Evil Girlfriend Prays Police Will Solve Lover’s Murder - Until Friend Outs Her As Scorned Killer episode artwork

EPISODE · Mar 23, 2025 · 1H

Evil Girlfriend Prays Police Will Solve Lover’s Murder - Until Friend Outs Her As Scorned Killer

from True Crime & The Court of Public Opinion with Alexis Knight · host Alexis Knight | Facts First. Clarity Always.

Evil Girlfriend Prays Police Will Solve Lover’s Murder - Until Friend Outs Her As Scorned KillerThis unbelievable true crime case made headline news in Yulee, Florida. Investigators quickly discover that a string of intertwined relationship and affairs - one of which turned deadly in this shocking true crime story. With their suspects all point the finger at each other, the case went cold... but police weren't about to give up on this real life murder mystery. Using a combination of police interviews and forensic science, investigators unraveled the truth from lies. In the end, they discovered a real life thriller full of manipulation, cheating, and an unexpected psychopath - and solved this disturbing cold case. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------On February 28, 2001, the body of father of 8, Paul Shealey Jr. was found floating in Lofton Creek in Yulee, Florida. He had a single gunshot wound. Close to the body, police found an area rug, a shower curtain, and a pair of eyeglasses.When detectives notified Paul's quiet, church-going girlfriend, Olicia Lee, she told them he had left for a business trip on February 25th and hadn't been in contact in days. She claimed that there were no issues with their relationship.  Investigators soon discovered that this wasn't true. Not only was Paul cheating with another woman, Aisha James, but she was pregnant with his child. James claimed that Lee had recently discovered the cheating and was furious. Lee responded by saying that James had actually learned that Paul was living with someone - and she was the one who exploded. With both women pointing the finger at one another, the case went cold... Then, 9 months later, police were contacted by Danielle “Deucy” Reddick, who was incarcerated for attempted burglary.Claiming to have key information that could help solve Paul's murder, Reddick is brought in for questioning…#policebodycams #bodycam #bodycamarrest #realbodycam #detectiveTrue Crime: The Court of Public Opinion Podcast:  Join the Podcast and dive deeper into the chaos of real-life crime with Alexis Knight! No fluff. No filter. Just the truth. https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-the-court-of-public-opinion-with-alexis-knight--6292057Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/alexis-knight-l-facts-first-clarity-always--6292057/support.

Evil Girlfriend Prays Police Will Solve Lover’s Murder - Until Friend Outs Her As Scorned KillerThis unbelievable true crime case made headline news in Yulee, Florida. Investigators quickly discover that a string of intertwined relationship and affairs - one of which turned deadly in this shocking true crime story. With their suspects all point the finger at each other, the case went cold... but police weren't about to give up on this real life murder mystery. Using a combination of police interviews and forensic science, investigators unraveled the truth from lies. In the end, they discovered a real life thriller full of manipulation, cheating, and an unexpected psychopath - and solved this disturbing cold case. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------On February 28, 2001, the body of father of 8, Paul Shealey Jr. was found floating in Lofton Creek in Yulee, Florida. He had a single gunshot wound. Close to the body, police found an area rug, a shower curtain, and a pair of eyeglasses.When detectives notified Paul's quiet, church-going girlfriend, Olicia Lee, she told them he had left for a business trip on February 25th and hadn't been in contact in days. She claimed that there were no issues with their relationship.  Investigators soon discovered that this wasn't true. Not only was Paul cheating with another woman, Aisha James, but she was pregnant with his child. James claimed that Lee had recently discovered the cheating and was furious. Lee responded by saying that James had actually learned that Paul was living with someone - and she was the one who exploded. With both women pointing the finger at one another, the case went cold... Then, 9 months later, police were contacted by Danielle “Deucy” Reddick, who was incarcerated for attempted burglary.Claiming to have key information that could help solve Paul's murder, Reddick is brought in for questioning…#policebodycams #bodycam #bodycamarrest #realbodycam #detectiveTrue Crime: The Court of Public Opinion Podcast:  Join the Podcast and dive deeper into the chaos of real-life crime with Alexis Knight! No fluff. No filter. Just the truth. https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-the-court-of-public-opinion-with-alexis-knight--6292057Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/alexis-knight-l-facts-first-clarity-always--6292057/support.

NOW PLAYING

Evil Girlfriend Prays Police Will Solve Lover’s Murder - Until Friend Outs Her As Scorned Killer

0:00 1:00:18

No transcript for this episode yet

We transcribe on demand. Request one and we'll notify you when it's ready — usually under 10 minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of True Crime & The Court of Public Opinion with Alexis Knight?

This episode is 1 hour and 0 minutes long.

When was this True Crime & The Court of Public Opinion with Alexis Knight episode published?

This episode was published on March 23, 2025.

What is this episode about?

Evil Girlfriend Prays Police Will Solve Lover’s Murder - Until Friend Outs Her As Scorned KillerThis unbelievable true crime case made headline news in Yulee, Florida. Investigators quickly discover that a string of intertwined relationship and...

Can I download this True Crime & The Court of Public Opinion with Alexis Knight episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.
URL copied to clipboard!