Skip to content
Evolution, Language, Domestication, Symbolic Cognition, AI & Large Language Models | Terrence Deacon episode artwork

Feb 21, 2024 2 hr 14 min

Evolution, Language, Domestication, Symbolic Cognition, AI & Large Language Models | Terrence Deacon

from Mind & Matter Podcast with Nick Jikomes, PhD: Biology, Nutrition and Health Science Hosted by Nick Jikomes, PhD and Terrence deacon

About the Guest: Terrence Deacon, PhD is a Professor in the department of Anthropology at UC-Berkeley. He has written many papers and multiple books about the evolution of human language, origins of consciousness, and related topics. Episode Summary: Nick and Dr. Deacon discuss various aspects of biological evolution, from natural vs. sexual selection to gene duplication and the consequences of domestication; the domestication of dogs and songbirds; human vs. non-human forms of vocal communication; ritual behavior & the origins symbolic cognition; artificial intelligence & large language models (LLMs); and more. *This content is never meant to serve as medical advice. * More M&M episodes with Terrence Deacon. * Support M&M if you find value in this content. * Full audio only version: [Apple Podcasts] [Spotify] * Full video version: [YouTube] [Odysee] * Episode transcript below. Full AI-generated transcript below. Beware of typos & mistranslations! Terrence Deacon 4:12 Oh, yes, I'm in the middle of a book called fouling up. How inverse Darwinism catalyzes evolution Nick Jikomes 4:21 what is what is inverse Darwin Darwinism. So Terrence Deacon 4:24 everybody asks, it's actually not anti Darwinism. It's a compliment to Darwinism. And I think it's a compliment that was there. In Darwin's own writing, though, he doesn't recognize it. And that's why I've used the phrase. So Darwinism in 1838. He came up with three ideas to send his chose up his notebook that basically drove the rest of his thinking. And it came up right after rereading or I don't know, they read the whole thing before this, but certainly reading Malthus on population this this whole problem Malthus realizes is that reproduction outpaces resource. And Malthus, of course, had this dire prediction that this would lead to terrible things in England in Europe. Because populations were growing so fast and resources were not growing fast enough. Darwin sees this and says, aha, but in the natural world, this is going to be the case. And that means there's going to be selection that favors a few over the others. Those that fit better with the contexts that can do better, they can outpace the others. And so this sort of drives his theory. And he comes up with three ideas, he says, the first thing is that I noticed that everybody realizes that the grandchildren are like grandparents, as basically they traits are inherited, they're passed on down. And he says, but but in fact, the second thing is that there is great variety and offspring. That is, although they carry some of those traits as a lot of variety. So that's a second story. That's a variation problem. Then the third one is, he says, But you know, then there's, there's great overproduction with respect to support of those offspring. And but those three things together, and you get natural selection. That's Darwin's basic idea. But notice that the Malthusian part isn't necessary. And it was what gave him the insight for natural selection. But if you think about things like gene duplication, that happens all the time in evolution, in fact, whole genome duplication does happen, particularly in plants. What happens is that the excess production doesn't necessarily mean that you're outstripping resources, doesn't take a lot of energy to produce extra genes, or to have a single gene that's duplicated, like in transpose on effect, there's not much energy use, but even in terms of multicellularity, think of the production of multiple cells, the reproduction by mitosis. Now, that builds a large multi cell body with maybe trillions of cells. There's some contexts in which some of those cells are in competition with each other, but not often. Usually, it's a context in which there's no competition, which is excess resources, in which overproduction is in fact, the way life has to work. In fact, to stay ahead of the second law of thermodynamics, you can't just repair things, you have to make extras, you have to have backups, you have to have duplicates, because something's gonna go wrong, eventually, we know that in terms of our own computer technology, that you got to have backups, you got to make copies of things. And that's how you keep things going. Well, evolution, of course works. But what happens when you don't have competition? When you don't have this subtractive effect, if you think about it, natural selection is a subtractive process. It requires variation. But it also requires overproduction. You have to make more than you need because you're gonna get rid of some. Nick Jikomes 7:59 Yes, so you're taking away individuals who are unmatched to their environment, and leaving behind those that are better matched to their environment. But But I think I see where you're going here. If you think about something like gene duplication, that's not happening at all, you're just adding a new thing. And then that redundancy gives you space to evolve a new function without any actual competition there Terrence Deacon 8:21 exactly are what it basically does is because there's redundancy, if one of them begins to degrade in some way, which will happen spontaneously. In fact, if you got two of them, then if one degrades, it won't be eliminated, unless it produces some troublesome project product. And one of the troublesome things that are going to happen if you've got to have something is that you can produce too much and too much can be a problem, I mean that we have a classic issue of that with respect to Trisomy 21, when the 21st chromosome is tripled, tripled, and said, Just dupe duplicated data produces Down syndrome. That is the overproduction of a bunch of genes is actually not such such a good thing. So oftentimes, when you over produce, it can also have negative consequences. So in fact, accumulating damage in the experts actually could be an advantage, you could decrease it. But the other thing is that you can also because damage on say one out of a few 100 nucleotides and the DNA molecule does a little bit a little bit of damage won't necessarily turn something completely off. It'll just kind of modify that function, oftentimes degrading it just a little bit. But there might be contexts in which a little bit of a change little bit of variation now actually complements what's already there. And so in effect, duplication, over duplication without elimination, allows enough redundancy that allows you to accumulate a little bit of variation and error without much cost. Nick Jikomes 9:53 Yeah, and there's actually like, there's multiple ways this can go so for example, you know, gene duplication is relatively common, you get an extra copy of a gene, it's often not catastrophic. It can be, but it's often not catastrophic. And you can imagine, I mean, this, there's, there's examples of this that have been documented. You know, one way this could happen as you preserve the original function and Gene one, and Gene two just sort of goes in a new direction. But another way that you see sort of complexification evolve in the genome is what they call sub functionalisation. So that if you've got sort of two jobs that gene is doing, and then you duplicate it, it can be that gene one now just does job one, and Gene two just jumped to the now you've got the same functional outcome. But now you've got more complexity, more parts doing it, right. And Terrence Deacon 10:40 that's the classic stories of those one is the hemoglobin gene, which is duplicated from myoglobin originally. And then the hemoglobin gene itself duplicates, and you've got an alpha and a beta. And they produce this, this tetramer, that now actually does a much more interesting job of carrying oxygen, because now you got four iron atoms, in this four part molecule, it's floating around your blood carries more oxygen, but also probably gets it off more easily to myoglobin in your tissues. But in addition, the beta hemoglobin duplicated a bunch of times, and now we have different hemoglobin through expresse… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit mindandmatter.substack.com/subscribe

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Evolution, Language, Domestication, Symbolic Cognition, AI & Large Language Models | Terrence Deacon

0:00 2:14:19

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Mind & Matter Podcast with Nick Jikomes, PhD: Biology, Nutrition and Health Science?

This episode is 2 hours and 14 minutes long.

When was this Mind & Matter Podcast with Nick Jikomes, PhD: Biology, Nutrition and Health Science episode published?

This episode was published on February 21, 2024.

Can I download this Mind & Matter Podcast with Nick Jikomes, PhD: Biology, Nutrition and Health Science episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.