EPISODE · Jun 12, 2026 · 14 MIN
Everyone In Caldwell Knows You Knock Twice Before You Cut The Ice
from CREEPY PASTA SCARY STORIES · host Ming Lan
THE ICE - Stephen King Inspired HorrorCaldwell Pond is deeper than it has any business being — the state survey crew ran out of line in 1968 and the map still says UNDETERMINED. Every winter the town fishes it through the ice, and every winter the fishing follows a rule nobody wrote down: knock twice before you drill, wait, and if three knocks come back, thank it out loud and fish somewhere else. Vernon Tilley kept the rule for sixty years without asking what it was for. Then his sister married a loud, friendly, reasonable man from downstate who thought knocking on a frozen lake was the most charming piece of hick folklore he'd ever heard — and who couldn't stop thinking about the thousand-dollar trout holding in the deep water nobody would touch. A winter story about old bargains, new men, and the morning the pond stopped answering and started asking.This episode includes AI-generated content.
Embed this episode
NOW PLAYING
Everyone In Caldwell Knows You Knock Twice Before You Cut The Ice
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.