Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on the gettable lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast, I'm Mike Atard. Well, it's been a frantic time, if, like me, you follow closely the movements and machinations of the media, and especially if you follow the US media and how it intersects with Australia through the Murdle family. Last week, the mother of bombshells dropped that Dominion and Fox News had reached an eye-wavering settlement in the defamation case Dominion had taken out against Fox over its coverage of the big steel.
A settlement of several $787 million American dollars would normally set for some serious bloodlet ink at any media organisation. And this week, it started and it started with the biggest star in the Fox universe, Tucker Carlson, who has been spectacularly sacked. Close it at home on Friday last week, Loplin Murdle pulled the pin on his defamation case against Australian News website, Crikey. Clearly, this was connected to the Dominion settlement.
But what does it actually mean and did Crikey just win or was it just a very lucky break? Harry Beacher is the chairman and the co-founder of Private Media, which publishes Crikey. He's also a former editor of the Sydney Morning Herald. Harry Beacher, welcome back to Fox's take.
Great to have you on the show again. Thank you, Micah. So, when the news came through that Murdle, Loplin Murdle was abandoning the defamation case against Crikey, tell us what that felt like. It felt pretty good, but I wouldn't say it was a sense of elation.
It was a sense to me and my colleagues of justice and to some extent of inevitability, because for this case, to actually proceed through to court in October, whatever required Loplin Murdle to have appeared in the witness box and taken potentially days and days across examination by our extremely capable leading council about issues like abuse of media power or Fox News' role in denying the 2020 US election result, that kind of thing. So, I always felt that was unlikely to happen, but I was certainly relishing the prospect. What do you think it was unlikely to happen? I mean, the Burdocks don't normally resolve from a fight, do they?
They do resolve from, as we saw in the Fox News Dominion case last week, they do resolve from public accountability, particularly the family owners who normally work behind the scenes, on the stage. So, the case that Loplin brought wasn't just aimed at Crikey, the publication, it was also quite personal, it was aimed at Bernard Keene who wrote the original piece, then editor Peter Frey, yourself and your CEO Will Haywood. He really wasn't messing around. How much pressure did you feel at the time that that action was brought?
Again, not enormous pressure, strangely enough. It's not unusual for plaintiffs to name and include individuals as defendants in defamation cases. It's happened to me in the past. It's not normal, but it's not unusual.
So, that part of it was just a legal tactic, as in fact, the whole process, I think, was about legal tactics rather than substantive issues or let alone defamation. But in terms of tactics, I mean, I'm sure that you feel vindicated, but you also must feel kind of lucky that it was the Dominion case that brought Fox to its knees. You wouldn't have anticipated that outcome in the US when you decided to rerun the piece in Crikey that seemed to sell a Fendlock Burdock. No, that's true, because none of that had come out at the time, but we did feel very strongly that this was not a defamatory piece of journalism by a million miles.
And so the fundamental core of his case and therefore the allegations that we defamed him and humiliated him and made him, he was claiming that we made him out to be a conspirator with Trump in the election denial and a conspirator with Trump in murdering people at the Capitol riot, things like that. It was just absurd. This was a pretty regular piece of op-ed opinion of which there are thousands published each day around the world. And it contained one sentence of hyperbole.
And you only have to pick up a newspaper like the Australian every day to find hyperbole rippling out of their opinion pieces. So there was nothing exceptional about this. He was also claiming that Crikey was being pretty opportunistic in operating the way he did in relation to the piece. So because it was published, he complained, you pulled it down, then all of a sudden it went back up again.
And we'll look at the circumstances around what came out of the discovery process in relation to that. But Loughlin and Murtok and pulling out the action that he remained confident that the court would ultimately find in his favour but didn't wish to further enable you to use the court to litigate a case from another jurisdiction that is the one of the United States with dominion that had been settled and facilitate a quote marketing campaign designed to attract subscribers and boost their profits. Does he have a point? I mean, Crikey certainly did get a lot of exposure and I'm guessing subscribers from his battle.
Look, there's a couple of things about what you just raised. The first is that Crikey's remit is to hold power to account. That's what we're there to do. And when we do it, it's rare to have the opportunity to do it on this scale.
But when we do have that opportunity, we want people to know about it. This is not about spelling subscriptions. Obviously, we'd like to sell subscriptions. But the idea, and I can understand why Loughlin and Murtok would suggest that, look at what's come out in the Dominion case.
They run the Fox News network in order to manipulate the content to make profits. I mean, he ought to know about that kind of thing. So that's wrong. Would you have got the piece back up if there was nothing attached to it that would have attracted attention to Crikey?
100%. I mean, I made the decision to put the piece back up. And we put it back up because we were not prepared to be intimidated by a billionaire media-owning bully. And this is compounded by the fact that he does own media, that he's probably in the defamation courts in this country, his companies, more than anyone else.
And here he is, having a major pot shot at us. We published all of the legal correspondence and it's still on our website. So people can go and form their own view about the intimidating legal behavior that we were enduring. And that's why we put it back up.
But knowing Australia as you do, and certainly knowing the kind of coverage that you would have gotten in putting the piece back up and essentially taking up the New York Times piece saying, come through us. Are you saying that really, there was no thought that this might assist the business side of the publication? Look, we're not naive. We understand that that would have happened.
But at the same time, we were standing up for what we believe was a really, really important principle of journalistic free speech and being able to publish opinions. I mean, it was for us. Yes, those things happened. Our primary motivation was standing up for our values.
Have you experienced an increase in subscribers since the defamation action was launched? Yes, we have. But that was not the reason that we did it. And why have we experienced an increase in subscribers?
Because I think there are a lot of people out there who feel the same way as we do about this kind of abuse of media power. I mean, after all, half a million people signed Kevin Rudd's parliamentary petition calling for a royal commission into the mailbox. There's a very strong groundswill of views on this subject in this country. Well, continuing on with this issue, let's just look at the information that came out of the discovery process that you'd engaged in marketing firm to help crack your increased subscribers by essentially taking on Loughlin.
There are some who did find that disappointing. A lot of people who actually supported it. But some who did find it a tad cynical. Do you understand those views?
Do you have those feelings? No, I don't. I mean, we're a small company. We don't actually have a marketing staff, let us all own anyone on staff or that we use as a consultant to deal with what you might call issues management.
And so all we were doing, I mean, would anyone be surprised if we called in experts in other areas like we do with our lawyers? No. We wanted to make sure that if we were going to present this case in public that we did it professionally and we knew what we were doing. And so what do you say to those people then who say that it was a cynical ploy that didn't backfire on you because of a case all the way over there in the United States?
Well, I say that it wasn't a cynical ploy from the get-go. Definitely the Dominion cases assisted the information that we had to defend ourselves. But it was not a cynical ploy in my view by any stretch of imagination. I mean, you know, we're a small independent news publisher that has to fight pretty hard to say the least to get ahead about the parapet.
This came along. Yes, we invited him to sue us. We took an ad in the New York Times, which is unusual. But that's because we were standing on our principles.
We passionately believe this. And yes, we got some professional help to make sure that we managed and handled it well. Were you concerned when news of that professional helped with so widely reported in the media as a result of the discovery process? Well, I wasn't concerned.
I mean, you and I might have known how journalists and journalists and works and other, you know, there is a level of competition and, you know, high degree of sensitivity sometimes emerging into jealousy and so the coverage of our case by people who don't like us for whatever reason, if we have a new score here because they didn't cover it. I wasn't surprised with that. OK, now, I mean, it seems obvious that Fox settled with the minion to end a very damaging court case elements of that case playing out here in Australia would have made the US element kind of many was do you accept that this is less a win for Cricky, more employed by the Murdochs to not redisticate in Australia? We have to ask them.
I mean, we won because they withdrew the case. So we won. And they lost. That's what happens when we throw a case.
They can say whatever they like about all we would have won and we're just doing it to say the court process and that kind of thing. But if he had believed as passionately in his case as we did in ours, he would not have withdrawn the case. But you don't accept that perhaps you know, had they continued on with the Dominion case, not settled that that they might have been enticed to continue the case here? Maybe I don't know.
But I mean, you've got to look at our case in a little bit of detail without getting too technical about it. Last August, they sued us for defamation over an individual over a single article by the King. And that's normally what happens with defamation. You sue over one piece of content or series or so on.
And then as we had case hearings in the court flowing through from August through to Christmas, it became clear to the other side because the judge basically told them that their idea that this was an article that was not in the public interest, which was our primary defense at that stage, was not true. The judge basically said to them, this is a story about the election result and alleged allegations of stolen election and march on the Capitol and so on. And so then what they did just before Christmas was they re-pleaded the case. In other words, they started their case again.
And they used material from discovery to say that instead of suing us just on the article, they were going to sue us again on the re-publication of the article. And that included some of the things we've just talked about. And at that point, our defense changed. And then it changed again after the dominion.
Information started sitting up. But our defense changed then to what we broadly call abuse of media power. So that meant even without the dominion material, that if the case had proceeded through the trial, that Lachlan Murdoch would have been having to defend himself on the grounds of abuse of media power. And that starts, I think, to get close to the bones of the Murdochs.
Yes, and certainly close to the dominion bone as well. So Eric, I mean, one of the things that a lot of legal commentators have raised is that it's kind of a pity that the public interest of offense doesn't get a testing. I'm sure that you're relieved to be out of this action, but is part of you a little disappointed that that's not going to be tested? Yes, it is.
And as I said earlier, I had hoped that this would go to court for that reason and for all sorts of reasons. I mean, this was an unusual case because the plaintiff was himself, probably the biggest media owner in the country. And he was suing a very small media outlet at a time when the defamation rules had been revised and had not been tested in the court. So the cases laced with items, but one of those items is the fact that if it had gone through the court and he had won, he would have actually raised the bar for publishers, particularly if he'd been able to prove serious harm, which is one of the other two aspects of the being added to the defamation was in Australia.
And so therefore, all of his editors in Australia would have found themselves in a much tougher position to think their journalism as a result of what he had won. Yes, and that has been commented upon quite widely. It feels extraordinary under those circumstances that he thought to bring the action to begin with. Can I just take a mind now back to the United States, there was a seismic event on the weekend when Fox decided to get rid of Tucker Carlson.
What did you make of that? What do you think is going on there? Is that part of Lockland Murdoch cleaning up and repositioning Fox and protecting news Corp? What do you think is happening?
Well, I don't have any inside knowledge of that. I like many other people I read analysis of it, but in answer to what you just asked, is this cleaning it up? If all it does is remove a few personalities like Tucker Carlson, but if Fox News remains the kind of outlet that it's been in recent years, then I'm not sure it's going to be that much cleaner. So you think it'll just be replaced by somebody of the same ilk?
It won't make any difference. I'll just find another extreme right wing of the fille of oil. Well, I don't know. I think it would be wonderful if the Murdochs had decided to clean up Fox News and to turn it into a journalism enterprise rather than a propaganda enterprise.
I think that'd be great. Maybe that's what we're seeing. I hope so. Okay, now back to your case though, Eric.
A lot of people thought at the time that this action was brought in, there's a lot of commentary to this effect as well that it really was an existential crisis for your company and for Crickie in particular. Can you speculate? What would have happened if Crickie had even been litigated and Crickie lost it? Look, we prepared ourselves.
We're not reckless people. Some of us have a bit of experience in the media. And so when we went into it, we were prepared for the worst, as it were. We planned for the worst, including financially.
And so it would never have brought Crickie down. It would never have resulted in us having to lay off staff or anything like that. So no, we weren't worried from that point. Okay.
And as you mentioned, you have raised money from the public. You're reportedly now trying to convince the federal court to order Murdoch to pay indemnity costs, some $1.1 million. And that would cover 100% of what the case has cost you so far. And that's despite you crowdfunding.
Was it $588,000 or $589,000? $589,000 in donations to a GoFundMe defense campaign. Now, the court would expect Murdoch to pay, I think, up to 80% of your costs, that's what would normally happen. But what Murdoch wants is the funds that you've raised should be deducted from the total.
Presumably, you don't personally expect to be permitted to double dip, though, do you? We're not going to double dip. I mean, we made it very clear when we started the crowdfunding, and as we prepared to do it, that if there was any surplus as a result of the outcome of the case, that it would go to a charity. So it's going to be a grist charity.
So that was clear to anyone that donated. And then that remains the case. I don't really want to speculate on this issue about how the court is going to decide on costs, because I'm not a lawyer. And in any case, that's up to the judge and the court.
But do you kind of understand Murdoch position that what you've raised should come off the total bottom line of his bill? Not at all. And that's not what the rules of the federal court say. Absolutely not.
But if he needs another $590,000 to aid a rent or something, well, maybe we could help. Now, if Krikey had one, if the case had been that they'd go and Krikey had one, it really would have bucked a trend with media companies who've been on a hiding to nothing of late with defamation cases. Tell me what do you make of our defamation protections at the moment, still too restrictive, even with the new public interest offense? Well, yes.
I think most journalists and editors and publishers are agreeing with that totally. And you only have to look at the US and look at the constitutional protection that exists there to realize what the best model for a working democracy looks like. The US model? Yes, the US model, absolutely.
They have an interest test. I mean, the block on the method I could never and would never dream of suing over this article had just been published in this. They've been hundreds of articles going back since the election, or going back for decades, actually, since Fox News was created, that were much, much more damaging than what we wrote. But in the US, you can't sue.
He couldn't sue for that or is it in Australia, you can't. But as I said earlier, this also comes down to the question of public interest. And we had no doubt that this article was in public interest. And we had no doubt that, I mean, what's in Murdoch?
It's not even named in the article. We named Murdoch and the Murdoch. And the Murdoch we refer to as Rippet Murdoch, because that's who everyone refers to when they talk about a Murdoch. But we had no doubt this was in the public interest.
It's really interesting here, for example, just to give you a tiny little snippet of this and all this is, some of this has come out in the public record and this particular piece has, because our barrister brought it up at the last hearing about a month ago. Since this action started, and when we did the interrogatories where you ask questions of each side, we have asked Lachlan Murdoch and re-asked him to confirm to us that he believes that Joe Biden is the duly elected president of the United States. And he has refused to answer that question. So, you know, what are we talking about here?
I mean, I just don't know. This is not a Ben Roberts Smith case. This is not, you know, we haven't personally attacked or defamed Lachlan you know, this was a normal piece of commentary. That's what it was.
Presumably answering that question would have gone at the time that he was asking the interrogatories that would have gone directly to what was central to the Dominion case. You could surely understand why he would refuse to answer under those circumstances when they hadn't yet settled that case. Mike, I cannot understand in 2023 or in 2022 last year that someone of his caliber running media all over the world is not prepared to say in public on the record that Joe Biden is the elected president of the United States. I do not accept that he's rational.
It might not be rational, but it certainly goes to the point that Dominion case, I guess, is my point that what was being mitigated there was their, you know, their support for the big lie. Why would he come out and say something that could potentially undermine the veracity of their case in that instance? Well, I mean, if you want to defend his position like that, you can. But, you know, to me, it sounds like Monty Python.
Eric, you said earlier that you were wondering yourself why he sued under the circumstances that he did. Can I ask you to speculate on that? Why do you think he went for you? He went for us in my view because he and his company are very big and very rich and very powerful and they see us as being very small and very poor and powerless.
And he was obviously very upset that we criticized him in that article. This was the fourth time that we had legal interactions and correspondence from his solicitor in the last year or two. And I think when we took advertising out, inviting him to sue so that we could actually test this in court, I think it probably went to his sense of self. In the original instance, his opposition to the piece, I mean, that feels like extreme sensitivity, personal sensitivity almost.
Is that how you read it? Well, I'm not a psychologist. So I don't think I'm capable of making a comment about that. Yeah, but as an old journal, you've been kicking around a long time.
You know, the public's fee pretty well. What do you think is behind that? Well, it's interesting, isn't it? But his father never sued for defamation and he's been in the business for 70 years.
Yeah, that is an interesting point. Okay. Can I ask you, what we're to now for Crikey? I mean, it started off years ago, started off by Stephen Lane.
It was a contrarian gossip sheet, basically, that was often considered to be kind of center-right business news website. Where do you see Crikey in the year of say, 2023, 24? Where is it going? Well, before I answer that, I don't necessarily concur with your analysis of its history.
I think there are elements of what it was when it started. But in some ways, it hasn't changed to this extent that as I say, our self-imposed remit to ourselves is to hold power to account. And we think, and I think that Crikey is now 23 years old. And so the world, and especially the world of media and the introduction of social media and the collapse of the business model of traditional media, I mean, so much has changed in that time.
And so we find ourselves now, in this country in particular, and the same around the world, where the old powerful big media are no longer powerful or big. And there's a far less of it, media concentration ownership in this country is greater than it's ever been, many, many newspapers and other outlets have closed. And so for Crikey to hold power to account in the current environment, in my view, is even more important, but it's different. And so I wouldn't call us a gossip rag or anything like that.
And I don't think we have been private media brought Crikey after it was five years old, since then we've changed the approach, but incredibly supportive of what the ethos that Stephen created. But I think it's just as important now. So just to be clear, what I was saying was that it started off as a contrarian gossip sheet, not that it was when you took it over. But that's the other point.
I guess my question is, would you agree that it started off then as a kind of center-right publication? And if you do, do you think it's still center-right? Where do you position it now? I don't agree that it started off as center-right.
And my view has always been to try and position it politically as close to the center as possible and not have a political view. Holding power to account in my view is not political. And so yes, at various times, including now, we have writers and have particular perspectives that might, in some cases, come from the left. Like lots of media in Australia, we would love to find more voices from the center-right and the right, but we do not see it as a political, polemic platform.
We see it as a place that digs under rocks and tells people things, particularly about power and politics and that kind of thing that they wouldn't otherwise hear in the media or anywhere else. And in terms of where you're going, you have a new editor now, Sophie Black. And she comes in, without the shadow of this terrible defamation case hanging over the organisation, is Crikey going to keep sailing on the same course? Do you think or do you see that Sophie would be plotting a fresh course for the organisation?
And if so, what might that course be? So I think for an outlet like Crikey, you're always thinking about not so much a fresh course, but it's not setting its ways. It's not like the Sydney Morning Herald or the age, 170 or 180 year old institution. It's not a paper of record.
It doesn't have a very clear mandate in terms of reporting the news or coming out every day with what happened yesterday. It's national, not local. And so that gives us enormous freedom. And I think for Sophie, it gives her a fantastic canvas on which to keep moving forward in a different environment.
I guess my point is, where does Crikey go from here? What does it look like in a few years' time? Does it have a different feel to it? Does it have a different political perspective to it?
What does it become? What does it say we do not see it as being political in that sense? So there are perceptions of it being political and there are other publications like the Guardian and the Saturday paper that are overtly politically directed. We're not like that, but there's still perceptions that we are.
So I think this court case showed that holding power to account and holding powerful people to account is something that a lot of people in our democratic environment had a real appetite for. Okay, Eric, I think we'll leave it there. Thank you very, very much for your time. Thanks, Mike.
On that note, I'd like to thank Eric Beecher for being on For The State and thanks to you for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the community radio network. For The State is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support.
Make sure you subscribe to For The State on your favourite podcast app so that you can hear us talk about media politics and, of course, everything in between. We'll be back with more next week, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle there is For The State AU. Thanks to my producer Anthony Dottle, I'm Monica Atard, and thank you for listening.