Hello again everybody and welcome into another edition of Political Beats, a presentation of National Review. Buy us on Twitter at political underscore beats or on Facebook, subscribe to our feed for new episodes through Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Stitcher, Tune In, go right to nationalreview.com, listen, enjoy, share, leave reviews wherever you can if you're positive, and even if you're negative I suppose. And check out our Patreon as well, only positive people there, patreon.com slash political beats, help the show stay ad free, support our efforts here on the program, we have entry level for supporting and voting, mid level for early access to new shows and with higher audio quality, and our upper level, upper level bestest friends of all, exclusive content at least once a month, remastered episodes with additional song clips, and Spotify Playlists too by popular demand with our end of show choices for each of our episodes as well, patreon.com slash political beats, my name is Scott Burchram, find me on Twitter at Scott Burchram, my tag team partner standing by as always, Jeff Blair, Jeff, how are you? Enjoying the lovely weather, it's 60 degrees, a bit breezy, but that's fine, you know what, there really is nothing better than Chicago at night.
And you know what, I think I could attest to that and I think I guess I can attest to that too, perhaps. And I'm going to go to Twitter at EsotericCD, our guest for today's program is a repeat offender, he is co-editor of Scalia Speaks, Reflections on Law, Faith, and Life Will Live, and I'm Faith, Lessons from American Believer, he's also the director of academic programs at the American Enterprise Institute, he is Christopher Scalia, right on Twitter at CJSGALIA, Chris, thanks for joining us once again. Thank you guys very much for having me back, I am really flattered that you chose me ahead of Beto and Pete Buttigieg to talk about tonight's band, and Chicago at night is wonderful as long as the bears have eaten the packers. Hey, by the way, we try to get Pete, but he's too good for us, so we had to settle for you, Chris, sorry.
It's all right, I'm still happy with it. As long as it works out in the end, that's what's important. And Chris being a repeat guest on the program, I believe, I'm pretty darn sure we have a job change, a job change since our first episode on Cheap Trick, so Chris tell us what you're doing now, how you got there, and what you're all about? Well, you know, as you can imagine, my knowledge and opinions of Cheap Trick really kind of opened a lot of doors for me up here in B.C.
So, no, I started work at the American Enterprise Institute a couple of years ago, I direct their academic programs, as you said, and basically what we do is we try to improve the substance and quality of discourse on campus by starting student councils on campuses around the country, having those student organizations invite AEI scholars to engage in policy conversations with professors and other people on campus, and we have programming at AEI and right now, remotely, that brings some of the best students from around the country to AEI to engage with our scholars and learn about significant policy issues. AEI.org for more on that. Chris, what was before for a great band, Cheap Trick is with us once again for another fantastic band, and it's Spoon. And it's weird reactions on Twitter when we brought up Spoon because some people are very familiar, very big fans.
And despite, I think arguably being the finest, perhaps, rock band, American rock band in the past 20 plus years, there are still some people who literally have not heard of this band, have just not run across them. But you're going to find out. I've gotten quite a few reactions in my response to saying like, oh, wow, I'm looking forward to this episode. I've never even heard of these people until you mentioned them.
And you know, I don't feel bad about that because I never heard of the old 97s until the bad episode. That worked out well too. A lot of people are going to be pleasantly surprised. Yeah, we're excited.
I'm excited about bringing this music to people who perhaps have not heard it before because it is phenomenal. Chris, first, Gileo, tell us why you love this band Spoon, how you got into them, and why people should care about this music. Well, as is the case with so many bands I like, I first heard them when a friend was driving me somewhere. I think he'd just gotten, girls can tell, and he put it in a CD player.
It was a long time ago, but I'm pretty sure it was a CD player. And I loved it right away. I think he knew I would like it because he knew I liked Elvis Costello. I think he immediately pointed out that Elvis Costello's similarities lyrically and vocally.
But I also, so I was attracted to that, but I also really liked Rick Daniels. His sneer, he has this, it's kind of like an Elvis Costello's sneer, but it also sounds like his marbles in his mouth a little bit. And I liked that. It reminded me a little bit of Jam-era Paul Weller.
And I just liked the kind of the fundamental simplicity, especially of that album. In some ways, just such a basic approach to song structure and instrumentation and all that. It's very, very effective. It's just precise and done very effectively.
I think it sounds so clinical, but that's the amazing thing about Spoon is that they are precise and things like that, but they're also very, very powerful. And so I liked that combination of elements immediately in their first album. So that I think that would have been a spring of 2000 when that came out or 2001. If it was girls can tell then it would be 2001.
Yeah, so I was later than you, Jeff, but yeah, so they're major label debut, I guess. And then from there, I bought every album as soon as it comes out. And it's been a lot of fun seeing them progress. The things that I liked about them right away have, I think they've maintained in a lot of ways, but they've also developed their sounds in a lot of ways.
They still have the signature style that I think we'll come back to again and again, but they've added some touches, gone in some different sonic directions that I think for the most part have worked really well. And they're one of the few bands now that I really get excited about when I hear a new album's coming out. And it's strange, I guess it's a side of how old I am, but I still consider them a new band, even though they've been around forever. And I think that's maybe because they just haven't had maybe the enormous success that maybe they should have had.
Spooned in a weird way from here, like the platonic ideal of a classic great band in quotes, great band. And the funny thing about that is that, you know, a lot of people, including people who were listening to the show, as I just said earlier, may not have even ever heard of them, or maybe only heard of them out of the corner of their ears or eyes, like, oh yeah, that band always gets like 10.0 reviews on pitchfork media or something like that, because they basically always kill it with the critics. But this is a group that is literally never disappointed, which is almost bizarre at this point. Because we're talking about a band that has nine albums at this point, and there's a tenth one that I think is apparently almost done or done that's going to be coming after everybody gets out of COVID lockdown.
So the show is going to be overtaken by events, unfortunately, not long after we put it in the bag. And yet, they're consistently great. They're consistently excellent. And yet, you never hear their music on the radio, and you're never going to hear their music like on, you know, it's not the kind of thing that comes up in discussions of popular music.
And you have to ask yourself, well, why? Why is that the case? And I think that they have, to the extent you can call a band that had this much success, critical success and is still going strong victims, in a way, they were a victim of their own strengths. They were a victim of the fact that they're so consistent.
They're like a Swiss timepiece. That's the way I described it to you guys when we were doing our pre-show notes. Like every year, a couple of years or so, you can just reliably count on them to crank out a great album. Oh, is this album a B plus or is it an A plus or an A minus?
It's never going to be a C. There are no C minus, you know, spoon albums. And I was joking. I was talking about it, but I was talking about it, and I was like, oh, I'm not only on Twitter, but also with Scott earlier, you know, that I almost dread doing this show because it's so hard to just keep saying, okay, and then they put another great album out.
And then this next album is awesome. Oh, this EP, that's really fantastic EP. You definitely need to hear that. But, you know, there are other bands including bands that I would compare them to.
I think of pavement is the one that always got compared to the Pixies in their first album. But really pavement to me feels like the one that they remind me the most of. They're final album like, you know, kind of face planted. You know, Terat twilight is not a great record.
I can't say that about any single record that spoon put out. The other thing, of course, is that the trends were moving away from this kind of music. And that's, I think, the real thing. That, you know, if spoon had started in 1989 instead of 1996 the way they did with their first record, then we might have a different story in terms of how well-known they are.
Or even like, you know, how they are super cult figures. They love it among like, you know, certain kinds of hipsters and indie rockers or, you know, people like me, frankly. But their sort of mind share among the general public is so small because by the time they really just came into the full bloom of their strength. Music, I mean, it was 1999, 2000.
What was current on the radio then? It was like, you know, a teeny pop or pop or a new metal. And now it's like, you know, sort of slick and robotic R&B music or hip hop. So the kind of music that they make, which is not remained the same.
It has changed throughout all their albums. But none of this stuff is trendy anymore. Which is, again, the funny thing I was thinking to myself before we started the show is like, listen, you know, if you're not familiar with Spoon, let me just tell you this. Do you like the Beatles?
You're gonna like Spoon. Do you like talk talk? Well, you're also gonna like Spoon. Do you only like De La Soul or Beck?
You're gonna like Spoon. I don't think you cannot like these guys, Daniel's songwriting in general. Because I think it's just so wonderful and weird, but also it never pushes you away. The way that sometimes, you know, bands like Paper E and Radio have for that matter.
Could kind of push you out a spoon or much more immediately. It's not as good as tomorrow's. It's a good bad bad it will soon turn to crystal form. A heartless attack and a invitation off again.
A secret is what you take it off again. And there's nothing about their music that, you know, tries to either push you away or make you cringe or force you to like it. And they manage this miraculous thing of still being like, you know, complex and thoughtful and not simplistic even as they play. You know, you can't even just reduce them to the term guitar rock.
Well, they started off as purely guitar rock, but then all of a sudden the piano's coming. The keyboards, the melitrons, strings, horns. They get into everything pretty much. They even get into like doing like rip-offs of, you know, Booker T and the MGs, green onions, like R&B, classic stuff.
There's something here for everyone and it's such a joy to talk about this crew. The consistency and the excellence of the output of something will return to over and over and over again. And from that angle, the only other, not the only other perhaps, the other band I put in that same category that we'll get to at some point, we'll get to one day. Putting out, you know, past 20 plus years, light clockwork, consistent releases, all quality, no duds, great songs on every album.
And that's, you know, that's the new pornography with them in the same sort of category. Just killer album after killer album. They know what their template is, but they're always painting with different brushes and using different colors. And that's what Spoon has done as well.
My first introduction to this band was on a mixed CD. My college roommate tonight at the end of each year would swap, would swap essentially best of, you know, best of, 10 best albums, 10 songs and a few extras. And we continued to do that even after we were, we graduated. But the one year, the song that was on, the mixed CD was something I had not heard before.
And that was Stay Don't Go from Kill the Moonlight. And it was immediately my favorite track on this compilation CD, it was Best of the Year CD that I had received. So yeah, I went back and grabbed, killed the moonlight the entire album and loved it. Loved it from the get go.
I mean, one of those albums for me that was immediately accessible. And I loved everything about it. Even though, you know, we'll talk about this, it is, you know, it's so minimalistic at points. But that works so well when it's built around the strength of Daniel's songwriting and that great percussion and drum playing of Jimino, you know, that's essentially the band.
I mean, they rotate through some bass players and there's some piano and organ players, especially one that's more than for a while now and in the past, I guess, decade or so. But I mean, really, it's about Daniel and it's about Eno. And they have been just an incredibly consistent band putting out really great albums, each of them with a couple of songs you can't forget with hooks that worm their way into your head. I'll make an argument in a bit that one of our albums is perhaps the best album of that decade.
It was released, I think that highly of it. And the strange thing is you talk to Spoon fans and ask them what their favorite album is or the best Spoon album is. And you'll likely get, I mean, at least four or maybe five different choices. And all of them are valid choices.
And I can understand why someone would say any of those might be the best or their favorite Spoon album. I have my choice. You guys will have your choice as we get further on the program. But I think there are multiple options that are all valid and that just speaks to the high quality, the great song writing and performances on all of these albums.
This is such a richly rewarding discography. It's a great, I think someone had tweeted at you, Jeff. It is a great band to put on a road trip because you're not going to hear anything that you're going to reach to skip. You're not going to hear anything that will immediately turn you away in the next song.
And then of course you'll hit the gems along the way too. It's just a really, really, really entertaining band that, again, arguably the greatest American rock band of the past 20 years. What do you hear? I'll always do these stupid historical setups.
Maybe for once you can set the scene and explain how this band came out of Austin. Well, as you mentioned, they're in Austin band and Brett Daniel and Jimmy will make up the nucleus of Spoon. So Brett Daniel is the main songwriter and Jimmy plays percussion drums mostly. And these guys were around, you know, at the very tail end of that big rock era of the 90s when they were still bands being scooped up by major labels and hoping to cash it on success.
The guys met in the early 90s and formed a band. In fact, if I'm not mistaken, the name of the band is chosen to honor one of your favorite band. Okay, my favorite band, one of my favorite bands indeed is a band called Can, one of the great outrock acts. And Can started their own little boutique label because who's going to release Can Records, right?
It's this weird funky, strange German group. What is the name of that label? It's the name of it is called Spoon. And so they decided, hey, that's a great name.
We're going to take that. We're going to make that our band name as a tribute. Now here's a hilarious thing. There isn't a single.
Spoon sounds nothing like the band can. Actually, not entirely. There's one album where they start to sound a little bit like they get into the minimalism. Now I'll get to that when we get there.
And it's a kimmy fiction. It's the one where all of a sudden you're like, hey, wait a second. I can hear some can coming in there, right? But no, they couldn't be any different.
They couldn't be more different. And yeah, and so what do they do? They sign with like, you know, what are all the indie bands have to do? Sign with Materor Records, right?
And it just seems like it's a rite of passage. And so that's where they start first with their... Can I hear Jack there about it? As long as we're talking a name, I didn't know that about the name.
That's really interesting. But I'm convinced, you know, you have to attribute some of their lack of popularity to that name. If they had even just been the spoons, I think people would have had an easier time with it. You know, you're right about that's a great talk.
I can't tell you how many times people have asked me, so what music are you into right now? And I say spoon. And they actually laugh at me. I'm not kidding.
They laugh at me. Because as you said, they haven't heard of the band. Even people really into indie music haven't heard of spoon. We're talking about a band that named its best album, arguably after what sounds a complete baby talk to.
So, you're right about that. So, yeah, maybe they aren't making a commercial play necessarily. So anyway, the short version is that they do the classic indie thing. They release an early EP.
It's an e-p. It's an e-p. And it's actually funny. I hadn't heard their e-p's until very recently.
I have all their albums. I bought them all actually at the time. But I hadn't gone back to hear their e-p's. Some of these e-p's are magnificent.
We will talk about them. The first one is actually probably the most disposable. It's nefarious. And it's just four songs they would rerecord a number of them for their first album.
And they're all far better in the re-recordings, in my opinion. And I think that's really where you start. You start with that first album. And of course, I'm going to embarrass myself.
I may be mispronouncing the name of it because I have never been able to figure out... I got this album in 1997 and I did this day. Still don't know whether it's pronounced telefono or telefono, like in the Spanish way. It's spelled with the pH.
So, I kind of emphasize it. Right, because I'm Americanized. It's a telephoto. It's a telephoto, right?
It's a fantastic record. And I know Chris actually will have a few criticisms of it. But I think this is a great debut album. This to me is the only time where you can see some of their early roots showing.
You know, spoon becomes spoon. And it's kind of difficult to explain without really dropping the music clips and how classic spoon has this weird mix of sort of ankylarity and interesting guitar ideas. And also, you know, beauty and piano and keyboard stuff. But they evolve into that later.
This is their first album. And of course, what it gets dinged sometimes for. It's just sounding very, very redolent of the Pixies. The Pixies.
And you know, it's not completely a Pixies knockoff. What the heck is wrong with a band that likes the Pixies? Like the world can use more Pixies imitators because this is how good a band spoon is. This is like the Pixies at their best.
Not like the really like not so great Chomp La Mon bossa Nova era Pixies where, you know, Black Francis was running out of steam. This is some quality surfa Rosa era Pixies sound to this music. But it is that one album of theirs where you can absolutely say, okay, when I hear dismembered, for example, from the title Aloe, that's that same kind of like frightening image like broken face or, you know, you know, and then the, the, the, has the female vocals that come out of the music. That the female vocals that come out as well just be Kim Deal in the background.
That is such a Pixies knockoff. But you know what? It's still a good song. And I have to say, this is one of those records where like, you know, despite the fact that it's so clearly to, you know, owes a debt to another group, it's still super fun to listen to.
And then if they're heaviest album, this is guitar bass and drums. There's nothing else. There's no piano. There's no violins.
There's no strings or horns or anything like that. This is just them as a three piece act. And I'm still up to listen to it, you know, a couple times every year. Scott, maybe you should go next.
I think you like this album a little more than I do. I do like it more than you do, or at least I anticipate you're going to. And I echo what Jeff said, which is, of course, yes, this is where you see the scenes on the band, right? This is where the influences shine through some pavement, a lot of Pixies, no doubt about that.
But as Jeff said, they do it well and they pick a great band to try to, to try to imitate and they pull it off very well. Don't buy the realistic as the first song that's sort of a long, low, slow fade in. It hits, it has that unmistakable pixie sound. I mean, great dynamics, vocal harmonies, that guitar tone is very joy Santiago and Frank Black and that just, you know, low end booming bass.
Don't buy the realistic is one of the better songs in the album than, yeah, it sounds like the Pixies. And the vocals of the vocals are pure Steve Malcolm. It's like the best way to explain this album to somebody on, you know, on your thumbnail description is sick. Imagine the Pixies with Steve and Malcolm is singing it.
And yeah, that's exactly what you get. Oh, which by the way, those two bands are great. So I like that. Yeah, the songs here are quick bursts, screaming and some howling.
This is the album most fueled by adrenaline, right? The songs rarely get more than two and a half minutes long or so. I just wrote down this note. I think there's more profanity on this record than the entire rest of the Spoon catalog combined.
I think there's random press words. Random F-Bombs all over the place. Yeah, right. I think it closes very strongly like the last trio of songs.
The last two songs are the best songs on the album. They're the best songs on the album. They're the best songs on the album. The acoustic mylar, those are so great.
The government darlin', that's a great song. It's a good lyric to the government darlin', you're sick of yourself. What would the powers that be do without your dad? We probably live among the socialist.
It's just like a funny, kind of insusiant, very again, pavement task kind of a take. But God, that melody is not only great, it's also just so notably improved from the first EP version of it. It's practically a different song when it went back to do it again. It's interesting to hear when they did a re-recording, it's not a rip off because they made it so much better.
Jumpy song structures here, almost spasms of songs in places. Again, there's some of their 90 seconds less than two minutes. Again, I just go back. It's adrenaline-filled, it's very uptempo.
It's very loud, fuzzy, sort of, that era of 1996. You're just seeing and hearing the influences. But as Jeff said, I think it's a very listable record. There's nothing that I dislike about it and hearing the echoes of those bands that influence the spoon.
I don't have a problem with it. The songs are pretty good. So, no, not crispy negative for. I think one of the reasons I don't like this album very much is that I came to it so late.
I wonder if this were the first spoon album I'd heard. I would appreciate it more. But it's just so different than what I like spoon for. It's hard for me to really like as a spoon album, if that makes sense.
I love the Pixies, but I don't want to listen to spoon for a pseudo-pixies album. I've just never really put this album on for anything but to give another try to see if there's something I was missing. I still have not as many times as I've tried. I haven't found real deep purchase in it.
So, I agree. Basically, everything you described about the album, I think you described it perfectly. I just don't like it. I don't disagree with any of your descriptions.
I do like, I agree with you. I think it ends really, really strongly. I love those last few tracks in particular, especially government darling and plastic my love. I think it's interesting to see Daniel's voice over the course of this album, just because after this album, he plays it a little bit cooler.
He still yells in later albums, but it's not quite as aggressive and it's a little bit more controlled. As a result, I think it's more effective. The description of the album as a series of quick verse, I think that's absolutely right. But again, I think they do that same type of approach later on with an album we'll talk about in a few minutes.
There are some moments where the pixies-ishness of it's just really, I almost laugh out loud at it when I hear it. Some of the lines, well, I can't quote some of the lines because it's... We can believe it. This is actually great.
This is great because it means our patreon, but their members will get to hear it. He says a few times, I'm not sure how to pronounce this title, but it's a vente. You can say so, motherfucker. You can say so, motherfucker.
And he repeats that a few times. I like I'm expecting him to say I was talking to P.T.P. about Kissi Kiss. It's just kind of the inflection.
It's so pixies-y. It's really kind of disarming to me. So I wouldn't say it's a bad album. I think for an album from 1997, it's kind of like I still wouldn't call it a top tier album from that time, but it's pretty good.
I just don't love it as a spoon album. But I have a question for you about this. So you would have been still in... It was in high school.
I was like, yeah, I think I got it by junior year, senior year of high school. So they never... Did HFS were any alternative rock station in the area played as album or abstract? Absolutely not.
I only found it because I had a friend of mine, Okshe. He's out there somewhere. Hopefully he listened to this show. It's academic team with me.
He was in that nerdy wheel. We were going unabashed at Nerds. He was the one who turned me on a spoon. He's like, hey, check this out.
And so that's how I found them. Back then. So yeah, it was very, very serendipitous. I think a lot.
I was really kind of a classic rock dork in high school. So the modern bands that I got into, in fact, whether it was pavement or spoon or radio head for that matter, actually, kind of sometimes were serendipitous accidents that thankfully have clung to me all this time. I wanted to say that the spoon aesthetic is actually maybe disguised by the Pixies-like approach, but it's still there. Every one of these songs, every one of them really, has nagging memorable riffs and hooks and little guitar figures that just...
Oh, yeah, that's good. Like, a toner. Like, that's a song that just goes on. Or even the stupid instrumental.
It's another very picky song. It's themed to Wendell's Divers, which is like a fake instrumental. It's like, you know, this is a song called Tony's Theme. It's about a superhero name, Tony.
You know, let's see, though. You can almost hear that, right? But they're good. They're really interesting tunes.
And there's one other thing I can say about this album, which is... I constantly return to this on the show. And this is the beginning of it. One of the best virtues and most underrated virtues of spoon albums is they are never too long.
The longest spoon album I think of all time is 43 minutes. This one's like 36. They understood on a gut level. Don't bore us.
Get to the chorus. You know, just like Barry Gordy might have said. So like, it's only 36 minutes. And there's never an overlong spoon record.
So that's why it's like, even if this isn't maybe necessarily your thing, this is the beginning of their career, it's also over in a half hour. And you know, you're going to still end up liking, listening to like, you know, all the negatives have been destroyed. The albums are relatively brief compared to their time, of course, but it's even shorter than the full-length albums. The EPs.
Which brings us to this bridge EP between telephoto and a series of sneaks. Where spoon immediately becomes spoon. It should be put an out too that nobody bought this album. It was like 3000 copies were sold.
They were not big. They did not, you know, they did not, in fact, I don't know if they'd buy it back to their label. If they were not picked up by a major label for the next release. And this soft effects EP that we're going to talk about here, the songs that were sort of meant to be saved as like singles that were going to release after a telephony was a big hit.
And now we're going to sing a little bit. Right. And that didn't happen. So they slapped all these songs they had on this EP called Soft Effects, Five Songs.
And Five Single Quality Songs. I think all three of us are going to say that we like the EP better than the previous album. Absolutely. It is amazing.
This is the one where I am embarrassed to admit that I didn't even hear this until this week. I literally like in our email thread. I was like, hey, you guys have the non-album material. I think you guys have it.
And they were like, you know, I want to check out one of these EP's. And now I feel like that idiot who claims to be a super pavement fan, but has never heard the Watery Domestic EP, which is like one of their greatest releases. Because Soft Effects won't make my top two at the end, but it will get an honorable mention. There are songs on this that actually probably will make my top five that are the best of their career.
This suddenly it's beautiful. Suddenly there are keyboards, not even keyboards. It's more of a keyboard aesthetic. It's a melodic aesthetic.
No longer a pixie stuff, but I could see the dude. It's just such a beautiful song. And it ends with, I think, one of their five best, which is Lost Leaders, a ballad or a rock ballad. That is secret, a secret, but probably one of the best things that Rick Daniels ever wrote.
I love this as well. This does really feel like where it may become where they really kind of find the sound that they build. They kind of sound that they develop over the course the rest of their career. And going back to the telephony, the song structure, even the song structure is kind of pixie-ish.
Because you have the slow and fast, slow template that the pixie's established in Nirvana, Meg famous. And that's not really typical for the rest of Spoon's career. And I think starting with this album, they kind of start with the groove. And the groove continues.
The song around it, around it, changed. But the basic template of the groove is consistent over the course of the song. Not every song does that. It would be oversimplifying to say that.
But it's a pretty common approach to their song structure. And you really see it over a number of songs here, waiting for the kids to come out, maybe the best one on this EP. And I really like it. Daniel's vocals.
I love, I mentioned how he didn't really control his vocals as much in telephony. Here, his vocals are really affected, especially waiting for the kids to come out. He pronounces words strangely, as he does in a lot of his early albums. I'm going to curse again, guys.
Get ready with the button. You can stick all that up your ass. He pronounces ass really strangely. We don't even need to bleed to bleed pad.
That's really disappointing. And then I think he barks a couple of times in that song. And I like to imagine there's an homage to Elvis Costello's Black Sales in the Sunset. I really doubt it's true, but I like to imagine that at the couple of points in the song, Daniel sings, let it lead and the vocal effect he does with that is straight out of something Costello does in Black Sales in the Sunset, which I think was a B side, right?
It was like an obscure bonus track on the reissues from the early 90s. It means that it's possible. That's where he picked it up. Yeah, it was out of our idiot too, before that I think.
So, yeah, he probably would have heard it somewhere. Also, going too far with references here, I also like to imagine that soft effects is a reference to the jam album. Sound effects, no, it has to be. It so clearly is.
Which is which is which is talk about a band that no one knows about, but they should have been everyone in Britain knows that jam. Everyone in Britain knows that jam. I know what America does. Yeah, that's their best record.
So Jeff, I wonder what you think. I know you love Lost Leaders. You know a lot more about pavement than I do, but that strikes me as the most most pavement like song on this EP. It reminds me of a song again, the comparisons to the pavement, Watery Domestic EP is so great because they're both like a fundamental like important foundational works for these bands.
It reminds me of the last song on that record, which is called Shoot the Singer, One the Sixth Verse, which is this thing, which is very different songs, but they're just fundamentally so melodic and so pain-stakingly constructed as you know, song craft that it's just, you know, I can understand why they got the comparisons. And it's actually this funny thing is like it's the next album really, but around it this time is when he would stop sounding like Maleficent. He still does. You know, you know, you know, Brit Daniel still sounds like he's doing like a Steve Maleficent impression.
I always wanted because they were on Mennador Records together. I always wonder if there was like, you know, some, you know, shade being thrown at one or the other because of the similarities, but yeah, they are both tributes to just beautiful craftsmanship in song, which is, I guess, what makes spoon, spoon from this point on. This EP, I think, even more so than the next album, is the closest that they come to really figuring things out before girls can tell. And that's reflected in, I think, Lost Leaders.
You guys have talked about two of my three favorite tracks, Lost Leaders, and then Waiting for the Kid to Come Out. And Waiting for the Kid to Come Out should mention two. That's the first time I really hear Enos drums have that spark, that jump, that we really define, that sound moving forward, that I hear that real strongly on Waiting for the Kid to Come Out. And I really enjoy Mountain to Sound, which is the first song on this little EP that starts, stop, simple foundation that's built upon, and I love that final 30 seconds of the song too.
This is a band that knows how to sort of craft a fade, right? How to bring all these disparate elements that they've presented in the first three minutes and really turn them inside out for the final 30 seconds. And I think we'll go here on that one too. Chris mentioned, I think Daniel's voice has more his own on the EP, no doubt about it.
And I think, again, this is, I think the EP is the most fully realized sound that they would have the four girls come to us. And we'll come back to you. We'll come back to you after all. We'll come back to you after this one.
One of the things I like about the end of Mountain to Sound, you mentioned his vocals there, towards the end, if I remember, he kind of starts harmonizing with himself, right? And he's on two tracks there. You figure, like, if this had been telephoned, they would have had the backup singer doing that, the female harmonizer there. And this one, I don't know if it's because of the budget, or because he just has more confidence in his voice.
And what he wants to get out of the song, Daniel's voice is coming in from multiple angles there. That's just such a great brooding and powerful song. I love that one. And I think I have to also agree with Scott that this EP is a little bit better than their second album, which comes right after this.
And it's very, again, we joke about this. How can you pick a worst spoon album? Well, I guess Chris can say that he doesn't really like telephoned. I think it's a fine album, all right?
But if I had a gun to my head and I'd say, well, what's the weakest spoon album? I think it might be the next one. A series of sneaks came out in 97, I believe. When I say that, this is not a bad album.
There are songs on this that are just sort of legendary. Legendary spoon, song, 30-gallon tank. I love June's Foreign Spell, actually, it's probably my favorite song on the album. But if I have to tell myself, you know, what gets the chop?
Well, there's stuff like staring at the board, which is like, okay, it's only a minute long, but it's some sort of lo-fi, like, I'm not a bad album. It's clearly some sort of lo-fi thing. And lo-fi was really not where Spoon was headed, and it was not really where their soul was at. So some of the minor squibs on this record are, again, you can't even call it a disappointment because it's still like a B plus record.
It's still good. The minor top actually is another one that I love just because of that naggy guitar riff on it. For extension. It never builds on it, though.
I think there's something, no, you're not. It's probably as close to purely generic spoon as you'll ever find. And of course, I have the version as the bonus tracks on it. So I get to hear him complaining about their record label guy putting on the Lafitte tracks.
That would be the best song that I've ever seen. That's a great one. It's an extremely graceful pop melody. And it is literally like a, I'm writing a song that conceivably in an alternate universe, a better universe, be a top 40 hit.
And it's really good. On the other hand, hearing them kind of like crack on. The guy who quit the record label after signing them is a bit silly. Maybe you shouldn't really care too much about the lyrics to Spoon's songs.
But yeah, this is to me, if I had to choose one of my least favorite of their records. I think I'm in agreement. There's one later in the end. How dare you guys?
Come on. And I think that Jeff picked up on something that I'll echo, which is there are some good ideas here on some songs. I don't know if they're developed as developed as they could be. Even 30 gallon tank, which I know people like about.
I would have loved to have heard it one album later. I think they do so much more with it. The songs on a series of sneaks to me aren't quite as individually, they don't stand on their own quite as much as their teacher songs would. I mean, every song on Kill the Moon has this very specific vibe and very specific thing.
And the title you know exactly what that song sort of feels and sounds like. And I don't get that from a lot of the songs on a series of sneaks. I think the vocals are buried a bit in places here on the album too. Or at least not as prominent as they should be or would be.
Again, this is an album full of really quick songs. I think only two songs are more than three minutes long. So you still have these very quick kind of chunky guitar slabs being thrown at you. If there's one more influence that I hear here, more so than the last album, but it's kind of almost a natural extension.
You know, guided by voices, those very, very, very quick kind of jingly and again still hooky. It's just perfect comparison. Nothing's necessarily wrong with a lot of these tracks. I just don't think they stand up quite as much as feature songs would.
And they're still developing their sound. They are confident though. The confidence and as Chris mentioned, having a swagger or a swag in Daniel's voice. I think just that the band had all together.
This was their major label swing that already sort of bottom out of minor labels. And here they are in a bigger label and they're going to bottom out again. But they don't sound that way. They sound very confident in what they're presenting a listener.
So yeah. Well, I think it's hilarious. He's still my joke. That was this is the big beginning and ending of Spoon's major.
It wasn't even like old 97's where they had three albums to try. Now this is me where we were getting later and later in the 90s. And I think the executives were running out of patience. So Spoon had one bite.
It was serious. It didn't sell. It didn't sell because of people like you. We don't appreciate it.
Maybe if more listeners had sophisticated tastes like me and understood the genius of this album, their career would have been more successful from at least from 98 on. That's just my first year here. So first of all, I'm really annoyed, Scott, that you brought up the guided by voices comparison. Because I was really eager to make that one.
But yeah, this really does remind me of a guided by voices album because of the quick verse like that of the songs. And the confidence can't really overstate just what a big difference that makes. With song like Utilitarian, I just love that strutting guitar riff. And Daniels' vocals are cool right away.
They're pretty much nonsense as far as I can tell. But he says them with such certainty. He pulls it off well. There are a number of tracks.
I just think are outstanding. Utilitarian, the guest list, slash the execution. I love 30 gallon tank. One of the shorter tracks I really like is car radio.
Daniels' vocal affectations here are really interesting. I get a kick out of them. He spends some time just going, mwah, mwah, mwah, mwah, mwah. Like he's talking about his generation or something.
He's talking about his car radio. And maybe it's because I first discovered Spoon in a car radio. I appreciate that one. And then the last track, Advance cassette.
I think that's a beautiful song. It's great. I think it's Advance cassette. That was a function that some take decks have where you could just push the fast forward button.
It would go to the end of the song, right? I always think about it from a label perspective. I thought it was industry jargon. You get it for the release.
Oh, okay. That makes sense too. And is probably more sensible. But oh well, I'm sticking with mine.
It's a song about relationships. And I think it's kind of a song about hearing a song that he shared with somebody and has to skip it now. And either that's going on to the next girl or literally just going on to pass it beyond that song. I've always found it.
Chris, I think you might be convincing me on this one actually. Nice. You'll know about the look on their faces. When they pass you, you've been dropped off on the Texas highway.
I've been out here now for so long. Little not sure how you wound me so tight. I'm afraid I won't ever hear that sad song again. So don't tell me.
No, contrary, I guess. But those are these doing these. We're working on two levels there. Exactly.
So yeah, I've always really enjoyed this album. It is not in the first class of their albums, but I think it's there. I definitely think it's better than telephono and there are a number of tracks. I'm going to say that it starts off very well.
It does peter out towards the end, but I think it's really quite solid. Well, so like the soccer team in that Ted Lasso series, Spoon and Midelli got relegated back to the minor leagues after their one shot on Elektra. And then they put out another EP. And this is the one.
Okay, so Scott said, okay, Jeff, you've got to really try the soft effects EP. And then Chris was like, you know what, love ways. Try love ways. And he was also right because this is a band where almost everything is worth hearing.
This is an EP that has maybe my single favorite Spoon song title in their entire career, which is, I didn't come here to die. Which I just love that as a first. I didn't come here to die, baby. But it also is one of their best ever tunes that I just, you know, I spare my final five at the end of the show, which is a jealousy.
Jealousy is such a beautiful song. And now, you know, this is a two man show. This is just Daniel and Eno. Okay, you know, pianos, keyboards everywhere now.
You know, all the go, you know, guitars and bass and then Eno is just all the drums. And they're self producing too, for that matter. And they actually sound very good, in my opinion, for guys who aren't working with pros, you know, like, you know, name producers. They know what they want to sound like.
They know what their style is. And this to me is, you know, just, you know, it needs to be mentioned because none of these songs are on any of their albums. Just go find it. It is really impressive stuff.
Jealousy. You can never die with Ben for me. Another dollar, Ben for me. Jealousy.
Jealousy. Fans, you're wrong. They say to me, song, I don't do it. That's a simple song, I don't do it.
I don't do it. Fans, you're wrong. You can't see. But that's a cab.
What I like about this is that they didn't sound like this ever again. It was like they were testing out different styles and approaches. And if I remember, right, they recorded this after they recorded Girls Can Tell. So this was kind of a stopgap or a place filler while people waited for Girls Can Tell to drop, as they say.
But I don't think said back then. So, yeah, I didn't come here to die. Great song. But it's much bluesier than anything they would have done to that point or with again.
And then Jealousy, I love that song. But it's pure pop with a bouncy piano and kind of Phil Spector drums crashing back there. And really, Jaunty Guitar. It reminds me a lot of Whiskey Town had a song called Mirror, Mirror, Mirror, maybe just a year after that.
That's a great comparison. But they never sounded like this again. They didn't even really try to. I love that.
The video, by the way, is fantastic too. Very funny. And then Figures of Art is another great one on this one on this EP. Yeah, if any Spoon fans somehow haven't heard this one, definitely check it out.
You guys covered everything? I didn't come here to die as that great bow-diddly beat. The blues elements, it's not previously present. And sort of opened the door to the experimentation, or at least the twists on the quote unquote spoon sound that would come on albums.
The way that they'd find new textures and new techniques and new rhythms to experiment with. That's right there on this one. And Chris is right. So this Loveways EP was recorded either at the same time or just after Girls Can Tell.
And then they released it first before Girls Can Tell came out in February of 2001. I don't think it was because there was so much built up designer spoon products. Demand for spoon products, exactly. I think it was kind of just making sure people knew they were still alive and making music before the next album was going to be released.
And boy, I guess we can go. This is your moment, Scott. This was your first album, I believe, if I recall. So queue it up for us.
Tell us about Girls Can Tell. And I'm going to just start by saying this myself. This might be one of my two at the end. I think if these points were one of our two at the end.
I mean, that's just how it is. So the last album is there is a sneak-stiff. And they get dropped by the major labels. They flunked out the minor labels.
They flunked out the major labels. And there's really some question about whether or not the band is going to continue in its form, whether or not it's a viable thing. And Eno is, I think already married at this time, and he's working as an engineer, I think. He's got a full-time job and Daniel moves to New York.
And it's essentially living on couches and picking up stuffs to teaching jobs here and there when he can and doing these odd things to make some money. He was essentially dirt poor. But in his mind, there was never a question that there would be more music. And so he and Eno continued writing songs.
He and Eno continued recording. And they were twitting the garage. They did find ways. There's a story of them sneaking into, I think, the University of Texas Music Department to record some of the piano parts on Girls' Contellan's Grand Piano.
That was at the Music Program at the University of Eno's Piano. But they did have some recording equipment and some guts. So they snuck in and recorded all these parts on Girls' Contell. I seem to remember sometimes there was an interview where we were recording the key, but we were hoping the janitors and the security guards would not find us.
Which is so perfect because this album doesn't sound like something that was recorded in the sneakily at all. It's so, so well. So, so, so short. So, you know, I think this record is made essentially at night after people have done their day jobs.
There's no, they're not attached to any label. You know, brick dangles between jobs, you know, between part-time things, between the substitute teaching, trying to figure things out. And this, this is what they come up with. And it's fantastic.
This is where, you know, if you think about the quote unquote spoon sound, this is where it really begins to come to fruition. These lean, spare, spiky, extremely well-crafted songs, eliminating all but what is necessary for the song to work. And Daniel tells the story he was listening to a lot of old music around this time, old Motown. Fluidback's Tusk is one of the albums he was listening to a lot during Writing Girls' Contell.
And the songwriting on here lives in this, lives in such a classic world of songwriting. It hits you immediately. And the, the song, everything hits at once. That hits you.
It's a modern version of like a Holland Oats track. Okay. Starts off like R&B almost. The drums are maybe a little bit louder than you would get on like a Philly soul.
It's just so effortless. And then, just when you think you've got it, you've got, you know, the hold of it. Boom. Melitrons.
Melitrons everywhere. Where do these melitrons come from? It becomes something different halfway through. And it's the first song on the record.
And right there, you know, this band has taken a quantum leap forward. Everything hits at once. The side is all. And traffic will change my mind tonight.
And it's traffic across the lake. And that's the key moment. That moment after I think it's the second chorus there where the decision is made, you know, guitar solo, you know, bridge, melitron. That's what's going to work here.
And of course it does. And that everything hits at once song. That steady organ pulse, setting of the mood. There's no real resolution to that song.
The tension continues even as it fades out. It's just a brilliant piece of songwriting. Yeah. This was the, I think this would have been the first song I heard.
And it's what kind of got my attention with Elvis Costello's similarity. You know, pre-show, I emailed you guys and I said, you know, even that opening lyric, it's just, it sounds like something Elvis Costello would have written. Don't say a word. The last one's still singing.
And then Scott, you pointed out that actually Elvis Costello did write that. Don't say a word. Don't say anything. Don't say a word.
I'm not even listening. So watch your step. Yeah. And it's just, so, you know, I don't know how conscious that is, but that driving, yeah, you guys mentioned that the melitron coming in there.
But then there's this bass line, this almost like a James Bondi bass line over the course of the song that drives it as well. It's just, it's like five different, you know, musical genres or ideas. Just thrown it to the stew, but it doesn't sound like it's labored or like your chime. Oh, it sounds very natural.
And that's the entire flippin album. This is, this is why girls can tell. And this is actually where they first became like, true indie darlings. They'd had some credibility prior to this.
But then people heard this, but now recorded, as you said, like in bass mince, stolen rooms at universities at night. And then this thing comes and you know, that's just, we've just talked about the first song. There are no bad songs on this record. Yeah.
You know, they even throw on a cover, me and the bean. I don't know who, I've never heard the original. I don't think I ever need to, because this version is awesome. So yeah, me and the bean was written by a guy named John Clayton.