Skip to content
EU in Practice: Can You Still Call It “Green”? episode artwork

Sep 8, 2026 2 min

EU in Practice: Can You Still Call It “Green”?

from REDefine // Civic Intelligence Podcast Hosted by REDefine // Civic Intelligence

Most of us have probably noticed that the humble leaf has had quite a career in marketing. Once confined largely to trees, it eventually discovered packaging design and has never looked back. It now lives on shampoo bottles, hotel websites, trainers, electricity tariffs, washing liquid, clothing collections, food-delivery services and an impressive assortment of products whose relationship with photosynthesis is, at best, indirect. Sometimes it appears alone. Sometimes it is accompanied by a water droplet, a tiny planet, an earnest hand cradling a seedling, or that particular shade of muted green that seems to say: this purchase has already discussed the matter with nature. Around the leaf grew an equally successful vocabulary. Products became green, eco-friendly, natural, responsible, conscious, climate friendly and, most majestically of all, sustainable. These words do rather more than describe. They reassure. They distinguish. They allow an ordinary purchase to acquire a small moral biography. The detergent is no longer merely going to clean your socks; it is apparently participating in the transition to a better civilisation. From 27 September 2026, some of that language becomes considerably harder to use casually in the European Union. Directive (EU) 2024/825, usually referred to as the Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition Directive, starts applying across the EU after Member States were required to transpose it by 27 March this year. It strengthens existing consumer law against misleading environmental claims, unreliable sustainability labels, misleading carbon-neutrality claims and several other practices associated with greenwashing. The interesting part is not that Brussels has suddenly developed an aversion to the colour green. It is that European consumer law is beginning to ask a deceptively difficult question about the environmental language surrounding everyday products: what, exactly, is this sentence asking the consumer to believe? That question turns out to take us somewhere much more interesting than packaging. The problem with buying something you cannot inspect When you buy a chair, you can sit on it. When you buy a peach, you can eventually discover whether it tastes like a peach or like a small damp disappointment. But many environmental qualities cannot be verified by the person buying the product, even after using it. Economists describe characteristics like these as credence attributes. Whether a product was made under particular environmental conditions, whether its supply chain really has lower emissions, whether a material comes from the source claimed, or whether a production process genuinely reduces ecological harm is largely invisible to the buyer. Consumers therefore depend on signals supplied by producers, labels, certifiers and retailers to bridge an information gap they cannot realistically investigate themselves. Research on sustainability certification has long identified exactly this problem: environmental qualities are unusually dependent on trust because the consumer often cannot independently verify them through either inspection or experience. This makes environmental communication commercially powerful. A sustainability claim does not merely transmit information; it can influence how the entire product is perceived. Psychologists and consumer researchers call one version of this the halo effect. Once something is marked as environmentally preferable, people may unconsciously attribute other positive qualities to it as well. A wonderfully strange series of experiments published in Food Quality and Preference found that an eco-label could even make fruit seem to taste better and influence assessments extending beyond environmental performance. More recent research continues to find similar effects: a 2024 study involving 1,010 German consumers found that an environmental score affected not only perceived environmental friendliness but, under some conditions, expectations about healthiness and taste. So when regulators worry about a vague green claim, they are not being pedantic about adjectives. They are dealing with an information signal capable of changing how people value the thing being sold. The problem becomes sharper when almost anybody can manufacture the signal. The European Commission’s own work found that 53% of green claims examined provided vague, misleading or unfounded information, while 40% had no supporting evidence. It also counted 230 sustainability labels and 100 green-energy labels in the EU, with widely varying levels of transparency, and found that around half of green labels offered weak or non-existent verification. At that point, the humble leaf starts looking less like decoration and more like an unregulated unit of credibility. A market in adjectives This is why the new rules make more sense if we stop thinking about them as environmental legislation and start thinking about them as market legislation. Imagine two companies selling comparable products. Company A spends several years redesigning production, changing suppliers, measuring impacts, improving materials and paying for independent certification. Company B keeps roughly the same product but introduces a new package featuring a tasteful forest, the words planet conscious and, naturally, our old friend the leaf. If consumers cannot distinguish the underlying environmental performance, Company A has a problem. It has invested in environmental improvement while Company B has invested in environmental atmosphere. This is partly what the EU is trying to correct. The Directive itself explicitly connects reliable environmental claims with fair competition: if consumers can distinguish products with genuinely better performance, businesses making substantive environmental improvements are less likely to compete on equal terms with businesses making substantively better graphics. There is a democratic dimension here too. The green transition relies heavily on consumer choice, but consumer choice only works as a policy instrument when the information entering that choice is reasonably trustworthy. Asking citizens to “vote with their wallets” while allowing the ballot paper to be written by the marketing department has certain structural weaknesses. And this is where Europe has arrived at the slightly surreal but entirely logical business of regulating adjectives. So, can you still call something “green”? Yes. But not quite in the carefree way the word has sometimes been used. The Directive identifies generic environmental claims such as environmentally friendly, eco-friendly, green, ecological, climate friendly, carbon friendly, energy efficient, biodegradable and similar expressions. From September, such broad claims cannot simply be made unless the trader can demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance relevant to the claim. There is, however, an important distinction between something generic and something specific. The Directive itself contrasts a phrase such as “climate-friendly packaging” with a statement explaining that 100% of the energy used to produce the packaging comes from renewable sources. The latter tells the consumer what the environmental advantage actually consists of, rather than asking two words and a hopeful colour palette to carry the entire burden. That distinction may sound linguistic, but it changes the logic of sustainability communication. For years, marketing has often done exactly what good marketing is trained to do: compress complexity. Supply chains, energy sources, material composition, lifecycle impacts and production methods become a memorable phrase because nobody has ever stood in a supermarket thinking, I wish this yoghurt label contained a methodological annex. The new law does not reverse that completely. Nor should it. But it does begin to set a limit on how much environmental complexity can be compressed before information becomes impression. The problem is not brevity. It is what disappears … Get full access to REDefine // Civic Intelligence at associationredefine.substack.com/subscribe

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

EU in Practice: Can You Still Call It “Green”?

0:00 2:14

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of REDefine // Civic Intelligence Podcast?

This episode is 2 minutes long.

When was this REDefine // Civic Intelligence Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on September 8, 2026.

Can I download this REDefine // Civic Intelligence Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.