disjointed And you have the BBC sessions you have the the kitty pop covers of the Vaseline's like, you know, Molly's lips And then you have these you know, you then you have like dive which is you know, them Like trying to personate the melons or something like that and then you have the fun poppies that like silver It's kind of over the map. Oh, you know, arrow's definitely in light of our previous conversation where That's a great song where but but it's just funny in light of what we were talking about I was talking about the classic rock divide right because the title of that song is not an accent There's like a weird galloping riff in that song that there's no doubt that the reason why the song is out of that was because it reminded them of Aerosmith and Zeppelin riffs.

There's just no question about it The box set begins with their cover version of heartbreaker And it's hilarious because like somebody in the crowd shouts out, hey play heartbreaker And then I think it's no facetelicus like I don't know how to play that song They go pages starts actually playing the riff because you know, it's out of play and then they do another like version of like, you know Like a jam that turns into Moby tick So like yeah, it might not have been cool when we met up, but they were huge zep heads Yeah, but yeah, it's weird because there's nothing stylistically holding any of this together and yet It's kind of a joy start to finish It's really interesting in that regard, but you know again, that's like I said, it's that lightning the bottle And I'm you know, like you mentioned pysys to scare it. So it's a very similar vibe I mean, I'm sorry, but like brown is probably my top 10, you know smashing pumpkin songs, you know, right? It when you know a band is firing and all cylinders like that It really allows them to branch out and you know, just do things like this You know, let's just release, you know what we're working on because you're gonna be interested because they're definitely onto something Maybe it's not never mind level good, but you know damn if it ain't you know, we're listening to There's a handful of I think really early songs dating back to like 88 Teresbury queen and next-gen seafood Eresepeline is one of those ones I like Eresepeline the rest. I'm not sure about I think those are the weakest parts of this of this collection But there are some I mean it might not be a totally necessary album But there are necessary tracks and some of them have been heard before as Jeff mentioned slipper had been released a bit ago That is again, not to echo what you said, but that's a ridiculously fun song It might be the most kind of joyous, but but certainly fun song in their collection Here at I mean there's no there's no coincidence, awful lot of the pixies in slipper, of course That version of been a song that's on here, which I think is also from BBC Sessions It's really good.

I mean that really that really kicks and they cover they cover divo here as well And you know, so many comparisons also with smashing pumpkins And you know, we talked about Billy Corgan's love of the neck earlier and I'm sorry Curcouvain's love of the neck earlier and Billy Corgan would say you know cheap trick was his band and cheap trick covers You know new wave, Alice Cooper with clones on a later album and you've got Nirvana covering divo of all bands here with turnaround and I think they nailed it They nailed it, but the bass line on that for some reason that might be my single favorite chrysno Right sort of like blue which also kicks off that particular album But you know low and heavy but still throwing off hooks left and right. There are certainly things that should be heard here But again, there are a few pieces most of the very early stuff. I think prevent it from being a truly necessary record I mean again, it's sort of like pixies a scary it's not a necessary record for the smashing pumpkins But you wouldn't want to be out without a copy of starla or you know or that landslide version I think that if you like Nirvana, you definitely need to hear sliver When stain and dive and you probably want to hear that arrow Zeppelin song too and an aneurism My god, you need to hear that song But it was just again a candy marking time option for the band because after the huge global success of Nevermind And then of course the the burgeoning problems that we've only sort of indirectly referenced here of kirko bane's heroin habit Which is something that I guess, you know, I didn't really want to dwell on this during the show that much But it is kind of impossible to avoid because it obviously bears hugely upon the end of the band's career You know kirko bane didn't just suffer from depression you suffered from a slowly acquired But that's always the most insidious way of all a slowly acquired and eventually kind of overwhelming heroin addiction and You know, she had a chronic painful stomach condition as well Yeah, don't help the heroin thing whatever because I think they made it a little better But you know, I don't again, I don't know much one of these well with other but I'll just gonna mention here that I was at I saw Nirvana on January 1st 1994 down in Medford, Oregon Which was gosh like a third or fourth the last show ever And it was depressing. I mean he had no energy the band was just going through the motions I mean it was so different compared to you know the earlier phase in their careers when you'd see them And it just it really really did take a poll Yeah, it's it's sad But it gets it has to be mentioned because you wonder why they're so such long delays between their albums Well, some of it is sort of creative indecision, you know, I decided to not repeat oneself to figure out what the next Way forward is supposed to be but a lot of it also has to do with you know Kurt's demons and they were very real And of course we all know how the story ends But what's important for this you know for this section of the show is is how they decided to follow up How do you follow up nevermind?

Number one hit album as he said, it's diamond it went 10 times platinum which makes it diamond And it's you know, it gets sparked a musical revolution and now you're the most important people in the world, you know, okay You went to the MTV music awards. You've gotten to fight with axle rose backstage You've had all these these great moments But how are you actually going to do an encore to that? And so what they decided to do is they wanted to get Steve albini who I will insist is my least favorite musical Person of the rock era and it's not because I dislike his work I think his production work is almost uniformly superb I just think he's one of the biggest pricks in the entire music scene I said this on twitter last night is I dare you to read any interview given by Steve albini from 1987 to maybe the year 2000 Did not want to punch him in the kidneys because he's so smug he's so arrogant He's even arrogant about our vanna. He's like, yeah, I listened to nirvana and you know, they just seem like they were just purveyors of you know No more interesting purveyors of that typical generic Seattle sound than any other group that came out of that region I'm sorry my favorite thing about albini is he will go on at length whenever asked about how much he enjoyed recording bushes razor blade suitcase Great guys they were um now.

I don't know whether that's a comment on you know the drama involving so many of the other bands I mean I suspect that you know recording in utero with Steve albini in the room and their bonnet with other problems is not a terribly pleasant process And I imagine that affected um what what came with with that I would say I would say that mark, but okay listen after the pixies went from surfuros that's a record do little with another producer He called do little the album do little for god's sake. He called it like sell out pop crap All right, he finally apologized for it like 20 years later, but my god would jerk I'm entirely with you, but I would also note that I do think that seagull bini has finally like grown up a lot in the last You know 10 to 20 years and has a much more Much more staying you know view of things and how he goes about things and you know, he has apologized for a lot of this stuff It only took him to reach 15 He's finally reached maturity. Right, but but I so I will say one thing that is one thing about this You know, I'll buy anything that you raise. I was you know, I've been doing a lot of you know deep diving into banhaylan because I play guitar And I'm not I was banhaylan wasn't a thing I was interested in growing up and now I'm more interested in doing it But one thing that's interesting that mark rock and roll from its earliest days I think on through well kind of the nirvana era was when this stuff kind of started to stop was rock and roll was very very competitive And so some extent that was a good thing There was a lot of flagging of other bands and other things like that the whole point was to like you know If you were the opener you wanted to make the headliner look bad and stuff like that to like prove your work And I think that kind of like animus to some extent And competitive spirit like pushed a lot of bands, you know to do better and in the studio Yes, the albany was a jerk But he would you know he would run into the you know the recording room and yell at bands to do better You know and get better performances out of them because you know, even though he was a jerk He was a jerk because cared about this stuff, right?

Right, you know more than a lot of corporate rock producers at the time in the 80s who were you know, just you know picking up jacks And you know at the same time, you know, it was interesting When their vanna came out and then the whole alternative thing like broke wide open There was a lot of like angry like, you know comments from like the traditional classic rock guys I mean Steve Luther her famously went out there and like trash Billy Corgan and the smashing pumpkins Again, Lutherton subsequently apologized for this a bunch of times I've never really corked in the time like snarking back but the best rock riff I'd ever written was hold the line I'd chef my mouth but that that kind of like competitiveness was Was a very much a factor in rock. It was very much a factor in revolving the explosion of grunge and why it was so impactful You know, and but also I don't know I mean I think to some extent these snippets that's kind of make and you know Provoked these arguments in rock and roll that what we do here It's fun for us to like discuss the relative merits itself And I almost wished it, you know artists these days to be you know a little more dramatic Sometimes because it makes things more interesting if nothing else you know I don't know how to go and become the blows but it's definitely you know part of the thing we like about rock and roll Yeah, and so albany produces in utero with the band in the middle of nowhere's ville minnesota Which I do like apparently it said it was like I think it was grow or maybe it was no vacella Like it was like being in a gulag in a Siberia because it's like, you know the middle of winter It's like snowfall everywhere. We're trapped. There's nothing we can do I think their instruments didn't even arrive on time So they just have nothing to do except sit around for the first like four days or something like that And uh, they record in utero without buying out, you know in the frozen northern wastes of uh minnesota And what do we get we get an album that this is one that I think I think seriously car corona van fans all say this is their greatest achievement This is their best album I'm I'm you know, I still got a bit of the the hot taker within me and also I think this is the weakest of their three student EL albums I don't think it's bad by any means there are a lot of great songs on it But there are actual for the first time there are songs on this that I have no time for like I don't like milk it at all I've never liked penny royalty.

I think it's as far as like a commercial song that was supposed to be a single I don't think it's very good radio friendly unit shifter is I love the title. I love the title so much Which because for those who aren't aware of like, you know industry jargon, you know, that's be like oh, yeah This is one because it's gonna sell a lot of units. It's gonna move a lot of units So this is a radio friendly unit shifter and I guarantee you this is not what a five minute long hard rock song is Tourette's I don't I think this the back half of this album is really weak I know it starts so strong with service servants and then sent less and a heart-shaped box and it ends with all apologies But I think there is a there's a span on here in the middle that I think is maybe just them being a little bit too intentionally abrasive and forgetting about What made Nirvana Nirvana was the fact that there were always these great hooks hidden in the middle of their songs But again, that's me hot taking over to start the conversation what you guys think Well, I can't believe I'm saying this but I think I agree with them here everything you just said Jeff No, second time you said that once on the replacement set as well Well, maybe it's not as much of surprises. I think I'm still used to your Twitter hot takes um, but yeah, um, I yeah I think you're pretty much diagnosed this record.

I think Tourette's in particular might be like the week one of the weakest songs in their catalog, you know Um, and it comes, you know right at the back end of you know, and already kind of I kind of like any royalty Um, but yeah, there's there's a lot of stuff in here that um, you know, I Don't know. I mean it's it's mediocre at best and there's some absolutely great stuff I mean, there's no doubt that you know all apologies and heart-shaped box are great great songs Um, but it's also true as you point out that you know working with albining, you know, it's always a bit of a crapshoot Um, you know, they were obviously having you know, lots of problems as a band. I mean, all this stuff shows It's just not nearly as cohesive in a lot of ways Um, and this record is kind of like the reverse of nevermind where they get done recording this and albining in his famously raw recording techniques and stuff Like that to some extent that that benefits the band, but you know for a large extent it doesn't and they the band themselves were supposedly unhappy with the final product Which is why they called in um scott lit who was you know, a big producer for ream and a number of other, you know, more polished alternative bands to come in and you know, basically fix, you know, a number of the singles like heart-shaped box and all apologies and stuff And what did albining do? This is classic Steve albining move.

He refused to send the master tapes to scott lit at first He said no, nobody touches my recordings. They are what they are He had to be like, I think like, you know, I think nova celica girl had to call him and listen to this like apparently it was like intense conversation Which I imagine was something more like listen to son of a pitch give the tapes to that this is our album for god's sake Yeah, that's that's that's that's Steve albining of the 90s Yeah, and scott lit is a great producer and a great craftsman, you know, he's worked on some just absolutely fantastic records And you know, I think I think his work was appreciated here, but yeah, I mean, I don't know It was kind of amazing to me and again when I talked about how that moment where felt like the good guys in the music industry were winning There briefly this is kind of in that window where people thought it was a good idea to have Steve albining producing in a major level records Which you know, I mean I actually love um surfa rosa. I mean, I love the production I love everything about that record, but it's it's kind of a happy accident in that regard and to trust albining to record an album, you know, a Band that's this poppy, you know, with his particular issues at the time I don't know what everybody involved was thinking to be honest So I like the album I guess better than both of you and I really don't mind Um the production I like a lot of things that he's done through his his career and I don't think it's I don't think it's a weak point here I don't think it's a production Scott. I just don't know if the songs are up to par.

Yeah, and I will agree the back half Yeah, this is a intentionally rougher sounding record right at some point after never mind Cobain I'm not sure about the other Cobain for sure was crap out from time to time Saying that's that's not exactly how rich it sound They wanted to go a different direction with the production. They wanted to go a different direction with the sound in utero But uh, there's no there's no reward for making it through right your reward for making it through most of in utero is is Is uh Tourette's and radio friend of you that shifter essentially and those are some of the most abrasive noisy Yowling songs you could imagine those things crop up earlier something like set set less apprentice where Cobain is just screaming go away and you know, he's way into the red he's way over modulated in the in the mix Um, that is that works that works right there early in the early on that works and it's a it's attacking A definition service which I think is a really great song with a great course and I guess some of the more personal lyrics If we can assign them right I tried to have a father, but instead I had a dad Uh, just want you to know that I don't hate you anymore. There's nothing I could say that I haven't thought before There's a little bit of stuff there a little bit of Cobain there more than we usually get on some of these lyrics Um, I like dumb. I think that's no dumb is great dumb is one of the best songs on the album dumb is again Almost that reminds me of on a plane.

It's their their beetle pops on for this record Yeah with probably his best bridge you ever wrote, you know, this is on fall away. Uh, that that part that's a great bridge Dumb is um a great song and you know, I think the lead single heart shakebox I think it's one of the most accomplished writing efforts of cobain's career. That's a really well-written song I like it and a lyric too. That's actually yeah, very good.

Yes. I mean this this idea of sort of a weary Helpless person in a relationship, but then you know breaking through on the chorus. I love this even back then you know, hey wait I've got a new complaint. Uh, I think that's one of his most accomplished writing efforts I'm not a giant fan of rape me But the way that he sort of turns inside out those opening chords of smelt like teen spirit in service of another song I guess alive occasionally they would sort of tease the audience by playing the chords and then getting right into writteny instead of smells like teen spirit And I guess one specific song I would I would say I like apparently a lot more than jeff is milk I do like milk and I think it's uh, I think it's one of the best examples here of sort of the shift that they wanted from the production I think milk it would fit fine on nevermind, but it would have a very different production set on it And this is the more updated or at least updated for their requests on in utero Um, and then I guess we gotta talk about all apologies, which is the last Recorded song and album proper until the greatest hits effort down the line and it took on life of its own after the unplugged Edition, which we'll talk about in a bit.

That's a really great song too. I guess that's that's a song to me that that sort of emphasizes what You know the guy probably gets the least attention in nirvana is christen ocelic because obviously kirko ban is kirko ban and then they have grow One on to do the Foo Fighters, which are still huge to this day The baseline on all apologies that opening the way it duets with the guitar that is one of the most sort of menacingly But also beautifully effective moments of nirvana's entire career Again, that goes exactly what i'm saying about how like a musicianship there especially from the sidemen gets, you know Short shrift and it really shouldn't um, I think what's interesting about this record is you have to kind of like step back and look at it in sort of the Larger context, which is to say that like I totally agree with Jeff about you know, it has you know distinct failings Um, however, what's it's ultimately an incredibly frustrating record because you know It doesn't take much imagination to see this in a larger context Which is to say that after the massive success of nevermind Which the band is like clearly like reeling from and trying to deal with and incorporate into this sort of like artistic vision They happen themselves to the point where they're like towing with some, you know, turning, you know Smells like Kingsbury inside out musically otherwise with the song rape me like they're messing with listeners expectations and and going with steve Byne and they're proving that they're independent and they still have these like punk rock abrasive roots And they're they're gonna, you know stay true to those roots They clearly felt like they had something to prove with this record that they weren't going to be like pop sellouts or whatever Um, and so you can imagine having gotten through this record Cobain hadn't killed himself that the next record would have been One coming from a place of confidence like okay, we've proven to people we're gonna do things on our own terms So we're really for real now going to do things without expectations And it just kills me because you feel like the follow-up record watching this sort of trajectory Which you know mirrors in some respects other bands trajectories where you know they're trying to prove their artistic independence They would have been in a place like a healthy place artistically off to this record where they wouldn't have had the expectations You know because they had thrown them off a bit with the last record They could just go out and do what they wanted, but you know, they never never got there So that's why it makes it really magnifies the failings of this record for me and makes it frustrating to have to you know, grapple with them I I think you know, rape me of course Just saying the song title. I mean, I you're obviously grasping the nettle You're taking the challenge that the band wanted you to take Uh, this is the song that famously saw George w bush shatter his daughter jenna's copy of in utero Uh, this is a true story that you know, you know, you know, dubya You know found this in his daughter's cd collection and saw the title track and he's like you're not gonna listen to this crap But he snapped the cd in half, right? Which is hilarious.

Although the song is obvious. It's not about that It's obviously it brutally, you know, you know, you know, of course skatingly and indictment of you know, you know The male gaze and the idea of you know, you know, you know, obviously rape and sexual assault But yeah, you know that that's blunt and putting it like that is dare guaranteed to put people off But then there are smaller songs in the sound that don't have a good talk about that I think I really love france's farmer We'll have a revenge on Seattle. I don't know why france's farmer's gonna have a revenge on Seattle I suppose the hollywood, but I love that song It's another one of those sort of quite almost bliss like songs that has a bunch of little hooks They're just hidden away in it and you don't realize until you've gotten through the song and you're like, oh, man That's still lingering in my head. Yes, I'm relaxing Yeah, that's right.

I'm just got already mentioned. I like very eight, you know, it's not a great song But it's amusing, but yeah, we all agree about you know that the back half of this album that you know from there until all apologies There is a certain discernible quality drop off here Um, I don't think that that meant that the band was done in any way necessarily despite of course Debands, you know addiction problems and I think obviously psychological issues and uh, you know All the other sort of pressures that were you know, you know, knowing at the band and I think the clearest evidence of that is It's not the last album they released during their lifetime sadly because it came out posthumously But this is sort of what most people consider to be like the end of nirvana their official terminus, which is a live album It's mtv unplugged. It's um, yeah I just want to make a point of order here about the fact that kobe did in us in a manner of speaking You know since you mentioned frances farmer, I've always understood that to be kind of a bleak reference to court You love who kind of like identified with her, um, but you know the whole the holes lived through this record Uh, I mean demos have since surfaced that a lot of those songs were written by kirk Um, and this was the sense of this was the source of tension within the band itself and giving away your songs to court. Yeah Yeah, um, and you know you and that record despite court, he loves baggage is you know, it's got some decent like pop songs on there And you can imagine had them recorded by nirvana They would have been you know big things and it does make me think about what i was saying about the trajectory of the band and how this record Turned out, you know, what if they had recorded like, you know for those songs from the through this on put them on ganiro We'd be having a very different discussion about this, you know You know if they put on some of the songs that never got released like uh, like uh sappy or verse verse whatever they call it That's a fantastic song they threw it away on that no alternative album Which is probably one of the greatest compilations ever released during the 90s You got classic pavement songs in there as well like unseen power the picket fence everybody go here no alternative It's like one of those things that was in its own secretly a legend But yeah, like you know koban was maybe making artistic decisions that were more about himself and his family life And this by the way is why you maybe don't realize as people who weren't there at the time there it was a super strong You know cult of hatred for court.

We love people would refer to her as like a vampire as no spheratu There was even this like the long-running conspiracy theory, which is slanderist complete bs Like oh court me love killed Kurt Cobain people were actually like a vuring court. He loves secretly murdered Kurt Cobain Why who knows why the reason people came up with these conspiracy theories is that there was hatred for her Why was there hatred for her? I think a lot of it was basically misogynistic that she was you know Wasn't gonna take any crap from anybody and she acted out and she misbehaved and she was assertive and aggressive and a lot of people couldn't process that in 1993 But there was also a sense I think particularly this isn't just you know a cultural thing within the group They were suing each other all the way through the 90s of the 2000s The sense that she was like sort of like taking over she was yoko onoing it. I so I'm from Oregon And love is a bit of a local legend.

I knew people that knew Courtney love And look I don't want to discount from the sog anything being a backer. Um, but I think that she was kind of psychotic So the words are true in other words. Yeah, yeah, I think there's a lot of truth to that Yeah, you know there was a um there was a book in the 90s It's kind of one of these quintessential gen x artifacts called long water and they made a movie out of it with Luke Wilson in the 90s Um, where there's a character involving you know girl who like burns down someone's house that is like it's all it's clearly based on Courtney love Like everyone that knew her was like, oh my gosh that girl's you know nuts. Um, so yeah, that that that's definitely Definitely an issue with her.

I remember Tori Amis hated her famously But she wrote a song about her called celebrity widow, which is just the most Vicious title you can imagine to describe someone like I'm famous for being the widow of a person far more talented than me Um, which again kind of goes into the whole yoko ono thing Um, but yeah, well, so we will never necessarily know the truth or the lie about the kind of person that Courtney love was but what we do know Is that nirvana's final release up there? They're sort of career era is um, tv unplug So not the last gig that the band ever played in fact, you know, uh, mark actually saw them after this show This would have been in like late 93 november, I believe on November 93 Um, and of course, it's the mtv unplugged thing like it needs to be be explained This is where you don't use your electric instruments and all the big amps and loud guitars you strip it down you strip it back And by 1993 the format had kind of become a little bit stale Uh, but nirvana agreed to do it nonetheless. I'm not sure why i'm not sure, you know, it seems a bit corporate for them But the fact of the matter is is that the entire world is grateful that they did because gosh This actually is conceivably one of the two albums that I will name at the end of the show and it's a live album Uh, it's a magnificent concert recording. It's almost painfully immediate and personal and kobeins never been in better voice Which is weird given how like, you know, how sick he must have been at this time and how difficult things might have been for him Uh, the performances are perfect the song choices are perfect the guest artists who come up to play with them are perfect It's a great live album.

It's probably one of the most important live albums of the rock era in my opinion I had not considered that until prepping for the episode but realized very quickly that This is probably one of the most famous live albums ever released. It's uh, I think eight times platinum So, I mean millions of copies sold the demand was off the charts after kobeins death and it earns all of it This, you know, famously people who have followed the show what I think of most live albums, uh, essentially inconsequential And that's not the case with unplugged at all This is almost certainly one of my top five live albums ever made It will end up in the two albums that I named at the end of the show Uh, it's an amazing piece of art. I mean really it's an amazing piece of art I mean you consider the build up it. Kobein was very nervous about this very nervous about playing in an acoustic type setting Although I think he ran his acoustic through a amplifier anyway Um, the network didn't like the set list they had picked up I didn't want free meat puppet songs They didn't want to be puppets at all.

They wanted some more famous friends and any better Someone else to come on stage and play and up until the day of the show There was some real question about whether kobein was going to go through with it and actually play the show And even after the show there were more there was more conflict because they wanted to do an encore and he said I don't think I could do better than that. And so he won there was no encore But uh, this is this is a this is an album. I think you take you know holistically It is a start to finish experience that works on every level. Jeff said performances are on Key the vocals are outstanding the arrangements are great the addition of that shallow to some of these songs just just makes it Such an amazing uh experience.

It's all of a single take. It's immediate It's intimate. I think part of that probably is because of how they had to record for tv Right, and so I think there's a little bit more immediately with the way that they were recorded You know the microphones and placements and all that I think there was part of the reason it's so immediate in the nature of the songs and the way they were performed The tension inherent in a lot of these compositions never blows up or maybe at the very end where do you sleep last night at final verse The haunting final verse the focal performance is amazing, but there's all this tension that lies just below the surface on a lot of these songs Um Come as you are is not one of my favorite Nirvana song. I don't really like the performance on Nevermind I think it's transformed on this unplugged version The guitar parts are beautiful the solo is fantastic I enjoy listening to this version of a song that I don't really like hearing all that much on Nevermind You have great covers the band and soul of the world and Bowie cover uh led belly cover Where did you sleep last night the final song on this record which just should leave you Breathless.

I mean it takes your breath away and then all apologies the song just before it When they performed this that song was not extremely well known it had not been released as a single Off of uh in utero before they played it unplugged and they just nail it Uh the cover the meat put covers are great. I love plateau of those three Uh even though like poly which they must have loved because it's there's like 18 different versions of poly On various compilations and albums through their career here I just it's extra sinister with that with the bass line of no facelike and how he plays that and the voice cracks of Cobain throughout Uh choice of material is fascinating. Uh and they do it in a way that each cut is each each song is singular Uh, I think part of doing an unplugged thing like this is you can get sort of an insane sort of sonic realm Everything's acoustic everything's unplugged But with each song in this record it really stand up individually that their individual pieces that together make up this amazing piece of work I I I I I know people at least have the record but I can't recommend it strongly enough again coming from someone who's not always a fan of live albums This takes that present material. It really transforms it and it gives you a different experience and lets you know how good these guys were Both vocally and musically it's a tremendous accomplishment Yeah, I mean I think that's right.

I mean about it being one of the best, you know Light records in rock history and what's interesting about it is is for all in a weird way It is a very fitting coda to nirvana's, you know brief career in the sense that for a band that was so much of a breakthrough band For a band that's so much revolutionized, you know The pop music landscape and you know push rock forward after being pretty stagnant for a long time The choice of covers here is the one the fact that there are so many I mean there are one two there are what six covers out of 14 songs here Are really interesting, you know, you have the Vaseline's or you know sort of a skewer Scottish, you know pop bunk band You have David Bowie with a man who sold the world and then you have lead valley for crying out loud You know this, you know fantastic old bluesman and then you have you know the three meat puppet songs Where you know like Jeff already mentioned you know me puppets are one of these bands that you know don't get the credit they deserve And you know they're gone in a lot of ways even though they broke through for specific reasons You know very much standing on the shoulders of giants You know if it weren't for the pixies and beef bands like a meat puppet and stuff They never would have you know been able to you know paving the way they never would have able to break through Seriously, I think the plateau might be my single favorite song on the album It's the play out the instrumental play out on the end of plateau with all those acoustics going on It's just beautiful one of the very rare moments of genuine beauty on an ervana performance because it's not really what they were ever going for But what an inspired choice to just play three consecutive meat puppet songs from their one album that second album which is a bazure piece by the way I love it. I just am so impressed by that choice But it's very interesting to me from punk rockers to data boe to lead belly how this record like actually contextualizes nirvana in the rock and roll Fermanent you know what I'm saying? I don't know if that was you know remotely conscious decision it feels ever it feels like an extension of who they are and what they liked Artistically, but at the same time you know from band that like literally like for the music industry apart This you know statement of like you know, we're here as part of this larger, you know cultural thing that we all value so much You know is it's really powerful to see them come closer like that It's wrong Well, I mean it's funny. I don't really have much more to add than what you guys have I think this is this is a magical concert you wouldn't need to be emphasized that this wasn't done over like multiple days and multiple takes one Again, they didn't go back to play us on twice after having flubbed at the first time This is the actual show from start to finish no overdubs no changes and you know Again mark told us a story about watching nirvana play a show after this where it was just depressing nobody was on they're going through the motions Nervana's played some bad shows.

I have that DVD on the with the lights out box that which is actually fun But you know there's definitely some like you know packed off stuff there whether not really like all in time or all playing together um, this is almost magically perfect there are no misplaced notes even the errors you hear a couple you know, somebody's harmony isn't quite right or somebody comes in a Little too early there it all is just perfect. It's weirdly perfect. It's something that I even knew back of them I knew back 1994 or five when it came out that this was a great record But again, I said it aside so coming back to it recently I was entranced by it And it is such a it does have the elegy ac feel because it obviously you know curcobane had committed suicide already We didn't even mention it, but it's almost like superfluous to mention that yes Curcobane had a drug overdose checked into rehab then left rehab after we then was found dead in this apartment from a shotgun blast to the face That's terrible, but it's a story that everyone knows already Because it's kind of one of those defining moments of the childhood of anybody who's from our age group I guess I don't understand what like you know millennials or zoomers must think if you're born in 2000 You can't even remember 9-11 much less have any concept of like how the world was rocked when curcobane was Found dead in this apartment in seattle. That was a huge thing for people my age I talked about it at the beginning of the show how I almost kind of got weirdly resentful Like why is everyone blowing this out of proportion?

I understand now. I think in my old age why people blew that up so much why it did feel so sort of like the end of an era Um, and of course other bands reacted in that same way I mean pearl jans entire career trajectory was based functionally altered by curcobane suicide, you know Everything from Vitalogy onwards seemed very clearly be a reaction to you know what had happened to nirvana and their determination to just go a different direction And sort of make it as a working band kind of come up with a modus event at which they successfully did Um, but yeah, this was the end. I mean and of course the only things after this are archival releases some of them are fantastic I don't know if you guys have any strong thoughts on that live album that was released several years later From the money banks of the wish car, which is of course the river in Aberdeen, Washington I think it's fantastic But it is very much the opposite of unplugged which is just a tight and calibrated and calm performance Uh, which car is them at their their electrified insane like, you know, let it all hang out best I think it's really great. It's not just one concert It takes from every year of their career including the Chad Jannick reid from 1989 all the way to 1994.

It's a pretty fun compilation of live hits Yeah, um, I would agree with that, you know completely And uh, you know coming out in 1996 I mean it was A really big deal at the time and him because of the pewding between love and the rest of the band or whatever I mean it was god knows how long it was years and years before any more new nirvana material came out I mean so if for nothing else, I mean aside from the fact that they had put out a proper, you know live electric album at least Um, it was you know very much, you know, um, you know, it's not like an earth shattering thing But it was definitely like welcome and you know, we had it out there. It was the only new nirvana people had for years The tracks are essentially chronological through this but again unlike unplug clearly This is these are performances, you know chosen selected from various years Uh, and that means that the quality of the source material is somewhat very It's not meant to sound like a peat like one piece, I suppose But some tracks are recorded a little bit better than others. That's apparent as you go through Uh, idiot. It's visceral.

It's loud. Uh, you know a song like lithium really does jump from the speakers in the setting I think the version of school that's on here is quite good. Um, you know, I guess getting back to marx comment from seeing them at the beginning of 94 There are some performances here from the 93 tour that are less than less than stellar I think yeah, they're rougher man. They really are you can see you can hear the age the age in conveying voice I mean the heart shake box here is you know adequate the sliver version that's on here has a It's like he's delivering the his lines with a clenched jaw whether he doesn't want to be singing that song anymore Or it's just you know some sort of performer audience interaction.

It's a little odd Sounding Then the end of the double back so it's like chronological for three quarters and at the very end there are four or five tracks that date back to very early In the career. So, uh, I'm not certain whites structured that way, but it is Um, and again, I've heard although I have not heard there have been a couple of other live releases in the years since and there's one in particular But of course, I'm not gonna be able to pull but I had run a few things saying that more than even the money banks album is sort of them at their They're loud live best. So it's a nice compilation. It gives you a sense of what they were doing in person and uh and on stage Of course the career, but I don't necessarily love it I mean one of the things that it's worth saying about nirvana is if you like verband and you like live performances is incredibly easy to find a Ton of soundboard performances of nirvana.

They had they're you know, this is we're getting into the late 80s early 90s and from that point on You know almost any band of repute had, you know, the ability to get good soundboard tapes of themselves performing So you can find a lot of other stuff. They actually even released the live reading much later This is like last uh, I was about to say last year But it was last decade which is sad because it makes me realize that the entire 2010s have just zoomed by me I think it came out in 2009 or something like that This is reading festival 92 at the height of their fame Um a great performance and much more motivated when I think by Kurt uh, but yeah You could find a lot of live stuff from your father I think the last thing to mention we don't have to dwell too much on this But I will say and this is one that I I got back in the day because you know me I was an inveterate box set collector even if I didn't much care for a band I had this sense that like I'm gonna get this just to make sure you know just in case one day I decided really like this band. I'm gonna be glad I had this box set and I can page through these liner notes So they came out with I think it must have been the end of my college year or something like that 2002 threes something like that They came out with with the lights out So three CD box set of out takes b sides rarities and stuff like that And they throw in a dvd there which is pretty good too A lot of people kind of treat this as a disappointment Well, it's not as impressive as it should be You know, it's a lot of home demos and boombox recordings and like garage rehearsals and then a few b-size and things like that Uh, I'm a huge fan of it I don't expect everyone to be you have to have a certain sort of obsessive quality to you to enjoy stuff like this Which is you know, they're they're they're naked baby photos so to speak You know you hear that as I said earlier in the show you're the first song on the set is them playing heartbreaker at their first ever concert And you know chris says like I don't know how to play a song It's really funny because then you hear curt this screaming the lyrics I think played the whole verse through the first time that he screams the lyrics out the second time and you know He's not robert plant um, but it has a charm to it All of these cds have a charm to them. It basically covers their first year as the fleet year a second is never mind your third is the end You know, you know, there's a lot of great music to be found here But you know, not I can't in good conscience recommend it to anybody but you know a person who actually is decided Yeah, I'm a real serious nerfano fan I've only been through it Here and there picking tracks and that's the main thing is some of this stuff is really low-fi Right, so this is really poor recordings.

I think the original the original demo of smells like teen spirit is just it's extremely poor quality recording Yeah, I mean it was basically them like putting the boombox on recording it and it's they're playing in the garage Right and in some ways I felt a little uncomfortable listening to some of that stuff Kurt's not around to say that these are the songs he would have liked to have seen the light of day or to approve any of this and You know, no but so like they do most of the compilation here. I believe or I'm growled it too This is one I think they both worked on together as there's a big legal fight because Courtney loved it one of them released this box set because of you know, you're right She wanted that for a single disc greatest hit compilation. She ended up getting away that song is on the nirvana Titled greatest itself and that was released and it's only adequate. It's an okay.

So it's good Right not like the world beating. Let's put it this way. It does not like blow away the reputation of commas you are smells like teen spirit It's not a it's not Mary James last dance. No, yes.

Yes, that's a great. It's a great comparison Like the greatest hits bonus track that was better than almost everything all the actual greatest hits and the greatest hits alone was pretty great So yeah, I mean, I would I don't know if I could have far with Mary James last dance, but I mean it's one of the best songs and for You know, I never understood that like this music era music In the area of physical media like there was a lot of instance by record companies and other people you throw out a bonus track on a greatest hits collection Because that would entice people to buy the record when they might have had the songs and other records they already own Um, and this is a classic example. You're right of that. You know, not necessarily being a necessary addition at all Um, you know and Mary James last time's being the complete total exception Do you were saying Scott or have we come to the end of the show?

I think we're about wrapped up here on the uh career of Nirvana So that means we've come to the part of the show in which your steam hosts give you the two albums and the five songs that you should hear from our band Nirvana mark Hemingway writer at real clear investigations and real clear politics our guest on today's program Mark of floors yours for your two albums that people must own the five songs from the career. They should hear Okay, um, well, um, let's see. I mean, I think obviously nevermind It's just really hard to get around that and I would probably say, you know, MTV unplugged in New York Um, those are the two albums that you know, I think define Nirvana, um, you know, bleach is definitely in the mix there Um, but but I think those are the two albums. You know, as are the five songs I mean, I I I don't want to be like one of these crazy musical contrarians, you know, I can have a couple something interesting to say all time So let's just get smells like King Spirit out of the way I mean, it's just one of the greatest things ever recorded in terms of like just the oral majesty of the sound coming out of your speakers You know, nevermind.

It's, you know pop culture significance. Um, so yeah, obviously that's there. Um, um, I would also say Um, um, um, I don't also think territorial pissings I I just think that like that really captures the bands, you know, energy and speaks to, you know, the more angry side of what they did in sort of the best possible way Um, um, I mean, what I would also say, you know, silver I think that speaks sorry sliver would I think that speaks to it there, you know, pop leanings in probably the best possible way, you know For people that would maybe be turned off by Nirvana's, you know, angry punk, you know, thing That is sort of a, you know, a good sort of, you know, big way drug. Um, and I would also say, um, about a girl on bleach One of two four here five.

Oh, yeah, that's who cares. Go for one more, you know, it doesn't have to be science and uh, I would probably say, um Heartshake box all that in utero. I think that's the best of their sort of sinister vibe songs that I think to find a lot of what they did So my two albums indeed will mirror marks nevermind for the obvious reasons And I just spent time saying how much I loved unplugged one of the best live albums I think ever recorded So those are the two albums I choose and there gonna be some repeats here too Uh, I think sliver for sure from the from sort of the early period of an screen that's one of the most joyously fun songs and extremely catchy Uh that you should hear from a nevermind uh drain you I think could be the best song on nevermind and I am somewhat assuming you've heard More than enough times or at least enough times the main singles from that record Um heartshake box from in utero and I'll put a second in utero song on there too Dumb and then from the unplugged album we just go right to the end and that cover version of weird Digit sleep last night is something that must be heard. Jeff over to you I hate it when you steal all my thoughts.

Scott. I hate it so much I think we're gonna have to agree I think it's amazing because you can make an argument for bleach you can make an argument for in utero Uh the nervana super fans listening to the show almost certainly will but yeah, it's it's nevermind and it's it's uh mtv unplugged those are the two Uh I can't really you know add to what you guys have said about unplugged we've talked about enough You really are not gonna find a more compelling live performance than that one Uh, that's from my five songs. I'm gonna start with a from bleach. It's blue I think it's the first song of the album kind of captures them at their early wonky art rocky sub poppy best Sliver is another one that made my list.

Uh, so scott you stole that one for me and I blame you personally Uh again mark said it best if you make a list like this and you don't include smells like teen spirit You're just being a jerk. So scott you're actually being a jerk. Yeah, I have to point that out Four i'll say is on a plane, which is I think actually my favorite song on nevermind It's just such great. You know as I said, you know dark john lennon heroine addicted late night pop music It has that vibe to it and it still works to this day and fifth is if I had to choose one from in utero It would be another one that scott shows which is dumb Which again has that people ask sound a lot of good songs on you neuter a lot of disappointing songs on in utero But I think dumb definitely is is one of its highlights and you know host prerogative I think mark my defrona sixth and so why don't I as well again scott you got there first But it has to be reemphasized the last song on mtv unplugged where did you sleep last night?

That led belly cover the way kirk go bang just takes it up and octave at the end and just howles his heart and his soul out on that song is It's it's hair. It's spine tingling. It's hair raising. It's something that you'll never forget once you've heard it And hopefully you'll be hearing it on this show Yeah, I didn't I didn't I picked on plug and I didn't pick any songs off of unplugged I would have picked one and we definitely be ready to sleep last night And there we are the political beach look at the career of nirvana We think our guest mark hemmingway rider at real clear investigations and real clear politics who can follow his work bear Find him on twitter at hemmingator mark.

Thanks so much for joining us. Jeff We knocked another big one off of the uh, so we got another remaining big acts that we haven't covered yet and fulfilled a request from our Patreon supporters who voted for nirvana for the next episode. So really making everyone happy We live to serve you folks and yet I must confess alas still no echo in the bunniman We need guests for a bunch of things we really want to do so we continue mining our friendships and twitter fees to find people to work with us Uh find Jeff on twitter at esoteric cd. I'll answer at scotbertram You can also find us a patreon we have more exclusive content coming up very soon for our exclusive content supporters Find out more at patreon.com slash political base help the show stay ad-free support our efforts right there entry level for voting on Future episodes and just lending support mid-level for early access to new shows higher audio quality Opera level our bestest friends you get all that stuff plus exclusive content once a month remastered episodes in the future Spotify playlists and more patreon.com slash political beats We take a moment here to say thank you to some of our supporters over at patreon including mike morrison john press nall Sean hackbar former guest chuck turner alex spurrier craig cupboard norman fly share david batig paul richie kyle van dursen Richard kacucci and jeff pik thank you and everyone else for supporting us over at patreon subscribe to our feed to new episodes apple Podcast google podcast ditertune go to national review dot com listen enjoy share with friends and leave reviews Find us on facebook find us on twitter at political underscore beats.

This has been a presentation of national review. This is political beats

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Political Beats?

This episode is 2 hours and 37 minutes long.

When was this Political Beats episode published?

This episode was published on February 15, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Political Beats episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.