Everybody Leaves! Why Most Nonprofits Are Unprepared

Send us Fan MailNonprofit succession planning strategy isn’t just a governance exercise—it’s a core risk management function that directly impacts mission delivery.  Joan Brown (Third Sector Company) and Erick Seelbach break down how nonprofits can proactively prepare for leadership transitions without creating fear or disruption.Too often, succession planning is treated as a reactive process—something triggered by a resignation or crisis. But as Joan explains, “A succession plan is a set of shared understandings and activities…that ensures we have the right people in the right places to deliver on our mission.” When embedded into organizational culture, succession planning becomes a stabilizing force—not a threatening one.This important convo draws a clear distinction between succession planning and transition planning—two concepts frequently confused but critically different. Succession planning focuses on long-term leadership continuity across the organization, while transition planning addresses the tactical steps when a specific role changes hands.The reality is sobering: fewer than 35% of nonprofits have a formal succession plan, and only 13% have plans for board leadership. At the same time, 86% of executive directors report they would leave for better professional development opportunities. That combination creates significant organizational vulnerability.Erick emphasizes the importance of shifting mindset: “We make better decisions when we’re not in the emotional response to a crisis.” By integrating succession planning into performance reviews, strategic planning, and talent development, nonprofits can reduce risk while strengthening retention.Key takeaways include:Why succession planning should be position-based, not person-basedHow to build an emergency leadership plan immediatelyThe role of professional development in retaining top talentHow to align succession planning with strategic goalsThis is not about replacing people—it’s about protecting your mission! 00:00:00 Introduction to Succession Planning 00:02:00 What Is a Nonprofit Succession Plan? 00:03:15 Should Succession Planning Be Transparent? 00:04:40 Position-Based vs Person-Based Planning 00:06:00 Overcoming Fear in Leadership Planning 00:07:00 Succession Planning as Risk Management 00:09:10 Succession vs Transition Planning Explained 00:10:30 Building Transition Plans for Every Role 00:12:00 Connecting Talent Development to Succession 00:14:00 Why Leaders Leave: The Professional Development Gap 00:16:00 What Goes Inside a Succession Plan 00:20:00 How to Start Without Overwhelming Your Team 00:24:00 Emergency Planning and Interim Leadership Find us Live daily on YouTube!Find us  Live daily on LinkedIn!Find us Live daily on X: @Nonprofit_ShowOur national co-hosts and amazing guests discuss management, money and missions of nonprofits!  12:30pm ET   11:30am CT  10:30am MT  9:30am PTSend us your ideas for Show Guests or Topics: [email protected] us on the web:The Nonprofit Show